Right to Recall laws in India

Last updated

"Right To Recall (RTR)" are existing laws in some states of India that allow citizens to remove or replace public servants holding posts of Sarpanch, Mukhiya, Corporator and Mayor in the government.

Contents

History

In modern India, Sachindra Nath Sanyal was the first to demand the right to replace public servants. The manifesto of the Hindustan Republican Association was written by Sachindra Nath Sanyal some when in December 1924. In his manifesto it's written that, "In this Republic the electors shall have the right to recall their representatives, if so desired, otherwise the democracy shall become a mockery." [1]

The debate over Recall of elected representatives has a long history in the Indian democracy; the matter was even discussed in the Constituent Assembly. The debate was centered on the belief that the Right to Recall must accompany the Right to Elect and the voters must be provided with a remedy 'if things go wrong'. However Dr. B.R. Ambedkar did not accept this amendment. [2]

While some members believed that Recall would help in political education of the people and would encourage voters to think, others argued that it would be improper to provide a Recall provision at the infancy of the Indian democracy. It was felt that Recall would render the constituencies a battleground between candidates and unnecessarily make them victims of political rivalry. [2]

"If there are any stray instances or some black sheep who having lost the confidence of their constituency still want to continue to represent the constituency in the House, for some such bad instances we should not disfigure our Constituency. We should leave it as it is, to the good sense of the members concerned" Sardar Vallabh bhai Patel on 18 July while discussing proposed amendment on power to recall in Constituent Assembly Debates. [3]

At the same time, however, some members feared that village or municipal level bodies could become autocratic in absence of No Confidence Motion or Recall. [2]

The first recall law came as a provision of No confidence motion over Sarpanch by Gram Sabha members in Uttar Pradesh in 1947. [4]

States having Recall laws at Panchayat level

Recall has been implemented at Panchayat level in the states of Uttar Pradesh, [4] Uttarakhand, [5] Bihar, [6] Jharkhand, [7] Madhya Pradesh, [8] Chhattisgarh, [9] Maharashtra [10] and Himachal Pradesh [11] Recall has been implemented at Panchayat level in the states of Punjab since 1994 as provision of no confidence motion. Right To Recall Sarpanch is also recently passed for Haryana.

The procedure of Recall over Sarpanch is a 2 step procedure which can be directly initiated by the citizens. After a lock-in period of 1–2 years varying from state to state, certain number of voters of the Gram Sabha need to submit their signatures / thumbprints and petition the Collector office. After verification of the signatures, a meeting of all the Gram Sabha members is organized and if majority of the Gram Sabha votes against the sitting Sarpanch, the Sarpanch is removed. [4] [6] [7] [10] [11]

Failure of Influence of Right to Recall laws at Panchayat level

Right to Recall has been in vogue in Uttar Pradesh since 1947 and in Madhya Pradesh for over a decade now but not exercised much at Gram Panchayats level, due to lack of awareness. [12]

In spite of villagers in these states having direct power to remove their Sarpanch, the corruption done by Sarpanch of these states is high and widespread. [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]

States having Recall laws at Municipal level

Recall has been implemented at Municipal level in the states of Madhya Pradesh, [18] Chhattisgarh, [19] Bihar, [20] Jharkhand [21] and Rajasthan. [22]

Right to Recall proposed bills for MP and MLA

Constitution (Amendment) Bill about Voter's right to recall elected representatives was introduced in Lok Sabha by C. K. Chandrappan in 1974 and Atal Bihari Vajpayee had supported this but the bill did not pass. [23] [24]

This Right has been opposed by Election Commission of India and debated and highlighted in Indian politics. [25] [26] [27] [28]

A private member bill, The Representation of the People (Amendment) Bill, 2016 was introduced by Varun Gandhi in Lok Sabha. [29] [30]

Campaign for Right to Recall laws on PM and CM

Rahul Chimanbhai Mehta an IIT Delhi graduate, activist and politician of India started first draft based campaign for right to recall laws on Prime Minister and Chief minister posts in India in 1999 after returning from United States. [31] [32] He proposed written drafts for recall of PM and CM in his book Vote Vapasi Dhan Vapasi. [33] He floated a group named right to recall group in 2006 and started contesting elections to promote his drafts. [31]

After 3 years of formation of Right to Recall group, Mehta want to form a political party to give more publicity to his proposed drafts by using election as a tool and in 2019 he founded Right to Recall Party and became its national president. [34] [35] [36] [37] Mehta had contested various elections from Gandhinagar loksabha constituency and Ghatlodia assembly constituency to promote his drafts.

See also

Related Research Articles

Gram Panchayat is a basic governing institution in Indian villages. It is a political institution, acting as the cabinet of a village. The Gram Sabha works as the general body of the Gram Panchayat. The members of the gram panchayat are elected directly by the people. The president of a gram panchayat is known as a "Pradhan" or "Sarpanch". There are about 250,000 gram panchayats present in India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Purulia district</span> District in West Bengal, India

Purulia district is one of the twenty-three districts of West Bengal state in Eastern India. Purulia is the administrative headquarters of the district. Some of the other important towns of Purulia district are Raghunathpur-Adra, Jhalda, Anara and Balarampur.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Garhwa district</span> District of Jharkhand in India

Garhwa District is one of the twenty-four districts in the Indian state of Jharkhand. The Garhwa District is part of the Palamu division and has its administrative headquarters in Garhwa City.

Sardarpur is a town and a nagar panchayat in Dhar district in the Indian state of Madhya Pradesh. It is a town on Mahi river on the Malwa plateau. There is an ancient Shivalinga situated at the bank of Mahi river at a place called Shree Jhineshwar Dham; Shri Mohankheda Jain Thirth and Bhopawar Jain Tirth are located nearby.

Although India is a parliamentary democracy, the country's politics has become dynastic or with high level of nepotism, possibly due to the absence of party organizations, independent civil-society associations which mobilize support for a party, or centralized financing of elections. The dynastic phenomenon is present at the national, state, regional, and district level. The Nehru–Gandhi family has produced three Indian prime ministers, and family members have largely led the Congress party since 1978. The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) also has several dynastic leaders. In addition to the major national parties, other national and regional parties such as Shiromani Akali Dal, Shiv Sena, Samajwadi Party, Rashtriya Janata Dal, Janata Dal Secular, Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, Kerala Congress, Jammu & Kashmir National Conference, Indian Union Muslim League, AIMIM, and the Nationalist Congress Party are all dominated by families, mostly those of the party founders.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Digvijaya Singh</span> 14th Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh, India

Digvijaya Singh is an Indian politician and a Member of Parliament in the Rajya Sabha. He is Ex-General Secretary of the Indian National Congress party's All India Congress Committee. Previously, he had served as the 14th Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh, a central Indian state, for two terms from 1993 to 2003. Prior to that he was a minister in Chief Minister Arjun Singh's cabinet between 1980 and 1984. In 2019 Lok Sabha elections he was defeated by Pragya Singh Thakur for Bhopal Lok Sabha seat.

A sarpanch, gram pradhan, mukhiya, or president is a decision-maker, elected by the village-level constitutional body of local self-government called the gram sabha in India. The sarpanch, together with other elected panchayat members, constitute gram panchayats and zilla panchayats. The sarpanch is the focal point of contact between government officers and the village community and retains power for five years. the term used to refer to the sarpanch can vary across different states of India. Here are some of the commonly used terms for sarpanch in various states: panchayat president, gram pramukh, gram pradhan, gram adhyaksha, gaon panchayat president, gram panchayat president, etc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Panchayati raj in India</span> Village self-government system in rural India

Panchayati raj is the system of local self-government of villages in rural India as opposed to urban and suburban municipalities.

Rampur may refer to:

In India, a number of political positions and university posts are held for specific groups of the population, including Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and women in some cases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ujiarpur Assembly constituency</span> Vidhan Sabha constituency

Ujiarpur Assembly constituency is an assembly constituency in Samastipur district in the Indian state of Bihar. The constituency was formed following the Delimitation Order of 2008.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">PESA Act</span> 244(A)

The Provisions of the Panchayats Act, 1996 abbreviated as PESA Act is a law enacted by the Government of India for ensuring self governance through traditional Gram Sabhas for people living in the Scheduled Areas of India. Scheduled Areas are areas identified by the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution of India. Scheduled Areas are found in ten states of India which have predominant population of tribal communities. The Scheduled Areas, were not covered by the 73rd Constitutional Amendment or Panchayati Raj Act of the Indian Constitution as provided in the Part IX of the Constitution. PESA was enacted on 24 December 1996 to extend the provisions of Part IX of the Constitution to Scheduled Areas, with certain exceptions and modifications. PESA sought to enable the Panchayats at appropriate levels and Gram Sabhas to implement a system of self-governance with respect to a number of issues such as customary resources, minor forest produce, minor minerals, minor water bodies, selection of beneficiaries, sanction of projects, and control over local institutions. PESA is an Act to provide for the extension of the provisions of Part IX of the Constitution relating to the Panchayats and the Scheduled Areas. PESA was viewed as a positive development for tribal communities in Scheduled Areas who had earlier suffered tremendously from engagement with modern development processes and from the operation of both colonial laws and statutes made in independent India. The loss of access to forest, land, and other community resources had increased their vulnerability. Rampant land acquisition and displacement due to development projects had led to large scale distress in tribal communities living in Scheduled Areas. PESA was seen as a panacea for many of these vulnerabilities and sought to introduce a new paradigm of development where the tribal communities in such Scheduled Areas were to decide by themselves the pace and priorities of their development.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chhattisgarh Legislative Assembly</span> Unicameral state legislature of Chhattisgarh state in India

The Chhattisgarh Legislative Assembly or the Chhattisgarh Vidhan Sabha is the unicameral state legislature of Chhattisgarh state in India.

Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana is a rural development programme broadly focusing upon the development in the villages which includes social development, cultural development and spread motivation among the people on social mobilization of the village community. The programme was launched by the Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi on the birth anniversary of Jayaprakash Narayan, on 11 October 2014.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">None of the above (India)</span> Ballot option in India to vote against all available candidates

"None of the Above" has been provided as an option to the voters of India in most elections since 2009. By expressing a preference for none of the above, a citizen can choose not to vote for any candidates who are contesting the elections.

Between 1952 and 2020, two seats were reserved in the Lok Sabha, the lower house of the Parliament of India, for members of the Anglo-Indian community. These two members were nominated by the President of India on the advice of the Government of India. In January 2020, the Anglo-Indian reserved seats in the Parliament and State Legislatures of India were discontinued by the 126th Constitutional Amendment Bill of 2019, when enacted as the 104th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pushprajgarh Assembly constituency</span> Constituency of the Madhya Pradesh legislative assembly in India

Pushprajgarh Assembly constituency is one of the 230 Vidhan Sabha constituencies of Madhya Pradesh state in central India. It is a segment of Shahdol.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Amarwara Assembly constituency</span> Constituency of the Madhya Pradesh legislative assembly in India

Amarwara Assembly constituency is one of the 230 Vidhan Sabha constituencies of Madhya Pradesh state in central India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Right to Recall Party</span> Political party in India

Right to Recall Party (RRP) is a registered political party in India. The RRP was founded by an IIT Delhi graduate and Indian anti corruption activist Rahul Chimanbhai Mehta in March 2019. RRP came into existence because Mehta and his companions wanted to form a political party to gave publicity to the drafts of Right to Recall laws on PM and CM in India by using elections as a tool.

References

  1. "Shaheed Bhagat Singh great martyrs of punjab(India).Shaheed Bhagat Singh was the hero of freedom struggle in india, great freedom fighter of Punjab, great freedom fighter of India, true freedom fighter of Punjab,true freedom fighter of india". www.shahidbhagatsingh.org. Retrieved 20 March 2024.
  2. 1 2 3 "Journal of Constitutional and Parliamentary Studies January - December 2015" https://ipsdelhi.org.in/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Right-to-Recall-in-India-An-Analysis-Kota-Neelima-1.pdf Archived 29 June 2019 at the Wayback Machine
  3. "CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY OF INDIA DEBATES (PROCEEDINGS)-VOLUME IV Friday, the 18th July 1947" http://164.100.47.194/loksabha/writereaddata/cadebatefiles/C18071947.html
  4. 1 2 3 "The U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 , page 32, section 14" http://panchayatiraj.up.nic.in/docs/ActsnRules/GP-Act-1947-English.pdf
  5. "उत्तराखंड पंचायती राज अधिनियम, 2016" http://ukpanchayat.org/pdf/Panchayati-Raj-Adhiniyam-2016.pdf
  6. 1 2 "THE BIHAR PANCHAYAT RAJ ACT, 2006" http://biharprd.bih.nic.in/StateActRules/ACT_Bihar%20Panchayat%20Raj%20Act%202006%20-%20English.pdf Archived 31 March 2020 at the Wayback Machine
  7. 1 2 "The Jharkhand Panchayat Raj Act, 2001" https://www.legalcrystal.com/act/135070/the-jharkhand-panchayat-raj-act-2001-complete-act Archived 29 June 2019 at the Wayback Machine
  8. "M.P. Panchayat Raj Avam Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam, 1993". www.bareactslive.com. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  9. "Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993". www.bareactslive.com. Retrieved 20 March 2024.
  10. 1 2 "THE MAHARASHTRA VILLAGE PANCHAYATS ACT" https://mahasec.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/GR/The%20Maharashtra%20Village%20Panchayts%20Act.pdf
  11. 1 2 "THE HIMACHAL PRADESH PANCHAYATI RAJ ACT, 1994" https://hppanchayat.nic.in/PDF/THE%20HIMACHAL%20PRADESH%20PANCHAYATI%20RAJ%20ACT,%201994(Final).pdf
  12. "MP: 'Right to Recall' in Panchayats not exercised". Zee News. 16 September 2011. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  13. "PMAY: Corruption Brings Housing Construction to a Standstill in UP's Village – Video Volunteers". www.videovolunteers.org. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  14. "Thane: Woman Sarpanch Accepts Rs. 2.5 Lakh Bribe By Cheque, Arrested". NDTV.com. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  15. "बेलगांव सरपंच ने पीएम आवास में लांघी भ्रष्टाचार की सीमा" http://www.palpalindia.com/2017/11/07/anuppur-mp-Belgaum-Sarpanch-PM-Housing-Scheme-Corruption-Interests-Bribery-news-in-hindi-216877.html Archived 29 June 2019 at the Wayback Machine
  16. "सचिव सरपंच की मिलीभगत से पंचायत के लाखों रुपए के कामों में हेराफेरी का आरोप, आंगनवाड़ी भवन बना खंडहर, दीवारों में आईं दरारें | New India Times". www.newindiatimes.net (in Hindi). 20 May 2019. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  17. "Millionaire mukhiyas". www.downtoearth.org.in. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  18. "The Madhya Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1961" http://www.mpurban.gov.in/pdf/MunicipalCorporationACT1961.pdf
  19. "The Chhattisgarh Municipalities Act, 1961 Complete Act" https://www.legalcrystal.com/act/134620/the-chhattisgarh-municipalities-act-1961-complete-act Archived 29 June 2019 at the Wayback Machine
  20. "बिहार नगरपालिका विधेयेक 2007" http://urban.bih.nic.in/Acts/AR-02-29-03-2007.pdf Archived 3 March 2019 at the Wayback Machine
  21. "The Jharkhand Municipal Act, 2011 Complete Act" https://www.legalcrystal.com/act/135068/the-jharkhand-municipal-act-2011-complete-act Archived 29 June 2019 at the Wayback Machine
  22. "The Rajasthan Municipalities (Amendment) Act, 2010" http://www.lawsofindia.org/pdf/rajasthan/2010/2010Rajasthan19.pdf
  23. Vajpayee, Atal Bihari (1996). Vajpayee, Atal Bihari (5 September 1996). "State of the Nation". Shipra Publications – via Google Books. Shipra Publications. ISBN   9788185402703.
  24. "Social activist Anna Hazare during his protests had been campaigning for Right to Recall and right to Reject". The Economic Times.
  25. "Right to recall a dangerous idea". BusinessLine. 19 October 2011. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  26. "A Critical Take On 'Right To Recall' | Live Law". 26 July 2018. Archived from the original on 26 July 2018. Retrieved 20 December 2023.
  27. Penguin Random House India Private Limited – via Google Books (13 December 2017). The Dramatic Decade – Landmark Cases of Modern India: Landmark Cases of Modern India. Penguin Random House India Private Limited. ISBN   9789387625372.{{cite book}}: |last= has generic name (help)
  28. Kumar, Sanjay (8 January 2014). Kumar, Sanjay (8 January 2014). "Indian Youth and Electoral Politics: An Emerging Engagement". SAGE Publications India – via Google Books. SAGE Publications. ISBN   9788132118831.
  29. "Varun Gandhi moves bill in Lok Sabha to recall MPs, MLAs for non-performance". 28 February 2017.
  30. "Right to recall representatives a must for people: Varun Gandhi". The Economic Times.
  31. 1 2 "Fight for recall right". Ahmedabad Mirror. Retrieved 9 February 2023.
  32. "Right-to-recall activist spurred by Anna's win". Ahmedabad Mirror. Retrieved 9 February 2023.
  33. Mehta, Rahul Chimanbhai; Sharma, Pawan Kumar (14 December 2021). Vote Vapasi Dhan Vapasi (in Hindi). India: Notion Press. ISBN   979-8885306997.
  34. "List of parties registered after 15.03.2019". ECI.
  35. "ECI gives Elections symbol to Right to Recall Party". ECI.
  36. Desk, NH Web (26 October 2019). "In a first, a newspaper ad calls for action against EVMs". National Herald. Retrieved 9 February 2023.
  37. "Rahul Chimanbhai Mehta, National President, Right to Recall Party". ECI. Archived from the original on 18 April 2023. Retrieved 9 February 2023.