Christianization of Iberia

Last updated

A benediction cross of Catholicos-Patriarch Domentius IV of Georgia showing the scenes of Triumphal Entry, Crucifixion and Ascension of Jesus, Dormition of the Mother of God, Raising of Lazarus and Pentecost. Catholicos-Patriarch asks for the "forgiveness of his sins" as written on the handle of the cross in Georgian Mkhedruli script. Kept at the Walters Art Museum in the United States. Georgian - Benediction Cross - Walters 61141 - Back.jpg
A benediction cross of Catholicos-Patriarch Domentius IV of Georgia showing the scenes of Triumphal Entry , Crucifixion and Ascension of Jesus, Dormition of the Mother of God , Raising of Lazarus and Pentecost . Catholicos-Patriarch asks for the "forgiveness of his sins" as written on the handle of the cross in Georgian Mkhedruli script . Kept at the Walters Art Museum in the United States.

The Christianization of Iberia (Georgian :ქართლის გაქრისტიანებაkartlis gakrist'ianeba) [a] refers to the spread of Christianity in the early 4th century by the sermon of Saint Nino in an ancient Georgian kingdom of Kartli, known as Iberia in classical antiquity, which resulted in declaring it as a state religion by then-pagan King Mirian III of Iberia. Per Sozomen, this led the king's "large and warlike barbarian nation to confess Christ and renounce the religion of their fathers", [1] as the polytheistic Georgians had long-established anthropomorphic idols, known as the "Gods of Kartli". [2] The king would become the main sponsor, architect, initiator and an organizing power of all building processes. [3] Per Socrates of Constantinople, the "Iberians first embraced the Christian faith" [4] alongside the Abyssinians, but most probably Kartli would become a second state after the Kingdom of Armenia, its longtime southern neighbor, that officially embraced the new religion. [5] Armenian and Georgian monarchs were among the first anywhere in the world to convert to a Christian faith. [6] Prior to the escalation of Armeno-Georgian ecclesiastical rivalry [7] and the christological controversies their Caucasian Christianity was extraordinarily inclusive, pluralistic and flexible that only saw the rigid ecclesiological hierarchies established much later, particularly as "national" churches crystallized from the 6th century. [8] Despite the tremendous diversity of the region, the christianization process was a pan-regional and a cross-cultural phenomenon in the Caucasus, [9] Eurasia's most energetic and cosmopolitan zones throughout the late antiquity, hard enough to place Georgians and Armenians unequivocally within any one major civilization. [10] The Jews of Mtskheta, the royal capital of Kartli, that did play a significant role in the Christianization of the kingdom, would give a strong impetus to deepen the ties between the Georgian monarchy and the Holy Land leading to an increasing presence of Georgians in Palestine, as the activities of Peter the Iberian confirm, including the oldest attested Georgian Bir el Qutt inscriptions found in the Judaean Desert. [11] [12]

Contents

Iberia was a factor in a competitive diplomacy of the Roman and Sasanian Empires, and on occasion became a major player in proxy wars between the two empires. Iberia, a Georgian monarchy, that shared many institutions and concepts with the neighboring Iranians, being physically connected to their "Iranian Commonwealth" since the Achaemenid period through commerce, war or marriage, [13] its adoption of Christianity meant that King Mirian III made a cultural and historical choice with profound international implications, though his decision was never tied with the Roman diplomatic initiatives. Iberia, architecturally and artistically rooted in Achaemenid culture, [14] from its Hellenistic-era establishment to the conversion of the crown, [15] embarked on a new multi-phased process that took centuries to complete, [16] [17] encompassing the entire 5th, 6th and early 7th centuries, [18] resulting in the emergence of a strong Georgian identity. [19]

On the eve of the historic christianization, the king and the queen were quickly acculturated Georgianized foreigners, [20] the physical fusion of Iranian and Greek cultures, Saint Nino, also a foreigner, [21] the earliest first two chief bishops of Kartli, also foreigners, the Greeks, sent by the emperor Constantine the Great. [22] Only in the first half of the 6th century, the Georgians would permanently seize the highest ecclesiastical posts, but outsiders like Iranians, Armenians and Syrians would continue playing a prominent role in the administration of the Georgian church. [23]

Christianization by an Apostle

Even though Iberia officially embraced Christianity in the early 4th century, the Georgian Orthodox Church claims Apostolic origin and regards Andrew the Apostle as the founder of the Georgian church, also supported by some Byzantine sources. Ephrem Mtsire would later explain Saint Nino's role with the necessity of Iberia's "second Christening". The archaeological artifacts confirm the spread of Christianity before the conversion of King Mirian in the 4th century. Some of the third-century burials in Georgia include Christian objects such as signet rings with a cross and ichthys or anchor and fish, clearly attesting their Christian affiliation. These can mean that the upper class Iberians had embraced Christianity much earlier than its "official Christianization" date. [24]

Christianization of the royal family

According to The Georgian Chronicles and the Conversion of Kartli chronicle, a Cappadocian woman Nino converted Queen Nana and later King Mirian III to Christianity, that led to the Christianization process of the entire kingdom of Kartli and its people. [25] Tyrannius Rufinus, Gelasius of Caesarea, Gelasius of Cyzicus, Theodoret, Socrates of Constantinople and Sozomen, whom Bacurius the Iberian, a royalty, a "little king" [26] and a principal commander of emperor Theodosius I, [27] [28] served as one of the sources of the Georgian conversion to Christianity; all have the similar narrative of the Georgian tradition, the only major thing that differs per these Greco-Roman authors is Nino being an unnamed Roman captive who was brought to Iberia. According to Georgian sources, Nino was a daughter of Zabilon and Susana, [29] a family endowed with a direct but unlikely link to Jerusalem. [30] When she went to Jerusalem to see her father once she asked if anyone knew where the Seamless Robe of Jesus was, she was told that it was kept "in the eastern city of Mtskheta, a country of Kartli [i.e. Iberia]." [31] She would decide to go to Iberia and will eventually reach the mountains of Javakheti after four months of travel, in June. She stayed for two days at the Paravani Lake and then continued her travel towards the royal city of Mtskheta. [32] When she reached the capital, she found herself at the pagan holiday held for god Armazi with King Mirian III taking part in the ceremony. Nino, shocked by the event, started to pray, resulting in the "severe wind" that destroyed the pagan statue. [33] Later she was approached by the attendants of Queen Nana of Iberia who was suffering from a grave illness. She was asked to cure the queen. The queen was healed immediately, and Nino converted the queen to Christ. Hearing about the queen's healing, the king was "very surprised". [34] He initially opposed his wife's new religion until he, too, encountered a miracle one day while hunting, riding and "looking over Uplistsikhe" through the woods of Tkhoti mountain when he suddenly was surrounded by a threatening darkness of the solar eclipse . [35]

და დაშთა მეფე მარტო, და იარებოდა მთათა და მაღნართა შეშინებული და შეძრწუნებული. დადგა ერთსა ადგილსა და წარეწირა სასოება ცხოვრებისა მისისა. და ვითარცა მოეგო თავსა თჳსსა ცნობასა, და განიზრახვიდა ესრეთ გულსა თჳსსა: "აჰა ესე რა, ვხადე ღმერთთა ჩემთა და არა ვპოვე ჩემ ზედა ლხინება. აწ, რომელსა იგი ქადაგებს ნინო ჯუარსა და ჯუარცმულსა და ჰყოფს კურნებასა, მისითა მოსავობითა, არამცა ძალ ედვაა ჴსნა ჩემი ამის ჭირისაგან? რამეთუ ვარ მე ცოცხლივ ჯოჯოხეთსა შინა და არა უწყი, თუ ყოვლისა ქუეყანისათჳს იქმნა დაქცევა ესე, ანუ თუ ჩემთჳს ოდენ იქმნა. აწ, თუ ოდენ ჩემთჳს არს ჭირი ესე, ღმერთო ნინოსო, განმინათლე ბნელი ესე და მიჩუენე საყოფელი ჩემი და აღვიარო სახელი შენი, და აღვმართო ძელი ჯუარისა და თაყუანისვცე მას და აღვაშენო სახლი სალოცველად ჩემდა, და ვიყო მორჩილ ნინოსა სჯულსა ზედა ჰრომთასა.
And the king got alone, and he walked over the hills and woods scared and terrified. He stood at one place and became desperate over his life. And when he recovered his consciousness, and decided to his heart: "So this is it, I had my god and found no joy. Let the one preached by Nino, the cross and the one that was crucified and does the healing, by his glory – isn't he powerful enough to save me from this trouble? As I am lively into a hell and I don't know, how the whole world was this destroyed, or is it just for me. Let, if this is only for me to be in trouble like this, O God of Nino, enlighten the darkness and show me the place of mine and I will recognize your name, and will erect a pillar of Cross and will respect it and will build a house for me to pray, and will be obedient to Nino's faith of Rome. [36]

When at last, he called Christ, his wife's new God, for help – the daylight immediately returned. The king jumped down from the horse, raised his hands up to the "eastern sky" and said:

შენ ხარ ღმერთი ყოველთა ზედა ღმერთთა და უფალი ყოველთა ზედა უფალთა, ღმერთი, რომელსა ნინო იტყჳს.
You are the God over all the other Gods and Lord over all the other Lords, God, who is proclaimed by Nino. [37]

After saying this, the king promised again to the new God to erect "a pillar of Cross". When safely returned to the capital, greeted by his "queen and the entire nation" of Kartli, the king "shouted loudly" where was his "savior and mother, a stranger lady", Nino. When told, he with his army went directly to her. At the urging of Nino, the king laid the foundations of a church to commemorate his new faith, Christianity. [38] According to Movses Khorenatsi after Mirian's conversion, Nino "destroyed the image of Armazi, the god of thunder". [39] When the church was completed, the king sent ambassadors to the emperor Constantine the Great requesting him to send clergy to help establish the faith in the kingdom. Per Sozomen, Constantine hearing the news of the Christian conversion of Iberia, "the emperor of the Romans was delighted, acceding to every request that was proffered." [40] Foundation of the Georgian Church and spread of a new religion in Kartli were made possible mostly by the activities of kings and aristocracy. [41] King Mirian III's main church-building activity in Mtskheta saw the construction of the Svetitskhoveli Cathedral, according to the Georgian tradition connected with the Seamless Robe of Jesus , [42] brought by a pious Jew named Elias, an eyewitness of the Crucifixion of Jesus, to Mtskheta from Jerusalem in the first century. [43] [44] [45] The Samtavro Monastery, king's own sepulchre church, was built outside the city though. This remembers the situation of the church buildings of Constantine the Great and his family outside of the Roman pomerium . But the sepulchre of the first Christian Georgian king was inside the church whereas the sepulchres for the members of the Constantinian dynasty were located in an own imperial mausoleum near the church. Also, the Constantinian churches were devoted to the cult of Christian martyrs, [46] whereas the earliest history of the Georgian church had no martyrs. [47]

After the conversion and Christianization of the monarchy, [48] the Georgians intensified their contacts with the Holy Land. A pre-Christian Iberia have had a Jewish community as early as the times of Nebuchadnezzar II [49] and there were close and deep connections in the Iberian ideology of the sacred – with the holiness of Jerusalem. This Iberian fascination with Jerusalem and Zion , largely predates the claims Georgia's unprecedented "Byzantinizing" [50] [51] Bagrationi monarchs to have descended directly from King David. [52] Iberia by having a direct connection to Jerusalem, had several monasteries there already. It was Jerusalem where Rufinus met Bacurius, and by the end of the fourth century a Georgian monastery was founded there. [53] During the reign of Vakhtang I, the Georgian hero-king, [54] the Georgian church would receive the rank of Catholicos and be recognized autocephalous by the Church of Antioch. [55]

Christianization of the countryside

Despite the royal enthusiasm for the new religion, and its adoption within court circles, Christianity took root slowly in the rural districts of the kingdom. [56] Nino and her entourage met hostility from highlanders inhabiting the southeastern slopes of the Caucasus Mountains, but ultimately, they were persuaded to surrender their idols. Resistance also arose within the Jewish community of Mtskheta. [57] The first steps in the Christianization of Iberia's countryside occurred in the late fifth and early sixth centuries when after it within a generation, the indigenous monastic traditions took deep root, and facilitated the spread of Christian faith into the more peripheral regions of Kartli. [58] Sometime in the 530s or 540s, Thirteen Assyrian Fathers arrived in Mtskheta, [59] whose activity would result in the establishment of some sixteen monasteries and other churches all around Georgia, many of whose sixth-century foundations still can be observed today. [60]

Christianization date

Solar eclipse of 11 July 2010, totality seen from the French Polynesia. Eclipse 2010 Hao 1.JPG
Solar eclipse of 11 July 2010, totality seen from the French Polynesia.

Estimates of the conversion date by historians have ranged over much of King Mirian III long reign. Foreign and Georgian scholars' proposed dates are the following: AD 312, 317, 318, 320, 323, 325/6/7/8, 330/1/2/3/4/5/6/7. Once widely accepted AD 337 for Iberia's conversion, is favored nowadays by many scholars to be AD 326, [61] possibly a "third Sunday after Easter" per John Zosimus, that was on 1 May, [62] the year traditionally held by the Georgian Orthodox Church. [63]

Apart from the historians, Iberia's conversion is of greater interest during decades of debates, to the Astronomy scholars – who maintain that there is a high possibility that the total solar eclipse of AD 319, 6 May is the exact date of the Georgian conversion, an eclipse that actually happened in the 4th century and reached eastern Georgia, and this "eclipse hypothesis" is not new. [64] An eclipse per model ΔT≈7500 with solar azimuth angle being about 290° [65] would make King Mirian III and his fellow hunters – or royal entourage – witness the totality of it, but not the townspeople nearby. [66] The visibility conditions for the king on the Tkhoti mountain could have been similar to the Solar eclipse of 11 July 2010 as seen at sunset from the mountainous terrain of Patagonia. [67] During the eclipse of AD 319, observers at lower elevations near Mtskheta, would have seen the sky grow prematurely dark and then slightly brighter, without the Sun reappearing over the horizon. At higher elevations nearby such as where the king might have been, totality of an eclipse may indeed have been a remarkable sight. L. V. Morrison and F. R. Stephenson according to their geophysical model ΔT≈7450±180°, do not contradict this scenario and an intriguing possibility, [68] but it remains an open question whether the ancient and medieval written accounts are trustworthy, if they are really based on actual facts. [69]

According to The Georgian Chronicles it was "one day of Summer, July 20, a Saturday." [70]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Georgian historiography refers to an event as Conversion of Kartli (Moktsevay Kartlisay) just like the chronicle.

Related Research Articles

Kingdom of Iberia (antiquity) Ancient Georgian kingdom of Kartli

In Greco-Roman geography, Iberia was an exonym for the Georgian kingdom of Kartli, known after its core province, which during Classical Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages was a significant monarchy in the Caucasus, either as an independent state or as a dependent of larger empires, notably the Sassanid and Roman empires. Iberia, centered on present-day Eastern Georgia, was bordered by Colchis in the west, Caucasian Albania in the east and Armenia in the south.

Georgian Orthodox Church National Eastern Orthodox church

The Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia, commonly known as the Georgian Orthodox Church or the Orthodox Church of Georgia, is an autocephalous Eastern Orthodox Church in full communion with the other churches of Eastern Orthodoxy. It is Georgia's dominant religious institution, and a majority of Georgian people are members. The Orthodox Church of Georgia is one of the oldest churches in the world. It asserts apostolic foundation, and its historical roots must be traced to the early and late Christianization of Iberia and Colchis by Saint Andrew in the 1st century AD and by Saint Nino in the 4th century AD, respectively.

Pharnavaz I of Iberia King of All Iberia and Colchis"`UNIQ--ref-00000047-QINU`"

Pharnavaz I was a king of Kartli, an ancient Georgian kingdom known as Iberia in classical antiquity. The Georgian Chronicles credits him with being the first monarch founding the kingship of Kartli and the Pharnavazid dynasty, while other independent chronicles, such as The Conversion of Kartli make him the second Georgian monarch. Based on the medieval evidence, most scholars locate Pharnavaz's rule in the 3rd century BC: 302–237 BC according to Prince Vakhushti of Kartli, 299–234 BC according to Cyril Toumanoff and 284–219 BC according to Pavle Ingoroqva. Pharnavaz's rise, advent and imperial expansion of the Iberian monarchy was directly tied to the victory of Alexander the Great over the Achaemenid Empire. Pharnavaz ruled under the suzerainty of the Seleucid Empire.

Mirian III of Iberia

Mirian III was a king of Iberia or Kartli (Georgia), contemporaneous to the Roman emperor Constantine the Great. He was the founder of the royal Chosroid dynasty.

Kartli Historical Region in Georgia

Kartli is a historical region in central-to-eastern Georgia traversed by the river Mtkvari (Kura), on which Georgia's capital, Tbilisi, is situated. Known to the Classical authors as Iberia, Kartli played a crucial role in the ethnic and political consolidation of the Georgians in the Middle Ages. Kartli had no strictly defined boundaries and they significantly fluctuated in the course of history. After the partition of the kingdom of Georgia in the 15th century, Kartli became a separate kingdom with its capital at Tbilisi. The historical lands of Kartli are currently divided among several administrative regions of Georgia.

Saint Nino Early Christian saint

Saint NinoEqual to the Apostles and the Enlightener of Georgia was a woman who preached Christianity in the territory of Caucasian Iberia, of what is now part of Georgia. It resulted in the Christianization of the royal house of Iberia, with the consequent Christianization of Iberia.

Azo, Azoy or Azon was a ruler of Georgians of ancient Kartli claimed by medieval Georgian annals to have been installed by Alexander the Great, king of Macedon.

Pkhovi

Pkhovi, also known as Pkhoet'i (ფხოეთი), is a medieval term for the mountainous district in northeast Georgia comprising the latter-day provinces of Pshavi and Khevsureti along the upper reaches of the Aragvi, and in three alpine valleys just north of the main crest of the Greater Caucasus. Its inhabitants – the Pkhovians – were a tribe of Georgian highlanders known for their warlike character and frequent disobedience to the royal authority.

The Chosroid dynasty, also known as the Iberian Mihranids, were a dynasty of the kings and later the presiding princes of the early Georgian state of Iberia from the 4th to the 9th centuries. The family, of Iranian Mihranid origin, accepted Christianity as their official religion c. 337, and maneuvered between the Byzantine Empire and Sassanid Iran to retain a degree of independence. After the abolition of the Iberian kingship by the Sassanids c. 580, the dynasty survived in its two closely related, but sometimes competing princely branches—the elder Chosroid and the younger Guaramid—down to the early ninth century when they were succeeded by the Georgian Bagratids on the throne of Iberia.

Amazasp II was a king of Iberia and the last in the P’arnavaziani line according to the medieval Georgian chronicles. A son and successor of P’arsman III, he is assumed to have ruled in the latter quarter of the 2nd century, from 185 to 189 according to Cyril Toumanoff.

Arian Kartli or Aryan-Kartli was a country claimed by the medieval Georgian chronicle "The Conversion of Kartli" to be the earlier homeland of the Georgians of Kartli.

Pharnavazid dynasty dynasty

The Pharnavazid, Pharnabazid or Parnavazianni is the name of the first dynasty of Georgian kings of Kartli (Iberia) preserved by The Georgian Chronicles. Their rule lasted, with intermissions, from the 3rd century BC to the 2nd century AD. The main male line is reported to have become extinct early on and followed by houses related to it in the female line. By the close of the 2nd century AD, the Pharnavazid rule came to an end and the Arsacid Dynasty took over the crown of Iberia.

Prince Archil the Martyr was an 8th-century Georgian Orthodox Christian royal prince of the eastern Georgian region of Kakheti.

Nana of Iberia Queen of Iberia

Nana was a Queen consort of Kingdom of Iberia as the second wife of Mirian III in the 4th century. For her role in the conversion of Georgians to Christianity she is regarded by the Georgian Orthodox Church as saint and is canonized as Saint Equal to the Apostles Queen Nana.

Salome was an Armenian princess from the Arsacid dynasty who was married into the Chosroid Dynasty of Iberia. She was a daughter of King Tiridates III of Armenia and Queen Ashkhen. She had a brother called Khosrov III and an unnamed sister who married St. Husik I, one of the earlier Catholicoi of the Armenian Apostolic Church. She has been canonized by the Armenian and Georgian churches. In Georgian tradition, she is referred to as Salome of Ujarma after a castle where she is credited to have erected a cross.

Ainina and Danina or Ainina and Danana are a pair of pre-Christian female deities worshipped in ancient Kartli—Iberia of the Classical sources—as claimed by the medieval Georgian chronicles. Beyond these later records no evidence is available for the existence of these cults.

Erusheti was a medieval Georgian fiefdom, currently part of the Ardahan Province in northeastern Turkey, close to the border with Georgia. The district was centered in the eponymous settlement, at the present-day village Oğuzyolu, which, according to the medieval historical tradition, was one of the earliest centres of Christianity in Georgia. Ruins of Christian churches are found throughout the region. In modern Georgia, the name "Erusheti" is preserved as a designation of a mountainous range along the border with Turkey.

Manglisi Borough in Kvemo Kartli, Georgia

Manglisi is a daba (townlet) in the Tetritsqaro Municipality, Kvemo Kartli region of Georgia. As of the 2014 census, it had the population of 1,441. With a recorded history going back to the 4th century, Manglisi was one of the earliest centers of Christianity in Georgia and is a home to the medieval cathedral of the Mother of God. It also functions as a mountain spa and health resort.

Sasanian Iberia

Sasanian Iberia refers to the period the Kingdom of Iberia was under the suzerainty of the Sasanian Empire. The period includes when it was ruled by Marzbans (governors) appointed by the Sasanid Iranian king, and later through the Principality of Iberia.

Aghaiani church of Saint Nino

Aghaiani church of Saint Nino is an early medieval Georgian Orthodox church on Mount Tkhoti, 2 km southeast of the village of Aghaiani in the Kaspi Municipality in Georgia's Shida Kartli region. It stands at the place of one of the three wooden crosses erected—according to historical tradition—at the behest of Saint Nino to mark adoption of Christianity by the people of Kartli. The extant structure is a hall church, a 9th–10th-century remodeling of an earlier cross-in-square building. The church is inscribed on the list of Georgia's Immovable Cultural Monuments of National Significance.

References

  1. Schaff, p. 263
  2. Rapp (2016) location: 4308
  3. Plontke-Lüning, p. 469
  4. Schaff, p. 23
  5. Suny, p. 21
  6. Rapp & Mgaloblishvili, p. 266
  7. Rapp (2016) location: 5439
  8. Rapp & Mgaloblishvili, p. 264
  9. Rapp, p. 4
  10. Rapp (2016) location: 413
  11. Rapp & Mgaloblishvili, p. 267
  12. Rapp (2016) location: 628
  13. Rapp & Mgaloblishvili, p. 263
  14. Rapp (2016) location: 753
  15. Rapp, p. 18
  16. Haas, (2008), p. 106
  17. Suny, p. 20
  18. Rapp (2016) location: 2221
  19. Haas, p. 44
  20. Rapp (2016) location: 8678
  21. Rapp (2016) location: 7149
  22. Rapp (2016) location: 8445
  23. Rapp (2016) location: 8454
  24. Haas, (2008), p. 114
  25. Rapp (2016) location: 8361
  26. Schaff, p. 25
  27. Haas, (2008), p. 108
  28. Schaff, p. 135
  29. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 76, line of ed 8
  30. Rapp (2016) location: 3658
  31. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 79, line of ed 2–5
  32. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 85, line of ed 5–6
  33. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 91, line of ed 13
  34. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 105, line of ed 12
  35. Rapp (2016) location: 3749
  36. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 109, line of ed 14–24
  37. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 110, line of ed 5–6
  38. Haas, (2008), p. 107
  39. Rapp (2016) location: 4370
  40. Schaff, p. 264
  41. Plontke-Lüning, p. 454
  42. Plontke-Lüning, p. 461
  43. Haas, p. 29
  44. Mgaloblishvili, p. 40
  45. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 99, line of ed 14
  46. Plontke-Lüning, p. 462
  47. Plontke-Lüning, p. 463
  48. Rapp, p. 5
  49. Mgaloblishvili, p. 39
  50. Rapp, p. 1
  51. Rapp (2016) location: 482
  52. Haas, (2008), p. 110
  53. Haas, (2008), p. 111
  54. Rapp, p. 22
  55. Haas, p. 42
  56. Haas, (2008), p. 116
  57. Rapp (2016) location: 4277
  58. Haas, (2008), p. 117
  59. Haas, (2008), p. 119
  60. Haas, (2008), p. 120
  61. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 31
  62. Mgaloblishvili, p. 44
  63. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 32
  64. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 26
  65. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 42
  66. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 41
  67. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 35
  68. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 43
  69. Sauter, Simonia, Stephenson & Orchiston, p. 44
  70. Georgian Chronicles, page of ed 108, line of ed 17

Bibliography