Ebla

Last updated

Ebla
HPIM3078 1.JPG
Ruins of the outer wall and the "Damascus Gate"
Syria physical location map.svg
Archaeological site icon (red).svg
Shown within Syria
Alternative nameTell Mardikh
تل مرديخ
Location Idlib Governorate, Syria
Coordinates 35°47′53″N36°47′53″E / 35.798°N 36.798°E / 35.798; 36.798 Coordinates: 35°47′53″N36°47′53″E / 35.798°N 36.798°E / 35.798; 36.798
Typesettlement
History
Foundedc. 3500 BC
Abandoned7th century  AD
Periods Bronze Age
Cultures Kish civilization, Amorite
Site notes
Excavation dates1964–2011
Archaeologists Paolo Matthiae
ConditionRuined
OwnershipPublic
Public accessYes

Ebla (Sumerian: 𒌈𒆷eb₂-la, [1] Arabic : إبلا, modern: تل مرديخ, Tell Mardikh) was one of the earliest kingdoms in Syria. Its remains constitute a tell located about 55 km (34 mi) southwest of Aleppo near the village of Mardikh. Ebla was an important center throughout the 3rd millennium BC and in the first half of the 2nd millennium BC. Its discovery proved the Levant was a center of ancient, centralized civilization equal to Egypt and Mesopotamia and ruled out the view that the latter two were the only important centers in the Near East during the Early Bronze Age. The first Eblaite kingdom has been described as the first recorded world power.

Contents

Starting as a small settlement in the Early Bronze Age (c. 3500 BC), Ebla developed into a trading empire and later into an expansionist power that imposed its hegemony over much of northern and eastern Syria. Ebla was destroyed during the 23rd century BC. It was then rebuilt and was mentioned in the records of the Third Dynasty of Ur. The second Ebla was a continuation of the first, ruled by a new royal dynasty. It was destroyed at the end of the 3rd millennium BC, which paved the way for the Amorite tribes to settle in the city, forming the third Ebla. The third kingdom also flourished as a trade center; it became a subject and an ally of Yamhad (modern-day Aleppo) until its final destruction by the Hittite king Mursili I in c. 1600 BC.

Ebla maintained its prosperity through a vast trading network. Artifacts from Sumer, Cyprus, Egypt and as far as Afghanistan were recovered from the city's palaces. The kingdom had its own language, Eblaite, and the political organization of Ebla had features different from the Sumerian model. Women enjoyed a special status, and the queen had major influence in the state and religious affairs. The pantheon of gods was mainly north Semitic and included deities exclusive to Ebla. The city was excavated from 1964 and became famous for the Ebla tablets, an archive of about 20,000  cuneiform tablets found there, dated to around 2350 BC. [note 1] Written in both Sumerian and Eblaite and using the cuneiform, the archive has allowed a better understanding of the Sumerian language and provided important information over the political organization and social customs of the mid-3rd millennium BC's Levant.

History

A possible meaning of the word "Ebla" is "white rock", referring to the limestone outcrop on which the city was built. [2] [3] Ebla was first settled around 3500 BC; [4] [5] its growth was supported by many satellite agricultural settlements. [4] The city benefited from its role as an entrepôt of growing international trade, which probably began with an increased demand for wool in Sumer. [4] Archaeologists designate this early habitation period "Mardikh I"; it ended around 3000 BC. [6] Mardikh I is followed by the first and second kingdoms era between about 3000 and 2000 BC, designated "Mardikh II". [7] I. J. Gelb considered Ebla as part of the Kish civilization, which was a cultural entity of East Semitic-speaking populations that stretched from the center of Mesopotamia to the western Levant. [8]

First kingdom

First Eblaite Kingdom
Ebla
c. 3000 BC–c. 2300 BC
First Eblaite Empire.png
The first kingdom at its greatest extent, including vassals
CapitalEbla
Common languages Palaeo-Syrian
Religion
Ancient Levantine religion. [9]
GovernmentMonarchy
Historical era Bronze Age
• Established
c. 3000 BC
• Disestablished
c. 2300 BC
Succeeded by
The second kingdom of Mari Second Mariote kingdom.png
Today part of Syria
Lebanon
Turkey

During the first kingdom period between about 3000 and 2300 BC, Ebla was the most prominent kingdom among the Syrian states, especially during the second half of the 3rd millennium BC, which is known as "the age of the archives" after the Ebla tablets. [7]

Early period

The early period between 3000 and 2400 BC is designated "Mardikh IIA". [7] [10] General knowledge about the city's history prior to the written archives is obtained through excavations. [11] The first stages of Mardikh IIA is identified with building "CC", [12] and structures that form a part of building "G2", [13] which was apparently a royal palace built c. 2700 BC. [4] [14] Toward the end of this period, a hundred years' war with Mari started. [15] [16] Mari gained the upper hand through the actions of its king Saʿumu, who conquered many of Ebla's cities. [17] In the mid-25th century BC, king Kun-Damu defeated Mari, but the state's power declined following his reign. [note 2] [18]

Archive period

Royal palace "G" Ebla - DecArch - 2-126.jpg
Royal palace "G"

The archive period, which is designated "Mardikh IIB1", lasted from c. 2400 BC until c. 2300 BC. [7] The end of the period is known as the "first destruction", [19] mainly referring to the destruction of the royal palace (called palace "G" and built over the earlier "G2"), [20] and much of the acropolis. [21] During the archive period, Ebla had political and military dominance over the other Syrian city-states of northern and eastern Syria, which are mentioned in the archives. [22] Most of the tablets, which date from that period, are about economic matters but also include royal letters and diplomatic documents. [23]

The written archives do not date from before Igrish-Halam's reign, [24] which saw Ebla paying tribute to Mari, [25] and an extensive invasion of Eblaite cities in the middle Euphrates region led by the Mariote king Iblul-Il. [26] [27] Ebla recovered under King Irkab-Damu in about 2340 BC; becoming prosperous and launching a successful counter-offensive against Mari. [28] [29] Irkab-Damu concluded a peace and trading treaty with Abarsal; [note 3] [30] it is one of the earliest-recorded treaties in history. [31]

At its greatest extent, Ebla controlled an area roughly half the size of modern Syria, [32] from Ursa'um in the north, [33] to the area around Damascus in the south, [34] and from Phoenicia and the coastal mountains in the west, [35] [36] to Haddu in the east. [30] [37] Large parts of the kingdom were under the direct control of the king and was administered by governors; the rest consisted of vassal kingdoms. [32] One of the most important of these vassals was Armi, [38] which is the city most often mentioned in the Ebla tablets. [39] Ebla had more than sixty vassal kingdoms and city-states, [40] including Hazuwan, Burman, Emar, Halabitu and Salbatu. [29] [37] [41]

The vizier was the king's chief official. [42] The holder of the office possessed great authority; the most powerful vizier was Ibrium, who campaigned against Abarsal during the term of his predecessor Arrukum. [43] Ibrium held office for 18 years with warfare occurring in all but one year. [44] During the reign of Isar-Damu, Ebla continued the war against Mari, which defeated Ebla's ally Nagar, blocking trade routes between Ebla and southern Mesopotamia via upper Mesopotamia. [25] Ebla conducted regular military campaigns against rebellious vassals, [43] including several attacks on Armi, [45] [46] [39] and a campaign against the southern region of Ib'al – close to Qatna. [43] [47] In order to settle the war with Mari, Isar-Damu allied with Nagar and Kish. Some scholars have suggested that the Kish in question was not the Mesopotamian city but rather a town near Nagar in the Khabur area. [48] [49] The campaign was headed by the Eblaite vizier Ibbi-Sipish, who led the combined armies to victory in a battle near Terqa. [43] The alliance also attacked Armi and occupied it, leaving Ibbi-Sipish's son Enzi-Malik as governor. [39] Ebla suffered its first destruction a few years after the campaign, [50] probably following Isar-Damu's death. [51]

First destruction of Ebla

The first destruction occurred c. 2300 BC; palace "G" was burned, baking the clay tablets of the royal archives and preserving them. [52] Many theories about the cause and the perpetrator have been posited: [50]

Akkadian soldier of Naram-Sin, with helmet and long sword, on the Nasiriyah stele. He carries a metal vessel of Anatolian type. From Mesopotamia, Iraq, c. 2300 BC. Iraq Museum. Akkadian soldier of Naram-Sin.jpg
Akkadian soldier of Naram-Sin, with helmet and long sword, on the Nasiriyah stele. He carries a metal vessel of Anatolian type. From Mesopotamia, Iraq, c. 2300 BC. Iraq Museum.
  • High (early) dating hypothesis: Giovanni Pettinato supports an early dating for Ebla that would put the destruction at around 2500 BC. [note 4] [55] Pettinato, while preferring the date of 2500 BC, later accepted the event could have happened in 2400 BC. [note 5] [56] The scholar suggests the city was destroyed in 2400 BC by a Mesopotamian such as Eannatum of Lagash – who boasted of taking tribute from Mari – or Lugalzagesi of Umma, who claimed to have reached the Mediterranean. [note 6] [56]
  • Akkadian hypothesis: Both kings Sargon of Akkad and his grandson Naram-Sin claimed to have destroyed a town called Ibla, [57] The discoverer of Ebla, Paolo Matthiae, considers Sargon a more likely culprit; [note 7] [59] his view is supported by Trevor Bryce, [60] but rejected by Michael Astour. [note 8] [64] The conquest of Armanum and Ebla on the Mediterranean coast by Naram-Sin is mentioned in several of his inscriptions: [65]

"Whereas, for all time since the creation of mankind, no king whosoever had destroyed Armanum and Ebla, the god Nergal, by means of (his) weapons opened the way for Naram-Sin, the mighty, and gave him Armanum and Ebla. Further, he gave to him the Amanus, the Cedar Mountain, and the Upper Sea. By means of the weapons of the god Dagan, who magnifies his kingship, Naram-Sin, the mighty, conquered Armanum and Ebla."

— Inscription of Naram-Sin. E 2.1.4.26 [65]
  • Mari's revenge: According to Alfonso Archi and Maria Biga, the destruction happened approximately three or four years after the battle of Terqa. [50] Archi and Biga say the destruction was caused by Mari [50] in retaliation for its humiliating defeat at Terqa. [66] [67] This view is supported by Mario Liverani. [43] Archi says the Mariote king Isqi-Mari destroyed Ebla before ascending the throne of his city. [68]
  • Natural catastrophe: Astour says a natural catastrophe caused the blaze which ended the archive period. [21] He says the destruction was limited to the area of the royal palace and there is no convincing evidence of looting. [21] He dates the fire to c. 2290 BC (Middle Chronology). [69]

Second kingdom

Second Eblaite Kingdom
Ebla
c. 2300 BC–c. 2000 BC
Second Eblaite Empire.png
Approximate borders of the second kingdom
CapitalEbla
Common languages Palaeo-Syrian
GovernmentMonarchy
Historical era Bronze Age
• Established
c. 2300 BC
• Disestablished
c. 2000 BC

The second kingdom's period is designated "Mardikh IIB2", and spans the period between 2300 and 2000 BC. [19] The second kingdom lasted until Ebla's second destruction, which occurred anytime between 2050 and 1950 BC, with the 2000 BC dating being a mere formal date. [70] [71] The Akkadians under Sargon of Akkad and his descendant Naram-Sin invaded the northern borders of Ebla aiming for the forests of the Amanus Mountain; the intrusions were separated by roughly 90 years and the areas attacked were not attached to Akkad. [16] Archi accept that the Ibla mentioned in the annals of Sargon and Naram-Sin is the Syrian Ebla but do not consider them responsible for the destruction which ended the Archive period. [72] By the time of Naram-Sin, Armi was the hegemonic city in northern Syria and was destroyed by the Akkadian king. [73]

Palace "P5" Ebla9.JPG
Palace "P5"

A new local dynasty ruled the second kingdom of Ebla, [60] but there was continuity with its first kingdom heritage. [74] Ebla maintained its earliest features, including its architectural style and the sanctity of the first kingdom's religious sites. [75] A new royal palace was built in the lower town, [76] and the transition from the archive period is marked only by the destruction of palace "G". [21] Little is known about the second kingdom because no written material have been discovered aside from one inscription dating to the end of the period. [76]

The second kingdom was attested to in contemporaneous sources; in an inscription, Gudea of Lagash asked for cedars to be brought from Urshu in the mountains of Ebla, indicating Ebla's territory included Urshu north of Carchemish in modern-day Turkey. [77] Texts that dates to the seventh year of Amar-Sin (c. 2040 BC), [note 9] a ruler of the Ur III empire, mention a messenger of the Ensí ("Megum") of Ebla. [note 10] [note 11] [84] The second kingdom was considered a vassal by the Ur III government, [85] but the nature of the relation is unknown and it included the payment of tribute. [86] A formal recognition of Ur's overlordship appears to be a condition for the right of trade with that empire. [33]

The second kingdom disintegrated toward the end of the 21st century BC, [33] and ended with the destruction of the city by fire, although evidence for the event has only been found outside of the so-called "Temple of the Rock", and in the area around palace "E" on the acropolis. [75] The reason for the destruction is not known; [75] according to Astour, it could have been the result of a Hurrian invasion c. 2030 BC, [87] led by the former Eblaite vassal city of Ikinkalis. [note 12] [89] The destruction of Ebla is mentioned in the fragmentary Hurro-Hittite legendary epic "Song of Release" discovered in 1983, [90] which Astour considers as describing the destruction of the second kingdom. [91] In the epic, an Eblaite assembly led by a man called "Zazalla" prevents king Meki from showing mercy to prisoners from Ebla's former vassal Ikinkalis, [88] provoking the wrath of the Hurrian storm god Teshub and causing him to destroy the city. [92]

Third kingdom

Third Eblaite Kingdom
Ebla
c. 2000 BC–c. 1600 BC
CapitalEbla
Common languages Amorite language. [93]
Religion
Ancient Levantine religion
GovernmentMonarchy
Historical era Bronze Age
• Established
c. 2000 BC
• Disestablished
c. 1600 BC
Succeeded by
Hittites AlterOrient2.png
Statue fragment of Ibbit-Lim. Ibbit-Lim.png
Statue fragment of Ibbit-Lim.

The third kingdom is designated "Mardikh III"; it is divided into periods "A" (c. 2000–1800 BC) and "B" (c. 1800–1600 BC). [19] In period "A", Ebla was quickly rebuilt as a planned city. [94] The foundations covered the remains of Mardikh II; new palaces and temples were built, and new fortifications were built in two circles – one for the low city and one for the acropolis. [94] The city was laid out on regular lines and large public buildings were built. [95] [96] Further construction took place in period "B". [95]

The vizier palace HPIM3077.JPG
The vizier palace

The first known king of the third kingdom is Ibbit-Lim, [97] who described himself as the Mekim of Ebla. [note 13] [81] A basalt votive statue bearing Ibbit-Lim's inscription was discovered in 1968; this helped to identify the site of Tell-Mardikh with the ancient kingdom Ebla. [81] [97] The name of the king is Amorite in the view of Pettinato; it is therefore probable the inhabitants of third kingdom Ebla were predominantly Amorites, as were most of the inhabitants of Syria at that time. [99]

By the beginning of the 18th century BC, Ebla had become a vassal of Yamhad, an Amorite kingdom centered in Aleppo. [100] [101] Written records are not available for this period, but the city was still a vassal during Yarim-Lim III of Yamhad's reign. [95] One of the known rulers of Ebla during this period was Immeya, who received gifts from the Egyptian Pharaoh Hotepibre, indicating the continuing wide connections and importance of Ebla. [102] The city was mentioned in tablets from the Yamhadite vassal city of Alalakh in modern-day Turkey; an Eblaite princess married a son of King Ammitaqum of Alalakh, who belonged to a branch of the royal Yamhadite dynasty. [103] [104]

Ebla was destroyed by the Hittite King Mursili I in about 1600 BC. [105] Indilimma was probably the last king of Ebla; [106] a seal of his crown prince Maratewari was discovered in the western palace "Q". [106] [107] Alternatively, Maratewari could well be the last king according to Archi, [108] who also argued that the "Song of Release" epic describes the destruction of the third kingdom and preserves older elements. [88]

Later periods

Ebla never recovered from its third destruction. It was a small village in the phase designated "Mardikh IV" (1600–1200 BC), [105] and was mentioned in the records of Alalakh as a vassal to the Idrimi dynasty. [109] "Mardikh V" (1200–535 BC) was a rural, Early Iron Age settlement that grew in size during later periods. [105] Further development occurred during "Mardikh VI", which lasted until c. 60 AD. [105] "Mardikh VII" began in the 3rd century AD and lasted until the 7th century, [110] after which the site was abandoned. [111]

Site

City layout

Ebla's landmarks Ebla main sites.jpg
Ebla's landmarks

Ebla consisted of a lower town and a raised acropolis in the center. [112] During the first kingdom, the city had an area of 56 hectares and was protected by mud-brick fortifications. [113] Ebla was divided into four districts – each with its own gate in the outer wall. [114] The acropolis included the king's palace "G", [115] and one of two temples in city dedicated to Kura (called the "Red Temple"). [116] The lower city included the second temple of Kura in the southeast called "Temple of the Rock". [117] During the second kingdom, a royal palace (Archaic palace "P5") was built in the lower town northwest of the acropolis, [80] in addition to temple "D" built over the destroyed "Red Temple". [118]

During the third kingdom, Ebla was a large city nearly 60 hectares in size, [119] and was protected by a fortified rampart, with double chambered gates. [120] The acropolis was fortified and separated from the lower town. [121] New royal palace "E" was built on the acropolis (during Mardikh IIIB), [96] and a temple of Ishtar was constructed over the former "Red" and "D" temples (in area "D"). [122] [116] The lower town was also divided into four districts; [114] palace "P5" was used during Mardikh IIIA, [123] and replaced during Mardikh IIIB by the "Intermediate Palace". [120]

Other third kingdom buildings included the vizier palace, [note 14] [124] the western palace (in area "Q"), [107] the temple of Shamash (temple "N"), the temple of Rasap (temple "B1") and the northern palace (built over the "Intermediate Palace"). [120] [125] In the north of the lower town, a second temple for Ishtar was built, [126] while the former "Temple of the Rock" was replaced by a temple of Hadad. [note 15] [126]

Royal burials

The western palace "Q" situated above the royal necropolis Ebla.jpg
The western palace "Q" situated above the royal necropolis

The kings of the first kingdom were buried outside the city; the last ten kings (ending with Irkab-Damu) were buried in Darib, [127] while older kings were buried in a royal mausoleum located in Binas and only one royal tomb dating to the first kingdom was discovered in Ebla (Hypogeum "G4"). [128] This first kingdom tomb was probably built during the reign of the last king and might be an indication of Eblaite adoption of Mesopotamian traditions to bury the kings beneath their royal palaces. [128]

The third kingdom royal necropolis was discovered beneath palace "Q" (the western palace); it contains many hypogea but only three were excavated. [129] Those tombs were natural caves in the bedrock of the palace's foundation; they all date to the 19th and 18th centuries BC and had a similar plan consisting of an entrance shaft, burial chambers and a dromos connecting the shaft to the chamber. [75] [130] [131]

Hypogeum G4

The royal tomb found in the royal palace "G" is designated hypogeum "G4"; it dates to the archive period, most probably the reign of Isar-Damu. [132] The tomb is heavily damaged; most of its stones were sacked and nothing of the roof system remains. [133] It also lacks any skeletal remains or funerary goods suggesting that it was either heavily pillaged, never used, or was built as a cenotaph. [133]

Excavated between 1992 and 1995, it is located underneath the western sector of the palace at a depth of almost 6 meters. [133] The tomb is composed of two rooms opened on each other's with lime plaster floors. [133] Both rooms are rectangular in shape; the eastern room (L.6402) is 4 meters wide, more than 3,5 meters long (total length is unknown due to heavy damage) and west–east oriented. [134] The western room (L.5762) is 5.20 meters long, 4 meters wide and west–east oriented. [135] Limestone was used to build the walls and few blocks protruding from the sides toward the middle of the rooms suggest the roof to have been a corbelled vault. [133] [134]

Western palace tombs

Plan of the western palace tombs Eblaite tombs.png
Plan of the western palace tombs

The tombs were found under the floor of Building Q, which was built in the Isin-Larsa period. [136]

  • The tomb of the princess: dating to c. 1800 BC, it is the oldest and smallest of the third kingdom tombs found. [131] [137] Excavated in 1978, [137] it contained the remains of a young woman, hence the naming. [138] The dromos has steps, partially cut in the bedrock and partially paved with stones, leading to the chamber, which was achieved through the enlargement of a natural cave. [139] The tomb is the only one not pillaged; [140] it contained precious jewels and funerary objects. [141]
  • The tomb of the cisterns: this tomb is the most damaged in the necropolis. [131] It consists of a double room burial; the earliest, (Q79A), was built at the same period of the tomb of the princess, and was badly damaged when the tomb was reused, and a dromos was built in the place of Q79A toward the end of the 17th century BC (leading to the founding of burial Q79B). [139] This was probably the resting place of a king; a club (a symbol of royal power) was discovered in Q79A. [139]
  • The tomb of the lord of the goats: it is the largest in the necropolis; it includes two depositional chambers and is reached through a vertical shaft. [139] The occupier of the tomb is not known with certainty, he is called the lord of the goats by archaeologists due to the existence of a throne decorated with bronze goat heads in the tomb. [142] A silver cup that has the name of king Immeya inscribed was found in the tomb making that king the most likely owner of the burial. [143]

Government

The first kingdom's government consisted of the king (styled Malikum) and the grand vizier, who headed a council of elders (Abbu) and the administration. [144] The second kingdom was also a monarchy, [86] but little is known about it because of a lack of written records. [76] The third kingdom was a city-state monarchy with reduced importance under the authority of Yamhad. [145]

Administration of the first kingdom

The queen shared the running of affairs of state with the king. [115] The crown prince was involved in internal matters and the second prince was involved in foreign affairs. [115] Most duties, including military ones, were handled by the vizier and the administration, which consisted of 13 court dignitaries – each of whom controlled between 400 and 800 men forming a bureaucracy with 11,700 people. [144] Each of the four quarters of the lower city was governed by a chief inspector and many deputies. [115] To oversee royal interest, the king employed agents (mashkim), collectors (ur) and messengers (kas). [32]

Administrative divisions

Many client kingdoms owed allegiance to Ebla and each was ruled by its own king (En); those vassal kings were highly autonomous, paying tribute and supplying military assistance to Ebla. [32] The administrative center in the capital was named the "SA.ZA"; it included the royal palaces, storerooms and some temples. [146] Regions beyond the walls of the capital were collectively named in Eblaite texts "uru-bar" (literally meaning outside of the city). [146] The villages and towns under the central authority were either ruled directly from the capital, [146] or had appointed officials. [146] The titles of the civil servants do not clearly define the bearer's responsibilities and authority as each town had its own political traditions. [147]

  • Lugal: while in Mesopotamia a lugal designated a king, in Ebla it designated a governor who was directly under the authority of the capital. [148] The nature of this title as part of Eblaite bureaucracy is ambiguous; each lugal was under the authority of the grand vizier, [149] and the bearers ruled cities directly under the authority of the capital and they all brought goods to be kept in Ebla's storehouses. [146] Pettinato counted 14 different lugals in the Eblaite administrative texts and deduced that the kingdom was divided into fourteen departments; two of them in the capital itself and the remaining twelve spanned the rest of the kingdom. [150]
  • Ugula: the title is translated as superintendent; some ugulas were independent rulers and some represented the highest authority of a tribal group. [151] Many cities had an appointed ugula as their head of administration such as the city of Darum. [146]

The chora

The regions under the direct control of the king that were economically vital for the capital are called the "chora" by archaeologists. [7] [152] Regions under direct control of the king extended beyond the chora and it is difficult to determine the exact size of the kingdom and the chora due to the constant military expansion of Ebla which added new territories; some of those were ruled directly while others were allowed to retain their own rulers as vassals. [152]

Generally, the chora is the core region of Ebla that includes the economic hinterland supporting the capital. [7] It includes the cities and villages where the king or his vizier had palaces, towns that included important sanctuaries of gods related to the royal institution, towns visited by the monarch during the different rituals he participated in (such as the renewal of royalty ritual), [note 16] and other cities such as the ones where textiles were delivered. [154] The chora spans around 3000 km2; from west to east it includes the plains east of Jabal Zawiya, the Maṭkh swamp, al-Hass mountain and mount Shabīth. [155] Areas directly on the borders of the chora such as al-Ghab, al-Rouge plain and al-Jabbul have close cultural affinity with the chora. [155]

People, language, and culture

The first and second kingdoms

Royal palace "G" courtyard Ebla6.JPG
Royal palace "G" courtyard

Mardikh II's periods shared the same culture. [123] the population of Ebla during Mardikh IIB1 is estimated to have numbered around 40,000 in the capital, and over 200,000 people in the entire kingdom. [156] The Eblaites of Mardikh II were Semite-speakers close to their Northwestern Semitic neighbors, such as the Amorites. [157] Giovanni Pettinato said the Eblaite language, one of the oldest attested Semitic languages, [158] was a West Semitic language; Gelb and others said it was an East Semitic dialect closer to the Akkadian language. [159] Academic consensus considers Eblaite an East Semitic language, which exhibits both West and East Semitic features. [note 17] [160] [161]

Ebla held several religious and social festivals, including rituals for the succession of a new king, which normally lasted for several weeks. [162] The Eblaite calendars were based on a solar year divided into twelve months. [163] Two calendars were discovered; the "old calendar" used during the reign of Igrish-Halam, and a "new calendar" introduced by vizier Ibbi-Sipish. [163] Many months were named in honor of deities; in the new calendar, "Itu be-li" was the first month of the year, and meant "the month of the lord". [164] Each year was given a name instead of a number. [165]

Women received salaries equal to those of men and could accede to important positions and head government agencies. [166] The Eblaites imported Kungas from Nagar, [note 18] [168] and used them to draw the carriages of royalty and high officials, as well as diplomatic gifts for allied cities. [168] Society was less centered around the palace and the temple than in Mesopotamian kingdoms. The Eblaite palace was designed around the courtyard, which was open toward the city, thus making the administration approachable. This contrasts with Mesopotamian palaces, which resembled citadels with narrow entrances and limited access to the external courtyard. [169] Music played an important part in the society and musicians were both locals, [170] or hired from other cities such as Mari. [171] Ebla also hired acrobats from Nagar, but later reduced their number and kept some to train local Eblaite acrobats. [172]

The third kingdom

The Mardikh III population was predominately Semitic Amorite. [99] The Amorites were mentioned in the first kingdom's tablets as neighbors and as rural subjects, [173] and they came to dominate Ebla after the destruction of the second kingdom. [174] The city witnessed a great increase in construction, and many palaces, temples and fortifications were built. [175] The Amorite Eblaites worshiped many of the same deities as the Eblaites of earlier periods, [176] and maintained the sanctity of the acropolis in the center of the city. [75] The third kingdom's iconography and royal ideology were under the influence of Yamhad's culture; kingship was received from the Yamhadite deities instead of Ishtar of Ebla, which is evident by the Eblaite seals of Indilimma's period. [177]

Economy

During the first kingdom period, the palace controlled the economy, [149] but wealthy families managed their financial affairs without government intervention. [178] The economic system was redistributive; the palace distributed food to its permanent and seasonal workers. It is estimated that around 40,000 persons contributed to this system, but in general, and unlike in Mesopotamia, land stayed in the hands of villages, which paid an annual share to the palace. [179] Agriculture was mainly pastoral; large herds of cattle were managed by the palace. [179] The city's inhabitants owned around 140,000 head of sheep and goats, and 9,000 cattle. [179]

Ebla derived its prosperity from trade; [179] its wealth was equal to that of the most important Sumerian cities, [180] and its main commercial rival was Mari. [60] Ebla's main articles of trade were probably timber from the nearby mountains, and textiles. [181] Handicrafts also appear to have been a major export, evidenced by the quantity of artifacts recovered from the palaces of the city. [182] Ebla possessed a wide commercial network reaching as far as modern-day Afghanistan. [183] It shipped textiles to Cyprus, possibly through the port of Ugarit, [184] but most of its trade seems to have been directed by river-boat towards Mesopotamia – chiefly Kish. [185] The main palace G was found to contain artifacts dating from Ancient Egypt bearing the names of the pharaohs Khafre and Pepi I. [186]

Ebla continued to be a center of trade during the second kingdom, evidenced by the surrounding cities that appeared during its period and were destroyed along with the city. [note 19] [70] Trade continued to be Ebla's main economic activity during the third kingdom; archaeological finds show there was an extensive exchange with Egypt and coastal Syrian cities such as Byblos. [119]

Religion

Ebla was a polytheistic state. [187] During the first kingdom, Eblaites worshiped their dead kings. [188] The pantheon of the first Ebla included pairs of deities and they can be separated into three genres; in the first and most common one, there were the couples, such as the deity and his female consort. [188] The second type of pairs was the divine twosomes, such as the deities that cooperate to create the cosmos, like in the Egyptian and Mesopotamian pantheons. [188] The third type included divine pairs who were actually a single deity that had two names. [188] Eblaites worshiped few Mesopotamian deities, preferring North-Western Semitic gods, some of which were unique to Ebla. [157] The first genre of pairs included Hadabal (dNI-da-KUL [189] ), who was exclusive to Ebla, and his consort, Belatu ("his wife"); [190] Rasap and his consort Adamma; [190] the patron gods of the city Kura, who was unique to Ebla, and his consort Barama. [191] [192] The third genre included the artisan god Kamish/Tit, Kothar-wa-Khasis and the planet Venus represented by twin mountain gods; Shahar as the morning star and Shalim as the evening star. [188]

The first Eblaites worshiped many other deities, such as the Syrian goddess Ishara, [note 20] who was the goddess of the royal family. [196] Ishtar was also worshiped but was mentioned only five times in one of the monthly offering lists, while Ishara was far more important, appearing 40 times. [197] Other deities included Damu; [note 21] [198] the Mesopotamian god Utu; [9] Ashtapi; [199] Dagan; [200] Hadad (Hadda) and his consort Halabatu ("she of Halab"); [201] [202] and Shipish, the goddess of the sun who had a temple dedicated to her cult. [203] The four city gates were named after the gods Dagan, Hadda, Rasap and Utu, but it is unknown which gate had which name. [204] Overall, the offering list mentioned about 40 deities receiving sacrifices. [9]

During the third kingdom, Amorites worshiped common northern Semitic gods; the unique Eblaite deities disappeared. [205] Hadad was the most important god, while Ishtar took Ishara's place and became the city's most important deity apart from Hadad. [176]

Biblical connection theories

At the beginning of the process of deciphering the tablets, Giovanni Pettinato made claims about a possible connections between Ebla and the Bible, [206] citing alleged references in the tablets to the existence of Yahweh, the Patriarchs, Sodom and Gomorrah and other Biblical references. [206] However, much of the initial media excitement about a supposed Eblaite connections with the Bible, based on preliminary guesses and speculations by Pettinato and others, is now widely discredited and the academic consensus is that Ebla "has no bearing on the Minor Prophets, the historical accuracy of the Biblical Patriarchs, Yahweh worship, or Sodom and Gomorrah". [206] In Ebla studies, the focus has shifted away from comparisons with the Bible; Ebla is now studied as a civilization in its own right. [206] The claims led to a bitter personal and academic conflict between the scholars involved, as well as what some described as political interference by the Syrian authorities. [207]

Genetics

According to ancient DNA analyses conducted by Skourtanioti et al. (2020) on 10 human remains from Tel Mardikh from Early and Middle Bronze Age, the inhabitants of the kingdom of Ebla were a mixture of Copper age Levantines and Mesopotamians, and were genetically similar to contemporary Levantines from Alalakh and Sidon. One Early Bronze Age (2700-2500 BC) individual carried haplogroup E1b1b1b2a-M123, a lineage likely linked to the diffusion of Afroasiatic languages. [208] Another Early Bronze Age (2572-2470 cal BCE) individual belonged to J1a2a1a2-P58, while four Middle Bronze Age (2000-1800 BC) individuals carried haplogroups G2a, J1a2a1a2-P58, and the West Asian T1a1-L162 which was present since the middle PPNB Levant. [209]

Discovery

Ebla Porta sud-Ovest - GAR - 9-01.JPG
Parts of the excavations (Damascus gate)
Calco di tavoletta in terracotta da Ebla - Museo d'Arte Orientale Roma.jpg
A tablet from the archive

In 1964, Italian archaeologists from the University of Rome La Sapienza under the direction of Paolo Matthiae began excavating at Tell Mardikh. [210] In 1968, they recovered a statue dedicated to the goddess Ishtar bearing the name of Ibbit-Lim, mentioning him as king of Ebla. [211] That identified the city, long known from Lagashite and Akkadian inscriptions. [212] In the next decade, the team discovered a palace (palace G) dating from c. 2500–2000 BC. [180] Finds in the palaces include a small sculpture made out of precious materials, black stones and gold. [180] Thirteen full and fragmentary lenticular cuneiform tablets were found in the palace throne room, thought to have been there versus the archive because of the city's fall. [213] In a storeroom off the throne room the nearly complete standard of the queen and fragments believed to come from the standard of the king were found. [214] Other artifacts included wood furniture inlaid with mother-of-pearl and composite statues created from colored stones. [182] A silver bowl bearing king Immeya's name was recovered from the "Tomb of the Lord of the Goats", together with Egyptian jewels and an Egyptian ceremonial mace presented by pharaoh Hotepibre. [102]

About 17,000  cuneiform tablet fragments were discovered; when put together, they constitute 2,500 complete tablets, making the archive of Ebla one of the biggest from the 3rd millennium BC. [215] About 80% of the tablets are written using the usual Sumerian combination of logograms and phonetic signs, [216] while the others exhibited an innovative, purely phonetic representation using Sumerian cuneiform of a previously unknown Semitic language, which was called "Eblaite". [217] Bilingual Sumerian/Eblaite vocabulary lists were found among the tablets, allowing them to be translated. [204] The tablets provide many important insights into the cultural, economic and political life in northern Mesopotamia around the middle of the 3rd millennium BC. [218] They also provide insight into the everyday lives of the inhabitants, [219] and contain information about state revenues, Sumerian-Eblaite dictionaries, [204] diplomatic exchanges with foreign rulers, [220] school texts, hymns and myths. [221]

Library

The over 4000-year-old tablets constitute one of the oldest libraries ever found. At Ebla, “the archives or library constituted an orderly collection of records at least 500 years older than any other that had been found anywhere before.” [222] There is evidence of their arrangement and classification. [223] The larger tablets had originally been stored on shelves, but had fallen onto the floor when the palace was destroyed. [224] The locations of the fallen tablets allowed the excavators to reconstruct their original positions on the shelves. [225] They found the tablets had originally been shelved according to subject. [219]

These features were absent from earlier Sumerian excavations. Sophisticated techniques of arrangement of texts, coupled with their composition, evidence the great antiquity of archival and library practices, which may be far older than was assumed to be the case before the discovery of the Ebla library. [223] A sizable portion of the tablets contain literary and lexicographic texts; evidence seems to suggest the collection also served – at least partially – as a true library rather than a collection of archives intended solely for use by the kings, their ministers, and their bureaucracy. [223] The tablets show evidence of the early transcription of texts into foreign languages and scripts, classification and cataloging for easier retrieval, and arrangement by size, form and content. [223] The Ebla tablets have thus provided scholars with new insights into the origin of library practices that were in use 4,500 years ago. [223]

While the absolute chronology of the archive is not yet certain a relative chronology for the 50-year period has been established. Because Ebla did not use Mesopotamian style year names or year numbers and the name of rulers was rarely mentioned in the texts scholars used script changes, grammar changes, and most importantly a prosopography of the members of the court, especially the wives and daughters of the king. The most relevant tablets for this effort were a series of yearly metal accounts and monthly linen accounts. [226] [227]

Most of the recovered tablets and tablet fragments were stored at the Idlib Regional Museum in Syria. Their current condition is unknown.

Legacy

Ebla's first kingdom is an example of early Syrian centralized states, [228] and is considered one of the earliest empires by scholars, [36] [229] such as Samuel Finer, [144] and Karl Moore, who considers it the first-recorded world power. [230] Ebla's discovery changed the former view of Syria's history as a bridge between Mesopotamia and Egypt; it proved the region was a center of civilization in its own right. [231]

Syrian Civil War

As a result of the Syrian Civil War, excavations of Ebla stopped in March 2011. [232] By 2013, it was under control of an opposition armed group called Arrows of the Right, who took advantage of its elevated location to use it as an observation point to watch for incoming government air attacks, as well as attempting to protect the site from looting. [233] [234] Many tunnels were dug and a crypt full of human remains was discovered; the remains were scattered and discarded by the robbers, who hoped to find jewelry and other precious artifacts. [233] Besides excavations by rebels, nearby villagers also began digging at the site with the aim of finding and looting artifacts; some villagers removed carloads of soil suitable for making ceramic liners for bread-baking ovens from the tunnels. [233] [235]

The site was captured by the Syrian Armed Forces on 30 January 2020 during the 5th Northwestern Syria offensive, along with surrounding villages. [236] [237] [238]

See also

Notes

    1. ↑ All dates in this article are estimated by the Middle Chronology, unless stated otherwise.
    2. ↑ The political weakness started during the short reign of Adub-Damu. [18]
    3. ↑ Probably located along the Euphrates river east of Ebla. [30]
    4. ↑ At first Pettinato supported the Naram-Sin theory before proposing the High dating. [54]
    5. ↑ Michael Astour argues that using the chronology accepted by Pettinato, one obtains the date of 2500 BC for the reign of Ur-Nanshe of Lagash, who ruled approximately 150 years prior to Lagash's destruction at the hands of king Lugalzagesi. Since Ur-Nanshe ruled in 2500 BC, and his reign is separated by at least 150 years from Hidar of Mari's reign which saw Ebla's destruction, then the date for that event is pulled beyond 2500 BC and even 2400 BC. [54]
    6. ↑ Astour argue that according to the middle chronology used for the 2400 BC date, Eannatum's reign ended in 2425 BC and Ebla was not destroyed until 2400 BC; according to the same chronology Lugalzagesi's reign would have started fifty years after 2400 BC. [56]
    7. ↑ At first Matthiae supported the Naram-Sin theory then switched to Sargon. [58]
    8. ↑ Astour believes that Sargon and his grandson were referring to a city with a similar name in Iraq named "Ib-la". [61] [62] Astour says the archives of Ebla at the time of their destruction correspond to the political situation predating the establishment of the Akkadian empire, not just the reign of Naram-Sin. [58] It is also unlikely Sargon was responsible because at the time of their destruction, the Ebla tablets describe Kish as independent. Lugalzagesi sacked Kish and was killed by Sargon before Sargon destroyed Ibla or Ebla. [63]
    9. ↑ Amar-Sin's reign lasted from 2045–2037 BC (middle chronology). [78]
    10. ↑ "Megum" is thought to have been a title of the ruler of Ebla rather than a personal name. [79] King Ibbit-Lim of the latter third kingdom of Ebla also used this title. [80] An Eblaite seal that reads the sentence Ib-Damu Mekim Ebla, was used in the 19th century BC by an Assyrian merchant named Assur-Nada from Kültepe. [81] Ib Damu was the name of an Eblaite king from the early period of the first kingdom. [81]
    11. ↑ In a tablet, the name of Ili-Dagan "the man of Ebla" is mentioned, and he was thought to be a ruler. [82] However, other texts mentions him as the envoy of Ebla's ruler. [83]
    12. ↑ Unidentified location to the north of Ebla in the proximity of Alalakh. [88]
    13. ↑ This led Astour, David I. Owen and Ron Veenker to identify Ibbit-Lim with the pre-Amorite Megum of the Third Ur era. [98] However, this identification is now refuted. [80]
    14. ↑ Called the southern palace (in area "FF"), it was located at the foot of the southern side of the acropolis. [124]
    15. ↑ Area HH. [124]
    16. ↑ The ritual had the king and the queen visiting Ninas, and making offerings to royal ancestors. [153]
    17. ↑ Grammatically, Eblaite is closer to Akkadian, but lexically and in some grammatical forms, Eblaite is closer to West Semitic languages. [96]
    18. ↑ The Kunga is a hybrid of a donkey and a female onager, which Nagar was famous for breeding. [167]
    19. ↑ Archaeologist Alessandro de Maigret deduced that Ebla retained its trading position. [70]
    20. ↑ At the beginning of Ebla's studies, it was believed that the existence of Ishara and another god Ashtapi in Ebla's pantheon, is a proof for a Hurrian existence in the Eblaite first kingdom. [193] However it is now known that those deities were pre-Hurrian and perhaps pre-Semitic deities, later incorporated into the Hurrian pantheon. [176] [194] [195]
    21. ↑ Probably an old Semitic deity and not identical to the Sumerian Damu. [198]

    Related Research Articles

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Yamhad</span> Semitic kingdom in Syria

    Yamhad was an ancient Semitic-speaking kingdom centered on Ḥalab (Aleppo) in Syria. The kingdom emerged at the end of the 19th century BC and was ruled by the Yamhad dynasty, who counted on both military and diplomacy to expand their realm. From the beginning of its establishment, the kingdom withstood the aggressions of its neighbors Mari, Qatna and the Old Assyrian Empire, and was turned into the most powerful Syrian kingdom of its era through the actions of its king Yarim-Lim I. By the middle of the 18th century BC, most of Syria minus the south came under the authority of Yamhad, either as a direct possession or through vassalage, and for nearly a century and a half, Yamhad dominated northern, northwestern and eastern Syria, and had influence over small kingdoms in Mesopotamia at the borders of Elam. The kingdom was eventually destroyed by the Hittites, then annexed by Mitanni in the 16th century BC.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Ibbit-Lim</span> King of Ebla

    Ibbit-Lim was the earliest known ruler of the Third kingdom of Ebla, in modern Syria, reigning most likely shortly before 1950 BCE.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Mari, Syria</span> Ancient Sumerian and Amorite city

    Mari was an ancient Semitic city-state in modern-day Syria. Its remains form a tell 11 kilometers north-west of Abu Kamal on the Euphrates River western bank, some 120 kilometers southeast of Deir ez-Zor. It flourished as a trade center and hegemonic state between 2900 BC and 1759 BC. The city was built in the middle of the Euphrates trade routes between Sumer in the south and the Eblaite kingdom and the Levant in the west.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Eblaite language</span> Extinct Semitic language used in the third millennium BC

    Eblaite, or Palaeo-Syrian, is an extinct East Semitic language used during the 3rd millennium BC by the populations of Northern Syria. It was named after the ancient city of Ebla, in modern western Syria. Variants of the language were also spoken in Mari and Nagar. According to Cyrus H. Gordon, although scribes might have spoken it sometimes, Eblaite was probably not spoken much, being rather a written lingua franca with East and West Semitic features.

    Irkab-Damu, was the king (Malikum) of the first Eblaite kingdom, whose era saw Ebla's turning into the dominant power in the Levant.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Tell Brak</span> Archaeological site in Syria

    Tell Brak was an ancient city in Syria; its remains constitute a tell located in the Upper Khabur region, near the modern village of Tell Brak, 50 kilometers north-east of Al-Hasaka city, Al-Hasakah Governorate. The city's original name is unknown. During the second half of the third millennium BC, the city was known as Nagar and later on, Nawar.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Nuhašše</span>

    Nuhašše, also Nuhašša, was a region in northwestern Syria that flourished in the 2nd millennium BC. It was a federacy ruled by different kings who collaborated and probably had a high king. Nuhašše changed hands between different powers in the region such as Egypt, Mitanni and the Hittites. It rebelled against the latter which led Šuppiluliuma I to attack and annex the region.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Ebla tablets</span> Collection of clay tablets from the ancient city of Ebla in Syria

    The Ebla tablets are a collection of as many as 1,800 complete clay tablets, 4,700 fragments, and many thousands of minor chips found in the palace archives of the ancient city of Ebla, Syria. The tablets were discovered by Italian archaeologist Paolo Matthiae and his team in 1974–75 during their excavations at the ancient city at Tell Mardikh. The tablets, which were found in situ on collapsed shelves, retained many of their contemporary clay tags to help reference them. They all date to the period between c. 2500 BC and the destruction of the city c. 2250 BC. Today, the tablets are held in museums in the Syrian cities of Aleppo, Damascus, and Idlib.

    Armi, was an important Bronze Age city-kingdom during the late third millennium BC located in northern Syria, or in southern Anatolia, Turkey, at the region of Cilicia.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Armani (kingdom)</span> Ancient kingdom mentioned by Sargon of Akkad

    Armani was an ancient kingdom mentioned by Sargon of Akkad.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Amorites</span> Ancient Semitic-speaking people from the Levant

    The Amorites were an ancient Northwest Semitic-speaking people from the Levant who also occupied large parts of southern Mesopotamia from the 21st century BC to the end of the 17th century BC, where they established several prominent city-states in existing locations, such as Isin, Larsa and later notably Babylon, creating the Old Babylonian Empire. The term Amurru in Akkadian and Sumerian texts refers to the Amorites, their principal deity and an Amorite kingdom. The term Amorite was never used in contemporary sources before the 1st Millennium BC. The Amorites are mentioned in the Bible as inhabitants of Canaan both before and after the conquest of the land under Joshua.

    The Ebla–biblical controversy refers to the disagreements between scholars regarding a possible connection between the Syrian city of Ebla and the Bible. At the beginning of the Ebla's tablets deciphering process in the 1970s, Giovanni Pettinato made claims about a connection. However, much of the initial media excitement about a supposed Eblaite connection with the Bible, based on preliminary guesses and speculations by Pettinato and others, is now widely described as "exceptional and unsubstantiated claims" and "great amounts of disinformation that leaked to the public". In Ebla studies, the focus has shifted away from comparisons with the Bible, and Ebla is now studied above all as a civilization in its own right. The tide turned after a bitter personal and scholarly conflict between the scientists involved, and an alleged interference by the Syrian authorities on political grounds.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Indilimma</span> King of Ebla

    Indilimma, previously read Indilimgur, was likely the last king of Ebla, in modern Syria, reigning around 1600 BCE.

    Iblul-Il, was the most energetic king (Lugal) of the second Mariote kingdom, noted for his extensive campaigns in the middle Euphrates valley against the Eblaites, and in the upper Tigris region against various opponents, which asserted the Mariote supremacy in the Syrian north.

    Ansud, was an early king (Lugal) of the second Mariote kingdom who reigned c. 2423-2416 BC. Ansud is known for warring against the Eblaites from a letter written by the later Mariote king Enna-Dagan.

    Isar-Damu, was the king (Malikum) of the first Eblaite kingdom. Isar-Damu fought a long war with Mari which ended in Eblaite victory; he was probably the last king of the first kingdom.

    Ib'al was the name used by Ebla in the 24th century BC to indicate a confederation of tribes occupying the steppic region south of Ebla; the region included small villages and towns. Qatna could have been one of the urban centers in the region.

    Hadabal was a god worshiped in Ebla and its surroundings in the third millennium BCE. He was one of the main gods of that area, and appears frequently in Eblaite documents. His character is not well understood, though it has been proposed that he might have been an agricultural or lunar god. Like the city's tutelary god Kura and his wife Barama, he is absent from sources postdating the destruction of Ebla.

    Barama was a goddess worshiped in the Syrian city of Ebla in the third millennium BCE as the wife of its tutelary god, Kura. She is not attested from any sources postdating the destruction of the city.

    References

    1. ↑ "Ebla". Sumerian Dictionary. University of Pennsylvania – via oracc.iaas.upenn.edu.
    2. ↑ Dolce 2010, p.  248.
    3. ↑ Mantellini, Micale & Peyronel 2013, p.  182.
    4. 1 2 3 4 Hamblin 2006, p.  241.
    5. ↑ Shaw 1999, p.  211.
    6. ↑ Leick 2009, p.  54.
    7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Matthiae 2013a, p.  37.
    8. ↑ Van De Mieroop 2002, p.  133.
    9. 1 2 3 Wright 2004, p.  173.
    10. ↑ Ökse 2011, p.  268.
    11. ↑ Dolce 2010, p.  250.
    12. ↑ Dolce 2010, p.  247.
    13. ↑ Dolce 2010, p.  246.
    14. ↑ Dolce 2008, p.  66.
    15. ↑ Nadali 2007, p.  349.
    16. 1 2 Astour 2002, p.  79.
    17. ↑ Liverani 2013, p.  119.
    18. 1 2 Dolce 2008, p.  68.
    19. 1 2 3 Matthiae 2013a, p.  38.
    20. ↑ Astour 1992, p.  19.
    21. 1 2 3 4 Astour 2002, p.  74.
    22. ↑ Pettinato 1981, p.  105.
    23. ↑ Bryce 2014, p.  15.
    24. ↑ Tonietti 2010, p.  69.
    25. 1 2 Nadali 2007, p.  350.
    26. ↑ Roux 1992, p.  200.
    27. ↑ Feliu 2003, p.  40.
    28. ↑ Podany 2010, p.  24.
    29. 1 2 Cooper 2006, p.  64.
    30. 1 2 3 Archi 2011, p.  5.
    31. ↑ Neff 2014, p.  14.
    32. 1 2 3 4 Hamblin 2006, p.  242.
    33. 1 2 3 Astour 2002, p.  101.
    34. ↑ Tubb 1998, p.  39.
    35. ↑ Aubet 2001, p.  18.
    36. 1 2 Astour 1981, p.  4.
    37. 1 2 Cooper 2010, p.  89.
    38. ↑ Pettinato 1991, p.  135.
    39. 1 2 3 Otto & Biga 2010, p.  486.
    40. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  66.
    41. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  83.
    42. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  59.
    43. 1 2 3 4 5 Liverani 2013, p.  123.
    44. ↑ Archi, Alfonso. "The Wars of Ebla at the Time of Minister Ibrium" Altorientalische Forschungen, vol. 48, no. 2, 2021, pp. 189-220
    45. ↑ Otto & Biga 2010, p.  484.
    46. ↑ Otto & Biga 2010, p.  485.
    47. ↑ Liverani 2013, p.  121.
    48. ↑ POMPONIO, Francesco. “FURTHER CONSIDERATIONS ON KIŠKI IN THE EBLA TEXTS.” Revue d’Assyriologie et d’archéologie Orientale, vol. 107, pp. 71–83, 2013
    49. ↑ Podany 2010, p.  57.
    50. 1 2 3 4 Biga 2014, p.  103.
    51. ↑ Stieglitz 2002, p.  219.
    52. ↑ Ristvet 2014, p.  54.
    53. ↑ McKeon, John F.X. (1970). "An Akkadian Victory Stele". Boston Museum Bulletin. 68 (354): 239. ISSN   0006-7997. JSTOR   4171539.
    54. 1 2 Astour 2002, p.  63.
    55. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  61.
    56. 1 2 3 Astour 2002, p.  62.
    57. ↑ Gurney 2003, p.  119.
    58. 1 2 Astour 2002, p.  64.
    59. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  68.
    60. 1 2 3 Bryce 2014, p.  16.
    61. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  65.
    62. ↑ Horowitz 1998, p.  82.
    63. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  72.
    64. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  70.
    65. 1 2 Frayne, Douglas. Sargonic and Gutian Periods. pp. 132–133.
    66. ↑ Archi, Alfonso, and Maria Giovanna Biga. “A Victory over Mari and the Fall of Ebla.” Journal of Cuneiform Studies, vol. 55, pp. 1–44, 2003
    67. ↑ Podany 2010, p.  59.
    68. ↑ Bretschneider, Van Vyve & Leuven 2009, p.  7.
    69. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  75.
    70. 1 2 3 Astour 2002, p.  78.
    71. ↑ Bryce 2014, p.  324.
    72. ↑ Archi 2015, p.  26.
    73. ↑ Archi 2015, p.  471.
    74. ↑ Dolce 2010, p.  245.
    75. 1 2 3 4 5 Dolce 2010, p.  252.
    76. 1 2 3 Astour 2002, p.  76.
    77. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  81.
    78. ↑ Crawford 2015, p.  83.
    79. ↑ Pinnock 2000, p.  1405.
    80. 1 2 3 Archi 2002, p.  26.
    81. 1 2 3 4 Archi 2002, p.  25.
    82. ↑ Goetze 1953, p.  103.
    83. ↑ Michalowski 1995, p.  185.
    84. ↑ Klengel 1992, p.  36.
    85. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  87.
    86. 1 2 Astour 2002, p.  132.
    87. ↑ Hamblin 2006, p.  250.
    88. 1 2 3 Archi 2002, p.  24.
    89. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  124.
    90. ↑ Bachvarova 2009, p.  66.
    91. ↑ Astour 2002, p.  153.
    92. ↑ Bachvarova 2009, p.  67.
    93. ↑ Weiss 1985, p.  213.
    94. 1 2 Harmanşah 2007, p.  75.
    95. 1 2 3 Bryce 2014, p.  25.
    96. 1 2 3 Hooks 1990, p.  226.
    97. 1 2 Matthiae 2013b, p.  103.
    98. ↑ Klengel 1992, p.  41.
    99. 1 2 Pettinato 1991, p.  22.
    100. ↑ Thuesen 2000, p.  61.
    101. ↑ Feldman 2007, p.  55.
    102. 1 2 Matthiae 2008, p.  35.
    103. ↑ Frayne 1990, p.  807.
    104. ↑ Teissier 1984, p.  72.
    105. 1 2 3 4 Bryce 2009, p.  211.
    106. 1 2 Matthiae 2013b, p.  106.
    107. 1 2 Matthiae 2006, p.  86.
    108. ↑ Archi 2015b, p. 24.
    109. ↑ Astour 1969, p.  388.
    110. ↑ Pettinato 1991, p.  16.
    111. ↑ Hooks 1990, p.  225.
    112. ↑ Cooper 2010, p.  86.
    113. ↑ Pinnock 2007, p.  110.
    114. 1 2 Pinnock 2007, p.  112.
    115. 1 2 3 4 Gilchrist 1995, p.  537.
    116. 1 2 Pinnock 2013, p.  543.
    117. ↑ Dolce 2010, p.  251.
    118. ↑ Matthiae 2013a, p.  40.
    119. 1 2 Matthiae 2008, p.  34.
    120. 1 2 3 Bonacossi 2013, p.  421.
    121. ↑ Baffi & Peyronel 2013, p.  200.
    122. ↑ Akkermans & Schwartz 2003, p.  295.
    123. 1 2 Astour 2002, p.  164.
    124. 1 2 3 Bonacossi 2013, p.  422.
    125. ↑ Peyronel 2008, p.  177.
    126. 1 2 Nigro 2007, p.  130.
    127. ↑ Michalowski 2003, p.  465.
    128. 1 2 Matthiae 2013, p.  50.
    129. ↑ Matthiae 2008, p.  37.
    130. ↑ Mogliazza & Polcaro 2010, p.  431.
    131. 1 2 3 Suriano 2010, p.  60.
    132. ↑ Matthiae 2013, p.  53.
    133. 1 2 3 4 5 Laneri 2016, p.  56.
    134. 1 2 Matthiae 1997, p.  270.
    135. ↑ Matthiae 1997, p.  269.
    136. ↑ MATTHIAE, PAOLO.,"Two Princely Tombs at Tell Mardikh-Ebla.", Archaeology, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 8–17, 1980
    137. 1 2 Matthiae 1989, p.  303.
    138. ↑ Matthiae 1984, p. 24.
    139. 1 2 3 4 Nigro 2009, p.  161.
    140. ↑ Pettinato 1991, p.  28.
    141. ↑ Grajetzki 2013, p.  173.
    142. ↑ Fortin 1999, p.  173.
    143. ↑ Matthiae 2010, p.  217.
    144. 1 2 3 Finer 1997, p.  172.
    145. ↑ Hamblin 2006, p.  267.
    146. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Biga 2013, p.  265.
    147. ↑ Cooper 2006, p.  91.
    148. ↑ Pongratz-Leisten 2015, p.  199.
    149. 1 2 Liverani 2013, p.  122.
    150. ↑ Stieglitz 2002, p.  215.
    151. ↑ Biga 2013, p.  260.
    152. 1 2 Biga 2013, p.  266.
    153. ↑ Biga 2007, p.  256.
    154. ↑ Biga 2014, p.  94.
    155. 1 2 D'Andrea & Ascalone 2013, p.  215.
    156. ↑ Kohl 1991, p.  230.
    157. 1 2 Rendsburg 1997, p.  183.
    158. ↑ Bernal 2006, p.  591.
    159. ↑ Faber 2013, p.  7.
    160. ↑ Stiebing 2016, p.  63.
    161. ↑ Gordon 2013, p.  101.
    162. ↑ Dolansky 2013, p.  66.
    163. 1 2 Pettinato 1981, p.  147.
    164. ↑ Shea 1981, p.  60.
    165. ↑ Podany 2010, p.  34.
    166. ↑ Pettinato 1991, p.  75.
    167. ↑ Kuz'mina 2007, p.  134.
    168. 1 2 Peyronel & Vacca 2013, p.  436.
    169. ↑ Liverani 2013, p.  127.
    170. ↑ Tonietti 2010, p.  73.
    171. ↑ Tonietti 2010, p.  76.
    172. ↑ Eidem, Finkel & Bonechi 2001, p.  101.
    173. ↑ Lönnqvist 2008, p.  205.
    174. ↑ Armstrong 1996, p.  191.
    175. ↑ Kuhrt 1995, p.  75.
    176. 1 2 3 Archi 2002, p.  31.
    177. ↑ Matthiae 2003, p.  393.
    178. ↑ Pettinato 1991, p.  168.
    179. 1 2 3 4 Liverani 2013, p.  124.
    180. 1 2 3 Liverani 2013, p.  129.
    181. ↑ Marchesi 2013, p.  274.
    182. 1 2 Akkermans & Schwartz 2003, p.  271.
    183. ↑ Liverani 2013, p.  126.
    184. ↑ Dahood 1978, p.  83.
    185. ↑ Pettinato 1991, p.  155.
    186. ↑ Aruz 2003, p.  241.
    187. ↑ McNulty & Brice 1996, p.  246.
    188. 1 2 3 4 5 Stieglitz 2002a, p.  209.
    189. ↑ Archi, Alfonso (2005). "The Head of Kura—The Head of ʾAdabal". Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 64 (2): 81–100. doi:10.1086/431684. JSTOR   10.1086/431684. S2CID   161744545.
    190. 1 2 Stieglitz 2002a, p.  210.
    191. ↑ Stieglitz 2002a, p.  212.
    192. ↑ Frayne 2008, p.  41-44.
    193. ↑ Biga 2014, p.  100.
    194. ↑ Westenholz 1999, p.  155.
    195. ↑ Fleming 2000, p.  208.
    196. ↑ Archi 2002, p.  28.
    197. ↑ Archi 2002, p.  27.
    198. 1 2 Stieglitz 1990, p.  81.
    199. ↑ Astour 1992, p.  10.
    200. ↑ Singer 2000, p.  223.
    201. ↑ Archi 2010, p. 4.
    202. ↑ Archi 1994, p.  250.
    203. ↑ Matthiae 2013b, p.  102.
    204. 1 2 3 Feliu 2003, p.  8.
    205. ↑ Archi 2002, p.  30.
    206. 1 2 3 4 Chavalas 2003, p.  41.
    207. ↑ McBee Roberts 2002, p.  13.
    208. ↑ Pereltsvaig, Asya (2020-09-03). Languages of the World: An Introduction. Cambridge University Press. p. 184. ISBN   978-1-108-78851-9.
    209. ↑ Skourtanioti, Eirini; Erdal, Yilmaz S.; Frangipane, Marcella; Balossi Restelli, Francesca; Yener, K. Aslıhan; Pinnock, Frances; Matthiae, Paolo; Özbal, Rana; Schoop, Ulf-Dietrich; Guliyev, Farhad; Akhundov, Tufan (2020-05-28). "Genomic History of Neolithic to Bronze Age Anatolia, Northern Levant, and Southern Caucasus". Cell. 181 (5): 1158–1175.e28. doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2020.04.044 . ISSN   0092-8674. PMID   32470401. S2CID   219105572.
    210. ↑ Fortin 1999, p.  54.
    211. ↑ DeVries 2006, p.  67.
    212. ↑ Kipfer 2000, p.  334 683.
    213. ↑ Archi, Alfonso. “The Tablets of the Throne Room of the Royal Palace G of Ebla.” Archiv Für Orientforschung, vol. 53, pp. 9–18, 2015
    214. ↑ Frances Pinnock. “THE KING’S STANDARD FROM EBLA PALACE G.” Journal of Cuneiform Studies, vol. 67, pp. 3–22, 2015
    215. ↑ Pitard 2001, p.  32.
    216. ↑ Naveh 1982, p.  28.
    217. ↑ Pettinato 1981, p.  59.
    218. ↑ Zettler 2006, p.  134.
    219. 1 2 Franks 2013, p.  2.
    220. ↑ Biga 2009, p. 30.
    221. ↑ Michalowski 2003, p.  453.
    222. ↑ Wellisch, H. H. (1981). Ebla: The World’s Oldest Library. The Journal of Library History (1974-1987), 16(3), 488–500. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25541212.
    223. 1 2 3 4 5 Wellisch 1981, p. 488–500.
    224. ↑ Stanley 2007, p.  141.
    225. ↑ Archi, Alfonso., "Position of the Tablets of Ebla.", Orientalia, vol. 57, no. 1, pp. 67–69, 1988
    226. ↑ Biga, Maria Giovanna, and Francesco Pomponio., "Elements for a Chronological Division of the Administrative Documentation of Ebla.", Journal of Cuneiform Studies, vol. 42, no. 2, pp. 179–201, 1990
    227. ↑ Biga, Maria Giovanna., "The Reconstruction of a Relative Chronology for the Ebla Texts.", Orientalia, vol. 72, no. 4, pp. 345–67, 2003
    228. ↑ Porter 2012, p.  199.
    229. ↑ Liverani 2009, p.  228.
    230. ↑ Moore & Lewis 2009, p.  34.
    231. ↑ McBee Roberts 2002, p.  12.
    232. ↑ Matthiae 2013c, p.  ix.
    233. 1 2 3 Chivers 2013, p.  1.
    234. ↑ Anthropology.msu.edu
    235. ↑ Casana J, Laugier EJ (2017) Satellite imagery-based monitoring of archaeological site damage in the Syrian civil war. PLoS ONE 12(11): e0188589. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0188589
    236. ↑ "As Syria's army advances into Idlib, a mass exodus is underway". Los Angeles Times. 2019-12-26. Retrieved 2020-03-03.
    237. ↑ Al-Masdar News
    238. ↑ Al-Masdar News (2)

    Bibliography

    • Akkermans, Peter M.M.G.; Schwartz, Glenn M. (2003). The Archaeology of Syria: From Complex Hunter-Gatherers to Early Urban Societies (c. 16,000-300 BC). Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-79666-8.
    • Archi, Alfonso (1994). "Studies in the Pantheon of Ebla". Orientalia. Pontificium Institutum Biblicum. 63 (3). OCLC   557711946.
    • Archi, Alfonso (2010). "Hadda of Ḫalab and his Temple in the Ebla Period". IRAQ. Cambridge University Press - On Behalf of The British Institute for the Study of Iraq (Gertrude Bell Memorial). 72: In Honour of the Seventieth Birthday of Professor David Hawkins: 3–17. doi:10.1017/S0021088900000565. ISSN   0021-0889. JSTOR   20779017. S2CID   191962310.
    • Archi, Alfonso (2002). "Formation of the West Hurrian Pantheon: The Case Of Ishara". In Yener, K. Aslihan; Hoffner, Harry A.; Dhesi, Simrit (eds.). Recent Developments in Hittite Archaeology and History. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-053-8.
    • Archi, Alfonso (2011). "In Search of Armi". Journal of Cuneiform Studies. The American Schools of Oriental Research. 63: 5–34. doi:10.5615/jcunestud.63.0005. ISSN   2325-6737. S2CID   163552750.
    • Archi, Alfonso (2015). Ebla and Its Archives: Texts, History, and Society. Walter de Gruyter. ISBN   978-1-61451-788-7.
    • Archi, Alfonso (2015b). "A Royal Seal from Ebla (17th cent. B.C.) with Hittite Hieroglyphic Symbols". Orientalia. Gregorian Biblical Press. 84 (1): 18–28. JSTOR   26153279.
    • Armstrong, James A. (1996). "Ebla". In Fagan, Brian M. (ed.). The Oxford Companion to Archaeology. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-507618-9.
    • Aruz, Joan (2003). "Art and interconnections in the third millennium B.C.". In Aruz, Joan; Wallenfels, Ronald (eds.). Art of the First Cities: The third millennium B.C. from the Mediterranean to the Indus . Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN   978-1-58839-043-1.
    • Astour, Michael C. (1969). "The Partition of the Confederacy of Mukiš-Nuḫiašše-Nii by Šuppiluliuma: A study in political geography of the Amarna age". Orientalia. Vol. 38. Pontificium Institutum Biblicum. OCLC   557711946.
    • Astour, Michael C. (1981). "Ugarit and the Great Powers". In Young, Gordon Douglas (ed.). Ugarit in Retrospect. Fifty years of Ugarit and Ugaritic: Proceedings of the symposium of the same title held at the University of Wisconsin at Madison, February 26, 1979, under the auspices of the Middle West Branch of the American Oriental Society and the Mid-West Region of the Society of Biblical Literature. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-0-931464-07-2.
    • Astour, Michael C. (1992). "An outline of the history of Ebla (part 1)". In Gordon, Cyrus Herzl; Rendsburg, Gary (eds.). Eblaitica: Essays on the Ebla Archives and Eblaite Language. Vol. 3. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-0-931464-77-5.
    • Astour, Michael C. (2002). "A Reconstruction of the History of Ebla (Part 2)". In Gordon, Cyrus Herzl; Rendsburg, Gary (eds.). Eblaitica: Essays on the Ebla Archives and Eblaite Language. Vol. 4. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-060-6.
    • Aubet, Maria Eugenia (2001). The Phoenicians and the West: Politics, Colonies and Trade. Translated by Turton, Mary (2 ed.). Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-79543-2.
    • Bachvarova, Mary R. (2009). "Manly Deeds: Hittite Admonitory History and Eastern Mediterranean Didactic Epic". In Konstan, David; Raaflaub, Kurt A. (eds.). Epic and History. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN   978-1-4443-1564-6.
    • Baffi, Francesca; Peyronel, Luca (2013). "Trends in Village Life. The Early Bronze Age Phases at Tell Tuqan". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Paolo Matthiae, Richard Bates, Mattia Bilardello, Anita Weston, Ebla: Archaeology and History, 2020 ISBN 9781315724607
    • Bernal, Martin (2006). Black Athena: Afroasiatic Roots of Classical Civilization. Vol. 3 (The Linguistic Evidence). Rutgers University Press. ISBN   978-0-8135-6441-8.
    • Biga, Maria Giovanna (2007). Bartoloni, Gilda (ed.). "Buried among the Living at Ebla". Scienze dell'antichità. Università degli Studi di Roma "La Sapienza". 14. OCLC   605398099.
    • Biga, Maria Giovanna (2009). "Discovering history through the Ebla tablets". In Servadio, Gaia (ed.). Ancient Syrian Writings: Syrian Preclassical and Classical Texts. General Secretariat of Damascus Arab Capital of Culture. OCLC   751116608.
    • Biga, Maria Giovanna (2013). "Defining the Chora of Ebla : A textual perspective". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early state formation in the ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Biga, Maria Giovanna (2014). "Inherited space – third millennium political and cultural landscape". In Cancik-Kirschbaum, Eva; Brisch, Nicole; Eidem, Jesper (eds.). Constituent, Confederate, and Conquered Space: The emergence of the mittani state. Walter de Gruyter. ISBN   978-3-11-026641-2.
    • Bretschneider, Joachim; Van Vyve, Anne-Sophie; Leuven, Greta Jans (2009). "War of the lords, the battle of chronology: Trying to recognize historical iconography in the 3rd millennium glyptic art in seals of Ishqi-Mari and from Beydar". Ugarit-Forschungen. Ugarit-Verlag. 41. ISBN   978-3-86835-042-5.
    • Bryce, Trevor (2009). The Routledge Handbook of the Peoples and Places of Ancient Western Asia. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-134-15908-6.
    • Bryce, Trevor (2014). Ancient Syria: A three thousand year history. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-100292-2.
    • Chavalas, Mark W. (2003). "Assyriology and Biblical studies: A century and a half of tension". In Chavalas, Mark W. Jr.; Younger, K. Lawson (eds.). Mesopotamia and the Bible. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement. Vol. 341. A&C Black. ISBN   978-0-567-08231-2.
    • Chivers, Christopher John (2013) [April 6, 2013]. "Grave Robbers and War Steal Syria's History". The New York Times. Retrieved December 1, 2016.
    • Cooper, Lisa (2006). Early Urbanism on the Syrian Euphrates. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-134-26107-9.
    • Cooper, Lisa (2010). "States of hegemony: Early forms of political control in Syria during the third millennium BC". In Bolger, Diane; Maguire, Louise C. (eds.). The Development of Pre-State Communities in the Ancient Near East: Studies in Honour of Edgar Peltenburg. Oxbow Books. ISBN   978-1-84217-837-9.
    • Bonacossi, Daniele Morandi (2013). "Northern Levant (Syria) During the Middle Bronze Age". In Steiner, Margreet L.; Killebrew, Ann E. (eds.). The Oxford Handbook of the Archaeology of the Levant: c. 8000-332 BCE. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-166255-3.
    • Crawford, Harriet (2015). Ur: The City of the Moon God. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN   978-1-4725-3169-8.
    • D'Andrea, Marta; Ascalone, Enrico (2013). "Assembling the Evidence. Excavated Sites Dating from the Early Bronze Age in and around the Chora of Ebla". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Dahood, Mitchell (1978). "Ebla, Ugarit and the Old Testament". In Emerton, John Adney; Holladay, William L.; Lemaire, André; Murphy, Roland Edmund; Nielsen, Eduard; Smend, Rudolf; Soggin, Jan Alberto (eds.). Congress Volume [International Organization for the Study of the Old Testament]. Göttingen 1977. Supplements to Vetus Testamentum. Vol. 29. Brill. ISBN   978-90-04-05835-4.
    • DeVries, LaMoine F. (2006). Cities of the Biblical World: An Introduction to the Archaeology, Geography, and History of Biblical Sites. Wipf and Stock Publishers. ISBN   978-1-55635-120-4.
    • Dolansky, Shawna (2013). "Syria-Canaan". In Spaeth, Barbette Stanley (ed.). The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Mediterranean Religions. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-11396-0.
    • Dolce, Rita (2008). "Ebla before the Achievement of Palace G Culture: An Evaluation of the Early Syrian Archaic Period". In Kühne, Hartmut; Czichon, Rainer Maria; Kreppner, Florian Janoscha (eds.). Proceedings of the 4th International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East, 29 March - 3 April 2004, Freie Universität Berlin. Vol. 2. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-05757-8.
    • Dolce, Rita (2010). "Ebla and its origins – a proposal". In Matthiae, Paolo; Pinnock, Frances; Nigro, Lorenzo; Marchetti, Nicolò; Romano, Licia (eds.). Proceedings of the 6th International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East: Near Eastern archaeology in the past, present and future: heritage and identity, ethnoarchaeological and interdisciplinary approach, results and perspectives; visual expression and craft production in the definition of social relations and status. Vol. 1. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-06175-9.
    • Eidem, Jesper; Finkel, Irving; Bonechi, Marco (2001). "The third-millennium inscriptions". In Oates, David; Oates, Joan; McDonald, Helen (eds.). Excavations at Tell Brak. Vol. 2: Nagar in the third millennium BC. British School of Archaeology in Iraq. ISBN   978-0-9519420-9-3.
    • Faber, Alice (2013). "Genetic subgrouping of the semitic languages". In Hetzron, Robert (ed.). The Semitic Languages. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-136-11580-6.
    • Feldman, Marian H. (2007). "Frescoes, exotica, and the reinvention of the northern Levantine kingdoms during the second millenium B.C.E.". In Heinz, Marlies; Feldman, Marian H. (eds.). Representations of Political Power: Case histories from times of change and dissolving order in the ancient Near East. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-135-1.
    • Feliu, Lluís (2003). The God Dagan in Bronze Age Syria. Translated by Watson, Wilfred G.E. Brill. ISBN   978-90-04-13158-3.
    • Finer, Samuel Edward (1997). Ancient Nonarchies and Empires. The History of Government from the Earliest Times. Vol. 1. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-820664-4.
    • Fleming, Daniel E. (2000). Time at Emar: The cultic calendar and the rituals from the diviner's archive. Mesopotamian Civilizations. Vol. 11. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-044-6.
    • Fortin, Michel (1999). Syria, land of civilizations. Musée de la civilisation, Québec. ISBN   978-2-7619-1521-2.
    • Franks, Patricia C. (2013). Records and Information Management. American Library Association. ISBN   978-1-55570-910-5.
    • Frayne, Douglas (1990). Old Babylonian Period (2003–1595 BC). The Royal Inscriptions of Mesopotamia Early Periods. Vol. 4. University of Toronto Press. ISBN   978-0-8020-5873-7.
    • Frayne, Douglas (2008). Pre-Sargonic Period: Early Periods (2700–2350 BC). The Royal inscriptions of Mesopotamia Early Periods. Vol. 1. University of Toronto Press. ISBN   978-1-4426-9047-9.
    • Gilchrist, Paul R. (1995) [1982]. "Government". In Bromiley, Geoffrey W.; Harrison, Everett F.; Harrison, Roland K.; LaSor, William Sanford (eds.). The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia. Vol. 2 (revised ed.). Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing. ISBN   978-0-8028-3782-0.
    • Goetze, Albrecht (1953). "Four Ur dynasty tablets mentioning foreigners". Journal of Cuneiform Studies. The American Schools of Oriental Research. 7 (3): 103–107. doi:10.2307/1359547. ISSN   0022-0256. JSTOR   1359547. S2CID   163789459.
    • Gordon, Cyrus H. (2013). "Amorite and Eblaite". In Hetzron, Robert (ed.). The Semitic Languages. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-136-11580-6.
    • Grajetzki, Wolfram (2013). Tomb Treasures of the Late Middle Kingdom: The archaeology of female burials. University of Pennsylvania Press. ISBN   978-0-8122-0919-8.
    • Gurney, Oliver Robert (2003). "The Upper Land, matum elitum". In Beckman, Gary M.; Beal, Richard Henry; McMahon, John Gregory (eds.). Hittite Studies in Honor of Harry A. Hoffner, Jr: On the Occasion of His 65th Birthday. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-079-8.
    • Hamblin, William J. (2006). Warfare in the Ancient Near East to 1600 BC. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-134-52062-6.
    • Harmanşah, Ömür (2007). "Upright Stones and Building Narratives: Formation of a Shared Architectural Practice In the Ancient Near East". In Cheng, Jack; Feldman, Marian H. (eds.). Ancient Near Eastern Art in Context . Brill. p.  75. ISBN   978-90-04-15702-6.
    • Hooks, Stephen M. (1990). "Ebla". In Mills, Watson E.; Bullard, Roger Aubrey; Drinkard, Joel F. Jr.; Harrelson, Walter; McKnight, Edgar V.; Armour, Rollin Stely; Rowell, Edd; Wilson, Richard F. (eds.). Mercer Dictionary of the Bible. Mercer University Press. ISBN   978-0-86554-373-7.
    • Horowitz, Wayne (1998). Mesopotamian Cosmic Geography. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-0-931464-99-7.
    • Kipfer, Barbara Ann (2000). Encyclopedic Dictionary of Archaeology. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN   978-0-306-46158-3.
    • Klengel, Horst (1992). Syria, 3000 to 300 B.C.: a handbook of political history. Akademie Verlag. ISBN   978-3-05-001820-1.
    • Kohl, Philip L. (1991). "The use and abuse of world systems theory: The case of the "pristine" west Asian state". In Lamberg-Karlovsky, Clifford Charles (ed.). Archaeological Thought in America. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-40643-7.
    • Kuz'mina, Elena E. (2007). Mallory, James Patrick (ed.). The Origin of the Indo-Iranians. Translated by Pitina, Svetlana; Prudovsky, P. Brill. ISBN   978-90-04-16054-5.
    • Kuhrt, Amélie (1995). The Ancient Near East, c. 3000-330 BC . Routledge History of the Ancient World. Vol. 1. Routledge. ISBN   978-0-415-01353-6.
    • Laneri, Nicola (2016). "Embodying the memory of the royal ancestors in western Syria during the third and second millennia BC: The case of Ebla and Qatna". In Nadali, Davide (ed.). Envisioning the Past Through Memories: How Memory Shaped Ancient Near Eastern Societies. Cultural Memory and History in Antiquity. Vol. 3. Bloomsbury. ISBN   978-1-4742-2398-0.
    • Leick, Gwendolyn (2009). Historical Dictionary of Mesopotamia. Historical Dictionaries of Ancient Civilizations and Historical Eras. Vol. 26 (2nd ed.). Scarecrow Press. ISBN   978-0-8108-6324-8.
    • Liverani, Mario (2009). "Imperialism". In Pollock, Susan; Bernbeck, Reinhard (eds.). Archaeologies of the Middle East: Critical Perspectives. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN   978-1-4051-3723-2.
    • Liverani, Mario (2013). The Ancient Near East: History, society and economy. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-134-75084-9.
    • Lönnqvist, Mina A. (2008). "Were Nomadic Amorites on the Move? Migration, Invasion and Gradual Infiltration as Mechanisms for Cultural Transitions". In Kühne, Hartmut; Czichon, Rainer Maria; Kreppner, Florian Janoscha (eds.). Proceedings of the 4th International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East, 29 March - 3 April 2004, Freie Universität Berlin. Vol. 2. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-05757-8.
    • Marchesi, Gianni (2013). "Of plants and trees: Crops and vegetable resources at Ebla". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early state formation in the ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (1984). "New Discoveries at Ebla: The Excavation of the Western Palace and the Royal. Necropolis of the Amorite Period". The Biblical Archaeologist. American Schools of Oriental Research. 47. ISSN   2325-534X.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (1989). "Jugs of the North-Syrian - Cilician and Levantine painted wares from the Middle Bronze II royal tombs at Ebla". In Emre, Kutlu; Hrouda, Barthel; Mellink, Machteld; Özgüç, Nimet (eds.). Anatolia and the ancient Near East: Studies in honor of Tahsin Özgüç. Türk Tarih Kurumu Basımevi. OCLC   33983890.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (1997). "Where were the early Syrian kings of Ebla buried?". Altorientalische Forschungen. Walter de Gruyter. 24 (2). doi:10.1524/aofo.1997.24.2.268. ISSN   0232-8461. S2CID   164174341.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2003). "Ishtar of Ebla and Hadad of Aleppo: Notes on terminology, politics, and religion of Old Syrian Ebla". In Marrassini, Paolo (ed.). Semitic and Assyriological Studies: Presented to Pelio Fronzaroli by Pupils and Colleagues. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-04749-4.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2006). "The archaic palace at Ebla: A royal building between Early Bronze Age IVB and Middle Bronze Age I". In Gitin, Seymour; Wright, J. Edward; Dessel, J. P. (eds.). Confronting the Past: Archaeological and Historical Essays on Ancient Israel in Honor of William G. Dever. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-117-7.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2008). "Ebla". In Aruz, Joan; Benzel, Kim; Evans, Jean M. (eds.). Beyond Babylon: Art, Trade, and Diplomacy in the Second Millennium B.C. . Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN   978-1-58839-295-4.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2010). Ebla: la città del trono: archeologia e storia. Piccola biblioteca Einaudi: Arte, architettura, teatro, cinema, música (in Italian). Vol. 492. Einaudi. ISBN   978-88-06-20258-3.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2013). "The Royal Palace. Functions of the Quarters and the Government of the Chora". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2013a). "A Long Journey. Fifty Years of Research on the Bronze Age at Tell Mardikh/Ebla". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2013b). "Ebla: Recent Excavation Results and the Continuity of Syrian Art". In Aruz, Joan; Graff, Sarah B.; Rakic, Yelena (eds.). Cultures in Contact: From Mesopotamia to the Mediterranean in the Second Millennium B.C.. Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN   978-1-58839-475-0.
    • Matthiae, Paolo (2013c). "Introduction". In Pinnock, Francis (ed.). Studies on the Archaeology of Ebla 1980–2010. Harrassowitz. ISBN   978-3-447-06937-3.
    • Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (2013). "Representing the Chora of Ebla". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • McBee Roberts, Jimmy Jack (2002). The Bible and the Ancient Near East: Collected Essays. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-066-8.
    • McNulty, Mary F.; Brice, Elizabeth (1996). "Ebla". In Berney, Kathryn Ann; Ring, Trudy; Watson, Noelle; Hudson, Christopher; La Boda, Sharon (eds.). Middle East and Africa. Vol. 4: International Dictionary of Historic Places. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-134-25993-9.
    • Mantellini, Simone; Micale, Maria Gabriella; Peyronel, Luca (2013). "Exploiting Diversity. The Archaeological Landscape of the Eblaite Chora". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Michalowski, Piotr (1995). "The Men from Mari". In van Lerberghe, Karel; Schoors, Antoon (eds.). Immigration and Emigration within the Ancient Near East: Festschrift E. Lipiński. Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta. Vol. 65. Peeters Publishers & Department of Oriental Studies, Leuven. ISBN   978-90-6831-727-5.
    • Michalowski, Piotr (2003). "The Earliest Scholastic Tradition". In Aruz, Joan; Wallenfels, Ronald (eds.). Art of the First Cities: The Third Millennium B.C. from the Mediterranean to the Indus . Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN   978-1-58839-043-1.
    • Mogliazza, Silvia; Polcaro, Andrea (2010). "Death and cult of dead in Middle Bronze Age II Ebla: An archaeological and anthropological study on shaft tomb P. 8680, near southern palace (Area FF)". In Matthiae, Paolo; Pinnock, Frances; Nigro, Lorenzo; Marchetti, Nicolò; Romano, Licia (eds.). Proceedings of the 6th International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East: Near Eastern archaeology in the past, present and future: heritage and identity, ethnoarchaeological and interdisciplinary approach, results and perspectives; visual expression and craft production in the definition of social relations and status. Vol. 3. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-06217-6.
    • Moore, Karl; Lewis, David Charles (2009). The Origins of Globalization. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-135-97008-6.
    • Nadali, Davide (2007). "Monuments of War, War of Monuments: Some considerations on commemorating war in the third millennium BC". Orientalia. Pontificium Institutum Biblicum. 76 (4). OCLC   557711946.
    • Naveh, Joseph (1982). Early History of the Alphabet: An introduction to West Semitic epigraphy and palaeography. Magnes Press, Hebrew University. ISBN   978-965-223-436-0.
    • Neff, Stephen C. (2014). Justice Among Nations. Harvard University Press. ISBN   978-0-674-72654-3.
    • Nigro, Lorenzo (2007). Byblos and Jericho in the Early Bronze I: Social Dynamics and Cultural Interactions: Proceedings of the International Workshop Held in Rome on March 6th 2007 by Rome "La Sapienza" University. Lorenzo Nigro.
    • Nigro, Lorenzo (2009). Doumet-Serhal, Claude (ed.). "The eighteenth century BC princes of Byblos and Ebla and the chronology of the Middle Bronze Age". BAAL: Bulletin d'Archéologie et d'Architecture Libanaises. Beyrouth: Ministère de la Culture, Direction Générale des Antiquités. Hors-Série VI (Interconnections in the Eastern Mediterranean: Lebanon in the Bronze and Iron Ages: Proceedings of the International Symposium Beirut 2008). ISSN   1683-0083.
    • Ökse, Tuba (2011). "The Early Bronze Age in Southeastern Anatolia". In Steadman, Sharon R.; McMahon, Gregory (eds.). The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia: (10,000-323 BCE). Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-537614-2.
    • Otto, Adelheid; Biga, Maria Giovanna (2010). "The Identification of Tall Bazi with Armi". In Matthiae, Paolo; Pinnock, Frances; Nigro, Lorenzo; Marchetti, Nicolò; Romano, Licia (eds.). Proceedings of the 6th International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East: Near Eastern archaeology in the past, present and future: Heritage and identity, ethnoarchaeological and interdisciplinary approach, results and perspectives; visual expression and craft production in the definition of social relations and status. Vol. 1. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-06175-9.
    • Pettinato, Giovanni (1981). The archives of Ebla: An empire inscribed in clay. Doubleday. ISBN   978-0-385-13152-0.
    • Pettinato, Giovanni (1991). Ebla, a new look at history. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN   978-0-8018-4150-7.
    • Peyronel, Luca (2008). "Domestic Quarters, Refuse Pits, and Working Areas. Reconstructing Human Landscape and Environment at Tell Mardikh-Ebla during the Old Syrian Period (c. 2000–1600 BC)". In Kühne, Hartmut; Czichon, Rainer Maria; Kreppner, Florian Janoscha (eds.). Proceedings of the 4th International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East, 29 March - 3 April 2004, Freie Universität Berlin. Vol. 1. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-05703-5.
    • Peyronel, Luca; Vacca, Agnese (2013). "Natural Resources, Technology and Manufacture Processes at Ebla. A Preliminary Assessment". In Matthiae, Paolo; Marchetti, Nicolò (eds.). Ebla and its Landscape: Early State Formation in the Ancient Near East. Left Coast Press. ISBN   978-1-61132-228-6.
    • Pinnock, Frances (2000). "Some thoughts about the transmission of iconographies between North Syria and Cappadocia, end of third – beginning of the second millennium BC". In Matthiae, Paolo (ed.). Proceedings of the First International Congress on the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East, Rome, May 18th-23rd 1998. Vol. 2. Università degli studi di Roma "La Sapienza." Dipartimento di scienze storiche, archeologiche ed antropologiche dell'antichità. ISBN   978-88-88233-00-0.
    • Pinnock, Frances (2007). "Byblos and Ebla in the third millennium BC. Two urban patterns in comparison". In Nigro, Lorenzo (ed.). Byblos and Jericho in the Early Bronze I: Social Dynamics and Cultural Interactions: Proceedings of the International Workshop Held in Rome on March 6th 2007 by Rome "La Sapienza" University. Rome "La Sapienza" Studies on the Archaeology of Palestine & Transjordan (ROSAPAT). Vol. 4. Rome "La Sapienza" University. ISSN   1826-9206.
    • Pinnock, Frances (2013). "Ebla". In Crawford, Harriet (ed.). The Sumerian World. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-136-21912-2.
    • Pitard, Wayne T. (2001) [1998]. "Before Israel: Syria-Palestine in the Bronze Age". In Coogan, Michael David (ed.). The Oxford History of the Biblical World (revised ed.). Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-513937-2.
    • Podany, Amanda H. (2010). Brotherhood of Kings: How international relations shaped the ancient Near East. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-979875-9.
    • Pongratz-Leisten, Beate (2015). Religion and Ideology in Assyria. Studies in Ancient Near Eastern Records. Vol. 6. Walter de Gruyter. ISBN   978-1-61451-426-8.
    • Porter, Anne (2012). Mobile Pastoralism and the Formation of Near Eastern Civilizations: Weaving together society. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-76443-8.
    • Rendsburg, Gary A. (1997). "Eblaites". In Meyers, Eric M. (ed.). The Oxford encyclopedia of archaeology in the Near East. Vol. 2. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-511216-0.
    • Ristvet, Lauren (2014). Ritual, Performance, and Politics in the Ancient Near East. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-1-316-19503-1.
    • Roux, Georges (1992). Ancient Iraq. Penguin UK. ISBN   978-0-14-193825-7.
    • Shaw, Ian (1999). "Ebla". In Shaw, Ian; Jameson, Robert (eds.). A Dictionary of Archaeology. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN   978-0-470-75196-1.
    • Shea, William H. (1981). "The Calendars of Ebla. Part II. The New Calendar". Andrews University Seminary Studies. Andrews University Press. 19 (1). ISSN   0003-2980.
    • Singer, Itamar (2000). "Semitic Dagan and Indo-European *dl'eg'om: Related Words?". In Arbeitman, Yoël L. (ed.). The Asia Minor Connexion: Studies on the Pre-Greek Languages in Memory of Charles Carter. Orbis Supplementa. Vol. 13. Peeters Publishers. ISBN   978-90-429-0798-0.
    • Stanley, Bruce E. (2007). "Ebla". In Dumper, Michael; Stanley, Bruce E. (eds.). Cities of the Middle East and North Africa: A historical encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO. ISBN   978-1-57607-919-5.
    • Stiebing, William H. Jr. (2016) [2009]. Ancient Near Eastern History and Culture (2 ed.). Routledge. ISBN   978-1-315-51116-0.
    • Stieglitz, Robert R. (1990). "Ebla and the gods of Canaan". In Gordon, Cyrus Herzl; Rendsburg, Gary (eds.). Eblaitica: Essays on the Ebla Archives and Eblaite Language. Vol. 2. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-0-931464-49-2.
    • Stieglitz, Robert R. (2002). "The Deified Kings of Ebla". In Gordon, Cyrus Herzl; Rendsburg, Gary (eds.). Eblaitica: Essays on the Ebla Archives and Eblaite Language. Vol. 4. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-060-6.
    • Stieglitz, Robert R. (2002a). "Divine Pairs in the Ebla Pantheon". In Gordon, Cyrus Herzl; Rendsburg, Gary (eds.). Eblaitica: Essays on the Ebla Archives and Eblaite Language. Vol. 4. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-060-6.
    • Suriano, Matthew J. (2010). The Politics of Dead Kings: Dynastic Ancestors in the Book of Kings and Ancient Israel. Forschungen zum Alten Testament. Vol. 48. Mohr Siebeck. ISBN   978-3-16-150473-0. ISSN   1611-4914.
    • Teissier, Beatrice (1984). Ancient Near Eastern Cylinder Seals from the Marcopolic Collection. University of California Press. ISBN   978-0-520-04927-7.
    • Thuesen, Ingolf (2000). "The City-State in Ancient Western Syria". In Hansen, Mogens Herman (ed.). A Comparative Study of Thirty City-state Cultures: An investigation. Vol. 21. Kgl. Danske Videnskabernes Selskab. ISBN   978-87-7876-177-4.
    • Tonietti, Maria Vittoria (2010). "Musicians in the Ebla Texts". In Pruzsinszky, Regine; Shehata, Dahlia (eds.). Musiker und Tradierung: Studien zur Rolle von Musikern bei der Verschriftlichung und Tradierung von literarischen Werken. LIT Verlag Münster. ISBN   978-3-643-50131-8.
    • Tubb, Jonathan N. (1998). Peoples Of The Past: Canaanites. University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN   978-0-8061-3108-5.
    • Van De Mieroop, Marc (2002). "Foreign Contacts and the Rise of an Elite in Early Dynastic Babylonia". In Ehrenberg, Erica (ed.). Leaving No Stones Unturned: Essays on the Ancient Near East and Egypt in Honor of Donald P. Hansen. Eisenbrauns. ISBN   978-1-57506-055-2.
    • Weiss, Harvey (1985). "Tell Leilan And Shubat Enlil". In Weiss, Harvey (ed.). Ebla to Damascus: Art and Archaeology of Ancient Syria : an Exhibition from the Directorate General of Antiquities and Museums of the Syrian Arab Republic. Smithsonian Institution Traveling Exhibition Service. ISBN   978-0-86528-029-8.
    • Wellisch, Hans H. (1981). "Ebla: The World's Oldest Library". The Journal of Library History. University of Texas Press. 16 (3): 488–500. ISSN   0275-3650. JSTOR   25541212.
    • Westenholz, Joan Goodnick (1999). "Emar – the City and its God". In van Lerberghe, Karel; Voet, Gabriela (eds.). Languages and Cultures in Contact: At the Crossroads of Civilizations in the Syro-Mesopotamian realm. Proceedings of the 42th RAI. Orientalia Lovaniensia analecta. Vol. 92. Peeters Publishers & Department of Oriental Studies, Leuven. ISBN   978-90-429-0719-5.
    • Wright, David P. (2004). "Syria and Canaan". In Johnston, Sarah Iles (ed.). Religions of the Ancient World: A Guide. Harvard University Press. ISBN   978-0-674-01517-3.
    • Zettler, Richard L. (2006). "Reconstructing the World of Ancient Mesopotamia: Divided Beginnings and Holistic History". In Yoffee, Norman; Crowell, Bradley L. (eds.). Excavating Asian History: Interdisciplinary Studies in Archaeology and History. University of Arizona Press. ISBN   978-0-8165-2418-1.

    Further reading