Billy Evans

Last updated
Billy Evans
Billy Evans 1914.jpg
Evans in 1914
Born:(1884-02-10)February 10, 1884
Chicago, US
Died: January 23, 1956(1956-01-23) (aged 71)
Miami, Florida, US
Member of the National
Empty Star.svgEmpty Star.svgEmpty Star.svg Baseball Hall of Fame Empty Star.svgEmpty Star.svgEmpty Star.svg
Induction 1973
Election MethodVeterans Committee

William George Evans (February 10, 1884 January 23, 1956), nicknamed "The Boy Umpire", was an American umpire in Major League Baseball who worked in the American League from 1906 to 1927. He became, at age 22, the youngest umpire in major league history, and later became the youngest to officiate in the World Series at age 25. [1]


Upon his retirement at age 43, his 3,319 career games ranked fifth in major league history; his 1,757 games as a home plate umpire ranked third in AL history, and remain the eighth-most by a major league umpire. He later became a key front office executive for three teams and president of the minor league Southern Association. [1]

In addition to his inside role in the sport, Evans authored countless articles, [2] as well as two books, Umpiring from the Inside (1947) and Knotty Problems in Baseball (1950). [1] He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1973, the third umpire ever selected. [3]

Formative years

Evans was born in Chicago. [2] When he was still a child, he relocated with his family to Youngstown, Ohio, where his Welsh-born father became superintendent at a Carnegie steel plant. [4] In Youngstown, the Evans family joined Westminster Presbyterian Church, where Billy Evans attended Sunday school. [5] As a youth, Evans was active in YMCA programs and participated in a neighborhood baseball club called the Youngstown Spiders, a team named in honor of the regionally popular Cleveland Spiders. [5] He gained notability as an athlete at Youngstown's Rayen School, excelling at baseball, football, and track. [1] In 1902, Evans enrolled at Cornell University, where he played on a freshman team managed by veteran major league shortstop Hughie Jennings. [5] After two years, his law studies and collegiate sports career came to an end, with the sudden death of his father. [6] Evans returned to Ohio and accepted a job as a sports reporter at the Youngstown Daily Vindicator . [3] The paper's city editor, Sam Wright, hired Evans on the basis of writing experience he secured as a staff member of his high school yearbook and college newspaper. [1] At the same time, Wright understood that Evans' varied experiences as an athlete provided him with an in-depth knowledge of sports. [1]

In the early 1900s, while covering a baseball game between the Youngstown Ohio Works club and a team from Homestead, Pennsylvania, Evans was approached by the manager of the local club, ex-major leaguer Marty Hogan, and asked to fill an umpire vacancy. [6] According to Evans's obituary, the aspiring reporter, who was on a date with a young woman, "wasn't interested until Hogan mentioned he would be paid $15 a week for officiating the game", a figure equivalent to a week's salary at his sportswriting job. [1]

Evans' ability caught the attention of Charlie Morton, president of the Ohio–Pennsylvania League, and he was offered a full-time position as a league umpire. [1] Evans accepted the job, on the condition that he could retain his position as a sportswriter. [1] In 1906, he received a spectacular career boost from fellow Youngstowner Jimmy McAleer, an ex-major leaguer who was so impressed with the young man's ability that he recommended Evans to American League president Ban Johnson. [6] This gesture enabled Evans to move from a Class C Division minor league club to the major leagues. [1]

Major league umpiring career

At 22 years of age, Evans was the youngest umpire in major league history; furthermore, he was among those very rare umpires who broke into the major leagues with little previous professional experience. [3] He was regarded as the only umpire of his era who never had played professional baseball himself. [2] After making his debut at Highlanders' Park in New York City, [1] he went on to umpire for six World Series: 1909, 1912, 1915, 1917, 1919 and 1923. Working in an era during which most major league games used no more than two umpires (and sometimes only one), Evans single-handedly umpired seven double-headers in eight days during the 1907 season. He was the base umpire for Charlie Robertson's perfect game on April 30, 1922. [7]

Unlike many umpires, Evans never made claims to infallibility. "I missed a lot of decisions", he once said. "At the time of making such a decision there was no doubt in my mind as to its correctness. However, a second or two later I felt that I erred and wished I could change my original ruling". [1] Evans' humility and impartiality did not always protect him from abusive fans. As sportswriters, Daniel Okrent and Steve Wulf observed, "roughness on the field seemed to elicit the same in the stands". [8] On September 15, 1907, in the midst of a doubleheader between the St. Louis Browns and Detroit Tigers, Evans suffered a skull fracture when a bottle hurled by an angry spectator knocked him unconscious. [9] The New York Times described the incident as "one of the most disgraceful scenes ever witnessed on a ball field". [9]

Evans became known as an innovator during more than two decades with the American League. One obituary observed that he "introduced something new to officiating by running down to a base where a play was made so that he would be on top of it". [1] This approach became a standard practice among major league officials. [1] He was also aware of the increasing demands placed on umpires and strongly advocated formal training for baseball officials. [4] Furthermore, in a game that retained much of the rough-and-tumble atmosphere of earlier decades, Evans "substituted diplomacy for belligerency and proved an arbiter could control a game without threats of physical violence". [1]

Ty Cobb Ty-Cobb-1913-NPC-detail-1.jpeg
Ty Cobb

At the same time, he was unwilling to "back down" when physically threatened. In September 1921, Evans was involved in a bloody fistfight with Ty Cobb, who contested one of Evans' calls. [4] Baseball historian David Anderson noted that the trouble began when Cobb threatened to "whip" Evans "right at home plate", a move that would have led to Cobb's immediate suspension. [4] Evans supposedly invited Cobb to the umpire's dressing room for "post-game festivities", and before long, the two men were brawling beneath the stands as players from both teams looked on. [4] According to some accounts, many of Cobb's Detroit Tigers teammates "rooted" for Evans. [4] After the fight, Cobb was suspended for one game, while Evans attended the next several games wearing bandages. [4] Both men had agreed before the fight that they would not report it to league officials, but a word of the incident eventually reached the league president, Ban Johnson. [10] According to sports writers Okrent and Wulf, Johnson responded to news of the incident "with uncharacteristic humor", saying "only that he was sorry that he missed it". [10]

For the duration of his career as an umpire, Evans also remained active as a sportswriter. From 1918 to 1928, he served as sports editor of Newspaper Enterprise Association and produced a syndicated sports column titled, "Billy Evans Says". [1] [11] His staff featured well-known sportswriters Jimmy Powers and Joe Williams. [1]

Executive career

Evans retired from umpiring following the 1927 season to become the general manager of the Cleveland Indians, earning a substantial annual salary of $30,000. [1] Baseball historian Bill James observed that Evans was the first front-office executive of a major league team to be officially called a "general manager". [12] In this capacity, Evans was credited with taking the Indians from a second division to a first division team. [1] He served as general manager for the next eight years, until budget cuts forced him out in 1935. [1] Rumors circulated that Evans's decision to leave the Indians was also motivated by a disagreement with the Indians' manager, Walter Johnson, over the suspension of third baseman Willie Kamm and the release of catcher Glenn Myatt. [1] Johnson allegedly accused Evans of "disloyalty", while Evans reportedly replied that he refused to be a "yes man". [1] Evans soon found work as chief scout and head of the Boston Red Sox farm system, but left on October 8, 1940, after the team sold Pee Wee Reese to the Brooklyn Dodgers over his objections. [3]

Shifting sports, Evans returned to Cleveland to become general manager of the Cleveland Rams for the 1941 season. Although the team struggled on the field, it was a financial success, but after failing to come to terms on a new contract, Evans left and spent the next year writing before accepting the position of league president of the Southern Association on December 3, 1942. [3]

During his four years leading the league, the Association thrived despite many other leagues shutting down due to World War II. In his first year, attendance increased by nearly 300,000,[ citation needed ] and while it dipped slightly in 1944, the threshold of one million people attending league games was again reached the following year. [13]

On December 16, 1946, Evans accepted a contract offer from the Detroit Tigers to become their general manager. [3] One of his first moves was dramatic selling ageing superstar Hank Greenberg to the Pittsburgh Pirates. Over the next four years, the team had two runner-up finishes to the New York Yankees, but after dropping in the standings during the 1951 season, Evans announced his resignation on July 28 in favor of Tiger legend Charlie Gehringer. [3]

Private life

Despite long absences from his residence in Cleveland, Evans was known as a devoted husband and father. [4] He married the former Hazel Baldwin in 1908; the couple had one child, Robert, who became the sports director of a radio station in Miami, Florida. [1] Evans maintained close ties with family members and died while visiting his son in Miami. [1]

Despite his success, Evans remained accessible to friends from his early days in Youngstown. Shortly after Evans' death, a former high school classmate, E. Allan Lightner, recalled that his late friend "was still the fine clean character that he was in his high school days in Youngstown". [5] Lightner recalled that, shortly after his final conversation with the retired umpire, Evans sent Lightner an autographed photo of himself with former Detroit Tigers manager Red Rolfe. [5]

Final years

By 1952, Evans had unofficially retired, then was injured in an automobile accident in Monroe, Michigan. After recovering, he remained in good health until January 21, 1956, when he suffered a massive stroke while visiting his son. [1] Evans died two days later at the age of 71. [2] Funeral services were held in Cleveland. [1] Evans' remains were interred at Knollwood Cemetery in Mayfield Heights, Ohio. [4]


Evans' contributions to baseball have been widely recognized. In 1946 he was named in the Honor Rolls of Baseball, and in 1973 he became the third umpire elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame. [3] Evans is honored for the high standard of professionalism he set during his career as an official, and he is credited as a tireless advocate of formal training for umpires. [4] Ironically, as David Anderson observed, Evans might have been denied the opportunity to serve as an official in the major leagues "if the present day umpire school system existed during the Dead Ball Era". [4] Anderson noted that Evans' description of the basic qualities required of an effective umpire holds up even today: "Good eyes, plenty of courage mental and physical thorough knowledge of the playing rules, more than average portions of fair play, common sense and diplomacy, an entire lack of vindictiveness, plenty of confidence in your ability". [4]


  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 "Billy Evans, Renowned Baseball Figure, Dies". The Youngstown Vindicator . January 24, 1956.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "Billy Evans Dies in Miami at 71; Major League Umpire 22 Years". The New York Times . Associated Press. January 24, 1956.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 "Billy Evans Obituary". Associated Press. Retrieved 2007-03-10.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Anderson, David. "Billy Evans". Society for American Baseball Research . Retrieved 2014-10-10.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Lightner, E. Allan (February 26, 1956). "Recalls When Billy Evans Played Sandlot Ball Here". The Youngstown Vindicator.
  6. 1 2 3 Baker, Jon (July 1, 2005). "In Valley's History, Evans Was an Early Scrapper". The Valley Voice.
  7. "Charlie Robertson Perfect Game Box Score". Retrieved 2007-12-25.
  8. Okrent and Wulf (1989), pp. 5253.
  9. 1 2 "Umpire's Skull Fractured – Spectator at Detroit-St. Louis Game Throws a Bottle". The New York Times. September 16, 1907.
  10. 1 2 Okrent and Wulf (1989), p. 53.
  11. "Billy Evans". Archived from the original on 2007-10-22. Retrieved 2007-12-22.
  12. James (2003), p. 128.
  13. Spink, J. G. Taylor (ed.) (1946). "Attendance Figures for 1945". Baseball Guide and Record Book 1946. St. Louis: The Sporting News. p. 189.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)

Related Research Articles

Ty Cobb American baseball player

Tyrus Raymond Cobb, nicknamed The Georgia Peach, was an American Major League Baseball (MLB) outfielder. He was born in rural Narrows, Georgia. Cobb spent 22 seasons with the Detroit Tigers, the last six as the team's player-manager, and finished his career with the Philadelphia Athletics. In 1936 Cobb received the most votes of any player on the inaugural Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, receiving 222 out of a possible 226 votes (98.2%); no other player received a higher percentage of votes until Tom Seaver in 1992. In 1999, the Sporting News ranked Ty Cobb third on their list of "Baseball's 100 Greatest Players".

Tris Speaker American baseball player

Tristram Edgar Speaker, nicknamed "The Gray Eagle", was an American professional baseball player. Considered one of the greatest offensive and defensive center fielders in the history of Major League Baseball (MLB), he compiled a career batting average of .345. His 792 career doubles represent an MLB career record. His 3,514 hits are fifth in the all-time hits list. Defensively, Speaker holds career records for assists, double plays, and unassisted double plays by an outfielder. His fielding glove was known as the place "where triples go to die."

Hughie Jennings American baseball player, coach, and manager

Hugh Ambrose Jennings was an American professional baseball player, coach and manager from 1891 to 1925. Jennings was a leader, both as a batter and as a shortstop, with the Baltimore Orioles teams that won National League championships in 1894, 1895, and 1896. During those three seasons, Jennings had 355 runs batted in and hit .335, .386, and .401.

Elmer Flick American baseball player

Elmer Harrison Flick was an American professional baseball outfielder who played in Major League Baseball from 1898 to 1910 for the Philadelphia Phillies, Philadelphia Athletics, and Cleveland Bronchos/Naps. In 1,483 career games Flick recorded a .313 batting average while accumulating 164 triples, 1,752 hits, 330 stolen bases, and 756 runs batted in. He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1963.

Nap Lajoie American baseball player and manager

Napoleon Lajoie, also known as Larry Lajoie and nicknamed "The Frenchman", was an American professional baseball second baseman and player-manager. He played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Philadelphia Phillies, Philadelphia Athletics (twice), and Cleveland Naps between 1896 and 1916. He managed the Naps from 1905 through 1909.

Addie Joss American baseball player

Adrian "Addie" Joss, nicknamed "The Human Hairpin," was an American pitcher in Major League Baseball. He pitched for the Cleveland Bronchos, later known as the Naps, between 1902 and 1910. Joss, who was 6 feet 3 inches (1.91 m) and weighed 185 pounds (84 kg), pitched the fourth perfect game in baseball history. His 1.89 career earned run average (ERA) is the second-lowest in MLB history, behind Ed Walsh.

Ban Johnson

Byron Bancroft "Ban" Johnson was an American executive in professional baseball who served as the founder and first president of the American League (AL).

Dutch Leonard (left-handed pitcher) American baseball player

Hubert Benjamin "Dutch" Leonard, was an American left-handed pitcher in Major League Baseball who had an 11-year career from 1913 to 1921, and 1924 to 1925. He played for the Boston Red Sox and Detroit Tigers, and holds the major league modern-era record for the lowest single-season ERA of all time — 0.96 in 1914. The all-time record holder is Tim Keefe with a 0.86 ERA in 1880. He is not to be confused with a pitcher of the same name that had pitched in the National League around a decade later.

Bill Donovan American baseball player and manager

William Edward Donovan, nicknamed "Wild Bill" and "Smiling Bill", was an American right-handed baseball pitcher and manager.

Jimmy McAleer American baseball player

James Robert "Loafer" McAleer was an American center fielder, manager, and stockholder in Major League Baseball who assisted in establishing the American League. He spent most of his 13-season playing career with the Cleveland Spiders, and went on to manage the Cleveland Blues, St. Louis Browns, and Washington Senators. Shortly before his retirement, he became a major shareholder in the Boston Red Sox.

Ossie Vitt American baseball player and manager

Oscar Joseph "Ossie" Vitt was a Major League Baseball third baseman and manager in the American League for the Detroit Tigers (1912–1918) and Boston Red Sox (1919–1921). Vitt later became manager of the Cleveland Indians (1938–1940), where he sometimes clashed with his players.

Marty Hogan Anglo-American baseball player

Martin Francis Hogan, nicknamed "The Indianapolis Ringer", was an Anglo-American right fielder in Major League Baseball who played for the Cincinnati Reds (1894) and St. Louis Browns (1894–1895). After leaving the National League, Hogan moved on to the minor league Indianapolis Hoosiers. Some sources suggest he set a national baserunning record in the 1890s.

Youngstown Ohio Works US baseball team

The Youngstown Ohio Works baseball team was a minor league club that was known for winning the premier championship of the Ohio–Pennsylvania League in 1905, and for launching the professional career of pitcher Roy Castleton a year later. A training ground for several players and officials who later established careers in Major League Baseball, the team proved a formidable regional competitor and also won the 1906 league championship.

Aloysius Joseph "Allan" Travers, aka Rev. Aloysius Stanislaus Travers was a Major League Baseball pitcher who made a one-game appearance during the 1912 strike of the Detroit Tigers. He is the only Catholic priest to have played major league baseball.

Tom Veryzer American baseball player

Thomas Martin Veryzer was an American baseball shortstop. He played 12 years in Major League Baseball, appearing in 979 games for the Detroit Tigers (1973-1977), Cleveland Indians (1978-1981), New York Mets (1982), and Chicago Cubs (1983-1984). He ranked third in the American League in 1977 with a range factor of 5.16 per nine innings at shortstop. His career range factor of 4.841 per nine innings at shortstop ranks as the 25th best in Major League history.

Bert Cole American baseball player

Albert George Cole was an American baseball pitcher.

The 1909 Detroit Tigers won the American League pennant with a record of 98–54, but lost to the Pittsburgh Pirates in the 1909 World Series, 4 games to 3. The season was their 9th since they were charter members of the American League in 1901. It was the third consecutive season in which they won the pennant but lost the World Series. Center fielder Ty Cobb won the Triple Crown and pitcher George Mullin led the league in wins (29) and winning percentage (.784).

William Edward John Deegan is a former Major League Baseball umpire who worked in the American League from 1971 to 1980. Deegan wore uniform number 17 when the American League adopted them for its umpires in 1980, later worn by John Hirschbeck.

Donald Lee Leshnock, was an American professional baseball left-handed pitcher, who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Detroit Tigers, in 1972.


Further reading