Rudolf Virchow

Last updated

Rudolf Virchow
Rudolf Virchow NLM3.jpg
Born(1821-10-13)13 October 1821
Died5 September 1902(1902-09-05) (aged 80)
Resting place Alter St.-Matthäus-Kirchhof, Schöneberg
52°17′N13°13′E / 52.28°N 13.22°E / 52.28; 13.22
Citizenship Kingdom of Prussia
Education Friedrich Wilhelm University (M.D., 1843)
Known for Cell theory
Cellular pathology
Biogenesis
Virchow's triad
Spouse(s)Ferdinande Rosalie Mayer (a.k.a. Rose Virchow)
Awards Copley Medal (1892)
Scientific career
Fields Medicine
Anthropology
Institutions Charité
University of Würzburg
Thesis De rheumate praesertim corneae  (1843)
Doctoral advisor Johannes Peter Müller
Other academic advisors Robert Froriep
Doctoral students Friedrich Daniel von Recklinghausen
Walther Kruse
Other notable students Ernst Haeckel
Edwin Klebs
Franz Boas
Adolph Kussmaul
Max Westenhöfer
William Osler
William H. Welch
Influenced Eduard Hitzig
Charles Scott Sherrington
Paul Farmer
Signature
Rudolf Virchow signature.svg

Rudolf Ludwig Carl Virchow ( /ˈvɪərk,ˈfɪərx/ ; [1] German: [ˈfɪʁço] or [ˈvɪʁço] ; [2] 13 October 1821 5 September 1902) was a German physician, anthropologist, pathologist, prehistorian, biologist, writer, editor, and politician. He is known as "the father of modern pathology" and as the founder of social medicine, and to his colleagues, the "Pope of medicine". [3] [4] [5]

Contents

Virchow studied medicine at the Friedrich Wilhelm University under Johannes Peter Müller. While working at the Charité hospital, his investigation of the 1847–1848 typhus epidemic in Upper Silesia laid the foundation for public health in Germany, and paved his political and social careers. From it, he coined a well known aphorism: "Medicine is a social science, and politics is nothing else but medicine on a large scale". He participation in the Revolution of 1848 led to his expulsion from Charité the next year. He then published a newspaper Die Medizinische Reform (The Medical Reform). He took the first Chair of Pathological Anatomy at the University of Würzburg in 1849. After five years, Charité reinstated him to its new Institute for Pathology. He co-founded the political party Deutsche Fortschrittspartei, and was elected to the Prussian House of Representatives and won a seat in the Reichstag. His opposition to Otto von Bismarck's financial policy resulted in an anecdotal "Sausage Duel", although he supported Bismarck in his anti-Catholic campaigns, which he named Kulturkampf ("culture struggle"). [6]

A prolific writer, he produced more than 2000 scientific writings. [7] Cellular Pathology (1858), regarded as the root of modern pathology, introduced the third dictum in cell theory: Omnis cellula e cellula ("All cells come from cells"). [8] He was a co-founder of Physikalisch-Medizinische Gesellschaft in 1849 and Deutsche Gesellschaft für Pathologie in 1897. He founded journals such as Archiv für Pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für Klinische Medicin (with Benno Reinhardt in 1847, later renamed Virchows Archiv ), and Zeitschrift für Ethnologie (Journal of Ethnology). [9] The latter is published by German Anthropological Association and the Berlin Society for Anthropology, Ethnology and Prehistory, the societies which he also founded. [10]

Virchow was the first to describe and name diseases such as leukemia, chordoma, ochronosis, embolism, and thrombosis. He coined biological terms such as "chromatin", "neuroglia", "agenesis", "parenchyma", "osteoid", "amyloid degeneration", and "spina bifida"; terms such as Virchow's node, Virchow–Robin spaces, Virchow–Seckel syndrome, and Virchow's triad are named after him. His description of the life cycle of a roundworm Trichinella spiralis influenced the practice of meat inspection. He developed the first systematic method of autopsy, [11] and introduced hair analysis in forensic investigation. [12] Opposing the germ theory of diseases, he rejected Ignaz Semmelweis's idea of disinfecting. He was critical of what he described as "Nordic mysticism" regarding the Aryan race. [13] As an anti-Darwinist, he called Charles Darwin an "ignoramus" and his own student Ernst Haeckel a "fool". He described the original specimen of Neanderthal man as nothing but that of a deformed human. [14]

Early life

Young Virchow Rudolf Virchow NLM9.jpg
Young Virchow

Virchow was born in Schievelbein, in eastern Pomerania, Prussia (now Świdwin, Poland). [15] He was the only child of Carl Christian Siegfried Virchow (1785–1865) and Johanna Maria née Hesse (1785–1857). His father was a farmer and the city treasurer. Academically brilliant, he always topped his classes and was fluent in German, Latin, Greek, Hebrew, English, Arabic, French, Italian and Dutch. He progressed to the gymnasium in Köslin (now Koszalin in Poland) in 1835 with the goal of becoming a pastor. He graduated in 1839 with a thesis titled A Life Full of Work and Toil is not a Burden but a Benediction. However, he chose medicine mainly because he considered his voice too weak for preaching. [16]

Scientific career

Memorial stone of Rudolf Virchow in his hometown Swidwin, now in Poland Erinnerungsstein und Denkmal fur den Arzt Rudolf Virchow in 78-300 Swidwin (Schivelbein).jpg
Memorial stone of Rudolf Virchow in his hometown Świdwin, now in Poland

In 1839, he received a military fellowship, a scholarship for gifted children from poor families to become army surgeons, to study medicine at the Friedrich Wilhelm University in Berlin (now Humboldt University of Berlin). [17] He was most influenced by Johannes Peter Müller, his doctoral advisor. Virchow defended his doctoral thesis titled De rheumate praesertim corneae (corneal manifestations of rheumatic disease) on 21 October 1843. [18] Immediately on graduation, he became subordinate physician to Müller. [19] But shortly after, he joined the Charité Hospital in Berlin for internship. In 1844, he was appointed as medical assistant to the prosector (pathologist) Robert Froriep, from whom he learned microscopy which interested him in pathology. Froriep was also the editor of an abstract journal that specialised in foreign work, which inspired Virchow for scientific ideas of France and England. [20]

Virchow published his first scientific paper in 1845, giving the earliest known pathological descriptions of leukemia. He passed the medical licensure examination in 1846 and immediately succeeded Froriep as hospital prosector at the Charité. In 1847, he was appointed to his first academic position with the rank of privatdozent . Because his articles did not receive favourable attention from German editors, he founded Archiv für Pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für Klinische Medicin (now known as Virchows Archiv) with a colleague Benno Reinhardt in 1847. He edited alone after Reinhardt's death in 1852 till his own. [17] This journal published critical articles based on the criterion that no papers would be published that contained outdated, untested, dogmatic or speculative ideas. [16]

Unlike his German peers, Virchow had great faith in clinical observation, animal experimentation (to determine causes of diseases and the effects of drugs) and pathological anatomy, particularly at the microscopic level, as the basic principles of investigation in medical sciences. He went further and stated that the cell was the basic unit of the body that had to be studied to understand disease. Although the term 'cell' had been coined in the 1665 by an English scientist Robert Hooke, the building blocks of life were still considered to be the 21 tissues of Bichat, a concept described by the French physician Xavier Bichat. [21] [20]

The Prussian government employed Virchow to study the typhus epidemic in Upper Silesia in 1847–1848. It was from this medical campaign that he developed his ideas on social medicine and politics after seeing the victims and their poverty. Even though he was not particularly successful in combating the epidemic, his 190-paged Report on the Typhus Epidemic in Upper Silesia in 1848 became a turning point in politics and public health in Germany. [22] [23] He returned to Berlin on 10 March 1848, and only eight days later, a revolution broke out against the government in which he played an active part. To fight political injustice he helped found Die Medizinische Reform (Medical Reform), a weekly newspaper for promoting social medicine, in July of that year. The newspaper ran under the banners "medicine is a social science" and "the physician is the natural attorney of the poor". Political pressures forced him to terminate the publication in June 1849, and he was expelled from his official position. [24]

In November 1848, he was given an academic appointment and left Berlin for the University of Würzburg to hold Germany's first chair of pathological anatomy. During his six-year period there, he concentrated on his scientific work, including detailed studies of venous thrombosis and cellular theory. His first major work there was a six-volume Handbuch der speciellen Pathologie und Therapie (Handbook on Special Pathology and Therapeutics) published in 1854. In 1856, he returned to Berlin to become the newly created Chair for Pathological Anatomy and Physiology at the Friedrich-Wilhelms-University, as well as Director of the newly built Institute for Pathology on the premises of the Charité. He held the latter post for the next 20 years. [20] [25] [26]

Cell biology

Illustration of Virchow's cell theory Virchow-cell.jpg
Illustration of Virchow's cell theory

Virchow is credited with several key discoveries. His most widely known scientific contribution is his cell theory, which built on the work of Theodor Schwann. He was one of the first to accept the work of Robert Remak, who showed that the origin of cells was the division of pre-existing cells. [27] He did not initially accept the evidence for cell division and believed that it occurs only in certain types of cells. When it dawned on him in 1855 that Remak might be right, he published Remak's work as his own, causing a falling-out between the two. [28]

Virchow was particularly influenced in cellular theory by the work of John Goodsir of Edinburgh, whom he described as "one of the earliest and most acute observers of cell-life both physiological and pathological". Virchow dedicated his magnum opusDie Cellularpathologie to Goodsir. [29] Virchow's cellular theory was encapsulated in the epigram Omnis cellula e cellula ("all cells (come) from cells"), which he published in 1855. [8] [20] [30] (The epigram was actually coined by François-Vincent Raspail, but popularized by Virchow.) [31] It is a rejection of the concept of spontaneous generation, which held that organisms could arise from nonliving matter. For example, maggots were believed to appear spontaneously in decaying meat; Francesco Redi carried out experiments that disproved this notion and coined the maxim Omne vivum ex ovo ("Every living thing comes from a living thing" — literally "from an egg"); Virchow (and his predecessors) extended this to state that the only source for a living cell was another living cell. [32]

Cancer

In 1845, Virchow and John Hughes Bennett independently observed abnormal increases in white blood cells in some patients. Virchow correctly identified the condition as a blood disease, and named it leukämie in 1847 (later anglicised to leukemia). [33] [34] [35] In 1857, he was the first to describe a type of tumour called chordoma that originated from the clivus (at the base of the skull). [36] [37]

Theory of cancer origin

Virchow was the first to correctly link the origin of cancers from otherwise normal cells. [38] (His teacher Müller had proposed that cancers originated from cells, but from special cells, which he called blastema.) In 1855, he suggested that cancers arise from the activation of dormant cells (perhaps similar to cells now known as stem cells) present in mature tissue. [39] Virchow believed that cancer is caused by severe irritation in the tissues, and his theory came to be known as chronic irritation theory. He thought, rather wrongly, that the irritation spread in the form of liquid so that cancer rapidly increases. [40] His theory was largely ignored, as he was proved wrong that it was not by liquid, but by metastasis of the already cancerous cells that cancers spread. (Metastasis was first described by Karl Thiersch in the 1860s.) [41]

He made a crucial observation that certain cancers (carcinoma in the modern sense) were inherently associated with white blood cells (which are now called macrophages) that produced irritation (inflammation). It was only towards the end of the 20th century that Virchow's theory was taken seriously. [42] It was realised that specific cancers (including those of mesothelioma, lung, prostate, bladder, pancreatic, cervical, esophageal, melanoma, and head and neck) are indeed strongly associated with long-term inflammation. [43] [44] In addition it became clear that prolonged use of anti-inflammatory drugs, such as aspirin, reduced cancer risk. [45] Experiments also show that drugs that block inflammation simultaneously inhibit tumour formation and development. [46]

The Kaiser's case

Virchow was one of the leading physicians to Kaiser Frederick III, who suffered from cancer of the larynx. While other physicians such as Ernst von Bergmann suggested surgical removal of the entire larynx, Virchow was opposed to it because no successful operation of this kind had ever been done. The British surgeon Morell Mackenzie performed a biopsy of the Kaiser in 1887 and sent it to Virchow, who identified it as "pachydermia verrucosa laryngis". Virchow affirmed that the tissues were not cancerous, even after several biopsy tests. [47] [48]

The Kaiser died on 15 June 1888. The next day a post-mortem examination was performed by Virchow and his assistant. They found that the larynx was extensively damaged by ulceration, and microscopic examination confirmed epidermal carcinoma. Die Krankheit Kaiser Friedrich des Dritten (The Medical Report of Kaiser Frederick III) was published on 11 July under the lead authorship of Bergmann. But Virchow and Mackenzie were omitted, and they were particularly criticised for all their works. [49] The arguments between them turned into a century-long controversy, resulting in Virchow being accused of misdiagnosis and malpractice. But reassessment of the diagnostic history revealed that Virchow was right in his findings and decisions. It is now believed that the Kaiser had hybrid verrucous carcinoma, a very rare form of verrucous carcinoma, and that Virchow had no way of correctly identifying it. [47] [48] [50] (The cancer type was correctly identified only in 1948 by Lauren Ackerman.) [51] [52]

Anatomy

It was discovered approximately simultaneously by Virchow and Charles Emile Troisier that an enlarged left supraclavicular node is one of the earliest signs of gastrointestinal malignancy, commonly of the stomach, or less commonly, lung cancer. This sign has become known as Virchow's node and simultaneously Troisier's sign. [53] [54]

Thromboembolism

Virchow is also known for elucidating the mechanism of pulmonary thromboembolism (a condition of blood clotting in the blood vessels), coining the terms embolism and thrombosis. [55] He noted that blood clots in the pulmonary artery originate first from venous thrombi, stating in 1859:

[T]he detachment of larger or smaller fragments from the end of the softening thrombus which are carried along by the current of blood and driven into remote vessels. This gives rise to the very frequent process on which I have bestowed the name of Embolia." [56]

Having made these initial discoveries based on autopsies, he proceeded to put forward a scientific hypothesis; that pulmonary thrombi are transported from the veins of the leg and that the blood has the ability to carry such an object. He then proceeded to prove this hypothesis by well-designed experiments, repeated numerous times to consolidate evidence, and with meticulously detailed methodology. This work rebutted a claim made by the eminent French pathologist Jean Cruveilhier that phlebitis led to clot development and that thus coagulation was the main consequence of venous inflammation. This was a view held by many before Virchow's work. Related to this research, Virchow described the factors contributing to venous thrombosis, Virchow's triad. [20] [57]

Pathology

Virchow founded the medical fields of cellular pathology and comparative pathology (comparison of diseases common to humans and animals). His most important work in the field was Cellular Pathology (Die Cellularpathologie in ihrer Begründung auf physiologische und pathologische Gewebelehre) published in 1858, as a collection of his lectures. [25] This is regarded as the basis of modern medical science, [58] and the "greatest advance which scientific medicine had made since its beginning." [59]

His very innovative work may be viewed as between that of Giovanni Battista Morgagni, whose work Virchow studied, and that of Paul Ehrlich, who studied at the Charité while Virchow was developing microscopic pathology there. One of Virchow's major contributions to German medical education was to encourage the use of microscopes by medical students, and he was known for constantly urging his students to "think microscopically". He was the first to establish a link between infectious diseases between humans and animals, for which he coined the term "zoonoses". [60] He also introduced scientific terms such as "chromatin", "agenesis", "parenchyma", "osteoid", "amyloid degeneration", and "spina bifida". [61] His concepts on pathology directly opposed humourism, an ancient medical dogma that diseases were due to imbalanced body fluids, hypothetically called humours, that still pervaded. [62]

Parasitology

Virchow worked out the life cycle of a roundworm Trichinella spiralis . Virchow noticed a mass of circular white flecks in the muscle of dog and human cadavers, similar to those described by Richard Owen in 1835. He confirmed by microscopic observation that the white particles were indeed the larvae of roundworms, curled up in the muscle tissue. Rudolph Leukart found that these tiny worms could develop into adult roundworms in the intestine of a dog. He correctly asserted that these worms could also cause human helminthiasis. Virchow further demonstrated that if the infected meat is first heated to 137 °F for 10 minutes, the worms could not infect dogs or humans. [63] He established that human roundworm infection occurs via contaminated pork. This directly led to the establishment of meat inspection, which was first adopted in Berlin. [64] [65]

Autopsy

Virchow was the first to develop a systematic method of autopsy, based on his knowledge of cellular pathology. The modern autopsy still constitutes his techniques. [66] His first significant autopsy was on a 50-year-old woman in 1845. He found an unusual number of white blood cells, and gave a detailed description in 1847 and named the condition as leukämie. [67] One on his autopsies in 1857 was the first description of vertebral disc rupture. [18] [68] His autopsy on a baby in 1856 was the first description of congenital pulmonary lymphangiectasia (the name given by K. M. Laurence a century later), a rare and fatal disease of the lung. [69] From his experience of post-mortem examinations of cadavers, he published his method in a small book in 1876. [70] His book was the first to describe the techniques of autopsy specifically to examine abnormalities in organs, and retain important tissues for further examination and demonstration. Unlike any other earlier practitioner, he practiced complete surgery of all body parts with body organs dissected one by one. This has become the standard method. [71] [72]

Ochronosis

Virchow discovered the clinical syndrome which he called ochronosis, a metabolic disorder in which a patient accumulates homogentisic acid in connective tissues and which can be identified by discolouration seen under the microscope. He found the unusual symptom in an autopsy of the corpse of a 67-year-old man on 8 May 1884. This was the first time this abnormal disease affecting cartilage and connective tissue was observed and characterised. His description and coining of the name appeared in the October 1866 issue of Virchows Archiv. [73] [74] [75]

Forensic work

Virchow was the first to analyse hair in criminal investigation, and made the first forensic report on it in 1861. [76] He was called as an expert witness in a murder case, and he used hair samples collected from the victim. He became the first to recognise the limitation of hair as evidence. He found that hairs can be different in an individual, that individual hair has characteristic features, and that hairs from different individuals can be strikingly similar. He concluded that evidence based on hair analysis is inconclusive. [77] His testimony runs:

[T]he hairs found on the defendant do not possess any so pronounced peculiarities or individualities [so] that no one with certainty has the right to assert that they must have originated from the head of the victim. [12]

Anthropology and prehistory biology

Portrait of Rudolf Virchow by Hugo Vogel, 1861 Rudolf Virchow by Hugo Vogel, 1861.JPG
Portrait of Rudolf Virchow by Hugo Vogel, 1861

Virchow developed an interest in anthropology in 1865, when he discovered pile dwellings in northern Germany. In 1869, he co-founded the German Anthropological Association. In 1870 he founded the Berlin Society for Anthropology, Ethnology, and Prehistory (Berliner Gesellschaft für Anthropologie, Ethnologie und Urgeschichte) which was very influential in coordinating and intensifying German archaeological research. Until his death, Virchow was several times (at least fifteen times) its president, often taking turns with his former student Adolf Bastian. [7] As president, Virchow frequently contributed to and co-edited the society's main journal Zeitschrift für Ethnologie (Journal of Ethnology), which Adolf Bastian, together with another student of Virchow, Robert Hartman, had founded in 1869. [78] [79]

In 1870, he led a major excavation of the hill forts in Pomerania. He also excavated wall mounds in Wöllstein in 1875 with Robert Koch, whose paper he edited on the subject. [16] For his contributions in German archaeology, the Rudolf Virchow lecture is held annually in his honour. He made field trips to Asia Minor, the Caucasus, Egypt, Nubia, and other places, sometimes in the company of Heinrich Schliemann. His 1879 journey to the site of Troy is described in Beiträge zur Landeskunde in Troas ("Contributions to the knowledge of the landscape in Troy", 1879) and Alttrojanische Gräber und Schädel ("Old Trojan graves and skulls", 1882). [21] [80]

Anti-Darwinism

Virchow was an opponent of Darwin's theory of evolution, [81] [82] and particularly skeptical of the emergent thesis of human evolution. [83] [84] He did not reject evolutionary theory as a whole, and viewed the theory of natural as "an immeasurable advance" but that still has no "actual proof." [85] On 22 September 1877, he delivered a public address entitled "The Freedom of Science in the Modern State" before the Congress of German Naturalists and Physicians in Munich. There he spoke against the teaching of the theory of evolution in schools, arguing that it was as yet an unproven hypothesis that lacked empirical foundations and that, therefore, its teaching would negatively affect scientific studies. [86] [87] Ernst Haeckel, who had been Virchow's student, later reported that his former professor said that "it is quite certain that man did not descend from the apes...not caring in the least that now almost all experts of good judgment hold the opposite conviction." [88]

Virchow became one of the leading opponents on the debate over the authenticity of Neanderthal, discovered in 1856, as distinct species and ancestral to modern humans. He himself examined the original fossil in 1872, and presented his observations before the Berliner Gesellschaft für Anthropologie, Ethnologie und Urgeschichte. [7] He stated that the Neanderthal had not been a primitive form of human, but an abnormal human being, who, judging by the shape of his skull, had been injured and deformed, and considering the unusual shape of his bones, had been arthritic, rickety, and feeble. [89] [90] [91] With such an authority, the fossil was rejected as new species. With this reasoning, Virchow "judged Darwin an ignoramus and Haeckel a fool and was loud and frequent in the publication of these judgments," [92] and declared that "it is quite certain that man did not descend from the apes." [93] The Neanderthals were later accepted as distinct species of humans, Homo neanderthalensis. [94] [95]

On 22 September 1877, at the Fiftieth Conference of the German Association of Naturalists and Physician held in Munich, Haeckel pleaded for introducing evolution in the public school curricula, and tried to dissociate Darwinism from social Darwinism. [96] His campaign was because of Herman Müller, a school teacher who was banned because of his teaching a year earlier on the inanimate origin of life from carbon. This resulted in prolonged public debate with Virchow. A few days later Virchow responded that Darwinism was only a hypothesis, and morally dangerous to students. This severe criticism of Darwinism was immediately taken up by the London Times , from which further debates erupted among English scholars. Haeckel wrote his arguments in the October issue of Nature titled "The Present Position of Evolution Theory", to which Virchow responded in the next issue with an article "The Liberty of Science in the Modern State". [97] Virchow stated that teaching of evolution was "contrary to the conscience of the natural scientists, who reckons only with facts." [85] The debate led Haeckel to write a full book Freedom in Science and Teaching in 1879. That year the issue was discussed in the Prussian House of Representatives and the verdict was in favour of Virchow. In 1882 the Prussian education policy officially excluded natural history in schools. [98]

Years later, the noted German physician Carl Ludwig Schleich would recall a conversation he held with Virchow, who was a close friend of his: "...On to the subject of Darwinism. 'I don't believe in all this,' Virchow told me. 'if I lie on my sofa and blow the possibilities away from me, as another man may blow the smoke of his cigar, I can, of course, sympathize with such dreams. But they don't stand the test of knowledge. Haeckel is a fool. That will be apparent one day. As far as that goes, if anything like transmutation did occur it could only happen in the course of pathological degeneration!'" [99]

Virchow's ultimate opinion about evolution was reported a year before he died; in his own words:

The intermediate form is unimaginable save in a dream... We cannot teach or consent that it is an achievement that man descended from the ape or other animal.

Homiletic Review, January, (1901) [100] [101]

Virchow's anti-evolutionism, like that of Albert von Kölliker and Thomas Brown, did not come from religion, since he was not a believer. [14]

Anti-racism

Virchow believed that Haeckel's monist propagation of social Darwinism was in its nature politically dangerous and anti-democratic, and he also criticized it because he saw it as related to the emergent nationalist movement in Germany, ideas about cultural superiority, [102] [103] [104] and militarism. [105] In 1885, he launched a study of craniometry, which gave results contradictory to contemporary scientific racist theories on the "Aryan race", leading him to denounce the "Nordic mysticism" at the 1885 Anthropology Congress in Karlsruhe. Josef Kollmann, a collaborator of Virchow, stated at the same congress that the people of Europe, be they German, Italian, English or French, belonged to a "mixture of various races", further declaring that the "results of craniology" led to a "struggle against any theory concerning the superiority of this or that European race" over others. [106] He analysed the hair, skin, and eye colour of 6,758,827 schoolchildren to identify the Jews and Aryans. His findings, published in 1886 and concluding that there could be neither a Jewish nor a German race, were regarded as a blow to anti-Semitism and the existence of an "Aryan race". [13] [107]

Anti-germ theory of diseases

Virchow did not believe in the germ theory of diseases, as advocated by Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch. He proposed that diseases came from abnormal activities inside the cells, not from outside pathogens. [60] He believed that epidemics were social in origin, and the way to combat epidemics was political, not medical. He regarded germ theory as a hindrance to prevention and cure. He considered social factors such as poverty major causes of disease. [108] He even attacked Koch's and Ignaz Semmelweis' policy of handwashing as an antiseptic practice, who said of him: "Explorers of nature recognize no bugbears other than individuals who speculate." [62] He postulated that germs were only using infected organs as habitats, but were not the cause, and stated, "If I could live my life over again, I would devote it to proving that germs seek their natural habitat: diseased tissue, rather than being the cause of diseased tissue". [109]

Politics and social medicine

Rudolf Virchow Rudolf Virchow NLM4.jpg
Rudolf Virchow

More than a laboratory physician, Virchow was an impassioned advocate for social and political reform. His ideology involved social inequality as the cause of diseases that requires political actions, [110] stating:

Medicine is a social science, and politics is nothing else but medicine on a large scale. Medicine, as a social science, as the science of human beings, has the obligation to point out problems and to attempt their theoretical solution: the politician, the practical anthropologist, must find the means for their actual solution... Science for its own sake usually means nothing more than science for the sake of the people who happen to be pursuing it. Knowledge which is unable to support action is not genuine – and how unsure is activity without understanding... If medicine is to fulfill her great task, then she must enter the political and social life... The physicians are the natural attorneys of the poor, and the social problems should largely be solved by them. [111] [112] [113]

Virchow actively worked for social change to fight poverty and diseases. His methods involved pathological observations and statistical analyses. He called this new field of social medicine a "social science". His most important influences could be noted in Latin America, where his disciples introduced his social medicine. [114] For example, his student Max Westenhöfer became Director of Pathology at the medical school of the University of Chile, becoming the most influential advocate. One of Westenhöfer's students, Salvador Allende, through social and political activities based on Virchow's doctrine, became the 29th President of Chile (1970–1973). [115]

Virchow made himself known as a pronounced pro-democracy progressive in the year of revolutions in Germany (1848). His political views are evident in his Report on the Typhus Outbreak of Upper Silesia, where he states that the outbreak could not be solved by treating individual patients with drugs or with minor changes in food, housing, or clothing laws, but only through radical action to promote the advancement of an entire population, which could be achieved only by "full and unlimited democracy" and "education, freedom and prosperity". [24]

These radical statements and his minor part in the revolution caused the government to remove him from his position in 1849, although within a year he was reinstated as prosector "on probation". Prosector was a secondary position in the hospital. This secondary position in Berlin convinced him to accept the chair of pathological anatomy at the medical school in the provincial town of Würzburg, where he continued his scientific research. Six years later, he had attained fame in scientific and medical circles, and was reinstated at Charité Hospital. [20]

In 1859, he became a member of the Municipal Council of Berlin and began his career as a civic reformer. Elected to the Prussian Diet in 1862, he became leader of the Radical or Progressive party; and from 1880 to 1893, he was a member of the Reichstag. [21] He worked to improve healthcare conditions for Berlin citizens, especially by working towards modern water and sewer systems. Virchow is credited as a founder of anthropology [116] and of social medicine, frequently focusing on the fact that disease is never purely biological, but often socially derived or spread. [117]

The Sausage Duel

As a co-founder and member of the liberal party Deutsche Fortschrittspartei, he was a leading political antagonist of Bismarck. He was opposed to Bismarck's excessive military budget, which angered Bismarck sufficiently that he challenged Virchow to a duel in 1865. [21] One version of the events has Virchow declining because he considered dueling an uncivilized way to solve a conflict. A second version has passed into legend, but was well documented in the contemporary scientific literature. It has Virchow, being the one challenged and therefore entitled to choose the weapons, selecting two pork sausages, one loaded with Trichinella larvae, the other safe; Bismarck declined. [60] [118] [119]

Kulturkampf

Virchow supported Bismarck in an attempt to reduce the political and social influence of the Catholic Church, between 1871 and 1887. [120] He remarked that the movement was acquiring "the character of a great struggle in the interest of humanity". He called it Kulturkampf ("culture struggle") [6] during the discussion of Paul Ludwig Falk's May Laws (Maigesetze). [121] Virchow was respected in Masonic circles, [122] and according to one source [123] may have been a freemason, though no official record of this has been found.

Personal life

Rudolf and Rose Virchow in 1851 Rudolf and Rose Virchow 1851.jpg
Rudolf and Rose Virchow in 1851
Virchow with his son Ernst and daughter Adele Virchow, Rudolf, Ernst und Adele.jpg
Virchow with his son Ernst and daughter Adele

On 24 August 1850 in Berlin, Virchow married Ferdinande Rosalie Mayer (29 February 1832 21 February 1913), a liberal's daughter. They had three sons and three daughters: [124]

Virchow was an agnostic . [62]

Death

The tomb of Rudolf and Rose Virchow at Alter St.-Matthaus-Kirchhof Grab Rudolf Virchow.jpg
The tomb of Rudolf and Rose Virchow at Alter St.-Matthäus-Kirchhof

Virchow broke his thigh bone on 4 January 1902, jumping off a running streetcar while exiting the electric tramway. Although he anticipated full recovery, the fractured femur never healed, and restricted his physical activity. His health gradually deteriorated and he died of heart failure after eight months, on 5 September 1902, in Berlin. [16] [125] A state funeral was held on 9 September in the Assembly Room of the Magistracy in the Berlin Town Hall, which was decorated with laurels, palms and flowers. He was buried in the Alter St.-Matthäus-Kirchhof in Schöneberg, Berlin. [126] His tomb was shared by his wife on 21 February 1913. [127]

Honours and legacy

Hospital - Campus Virchow Klinikum, Cardiology Center Berlin-Wedding Virchow-Klinikum 06 Herzzentrum.jpg
Hospital – Campus Virchow Klinikum, Cardiology Center

Eponymous medical terms

  • Virchow's angle, the angle between the nasobasilar line and the nasosubnasal line
  • Virchow's cell, a macrophage in Hansen's disease
  • Virchow's cell theory, omnis cellula e cellula – every living cell comes from another living cell
  • Virchow's concept of pathology, comparison of diseases common to humans and animals
  • Virchow's disease, leontiasis ossea, now recognized as a symptom rather than a disease
  • Virchow's gland, Virchow's node
  • Virchow's Law, during craniosynostosis, skull growth is restricted to a plane perpendicular to the affected, prematurely fused suture and is enhanced in a plane parallel to it.
  • Virchow's line, a line from the root of the nose to the lambda
  • Virchow's metamorphosis, lipomatosis in the heart and salivary glands
  • Virchow's method of autopsy, a method of autopsy where each organ is taken out one by one
  • Virchow's node , the presence of metastatic cancer in a lymph node in the supraclavicular fossa (root of the neck left of the midline), also known as Troisier's sign
  • Virchow's psammoma, psammoma bodies in meningiomas
  • Virchow–Robin spaces , enlarged perivascular spaces (EPVS) (often only potential) that surround blood vessels for a short distance as they enter the brain
  • Virchow–Seckel syndrome , a very rare disease also known as "bird-headed dwarfism"
  • Virchow skull breaker, a chisel-like device used to separate the calvaria from the rest of the skull to expose the brain in autopsies
  • Virchow's triad , the classic factors which precipitate venous thrombus formation: endothelial dysfunction or injury, hemodynamic changes, and hypercoagulability

Works

Virchow was a prolific writer. Some of his works are: [136]

Related Research Articles

Robert Koch 19/20th-century German physician and bacteriologist

Heinrich Hermann Robert Koch was a German physician and microbiologist. As the discoverer of the specific causative agents of deadly infectious diseases including tuberculosis, cholera, and anthrax, he is regarded as one of the main founders of modern bacteriology. As such he is popularly nicknamed the father of microbiology, and as the father of medical bacteriology. His discovery of the anthrax bacterium in 1876 is considered as the birth of modern bacteriology. His discoveries directly provided proofs for the germ theory of diseases, and the scientific basis of public health.

Pathology Study of the causes and effects of disease or injury, also how they arise

Pathology is the study of the causes and effects of disease or injury. The word pathology also refers to the study of disease in general, incorporating a wide range of biology research fields and medical practices. However, when used in the context of modern medical treatment, the term is often used in a more narrow fashion to refer to processes and tests which fall within the contemporary medical field of "general pathology", an area which includes a number of distinct but inter-related medical specialties that diagnose disease, mostly through analysis of tissue, cell, and body fluid samples. Idiomatically, "a pathology" may also refer to the predicted or actual progression of particular diseases, and the affix pathy is sometimes used to indicate a state of disease in cases of both physical ailment and psychological conditions. A physician practicing pathology is called a pathologist.

Élie Metchnikoff 19th and 20th-century Russian and French immunologist, embryologist, biologist, and Nobel laureat

Ilya Ilyich Mechnikov was a Russian Imperial zoologist of Romanian nobility ancestry and Ukrainian Jewish origin best known for his pioneering research in immunology. He and Paul Ehrlich were jointly awarded the 1908 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine "in recognition of their work on immunity". He was born, lived and worked for many years on the territory of Ukraine. Given this complex heritage, four different nations and peoples justifiably lay claim to Mechnikov.

Victor Babeș Romanian physician and professor

Victor Babeș was a Romanian physician, bacteriologist, academician and professor. One of the founders of modern microbiology, Victor Babeș is author of one of the first treatises of bacteriology in the world – Bacteria and their role in pathological anatomy and histology of infectious diseases, written in collaboration with French scientist Victor André Cornil in 1885. In 1888, Babeș underlies the principle of passive immunity, and a few years later enunciates the principle of antibiosis. He made early and significant contributions to the study of rabies, leprosy, diphtheria, tuberculosis and other infectious diseases. He also discovered more than 50 unknown germs and foresaw new methods of staining bacteria and fungi. Victor Babeș introduced rabies vaccination and founded serotherapy in Romania.

Pathophysiology – a convergence of pathology with physiology – is the study of the disordered physiological processes that cause, result from, or are otherwise associated with a disease or injury. Pathology is the medical discipline that describes conditions typically observed during a disease state, whereas physiology is the biological discipline that describes processes or mechanisms operating within an organism. Pathology describes the abnormal or undesired condition, whereas pathophysiology seeks to explain the functional changes that are occurring within an individual due to a disease or pathologic state.

James Paget

Sir James Paget, 1st Baronet FRS HFRSE was an English surgeon and pathologist who is best remembered for naming Paget's disease and who is considered, together with Rudolf Virchow, as one of the founders of scientific medical pathology. His famous works included Lectures on Tumours (1851) and Lectures on Surgical Pathology (1853). There are several medical conditions which were described and later named after Paget:

Charité University hospital in Berlin

The Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin is one of Europe's largest university hospitals, affiliated with Humboldt University and Free University Berlin. With numerous Collaborative Research Centres (CRC) of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft it is one of Germany's most research-intensive medical institutions. From 2012 to 2020, it was ranked by Focus as the best of over 1000 hospitals in Germany. In 2019, 2020 and 2021 Newsweek ranked the Charité as sixth best hospital in the world and best in Europe. More than half of all German Nobel Prize winners in Physiology or Medicine, including Emil von Behring, Robert Koch and Paul Ehrlich, have worked at the Charité. Several politicians and diplomats have been treated at the Charité, including German Chancellor Angela Merkel, who underwent meniscus treatment at the Orthopaedic Department, Yulia Tymoshenko from Ukraine, and, more recently, Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny, who had received treatment at the hospital due to his poisoning in August 2020.

Edwin Klebs

Theodor Albrecht Edwin Klebs was a German-Swiss microbiologist. He is mainly known for his work on infectious diseases. His works paved the way for the beginning of modern bacteriology, and inspired Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch. He was the first to identify a bacterium that causes diphtheria, which was called Klebs–Loeffler bacterium. He was the father of physician Arnold Klebs.

Johann Lukas Schönlein

Johann Lukas Schönlein was a German naturalist, and professor of medicine, born in Bamberg. He studied medicine at Landshut, Jena, Göttingen, and Würzburg. After teaching at Würzburg and Zurich, he was called to Berlin in 1839, where he taught therapeutics and pathology. He served as physician to Frederick William IV.

Friedrich Daniel von Recklinghausen German pathologist

Friedrich Daniel von Recklinghausen was a German pathologist born in Gütersloh, Westphalia. He was the father of physiologist Heinrich von Recklinghausen (1867–1942).

Robert Remak Polish/German embryologist, physiologist, and neurologist

Robert Remak was a Jewish Polish-German embryologist, physiologist, and neurologist, born in Posen, Prussia, who discovered that the origin of cells was by the division of pre-existing cells. as well as several other key discoveries.

Giulio Bizzozero Italian physician

Giulio Bizzozero was an Italian doctor and medical researcher. He was a pioneer of histology and is credited with the coining of the term platelets and identifying their function in coagulation.

Johann Friedrich Meckel German anatomist

Johann Friedrich Meckel, often referred to as Johann Friedrich Meckel, the Younger, was a German anatomist born in Halle. He worked as a professor of anatomy, pathology and zoology at the University of Halle, Germany.

Supraclavicular lymph nodes

Supraclavicular lymph nodes are lymph nodes found above the clavicle, that can be felt in the supraclavicular fossa. The supraclavicular lymph nodes on the left side are called Virchow's nodes. It leads to an appreciable mass that can be recognized clinically, called Troisier sign.

Benno Ernst Heinrich Reinhardt was a German physician who worked as prosector at Charité hospital in Berlin. He is known for his contributions to pathology, especially as co-founder of the journal Virchows Archiv.

The history of pathology can be traced to the earliest application of the scientific method to the field of medicine, a development which occurred in the Middle East during the Islamic Golden Age and in Western Europe during the Italian Renaissance.

Cancer cell Tumor cell

Cancer cells are cells that divide continually, forming solid tumors or flooding the blood with abnormal cells. Cell division is a normal process used by the body for growth and repair. A parent cell divides to form two daughter cells, and these daughter cells are used to build new tissue or to replace cells that have died because of aging or damage. Healthy cells stop dividing when there is no longer a need for more daughter cells, but cancer cells continue to produce copies. They are also able to spread from one part of the body to another in a process known as metastasis.

Max Westenhöfer was a German pathologist and biologist who contributed to the development of the anatomic pathology and the reform of public health in Chile.

Corrado Tommasi-Crudeli

Corrado Tommasi-Crudeli was an Italian physician known for his works in pathology and hygiene. He studied for his medical degree at the University of Pisa. He was trained in pathology under the German pathologist Rudolf Virchow. He worked in medical services at Florence, Palermo, and Rome. He was Chair of Pathology at the Sapienza University of Rome. He was known to the public for his service during cholera outbreak and in establishing hospitals, particularly the Institute for Experimental Hygiene in Rome. He was elected to Italian Senate during 1892–1893. He, with Edwin Klebs, discovered that typhoid and diphtheria were caused by bacteria. However, they made a mistake in declaring that a bacterium was also responsible for malaria.

Virchows Archiv: European Journal of Pathology is a monthly peer-reviewed medical journal of all aspects of pathology, especially human pathology. It is published by Springer Science+Business Media and an official publication of the European Society of Pathology. It was established in 1847 by Rudolf Virchow and his friend Benno Reinhardt as the Archiv für pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin. After Virchow's death, it was renamed after him to Virchows Archiv für pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medizin. The European Society of Pathology adopted it as its official journal in 1999, so that its current name became Virchows Archiv: European Journal of Pathology.

References

  1. "Virchow". The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language .
  2. Duden – Virchow
  3. Silver, G A (1987). "Virchow, the heroic model in medicine: health policy by accolade". American Journal of Public Health. 77 (1): 82–88. doi:10.2105/AJPH.77.1.82. PMC   1646803 . PMID   3538915.
  4. Nordenström, Jörgen (2012). The Hunt for the Parathyroids. Chichester, West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons. p. 10. ISBN   978-1-118-34339-5.
  5. Huisman, Frank; Warner, John Harley (2004). Locating Medical History: The Stories and Their Meanings. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. p. 415. ISBN   978-0-8018-7861-9.
  6. 1 2 "Kulturkampf". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 27 November 2014.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Buikstra, Jane E.; Roberts, Charlotte A. (2012). The Global History of Paleopathology: Pioneers and Prospects. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 388–390. ISBN   978-0-1953-8980-7.
  8. 1 2 Kuiper, Kathleen (2010). The Britannica Guide to Theories and Ideas That Changed the Modern World. New York, NY: Britannica Educational Pub. in association with Rosen Educational Services. p. 28. ISBN   978-1-61530-029-7.
  9. Skoczylas, M; Pierzak-Sominka, J; Rudnicki, J (2013). "O formach aktywności dydaktycznej Rudolfa Virchowa w zakresie medycyny". Problems of Applied Sciences. 1: 197–200.
  10. "Zeitschrift für Ethnologie" . Retrieved 29 November 2014.
  11. "Rudolf Virchow". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 29 November 2014.
  12. 1 2 Oien, Cary T (2009). "Forensic Hair Comparison: Background Information for Interpretation". Forensic Science Communications. 11 (2): Online.
  13. 1 2 Silberstein, Laurence J.; Cohn, Robert L. (1994). The Other in Jewish Thought and History: Constructions of Jewish Culture and Identity. New York: New York University Press. pp. 375–376. ISBN   978-0-8147-7990-3.
  14. 1 2 Glick, Thomas F. (1988). The Comparative reception of Darwinism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. pp. 86–87. ISBN   978-0-226-29977-8.
  15. "Virchow, Rudolf". Appletons' Cyclopaedia for 1902. NY: D. Appleton & Company. 1903. pp. 520–521.
  16. 1 2 3 4 Weisenberg, Elliot (2009). "Rudolf Virchow, pathologist, anthropologist, and social thinker". Hektoen International Journal. Online. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  17. 1 2 "Rudolf Ludwig Carl Virchow". Encyclopedia of World Biography. HighBeam™ Research, Inc. 2004. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  18. 1 2 Weller, Carl Vernon (1921). "Rudolf Virchow—Pathologist". The Scientific Monthly. 13 (1): 33–39. Bibcode:1921SciMo..13...33W. JSTOR   6580.
  19. 1 2 "Rudolf Ludwig Karl Virchow". Whonamedit?. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  20. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Bagot, Catherine N.; Arya, Roopen (2008). "Virchow and his triad: a question of attribution". British Journal of Haematology. 143 (2): 180–190. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2141.2008.07323.x. ISSN   1365-2141. PMID   18783400. S2CID   33756942.
  21. 1 2 3 4 Rines, George Edwin, ed. (1920). "Virchow, Rudolf"  . Encyclopedia Americana .
  22. Taylor, R; Rieger, A (1985). "Medicine as social science: Rudolf Virchow on the typhus epidemic in Upper Silesia". International Journal of Health Services. 15 (4): 547–559. doi:10.2190/xx9v-acd4-kuxd-c0e5. PMID   3908347. S2CID   44723532.
  23. Azar, HA (1997). "Rudolf Virchow, not just a pathologist: a re-examination of the report on the typhus epidemic in Upper Silesia". Annals of Diagnostic Pathology. 1 (1): 65–71. doi:10.1016/S1092-9134(97)80010-X. PMID   9869827.
  24. 1 2 Brown, Theodore M.; Fee, Elizabeth (2006). "Rudolf Carl Virchow". American Journal of Public Health. 96 (12): 2104–2105. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2005.078436. PMC   1698150 . PMID   17077410.
  25. 1 2 3 4 "Virchow's Biography". Berliner Medizinhistorisches Museum der Charité. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  26. 1 2 Boak, Arthur ER (1921). "Rudolf Virchow—Anthropologist and Archeologist". The Scientific Monthly. 13 (1): 40–45. Bibcode:1921SciMo..13...40B. JSTOR   6581.
  27. Lois N. Magner A history of the life sciences, Marcel Dekker, 2002, ISBN   0-8247-0824-5, p. 185
  28. Rutherford, Adam (August 2009). "The Cell: Episode 1 The Hidden Kingdom". BBC4.
  29. Gardner, D. John Goodsir FRS (1814–1867): Pioneer of cytology and microbiology. J Med. Biog. 2015;25:114–122
  30. Tixier-Vidal, Andrée (2011). "De la théorie cellulaire à la théorie neuronale". Biologie Aujourd'hui (in French). 204 (4): 253–266. doi:10.1051/jbio/2010015. PMID   21215242.
  31. Tan SY, Brown J (July 2006). "Rudolph Virchow (1821–1902): "pope of pathology"" (PDF). Singapore Med J. 47 (7): 567–8. PMID   16810425.
  32. Virchow, R. (1858). Cellular pathology: As based upon physiological and pathological histology, 20 lectures delivered in the Pathological Institute of Berlin, during Feb. Mar. and Apr. 1858. New York: De Witt.
  33. Degos, L (2001). "John Hughes Bennett, Rudolph Virchow... and Alfred Donné: the first description of leukemia". The Hematology Journal. 2 (1): 1. doi:10.1038/sj/thj/6200090. PMID   11920227.
  34. Kampen, Kim R. (2012). "The discovery and early understanding of leukemia". Leukemia Research. 36 (1): 6–13. doi:10.1016/j.leukres.2011.09.028. PMID   22033191.
  35. Mukherjee, Siddhartha (16 November 2010). The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer. Simon and Schuster. ISBN   978-1-4391-0795-9 . Retrieved 6 September 2011.
  36. Hirsch, Edwin F (1923). "Sacrococcygeal Chordoma". JAMA. 80 (19): 1369–70. doi:10.1001/jama.1923.02640460019007.
  37. Lopes, Ademar; Rossi, Benedito Mauro; Silveira, Claudio Regis Sampaio; Alves, Antonio Correa (1996). "Chordoma: retrospective analysis of 24 cases". Sao Paulo Medical Journal. 114 (6): 1312–1316. doi:10.1590/S1516-31801996000600006. PMID   9269106.
  38. Wagner, RP (1999). "Anecdotal, historical and critical commentaries on genetics. Rudolph Virchow and the genetic basis of somatic ecology". Genetics. 151 (3): 917–920. doi:10.1093/genetics/151.3.917. PMC   1460541 . PMID   10049910.
  39. Goldthwaite, Charles A. (20 November 2011). "Are Stem Cells Involved in Cancer?". National Institutes of Health. Retrieved 22 December 2014.
  40. "The History of Cancer". American Cancer Society, Inc. Retrieved 22 December 2014.
  41. Mandal, Aranya (2 December 2009). "Cancer History". News-Medical.net. Retrieved 22 December 2014.
  42. Balkwill, Fran; Mantovani, Alberto (2001). "Inflammation and cancer: back to Virchow?". The Lancet. 357 (9255): 539–545. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(00)04046-0. PMID   11229684. S2CID   1730949.
  43. Coussens, LM; Werb, Z (2002). "Inflammation and cancer". Nature. 420 (6917): 860–867. Bibcode:2002Natur.420..860C. doi:10.1038/nature01322. PMC   2803035 . PMID   12490959.
  44. Ostrand-Rosenberg, S.; Sinha, P. (2009). "Myeloid-derived suppressor cells: linking inflammation and cancer". The Journal of Immunology. 182 (8): 4499–4506. doi:10.4049/jimmunol.0802740. PMC   2810498 . PMID   19342621.
  45. Baron, John A.; Sandler, Robert S. (2000). "Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and cancer prevention". Annual Review of Medicine. 51 (1): 511–523. doi:10.1146/annurev.med.51.1.511. PMID   10774479.
  46. Mantovani, Alberto; Allavena, Paola; Sica, Antonio; Balkwill, Frances (2008). "Cancer-related inflammation" (PDF). Nature. 454 (7203): 436–444. Bibcode:2008Natur.454..436M. doi:10.1038/nature07205. hdl:2434/145688. PMID   18650914. S2CID   4429118.
  47. 1 2 Cardesa, Antonio; Zidar, Nina; Alos, Llucia; Nadal, Alfons; Gale, Nina; Klöppel, Günter (2011). "The Kaiser's cancer revisited: was Virchow totally wrong?". Virchows Archiv. 458 (6): 649–657. doi:10.1007/s00428-011-1075-0. PMID   21494762. S2CID   23301771.
  48. 1 2 Ober, WB (1970). "The case of the Kaiser's cancer". Pathology Annual. 5: 207–216. PMID   4939999.
  49. Lucas, Charles T. "Virchow's mistake". The Innominate Society of Louisville. Retrieved 27 November 2014.
  50. Wagener, D.J.Th. (2009). The History of Oncology. Houten: Springer. pp. 104–105. ISBN   978-9-0313-6143-4.
  51. Oliva, H; Aguilera, B (1986). "The harmful biopsies of Kaiser Frederick III". Revista Clinica Espanola (in Spanish). 178 (8): 409–411. PMID   3526428.
  52. Depprich, Rita A.; Handschel, Jörg G.; Fritzemeier, Claus U.; Engers, Rainer; Kübler, Norbert R. (2006). "Hybrid verrucous carcinoma of the oral cavity: A challenge for the clinician and the pathologist". Oral Oncology Extra. 42 (2): 85–90. doi:10.1016/j.ooe.2005.09.006.
  53. Loh, Keng Yin; Yushak, Abd Wahab (2007). "Virchow's Node (Troisier's Sign)". New England Journal of Medicine. 357 (3): 282. doi:10.1056/NEJMicm063871. PMID   17634463.
  54. Sundriyal, D; Kumar, N; Dubey, S. K; Walia, M (2013). "Virchow's node". BMJ Case Reports. 2013: bcr2013200749. doi:10.1136/bcr-2013-200749. PMC   3794256 . PMID   24031077.
  55. Kumar, D. R.; Hanlin, E.; Glurich, I.; Mazza, J. J.; Yale, S. H. (2010). "Virchow's contribution to the understanding of thrombosis and cellular biology". Clinical Medicine & Research. 8 (3–4): 168–172. doi:10.3121/cmr.2009.866. PMC   3006583 . PMID   20739582.
  56. Murray, T. Jock (2006). Huth, Edward J. (ed.). Medicine in Quotations: Views of Health and Disease Through the Ages (2 ed.). Philadelphia, US: American College of Physicians. p. 115. ISBN   978-1-93051-367-9.
  57. Dalen, James E. (2003). Venous Thromboembolism. New York: Marcel Decker, Inc. ISBN   978-0-8247-5645-1.
  58. Reese, DM (1998). "Fundamentals—Rudolf Virchow and modern medicine". The Western Journal of Medicine. 169 (2): 105–108. PMC   1305179 . PMID   9735691.
  59. Knatterud, Mary E. (2002). First Do No Harm: Empathy and the Writing of Medical Journal Articles. New York: Routledge. pp. 43–45. ISBN   978-0-4159-3387-2.
  60. 1 2 3 Schultz, Myron (2008). "Rudolf Virchow". Emerg Infect Dis. 14 (9): 1480–1481. doi:10.3201/eid1409.086672. PMC   2603088 .
  61. Titford, M. (21 April 2010). "Rudolf Virchow: Cellular Pathologist". Laboratory Medicine. 41 (5): 311–312. doi:10.1309/LM3GYQTY79CPYLBI.
  62. 1 2 3 Etzioni, Amos; Ochs, Hans D. (2014). Primary Immunodeficiency Disorders: A Historic and Scientific Perspective. Oxford, UK: Elsevier Academic Press. pp. 3–4. ISBN   978-0-12-407179-7.
  63. "Discovery of Life Cycle". Trichinella.org. Archived from the original on 19 March 2014. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  64. Nöckler, K (2000). "Current status of the discussion on the certification of so-called "Trichinella-free areas"". Berliner und Munchener Tierarztliche Wochenschrift. 113 (4): 134–138. PMID   10816912.
  65. Saunders, L. Z. (2000). "Virchow's Contributions to Veterinary Medicine: Celebrated Then, Forgotten Now". Veterinary Pathology. 37 (3): 199–207. doi:10.1354/vp.37-3-199. PMID   10810984. S2CID   19501338.
  66. "Autopsy: History of autopsy". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 26 November 2014.
  67. "Rudolf Virchow (1821–1902)". CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians. 25 (2): 91–92. 1975. doi:10.3322/canjclin.25.2.91. PMID   804974. S2CID   1806845.
  68. Maurice-Williams, R.S. (2013). Spinal Degenerative Disease. Butterworth-Heinemann. p. 2. ISBN   978-1-4831-9340-3.
  69. Hwang, Joon Ho; Kim, Joo Heon; Hwang, Jung Ju; Kim, Kyu Soon; Kim, Seung Yeon (2014). "Pneumonectomy case in a newborn with congenital pulmonary lymphangiectasia". Journal of Korean Medical Science. 29 (4): 609–13. doi:10.3346/jkms.2014.29.4.609. PMC   3991809 . PMID   24753713.
  70. Saukko, Pekka J; Pollak, Stefan (2009). "Autopsy". Wiley Encyclopedia of Forensic Science. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. doi:10.1002/9780470061589.fsa036. ISBN   978-0-470-01826-2.
  71. Finkbeiner, Walter E; Ursell, Philip C; Davis, Richard L (2009). Autopsy Pathology: A Manual and Atlas (2 ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier Health Sciences. p. 6. ISBN   978-1-4160-5453-5.
  72. Skowronek, R; Chowaniec, C (2010). "The evolution of autopsy technique--from Virchow to Virtopsy". Archiwum Medycyny Sadowej I Kryminologii. 60 (1): 48–54. PMID   21180108.
  73. Virchow, RL (1966) [1866]. "Rudolph Virchow on ochronosis.1866". Arthritis and Rheumatism. 9 (1): 66–71. doi:10.1002/art.1780090108. PMID   4952902.
  74. Benedek, Thomas G. (1966). "Rudolph virchow on ochronosis". Arthritis & Rheumatism. 9 (1): 66–71. doi:10.1002/art.1780090108. PMID   4952902.
  75. Wilke, Andreas; Steverding, Dietmar (2009). "Ochronosis as an unusual cause of valvular defect: a case report". Journal of Medical Case Reports. 3 (1): 9302. doi:10.1186/1752-1947-3-9302. PMC   2803825 . PMID   20062791.
  76. Committee on Science, Technology, and Law, Federal Judicial Center, National Research Council, Policy and Global Affairs, Committee on the Development of the Third Edition of the Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence (2011). Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence (3 ed.). US: National Academies Press. p. 112. ISBN   978-0-3092-1425-4.CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  77. Inman, Keith; Rudin, Norah (2000). Principles and Practice of Criminalistics the Profession of Forensic Science. Hoboken: CRC Press. p. 50. ISBN   978-1-4200-3693-0.
  78. "Zeitschrift für Ethnologie: Journal Info". JSTOR. Retrieved 16 July 2019.
  79. "Front Matter". Zeitschrift für Ethnologie. 2: front cover. 1870. JSTOR   23025919.
  80. Reynolds, Francis J., ed. (1921). "Virchow, Rudolf"  . Collier's New Encyclopedia . New York: P. F. Collier & Son Company.
  81. Hodgson, Geoffrey Martin (2006). Economics in the Shadows of Darwin and Marx. Edward Elgar Publishing., p. 14 ISBN   978-1-78100-756-3
  82. Vucinich, Alexanderm (1988), Darwin in Russian Thought. University of California Press. p. 4 ISBN   978-0-520-06283-2
  83. Robert Bernasconi (2003). Race and Anthropology: De la pluralité des races humaines. Thoemmes. p. XII
  84. Ian Tattersall (1995). The Fossil Trail. Oxford paperbacks. Oxford University Press, p. 22 ISBN   978-0-19-510981-8
  85. 1 2 Boak, Arthur E. R. (1921). "Rudolf Virchow–Anthropologist and Archeologist". The Scientific Monthly. 13 (1): 40–45. JSTOR   6581.
  86. Kelly, Alfred (1981). Descent of Darwin: The Popularization of Darwinism in Germany, 1860–1914. UNC Press Books. See: Chapter 4: "Darwinism and the schools". ISBN   978-1-4696-1013-9
  87. Kuklick, Henrika (2009). New History of Anthropology. John Wiley & Sons. pp. 86–87
  88. Smithsonian Institution (1899). Board of Regents Annual Report of the Board of Regents of the Smithsonian Institution. Board of Regents. p. 472
  89. Wendt, H. 1960. Tras la huellas de Adán, 3ª edición. Editorial Noguer, Barcelona-México, 566 pp.
  90. Adam Kupler (1996). The Chosen Primate. Harvard University Press. p. 38 ISBN   978-0-674-12826-2
  91. De Paolo, 'Charles (2002); Human Prehistory in Fiction. McFarland. p. 49 ISBN   978-0-7864-8329-7
  92. American Society of Medical History (1927). Medical Life, Volume 34. Historico-Medico Press. p. 492
  93. Walter, Edward; Scott, Mike (2017). "The life and work of Rudolf Virchow 1821-1902: "Cell theory, thrombosis and the sausage duel"". Journal of the Intensive Care Society. 18 (3): 234–235. doi:10.1177/1751143716663967. PMC   5665122 . PMID   29118836.
  94. White, Suzanna; Gowlett, John A.J.; Grove, Matt (2014). "The place of the Neanderthals in hominin phylogeny". Journal of Anthropological Archaeology. 35: 32–50. doi:10.1016/j.jaa.2014.04.004.
  95. Rogers, Alan R.; Harris, Nathan S.; Achenbach, Alan A. (2020). "Neanderthal-Denisovan ancestors interbred with a distantly related hominin". Science Advances. 6 (8): eaay5483. doi:10.1126/sciadv.aay5483. PMC   7032934 . PMID   32128408.
  96. Weiss, Sheila Faith (1987). Race Hygiene and National Efficiency: The Eugenics of Wilhelm Schallmayer . Berkeley: University of California Press. pp.  67, 179. ISBN   978-0-520-05823-1.
  97. Porter, Theodore M. (2006). Karl Pearson: The Scientific Life in a Statistical Age. Princeton: Princeton University Press. p. 36. ISBN   978-1-400-83570-6.
  98. Weindling, Paul (1993). Health, Race, and German Politics Between National Unification and Nazism, 1870–1945. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 43. ISBN   978-0-521-42397-7.
  99. Schleich, Carl Ludwig (1936). Those were good days, p. 159. (Note: this conversation was taken from Schleich's memoirs Besonnte Vergangenheit (1922), and translated into English by Bernard Miall)
  100. Ronald L. Numbers (1995). Antievolutionism Before World War I: Volume 1 of Garland Reference Library of the Humanities. Taylor & Francis. p. 101. ISBN   978-0-8153-1802-6
  101. Patterson, Alexander (1903). The Other Side of Evolution, Winona Publishing Company, p.79
  102. Hodge, Jonathan; Radick, Gregory (2009). The Cambridge Companion to Darwin (2 ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 238. ISBN   978-0-521-71184-5.
  103. Hawkins, Mike (1998). Social Darwinism in European and American thought, 1860-1945 : Nature as Model and Nature as Threat (Reprinted ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 138. ISBN   978-0-521-57434-1.
  104. Moore, Randy; Decker, Mark; Cotner, Sehoya (2010). Chronology of the Evolution-creationism Controversy. Santa Barbara, Calif.: Greenwood Press/ABC-CLIO. pp.  121–122. ISBN   978-0-313-36287-3.
  105. Regal, Brian (2004). Human Evolution : A Guide to Debates. Santa Barbara, Calif: ABC-Clio. ISBN   978-1-85109-418-9.
  106. Andrea Orsucci, "Ariani, indogermani, stirpi mediterranee: aspetti del dibattito sulle razze europee (1870–1914)" Archived 5 November 2007 at the Wayback Machine , Cromohs, 1998 (in Italian)
  107. Zimmerman, Andrew (2008). "Anti-Semitism as Skill: Rudolf Virchow's Schulstatistik and the Racial Composition of Germany". Central European History. 32 (4): 409–429. doi:10.1017/S0008938900021762. JSTOR   4546903. S2CID   53987293.
  108. "Rudolf Virchow, 1821–1902". The President and Fellows of Harvard College. Retrieved 8 July 2014.
  109. Cayleff, Susan E. (2016). Nature's Path: A History of Naturopathic Healing in America. Hopkins University Press. p. 59. ISBN   978-1-4214-1903-9
  110. Mackenbach, J P (2009). "Politics is nothing but medicine at a larger scale: reflections on public health's biggest idea". Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health. 63 (3): 181–184. doi:10.1136/jech.2008.077032. PMID   19052033. S2CID   24916013.
  111. Wittern-Sterzel, R (2003). "Politics is nothing else than large scale medicine"--Rudolf Virchow and his role in the development of social medicine". Verhandlungen der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Pathologie. 87: 150–157. PMID   16888907.
  112. J R A (2006). "Virchow misquoted, part‐quoted, and the real McCoy". Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 60 (8): 671. PMC   2588080 .
  113. "Rudolf Virchow on Pathology Education". The Pathology Guy. Retrieved 28 November 2014.
  114. Porter, Dorothy (2006). "How did social medicine evolve, and where is it heading?". PLOS Medicine. 3 (10): e399. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0030399. PMC   1621092 . PMID   17076552.
  115. Waitzkin, H; Iriart, C; Estrada, A; Lamadrid, S (2001). "Social medicine then and now: lessons from Latin America". American Journal of Public Health. 91 (10): 1592–601. doi:10.2105/ajph.91.10.1592. PMC   1446835 . PMID   11574316.
  116. Rx for Survival. Global Health Champions. Paul Farmer, MD, PhD | PBS. www.pbs.org
  117. Virchow, Rudolf Carl (2006). "Report on the Typhus Epidemic in Upper Silesia". American Journal of Public Health. 96 (12): 2102–5. doi:10.2105/AJPH.96.12.2102. PMC   1698167 . PMID   17123938.
  118. Isaac Asimov (1991). Treasury of Humor. Mariner Books. p.  202. ISBN   978-0-395-57226-9.
  119. Cardiff, Robert D; Ward, Jerrold M; Barthold, Stephen W (2008). "'One medicine—one pathology': are veterinary and human pathology prepared?". Laboratory Investigation. 88 (1): 18–26. doi:10.1038/labinvest.3700695. PMC   7099239 . PMID   18040269.
  120. "This anti-Catholic crusade was also taken up by the Progressives, especially Rudolf Virchow, though Richter himself was tepid in his occasional support." Authentic German Liberalism of the 19th century by Ralph Raico
  121. A leading German school teacher, Rudolf Virchow, characterized Bismarck's struggle with the Catholic Church as a Kulturkampf  a fight for culture  by which Virchow meant a fight for liberal, rational principles against the dead weight of medieval traditionalism, obscurantism, and authoritarianism." from The Triumph of Civilization by Norman D. Livergood and "Kulturkampf \Kul*tur"kampf'\, n. [G., fr. kultur, cultur, culture + kampf fight.] (Ger. Hist.) Lit., culture war; – a name, originating with Virchow (1821–1902), given to a struggle between the Roman Catholic Church and the German government" Kulturkampf in freedict.co.uk
  122. "Rizal's Berlin associates, or perhaps the word "patrons" would give their relation better, were men as esteemed in Masonry as they were eminent in the scientific world—Virchow, for example." in JOSE RIZAL AS A MASON by AUSTIN CRAIG, The Builder Magazine, August 1916 – Volume II – Number 8
  123. "It was a heady atmosphere for the young Brother, and Masons in Germany, Dr. Rudolf Virchow and Dr. Fedor Jagor, were instrumental in his becoming a member of the Berlin Ethnological and Anthropological Societies." From Dimasalang: The Masonic Life Of Dr. Jose P. Rizal By Reynold S. Fajardo, 33° by Fred Lamar Pearson, Scottish Rite Journal, October 1998
  124. Marco Steinert Santos (1 September 2008). Virchow: medicina, ciência e sociedade no seu tempo. Imprensa da Univ. de Coimbra. pp. 140–. ISBN   978-989-8074-45-4 . Retrieved 7 May 2012.
  125. "Prof. Virchow is Dead. Famous Scientist's Long Illness Ended Yesterday". New York Times . 5 September 1902. Retrieved 4 August 2012.
  126. "Prof. Virchow's Funeral. Distinguished Scholars, Scientists, and Doctors in the Throng That Attends the Ceremonies in Berlin". New York Times. 9 September 1902. Retrieved 4 August 2012.
  127. "Rudolf Virchow tomb". HimeTop. Retrieved 28 November 2014.
  128. "Rudolf Virchow". American Philosophical Society Member History Database. Retrieved 18 February 2021.
  129. "The Rudolf Virchow Center". The Rudolf Virchow Center. Archived from the original on 29 November 2014. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  130. "Call for Submissions: Rudolf Virchow Awards". Society for Medical Anthropology. 13 May 2014. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  131. "Rudolf Virchow Medal". Oregon State University Libraries' Special Collections & Archives Research Center. Retrieved 24 November 2014.
  132. "Rudolf Virchow monument". HimeTop. Retrieved 28 November 2014.
  133. "Langenbeck-Virchow-Haus" (in German). Retrieved 28 November 2014.
  134. "Rudolf Virchow Study Center: Rudolf Virchow and Transcultural Health Sciences". European University Viadrina. Retrieved 29 November 2014.
  135. Virchow Hill. SCAR Composite Antarctic Gazetteer
  136. Harsch, Ulrich. "Rudolf Virchow". Bibliotecha Augustana (in German). Augsburg University of Applied Sciences . Retrieved 10 October 2019.

Further reading