John Stuart (actor)

Last updated

John Stuart
John Stuart publicity photo.jpg
Autographed publicity photo from 1934
John Alfred Louden Croall

(1898-07-18)18 July 1898
Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland
Died17 October 1979(1979-10-17) (aged 81)
London, England
Years active1920–1979
Spouse(s)Jeanne Irene V. Lagrene (m.1924– ?); Muriel E S M Findlay (m.1933–1940) ; Eunice Barbara Francis (m. 1943–1979)

John Stuart (John Alfred Louden Croall; 18 July 1898 – 17 October 1979) was born to Scottish parents, and was a very popular leading man in British silent films in the 1920s. He successfully made the transition to talking pictures in the 1930s and his film career went on to span almost six decades. He appeared in 172 films (including shorts), 123 stage plays, and 103 television plays and series.


Early life

John Croall – later John Stuart – was born in Edinburgh on 18 July 1898. He came from a wealthy family whose company John Croall & Sons, run by his grandfather, made chassis for luxury cars such as Rolls-Royce. When he was seven the family moved to London, living in a house in Hampstead. [1] His parents separated the following year, and John lived with his mother and two brothers in St John's Wood. He attended Dunstable Grammar School as a boarder, and at thirteen moved to Eastbourne College: 'Scholastically I was pretty hopeless. I loved games, particularly rugger and fives'. [2] An early ambition was to become a naval doctor, but he then decided to join the army. Initially rejected because he was under age, at nineteen he was accepted and joined the Black Watch regiment as a private. He was then posted as a Second Lieutenant in the 2nd Battalion of the Seaforth Highlanders, with which he saw active service in the Arras sector of the Western Front. He was invalided out with trench fever in September 1918, and hospitalised in London, being released on Armistice Day. [3] Whilst waiting in Scotland to be demobilised he became the battalion’s entertainment officer, organising concert parties for charity. [4]

Breaking into films

After a brief spell working in the family firm’s London office, against his family’s wishes he decided to try a career as an actor, using the stage name John Stuart. [5] Despite having no acting training, he made his stage debut as an extra in a 1919 production of The Trojan Women at the Old Vic theatre, then appeared as the juvenile lead in a six-month tour of The Chinese Puzzle. [6] The film producer and director Walter West, who thought he had ‘a film face’, asked him to play a small role in his 1920 silent film Her Son , for which he was paid three guineas a day. The film was shot at Broadwest Company's studio in Walthamstow. [7] This led to him being cast that year in two other films for West The Great Gay Road and The Lights of Home, after which he decided to concentrate on a film career. He was then cast as the famous Welsh violinist David Morgan, the lead role in Land of My Fathers . Having received good notices, he went on in 1922 to play the romantic lead in Sinister Street , A Sporting Double and If Four Walls Told , while 1923 found him appearing in This Freedom , The School for Scandal and The Loves of Mary, Queen of Scots . [8] During a slump in the British film industry he returned to the stage, making his debut in the West End as Lord Bleane in Our Betters , Somerset Maugham's withering attack on contemporary society, which ran for 548 performances. [9] During this period he worked in the film studios during the day and at the theatre in the evenings.

A star of the silent screen

Poster for 'The Flight Commander', 1927 The Flight Commander (film).jpg
Poster for 'The Flight Commander', 1927

In 1924 he married Jeanne Lagrene, a young French woman from Amiens. During the 1920s he starred in 35 silent feature films (and 20 short films) most of which are now lost. [10] Two of his better-known films from this period were Hitchcock's debut as a director The Pleasure Garden (1925) [11] and Hindle Wakes (1927), directed by Maurice Elvey from Stanley Houghton’s controversial play. [12]

He became especially popular among cinema-goers with three war films [13] directed by Elvey: Mademoiselle from Armentieres (1926) and The Flight Commander (1927) in which he played opposite the American actress Estelle Brody, and Roses of Picardy , where his co-star was Lilian Hall-Davis. These films were widely praised, with the Daily Chronicle stating that 'John Stuart is easily the best leading man in British pictures.' [14] His popularity was such that a fan club, named the John Stuart Friendship Club, was set up in 1927 and attracted a large number of members. But his fame came at a price, for he was frequently mobbed by female fans. When he opened the new Clapham Pavilion cinema, he had to be given police protection from cheering fans. [15] After visiting the Film Artists Fair in Bloomsbury he was surrounded by two hundred screaming young women, who clasped him around the neck and seized his arms. 'My hat, handkerchief and tie were snatched away, my pockets ripped off and my coat torn, all apparently for souvenirs' he explained the next morning.' [16]

The talkies

Cover of 'Picture Show' magazine 25 August 1934 featuring 'Bella Donna' and showing Conrad Veidt (top), Mary Ellis and John Stuart Picture Show cover featuring Bella Donna.jpg
Cover of 'Picture Show' magazine 25 August 1934 featuring 'Bella Donna' and showing Conrad Veidt (top), Mary Ellis and John Stuart

In 1929 he and Estelle Brody were reunited in Kitty , directed by Victor Saville – one of the first British 'talkies'. [17] The film featured a synchronised music score with sound effects and sequences of dialogue, recorded in New York as sound recording equipment wasn't available in Britain. [18] Unlike several silent stars he made an easy transition to talking pictures. Now divorced from his first wife, in 1928 he met Muriel Angelus (born Muriel Findlay to Scottish parents in London) on the set of Sailors Don't Care . In 1931 she was cast as his fiancée in the sound re-make of Hindle Wakes , and in 1933 they were married.

Illustration from theatre programme of 1936 based on a photo of the Saville Theatre, featuring the play 'The Limping Man' The Limping Man Saville Theatre 1936.jpg
Illustration from theatre programme of 1936 based on a photo of the Saville Theatre, featuring the play 'The Limping Man'

In 1932 he played three contrasting roles: he had the lead as a detective in his second film directed by Alfred Hitchcock, the thriller Number Seventeen ; [19] he was an aggressive and ambitious foreman in a steel works in Men of Steel , which also featured Franklin Dyall, Benita Hume and Heather Angel; and he starred as the soldier hero who succumbs to the charms of Brigitte Helm in L'Atlantide (also known as 'The Mistress of Atlantis'), directed by the eminent G. W. Pabst, who shot many scenes in the Sahara desert. In Bella Donna (1934) he impressed as Mary Ellis's idealistic and deluded husband, matched well with co-star Conrad Veidt. He also played in two films starring Gracie Fields: as her teacher in This Week of Grace (1933), and as her fiancé in The Show Goes On (1937).

Around this time he started to work more in the theatre. As well as such West End productions as Finished Abroad in 1934 (Savoy), and in 1935 Public Saviour No.1 (Piccadilly), Butterfly on the Wheel (Playhouse) and The Limping Man (Saville), he toured with No Exit (1936) and What We All Want (1937). In 1938 and 1939 he led a repertory company in two seasons at the Sunderland Empire. [20] Meanwhile Muriel Angelus had been a success in the stage musical Balalaika in the West End, and was offered a Hollywood contract with Paramount Studios. [21] The couple separated when she moved to America.

The second world war

At the outbreak of war he attempted to rejoin his old regiment, but was deemed unfit on account of his previous disease, trench fever. [22] In spring 1940 he undertook another repertory season in Sunderland, this time at the King’s theatre. Back in films, he appeared in two low-budget comedy films with Arthur Lucan and Kitty McShane: Old Mother Riley in Society (1940) and Old Mother Riley's Ghosts (1941), and starred with Wilfred Lawson and Betty Stockfeld in Hard Steel (1942) as a romantic poet and composer. He had smaller roles in propaganda films about the war, including Michael Balcon's Ships with Wings (1941), a tribute to the Fleet Air Arm, starring Leslie Banks, Ann Todd and John Clements; the drama-documentary The Big Blockade (1941), in which many stars played cameo parts; and Flying Fortress (1942), about the arrival of American airmen in Britain. But substantial parts continued: he was convincing as the cynical newspaper editor married to Anne Crawford in the thriller Headline (1943), and as the sympathetic husband of Phyllis Calvert in the Gainsborough melodrama Madonna of the Seven Moons (1945). He continued working in the theatre throughout this time. [23] Having been divorced from Muriel Angelus, in 1943 he married the actress Barbara Francis, [24] who had been his leading lady at Sunderland. They had two sons, Jonathan and Stephen, both born during the war. [25]

Later work

His professionalism and reliability was such that throughout the 1950s he worked constantly, playing minor roles as middle-class professionals such as doctors, police inspectors, detectives, a bank manager, a coroner and a magistrate. He also appeared in three films for Hammer Studios, The Revenge of Frankenstein (1958), Blood of the Vampire (1958) and The Mummy , and featured in two acclaimed comedies, The Naked Truth (1957) and Too Many Crooks (1959).

In the aftermath of television resuming after the war, he acted in Murder in the Cathedral (1947), R.U.R. (1948), Ten Little Niggers (1949), Time and the Conways (1950), and The Railway Children (1951). His many subsequent television roles included appearances in Billy Bunter of Greyfriars School (1952–4), The Railway Children (again,1957-8), the children's science-fiction series The Lost Planet (1954-5), and the popular hospital drama Emergency Ward 10 (1959). Meanwhile in the cinema he played Captain Kerr of H.M.S Hood in Lewis Gilbert’s epic film Sink the Bismarck! (1960), while in the theatre he was cast as Group Captain Wood in Terence Rattigan’s play Ross (Haymarket and tour, 1960), the story of Lawrence of Arabia. In the 1960s he mainly worked in television, [26] but the 1970s brought interesting film appearances in Young Winston (1972) and Superman (1978). He died on 17 October 1979, his acting career having lasted almost sixty years. [27]


Publicity photograph, date unknown Actor John Stuart.jpg
Publicity photograph, date unknown

His short memoir Caught in the Act was published by The Silent Picture (1971). His son, Jonathan Croall, has written three books about his father: John Stuart: Portrait of an Actor (Blurb Books, 2011); Forgotten Stars: My Father and the British Silent Film World (Fantom, 2013); and From Silent Film Idol to Superman: The Life and Career of John Stuart (McFarland, 2023). The latter includes much previously unpublished personal and professional information. His son has also written two newspaper articles: 'My father, the silent film star' in The Stage, and 'My dad, the silent film star' in The Guardian. [28]


This filmography includes feature films only and draws from Jonathan Croall's From Silent Film Idol to Superman: The Life and Career of John Stuart (McFarland, 2023).

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edmund Gwenn</span> English actor (1877–1959)

Edmund Gwenn was an English actor. On film, he is best remembered for his role as Kris Kringle in the Christmas film Miracle on 34th Street (1947), for which he won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor and the corresponding Golden Globe Award. He received a second Golden Globe and another Academy Award nomination for the comedy film Mister 880 (1950). He is also remembered for his appearances in four films directed by Alfred Hitchcock.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edgar Kennedy</span> American actor (1890–1948)

Edgar Livingston Kennedy was an American comedic character actor who appeared in at least 500 films during the silent and sound eras. Professionally, he was known as "Slow Burn", owing to his ability to portray characters whose anger slowly rose in frustrating situations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marie Ault</span> British actress (1870–1951)

Marie Ault was a British character actress of stage and film.

Charles Alfred Selwyn Bennett was an English playwright, screenwriter and director probably best known for his work with Alfred Hitchcock.

Mutz Greenbaum, sometimes credited as Max Greene or Max Greenbaum, was a German film cinematographer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malcolm Keen</span> British actor

Malcolm Keen was an English actor of stage, film and television. He was sometimes credited as Malcolm Keane.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Roy William Neill</span> Irish-American film director (1887–1946)

Roy William Neill was an Irish-born American film director best known for producing and directing almost all of the Sherlock Holmes films starring Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce, made between 1943 and 1946 and released by Universal Pictures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Loder (actor)</span> British actor (1898–1988)

John Loder was established as a British film actor in Germany and Britain before migrating to the United States in 1928 for work in the new talkies. He worked in Hollywood for two periods, becoming an American citizen in 1947. After living also in Argentina, he became a naturalized British citizen in 1959.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Miles Mander</span> English actor

Miles Mander, was an English character actor of the early Hollywood cinema, also a film director and producer, and a playwright and novelist. He was sometimes credited as Luther Miles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">J. Farrell MacDonald</span> American actor and director (1875–1952)

John Farrell MacDonald was an American character actor and director. He played supporting roles and occasional leads. He appeared in over 325 films over a four-decade career from 1911 to 1951, and directed forty-four silent films from 1912 to 1917.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Muriel Angelus</span> English stage, musical theatre, and film actress

Muriel Angelus was an English stage, musical theatre, and film actress.

Bernard Knowles was an English film director, producer, cinematographer and screenwriter. Born in Manchester, Knowles worked with Alfred Hitchcock on numerous occasions before the director emigrated to Hollywood.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Miljan</span> American actor

John Miljan was an American actor. He appeared in more than 200 films between 1924 and 1958.

Maurice Elvey was one of the most prolific film directors in British history. He directed nearly 200 films between 1913 and 1957. During the silent film era he directed as many as twenty films per year. He also produced more than fifty films – his own as well as films directed by others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gordon Harker</span> English film actor

William Gordon Harker was an English stage and film actor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Longden</span> English actor (1900–1971)

John Longden was a British film actor. He appeared in more than 80 films between 1926 and 1964, including six films directed by Alfred Hitchcock.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Victor Saville</span> English film director

Victor Saville was an English film director, producer, and screenwriter. He directed 39 films between 1927 and 1954. He also produced 36 films between 1923 and 1962.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Turnbull (actor)</span> Scottish actor (1880–1956)

John Turnbull was a British stage and film actor. He was married to Eve Marchew and Beatrice Alice Scott (actress).

<i>Kitty</i> (1929 film) 1929 film by Victor Saville

Kitty is a 1929 sound part-talkie British drama film directed by Victor Saville and starring Estelle Brody and John Stuart. In addition to sequences with audible dialogue or talking sequences, the film features a synchronized musical score and sound effects along with English intertitles. The film was adapted from the 1927 novel of the same name by Warwick Deeping and marked the third co-star billing of Brody and Stuart, who had previously proved a very popular screen pairing in Mademoiselle from Armentieres (1926) and Hindle Wakes (1927).

<i>Hindle Wakes</i> (1931 film) 1931 film

Hindle Wakes is a 1931 British drama film directed by Victor Saville for Gainsborough Pictures and starring Belle Chrystall and John Stuart. The film is adapted from Stanley Houghton's 1912 stage play of the same name, which had previously been filmed twice as a silent in 1918 and 1927. Saville had been the producer on the highly regarded 1927 version directed by Maurice Elvey. Both Stuart and Norman McKinnel returned in 1931 to reprise their roles from the 1927 film.


  1. Jonathan Croall From Silent Film Idol to Superman, McFarland (2023), page 7
  2. John Stuart Caught in the Act (1971), The Silent Picture, page 1
  3. Caught in the Act, page 3
  4. Caught in the Act, page 3
  5. From Silent Film Idol to Superman, pages 10–12
  6. From Silent Film Idol to Superman, page 13
  7. Caught in the Act, page 3
  8. From Silent Film Idol to Superman, page 24
  9. Wearing, J.P. The London Stage 1920–1929: A Calendar of Productions, Performers, and Personnel, Rowman & Littlefield (2014)
  10. From Silent Film Idol to Superman, page 1
  11. Donald Spoto The Art of Alfred Hitchcock, Hopkinson & Blake (1976), page 4
  12. Pamela Hutchinson 10 great British silent films (2019)
  13. Clarence Winchester (editor) The World Film Encyclopedia, London (1933), page 164
  14. Daily Chronicle, 29 April 1927
  15. Jonathan Croall Forgotten Stars: My Father and the British Silent Film World, Fantom (2013), page 137
  16. Daily Chronicle, 17 September 1928
  17. Kitty was released in January 1929 in a silent version; then withdrawn and re-released as a part-talkie in June, two weeks before Alfred Hitchcock's Blackmail , the first full-talkie. Rachael Low, 'Film List', The History of the British Film 1918-1929, Allen & Unwin (1971)
  18. Victor Saville and Roy Moseley, Evergreen: Victor Saville in His Own Words, Southern Illinois University Press (2000), page 45
  19. Hitchcock and Stuart were both on the credits of the 1930 musical revue Elstree Calling , but Stuart isn't in the final cut
  20. Caught in the Act, pages 27–28
  21. Ronald Bergan, 'Muriel Angelus - obituary', The Guardian 2 September 2004
  22. Caught in the Act, page 17
  23. Escort (Lyric, 1942), Jam Today (St. Martin's, 1942), What Every Woman Knows (Lyric, 1943), season at the Oxford Playhouse (1945)
  24. Barbara Francis (1910–1983) made a number of films in the 1960s and 1970s under the screen name Barbara Markham
  25. 'Jonathan Croall 'My Dad the silent film star', The Guardian 11 February 2012
  26. From Silent Film Idol to Superman, pages 211-213, documents extensive television appearances in the 1960s and 1970s
  27. Buried at Sheen Cemetery (Richmond) on 22 October 1979
  28. The Guardian, 11 February 2012