The Milk of Sorrow

Last updated
The Milk of Sorrow
The Milk Of Sorrow.jpg
Spanish La teta asustada
Directed by Claudia Llosa
Written byClaudia Llosa
Produced by Antonio Chavarrías
Claudia Llosa
José María Morales
Starring Magaly Solier
Susi Sánchez
Efrain Solís
Cinematography Natasha Braier
Edited byFrank Gutiérrez
Music by Selma Mutal
Release dates
  • February 12, 2009 (2009-02-12)(Berlinale)
  • February 13, 2009 (2009-02-13)(Spain)
  • March 12, 2009 (2009-03-12)(Peru)
Running time
95 minutes
CountriesPeru
Spain
Languages Spanish
Quechua

The Milk of Sorrow (Spanish : La Teta Asustada, The frightened teat) is a 2009 Peruvian-Spanish drama film directed, written and co-produced by Claudia Llosa. The film stars Magaly Solier and addresses the fears of abused women during Peru's recent history.

Contents

It won the Golden Bear award and FIPRESCI prize at the 2009 Berlin International Film Festival, as well as the award for best film in the 24 Festival Internacional de Cine de Guadalajara in Mexico. It was nominated for the 82nd Academy Awards for Best Foreign Language Film, becoming the first Peruvian film to be nominated for the award.

Plot

An elderly woman sings a song as she lies dying in her bed. She describes her own rape and the death of her husband. At the end of the song, she slowly passes away while lying next to her daughter, Fausta (Magaly Solier). Fausta has grown up on stories of the horrors that occurred during the internal conflict in Peru between Sendero Luminoso, a guerrilla group, and the Peruvian government. This has left Fausta with a crippling fear of men and rape. To dissuade any attempts of rape, she has placed a potato in her vagina. Throughout the film, this potato begins to impact her health yet she continues to refuse to allow the doctors to remove it. In the aftermath of her mother's death Fausta and her family do not have enough money to take her mother's body back to their village for burial. Fausta takes work in the home of a wealthy pianist, Aída (Susi Sánchez) who is struggling to complete a new piece in time for an upcoming recital. When the pianist discovers that Fausta has a knack for writing her own songs, Aída encourages her to complete a song for her by offering a string of pearls in exchange. Fausta desperately needs this money in order to pay for her mother's funeral and agrees. The night of the recital, Aída performs Fausta's song to a roaring applause. On the way back to Aida's home after the recital, Fausta comments about the positive reception that the song received. Aída is afraid Fausta will say something that will let the driver know Aida is not the composer and responds by kicking Fausta out into the dark streets of Lima by herself.

The night after her cousin's wedding, Fausta's uncle comes into her room and frightens her while she sleeps. He begs her to live her life and not waste her days in a state of never-ending fear like her mother did. At the end of the film, Fausta decides to go through with the operation to get the potato removed and buries her mother near the ocean. It is implied that Fausta will move on with her life, leaving her fears behind her.

Background

Between 1980 and 1992 Peru experienced a period of extreme violence, particularly in the Andean region, because of the uprising of the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path) and the actions of the paramilitary and state armed forces. By 1990 the conflict had reached Lima, the capital city of Peru. Claudia Llosa refers in her film to the folk belief that the trauma experienced by women who were raped by members of security force was passed on to their children through their breast milk. Thus, this period of violence continues to affect not only those who experienced it but also the next generation.

Llosa's work is a psychological as well as sociological approach to the 12 years of conflict, and exposes the mass rapes used by the army as a strategy of war. The film is based on the book Entre Prójimos, by Kimberly Theidon. [1] [2] In her book, Theidon documents a number of testimonials by women who were raped by as many as thirty men at a time, atrocities that often resulted in pregnancies. Theidon states that "when survivors of sexual violence speak about their experiences, they place a responsibility on their listeners to respond to what they have heard." [3] Llosa's film, too, is an attempt to respond to such testimonies.

Filming

Most of the filming locations are in Manchay, an impoverished suburban area in Pachacamac, southeast of Lima, which indigenous people took over during the 1980s to escape from terrorism, and near a high-class area of Lima called Cieneguilla.

Critical reception

The film received positive reviews, having a 78% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 41 reviews, and an average rating of 6.79/10, and a critical consensus:"Claudia Llosa's deliberate pace and abstract storytelling may frustrate some viewers, but there's no denying the visual pleasures soaking in The Milk of Sorrow". [4] Metacritic assigned a weighted average score of 68 out of 100, based on 10 critics. [5]

Peter Brunette, from The Hollywood Reporter , said "The film is gorgeously shot and contains a plethora of haunting images". Boyd van Hoeij from Variety said that "Peruvian realities and Llosa's light magical realism mesh to create a vivid picture of a society and its problems."

While some Peruvian critics gave the film negative reviews, the plot and the performances were praised by American and European critics.

Awards

Film awards

YearCategoryPerson NominatedBest Movie Nominated (Results)
59th Berlin International Film Festival Golden Bear Claudia Llosa Won
FIPRESCI Won
2009 Guadalajara International Film Festival Best MovieWon
Best Actress Magaly Solier Won
2009 Montreal World Film Festival Best ActressWon
2009 Association Québécoises des Critiques de Cinéma Best Movie Claudia Llosa Won
2009 Lima Film FestivalBest Peruvian MovieWon
CONACINE AwardWon
Best Actress Magaly Solier Won
2009 Havana Film Festival Best Movie Claudia Llosa Won
2009 Bogota Film Festival Best MovieWon
2009 Peruvian Association of Cinematographic PressBest Peruvian MovieWon
2010 Goya Awards Best Spanish Language Foreign Film Nominated
82nd Academy Awards Best Foreign Language Film Nominated
2010 Ariel Award Best Ibero-American Film Nominated

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shining Path</span> Maoist communist party in Peru

The Shining Path, officially the Communist Party of Peru, is a far-left political party and guerrilla group in Peru, following Marxism–Leninism–Maoism and Gonzalo Thought. Academics often refer to the group as the Communist Party of Peru – Shining Path to distinguish it from other communist parties in Peru.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">María Elena Moyano</span> Peruvian community organizer and activist

María Elena Moyano Delgado was an Afro-Peruvian community organizer and feminist who was assassinated by the Shining Path. She grew up in poverty in the Villa El Salvador pueblo joven, then became involved in local activism. She was twice president of FEPOMUVES and at the time of her death was deputy mayor. Her funeral was attended by 300,000 people and resulted in a downturn in support for the Shining Path. She received the Peruvian Order of Merit posthumously.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quechua people</span> Ethnic group indigenous to Andean South America

Quechua people or Quichua people may refer to any of the indigenous peoples of South America who speak the Quechua languages, which originated among the Indigenous people of Peru. Although most Quechua speakers are native to Peru, there are some significant populations in Ecuador, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, and Argentina.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cinema of Peru</span> Filmmaking industry in Peru

While the Peruvian film industry has not been nearly as prolific as that of some other Latin American countries, such as Mexico or Argentina, some Peruvian movies produced enjoyed regional success. Historically, the cinema of Peru began in Iquitos in 1932 by Antonio Wong Rengifo because of the rubber boom and the intense arrival of foreigners with technology to the city, and thus continued an extensive, unique filmography, with a different style than the films made in the capital, Lima.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Martha Moyano</span> Peruvian nurse and politician

Martha Lupe Moyano Delgado is a Peruvian nurse, Fujimorist politician and a congresswoman representing Lima for the 2021–2026 term, previously serving in the 2000–2001, 2001–2006, and 2006-2011 terms. Moyano belongs to the Alliance for the Future party. She is the sister of María Elena Moyano, who was assassinated by Shining Path.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peruvian retablo</span>

Retablos are a sophisticated Peruvian folk art in the form of portable boxes which depict religious, historical, or everyday events that are important to the Indigenous people of the highlands. It is a tradition originated in Ayacucho.

<i>Madeinusa</i> 2006 film

Madeinusa is a 2006 Peruvian-Spanish drama film directed by Claudia Llosa.

State of Fear: The Truth about Terrorism (2005) is a documentary film produced by Skylight Pictures and directed by Pamela Yates. It won the 2006 Overseas Press Club Award for "Best Reporting in Any Medium on Latin America". It has been translated into 48 languages and broadcast in 157 countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Claudia Llosa</span>

Claudia Llosa Bueno is a Peruvian film director, writer, producer, and author. She is recognized for her Academy-Award-nominated film The Milk of Sorrow.

Magaly Solier Romero is a Peruvian actress and singer.

<i>Altiplano</i> (2009 film) 2009 Peruvian-Belgian drama film

Altiplano is a 2009 Peruvian-Belgian drama film by Peter Brosens and Jessica Woodworth, starring Magaly Solier, Jasmin Tabatabai, and Olivier Gourmet. It takes places on three continents in five different languages. It tells the stories of two women in mourning and how their destinies merge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Eye that Cries</span> Monument in Jesús María, Lima, Peru

The Eye that Cries is a memorial that was born as a private initiative designed to honor the thousands of victims as a result of terrorism in Peru, to strengthen the collective memory of all Peruvians and to promote peace and reconciliation in the country.

Selma Mutal is a Franco-Dutch film score composer. She is known for her collaborations with filmmakers Claudia Llosa, Javier Fuentes-León, and Tod Lending. Mutal has also scored films directed by Fabien Gorgeart, Piotr Dumala, Pola Rapaport, and Víctor García León, work for TV, and a Chanel campaign, among other things.

<i>Extirpator of Idolatries</i> 2014 Peruvian film

Extirpator of Idolatries is a 2014 Peruvian thriller drama film written and directed by Manuel Siles, completed in 2014 and released commercially in Peru in 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gonzalo Thought</span> Peruvian communist ideology

The Gonzalo Thought or Marxism-Leninism-Maoism-Gonzalo Thought is a system of ideas developed by Peruvian revolutionary Abimael Guzmán as an interpretation of Peruvian reality based on Marxism-Leninism-Maoism.

<i>Fever Dream</i> (film) 2021 film directed by Claudia Llosa

Fever Dream is a 2021 psychological thriller film directed by Claudia Llosa from a screenplay that she co-wrote with Samanta Schweblin, based on Schweblin's 2014 novel of the same name. The film stars María Valverde, Dolores Fonzi, German Palacios, Guillermo Pfening and Emilio Vodanovich.

Women in the Internal conflict in Peru were active in a large variety of roles, both making significant impacts on the Conflict and with the Conflict having significant impacts on them. Post-conflict women, especially Indigenous women, have played major roles in reconciliation efforts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Luz del Carmen Ibáñez Carranza</span> Peruvian jurist and judge

Luz del Carmen Ibáñez Carranza is a Peruvian jurist and judge at the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, Netherlands. Ibañez Carranza is the first Peruvian judge at the ICC. Before being elected as a judge at the ICC, she was a prosecutor and professor in Peru.

Bárbara D'Achille (1941-1989) was a Latvian-Peruvian journalist and conservationist. She was born in Latvia but spent most of her adult life in Western Europe and South America. She wrote for El Comercio, where she managed a regular ecology section. Brown describes her as Peru's foremost environmental journalist. She also consulted for the World Wildlife Fund and other international NGOs.

<i>Lina from Lima</i> 2019 Chilean film

Lina from Lima is a 2019 drama film written and directed by María Paz González in her directorial debut. Starring Magaly Solier. It won several awards including "Best Chilean Feature Film" and the Héctor Ríos Award for "Best Direction of Photography" at the Valdivia International Film Festival. It is a co-production between Chile, Peru and Argentina.

References

  1. Interview with Kimberly Theidon by Paola Ugaz from La Terra http://www.terra.com.pe/noticias/articulo/html/act1659267.htm
  2. "Harvard Department of Anthropology".
  3. Theidon, Kimberly Susan. Entre prójimos el conflicto armado interno y la política de la reconciliación en el Perú. Lima, Peru: IEP Ediciones, 2004. Pg 130
  4. "The Milk of Sorrow".
  5. "The Milk of Sorrow".