Louis Blanc

Last updated
Louis Blanc
Louis Blanc b Carjat 1848.jpg
Born(1811-10-29)29 October 1811
Died6 December 1882(1882-12-06) (aged 71)
Residence Paris, France
Era 19th-century philosophy
Region Western philosophy
School Socialism
Main interests
Politics, history, economy
Notable ideas
Right to work, national Workshops

Louis Jean Joseph Charles Blanc ( /blɑːn/ ; French:  [blɑ̃] ; 29 October 1811 – 6 December 1882) was a French politician and historian. A socialist who favored reforms, he called for the creation of cooperatives in order to guarantee employment for the urban poor.

Socialism is a range of economic and social systems characterised by social ownership of the means of production and workers' self-management, as well as the political theories and movements associated with them. Social ownership can be public, collective or cooperative ownership, or citizen ownership of equity. There are many varieties of socialism and there is no single definition encapsulating all of them, with social ownership being the common element shared by its various forms.

A job guarantee (JG) is an economic policy proposal aimed at providing a sustainable solution to the dual problems of inflation and unemployment. Its aim is to create full employment and price stability, by having the state promise to hire unemployed workers as an employer of last resort (ELR).


Following the Revolution of 1848, Blanc became a member of the provisional government and began advocating for cooperatives which would be initially aided by the government but ultimately controlled by the workers themselves. Blanc's advocacy failed and caught between radical worker tendencies and the National Guard he was forced into exile. Blanc returned to France in 1870, shortly before the conclusion of the Franco-Prussian war and served as a member of the National Assembly. While he did not support the Paris Commune, Blanc successfully proposed amnesty to the Communards.

French Provisional Government of 1848

The Provisional government was a short-lived government formed on 24 February 1848 at the start of the French Second Republic, after the Cabinet of François-Pierre Guizot and the July Monarchy had been thrown out of power. It was succeeded by the Executive Commission of 1848.

National Guard (France) 1789–1872 military reserve and police branch of Frances military

The National Guard is a French military, gendarmerie, and police reserve force, active in its current form since 2016 but originally founded in 1789 after the French Revolution.

Paris Commune revolutionary city council of Paris 1871

The Paris Commune was a radical socialist and revolutionary government that ruled Paris from 18 March to 28 May 1871. The Franco-Prussian War had led to the capture of Emperor Napoleon III in September 1870, the collapse of the Second French Empire, and the beginning of the Third Republic. Because Paris was under siege for four months, the Third Republic moved its capital to Tours. A hotbed of working-class radicalism, Paris was primarily defended during this time by the often politicised and radical troops of the National Guard rather than regular Army troops. Paris surrendered to the Prussians on 28 January 1871, and in February Adolphe Thiers, the new chief executive of the French national government, signed an armistice with Prussia that disarmed the Army but not the National Guard.

Although Blanc's ideas of the workers' cooperatives were never realized, his political and social ideas greatly contributed to the development of socialism in France.


Early years

Blanc was born in Madrid. His father held the post of inspector-general of finance under Joseph Bonaparte. His younger brother was Charles Blanc, who later became an influential art critic. [2] Failing to receive aid from Pozzo di Borgo, his mother's uncle, Louis Blanc studied law in Paris, living in poverty, and became a contributor to various journals. In the Revue du progres, which he founded, he published in 1839 his study on L'Organisation du travail. The principles laid down in this famous essay form the key to Louis Blanc's whole political career. He attributes all the evils that afflict society to the pressure of competition, whereby the weaker are driven to the wall. He demanded the equalization of wages, and the merging of personal interests in the common good—"De chacun selon ses facultés, à chacun selon ses besoins", [3] which is often translated as "from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs." This was to be affected by the establishment of "social workshops", a sort of combined co-operative society and trade-union, where the workmen in each trade were to unite their efforts for their common benefit. In 1841 he published his Histoire de dix ans 1830-1840, an attack upon the monarchy of July. It ran through four editions in four years.

Madrid Capital of Spain

Madrid is the capital of Spain and the largest municipality in both the Community of Madrid and Spain as a whole. The city has almost 3.3 million inhabitants and a metropolitan area population of approximately 6.5 million. It is the third-largest city in the European Union (EU), smaller than only London and Berlin, and its monocentric metropolitan area is the third-largest in the EU, smaller only than those of London and Paris. The municipality covers 604.3 km2 (233.3 sq mi).

Joseph Bonaparte elder brother of Napoleon Bonaparte

Joseph-Napoléon Bonaparte, born Giuseppe di Buonaparte, was a French diplomat and nobleman, the older brother of Napoleon Bonaparte, who made him King of Naples and Sicily, and later King of Spain. After the fall of Napoleon, Joseph styled himself Comte de Survilliers.

Charles Blanc French art critic

Charles Blanc was a French art critic.

Revolution of 1848

Frontis from Blanc's Organisation du Travail, published in Paris in 1850 by Nouveau Monde Blanc-louis-1850.jpg
Frontis from Blanc's Organisation du Travail, published in Paris in 1850 by Nouveau Monde

In 1847, Blanc published the two first volumes of his Histoire de la Revolution Française. Its publication was interrupted by the Revolution of 1848, when he became a member of the provisional government. It was on his motion that, on 25 February, the government undertook "to guarantee the existence of the workmen by work"; and though his demand for the establishment of a ministry of labour was refused—as beyond the competence of a provisional government—he was appointed to preside over the government labour commission (Commission du Gouvernement pour les travailleurs) established at the Palais du Luxembourg to inquire into and report on the labour question.

The revolution of 1848 was the real chance for Louis Blanc's ideas to be implemented. His theory of using the established government to enact change was different from those of other socialist theorists of his time. Blanc believed that workers could control their own livelihoods, but knew that unless they were given help to get started the cooperative workshops would never work. To assist this process along Blanc lobbied for national funding of these workshops until the workers could assume control. To fund this ambitious project, Blanc saw a ready revenue source in the rail system. Under government control the railway system would provide the bulk of the funding needed for this and other projects Blanc saw in the future.

When the workshop program was ratified in the National Assembly, Blanc's chief rival Émile Thomas  [ fr ] was put in control of the project. The National Assembly was not ready for this type of social program and treated the workshops as a method of buying time until the assembly could gather enough support to stabilize themselves against another worker rebellion. Thomas's deliberate failure in organizing the workshops into a success only seemed to anger the public more. The people had been promised a job and a working environment in which the workers were in charge, from these government funded programs. What they had received was hand outs and government funded work parties to dig ditches and hard manual labor for meager wages or paid to remain idle. When the workshops were closed the workers rebelled again but were put down by force by the National Guard. The National Assembly was also able to blame Blanc for the failure of the workshops. His ideas were questioned and he lost much of the respect which had given him influence with the public.

National Workshops refer to areas of work provided for the unemployed by the French Second Republic after the Revolution of 1848. The political crisis which resulted in the abdication of Louis Philippe caused an industrial crisis adding to the general agricultural and commercial distress which had prevailed throughout 1847. It rendered the problem of unemployment in Paris very acute. The provisional government under the influence of one of its members, Louis Blanc passed a decree guaranteeing government-funded jobs. The following is an extract: "The provisional government of the French Republic undertakes to guarantee the existence of the workmen by work. It undertakes to guarantee work for every citizen."

National Assembly (France) lower house of the French Parliament under the Fifth Republic

The National Assembly is the lower house of the bicameral Parliament of France under the Fifth Republic, the upper house being the Senate. The National Assembly's legislators are known as députés.

Between the sans-culottes, who tried to force him to place himself at their head, and the National Guards, who mistreated him, he was nearly killed. Rescued with difficulty, he escaped with a false passport to Belgium, and then to London. He was condemned to deportation in absentia by a special tribunal at Bourges. Against trial and sentence he alike protested, developing his protest in a series of articles in the Nouveau Monde, a review published in Paris under his direction. These he afterwards collected and published as Pages de l'histoire de la révolution de 1848 (Brussels, 1850).


During his stay in Britain he made use of the unique collection of materials for the revolutionary period preserved at the British Museum to complete his Histoire de la Revolution Française 12 vols. (1847–1862). In 1858 he published a reply to Lord Normanby's A Year of Revolution in Paris (1858), which he developed later into his Histoire de la révolution de 1848 (2 vols., 1870–1880). He was also active in the masonic organisation, the Conseil Suprême de l'Ordre Maçonnique de Memphis. His membership in the London-based La Grand Loge des Philadelphes is unconfirmed.

Return to France

Blanc in his last years Louis Blanc mid career.jpg
Blanc in his last years

As far back as 1839, Louis Blanc had vehemently opposed the idea of a Napoleonic restoration, predicting that it would be "despotism without glory", "the Empire without the Emperor." He therefore remained in exile until the fall of the Second Empire in September 1870, after which he returned to Paris and served as a private in the National Guard. On 8 February 1871 he was elected a member of the National Assembly, in which he maintained that the Republic was "the necessary form of national sovereignty", and voted for the continuation of the war; yet, though a leftist, he did not sympathize with the Paris Commune, and exerted his influence in vain on the side of moderation. In 1878 he advocated the abolition of the presidency and the Senate. In January 1879 he introduced into the chamber a proposal for the amnesty of the Communards, which was carried. This was his last important act. His declining years were darkened by ill-health and by the death, in 1876, of his wife Christina Groh, whom he had married in 1865. He died at Cannes, and on 12 December received a state funeral in Père Lachaise Cemetery.


Blanc possessed a picturesque and vivid style, and considerable power of research; but the fervour with which he expressed his convictions, while placing him in the first rank of orators, tended to turn his historical writings into political pamphlets. His political and social ideas have had a great influence on the development of socialism in France. His Discours politiques (1847–1881) was published in 1882. his most important works, besides those already mentioned, are Lettres sur l'Angleterre (1866–1867), Dix années de l'Histoire de l'Angleterre (1879–1881), and Questions d'aujourd'hui et de demain (1873–1884).

The Paris Metro Station Louis Blanc is named after him.


Blanc is sometime cited as the first person to use the word capitalism in something like its modern form. While he did not mean the economic system described by Karl Marx in Das Kapital , Blanc sowed the seeds of that usage, coining the word to mean the holding of capital away from others:


Reformist socialism

Blanc was unusual in advocating for socialism without revolution first. [5]

Right to work

Blanc invented the right to work with his Le Droit au Travail. [6]


Blanc resisted what he perceived as the atheism implicit in Hegel, claiming that it corresponded to anarchism in politics and was not an adequate basis for democracy. [7] Engels claimed that "Parisiann reformers of the Louis Blanc trend" could only imagine atheists as monsters. [8]

Instead, Blanc claimed that religion was foundational for revolution to take place, in keeping with the romantic tradition. [9] He regarded liberalism and Protestantism as part of the same historical and ideological movement [10] and accordingly considered the French Revolution of 1789 as a political outgrowth of the individualistic rejection of authority inherent in Protestantism and heretical movements. [11] [12] Blanc thought the best of the revolution was the Jacobin dictatorship in the communitarian spirit of Catholicism. [13] Blanc himself sought to combine Catholicism and Protestantism in order to synthesize the values of authority, community, and individualism that he both affirmed as necessary for community. [11] He was unusual in combining Catholicism and socialism. [14]

Along with Etienne Cabet, Blanc advocated for what he understood as true Christianity while simultaneously critiquing the religion of Catholic clergy. [9] He was hopeful about the religious innovation taking place in early revolutionary france. [14] His understanding of God was shaped by romanticism and was similar to Rousseau, Phillipe Buchez and Respail. [15]


At the turn of 1830–1840's made in France with the ideas of social reform, Blanc, who had to then play a significant role in the history of the 1848 revolution in the 1840s, he was one of the prominent representatives of the democratic opposition against leaders of French socialism. Blanc received secondary education in one of the provincial cities of France, he was very young made on a literary career with two poems in verse, and then with the political articles. In 1834 he moved to Paris and soon began working here in the newspaper "Common Sense." Articles Louis Blanc drew attention to themselves, and Armand Carrel invited him to collaborate in «Le National» his newspaper. Somewhat later and Godefrua Cavaignac (Cavaignac), one of the leaders of the Republican Party, invited him to write in the "reform" to publish them. In 1839, a young publicist could have set up their own body, to which he gave the name of the "Review of the political, social and literary progress” (“La revue du progrès politique, social et littéraire”).

All the newspapers, which previously was Louis Blanc, belonged to a democratic direction, but dominant in their view was mainly political, although already in them Louis Blanc concerned purely social relations. On the contrary, a new newspaper from the very beginning made an organ of social reform. It appeared first and most important journalistic work of Louis Blanc's "Organization of Labor" (1839), immediately proposed him forward as a harbinger of a new social order. Subsequently, this small work is not reprinted, being subject to alterations. "Organization of labor" was a huge success among the workers. Shortly after Louis Blanc published another work of large dimensions, which made a strong impression on the bourgeoisie. This was the famous "History of Ten Years" (1830 - 1840), the first half of the reign of Louis Philippe. In this work, Louis Blanc was able to take advantage of very many materials remain until it completely unknown to the public.

Characteristically, many Louis Blanc was reportedly hated the July monarchy Legitimists, accept it welcome in their salons. The July government has been in this book is very harsh, and in general a very fair criticism. In a very short time, the book ran through several editions.

This success led Blanc to take up a major historical work already on the history of the Great French Revolution. The first volume of this story appeared already in 1846, but her finish Louis Blanc had been in exile after the December 1851 coup. Taking up of historical works, Louis Blanc was forced to cease publication of its own body, but he continued to participate in Cavaignac newspaper. Under his influence, the newspaper adopted gradually definitely socialist character. Incidentally, at the beginning of 1848, when it was very much the fermentation, to prepare the February revolution, "reform" has published its political program, which, in fact, repeated the main provisions of the "Labor Organization".

Already in 1846, he was offered a place in the Chamber of Deputies, but then he turned away from candidacy. When the popularity which he enjoyed in the working class, while the outstanding position which he occupied in the Republican Party, he certainly could not stay in the shade when flushed February revolution. It can be stated that his "History of ten years", he severely damaged the July monarchy, and his other writings, to a certain extent determined the general nature and direction of the revolution, reviving Jacobin tradition and giving the social movement of a specific program. These are the main ideas of Louis Blanc. Everyone has the right to work and to ensure that this right was exercised in reality, it is necessary to entrust the duty of society to organize work in accordance with this requirement. In considering this issue, and all of the content is "labor organizations" of Louis Blanc. From the fact the importance that belonged to the "right to work" in the revolution of 1848, it is worthwhile concluding about the widespread and deeply influenced by the ideas of Louis Blanc in the French society of the forties. He created a plan of social reform was understandable, seemed simple and easy to implement. The state had to form a pool of money through the big national loan with which to major industries were based so-called “social workshops” (ateliers sociaux). To work in these workshops were to be allowed to work, standing in a certain moral level, and all of them for their work would receive exactly the same fee. At first, the internal regulations of such workshops would be established by the Government. It is appointed to and heads for work occurring in them, but after the first year should be the workers themselves to grant the right to choose their leaders.

The main task of these institutions, on the proposal of Louis Blanc, was to strike a blow to all private industry. As a principle, an enemy of free competition, he thought to use this competition in order to make it in the future completely impossible. Private industry would have gradually disappeared, and the entire industry would have then strictly social organization. Public workshops same specialty could get along with each other quite peacefully. Old competition would now replace the coincidence of effort. In the end, it was to and solidarity between the different branches of industry. An important tool for carrying out its plan in practice, Louis Blanc seen in the compulsory and gratuitous public education: it would have for its aim to educate the younger generation in the ideas, feelings and inclinations, which should require a new social system of people. In general, the state had by this theory not only to create a new order of things, but also to guide social activities. Louis Blanc himself called the state the “supreme regulator of production” and said that his intervention is needed everywhere, where only the need to “maintain a balance between the rights and protect the interests”. On the same state it also imposes a duty “to put all citizens in equal conditions of moral, intellectual and physical development”. Of course, it stipulated Louis Blanc, where the power on one side and the people on the other, being organized democratically. The state is only the people leading their own affairs through their representatives, the state may not be of interest other than the interest of the people. Such a state, adds Louis Blanc, cannot be the master: it can only be a servant and protector of inexperienced, weak, miserable. mental and physical development. However, the state could fulfill its purpose, Louis Blanc, saw fit to give him greater power to restore in its favor the authority principle.

From this point of view, he even attacked in the "History of a decade" for liberals restoration era because they weaken the power, and expressed sympathy. That, on the contrary, worked in favor of the strengthening of the public authority. Nevertheless, Louis Blanc wanted to retain the minority a certain freedom from the tyranny of the majority. He did not want to bring their socialism to the extreme, and in his works, there are direct statements against communism. The preaching of absolute equality, he openly called nonsense. According to him, the distribution of wealth in society must be done even for the formula which proclaimed Saint-Simonianism ("To each according to his ability, to each capacity according to its works"). "To each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" - this is the principle of Louis Blanc expressed them, in addition, and in the following formula: "debt commensurate with abilities and powers, the right to commensurate with the needs." This, as he puts it, "a just equality" already made in family life: each member of the family works, and their work contributes to the overall welfare of the extent of its powers, but when all sit at the table, the one who is more hungry and eat more without encountering any obstacles on the part of others. All requirements of the socialist Louis Blanc came to the fact that the society has been organized as a family.

See also

Related Research Articles

Bourbon Restoration Period of French history, 1814-1830

The Bourbon Restoration was the period of French history following the first fall of Napoleon in 1814, and his final defeat in the Hundred Days in 1815, until the July Revolution of 1830. The brothers of the executed Louis XVI came to power and reigned in highly conservative fashion. Exiled supporters of the monarchy returned to France. They were nonetheless unable to reverse most of the changes made by the French Revolution and Napoleon. At the Congress of Vienna they were treated respectfully, but had to give up nearly all the territorial gains made since 1789.

Benjamin Constant Swiss-born French politician, writer on politics and religion

Henri-Benjamin Constant de Rebecque, or simply Benjamin Constant, was a Swiss-French political activist and writer on politics and religion. He was the author of a partly biographical psychological novel, Adolphe. He was a fervent classical liberal of the early 19th century, who influenced the Trienio Liberal movement in Spain, the Liberal Revolution of 1820 in Portugal, the Greek War of Independence, the November Uprising in Poland, the Belgian Revolution, and liberalism in Brazil and Mexico.

Hippolyte Taine French critic and historian

Hippolyte Adolphe Taine was a French critic and historian. He was the chief theoretical influence of French naturalism, a major proponent of sociological positivism and one of the first practitioners of historicist criticism. Literary historicism as a critical movement has been said to originate with him. Taine is also remembered for his attempts to provide a scientific account of literature.

Louis-Eugène Cavaignac French general and politician

Louis-Eugène Cavaignac was a French general who put down a massive rebellion in Paris in 1848, known as the June Days Uprising. This was a 4-day riot against the Provisional Government, in which Cavaignac was the newly appointed Minister of War, but soon had to be granted dictatorial powers in order to suppress the revolt. By adopting ruthless methods, he achieved his objective, though some have claimed that he spent too long preparing for the operation, allowing the mob to strengthen their defences. He received the thanks of parliament, but failed to be elected president, losing heavily to Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte.

French Second Republic government of France between 1848-1852

The French Second Republic was a short-lived republican government of France under President Louis-Napoléon Bonaparte. It lasted from the 1848 Revolution to the 1851 coup by which the president made himself Emperor Napoleon III and initiated the Second Empire. It officially adopted the motto of the First Republic, Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité. The Second Republic witnessed the tension between the "Social and Democratic Republic" and a Radical form of republicanism, which exploded during the June Days uprising of 1848.

Historiography of the French Revolution Wikimedia list article

The historiography of the French Revolution stretches back over two hundred years, as commentators and historians have sought to answer questions regarding the origins of the Revolution, and its meaning and effects. By the year 2000, many historians were saying that the field of the French Revolution was in intellectual disarray. The old model or paradigm focusing on class conflict has been challenged but no new explanatory model had gained widespread support. Nevertheless, there persists a very widespread agreement to the effect that the French Revolution was the watershed between the premodern and modern eras of Western history.

September Massacres Wave of killings in France in 2–7 Sept. 1792 during the French Revolution, in which half the prison population of Paris (that is, approx. 1200–1400 people) were summarily executed

The September Massacres were a number of killings in Paris and other cities that occurred from 2–4 September 1792 during the French Revolution. Not an outburst of passion, but coldly and carefully organized.

The Enraged Ones were a small number of firebrands known for defending the lower class and expressing the demands of the radical sans-culottes during the French Revolution. They played an active role in the 31 May 31 – 2 June 1793 Paris uprisings that forced the expulsion of the Girondins from the National Convention, allowing the Montagnards to assume full control.

Cult of Reason religion

The Cult of Reason was France's first established state-sponsored atheistic religion, intended as a replacement for Roman Catholicism during the French Revolution. After holding sway for barely a year, in 1794 it was officially replaced by the rival Cult of the Supreme Being, promoted by Robespierre. Both cults were officially banned in 1801 by Napoleon Bonaparte with his Law on Cults of 18 Germinal, Year X.

François Furet was a French historian and president of the Saint-Simon Foundation, best known for his books on the French Revolution.

Philippe Buchez French historian, sociologist, and politician

Philippe-Joseph-Benjamin Buchez (1796–1865), more commonly called Philippe Buchez, was a French historian, sociologist, and politician. He was the founder of the newspaper L'Atelier, and he served briefly, in 1848, as the president of the Constituent National Assembly, which was then meeting at the Palais Bourbon in Paris.

Alexandre Martin French politician

Alexandre Martin, nicknamed Albert l'Ouvrier, was a French socialist statesman of the French Second Republic. He was the first member of the industrial working class to be in French government.

June Days uprising June 1848 revolt in France

The June Days uprising was an uprising staged by French workers from 23 to 26 June 1848. It was in response to plans to close the National Workshops, created by the Second Republic in order to provide work and a source of income for the unemployed, albeit with pay just enough to survive. The National Guard, led by General Louis Eugène Cavaignac, was called out to quell the rebellion. Things did not go peacefully and over 10,000 people were either killed or injured, while 4,000 insurgents were deported to Algeria. This marked the end of the hopes of a "Democratic and Social Republic" and the victory of the liberals over the Radical Republicans.

French Executive Commission (1848)

The Executive Commission of 1848 was a short-lived government during the French Second Republic, chaired by François Arago, that exercised executive power from 9 May 1848 to 24 June 1848. It succeeded the Provisional Government of 1848 and was in turn replaced by the Cabinet of General Cavaignac. The members of the Commission acted as joint head of state.

François-Nicolas Vincent French revolutionary

François-Nicolas Vincent was the Secretary General of the War Ministry in the First French Republic, and a significant figure in the French Revolution. A member of the Cordelier Club, he is best known as a radical sans-culottes leader and prominent member of the Hébertist faction.

French Revolution of 1848 End of the reign of King Louis Philippe and start of the Second Republic

The 1848 Revolution in France, sometimes known as the February Revolution, was one of a wave of revolutions in 1848 in Europe. In France the revolutionary events ended the July Monarchy (1830–1848) and led to the creation of the French Second Republic.

Charles Constantin Pecqueur was a French economist, socialist theoretician and politician. He participated in the Revolution of 1848 and influenced Karl Marx.

Pierre-Joseph Proudhon French politician, mutualist philosopher, economist, and socialist

Pierre-Joseph Proudhon was a French politician and the founder of mutualist philosophy. He was the first person to declare himself an anarchist, using that term and is widely regarded as one of the ideology's most influential theorists. Proudhon is even considered by many to be the "father of anarchism". He became a member of the French Parliament after the Revolution of 1848, whereafter he referred to himself as a federalist.

Ferdinand Flocon French politician and journalist

Ferdinand Flocon was a French journalist and politician who was one of the founding members of the Provisional Government at the start of the French Second Republic in 1848. He was Minister of Agriculture and Commerce for the Executive Commission of 1848. He opposed Louis Napoleon and was forced into exile in the Second French Empire (1852–1870).

Moderate Republicans (France) parliamentary group in the French Second Republic

The Moderate Republicans were a large political group active from the birth of the French Second Republic (1848) to the collapse of the Second French Empire (1870).


  1. Finn, Margot C. (2003). After Chartism: Class and Nation in English Radical Politics 1848-1874. Cambridge University Press. p. 176.
  2. Varouxakis, Georgios (2004). "Blanc, (Jean Joseph) Louis (1811–1882), political thinker and exile". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Retrieved 15 January 2014.
  3. Louis Blanc, Plus de Girondins, 1851, p. 92.
  4. Conceptualizing Capitalism: Institutions, Evolution, Future
  5. Herzog et al. 1884, p. 2205.
  6. Day 1914, p. 85.
  7. Moggach 2011, p. 319.
  8. Marx & al 2001, p. 63.
  9. 1 2 Joskowicz 2013, p. 46.
  10. Stirner, Byington & Martin 2012, p. 106.
  11. 1 2 Furet & Ozouf 1989, p. 902.
  12. Malia & Emmons 2006, p. 59.
  13. Comay 2011, p. 187.
  14. 1 2 Furet & Ozouf 1989, p. 700.
  15. Eisenstein 1959, p. 136.



Further reading