Brontosaurus

This article is about the dinosaur. For other uses, see Brontosaurus (disambiguation).

Brontosaurus Temporal range: Late Jurassic (Kimmeridgian to Tithonian), 156.3–146.8  Ma PreꞒ Ꞓ O S D C P T J K Pg N
Holotype specimen of B. excelsus (YPM 1980), Peabody Museum of Natural History
Scientific classification
Kingdom:	Animalia
Phylum:	Chordata
Clade:	Dinosauria
Clade:	Saurischia
Clade:	† Sauropodomorpha
Clade:	† Sauropoda
Superfamily:	† Diplodocoidea
Family:	† Diplodocidae
Subfamily:	† Apatosaurinae
Genus:	† Brontosaurus Marsh, 1879
Type species
†Brontosaurus excelsus Marsh, 1879
Referred species
†Brontosaurus parvus (Peterson & Gilmore, 1902) †Brontosaurus yahnahpin (Filla & Redman, 1994)
Synonyms
ElosaurusPeterson & Gilmore, 1902 EobrontosaurusBakker, 1998 Brontosaurus excelsus synonymy Brontosaurus amplus Marsh, 1881 Apatosaurus excelsus (Marsh, 1879) Riggs, 1903 Apatosaurus amplus (Marsh, 1881) Riggs, 1903 Atlantosaurus excelsus (Marsh, 1879) Steel, 1970 Atlantosaurus amplus (Marsh, 1881) Steel, 1970 Brontosaurus parvus synonymy Elosaurus parvus Peterson & Gilmore, 1902 Apatosaurus parvus (Peterson & Gilmore, 1902) Upchurch et al., 2004 Brontosaurus yahnahpin synonymy Apatosaurus yahnahpin Filla & Redman, 1994 Eobrontosaurus yahnahpin (Filla & Redman, 1994) Bakker, 1998

Brontosaurus ( /ˌbrɒntəˈsɔːrəs/ ; ^{[1] [2]} meaning "thunder lizard" from Greek βροντή, brontē "thunder" and σαῦρος, sauros "lizard") is a genus of gigantic quadruped sauropod dinosaurs. Although the type species, B. excelsus, had long been considered a species of the closely related Apatosaurus and therefore invalid, ^[3] researchers proposed in 2015 that Brontosaurus is a genus separate from Apatosaurus and that it contains three species: B. excelsus, B. yahnahpin, and B. parvus. ^[4]

Brontosaurus had a long, thin neck and a small head adapted for a herbivorous lifestyle, a bulky, heavy torso, and a long, whip-like tail. The various species lived during the Late Jurassic epoch, in the Morrison Formation of what is now North America, and were extinct by the end of the Jurassic. ^[5] Adult individuals of Brontosaurus are estimated to have measured up to 19–22 metres (62–72 feet) long and weighed up to 14–17 tonnes (15–19 short tons).

As the archetypal sauropod, Brontosaurus is one of the best-known dinosaurs and has been featured in film, advertising, and postage stamps, as well as many other types of media.

History of discovery

An 1896 diagram of the B. excelsus holotype skeleton by O.C. Marsh. The head is based on material now assigned to Brachiosaurus sp.

Initial discovery and the Felch Quarry skull

In 1879, Othniel Charles Marsh, a professor of paleontology at Yale University, announced the discovery of a large and fairly complete sauropod skeleton collected from Morrison Formation rocks at Como Bluff, Wyoming by William Harlow Reed. He identified it as belonging to an entirely new genus and species, which he named Brontosaurus excelsus, ^{[3] [6]} meaning "thunder lizard", from the Greek brontē/βροντη meaning "thunder" and sauros/σαυρος meaning "lizard", ^[7] and from the Latin excelsus, "noble" or "high". ^[8] By this time, the Morrison Formation had become the center of the Bone Wars, a fossil-collecting rivalry between Marsh and another early paleontologist, Edward Drinker Cope. Because of this, the publications and descriptions of taxa by Marsh and Cope were rushed at the time. ^[9] Brontosaurus excelsus' type specimen (YPM 1980) was one of the most complete sauropod skeletons known at the time, preserving many of the characteristic but fragile cervical vertebrae. ^{[10] [11]} Marsh believed that Brontosaurus was a member of the Atlantosauridae, a clade of sauropod dinosaurs named by him in 1877 that also comprised Atlantosaurus and Apatosaurus . ^[10]

Hypothetical skull, sculpted in 1931, Yale Peabody Museum

A year later in 1880, another partial postcranial Brontosaurus skeleton was collected in Como Bluff by Reed, ^{[12] [13]} including well preserved limb elements. ^[11] Marsh named this second skeleton Brontosaurus amplus ("large thunder lizard") in 1881, ^[13] but it was considered a synonym of B. excelsus in 2015 ^[11] .

Further south in Felch Quarry at Garden Park, Colorado, Marshall P. Felch collected a disarticulated partial skull (USNM V 5730) of a sauropod in August 1883 and sent the specimen to Yale. ^{[14] [15]} Marsh referred the skull to B. excelsus, ^{[14] [16]} later featuring it in a skeletal reconstruction of the B. excelsus type specimen in 1891 ^[16] and the illustration was featured again in Marsh's landmark publication, The Dinosaurs of North America, in 1896. ^[10] At the Yale Peabody Museum, the skeleton of Brontosaurus excelsus was mounted in 1931 with a skull based on the Marsh reconstruction of the Felch Quarry skull. ^[17] While at the time most museums were using Camarasaurus casts for skulls, the Peabody Museum sculpted a completely different skull based on Marsh's recon. ^{[17] [14]} The skull also included forward-pointing nasals, something truly different to any dinosaur, and fenestrae differing from the drawing and other skulls, and the mandible was based on a Camarasaurus'. ^[17] In 1998, the Felch Quarry skull that Marsh included in his 1896 skeletal restoration was suggested to belong to Brachiosaurus instead ^[14] and this was supported in 2020 with a redescription of the Brachiosaurid material found at Felch Quarry. ^[15]

Second Dinosaur Rush and skull issue

Skeleton of the AMNH apatosaurine (possibly B. excelsus, specimen AMNH 460) as remounted in 1995

During a Carnegie Museum expedition in 1901 to Wyoming, William Harlow Reed collected another Brontosaurus skeleton, a partial postcranial skeleton of a young juvenile (CM 566), including partial limbs, intermingled with a fairly complete skeleton of an adult (UW 15556). ^{[18] [11]} The adult skeleton specifically was very well preserved, bearing many cervical and caudal vertebrae, and is the most complete definite specimen of Brontosaurus parvus. ^[11] The skeletons were granted a new genus and species name, Elosaurus parvus ("little field lizard"), by Olof A. Peterson and Charles Gilmore in 1902. ^[18] Both of the specimens came from the Brushy Basin Member of the Morrison Formation. The species was later transferred to Apatosaurus by several authors ^{[11] [19]} until it was placed in Brontosaurus in 2015 by Tschopp et al. ^{[11] [20]}

Elmer Riggs, in the 1903 edition of Geological Series of the Field Columbian Museum, argued that Brontosaurus was not different enough from Apatosaurus to warrant its own genus, so he created the new combination Apatosaurus excelsus for it. Riggs stated that "In view of these facts the two genera may be regarded as synonymous. As the term 'Apatosaurus' has priority, 'Brontosaurus' will be regarded as a synonym". ^[3] Nonetheless, before the mounting of the American Museum of Natural History specimen, Henry Fairfield Osborn chose to label the skeleton "Brontosaurus", though he was a strong opponent of Marsh and his taxa. ^{[17] [21]}

Obsolete mount of an apatosaurine referred to B. excelsus (specimen AMNH 460) with sculpted skull, completed in 1905, American Museum of Natural History

In 1905, the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH) unveiled the first-ever mounted skeleton of a sauropod, a composite specimen (mainly made of bones from AMNH 460) that they referred to as the species Brontosaurus excelsus. The AMNH specimen was very complete, only missing the feet (feet from the specimen AMNH 592 were added to the mount), lower leg, and shoulder bones (added from AMNH 222), and tail bones (added from AMNH 339). ^[22] To complete the mount, the rest of the tail was fashioned to appear as Marsh believed it should, which had too few vertebrae. In addition, a sculpted model of what the museum felt the skull of this massive creature might look like was placed on the skeleton. This was not a delicate skull like that of Diplodocus, which would later turn out to be more accurate, but was based on "the biggest, thickest, strongest skull bones, lower jaws and tooth crowns from three different quarries". ^{[23] [3] [24] [25]} These skulls were likely those of Camarasaurus, the only other sauropod for which good skull material was known at the time. The mount construction was overseen by Adam Hermann, who failed to find Brontosaurus skulls. Hermann was forced to sculpt a stand-in skull by hand. Henry Fairfield Osborn noted in a publication that the skull was "largely conjectural and based on that of Morosaurus" (now Camarasaurus). ^[17]

In 1909, an Apatosaurus skull was found, during the first expedition to what would become the Carnegie Quarry at Dinosaur National Monument, led by Earl Douglass. The skull was found a few meters away from a skeleton (specimen CM 3018) identified as the new species Apatosaurus louisae . The skull was designated CM 11162, and was very similar to the skull of Diplodocus. It was accepted as belonging to the Apatosaurus specimen by Douglass and Carnegie Museum director William H. Holland, although other scientists, most notably Osborn, rejected this identification. Holland defended his view in 1914 in an address to the Paleontological Society of America, yet he left the Carnegie Museum mount headless. While some thought Holland was attempting to avoid conflict with Osborn, others suspected that Holland was waiting until an articulated skull and neck were found to confirm the association of the skull and skeleton. ^[17] After Holland's death in 1934, a cast of a Camarasaurus skull was placed on the mount by museum staff. ^[21]

Skull correction, resurgent discoveries, and reassessment

No apatosaurine skull was mentioned in literature until the 1970s, when John Stanton McIntosh and David Berman redescribed the skulls of Diplodocus and Apatosaurus in 1975. ^[25] They found that though he never published his opinion, Holland was almost certainly correct, that Apatosaurus (and Brontosaurus) had a Diplodocus-like skull. ^[25] According to them, many skulls long thought to pertain to Diplodocus might instead be those of Apatosaurus. ^[25] They reassigned multiple skulls to Apatosaurus based on associated and closely associated vertebrae. ^[25] Though they supported Holland, Apatosaurus was noted to possibly have possessed a Camarasaurus-like skull, based on a disarticulated Camarasaurus-like tooth found at the precise site where an Apatosaurus specimen was found years before. ^[25] On October 20, 1979, after the publications by McIntosh and Berman, the first skull of an Apatosaurus was mounted on a skeleton in a museum, that of the Carnegie. ^[21] In 1995, the American Museum of Natural History followed suit, and unveiled their remounted skeleton (now labelled Apatosaurus excelsus) with a corrected tail and a new skull cast from A. louisae. ^[22] In 1998, Robert T. Bakker referred a skull and mandible of an Apatosaurine from Como Bluff to Brontosaurus excelsus (TATE 099-01), though the skull is still undescribed. ^[26] In 2011, the first specimen of Apatosaurus where a skull was found articulated with its cervical vertebrae was described. This specimen, CMC VP 7180, was found to differ in both skull and neck features from A. louisae, and the specimen was found to have a majority of features related to those of A. ajax. ^[27]

Infographic explaining the history of Brontosaurus and Apatosaurus according to Tschopp et al. 2015

Another specimen of an Apatosaurine now referred to Brontosaurus was discovered in 1993 by the Tate Geological Museum, also from the Morrison Formation of central Wyoming. The specimen consisted of a partial postcranial skeleton, including a complete manus and many vertebrae, and described by James Filla and Pat Redman a year later. ^{[11] [26]} Filla and Redman named the specimen Apatosaurus yahnahpin ("yahnahpin-wearing deceptive lizard"), but Robert T. Bakker gave it the genus name Eobrontosaurus in 1998. ^[26] Bakker believed that Eobrontosaurus was the direct predecessor to Brontosaurus ^[26] , although later Tschopp et al.'s phylogenetic analysis placed B. yahnahpin as the basalmost species of Brontosaurus ^[11] .

In 2008, a nearly complete postcranial skeleton of an Apatosaurine was collected in Utah by crews working for Brigham Young University (BYU 1252-18531) where some of the remains are currently on display. ^[11] The skeleton is undescribed, but many of the features of the skeleton are shared with Brontosaurus parvus. ^[11]

Almost all 20th-century paleontologists agreed with Riggs that all Apatosaurus and Brontosaurus species should be classified in a single genus. According to the rules of the ICZN (which governs the scientific names of animals), the name Apatosaurus, having been published first, had priority as the official name; Brontosaurus was considered a junior synonym and was therefore discarded from formal use. ^{[28] [29] [30] [31]} Despite this, at least one paleontologist—Robert T. Bakker—argued in the 1990s that A. ajax and A. excelsus are in fact sufficiently distinct that the latter continues to merit a separate genus. ^[26] In 2015, an extensive study of diplodocid relationships by Emanuel Tschopp, Octavio Mateus, and Roger Benson concluded that Brontosaurus was indeed a valid genus of sauropod distinct from Apatosaurus. The scientists developed a statistical method to more objectively assess differences between fossil genera and species, and concluded that Brontosaurus could be "resurrected" as a valid name. They assigned two former Apatosaurus species, A. parvus and A. yahnahpin, to Brontosaurus, as well as the type species B. excelsus. ^[4] Paleontologist Michael D'Emic made a critique. ^[32] Paleontologist Donald Prothero criticized the mass media reaction to this study as superficial and premature. ^[33]

Description

Comparison of three specimens and a human: Oklahoma specimen of Apatosaurus ajax (orange), A. louisae (red), and Brontosaurus parvus (green)

Brontosaurus was a large, long-necked, quadrupedal animal with a long, whip-like tail, and forelimbs that were slightly shorter than its hindlimbs. The largest species, B. excelsus, measured up to 21–22 m (69–72 ft) long from head to tail and weighed up to 15–17 t (17–19 short tons); other species were smaller, measuring 19 m (62 ft) long and weighing 14 t (15 short tons). ^{[34] [35]}

The skull of Brontosaurus has not been found, but was probably similar to the skull of the closely related Apatosaurus . Like those of other sauropods, the vertebrae of the neck were deeply bifurcated; that is, they carried paired spines, resulting in a wide and deep neck. ^[36] The spine and tail consisted of 15 cervicals, ten dorsals, five sacrals, and about 82 caudals. The number of caudal vertebrae was noted to vary, even within a species. The cervical vertebrae were stouter than other diplodocids, though not as stout as in mature specimens of Apatosaurus. The dorsal ribs are not fused or tightly attached to their vertebrae, instead being loosely articulated. ^[23] Ten dorsal ribs are on either side of the body. ^[3] The large neck was filled with an extensive system of weight-saving air sacs.^{[ citation needed ]}Brontosaurus, like its close relative Apatosaurus, had tall spines on its vertebrae, which made up more than half the height of the individual bones. The shape of the tail was unusual for diplodocids, being comparatively slender, due to the vertebral spines rapidly decreasing in height the farther they are from the hips. Brontosaurus spp. also had very long ribs compared to most other diplodocids, giving them unusually deep chests. ^[37] As in other diplodocids, the last portion of the tail of Brontosaurus possessed a whip-like structure. ^[23]

Restoration of B. excelsus.

The limb bones were also very robust. ^[37] The arm bones are stout, with the humerus resembling that of Camarasaurus , and those of B. excelsus being nearly identical to those of Apatosaurus ajax. Charles Gilmore in 1936 noted that previous reconstructions erroneously proposed that the radius and ulna could cross, when in life they would have remained parallel. ^[23] Brontosaurus had a single large claw on each forelimb, and the first three toes possessed claws on each foot. ^[38] Even by 1936, it was recognized that no sauropod had more than one hand claw preserved, and this one claw is now accepted as the maximum number throughout the entire group. ^{[23] [39]} The single front claw bone is slightly curved and squarely shortened on the front end. The hip bones included robust ilia and the fused pubes and ischia. The tibia and fibula bones of the lower leg were different from the slender bones of Diplodocus, but nearly indistinguishable from those of Camarasaurus. The fibula is longer than the tibia, although it is also more slender. ^[23]

Classification

Brontosaurus is a member of the family Diplodocidae, a clade of gigantic sauropod dinosaurs. The family includes some of the longest and largest creatures ever to walk the earth, including Diplodocus , Supersaurus , and Barosaurus . Brontosaurus is also classified in the subfamily Apatosaurinae, which also includes Apatosaurus and one or more possible unnamed genera. ^[4] Othniel Charles Marsh described Brontosaurus as being allied to Atlantosaurus , within the now defunct group Atlantosauridae. ^{[3] [40]} In 1878, Marsh raised his family to the rank of suborder, including Apatosaurus, Brontosaurus, Atlantosaurus, Morosaurus (=Camarasaurus), and Diplodocus. He classified this group within Sauropoda. In 1903, Elmer S. Riggs mentioned that the name Sauropoda would be a junior synonym of earlier names, and grouped Apatosaurus within Opisthocoelia. ^[3] Most authors still use Sauropoda as the group name. ^[19]

Left front limb of B. yahnahpin, Morrison Natural History Museum

Originally named by its discoverer Othniel Charles Marsh in 1879, Brontosaurus had long been considered a junior synonym of Apatosaurus ; its type species, Brontosaurus excelsus, was reclassified as A. excelsus in 1903. However, an extensive study published in 2015 by a joint British-Portuguese research team concluded that Brontosaurus was a valid genus of sauropod distinct from Apatosaurus. ^{[4] [41] [42]} Nevertheless, not all paleontologists agree with this division. ^{[32] [33]} The same study classified two additional species that had once been considered Apatosaurus and Eobrontosaurus as Brontosaurus parvus and Brontosaurus yahnahpin respectively. ^[4]

Cladogram of the Diplodocidae after Tschopp, Mateus, and Benson (2015): ^[4]

Diplodocidae	Amphicoelias altus Apatosaurinae Unnamed species Apatosaurus ajax Apatosaurus louisae Brontosaurus excelsus Brontosaurus yahnahpin Brontosaurus parvus Diplodocinae Unnamed species Tornieria africana Supersaurus lourinhanensis Supersaurus vivianae Leinkupal laticauda Galeamopus hayi Diplodocus carnegii Diplodocus hallorum Kaatedocus siberi Barosaurus lentus

Species

• Brontosaurus excelsus, the type species of Brontosaurus, was first named by Marsh in 1879. Many specimens, including the holotype specimen YPM 1980, have been assigned to the species. They include FMNH P25112, the skeleton mounted at the Field Museum of Natural History, which has since been found to represent an unknown species of apatosaurine. Brontosaurus amplus, occasionally assigned to B. parvus, is a junior synonym of B. excelsus. B. excelsus therefore only includes its type specimen and the type specimen of B. amplus. ^{[4] [19]} The largest of these specimens is estimated to have weighed up to 15 tonnes and measured up to 22 m (72 ft) long from head to tail. ^[34] Both known definitive B. excelsus fossils have been reported from Reed's Quarry 10 of the Morrison Formation Brushy Basin member in Albany County, Wyoming, dated to the late Kimmeridgian age, ^[4] about 152 million years ago.

• 

  Mounted cast skeleton of B. parvus (UW 15556)

  Brontosaurus parvus, first described as Elosaurus in 1902 by Peterson and Gilmore, was reassigned to Apatosaurus in 1994, and to Brontosaurus in 2015. Specimens assigned to this species include the holotype, CM 566 (a partial skeleton of a juvenile found in Sheep Creek Quarry 4 in Albany County, WY), BYU 1252-18531 (a nearly complete skeleton found in Utah and mounted at Brigham Young University), and the partial skeleton UW 15556 (which had once been accidentally mixed together with the holotype). It dates to the middle Kimmeridgian. ^[19] Adult specimens are estimated to have weighed up to 14 tonnes and measured up to 22 m (72 ft) long from head to tail. ^[34]
• Brontosaurus yahnahpin is the oldest species, known from a single site from the lower Morrison Formation, Bertha Quarry, in Albany County, Wyoming, dating to about 155 million years ago. ^{[5] [43]} It grew up to 21 m (69 ft) long. ^[44] The type species, E. yahnahpin, was described by James Filla and Patrick Redman in 1994 as a species of Apatosaurus (A. yahnahpin). ^[45] The specific name is derived from Lakota mah-koo yah-nah-pin, "breast necklace", a reference to the pairs of sternal ribs that resemble the hair pipes traditionally worn by the tribe. The holotype specimen is TATE-001, a relatively complete postcranial skeleton found in Wyoming, in the lower Morrison Formation. More fragmentary remains have also been referred to the species. A re-evaluation by Robert T. Bakker in 1998 found it to be more primitive, so Bakker coined the new generic name Eobrontosaurus, derived from Greek eos, "dawn", and Brontosaurus. ^[46]

The cladogram below is the result of an analysis by Tschopp, Mateus, and Benson (2015). The authors analyzed most diplodocid type specimens separately to deduce which specimen belonged to which species and genus. ^[4]

Tail vertebra of B. excelsus specimen YPM 1980

Apatosaurinae

YPM 1840 ("Atlantosaurus" immanis type) NSMT-PV 20375 AMNH 460   Apatosaurus    Apatosaurus ajax  YPM 1860 (Apatosaurus ajax type)  Apatosaurus louisae  CM 3018 (Apatosaurus louisae type) YPM 1861 ( Apatosaurus laticollis type)  Brontosaurus   Brontosaurus excelsus  YPM 1980 (Brontosaurus excelsus type) YPM 1981 (Brontosaurus amplus type) AMNH 5764 ( Amphicoelias altus type) FMNH P25112  Brontosaurus yahnahpin  Tate-001 (Eobrontosaurus yahnahpin type)  Brontosaurus parvus  CM 566 (Elosaurus parvus type) UM 15556 BYU 1252-18531

Palaeobiology

Posture and locomotion

Further information: Sauropod neck posture

Cast of B. parvus specimen UWGM 15556 at Tellus Science Museum

Historically, sauropods like Brontosaurus were believed to be too massive to support their own weight on dry land, so theoretically they must have lived partly submerged in water, perhaps in swamps. Recent findings do not support this, and sauropods are thought to have been fully terrestrial animals. ^[47]

Diplodocids like Brontosaurus are often portrayed with their necks held high up in the air, allowing them to browse on tall trees. Though some studies have suggested that diplodocid necks were less flexible than previously believed, ^[48] other studies have found that all tetrapods appear to hold their necks at the maximum possible vertical extension when in a normal, alert posture, and argue that the same would hold true for sauropods barring any unknown, unique characteristics that set the soft tissue anatomy of their necks apart from that of other animals. ^[49]

Trackways of sauropods like Brontosaurus show that the average range for them was around 20–40 km (10–25 mi) per day, and they could potentially reach a top speed of 20–30 km/h (12–19 mph). ^[36] The slow locomotion of sauropods may be due to the minimal muscling or recoil after strides. ^[50]

Various uses have been proposed for the single claw on the forelimb of sauropods. They were suggested to have been for defence, but the shape and size of them makes this unlikely. Other predictions were that it could be for feeding, but the most probable is that the claw was for grasping objects like tree trunks when rearing. ^[39]

Physiology

Further information: Physiology of dinosaurs

James Spotila et al. (1991) suggest that the large body size of Brontosaurus and other sauropods would have made them unable to maintain high metabolic rates, as they would not be able to release enough heat. However, temperatures in the Jurassic were 3 degrees Celsius higher than present. ^[51] They assumed that the animals had a reptilian respiratory system. Wedel found that an avian system would have allowed them to dump more heat. ^[52] Some scientists have argued that the heart would have had trouble sustaining sufficient blood pressure to oxygenate the brain. ^[47]

Juveniles

Reconstructed skeleton of a juvenile B. parvus (type specimen CM 566), Carnegie Museum of Natural History

Juvenile Brontosaurus material is known based on the type specimen of B. parvus. The material of this specimen, CM 566, includes vertebrae from various regions, one pelvic bone, and some bones of the hindlimb. ^[19]

Tail

An article that appeared in the November 1997 issue of Discover magazine reported research into the mechanics of diplodocid tails by Nathan Myhrvold, a computer scientist from Microsoft. Myhrvold carried out a computer simulation of the tail, which in diplodocids like Brontosaurus was a very long, tapering structure resembling a bullwhip. This computer modeling suggested that sauropods were capable of producing a whip-like cracking sound of over 200 decibels, comparable to the volume of a cannon. ^[53] There is some circumstantial evidence supporting this as well: a number of diplodocids have been found with fused or damaged tail vertebrae, which may be a symptom of cracking their tails: these are particularly common between the 18th and the 25th caudal vertebra, a region the authors consider a transitional zone between the stiff muscular base and the flexible whiplike section. ^[54] However, Rega (2012) notes that Camarasaurus , while lacking a tailwhip, displays a similar level of caudal co-ossification, and that Mamenchisaurus , while having the same pattern of vertebral metrics, lacks a tailwhip and does not display fusion in any "transitional region". Also, the crush fractures which would be expected if the tail was used as a whip have never been found in diplodocids. ^[55] More recently, Baron (2020) considers the use of the tail as a bullwhip unlikely because of the potentially catastrophic muscle and skeletal damage such speeds could cause on the large and heavy tail. Instead, he proposes that the tails might have been used as a tactile organ to keep in touch with the individuals behind and on the sides in a group while migrating, which could have augmented cohesion and allowed communication among individuals while limiting more energetically demanding activities like stopping to search for dispersed individuals, turning to visually check on individuals behind, or communicating vocally. ^[56]

Paleoecology

Restoration of a B. excelsus group

The Morrison Formation is a sequence of shallow marine and alluvial sediments which, according to radiometric dating, ranges between 156.3 million years old (Mya) at its base, ^[57] and 146.8 Mya at the top, ^[58] which places it in the late Oxfordian, Kimmeridgian, and early Tithonian stages of the Late Jurassic period. This formation is interpreted as a semiarid environment with distinct wet and dry seasons. The Morrison Basin, where dinosaurs lived, stretched from New Mexico to Alberta and Saskatchewan, and was formed when the precursors to the Front Range of the Rocky Mountains started pushing up to the west. The deposits from their east-facing drainage basins were carried by streams and rivers and deposited in swampy lowlands, lakes, river channels, and floodplains. ^[59] This formation is similar in age to the Lourinha Formation in Portugal and the Tendaguru Formation in Tanzania. ^[60]

Brontosaurus may have been a more solitary animal than other Morrison Formation dinosaurs. ^[61] As a genus, Brontosaurus existed for a long span of time, and have been found in most levels of the Morrison. B. excelsus fossils have been reported from the upper Salt Wash Member to the upper Brushy Basin Member, ranging from the middle to late Kimmeridgian age, about 154–151 Mya. Additional remains are known from even younger rocks, but they have not been identified as any particular species. ^[43] Older Brontosaurus remains have also been identified from the middle Kimmeridgian, and are assigned to B. parvus. ^[19] Fossils of these animals have been found in Nine Mile Quarry and Bone Cabin Quarry in Wyoming and at sites in Colorado, Oklahoma, and Utah, present in stratigraphic zones 2–6. ^[62]

The Morrison Formation records an environment and time dominated by gigantic sauropod dinosaurs. ^[62] Dinosaurs known from the Morrison include the theropods Ceratosaurus , Ornitholestes , and Allosaurus , the sauropods Apatosaurus, Brachiosaurus, Camarasaurus, and Diplodocus, and the ornithischians Camptosaurus , Dryosaurus , and Stegosaurus . ^[63] Other vertebrates that shared this paleoenvironment included ray-finned fishes, frogs, salamanders, turtles, sphenodonts, lizards, terrestrial and aquatic crocodylomorphs, and several species of pterosaurs. Shells of bivalves and aquatic snails are also common. The flora of the period has been revealed by fossils of green algae, fungi, mosses, horsetails, cycads, ginkgoes, and several families of conifers. Vegetation varied from river-lining forests of tree ferns, and ferns (gallery forests), to fern savannas with occasional trees such as the Araucaria -like conifer Brachyphyllum . ^[64]

In popular culture

Outdated 1897 restoration by Charles R. Knight of B. excelsus submerged in water, and Diplodocus dragging its tail

The length of time taken for Riggs's 1903 reclassification of Brontosaurus as Apatosaurus to be brought to public notice, as well as Osborn's insistence that the Brontosaurus name be retained despite Riggs's paper, meant that Brontosaurus became one of the most famous dinosaurs. Brontosaurus has often been depicted in cinema, beginning with Winsor McCay's 1914 classic Gertie the Dinosaur , one of the first animated films. ^[65] McCay based his unidentified dinosaur on the apatosaurine skeleton in the American Museum of Natural History. ^[66] The 1925 silent film The Lost World featured a battle between a Brontosaurus and an Allosaurus, using special effects by Willis O'Brien. ^[67] The 1933 film King Kong featured a Brontosaurus chasing Carl Denham, Jack Driscoll and the terrified sailors on Skull Island. These, and other early uses of the animal as major representative of the group, helped cement Brontosaurus as a quintessential dinosaur in the public consciousness. ^[68]

Sinclair Oil Corporation has long been a fixture of American roads (and briefly in other countries) with its green dinosaur logo and mascot, a Brontosaurus. While Sinclair's early advertising included a number of different dinosaurs, eventually only Brontosaurus was used as the official logo, due to its popular appeal. ^[69]

Gertie the Dinosaur (1914)

As late as 1989, the U.S. Postal Service caused controversy when it issued four "dinosaur" stamps: Tyrannosaurus , Stegosaurus, Pteranodon , and Brontosaurus. The use of the term Brontosaurus in place of Apatosaurus led to complaints of "fostering scientific illiteracy." ^[70] The Postal Service defended itself (in Postal Bulletin 21744) by saying, "Although now recognized by the scientific community as Apatosaurus, the name Brontosaurus was used for the stamp because it is more familiar to the general population." Indeed, the Postal Service even implicitly rebuked the somewhat inconsistent complaints by adding that "[s]imilarly, the term 'dinosaur' has been used generically to describe all the animals [i.e., all four of the animals represented in the given stamp set], even though the Pteranodon was a flying reptile [rather than a true 'dinosaur']," a distinction left unmentioned in the numerous correspondence regarding the Brontosaurus/Apatosaurus issue. Palaeontologist Stephen Jay Gould supported this position. In the essay from which the title of the collection Bully for Brontosaurus is taken, Gould wrote: "Touché and right on; no one bitched about Pteranodon, and that's a real error." ^[68] His position, however, was not one suggesting the exclusive use of the popular name; he echoed Riggs' original argument that Brontosaurus is a synonym for Apatosaurus. Nevertheless, he noted that the former has developed and continues to maintain an independent existence in the popular imagination. ^[68]

The more vociferous denunciations of the usage have elicited sharply defensive statements from those who would not wish to see the name be struck from official usage. ^[68] Tschopp's study ^[4] has generated a very high number of responses from many, often opposed, groups — of editorial, ^[71] news staff, ^{[41] [72]} and personal blog nature (both related ^{[73] [74]} and not ^[75] ), from both ^[76] sides of the debate, from related ^[20] and unrelated contexts, and from all over the world. ^[77]

References

1. "Brontosaurus". Lexico UK English Dictionary. Oxford University Press. Archived from the original on August 14, 2020.
2. "Brontosaurus". Merriam-Webster Dictionary . Retrieved January 21, 2016.
3. Riggs, E. S. (August 1903). "Structure and Relationships of Opisthocoelian Dinosaurs. Part I, Apatosaurus Marsh" (PDF). Publications of the Field Columbian Museum Geographical Series. 2 (4): 165–196. OCLC   494478078.
4. Tschopp, E.; Mateus, O. V.; Benson, R. B. J. (2015). "A specimen-level phylogenetic analysis and taxonomic revision of Diplodocidae (Dinosauria, Sauropoda)". PeerJ. 3: e857. doi:10.7717/peerj.857. PMC   4393826 . PMID   25870766.
5. Foster, J. (2007). Jurassic West: The Dinosaurs of the Morrison Formation and Their World. Indiana University Press. 389pp.
6. Marsh, O. C. (1879). "Notice of new Jurassic reptiles" (PDF). American Journal of Science. 18 (108): 501–505. Bibcode:1879AmJS...18..501M. doi:10.2475/ajs.s3-18.108.501. S2CID   131001110.
7. Liddell, G. H.; Scott, R. (1882). A Greek-English Lexicon. Harper & Brothers. pp. 1–1774.
8. Mahoney, K. D. (2015). "Latin Definitions for: excelsus (Latin search)". LatDict Latin Dictionary and Grammar Resources.
9. Moon, B. (2010). "The Sauropod Dinosaurs of the Morrison Formation (Upper Jurassic, USA): A Review". Dinosauria: 1–9. Archived from the original on January 28, 2015.
10. Marsh, O. C. (1896). The dinosaurs of North America . US Government Printing Office.
11. Tschopp, E., Mateus, O., & Benson, R. B. (2015). A specimen-level phylogenetic analysis and taxonomic revision of Diplodocidae (Dinosauria, Sauropoda). PeerJ, 3, e857.
12. Marsh, Othniel Charles. "Apatosaurus excelsus; YPM VP 001981; North America; USA; Wyoming; Albany County; William H. Reed, Reed-Como party, 1880; 1880". collections.peabody.yale.edu. Retrieved March 10, 2022.
13. Marsh, Othniel Charles (May 1, 1881). "Principal characters of American Jurassic dinosaurs, Part V". American Journal of Science. s3-21 (125): 417–423. Bibcode:1881AmJS...21..417M. doi:10.2475/ajs.s3-21.125.417. ISSN   0002-9599. S2CID   219234316.
14. Carpenter, Kenneth; Tidwell, Virginia (1998). "Preliminary Description of a Brachiosaurus Skull from Felch Quarry 1, Garden Park, Colorado". In Carpenter, Kenneth; Chure, Dan; Kirkland, James Ian (eds.). The Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation: an interdisciplinary study. Taylor & Francis. ISBN   978-90-5699-183-8.
15. D'Emic, Michael D.; Carrano, Matthew T. (June 28, 2019). "Redescription of Brachiosaurid Sauropod Dinosaur Material From the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation, Colorado, USA". The Anatomical Record. 303 (4): 732–758. doi:10.1002/ar.24198. ISSN   1932-8486. PMID   31254331. S2CID   195765189.
16. Marsh, O. C. (1891). Restoration of Brontosaurus. American Journal of Science, Series 3, 41, 341-342.
17. Miller, B. (October 30, 2014). "Bully for Camarasaurus". Dinosours.
18. Peterson, Olof August; Gilmore, Charles W. (March 1902). "Elosaurus parvus: a new genus and species of the Sauropoda". Annals of the Carnegie Museum. 1 (3): 490––499. doi: 10.5962/p.78087 . ISSN   0097-4463. S2CID   145874092.
19. Upchurch, P.; Tomida, Y.; Barrett, P. M. (2005). "A new specimen of Apatosaurus ajax (Sauropoda: Diplodocidae) from the Morrison Formation (Upper Jurassic) of Wyoming, USA". National Science Museum Monographs. 26 (118): 1–156. ISSN   1342-9574.
20. "Brontosaurus is back! Brontosaurus is a unique genus after all". Science Daily . PeerJ. April 7, 2015. Retrieved June 18, 2015.
21. Parsons, K. M. (1997). "The Wrongheaded Dinosaur". Carnegie Magazine. Archived from the original on April 14, 2010.
22. Norell, M.A., Gaffney, E.S., & Dingus, L. (1995). Discovering Dinosaurs in the American Museum of Natural History. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc.
23. Gilmore, C. W. (February 1936). "Osteology of Apatosaurus, with special references to specimens in the Carnegie Museum". Memoirs of the Carnegie Museum. 11 (4): 175–300. doi: 10.5962/p.234849 . OCLC   16777126. S2CID   89649268.
24. Bakker, R. T. (1994). "The Bite of the Bronto". Earth. 3 (6): 26–33. Archived from the original on February 9, 2015.
25. McIntosh, J. S.; Berman, D. S. (1975). "Description of the Palate and Lower Jaw of the Sauropod Dinosaur Diplodocus (Reptilia: Saurischia) with Remarks on the Nature of the Skull of Apatosaurus". Journal of Paleontology. 49 (1): 187–199. JSTOR   1303324.
26. Bakker, R. T. (1998). "Dinosaur mid-life crisis: the Jurassic-Cretaceous transition in Wyoming and Colorado". In Lucas, Spencer G.; Kirkland, James I.; Estep, J. W. (eds.). Lower and Middle Cretaceous Terrestrial Ecosystems. Vol. 14. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. pp. 67–77.
27. Barrett, P. M.; Storrs, G. W.; Young, M. T.; Witmer, L. M. (2011). "A new skull of Apatosaurus and its taxonomic and palaeobiological implications" (PDF). Symposium of Vertebrate Palaeontology & Comparative Anatomy Abstracts of Presentations: 5.
28. Taylor, M. P. (2010). "Sauropod dinosaur research: a historical review" (PDF). Geological Society, London, Special Publications. 343 (1): 361–386. Bibcode:2010GSLSP.343..361T. doi:10.1144/SP343.22. S2CID   910635.
29. Brinkman, P. (2006). "Bully for Apatosaurus". Endeavour. 30 (4): 126–130. doi:10.1016/j.endeavour.2006.10.004. PMID   17097734.
30. Upchurch, P.; Barrett, P. M.; Dodson, P. (2004). "Sauropoda". In Weishampel, D. B.; Osmólska, H.; Dodson, P. (eds.). The Dinosauria (2 ed.). University of California Press. pp. 259–322.
31. McIntosh, J. S. (1995). A. Sun; Y. Wang (eds.). "Remarks on the North American sauropod Apatosaurus Marsh". Sixth Symposium on Mesozoic Terrestrial Ecosystems and Biota Short Papers: 119–123.
32. D'Emic, M. 2015. "Not so fast, Brontosaurus". Time.com
33. Prothero, D. 2015. "Is "Brontosaurus" Back? Not So Fast!". Skeptic.com.
34. Paul, Gregory S. (2010). Princeton Field Guide to Dinosaurs . Princeton University Press. ISBN   978-0-691-13720-9.
35. Molina-Pérez, R.; Larramendi, A. (2020). Dinosaur Facts and Figures: The Sauropods and Other Sauropodomorphs. Princeton University Press. p. 256. ISBN   978-0691190693.
36. Fastovsky, D. E.; Weishampel, D. B. (2009). Dinosaurs: A Concise Natural History (PDF). Cambridge University Press. pp. 165–200. ISBN   978-0-521-88996-4.
37. Lovelace, D. M.; Hartman, S. A.; Wahl, W. R. (2007). "Morphology of a specimen of Supersaurus (Dinosauria, Sauropoda) from the Morrison Formation of Wyoming, and a re-evaluation of diplodocid phylogeny". Arquivos do Museu Nacional. 65 (4): 527–544. ISSN   0365-4508.
38. Martin, A. J. (2006). Introduction to the Study of Dinosaurs (Second ed.). Blackwell Publishing. p. 560. ISBN   978-1-4051-3413-2. ASIN   1405134135.
39. Upchurch, P. (1994). "Manus claw function in sauropod dinosaurs" (PDF). Gaia. 10: 161–171. ISSN   0871-5424.
40. Marsh, O. C. (December 1877). "Notice of New Dinosaurian Reptiles from the Jurassic formation" (PDF). American Journal of Science. 14 (84): 514–516. Bibcode:1877AmJS...14..514M. doi:10.2475/ajs.s3-14.84.514. S2CID   130488291.
41. Gorman, James (April 7, 2015). "A Prehistoric Giant Is Revived, if Only in Name". The New York Times . Retrieved April 7, 2015.
42. Choi, Charles. "The Brontosaurus Is Back". Scientific American. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
43. Turner, C.E. and Peterson, F., (1999). "Biostratigraphy of dinosaurs in the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation of the Western Interior, U.S.A." Pp. 77–114 in Gillette, D. D. (ed.), Vertebrate Paleontology in Utah. Utah Geological Survey Miscellaneous Publication 99-1.
44. Holtz, Thomas R. Jr. (2011) Dinosaurs: The Most Complete, Up-to-Date Encyclopedia for Dinosaur Lovers of All Ages, Winter 2010 Appendix.
45. Filla, J.A., Redman, P.D. (1994). "Apatosaurus yahnahpin: a preliminary description of a new species of diplodocid dinosaur from the Late Jurassic Morrison Formation of southern Wyoming, the first sauropod found with a complete set of "belly ribs"." Wyoming Geological Association, 44th Annual Field Conference Guidebook. 159–178.
46. Bakker, R.T. (1998). "Dinosaur mid-life crisis: the Jurassic-Cretaceous transition in Wyoming and Colorado". In: S.G. Lucas, J.I. Kirkland, & J.W. Estep (eds.) Lower and Middle Cretaceous Terrestrial Ecosystems; New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin, 14: 67–77.
47. Pierson, D. J. (2009). "The Physiology of Dinosaurs: Circulatory and Respiratory Function in the Largest Animals Ever to Walk the Earth". Respiratory Care. 54 (7): 887–911. doi:10.4187/002013209793800286. PMID   19558740.
48. Stevens, Kent A.; Parrish, J. M. (1999). "Neck Posture and Feeding Habits of Two Jurassic Sauropod Dinosaurs". Science. 284 (5415): 798–800. Bibcode:1999Sci...284..798S. doi:10.1126/science.284.5415.798. PMID   10221910 . Retrieved August 3, 2008.
49. Taylor, M. P. (2014). "Quantifying the effect of intervertebral cartilage on neutral posture in the necks of sauropod dinosaurs". PeerJ. 2: e712. doi:10.7717/peerj.712. PMC   4277489 . PMID   25551027.
50. Sellers, W. I.; Margetts, L.; Coria, R. A.; Manning, P. L. (2012). "March of the Titans: The Locomotor Capabilities of Sauropod Dinosaurs". PLOS ONE. 8 (10): e78733. Bibcode:2013PLoSO...878733S. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0078733 . PMC   3864407 . PMID   24348896.
51. Spotila, J. R.; O'Connor, M. P.; Dodson, P. R.; Paladino, F. V. (1991). "Hot and cold running dinosaurs. Metabolism, body temperature, and migration". Modern Geology. 16: 203–227.
52. Wedel, M. J. (2003). "Vertebral Pneumaticity, Air Sacs, and the Physiology of Sauropod Dinosaurs" (PDF). Paleobiology. 29 (2): 243–255. doi:10.1666/0094-8373(2003)029<0243:vpasat>2.0.co;2. JSTOR   4096832. S2CID   46619244.
53. Zimmer, C. (November 1997). "Dinosaurs in Motion". Discover . Retrieved July 27, 2008.
54. Myhrvold, Nathan P.; Currie, Philip J. (1997). "Supersonic sauropods? Tail dynamics in the diplodocids". Paleobiology. 23 (4): 393–409. doi:10.1017/S0094837300019801. ISSN   0094-8373. S2CID   83696153.
55. Rega, E. (2012). "Disease in Dinosaurs". In Brett-Surman, M.; Holtz, T.; Farlow, J. (eds.). The Complete Dinosaur. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
56. Baron, Matthew G. (October 3, 2021). "Tactile tails: a new hypothesis for the function of the elongate tails of diplodocid sauropods". Historical Biology. 33 (10): 2057–2066. doi:10.1080/08912963.2020.1769092. ISSN   0891-2963. S2CID   219762797.
57. Trujillo, K. C.; Chamberlain, K. R.; Strickland, A. (2006). "Oxfordian U/Pb ages from SHRIMP analysis for the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation of southeastern Wyoming with implications for biostratigraphic correlations". Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs. 38 (6): 7.
58. Bilbey, S. A. (1998). "Cleveland-Lloyd Dinosaur Quarry – age, stratigraphy and depositional environments". In Carpenter, K.; Chure, D.; Kirkland, J. I. (eds.). The Morrison Formation: An Interdisciplinary Study. Modern Geology 22. Taylor and Francis Group. pp. 87–120. ISSN   0026-7775.
59. Russell, Dale A. (1989). An Odyssey in Time: Dinosaurs of North America. Minocqua, Wisconsin: NorthWord Press. pp. 64–70. ISBN   978-1-55971-038-1.
60. Mateus, Octávio (2006). "Jurassic dinosaurs from the Morrison Formation (USA), the Lourinhã and Alcobaça Formations (Portugal), and the Tendaguru Beds (Tanzania): A comparison". In Foster, John R.; Lucas, Spencer G. (eds.). Paleontology and Geology of the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin, 36. Albuquerque, New Mexico: New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. pp. 223–231.
61. Dodson, Peter; Behrensmeyer, A.K.; Bakker, Robert T.; McIntosh, John S. (1980). "Taphonomy and paleoecology of the dinosaur beds of the Jurassic Morrison Formation". Paleobiology. 6 (2): 208–232. doi:10.1017/S009483730000676X. S2CID   130686856.
62. Foster, John (2007). Jurassic West: The Dinosaurs of the Morrison Formation and Their World. Indiana University Press. pp. 273–329. ISBN   978-0-253-34870-8.
63. Chure, Daniel J.; Litwin, Ron; Hasiotis, Stephen T.; Evanoff, Emmett; Carpenter, Kenneth (2006). "The fauna and flora of the Morrison Formation: 2006". In Foster, John R.; Lucas, Spencer G. (eds.). Paleontology and Geology of the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin, 36. Albuquerque, New Mexico: New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. pp. 233–248.
64. Carpenter, Kenneth (2006). "Biggest of the big: a critical re-evaluation of the mega-sauropod Amphicoelias fragillimus". In Foster, John R.; Lucas, Spencer G. (eds.). Paleontology and Geology of the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin, 36. Albuquerque, New Mexico: New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. pp. 131–138.
65. Donald Crafton (1982). Before Mickey: The Animated Film 1898–1928. MIT Press. ISBN   978-0-262-03083-0.
66. "Dinos Parade across the Silver Screen". San Diego Natural History Museum. Archived from the original on October 11, 2011.
67. Glut, Donald F.; Brett-Surman, Michael K. (1997). "Dinosaurs and the media". In Farlow, James; Brett-Surman, Michael K. (eds.). The Complete Dinosaur . Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press. pp.  675–706. ISBN   978-0-253-33349-0.
68. Gould, S. J. (1991). Bully for Brontosaurus: Reflections in Natural History . W. W. Norton & Co. p. 540.
69. "Evolution of the Company Symbol". Sinclair Oil Corporation. 2013. Archived from the original on June 21, 2014. Retrieved April 8, 2014.
70. "Topics of The Times: Leapin' Lizards!". The New York Times . October 11, 1989. Retrieved June 8, 2008.
71. Larimore, Rachael (April 7, 2015). "Dino-Mite! Study Suggests That the Brontosaurus Really Did Exist". Slate. ISSN   1091-2339 . Retrieved June 18, 2015.
72. "Why Do We Love the Brontosaurus?". The New Yorker. Retrieved June 18, 2015.
73. Laden, Greg (April 8, 2015). "Bully for Brontosaurus". Greg Laden's Blog. Science. 348 (6231): 168. Bibcode:2015Sci...348..168B. doi:10.1126/science.348.6231.168. PMID   25859023 . Retrieved June 18, 2015.
74. Wedel, Matt (April 7, 2015). "Welcome back, Brontosaurus! And other first thoughts on Tschopp et al. (2015)". Sauropod Vertebra Picture of the Week. Retrieved June 18, 2015.
75. "Did You Ever Think You'd See The Day? The Brontosaurus Exists Once Again!". perezhilton.com. April 7, 2015. Archived from the original on July 2, 2017. Retrieved June 18, 2015.
76. Callaway, Ewen (April 7, 2015). "Beloved Brontosaurus makes a comeback". Nature . doi:10.1038/nature.2015.17257 . Retrieved June 18, 2015.
77. Devlin, Hannah (April 7, 2015). "Brontosaurus is back! New analysis suggests genus might be resurrected". Science. The Guardian. Retrieved June 18, 2015.

External links

• Media related to Brontosaurus at Wikimedia Commons
• Wikijunior Dinosaurs/Brontosaurus at Wikibooks
• Is Brontosaurus Back? (Youtube video, 11 minutes, 2015)