National War Memorial (Canada)

Last updated

National War Memorial
Monument commémoratif de guerre
The Response (La Réponse)
War Memorial Guards Ottawa.jpg
Two Ceremonial Guard sentries at the National War Memorial in Ottawa
Coordinates 45°25′26.53″N75°41′43.79″W / 45.4240361°N 75.6954972°W / 45.4240361; -75.6954972
Location Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Designer Vernon March
TypeWar memorial
MaterialGranite, bronze
Length15.90 metres (52 ft 2 in)
Width8.00 metres (26 ft 6 in)
Height21.34 metres (70 ft)
Opening date21 May 1939
Dedicated toCanadian dead of all wars

The National War Memorial (titled The Response) is a tall, granite memorial arch with accreted bronze sculptures in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, designed by Vernon March and first dedicated by King George VI in 1939. Originally built to commemorate the Canadians who died in the First World War, it was in 1982 rededicated to also include those killed in the Second World War and Korean War and again in 2014 to add the dead from the Second Boer War and War in Afghanistan, as well as all Canadians killed in all conflicts past and future. It now serves as the pre-eminent war memorial [1] of 76 cenotaphs in Canada. [2] In 2000, the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier was added in front of the memorial and symbolizes the sacrifices made by all Canadians who have died or may yet die for their country.

Ottawa Federal capital city in Ontario, Canada

Ottawa is the capital city of Canada. It stands on the south bank of the Ottawa River in the eastern portion of southern Ontario. Ottawa borders Gatineau, Quebec; the two form the core of the Ottawa–Gatineau census metropolitan area (CMA) and the National Capital Region (NCR). As of 2016, Ottawa had a city population of 934,243 and a metropolitan population of 1,323,783 making it the fourth-largest city and the fifth-largest CMA in Canada.

Ontario Province of Canada

Ontario is one of the 13 provinces and territories of Canada and is located in east-central Canada. It is Canada's most populous province accounting for 38.3 percent of the country's population, and is the second-largest province in total area. Ontario is fourth-largest jurisdiction in total area when the territories of the Northwest Territories and Nunavut are included. It is home to the nation's capital city, Ottawa, and the nation's most populous city, Toronto, which is also Ontario's provincial capital.

Vernon March British artist

Vernon March (1891–1930) was an English sculptor, renowned for major monuments such as the National War Memorial of Canada in Ottawa, Ontario, the Samuel de Champlain Monument in Orillia, Ontario, and the Cape Town Cenotaph, South Africa. Without the benefit of a formal education in the arts, he was the youngest exhibitor at The Exhibition of the Royal Academy of Arts.

Contents

Monument and context

The National War Memorial is the focal point of Confederation Square in Canada's capital city, Ottawa, Ontario. This locates it between Parliament Hill to the west and the Château Laurier hotel to the east. There are several other commemorative buildings and monuments nearby, including the Peace Tower (and the Memorial Chamber) at the parliament buildings, the National Aboriginal Veterans Monument, the Animals in War Memorial, a Boer War memorial, the Peacekeeping Monument, [3] the Valiants Memorial, and the War of 1812 Monument.

Confederation Square square in Ottawa, Canada

Confederation Square is an urban square in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, and is considered the second most important ceremonial centre in Canada's capital city, after Parliament Hill. Roughly triangular in area, with Canada's National War Memorial at its centre and the Valiants Memorial at its periphery, the square is bounded by Wellington Street to the north and branches of Elgin Street to the east and west.

Parliament Hill site of the Canadian Parliament buildings, in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Parliament Hill, colloquially known as The Hill, is an area of Crown land on the southern banks of the Ottawa River in downtown Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Its Gothic revival suite of buildings is the home of the Parliament of Canada and has architectural elements of national symbolic importance. Parliament Hill attracts approximately 3 million visitors each year. Law enforcement on Parliament Hill and in the parliamentary precinct is the responsibility of the Parliamentary Protective Service (PPS).

Château Laurier

The Fairmont Château Laurier is a 660,000-square-foot hotel with 429 guest rooms in downtown Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, located near the intersection of Rideau Street and Sussex Drive and designed in a French Gothic Revival Châteauesque style to complement the adjacent Parliament buildings. The hotel is above the Rideau Canal locks and overlooks the Ottawa River. The main dining room overlooks Major's Hill Park. The reception rooms include the Wedgewood-blue Adam Room; the Laurier Room defined by Roman columns; the Empire-style ballroom and the Drawing Room featuring cream and gold plaster ornament. The hotel was designated a national historic site in 1980.

The memorial, from grade to the tip of the surmounting statues' wings, is approximately 21.34 m (70 ft), with the arch itself 3.05 m (10 ft) wide, 2.44 m (8 ft) deep, and 8.03 m (26 ft 4 in) high. The lowest step of the pedestal is 15.9 m (52 ft 2 in) by 8.08 m (26 ft 6 in). 503 tonnes of rose-grey Canadian granite from the Dumas Quarry at Rivière-à-Pierre, Quebec, [4] and 32 tonnes of bronze were used, all of which rests on a block of reinforced concrete based on steel columns set into bedrock. [4]

Rivière-à-Pierre, Quebec Municipality in Quebec, Canada

Rivière-à-Pierre is a municipality of the Portneuf Regional County Municipality, in the administrative region of the Capitale-Nationale. This territory of Laurentian Mountains is part of the Quebec has more than 200 lakes. The village of Rivière-à-Pierre was developed on each side of the river that bears its name. Rivière-à-Pierre is the second largest municipality in the Portneuf RCM in terms of area.

Bedrock Lithified rock under the regolith

In geology, bedrock is the lithified rock that lies under a loose softer material called regolith within the surface of the crust of the Earth or other terrestrial planets.

Two 5.33-metre-high (17.5 ft) allegories of peace and freedom stand at the apex of the arch, their proximity to each other representing the inseparability of the two concepts, though, the figure bearing a torch alludes in Roman mythology to Demeter and the winged figure with a laurel depicts Nike, the Greek goddesses of agriculture and victory, respectively. [5] Below are the depictions of 22 Canadian servicemen from all branches of the forces and other groups engaged in the First World War. At front, to the left, a Lewis gunner, to the right, a kilted infantryman with a Vickers machine gun. Following these are a pilot in full gear and an air mechanic of the Royal Canadian Air Force, as well as a sailor in the Royal Canadian Navy from HMCS Stadacona. Two mounted figures—a member of the Canadian Cavalry Brigade and a dispatch rider—are emerging from the arch, side by side, followed by two infantry riflemen pressing through the arch and behind them are the men and women of the support services, including two nurses from the Militia Army Medical Corps, a stretcher bearer, and one member each of the Royal Canadian Engineers and the Canadian Forestry Corps. Further, there is one member each of the Canadian Army Service Corps, the Canadian Signals Corps, the Corps of Canadian Railway troops, the Royal Regiment of Canadian Artillery, and the Motor Machine Gun Corps. There are three additional infantrymen; all six carry among them respirators and other items of the "basic load" carried by every member of the infantry. [6] [7]

Allegory Literary device

As a literary device, an allegory is a metaphor in which a character, place or event is used to deliver a broader message about real-world issues and occurrences. Allegory has occurred widely throughout history in all forms of art, largely because it can readily illustrate or convey complex ideas and concepts in ways that are comprehensible or striking to its viewers, readers, or listeners.

Demeter Greek goddess of the harvest, grains, and agriculture

In ancient Greek religion and mythology, Demeter is the goddess of the grain, agriculture, harvest, growth, and nourishment, who presided over grains and the fertility of the earth. Her cult titles include Sito (Σιτώ), "she of the Grain", as the giver of food or grain, and Thesmophoros, "Law-Bringer", as a mark of the civilized existence of agricultural society.

Nike (mythology) goddess of victory in Greek mythology

In ancient Greek religion, Nike was a goddess who personified victory. Her Roman equivalent was Victoria.

The figures are moving towards the call of duty atop a pedestal. To avoid foreshortening from a pedestrian viewpoint, the group of figures is placed at a specific height above street level; each body is approximately 2.4 metres (7.9 ft) high, or one third larger than life size. [8] The postures are animated and strained, not in parade form, and the expressions "convey pride, longing, defiance, a strong sense of purpose, vacancy, camaraderie and perhaps a touch of dejection, but mostly firm resolve." [8] All are in historically correct and distinctly Canadian uniforms, [9] and they were deliberately rendered by the sculpture's artist, Vernon March, so as to not associate any with a particular region of the country nor any ethnicity or language, thus highlighting unity. [9]

Canadian Tomb of the Unknown Soldier war memorial in Ottawa, Canada

The Canadian Tomb of the Unknown Soldier is located before the National War Memorial in Confederation Square, Ottawa, Ontario. The culmination of a project begun by the Royal Canadian Legion, the tomb was added to the war memorial in 2000 and holds the remains of an unidentified Canadian soldier who died in France during World War I. The soldier was selected from a cemetery in the vicinity of Vimy Ridge, the site of a famous Canadian battle.

Of the memorial, March wrote "[I intend] to perpetuate in this bronze group the people of Canada who went Overseas to the Great War, and to represent them, as we of today saw them, as a record for future generations..." [11] The allegorical representations of peace and freedom were meant to be seen "alighting on the world with the blessings of Victory, Peace and Liberty in the footsteps of the people's heroism and self-sacrifice who are passing through the archway below." [12] The persons emerging through the arch have also been interpreted as representing Canada's "rite of passage" or "coming of age", [5] its birth as a proper nation during the First World War, reflected in its attainment of a place in the negotiations of the Treaty of Versailles at the conflict's end. Similarly, the figures of Peace and Freedom "speak both to Canada's participation in the struggle to achieve lasting stability and democratic values that resulted in the creation of the League of Nations, and to the hope that in Canada itself peace and freedom may continue to triumph over the forces of instability and the tyrannies of ethnicity." [8] Laura Brandon, Historian, Art & War at the National War Museum in Ottawa, opined that the agricultural connotations of the torch-bearing figure may have been intended by March to relate to the dominance of agriculture in Canada at the time of the monument's design. It may also refer to the line in the war poem In Flanders Fields , penned by John McCrae while in the battlefields of the First World War: "The torch; be yours to hold it high/If ye break faith with us who die." [5]

On the north and south faces of the statuary base are the dates 1914–1918 (the First World War) above the words Service to Canada/Au service du Canada, [13] which are intended to include all Canadians who served in all armed conflicts, past, present, and future. The dates 1939–1945 (the Second World War) and 1950–1953 (the Korean War) are on the east and west flanks of the base, while the years 1899–1902 (the Second Boer War) and 2001–2014 (the War in Afghanistan) are on the east and west arch pier footings, respectively. [14] The Tomb of the Unknown Soldier rests in the podium surface immediately in front of and on axis with the war memorial.

Modern usage

The memorial serves as the focal point of Remembrance Day ceremonies in Ottawa Canadian National War Memorial on Remembrance Day.jpg
The memorial serves as the focal point of Remembrance Day ceremonies in Ottawa

Since 1940, [15] the National War Memorial is the site of the national Remembrance Day ceremony, organised every year by the Royal Canadian Legion for 11 November. Along with Canadian war veterans, the ceremony is attended by the governor general, sometimes members of the Canadian Royal Family, the prime minister, the Silver Cross Mother, representatives of the Canadian Armed Forces and Royal Canadian Mounted Police, members of the diplomatic corps, and youth representatives. [16] Some of these groups place wreaths at the foot of the war memorial. The event is attended by between 25,000 and 45,000 people and is nationally televised. [17]

Before each Remembrance Day ceremony, Public Works and Government Services Canada (PWGSC) repairs and levels stones in the area of the war memorial, fills joints, waxes the bronzes, and applies a protective coating to the lettering on the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. Plywood is placed over surrounding flower beds and approximately 6,000 metres of cable is run to connect sound systems and 12 television cameras. Any mementos or pictures attendees leave at the memorial following the ceremony are given to the Canadian War Museum for review and possible storage, while any money left is donated to The Perley & Rideau Veterans' Health Centre. [17]

Whenever the monarch or another member of the Royal Family is in Ottawa, they will, regardless of the date, lay a wreath at the monument. [18] Visiting foreign dignitaries will also sometimes lay a wreath at the monument; prominent figures who have done so include US President John F. Kennedy in 1961, [19] Soviet Union leader Mikhail Gorbachev in 1990, [20] US Secretary of State John Kerry, and French President François Hollande in 2014.

The Department of Canadian Heritage and the Department of Veterans Affairs also fund summer students at the site, hired to provide site and historical information. [21]

History

Conception and debate

The subject of a memorial to commemorate those killed in the First World War was raised even before the conflict had ended; Prime Minister Robert Borden said in 1915 "[i]t is my desire and intention that some splendid monument shall be erected in this country, perhaps in the capital of the Dominion, which will commemorate the men who responded so splendidly to the call of duty." [22] There was opposition to the idea, mostly to its cost, especially as the argument continued through the Great Depression. The Lord Beaverbrook initiated, in partnership with the government, the Canadian War Memorial Fund (CWMF) in April 1918 with the purpose of "perpetuating the memory of what Canada has accomplished in this war" [23] through paintings, photographs, and the erection of memorials. An early proposal in 1919 was a memorial hall in Ottawa, to act as a social centre for between 2,000 and 4,000 people as well as a monument to the Canadians who served in the Great War. It did not grow past the concept stage, but, an idea from the CWMF for a memorial building did progress to the detail design phase. It would have resembled the Pantheon in Rome and housed the art in the CWMF's collection, while acting "as a great war memorial in itself." [24] [25] Immediately after the war's end, however, focus shifted to the burial of the dead: the design of markers and headstones. [8]

Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King in 1922 King1922.jpg
Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King in 1922

To meet a growing call across Canada for a memorial to commemorate those who died in the First World War, the Cabinet of Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King suggested in 1921 that a national memorial be built in Canada. [8] The Ottawa Citizen on 19 December 1922 reported that the government was going to announce a plan to erect just such a monument and, [26] in parliament on the last day of the session, the Cabinet requested appropriation for a war memorial to be built in Ottawa. [27] A site in the Gatineau Hills was originally considered but it was determined the best option was the redevelopment and expansion of downtown Ottawa's Connaught Place into a plaza for the memorial, [3] giving it the parliament buildings—the seat of Canadian democracy—as a backdrop. [8] This, Mackenzie King later said, put it in the most visible spot in the city, akin to The Cenotaph and Nelson's Column in London, England. [28]

In May 1923, the Minister of Public Works James Horace King asked the legislature to approve $10,000 for the memorial. [29] However, with the minister unable to satisfactorily answer members' questions on what the money would be used for and the Prime Minister absent, it was determined to leave the matter for another time. Subsequently, the issue was again raised on 11 May 1923, when King stated "[i]n every country in the world the spirit of the nation has found some expression in regard to great events in the form of permanent monuments if the occasions have been sufficiently worthy of such recognition from the national point of view. The government felt that a monument should be erected in the capital of Canada expressive of the feelings of the Canadian people as a whole to the memory of those who had participated in the Great War and had lost their lives in the service of humanity." [30] In response to a statement by Murray MacLaren that the central column of Confederation Hall (the main entrance) of the new Centre Block already had an inscription noting the service of Canadians who had fought overseas, Mackenzie King said the inscription made reference to many other events in Canadian history and, as such, was never meant to act as a national war memorial; he elaborated: "there is, as of yet, no monument of a national character in the capital of the Dominion" and what the Cabinet proposed was "intended to be a national monument in the national capital." [30]

In further debate, it was said the project should strive for "something loftier than a monument in stone" [31] and not reflexively "follow precedent, to follow ancient countries." [32] Generally, the opposition was in favour of the idea, but criticised the projected costs. Mackenzie King responded: "When a nation loses what is signified by its art it loses its own spirit, and when it loses the remembrance of the sacrifices and heroism by which it has gained the liberty it enjoys, it loses all the vision that makes a people great." [6] Indeed, the Prime Minister managed to force Members of Parliament who critiqued the idea of spending money on a memorial to defend their patriotism and gratitude for those who had died or been wounded in the war. Parliament approved $10,000 to begin the project. [33]

Design and construction

Over two years, the parameters for a competition were created by a team consisting of, among others, the Deputy Minister of Public Works, J. B. Hunter, who had experience with the process of creating numerous memorials in Canada; Eric Brown, former Director of the National Gallery of Canada and a member of the Canadian War Artists Advisory Committee; and Colonel H. C. Osborne, who acted as Honorary Secretary of the Canadian Battlefields Memorials Commission. [34] On 12 February 1925, design proposals were sought, with a budget for the monument set at $100,000. [6] Entrants were limited to residents of the British Empire who were British subjects or who were citizens of allied nations. The competition regulations outlined the monument was intended to not be simply a tribute to those who has contributed to Canada's effort in the First World War, but also an expression of the nation's character. [35] It was to evoke "the spirit of heroism, the spirit of self-sacrifice, the spirit of all that is noble and great that was exemplified in the lives of those sacrificed in the Great War, and the services rendered by the men and women who went overseas." [4] The competition brief explained "[w]hile the spirit of victory is essential it should be expressed so as to not only immortalize Canada's defenders, but convey a feeling of gratitude that out of this great conflict a new hope has sprung for future prosperity under peaceful conditions." [36] Absent from the document was reference to the Empire, focusing only on Canada and its efforts. This illustrated the desire for the war memorial to be a marker of Canada's attainment of nationhood. [37]

One hundred and twenty-seven entries were submitted—66 from Canada, 24 from England, 21 from France, seven from the United States, five from Belgium, two from Italy, one from Scotland, and one from Trinidad. [11] —of which seven were asked to provide scale models for final judging. [4] Tasked with judging the proposals was the Board of Assessors, composed of three people drawn from Canada's architectural and artistic fields: Henry Sproatt was chosen by the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada; Herman A. MacNeil by the Royal Canadian Academy of Arts; and, by the Cabinet, Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the National Gallery of Canada F.J. Shepherd. [38] From among seven finalists, the winner, announced on 18 January 1926, [11] [39] was Vernon March from Farnborough, United Kingdom. His theme was the response of Canada to war, signified by the uniformed figures, in the then correct order of precedence, [6] passing through the arch, but with a deliberate aim to avoid the glorification of armed conflict. [4] March wrote in his anonymous submission that the figures' expressions would not show any combative attitude. Rather, they would "express movement and the eagerness and enthusiasm of the people" to respond to the call. [40]

Construction of the National War Memorial takes place at far right, 31 August 1938 Improvements to Confederation and widening of bridge Connaught Place Ottawa.jpg
Construction of the National War Memorial takes place at far right, 31 August 1938
The sculptures on display in Hyde Park, London Canadian National War Memorial on display in Hyde Park.jpg
The sculptures on display in Hyde Park, London

Work on the memorial began in 1926 under the auspices of the Dominion's Department of Public Works. March was assisted by his six brothers and his sister, all of whom completed the work after March's death in 1930. [41] His design was, over the ensuing years, revised and adjusted: the number of figures and certain dimensions increased and, accordingly, so did the estimated cost, by $85,000. [42] This gave fuel to the parliamentary opposition, who argued the money could be better spent aiding veterans. Progressive Party Member of Parliament (MP) J. S. Woodsworth asserted in 1931: "[i]f there is a contract…we must go through with it... but with poor unemployed soldiers in the country, I do not think we shall need many monuments for a while." [43]

Even through the time R. B. Bennett served as prime minister (1930 to 1935), the officials overseeing the war memorial project continued to adhere to the design principles set out by Mackenzie King and the other competition directors, demonstrating a bipartisan support for the memorial. [44] As the accuracy of the uniforms and equipment—at March's request, down to details such as buttons and straps [45] —was directed by Canadian officials, [6] the sculptures were first produced in clay, from which moulds were made and the bronze was then cast in the Marchs' foundry. This work was finished in July 1932 and the bronzes were, with the permission of King George V, [46] put on display in Hyde Park, London, within a mock-up of the granite arch and plinth. It was then that more than one member of the public pointed out that the archway was too narrow for the artillery carriage to pass through. This led the Marchs to make the arch three feet wider and six feet taller and enlarge the size of the plinth the figures would be mounted on. Those moves, though, created gaps on either side of the crowd of bronze statues, which Sydney March felt negatively impacted the overall appearance of the monument. His proposed solution was to add another three figures to the existing 19. [47] This was approved, the bronze figures were cast, [48] and the entire collection was put in storage at the Marchs' foundry as argument continued in Ottawa over the monument's location.

Disapproval or blatant rejection of the Connaught Place site was expressed by the Federal District Commission (predecessor of the National Capital Commission), Mayor J. E. Stanley Lewis, social commentators, journalists, and members of the public. [49] Some groups demanded the war memorial be central on Parliament Hill, others said a spot overlooking the Ottawa River, west of parliament was more appropriate. [50] Even the French architect Jacques Gréber, whom Mackenzie King (once again prime minister) had spoken to about the beautification of downtown Ottawa and was thought to be a supporter of the idea to put the war memorial in Connaught Place, penned a report on the redevelopment of Ottawa in which he recommended the monument to the war dead be put in Major's Hill Park. [51] However, after Mackenzie King pointed out that the park would not be as hospitable or accessible during the winter months, Gréber agreed and drew up plans for the Connaught Place site. [52]

The bronzes were finally relocated to Ottawa in the summer of 1937, [4] accompanied by Sydney, Percival, and Walter March. [53] In December, after years of bickering, [6] the contract for the construction of the pedestal and arch was awarded to E.G.M. Cape and Company of Montreal. [11] The entire cenotaph was completed on 19 October 1938, after which the landscaping surrounding the memorial was laid out and installed by Toronto contractors A.W. Robertson Limited with consultation from Gréber. [4] [11] The cost by that point had risen to over $1,300,000. Conservative MP Alonzo Hyndman quipped: "if those soldiers were to come back to-day and look at the memorial... and realize that $1,300,000 was being spent on it, while [their] sons and daughters... are walking the streets of Ottawa hungry, barefoot and without jobs... No wonder the sculptor has depicted the soldiers going through the arch with their heads hanging down, as though perplexed at what is going on." [54] Still, the figures of peace and freedom were placed atop the granite arch on the same day the Munich Agreement was signed in Germany. [55] Mackenzie King was optimistic: "Canada will remember throughout her history, that these two symbolical figures found their place at the top of the National Memorial on September the 30th, the day of the signing of the 4-power agreement which averted another Great War." [56]

Dedication and onward

The dedication of the memorial by King George VI in 1939 RoyalVisitNationalWarMemorial.jpg
The dedication of the memorial by King George VI in 1939

The memorial was officially dedicated on 21 May 1939 by King George VI, the then reigning Canadian monarch, in the presence of Queen Elizabeth, Governor General the Lord Tweedsmuir, Mackenzie King, [57] and an estimated 100,000 people, [4] including some 12,000 veterans, attending. The site was decorated with banners depicting the heraldic elements of the Royal Arms of Canada. [55] In his speech, the King focused on Canada having, through defending decency and democracy, reached nationhood among other Western countries. He said: "On the battlefields of Europe and throughout the Dominion, there are many memorials to Canada's honoured dead. Today, in her own capital, Canada dedicates her national memorial. [It] speaks to the world of Canada's heart... Something deeper than chivalry is portrayed. It is the spontaneous response of the nation's conscience. The very soul of the nation is here revealed." [8] After the formal ceremony, the King and his wife made their way to talk to gathered veterans. After doing so, the cheering crowd broke through military and police lines to "greet them [the King and Queen] personally as fellow citizens"; reporters noted that a king and queen had never before "walked unescorted in the midst of such a multitude." [58] It is thought that "O Canada" became the de facto national anthem after the King remained at attention during its playing at the dedication of the National War Memorial; [59] George, though, was actually following a precedent set by his brother, Edward, the previous king of Canada, when he dedicated the Canadian National Vimy Memorial in France in 1936. [60]

Despite the joyous environment, Mackenzie King felt the monument's allusions to the sacrifice required for peace and freedom would soon take on greater force: he and the King both were now certain another war was looming. [61] They were proven correct and, after Canada became involved in further military conflict in and after September 1939, the symbolism of the National War Memorial came into question. [62] While the monument in Ottawa was unofficially becoming a symbol of Canada's dead in all of the wars it fought in, the Royal Canadian Legion argued that new memorials should be created to mark the service of Canada's military in the Second World War and Korean War; [63] the problem with The Response, they argued, was "the heroic figures of our present National War Memorial portray Canada's fighting men of the First World War so faithfully as to render it unsuitable as a memorial to our fallen in World War II and the Korean War." [64] In 1947, Jacques Gréber, who continued to work on the development and beautification of Ottawa, designed a traditional monument to the Canadians who died in the Second World War, locating it in the Gatineau Hills, in a manner similar to the Vimy memorial in France and visible from downtown Ottawa. After veterans' groups complained the location would be difficult for tourists to reach, Gréber suggested placing the dates 1939–1945 on The Response. Veterans found that unacceptable, as well, insisting that monument was to commemorate the dead of the First World War only. [63] The federal government stated before the close of the Korean War that the East and West Memorial Buildings on Wellington Street would serve as a commemoration of the Canadian men and women who served in the Second World War; a lintel was built between the two structures and on it placed the inscription: ALL THESE WERE HONOURED IN THEIR GENERATIONS AND WERE THE GLORY OF THEIR TIMES. [65] Veterans' groups were again unsatisfied. [66] In a brief given by the Royal Canadian Legion to the Cabinet on 10 November 1955, it was outlined that the organisation wanted a national cenotaph, that would "honour the fallen of all wars", placed in front of the Peace Tower. [64]

In 1963, the matter became more prominent when the federal Cabinet announced a plan to have a national shrine of remembrance built at Nepean Point to house the Books of Remembrance [67] and a cenotaph to commemorate "the service and sacrifice of the veterans and war dead of all wars." [68] Architects from Toronto and Quebec City were asked by the Cabinet to draw up plans for such a memorial complex and the announcement was made on 19 February 1963 by the Minister of Public Works, Davie Fulton, that the project would be completed for the Canadian Centennial in 1967. [67] [69] However, this plan never came to fruition, as it was denounced by some of the media, various organizations, veterans, a large number of Canadians, [70] and eventually parliamentarians, even in the governing Liberal Party. [71] The meaning of the war memorial in Confederation Square had shifted in the public consciousness; [62] [68] [72] through its location in downtown Ottawa, renovations to Confederation Square to further highlight The Response, and its constant use as a site for national Remembrance Day services (especially through the Second World War, as Canadians were dying overseas), it had come to represent in the Canadian collective consciousness all of Canada's war dead. [73]

The Royal Canadian Legion requested in 1980 that the Crown rededicate the National War Memorial so as to formally recognise the sacrifices of those who had fought in the Second World and Korean Wars. Wishing to not repeat the confusion and problems around the national shrine of remembrance, the then Minister of Veterans Affairs, Dan MacDonald, almost immediately agreed to the proposal. [74] The monument was re-dedicated on 29 May 1982 by Governor General Edward Schreyer, [75] with the dates 1939–1945 and 1950–1953 added. the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier was added before the monument in 2000 and dedicated by Governor General Adrienne Clarkson on 28 May of that year.

Dr. Michael Pilon, a retired Canadian Forces major, observed and photographed a group of young men urinating on the war memorial on the evening of Canada Day 2006. [76] Two teenagers later issued apologies and undertook community service. Another 23-year-old man of Montreal was charged with mischief by the Ottawa Police Service, [77] though he later claimed to have no memory of the event. [78] The incident, along with the common sight of persons skateboarding and riding bicycles on the memorial's podium, prompted the posting of sentries at the site, [79] though they are only present between 9 am and 5 pm from 9 April to 10 November.

On 22 October 2014, a gunman, armed with a rifle, shot at the sentries on duty at the tomb, fatally wounding one, Corporal Nathan Cirillo of The Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders of Canada (Princess Louise's), before proceeding across the street and into the Centre Block parliament building. There, the gunman was killed in a firefight inside the building. [80] Cirillo (and Warrant Officer Patrice Vincent) was mentioned by Governor General David Johnston in his speech at the Remembrance Day ceremony of that same year, when the Governor General and Anne, Princess Royal (who brought a message from Queen Elizabeth II), [13] re-dedicated the monument once again. Its representation was expanded to include to those who served in the Second Boer War, the War in Afghanistan, and to "formally recognize all Canadians who served in the past, who serve today, and who will serve in the future." [81] [82]

Commemoration

On 15 May 1939, the Post Office Department issued a stamp called National Memorial, designed by Herman Herbert Schwartz based on a picture engraved by Joseph Keller. [83] A model of the war memorial also sits in the Royal Canadian Legion's Hall of Honour at the Canadian War Museum and the legion offers lapel pins depicting the monument.

See also

Related Research Articles

Remembrance Day memorial day on 11 November

Remembrance Day is a memorial day observed in Commonwealth member states since the end of the First World War to remember the members of their armed forces who have died in the line of duty. Following a tradition inaugurated by King George V in 1919, the day is also marked by war remembrances in many non-Commonwealth countries. Remembrance Day is observed on 11 November in most countries to recall the end of hostilities of First World War on that date in 1918. Hostilities formally ended "at the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month", in accordance with the armistice signed by representatives of Germany and the Entente between 5:12 and 5:20 that morning. The First World War officially ended with the signing of the Treaty of Versailles on 28 June 1919.

Cenotaph "empty tomb" or monument erected in honor of a person whose remains are elsewhere

A cenotaph is an empty tomb or a monument erected in honour of a person or group of people whose remains are elsewhere. It can also be the initial tomb for a person who has since been reinterred elsewhere. Although the vast majority of cenotaphs honour individuals, many noted cenotaphs are instead dedicated to the memories of groups of individuals, such as the lost soldiers of a country or of an empire.

Walter Seymour Allward Canadian artist

Walter Seymour Allward, was a Canadian monumental sculptor best known for the Canadian National Vimy Memorial. He has been widely praised for his "original sense of spatial composition, his mastery of the classical form and his brilliant craftsmanship".

War memorial type of memorial

A war memorial is a building, monument, statue or other edifice to celebrate a war or victory, or to commemorate those who died or were injured in a war.

Mackenzie–Papineau Battalion

The Mackenzie–Papineau Battalion or Mac-Paps were a battalion of Canadians who fought as part of the XV International Brigade on the Republican side in the Spanish Civil War. Except for France, no other country gave a greater proportion of its population as volunteers in Spain than Canada. The first Canadians in the conflict were dispatched mainly with the U.S. Abraham Lincoln Battalion and later the North American George Washington Battalion, with about forty Canadians serving in each group. The XV International Brigade was involved in the Battle of Jarama in which nine Canadians are known to have been killed.

Shrine of Remembrance War memorial in Melbourne, Australia

The Shrine of Remembrance is a war memorial in Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, located in Kings Domain on St Kilda Road. It was built to honour the men and women of Victoria who served in World War I, but is now a memorial to all Australians who have served in war. It is a site of annual observances of ANZAC Day and Remembrance Day and is one of the largest war memorials in Australia.

Green Island (Rideau River) island at the end of the Rideau River, Ontario, Canada

Green Island in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, is an island at the junction of the Rideau River, just off Sussex Drive in Ottawa at the Rideau Falls at the confluence with the Ottawa River. It is situated near the neighbourhood of New Edinburgh.

Veterans Affairs Canada (VAC) is the department within the Government of Canada with responsibility for pensions, benefits and services for war veterans, retired and still-serving members of the Canadian Armed Forces and Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), their families, as well as some civilians.

The Peace Tower, also known as the Tower of Victory and Peace, is a focal bell and clock tower sitting on the central axis of the Centre Block of the Canadian parliament buildings in Ottawa, Ontario. The present incarnation replaced the 55-metre (180 ft) Victoria Tower after the latter burned down in 1916, along with most of the Centre Block; only the Library of Parliament survived. It serves as a Canadian icon and had been featured prominently on the Canadian twenty-dollar bill directly adjacent the queen's visage, until the change to polymer.

Royal Artillery Memorial war memorial in central London

The Royal Artillery Memorial is a stone memorial at Hyde Park Corner in London, dedicated to the First World War casualties of the Royal Regiment of Artillery. The memorial was designed by Charles Jagger and Lionel Pearson, and features a giant sculpture of a BL 9.2-inch Mk I howitzer upon a large plinth of Portland stone, with stone reliefs depicting scenes from the conflict. Four bronze figures of artillerymen are positioned around the outside of the memorial. The memorial is famous for its realist contrast with other First World War memorials, such as the Cenotaph designed by Edwin Lutyens, and attracted much public debate during the 20th century.

National Monument (Malaysia) monument in Malaysia

The National Monument is a sculpture that commemorates those who died in Malaysia's struggle for freedom, principally against the Japanese occupation during World War II and the Malayan Emergency, which lasted from 1948 until 1960. It is located in the Federal capital, Kuala Lumpur. The Malaysian Houses of Parliament are situated near the monument.

National War Memorial (Newfoundland)

The National War Memorial in Downtown St. John's is the most elaborate of all the post World War I monuments in Newfoundland and Labrador. It was erected at King's Beach on Water Street where, in 1583, Sir Humphrey Gilbert claimed Newfoundland for England. It was formally unveiled on Memorial Day, July 1, 1924 by Field Marshal Douglas Haig, 1st Earl Haig. The term "National" refers to this monument being built by the Dominion of Newfoundland as a nation, before it became part of Canada.

Emanuel Hahn Canadian artist

Emanuel Otto Hahn was a German-born Canadian sculptor and coin designer. He taught and later married Elizabeth Wyn Wood. He co-founded and was the first president of the Sculptors' Society of Canada.

Canadian war memorials

Canadian war memorials are buildings, monuments, and statues that commemorate the armed actions in the territory encompassing modern Canada, the role of the Canadian military in conflicts and peacekeeping operations, and Canadians who died or were injured in a war. Much of this military history of Canada is commemorated today with memorials across the country and around the world. Canadian memorials commemorate the sacrifices made as early as the Seven Years' War to the modern day War on Terror. As Newfoundland was a British Dominion until joining Confederation in 1949, there are several monuments in Newfoundland and Labrador and abroad which were dedicated to Newfoundland servicemen and women.

Sydney March British artist

Sydney March (1876–1968) was an English sculptor. His primary focus was portrait busts and other sculptures of British royalty and contemporary figures, as well as war memorials. The second-born of eight artists in his family, he and his siblings completed the National War Memorial of Canada after the death of their brother Vernon March in 1930, who had created the winning design. It is the site in Ottawa of annual Remembrance Day ceremonies.

Bromley War Memorial war memorial in London

The Bromley War Memorial in Bromley, Greater London, England commemorates the fallen of World War I and World War II. It was designed by British sculptor Sydney March, of the March family of artists.

Rochdale Cenotaph war memorial in Rochdale, Greater Manchester

Rochdale Cenotaph is a First World War memorial on the Esplanade in Rochdale, Greater Manchester, in the north west of England. Designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens, it is one of seven memorials in England based on his Cenotaph on Whitehall in London and one of his more ambitious designs. The memorial was unveiled in 1922 and consists of a raised platform bearing Lutyens' characteristic Stone of Remembrance next to a 10-metre (33 ft) pylon topped by an effigy of a recumbent soldier. A set of painted stone flags surrounds the pylon.

The Cenotaph, Cape Town

The Cenotaph is a war memorial on Heerengracht Street in Cape Town. The city's annual Remembrance Day ceremonies are held there. It is classified as a public memorial and as such is subject to protection in terms of heritage legislation administered by Heritage Western Cape, the provincial heritage resources authority of the Western Cape province of South Africa.

Norwich War Memorial war memorial in Norwich, England

Norwich War Memorial is a First World War memorial in Norwich in Eastern England. It was designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens, the last of his eight cenotaphs to be erected in England. Prior to Lutyens' involvement, several abandoned proposals had been made for commemorating Norwich's war dead, and by 1926 the newly elected lord mayor was determined to see the construction of a memorial before he left office. He established an appeal to raise funds for local hospitals in memory of the dead as well as a physical monument. He commissioned Lutyens, who designed an empty tomb (cenotaph) atop a low screen wall from which protrudes a Stone of Remembrance. Bronze flambeaux at either end can burn gas to emit a flame. Lutyens also designed a roll of honour, on which the names of the city's dead are listed, which was installed in Norwich Castle in 1931.

References

  1. 1 2 "National War Memorial". Ottawakiosk.com. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
  2. "Cenotaphs: monuments to our veterans". CBC News. 25 October 2010. Retrieved 13 November 2014.
  3. 1 2 Canadian Heritage Information Network. "The National War Memorial". Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 13 November 2014.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Veterans Affairs Canada. "The National War Memorial". Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
  5. 1 2 3 Kates, David (10 November 2014). "National War Memorial an enduring symbol of service, sacrifice". Postmedia. Retrieved 15 November 2014.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "National War Memorial". The Canadian Encyclopedia. Mel Hurtig.|access-date= requires |url= (help)
  7. Ferguson 2012 , p. 70.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Zucchero, Jim, The Canadian National War Memorial: Metaphor for the Birth of the Nation, Canadian Poetry, retrieved 14 November 2014
  9. 1 2 Ferguson, Malcolm (2012), Canada's Response: The Making and Remaking of the National War Memorial (PDF), Carlton University Research Virtual Environment, p. 46, retrieved 15 November 2014
  10. "National War Memorial". Centre for Distance Learning and Innovation. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 Veterans Affairs Canada. "The National War Memorial". Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 8 November 2014.
  12. Gardam, John; Giesler, Patricia (1982), The National War Memorial, Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services Canada
  13. 1 2 The Canadian Press (11 November 2014). "Canada remembers: Governor General rededicates National War Memorial". Toronto Star. Retrieved 11 November 2014.
  14. Remembrance Day Preparations (Digital video). Ottawa: Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 10 November 2014.
  15. Bostelaar, Robert (7 November 2014). "Why Ottawa's Remembrance Day ceremony won't focus on recent slayings". Ottawa Citizen. Retrieved 12 November 2014.
  16. "The National Ceremony". Royal Canadian Legion. Retrieved 12 November 2014.
  17. 1 2 Public Works and Government Services Canada. "nfographic: National War Memorial". Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 15 November 2014.
  18. "Ottawa—Canada's Royal Capital". Canadian Royal Heritage Trust. Retrieved 12 November 2014.
  19. "ST-120-1-61. Wreath-laying Ceremony at the National War Memorial, Ottawa, Canada". John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum. Retrieved 13 November 2014.
  20. The Associated Press (29 May 1990). "Gorbachev Makes Canada Stopover". Spokane Chronicle. p. A9.
  21. Department of Canadian Heritage. "Visitor Information". Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 8 November 2014.
  22. Department of National Defence (1943), The National War Memorial, 1752, p. 2
  23. Robert Borden, Prime Minister (1918). Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Canada: House of Commons. col. 1195.
  24. Brandon, Laura (2007). Art and War. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. p. 5.
  25. Ferguson 2012 , p. 5.
  26. "National Soldiers' Monument Planned". Ottawa Citizen. 19 December 1922.
  27. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 17–18.
  28. Ferguson 2012 , p. 61.
  29. Ferguson 2012 , p. 18.
  30. 1 2 William Lyon Mackenzie King, Prime Minister of Canada (11 May 1923). Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Canada: House of Commons. col. 2685–2686.
  31. Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Canada: House of Commons. 1923. col. 2688.
  32. Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Canada: House of Commons. 1923. col. 2688/2689.
  33. Ferguson 2012 , p. 23.
  34. Ferguson 2012 , p. 24.
  35. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 31–33.
  36. Conditions of Open Competition, 337, Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, 1925
  37. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 33–34.
  38. Ferguson 2012 , p. 28.
  39. Ferguson 2012 , p. 44.
  40. Ferguson 2012 , p. 42.
  41. Department of Canadian Heritage. "The Response, National War Memorial". Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 8 November 2014.
  42. Ferguson 2012 , p. 52.
  43. James Shaver Woodsworth, Member of Parliament for Winnipeg Centre (1931). Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Canada: House of Commons. col. 2853.
  44. Ferguson 2012 , p. 65.
  45. Vernon March to William Lyon Mackenzie King, 154, Library and Archives Canada, 21 August 1928, C-2304
  46. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 66–67.
  47. Sydney March to Bennett, 815, Library and Archives Canada, 25 January 1933, M-1463
  48. Ferguson 2012 , p. 69.
  49. Ferguson 2012 , p. 74.
  50. Ferguson 2012 , p. 60.
  51. Gréber, Jacques (2 July 1937), Consultation on Development of Government Grounds, 199, Library and Archives Canada, C-4277
  52. Ferguson 2012 , p. 77.
  53. Ferguson 2012 , p. 78.
  54. Alonzo Hyndman, Member of Parliament for South Mountain (1939). Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) . Canada: House of Commons. col. 3401.
  55. 1 2 Ferguson 2012 , p. 81.
  56. King, William Lyon Mackenzie King (30 September 1938), Diary of William Lyon Mackenzie King, Library and Archives Canada
  57. Ferguson 2012 , p. 50.
  58. The Royal Visit (Digital recording of original film). Ottawa: National Film Board of Canada. 1939.
  59. Bethune, Brian (7 July 2011). "A gift fit for a king". Maclean's. Toronto: Rogers Communications. ISSN   0024-9262 . Retrieved 9 July 2011.
  60. Galbraith, William (1989). "Fiftieth Anniversary of the 1939 Royal Visit". Canadian Parliamentary Review. Ottawa: Commonwealth Parliamentary Association. 12 (3): 10. Archived from the original on 5 December 2012. Retrieved 10 March 2010.
  61. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 80–81.
  62. 1 2 Ferguson 2012 , p. 87.
  63. 1 2 Ferguson 2012 , p. 89.
  64. 1 2 "A National Cenotaph", The Legionary, 12, December 1955
  65. Veterans Affairs Canada. "East and West Memorial Buildings". Queen's Printer for Canada. Archived from the original on 29 November 2014. Retrieved 20 November 2014.
  66. Ferguson 2012 , p. 90.
  67. 1 2 Ferguson 2012 , p. 95.
  68. 1 2 Ferguson 2012 , p. 9.
  69. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 96–98.
  70. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 99–101.
  71. Ferguson 2012 , p. 110.
  72. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 106–107.
  73. Ferguson 2012 , pp. 112–117.
  74. Sullivan, Pat (August 1982), "Minor Change, Major Meaning", Legion Magazine, 31
  75. Ferguson 2012 , p. 124.
  76. Proudfoot, Shannon (3 July 2006). "A National Disgrace". Ottawa Citizen. Archived from the original on 22 February 2007. Retrieved 11 September 2006.
  77. "Teen offers 'heartfelt' apology for urinating on National War Memorial". CBC. 7 July 2006. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
  78. "Accused has 'no memory' of night at War Memorial". CTV News. 7 July 2006. Archived from the original on 16 February 2007. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
  79. Cobb, Chris (22 October 2014). "War Memorial guard program is designed for dignity". Ottawa Citizen. Retrieved 11 November 2014.
  80. Puzic, Sonja (22 October 2014). "'Canada will never be intimidated,' Harper says after shootings in Ottawa". CTV News. Retrieved 6 November 2014.
  81. Government of Canada. "Government of Canada to rededicate National War Memorial" (Press release). Queen's Printer for Canada. Retrieved 11 November 2014.
  82. Levitz, Stephanie (27 October 2014). "Calls grow for re-dedication of National War Memorial to include Cpl. Cirillo". CTV News. Retrieved 8 November 2014.
  83. "Canada Post stamp". Canadian Postal Archives. Archived from the original on 1 January 2013. Retrieved 13 November 2014.

Coordinates: 45°25′26.53″N75°41′43.79″W / 45.4240361°N 75.6954972°W / 45.4240361; -75.6954972