Tochigi patricide case

Last updated

The Tochigi patricide case (栃木実父殺し事件, Tochigi Jippugoroshi Jiken), or Aizawa patricide case, [1] is a landmark fatherdaughter incest and patricide case in Tochigi Prefecture, Japan. The trial of the incident is also known as its common case name Aizawa v. Japan. [2] [3] [4] In the incident, a victimized daughter, Chiyo Aizawa (相沢 チヨ, Aizawa Chiyo) [5] [6] (born January 31, 1939) who had been sexually abused by her father for about 15 years, eventually killed him on October 5, 1968. She was accused and convicted of murdering her father, but her sentence was suspended. [5] [7]


Aizawa's controversial trial led to a change in the penalty for parricide in the Criminal Code of Japan.

Background and murder

Born in Tochigi Prefecture, Aizawa was the first of six children. Her father was Takeo Aizawa (相沢 武雄, Aizawa Takeo, May 3, 1915 – October 5, 1968) and her mother was Rika Aizawa (相沢 リカ, Aizawa Rika). [8] Takeo was an alcoholic and systematically raped his daughter from 1953, when she was fourteen years old, onwards. Rika fled to Hokkaidō soon after, leaving Chiyo behind. She returned several years later, attempting to stop their relationship. By then, Takeo was living with his daughter, treating her as if she were his wife. Chiyo became pregnant 11 times and had five daughters by her father, two of whom died in infancy. In 1967, she underwent sterilization after her sixth abortion.

In 1968, Chiyo fell in love with a 22-year-old man, and her father became angry. He confined her and said that he would kill her three children. On October 5, 1968, she strangled her father in Yaita, Tochigi Prefecture. [7] Her neighbors had thought Chiyo was her father's wife until her arrest, and the Japanese police then determined that her three children were sired by her father. Because the family law in Japan forbids polygamy and intermarriage between close relatives but does not forbid inbreeding, a family register recorded Chiyo's children as her father's illegitimate children. [7]

Aizawa v. Japan

The penalty for parricide was the death penalty or life imprisonment under article 200 of the Criminal Code of Japan. [9] Justices typically accept mitigating circumstances in such incidents; Japanese laws at the time permitted two reductions in sentencing, each reduction half of the appropriate sentence, with life imprisonment reduced to a seven-year sentence when reduction is applicable. Still, the minimum sentence Aizawa would have received was three years and six months in prison, and the laws did not allow suspended sentences for terms longer than three years.

Her lawyer insisted that the murder was self-defense and that she had been insane because of the rapes. The Utsunomiya District Court considered article 200 unconstitutional and acquitted Aizawa because the crime originated via self-defense on May 29, 1969. However, the Tokyo High Court did not concur and sentenced her to three years and six months on May 12, 1970. In a final appeal, the Supreme Court of Japan accepted the argument that imposing a harsh penalty on Aizawa would violate the principle of human equality before the law found in the constitution.

The court ruled the article unconstitutional on April 4, 1973. Aizawa was found guilty of regular homicide and received a sentence of two years and six months in prison, suspended for three years. [5] If the court had not annulled the precedents, she could not have received a suspended sentence. She was effectively acquitted, and she worked in Utsunomiya after her release.

Effect of her sentence

On April 19, 1973, the Japanese Ministry of Justice announced that Japanese murderers who had killed their parents could be individually granted amnesty. Article 200 of the penal code was abolished in 1995. [10]

See also

Further reading

Related Research Articles

Parricide refers to the deliberate killing of one's own father and mother, spouse, children, and/or close relative. However, the term is sometimes used more generally to refer to the intentional killing of a near relative. It is an umbrella term that can be used to refer to acts of matricide and patricide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Patricide</span> Act of killing ones father

Patricide is the act of killing one's own father or stepfather. The word patricide derives from the Latin word pater (father) and the suffix -cida. Patricide is a sub-form of parricide, which is defined as an act of killing a close relative. In many cultures and religions patricide was considered one of the worst sins. For example, according to Marcus Tullius Cicero, in the Roman Republic it was the only crime for which the civilian could be sentenced to death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sasebo slashing</span> 2004 Japanese murder

The "Sasebo slashing", also known as the Nevada-tan murder, was the murder of a 12-year-old Japanese schoolgirl, Satomi Mitarai, by an 11-year-old female classmate referred to as "Girl A". The murder occurred on June 1, 2004, at an elementary school in the city of Sasebo in Nagasaki Prefecture. The murderer slit Mitarai's throat and arms with a box cutter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Junko Furuta</span> 1980s murder of Japanese high school student

Junko Furuta was a Japanese high school student who was abducted, raped, tortured and then subsequently murdered. Her case was called the "concrete-encased high school girl murder case" (女子高生コンクリート詰め殺人事件), due to her body being discovered in a concrete drum. The abuse was mainly perpetrated by four male teenagers over a period of 40 days from 25 November 1988 to 4 January 1989. The crime has been described as the worst case of juvenile delinquency in post-war Japan. The perpetrators' sentences ranged from juvenile detention to 20 years in prison.

The Military Academy incident, also known as the November incident was an attempted coup d'état that took place in Japan in November 1934. It was one of a sequence of similar conspiracies for a "Shōwa Restoration" led by radical elements with the Imperial Japanese Army.

Fusako Sano is a Japanese woman who was kidnapped at age nine by Nobuyuki Satō, and held in captivity for nine years and two months from November 13, 1990, to January 28, 2000. In Japan, the case is also known as the " Niigata girl confinement incident".

Aizawa is a Japanese surname. Alternate writings include 相澤, 藍澤 and 藍沢. Notable people with the surname include:

Futoshi Matsunaga is a Japanese serial killer who both defrauded and tortured his victims in what is collectively known as the Kitakyūshū Serial Murder Incident. Matsunaga was convicted of six counts of murder and one count of manslaughter between 1996 and 1998 and sentenced to death. He murdered his victims with an accomplice, Junko Ogata, who received a life sentence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yoshio Kodaira</span> Japanese serial killer and rapist

Yoshio Kodaira was a Japanese serial killer, serial rapist, and war criminal who murdered at least 8 people in the Tokyo and Tochigi Prefecture areas between 1932 and 1946.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 Akihabara massacre</span> 2008 civilian attack in Tokyo, Japan

The Akihabara massacre was an incident of mass murder that took place on 8 June 2008, in the Akihabara shopping quarter in Chiyoda, Tokyo, Japan. The perpetrator, 25-year-old Tomohiro Katō of Susono, Shizuoka, drove into a crowd with a rented truck, initially killing three people and injuring two; he then stabbed at least twelve people using a dagger, killing four other people and injuring eight.

Rie Isogai was a 31-year-old Japanese office clerk who was robbed and murdered in Aichi Prefecture on the night of 24 August 2007 by three men who became acquainted through an underground message board. Because the three men met on an underground website, the case is frequently called the Dark Site Murder in Japan, "dark site" being the Japanese term for underground websites. Despite Japan's death penalty not normally being used in cases involving a single murder, Isogai's mother launched a petition to have the three killers face the death penalty; one was sentenced to death on 18 March 2009, while the other two were sentenced to life in prison on 13 April 2011.

The Sagamihara stabbings were committed on 26 July 2016 in Midori Ward, Sagamihara, Kanagawa, Japan. Nineteen people were killed and twenty-six others were injured, thirteen severely, at a care home for disabled people. The crimes were committed by a 26-year-old man, identified as Satoshi Uematsu, a former employee of the care facility. Uematsu surrendered at a nearby police station with a bag of knives and was subsequently arrested. Justin McCurry of The Guardian described the attack as one of the worst crimes committed on Japanese soil in modern history. Uematsu was sentenced to death on 16 March 2020 after the prosecution sought the maximum penalty for murder in his trial; as of July 2022, he is on death row awaiting execution.

The North Kanto Young Girl Serial Kidnapping and Murder Case is a serial kidnapping and murder case that has been going on since 1979 in Japan's Tochigi and Gunma prefectures. The Ashikaga murder case is included in this.

The Fukuoka family murder case was a robbery-murder by three Chinese international students in the Higashi-ku ward of Fukuoka, Japan, on June 20, 2003.

Ryuichi Tsukamoto is the alias of a Japanese serial killer who, as a teenager, killed three women in three separate prefectures between 1966 and 1967. Dubbed by investigators "Metropolitan Designated Case No. 106", Tsukamoto was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment in 1972, but is believed to have been paroled in the late 1980s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gen Sekine</span> Japanese serial killer

Gen Sekine was a Japanese dog breeder and serial killer who, together with his common-law wife Hiroko Kazama, murdered at least four clients in Kumagaya from April to August 1993 in what were called the Saitama Dog Lover Murders. Both were sentenced to death for their crimes, but Sekine died on death row prior to execution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Masakatsu Nishikawa (serial killer)</span> Executed Japanese serial killer

Masakatsu Nishikawa was a Japanese serial killer who killed four snack bar hostesses and attempted to kill two others from 1991 to 1992 in three prefectures. An ex-criminal with a murder conviction, he was convicted of his latter crimes, sentenced to death and executed in 2017.

Ayumi Kuboki is a Japanese spree killer, suspected serial killer and former nurse who was convicted of killing three patients at the Oguchi Hospital in Yokohama using diamitol, all of which occurred September 2016. She is currently serving a life term, and remains under investigation for up to 48 total deaths that occurred at the hospital dating to July of that year.

Tetsuyuki Morikawa was a Japanese serial killer who killed two of his ex-wife's relatives in Kumamoto, after having been released on parole for killing his mother-in-law in 1962. For the latter crimes, Morikawa was sentenced to death and subsequently executed in 1999.

Susumu Nakayama was a Japanese serial killer who killed his girlfriend's estranged husband and the latter's girlfriend in 1998, after being paroled from prison for a previous murder conviction in 1969. For the latter crimes, Nakayama was sentenced to death, but died in prison before the sentence could be carried out.


  1. Itoh, Hiroshi (2010), The Supreme Court and benign elite democracy in Japan. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. via Google Books. p. 283
  2. Franklin, Daniel P.; Baun, Michael J. (1995). Political culture and constitutionalism: a comparative approach. M. E. Sharpe via Google Books. p. 114
  3. Itoh, Hiroshi (1989), The Japanese Supreme Court: constitutional policies. Markus Wiener Publishers via Google Books. p. 195
  4. Goodman, Carl F. (2008). The rule of law in Japan: a comparative analysis. Kluwer Law International via Google Books. p. 178
  5. 1 2 3 "1970(A)No.1310". Supreme Court of Japan . Retrieved June 24, 2008.
  6. Satoh, Jun-ichi (2008). "Judicial Review in Japan: An Overview of the Case Law and an Examination of Trends in the Japanese Supreme Court's Constitutional Oversight" (PDF). Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review. Loyola Law School. 41 (2): 603–627. Retrieved August 28, 2011.
  7. 1 2 3 栃木実父殺し事件 (in Japanese). 無限回廊. Archived from the original on December 28, 2007. Retrieved December 27, 2007.
  8. "Seminar Constitutional Law 2005" (PDF). Keio University SFC (in Japanese). Komazawa University. Archived from the original (PDF) on August 27, 2011. Retrieved August 28, 2011.
  9. 矢板市・尊属殺人事件 (in Japanese). 事件史探求. Archived from the original on December 19, 2007. Retrieved December 27, 2007.
  10. "The Japanese Constitution gets a provocative look". The Japan Times. July 8, 2001. Retrieved October 15, 2010.
  11. The scream that doesn't reach: Day when severe punishment penalty for parent killing disappeared.