Thorne–Żytkow object

Last updated

A Thorne–Żytkow object (TŻO or TZO), also known as a hybrid star, is a conjectured type of star wherein a red giant or red supergiant contains a neutron star at its core, formed from the collision of the giant with the neutron star. Such objects were hypothesized by Kip Thorne and Anna Żytkow in 1977. [1] In 2014, it was discovered that the star HV 2112, located in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), was a strong candidate. [2] [3] Another possible candidate is the star HV 11417, also located in the SMC. [4]



A Thorne–Żytkow object is formed when a neutron star collides with another star, typically a red giant or supergiant. The colliding objects can simply be wandering stars. This is only likely to occur in extremely crowded globular clusters. Alternatively, the neutron star could form in a binary system when one of the two stars goes supernova. Because no supernova is perfectly symmetric, and because the binding energy of the binary changes with the mass lost in the supernova, the neutron star will be left with some velocity relative to its original orbit. This kick may cause its new orbit to intersect with its companion, or, if its companion is a main-sequence star, it may be engulfed when its companion evolves into a red giant. [5]

Once the neutron star enters the red giant, drag between the neutron star and the outer, diffuse layers of the red giant causes the binary star system's orbit to decay, and the neutron star and core of the red giant spiral inward toward one another. Depending on their initial separation, this process may take hundreds of years. When the two finally collide, the neutron star and red giant core will merge. If their combined mass exceeds the Tolman–Oppenheimer–Volkoff limit, then the two will collapse into a black hole. Otherwise, the two will coalesce into a single neutron star. [6]

If a neutron star and a white dwarf merge, this could form a Thorne–Żytkow object with the properties of an R Coronae Borealis variable. [7]


The surface of the neutron star is very hot, with temperatures exceeding 109 K, hotter than the cores of all but the most massive stars. This heat is dominated either by nuclear fusion in the accreting gas or by compression of the gas by the neutron star's gravity. [8] [9] Because of the high temperature, unusual nuclear processes may take place as the envelope of the red giant falls onto the neutron star's surface. Hydrogen may fuse to produce a different mixture of isotopes than it does in ordinary stellar nucleosynthesis, and some astronomers have proposed that the rapid proton nucleosynthesis that occurs in X-ray bursts also takes place inside Thorne–Żytkow objects. [10]

Observationally, a Thorne–Żytkow object may resemble a red supergiant, [2] or, if it is hot enough to blow off the hydrogen-rich surface layers, a nitrogen-rich Wolf–Rayet star (type WN8). [11]

A TŻO has an estimated lifespan of 105–106 years. Given this lifespan, it is possible that between 20 and 200 Thorne-Żytkow objects currently exist in the Milky Way. [12]

The only way to unambiguously determine whether or not a star is a TŻO is a multi-messenger detection of both the gravitational waves of the inner neutron star and an optical spectrum of the metals atypical of a normal red supergiant. It is possible to detect pre-existing TŻOs with current LIGO detectors; the neutron star core would emit a continuous wave. [13]


It has been theorized that mass loss will eventually end the TŻO stage, with the remaining envelope converted to a disk, resulting in the formation of a neutron star with a massive accretion disk. [14] These neutron stars may form the population of isolated pulsars with accretion disks. [14] The massive accretion disk may also result in the collapse of a star, becoming a stellar companion to the neutron star. The neutron star may also accrete sufficient material to collapse into a black hole. [15]

Observation history

In 2014, a team led by Emily Levesque argued that the star HV 2112 had unusually high abundances of elements such as molybdenum, rubidium, lithium, and calcium, and a high luminosity. Since both are expected characteristics of Thorne–Żytkow objects, this led the team to suggest that HV 2112 might be the first discovery of a TZO. [2] However, this claim was challenged in a 2018 paper by Emma Beasor and collaborators, [4] who argued that there is no evidence for HV 2112 having any unusual abundance patterns beyond a possible enrichment of lithium and that its luminosity is too low. They put forth another candidate, HV 11417, based on an apparent over-abundance of rubidium and a similar luminosity as HV 2112. However, HV 11417 has since been identified as a likely foreground halo star. [16]

List of candidate TŻOs

CandidateRight AscensionDeclinationLocationDiscoveryNotesRefs
HV 2112 01h 10m 03.87s−72° 36 52.6 Small Magellanic Cloud 2014Classified as a supergiant TZO candidate [2] [17] [18] [19] or an AGB star [4] [2] [17] [18] [19] [4]
HV 11417 01h 00m 48.2s−72° 51 02.1 Small Magellanic Cloud 2018Classified as an AGB star [4] or a foreground halo star [16] [4] [16]
V595 Cassiopeiae 01h 43m 02.72s+56° 30 46.02 Cassiopeia 2002 [20]
IO Persei 03h 06m 47.27s+55° 43 59.35 Perseus 2002 [20]
KN Cassiopeiae 00h 09m 36.37s+62° 40 04.12 Cassiopeia 2002 [20]
U Aquarii 22h 03m 19.69s−16° 37 35.2 Aquarius 1999This star was catalogued as a R Coronae Borealis variable. [7]
VZ Sagittarii 18h 15m 08.58s−29° 42 29.6 Sagittarius 1999This star was catalogued as a R Coronae Borealis variable. [7]

List of candidate former and future TŻOs

Candidate former TŻORight AscensionDeclinationLocationDiscoveryNotesRefs
GRO J1655-40 16h 54m 00.14s−39° 50 44.9 Scorpius 1995The progenitor for both the companion star and the black hole in this system is hypothesized to have been a TŻO. [15]
BD+61 2536

(TIC 470710327)

23h 49m 18.99s+61° 57 46.0 Cassiopeia 2022Massive hierarchical triple star system that could evolve either into a neutron-star merger or a TŻO. [21]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Red supergiant</span> Stars with a supergiant luminosity class

Red supergiants (RSGs) are stars with a supergiant luminosity class of spectral type K or M. They are the largest stars in the universe in terms of volume, although they are not the most massive or luminous. Betelgeuse and Antares are the brightest and best known red supergiants (RSGs), indeed the only first magnitude red supergiant stars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wolf–Rayet star</span> Heterogeneous stars with unusual spectra

Wolf–Rayet stars, often abbreviated as WR stars, are a rare heterogeneous set of stars with unusual spectra showing prominent broad emission lines of ionised helium and highly ionised nitrogen or carbon. The spectra indicate very high surface enhancement of heavy elements, depletion of hydrogen, and strong stellar winds. The surface temperatures of known Wolf–Rayet stars range from 20,000 K to around 210,000 K, hotter than almost all other kinds of stars. They were previously called W-type stars referring to their spectral classification.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">S Doradus</span> Luminous blue variable star in the Large Magellanic Cloud

S Doradus is one of the brightest stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), a satellite galaxy of the Milky Way, located roughly 160,000 light-years away. The star is a luminous blue variable, and one of the most luminous stars known, having a luminosity varying widely above and below 1,000,000 times the luminosity of the Sun, although it is too far away to be seen with the naked eye.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NGC 3603</span> Open cluster in the constellation Carina

NGC 3603 is a nebula situated in the Carina–Sagittarius Arm of the Milky Way around 20,000 light-years away from the Solar System. It is a massive H II region containing a very compact open cluster HD 97950.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scutum–Centaurus Arm</span>

The Scutum–Centaurus Arm, also known as Scutum-Crux arm, is a long, diffuse curving streamer of stars, gas and dust that spirals outward from the proximate end of the Milky Way's central bar. The Milky Way has been posited since the 1950s to have four spiral arms — numerous studies contest or nuance this number. In 2008, observations using the Spitzer Space Telescope failed to show the expected density of red clump giants in the direction of the Sagittarius and Norma arms. In January 2014, a 12-year study into the distribution and lifespan of massive stars and a 2013-reporting study of the distribution of masers and open clusters both found corroboratory, though would not state irrefutable, evidence for four principal spiral arms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Long-period variable star</span> Description for certain cool luminous pulsating variable stars

The descriptive term long-period variable star refers to various groups of cool luminous pulsating variable stars. It is frequently abbreviated to LPV.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sher 25</span> Star in the constellation Carina

Sher 25 is a blue supergiant star in the constellation Carina, located approximately 25,000 light years from the Sun in the H II region NGC 3603 of the Milky Way. It is a spectral type B1Iab star with an apparent magnitude of 12.2. Its initial main sequence mass is calculated at 60 times the mass of our Sun, but a star of this type will have already lost a substantial fraction of that mass. It is unclear whether Sher 25 has been through a red supergiant phase or has just evolved from the main sequence, so the current mass is very uncertain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">U Aquarii</span> Star in the constellation of Aquarius

U Aquarii, abbreviated U Aqr, is a variable star in the equatorial constellation of Aquarius. It is invisible to the naked eye, having an apparent visual magnitude that ranges from 10.6 down to as low as 15.9. Based on parallax measurements, the distance to this star is approximately 38 kly (12 kpc). In 1990, W. A. Lawson and associates provided a distance estimate of 43 kly (13.2 kpc) based on the assumption of a bolometric magnitude of −5. It appears to lie several kiloparsecs below the galactic plane, and thus may belong to an old stellar population.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">WOH G64</span> Unusual red supergiant star in the constellation Dorado

WOH G64 is an unusual red supergiant (RSG) star in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) satellite galaxy in the southern constellation of Dorado. It is one of the largest known stars, being described as possibly being the largest star known. It is also one of the most luminous and massive red supergiants, with a radius calculated to be around 1,540 times that of the Sun (R) and a luminosity around 282,000 times the solar luminosity (L).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">RT Carinae</span> Star in the constellation Carina

RT Carinae, also known as CD-58 3538, is a variable star in the Carina Nebula in the constellation Carina. It has a mean apparent magnitude of +8.55.

Anna N. Żytkow is a Polish astrophysicist working at the Institute of Astronomy of the University of Cambridge. Żytkow and Kip Thorne proposed a model for what is called the Thorne–Żytkow object, which is a star within another star. Żytkow in 2014 was part of the team led by Emily M. Levesque which discovered the first candidate for such an object.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">HV 2112</span> Small Magellanic Cloud star in the constellation Tucana

HV 2112 is a cool luminous variable star in the Small Magellanic Cloud. Until 2018, it was considered to be the most likely candidate for a Thorne–Żytkow object, but it is now thought to be an asymptotic giant branch star.

Emily Levesque is an American astronomer and assistant professor in the Department of Astronomy at the University of Washington. She is renowned for her work on massive stars and using these stars to investigate galaxy formation. In 2014, she received the Annie Jump Cannon award for her innovative work on gamma ray bursts and the Sloan Fellowship in 2017. In 2015, Levesque, Rachel Bezanson, and Grant R. Tremblay published an influential paper, which critiqued the use of the Physics GRE as an admissions cutoff criterion for astronomy postgraduate programs by showing there was no statistical correlation between applicant's score and later success in their academic careers. Subsequently, the American Astronomical Society adopted the stance that the Physics GRE should not be mandatory for graduate school applications, and many graduate astronomy programs have since removed the Physics GRE as a required part of their graduate school applications. She is also the author of the 2020 popular science book The Last Stargazers: The Enduring Story of Astronomy's Vanishing Explorers.

A failed supernova is an astronomical event in time domain astronomy in which a star suddenly brightens as in the early stage of a supernova, but then does not increase to the massive flux of a supernova. They could be counted as a subcategory of supernova imposters. They have sometimes misleadingly been called unnovae.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SMC 018136</span> Star in the Small Magellanic Cloud in the constellation Tucana

SMC 018136, also known as PMMR 37, is a red supergiant star located in the Small Magellanic Cloud. It is one of the largest stars and one of most luminous SMC cool supergiants so far discovered, with a radius of 1,310 times that of the sun and a bolometric luminosity over 200,000 times more than Sun. If it were in the place of the Sun, its photosphere would at least engulf the orbit of Jupiter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">HV 888</span> Red supergiant star in the constellation Dorado

HV 888, also known as WOH S140, is a red supergiant (RSG) star located in the Large Magellanic Cloud. It is among the largest known stars, with a radius ranging from over 1,400 to nearly 2,000 times that of the Sun (R) and is also one of the most luminous of its type with a range of nearly 300,000 to over 500,000 times that of the Sun (L). The effective temperature is estimated to be around 3,500 K. If placed at the center of the Solar System, its photosphere would engulf the orbit of Jupiter and possibly even Saturn.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">IRAS 05280–6910</span> Red supergiant star in the Large Magellanic Cloud

IRAS 05280–6910 is a red supergiant star or OH/IR supergiant star located in the Large Magellanic Cloud. Its radius is calculated to be more than a thousand times that of the Sun, making it one of the largest stars discovered so far. If placed at the center of the Solar System, its photosphere would engulf the orbit of Jupiter. It has an estimated mass loss rate of 5.4×10−4 M per year, one of the highest known for any red supergiant star.

HV 11417 is a candidate Thorne–Żytkow object, put forward in a paper by Emma Beasor and collaborators. The paper also claims that another candidate for the Thorne–Żytkow object, HV 2112, was not a Thorne–Żytkow object because it seemingly possessed no strange quality that would label it as a Thorne–Żytkow object. HV 11417 has since been identified as a likely foreground halo star.


  1. Thorne, Kip S.; Żytkow, Anna N. (15 March 1977). "Stars with degenerate neutron cores. I - Structure of equilibrium models". The Astrophysical Journal . 212 (1): 832–858. Bibcode:1977ApJ...212..832T. doi:10.1086/155109.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Levesque, Emily M.; Massey, Philip; Zytkow, Anna N.; Morrell, Nidia (2014). "Discovery of a Thorne–Żytkow object candidate in the Small Magellanic Cloud". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters. 443: L94–L98. arXiv: 1406.0001 . Bibcode:2014MNRAS.443L..94L. doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slu080. S2CID   119192926.
  3. "Astronomers discover first Thorne-Zytkow object, a bizarre type of hybrid star". PhysOrg . 4 June 2014.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Beasor, Emma; Davies, Ben; Cabrera-Ziri, Ivan; Hurst, Georgia (2 July 2018). "A critical re-evaluation of the Thorne-Żytkow object candidate HV 2112". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 479 (3): 3101–3105. arXiv: 1806.07399 . Bibcode:2018MNRAS.479.3101B. doi:10.1093/mnras/sty1744. S2CID   67766043.
  5. Brandt, W. Niel; Podsiadlowski, Philipp (May 1995). "The effects of high-velocity supernova kicks on the orbital properties and sky distributions of neutron-star binaries". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 274 (2): 461–484. arXiv: astro-ph/9412023 . Bibcode:1995MNRAS.274..461B. doi:10.1093/mnras/274.2.461. S2CID   119408422.
  6. Oohara, Ken-ichi; Nakamura, Takashi (1989). "Three dimensional initial data of numerical relativity". In Evans, Charles R.; Finn, Lee S.; Hobill, David W. (eds.). Frontiers in Numerical Relativity. Cambridge University Press. p. 84. ISBN   978-0-521-36666-3.
  7. 1 2 3 Vanture, Andrew; Zucker, Daniel; Wallerstein, George (April 1999). "U Aquarii a Thorne–Żytkow Object?". The Astrophysical Journal . 514 (2): 932–938. Bibcode:1999ApJ...514..932V. doi: 10.1086/306956 .
  8. Eich, Chris; Zimmerman, Mark; Thorne, Kip; Żytkow, Anna N. (November 1989). "Giant and supergiant stars with degenerate neutron cores". The Astrophysical Journal . 346 (1): 277–283. Bibcode:1989ApJ...346..277E. doi:10.1086/168008.
  9. Cannon, Robert; Eggleton, Peter; Żytkow, Anna N.; Podsialowsky, Philip (February 1992). "The structure and evolution of Thorne-Zytkow objects". The Astrophysical Journal . 386 (1): 206–214. Bibcode:1992ApJ...386..206C. doi:10.1086/171006.
  10. Cannon, Robert (August 1993). "Massive Thorne–Żytkow Objects – Structure and Nucleosynthesis". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 263 (4): 817–838. Bibcode:1993MNRAS.263..817C. doi: 10.1093/mnras/263.4.817 .
  11. Foellmi, C.; Moffat, A.F.J. (2002). "Are Peculiar Wolf-Rayet Stars of Type WN8 Thorne-Zytkow Objects?". In Shara, Michael M. (ed.). Stellar Collisions, Mergers and their Consequences. ASP Conference Proceedings. Vol. 263. arXiv: astro-ph/0607217 . Bibcode:2002ASPC..263..123F. ISBN   1-58381-103-6.
  12. Podsiadlowski, P.; Cannon, R. C.; Rees, M. J. (May 1995). "The evolution and final fate of massive Thorne-Żytkow objects". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 274 (2): 485–490. Bibcode:1995MNRAS.274..485P. doi: 10.1093/mnras/274.2.485 .
  13. DeMarchi, L.; Sanders, J.; Levesque, E. M. (Apr 2021). "Prospects for Multimessenger Observations of Thorne-Żytkow Objects". The Astrophysical Journal . 911 (2): 101. arXiv: 2103.03887 . Bibcode:2021ApJ...911..101D. doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/abebe1 .
  14. 1 2 Mereghetti, Sandro (1995). "A Spin-down Variation in the 6 Second X-Ray Pulsar 1E 1048.1-5937". Astrophysical Journal (published December 1995). 455: 598. Bibcode:1995ApJ...455..598M. doi:10.1086/176607.
  15. 1 2 Brandt, W. Niel; Podsiadlowski, Philipp; Sigurðsson, Steinn (1995). "On the high space velocity of X-ray Nova SCO 1994: Implications for the formation of its black hole". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 277 (2): L35–L40. Bibcode:1995MNRAS.277L..35B. doi: 10.1093/mnras/277.1.L35 .
  16. 1 2 3 O'Grady, Anna (2020). "Cool, Luminous, and Highly Variable Stars in the Magellanic Clouds from ASAS-SN: Implications for Thorne-Żytkow Objects and Super-asymptotic Giant Branch Stars". Astrophysical Journal (published September 2020). 901: 135. Bibcode:2020ApJ...901..135O. doi:10.3847/1538-4357/abafad.
  17. 1 2 McMillan, Paul (2018). "Gaia DR2 Confirms that Candidate Thorne-Żytkow Object HV 2112 is in the Small Magellanic Cloud". Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society (published May 2018). Bibcode:2018RNAAS...2...18M. doi:10.3847/2515-5172/aac0fb.
  18. 1 2 Tout, Christopher (2014). "HV2112, a Thorne-Zytkow object or a super asymptotic giant branch star". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (published November 2014). Bibcode:2014MNRAS.445L..36T. doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slu131.
  19. 1 2 Worley, Clare (2016). "The proper motion of HV2112: a TŻO candidate in the SMC". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (published June 2016). Bibcode:2016MNRAS.459L..31W. doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slw034.
  20. 1 2 3 Kuchner, Marc J.; Vakil, David; Smith, Verne V.; Lambert, David L.; Plez, Bertrand; Phinney, E. Sterl (May 30 – June 2, 2000). Shara, Michael M. (ed.). A Spectroscopic Search for Massive Thorne-Żytkow Objects (PDF). Stellar Collisions, Mergers and Their Consequences. ASP Conference Series. Vol. 263. American Museum of Natural History, New York. pp. 131–136. Bibcode:2002ASPC..263..131K. ISBN   1-58381-103-6.
  21. Eisner, N. L.; Johnston, C.; Toonen, S.; Frost, A. J.; Janssens, S.; Lintott, C. J.; Aigrain, S.; Sana, H.; Abdul-Masih, M.; Arellano-Córdova, K. Z.; Beck, P. G.; Bordier, E.; Cannon, E.; Escorza, A.; Fabry, M. (2022-04-01). "Planet Hunters TESS IV: a massive, compact hierarchical triple star system TIC 470710327". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 511: 4710–4723. doi:10.1093/mnras/stab3619. ISSN   0035-8711.