Joshua Toulmin

Last updated

Joshua Toulmin
Joshua Toulmin.jpg
1810 portrait of Joshua Toulmin
Born(1740-04-30)30 April 1740
Died23 July 1815(1815-07-23) (aged 75)
Birmingham, England Flag of the United Kingdom.svg
Alma mater Brown University, Harvard University
OccupationDissenting Minister
SpouseJane Smith

Joshua Toulmin (11 May [ O.S. 30 April] 1740 – 23 July 1815) of Taunton, England was a noted theologian and a serial Dissenting minister of Presbyterian (1761–1764), Baptist (1765–1803), and then Unitarian (1804–1815) congregations. Toulmin's sympathy for both the American (1775–1783) and French (1787–1799) revolutions led the Englishman to be associated with the United States and gained the prolific historian the reputation of a religious radical. [1]



Early life

Toulmin was born in London, England on 30 April 1740 to Caleb Toulmin and Mary Skinner, daughter of Thomas Skinner. [2] At age eight, on 11 November 1748, Toulmin was admitted to St. Paul's School in London. As he grew, so did his nonconformist views. Because Toulmin refused to conform to the Church of England, he next was educated under David Jennings [3] at the dissenting academy in Wellclose Square, of the Coward Trust, located on The Highway in the East End of London.

The Serial Dissenting Minister

By 1761 at age twenty-one, the Dissenting Academy ordained Toulmin as a Dissenting minister. On graduating from Wellclose Square Dissenting Academy, now Reverend (Rev.) Toulmin became the Presbyterian minister of his first congregation at Colyton, a civil parish located within east Devonshire. Although the Colyton congregation was Presbyterian, Toulmin eventually became a convert to the opinions of the Baptists. Now an antipaedobaptist, Toulmin began to advocate adult baptism and to theologically oppose infant baptism.

Marriage and descendants

At the age of twenty-four, Toulmin married Jane Smith. The Toulmins eventually had twelve children, of whom only five survived. Toulmin's theological objections to infant baptism possibly extended to infant registration, as none of his children's births were registered. [4] Their eldest son, Harry Toulmin, went on to become a Unitarian minister and then emigrated to America, where eventually he was forced to resign as President of Transylvania Seminary in Lexington, Kentucky "under disapproval of his Socinian (Unitarian) errors." [5]

Joshua Toulmin Smith was his grandson.

From Presbyterian to Baptist minister

In 1765, at the age of twenty-five, Toulmin transferred himself to his second congregation at Taunton, in Somersetshire, as a Baptist minister. For the next thirty-nine years, Toulmin lived in Taunton and had charge of the Taunton Baptist congregation at Mary Street Unitarian Chapel, [6] where he also taught school and published most of his sixty-plus works through which he expressed his anti-England sympathy with both the American Revolutionary War (1775–1783) and the French Revolution (1787–1799).

Because Toulmin favored the United States and France, then-enemies of England, he "could seldom pass through the streets without insult, while to keep company with him was deemed contagious and impossible." [4] For example, during the French Revolution, an effigy of Thomas Paine was burned before Toulmin's door and his windows were broken.

In 1769, Toulmin received an Artium Magister (A.M.) degree from the recently founded College in the English Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations (the former name for Brown University) [7] in Providence, Rhode Island. [4]

Toulmin's 1778 letter to Robinson
Page 1Page 2Page 3Page 4

In 1778, Toulmin wrote to Rev. Robert Robinson of Cambridge requesting copies of Robinson's lectures on nonconformity to use as a guide for Toulmin's own lectures. In the letter (see above), Toulmin expresses his opinion about baptism. [8]

In 1790, Toulmin carried out a census of Taunton and "counted nearly five and a half thousand people living within the area ringed by the turnpike gates." [4] He followed up this census with his book, The History of Taunton in the County of Somerset, which was published in 1791 while he held the title schoolmaster. [9]

In 1794, Toulmin received his Doctor of Divinity (D.D.) diploma from Harvard University in the United States and was accorded the title Doctor. [1]

In 1798, Toulmin's daughter Jane drowned. In the face of this hardship and his longtime political persecutions, he stood strong. For example, during his ministry in Taunton at the Mary Street Unitarian Chapel, [6] poet Samuel Taylor Coleridge wrote, in a 1798 letter to John Prior Estlin, "I walked into Taunton (eleven miles) and back again, and performed the divine services for Dr. Toulmin. I suppose you must have heard that his daughter, (Jane, on 15 April 1798) in a melancholy derangement, suffered herself to be swallowed up by the tide on the sea-coast between Sidmouth and Bere (sic. Beer). These events cut cruelly into the hearts of old men: but the good Dr. Toulmin bears it like the true practical Christian, — there is indeed a tear in his eye, but that eye is lifted up to the Heavenly Father." [4]

From Baptist to Unitarian minister

Somewhere along the way, Toulmin's beliefs changed again from Baptist to Unitarian. In January 1804, at age sixty-four, Toulmin moved to Birmingham, England and accepted a position as one of the pastors of the Birmingham Unitarian congregation, formerly presided over by the co-discover of oxygen, Joseph Priestley. Between 1809 and 1811, Toulmin lived in Birmingham on Paradise Row, and he died there on 23 July 1815, at the age of seventy-five. [1]

Toulmin initially was buried in the Old Meeting graveyard in Birmingham. [10] His tombstone was moved to the borough cemetery at Witton in 1886. At the time of his death, Toulmin had a plan for an annuitant society for the benefit of widows. However, this society plan came to grief because it was based on London death rates, which differed from those of Birmingham. [4]


Dr. Toulmin was a prolific writer, and is known to have written over sixty publications in the areas of (i) religion and spirituality, history, parenting and families, reference, and nonfiction. [11] He occasionally contributed to the Theological Repository , The Nonconformists' Memorial , The Monthly Magazine , and other periodical publications. Many of his personal letters have survived, and may be seen in Dr Williams's Library in London. In addition, Taunton public library has a copy of his book, "The History of Taunton in the County of Somerset", (published in 1791) and many papers related to him "Joshua Toulmin[*1331] 1740 - 1815". Archived from the original on 12 September 2012..

Published books

Published letters


  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Rose, Hugh J., (1857). Google Book Search. A New General Biographical Dictionary. Vol. I. London: B. Fellowes, 1857. Obtained 21 October 2006.
  2. On 14 September 1752, the British Empire adopted the Gregorian calendar, making it necessary to skip eleven days (i.e. 2 September was followed directly by 14 September 1752). Since Toulmin was alive at the time of Gregorian calendar transition, his birth date was advanced by some records to 11 May but not advanced by other records, thereby creating some confusion.
  3. "Jennings, David"  . Dictionary of National Biography . London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1885–1900.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Calvert-Toulmin, Bruce. (2006) Toulmin Family Home Page. "Joshua Toulmin (*1331) 1740–1815". Archived from the original on 12 September 2012. Obtained 21 October 2006.
  5. Keyes, Clara. (2006). Unitarian Universalist Historical Society (UUHS). Harry Toulmin. Obtained 21 October 2006.
  6. 1 2 Taunton's Historic Unitarian Congregation and Chapel (Dec. 2005). Unitarian Chapel, Mary Street, Taunton. Obtained 21 October 2006.
  7. Brown University was founded in 1764, five years prior to Toulmin's A.M. degree, and was then known as the College in the English Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations
  8. Toulmin, Joshua. (1778). Letter to Rev. Robert Robinson dated 30 October 1778. Pg. 1, Pg. 2, Pg. 3, Pg. 4.
  9. Bush, Robin, The Book of Taunton. Archived 22 August 1999 at
  10. The earliest nonconformist place of worship in Birmingham of which any record remains was "The Old Meeting," which, with its graveyard, was removed in 1882 for the enlargement of the railway station in New Street. Spencer, Andrew, (2005). Nonconformism in Birmingham. (Excerpt by Spencer from The British Association Handbook of Birmingham, 1886.) Obtained 21 October 2006.
  11. " Joshua Toulmin: Books".

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Daniel Neal</span> English historian (1678–1743)

Daniel Neal was an English historian.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Robinson (Baptist)</span> English Baptist minister

Robert Robinson was an English Dissenter, influential Baptist and scholar who made a lifelong study of the antiquity and history of Christian Baptism. He was also author of the hymns "Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing" and "Mighty God, while angels bless Thee", the former of which he wrote at age 22 after converting to Methodism. The latter was later set to music by Dr John Randall, Music Professor at Cambridge University.

Theophilus Browne (1763–1835) was a Unitarian clergyman who was born in 1763 in Derby, England. He had a varied career, with a congregation once paying him to leave a chapel. He also proposed that church funds could be improved using state lotteries.

Harry Toulmin was a Unitarian minister and politician. The son of noted Dissenting minister Joshua Toulmin, Toulmin fled his native England for the United States after he and his followers were persecuted for their beliefs. He arrived in Virginia in 1793, and aided by recommendations from Thomas Jefferson and James Monroe, he was chosen president of Transylvania Seminary in Lexington, Kentucky. His Unitarian views, however, offended many of the orthodox Presbyterian members of Transylvania's board of regents, and Toulmin resigned after two years.

Hugh Farmer was an English Dissenter and theologian.

Robert Aspland was an English Unitarian minister, editor and activist. To be distinguished from his son Robert Brook Aspland (1805-1869).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Obadiah Bruen Brown</span>

Obadiah Bruen Brown was a Baptist clergyman who served as Chaplain of the House and as Chaplain of the Senate (1809–1810).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Samuel Bache</span> English Unitarian minister

Samuel Bache was an English Unitarian minister.

Samuel Bourn the Younger was an English dissenting minister. He was an English presbyterian preaching on protestant values learned from the New Testament. Through his published sermons, he entered the theological debate that flourished around the Arian controversy, and the doctrinal question as to Man's essential nature. He contested the Deism of the Norwich rationalists in the early enlightenment, and challenged the Trinitarian conventional wisdoms about the seat of humanity and its origins.

Robert Robinson D.D., was an eccentric Dissenting Minister, and has been accused of being controversial and belligerent.

Henry Grove was an English nonconformist minister, theologian, and dissenting tutor.

John Wiche (1718–1794) was an English Baptist minister.

James Yates F.R.S., F.L.S., F.G.S. was an English Unitarian minister and scholar, known as an antiquary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Church of the Messiah, Birmingham</span> Church in Birmingham, England

The Church of the Messiah, Birmingham was a Unitarian church on Church Street. The congregation continues, having moved to purpose-built premises at Five Ways in 1973. The impressive Victorian building was demolished in 1978.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Kentish (minister)</span>

John Kentish was an English Unitarian minister.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Kinghorn</span>

Joseph Kinghorn (1766–1832) was an English particular Baptist and a life-long minister of St. Mary's Baptist Church in Norwich.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Taunton Unitarian Chapel</span> Church in Somerset, England

Taunton Unitarian Chapel is on Mary Street, Taunton, Somerset, England. It was built in the early 18th century as a Baptist chapel, but later adopted Unitarianism. The exterior was extensively renovated in the 19th century in an Italianate style. The chapel has been designated as a Grade II* listed building.

John Edwards (1768–1808) was an English nonconformist minister and political radical. He is best known as the successor of Joseph Priestley at the New Meeting House, Birmingham.