Allan H. Meltzer

Last updated
Allan H. Meltzer
Elaine Chao Meets with Allan H. Meltzer 174-CD-L03-11-03B-003 (cropped).jpg
Meltzer in 2003
BornFebruary 6, 1928
DiedMay 8, 2017(2017-05-08) (aged 89)
Nationality American
Institution Carnegie Mellon University
Field Economist
School or
Alma mater Duke University (BA, MA)
Influences Karl Brunner
Milton Friedman
Information at IDEAS / RePEc

Allan H. Meltzer ( /ˈmɛltsər/ ; February 6, 1928 – May 8, 2017) was an American economist and Allan H. Meltzer Professor of Political Economy at Carnegie Mellon University's Tepper School of Business and Institute for Politics and Strategy in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. [1] Meltzer specialized on studying monetary policy and the US Federal Reserve System, and authored several academic papers and books on the development and applications of monetary policy, and about the history of central banking in the US. [2] Together with Karl Brunner, he created the Shadow Open Market Committee: a monetarist council that deeply criticized the Federal Open Market Committee. [3]


Meltzer originated the aphorism "Capitalism without failure is like religion without sin. It doesn't work." That is, guarding companies from failure "removes the dynamic process that makes stockholders responsible for losses and disciplines managers who make mistakes." [4]


He was born in 1928 Boston, Massachusetts. [5] Meltzer received his A.B. and M.A. degrees from Duke University in 1948 and 1955, respectively. He earned his Ph.D. degree from UCLA in 1958 under supervision of Karl Brunner. [6] [7] He became an associate professor at Carnegie Mellon the following year. [8]

Meltzer served, from 1973 to 1999, as the Chair of the Shadow Open Market Committee, a group of economists, academics, and bankers that met to critique the actions of the Federal Reserve's Federal Open Market Committee. He served as an Acting Member of the Council of Economic Advisors in 1988–89 at the end of the Ronald Reagan administration. He was a visiting scholar at the American Enterprise Institute.

Meltzer was the first ever recipient of the AEI's Irving Kristol award in 2003. [9] He was honored at the award dinner by President George W. Bush, who remarked "I know I'm not the featured speaker; I'm just a warm-up act for Allan Meltzer." [10]

Meltzer was the Chairman of the Congressionally-mandated International Financial Institution Advisory Commission, [11] known as the Meltzer Commission. The Commission's majority report (2000) proposed changes to the operations of the International Monetary Fund and especially to those of the World Bank, which the majority recommended should withdraw from lending to "middle income countries". Four (out of 5) Commission members nominated by the then-minority Congressional Democrats filed a dissent from the majority's recommendations (Bergsten, Huber, Levinson and Torres), though one of the four (Huber) both voted for the majority report and joined the dissent. The official vote tally in favor was thus recorded as 8 to 3. Controversy over the majority's arguments and recommendations continued after the report's publication: critics, including David de Ferranti, a former Vice President at the World Bank, argued inter alia that the majority's report reflected ideological preconceptions rather than any demonstrated understanding of how the World Bank actually works, including the extensive complementarities between World Bank programs and private sector investment in developing countries. The Commission's report is defended by Meltzer's chief advisor Adam Lerrick and critiqued by de Ferranti in their respective chapters in an edited volume published by the Center for Global Development and fully accessible on the web. The report's recommendations were not adopted by subsequent U.S. administrations of either party.

Meltzer was critical of the Federal Reserve's decision to rescue the leading bond-insurer AIG when it did so in 2008: "these disasters should be headed off early, or should be left to the marketplace to settle." [12] In turn, the Fed's decision not to rescue Lehman Brothers was one which, at the time, Meltzer appeared to applaud. Contrasting it with the AIG rescue, he commented: "I would say we ought to look at Lehman Brothers. They let Lehman Brothers fail. Within a few days, just a few days, Barclays was there buying up some of Lehman's assets..." [12] A year later, however, Meltzer expressed a more critical view of the Fed's handling of the Lehman case: "After 30 years of bailing out almost all large financial firms, the Fed made the horrendous mistake of changing its policy in the midst of a recession... Allowing Lehman to fail without warning is one of the worst blunders in Federal Reserve history..." [13]

In May 2009, Meltzer warned that "the enormous increase in bank reserves—caused by the Fed’s purchases of bonds and mortgages—will surely bring on severe inflation if allowed to remain." [14] Four years after Meltzer's comment, with the Fed's quantitative easing program still continuing, US inflation as measured by the consumer price index (CPI-U) was running at a year-on-year rate of 1.4%, [15] while expected inflation over a 10-year period, as estimated by the Cleveland Federal Reserve, was running at around 1.55%. [16] Meltzer's argument that nobody had expected the lack of inflation has been challenged by Paul Krugman. [17]

Meltzer's study A History of the Federal Reserve is considered the most comprehensive history of the central bank. [18] Volume I covers the years from the creation of the Fed in 1913 until the accord with the Treasury in 1951. [19] [20] Volume II Book 1 covers the years from the accord in 1951 until 1969, [21] and Volume II Book 2 discusses the period from 1970 until the end of the Great Inflation in the mid-1980s. [22]

Meltzer served as president of the Mont Pelerin Society for the 2012–2014 term. [23] Meltzer has opposed US adoption of a "cap and trade" scheme for carbon emissions, designed to help combat global climate change. [13]


Allan H. Meltzer and Scott F. Richard (1981). "A Rational Theory of the Size of Government," Journal of Political Economy, 89(5), pp. 914–27. Abstract.

See also

Related Research Articles

Federal Reserve Central banking system of the United States

The Federal Reserve System is the central banking system of the United States of America. It was created on December 23, 1913, with the enactment of the Federal Reserve Act, after a series of financial panics led to the desire for central control of the monetary system in order to alleviate financial crises. Over the years, events such as the Great Depression in the 1930s and the Great Recession during the 2000s have led to the expansion of the roles and responsibilities of the Federal Reserve System.

Monetarism School of thought in monetary economics

Monetarism is a school of thought in monetary economics that emphasizes the role of governments in controlling the amount of money in circulation. Monetarist theory asserts that variations in the money supply have major influences on national output in the short run and on price levels over longer periods. Monetarists assert that the objectives of monetary policy are best met by targeting the growth rate of the money supply rather than by engaging in discretionary monetary policy. Monetarism is commonly associated with neoliberalism.

Money supply Total value of money available in an economy at a specific point in time

In macroeconomics, the money supply refers to the total volume of money held by the public at a particular point in time in an economy. There are several ways to define "money", but standard measures usually include currency in circulation and demand deposits. The central bank of each country may use a definition of what constitutes money for its purposes.

Monetary economics is the branch of economics that studies the different competing theories of money: it provides a framework for analyzing money and considers its functions, and it considers how money can gain acceptance purely because of its convenience as a public good. The discipline has historically prefigured, and remains integrally linked to, macroeconomics. This branch also examines the effects of monetary systems, including regulation of money and associated financial institutions and international aspects.

G. William Miller 11th Chairman of the Federal Reserve in the United States

George William Miller was an American businessman and politican who served as the 65th United States Secretary of the Treasury under President Carter from August 6, 1979 to January 20, 1981. He previously served as the 11th Chair of the Federal Reserve, where he began service on March 8, 1978.

William McChesney Martin

William McChesney Martin Jr. was the ninth and longest-serving Chairman of the United States Federal Reserve Bank, serving from April 2, 1951, to January 31, 1970, under five presidents. Martin, who once considered becoming a Presbyterian minister, was described by a Washington journalist as "the happy Puritan".

Liquidity trap Situation described in Keynesian economics

A liquidity trap is a situation, described in Keynesian economics, in which, "after the rate of interest has fallen to a certain level, liquidity preference may become virtually absolute in the sense that almost everyone prefers holding cash rather than holding a debt which yields so low a rate of interest."

This history of central banking in the United States encompasses various bank regulations, from early "wildcat" practices through the present Federal Reserve System.

Criticism of the Federal Reserve

The Federal Reserve System has faced various criticisms since it was authorized in 1913. Nobel laureate economist Milton Friedman and his fellow monetarist Anna Schwartz criticized the Fed's response to the Wall Street Crash of 1929 arguing that it greatly exacerbated the Great Depression. More recent prominent critics include former Congressman Ron Paul.

Arthur F. Burns American economist, diplomat, and 10th Chairman of the Federal Reserve in the United States

Arthur Frank Burns was an American economist. His career alternated between academia and government. From 1927 to the 1970s, Burns taught and researched at Rutgers University, Columbia University, and the National Bureau of Economic Research.

Recession of 1953 In the U.S., began in the second quarter of 1953 and lasted until the first quarter of 1954

In the United States the Recession of 1953 began in the second quarter of 1953 and lasted until the first quarter of 1954. The total recession cost roughly $56 billion. It has been described by James L. Sundquist, a staff member of the Bureau of the Budget and speech-writer for President Harry S. Truman as "relatively mild and brief."

Karl Brunner was a Swiss economist.

The Shadow Open Market Committee (SOMC) is an independent group of economists, first organized in 1973 by Professors Karl Brunner, from the University of Rochester, and Allan Meltzer, from Carnegie Mellon University, to provide a monetarist alternative to the views on monetary policy and its inflation effects then prevailing at the Federal Reserve and within the economics profession.

Recession of 1969–1970 Relatively mild recession in the United States

The Recession of 1969–1970 was a relatively mild recession in the United States. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research the recession lasted for 11 months, beginning in December 1969 and ending in November 1970, following an economic slump which began in 1968 and by the end of 1969 had become serious, thus ending the third longest economic expansion in U.S. history which had begun in February 1961.

Recession of 1960–1961 Recession in the United States that lasted for 10 months

The Recession of 1960–1961 was a recession in the United States. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research the recession lasted for 10 months, beginning in April 1960 and ending in February 1961. The recession preceded the third-longest economic expansion in U.S. history, from February 1961 until the beginning of the Recession of 1969–1970 in December 1969—to date only the 1990s and post-financial crisis (2009-2020) have seen a longer period of growth.

Scott B. Sumner is an American economist. He is the Director of the Program on Monetary Policy at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, a Research Fellow at the Independent Institute, and professor who teaches at Bentley University in Waltham, Massachusetts. His economics blog, The Money Illusion, popularized the idea of nominal GDP targeting, which says that the Federal Reserve and other central banks should target nominal GDP, real GDP growth plus the rate of inflation, to better "induce the correct level of business investment".

Federal Reserve Reform Act of 1977

The Federal Reserve Reform Act of 1977 enacted a number of reforms to the Federal Reserve, making it more accountable for its actions on monetary and fiscal policy and tasking it with the goal to "promote maximum employment, production, and price stability". The act explicitly established price stability as a national policy goal for the first time. It also required quarterly reports to Congress "concerning the ranges of monetary and credit aggregates for the upcoming 12 months." It also modified the selection of the Class B and C Reserve Bank Directors. Discrimination on the basis of race, creed, color, sex, or national origin was prohibited, and the composition of the directors was required to represent interests of "agriculture, commerce, industry, services, labor and consumers". The Federal Reserve Act, which created the Federal Reserve in 1913, made no mention of services, labor, and consumers. Finally, the act established Senate confirmation of chairmen and vice chairmen of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve Reform Act made the Federal Reserve more transparent to Congressional oversight.

Market monetarism is a school of macroeconomic thought that advocates that central banks target the level of nominal income instead of inflation, unemployment, or other measures of economic activity, including in times of shocks such as the bursting of the real estate bubble in 2006, and in the financial crisis that followed. In contrast to traditional monetarists, market monetarists do not believe monetary aggregates or commodity prices such as gold are the optimal guide to intervention. Market monetarists also reject the New Keynesian focus on interest rates as the primary instrument of monetary policy. Market monetarists prefer a nominal income target due to their twin beliefs that rational expectations are crucial to policy, and that markets react instantly to changes in their expectations about future policy, without the "long and variable lags" postulated by Milton Friedman.

Thomas M. Humphrey

Thomas MacGillivray Humphrey is an American economist. Until 2005 he was a research advisor and senior economist in the research department of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond and editor of the Bank's flagship publication, the Economic Quarterly. His publications cover macroeconomics, monetary economics, and the history of economic thought. Mark Blaug called him the "undisputed master" of British classical monetary thought.

Marvin Seth Goodfriend was an American economist. He was a professor of economics at Carnegie Mellon University. He was previously the director of research at the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond. Following his 2017 nomination to the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, the White House decided to forgo renominating Goodfriend at the beginning of the new term.


  1. "Faculty Information" . Retrieved 2007-06-11.
  2. "A History of the Federal Reserve" . Retrieved 2019-05-15. (subscription required)
  3. Reichart Alexandre & Abdelkader Slifi (2016). 'The Influence of Monetarism on Federal Reserve Policy during the 1980s.' Cahiers d'économie Politique/Papers in Political Economy, (1), pp. 107–50.
  4. "A life's recounting in the subject's own words".
  5. White, Lawrence H. (2012-04-09). The Clash of Economic Ideas: The Great Policy Debates and Experiments of the Last Hundred Years. ISBN   9781107378773.
  6. Cate, Thomas (January 2013). An Encyclopedia of Keynesian Economics, Second edition. ISBN   9781782546795.
  7. Wichter, Zach (13 May 2017). "Allan H. Meltzer, Conservative Economist, Dies at 89". The New York Times . p. A18. Retrieved 14 May 2017.
  8. "Annual Dinner and Lecture" . Retrieved 2009-07-09.
  9. "Bush Speech -- Full Text".
  10. "International Financial Institutions Advisory Commission" . Retrieved 2007-06-11.
  11. 1 2 "Government's Rescue of AIG Fails to Calm Nervous Investors | Online NewsHour | September 17, 2008 | PBS". Archived from the original on 2008-09-19.
  12. 1 2 "What Happened to the 'Depression'?" Allan H. Meltzer, Wall Street Journal, September 1, 2009.
  13. Meltzer, Allan H. (3 May 2009). "Inflation Nation". The New York Times . Retrieved 2013-05-03.
  14. U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index, accessed on 7/2/13 at:
  15. "Cleveland Fed Estimates of Inflation Expectations" accessed on 7/3/13 at:
  16. "Hawks, Doves, and Ostriches". 14 August 2013.
  17. Andrews, Edmund (9 July 2009). "Two Authorities on Fed Advise Congress Against Expanding Its Power". The New York Times. Retrieved 3 January 2016.
  18. Meltzer, Allan (2003). A History of the Federal Reserve, Volume 1: 1913–1951 . University of Chicago Press. ISBN   0226519996.
  19. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis (1 September 2003). "Allan H. Meltzer: The author of "A History of the Federal Reserve" and architect of the Shadow Open Market Committee shares his thoughts on everything from failures of the Fed to international monetary reform" (Interview). Retrieved 12 January 2016.
  20. Meltzer, Allan (2009). A History of the Federal Reserve, Volume 2, Book 1, 1951–1969. University of Chicago Press. ISBN   9780226520018.
  21. Meltzer, Allan (2009). A History of the Federal Reserve, Volume 2, Book 2, 1970–1986. University of Chicago Press. ISBN   9780226519944.
  22. "The Mont Pelerin Society" . Retrieved 2012-12-25.