Five O'Clock Club of Philadelphia

Last updated
Mark Richards Muckle, founding member of the Five O'Clock Club FOCC muckle.jpg
Mark Richards Muckle, founding member of the Five O'Clock Club
Fiveoclockiana and Other Poems, by J. Hampton Moore. A souvenir of the 15th anniversary of the Five O'Clock Club. Privately published in Philadelphia in 1898. Fiveoclockiana and other poems.jpg
Fiveoclockiana and Other Poems, by J. Hampton Moore. A souvenir of the 15th anniversary of the Five O'Clock Club. Privately published in Philadelphia in 1898.
In Memoriam: J. Martin Rommel and B. Frank Breneman. A volume published in 1906 by the Five O'Clock Club upon the death of two members. In memoriam rommel breneman.jpg
In Memoriam: J. Martin Rommel and B. Frank Breneman. A volume published in 1906 by the Five O'Clock Club upon the death of two members.
J. Hampton Moore in 1891. Moore was a two-term Philadelphia Mayor as well as a 50-year member and long-time secretary of the Five O'Clock Club. J hampton moore 1891.jpg
J. Hampton Moore in 1891. Moore was a two-term Philadelphia Mayor as well as a 50-year member and long-time secretary of the Five O'Clock Club.

The Five O'Clock Club of Philadelphia was a social dining club founded by a group of prominent Philadelphia business and government leaders in 1883. With 35 members, the club had no building of its own, but organized dinners, banquets, and other entertainments at other clubs and hotels in Philadelphia. While the club was created by newspaper men, among its members were local Republican politicians, including Philadelphia Mayor Charles F. Warwick, Philadelphia Mayor and US Congressman J. Hampton Moore, Pennsylvania Attorney General Francis Shunk Brown, Pennsylvania Attorney General F. Carroll Brewster, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice William I. Schaffer, US Congressman Robert H. Foerderer, and US Senator Joseph R. Grundy.

Contents

In its early days, the club met on the second Saturday of each month, taking the summer months off. [1] The Bellevue-Stratford Hotel, [2] the Manufacturers' Club [3] and the Union League of Philadelphia [4] were frequently the scene of Five O'Clock Club meetings. The club was the successor of the short-lived Thursday Club and was launched within days of the folding of that club, [5] and was a main competitor to the similarly organized Clover Club of Philadelphia, which survived the Five O'Clock Club. The Five O'Clock Club was dissolved in 1937.

Beginnings

The club was conceived in the business office of George William Childs, owner of the Philadelphia Public Ledger newspaper. In January 1883, Childs issued a call for a meeting to organize a new club to replace the defunct Thursday Club. The following month, in room 20 of the Public Ledger building, a number of men met and organized the new society. Newspaper men were the majority. Among those present were M. Richards Muckle, Joel Cook, Israel F. Sheppard, Robert M. McWade, Frank Smith, and James H. Alexander, all connected with the Public Ledger. Also present were W. H. C. Hargrave, John M. Perry, James R. Wood, George W. Boyd, Robert C. Clipperton, John L. Carncross, Henry R. Edmunds, and Charles Lawrence. [6] The first officers of the club were Captain Robert C. Clipperton, the British Consul in Philadelphia, as president; Joel Cook, of the Philadelphia Public Ledger, as vice president; and Frank Smith, also of the Philadelphia Public Ledger, as secretary. [7]

Meetings

Meetings of the Five O'Clock Club were marked both by their informality -- meeting at 5:00 p.m. meant gentlemen were not required to wear formal clothes -- and by their wit. Distinguished guests were typically present at meetings and the evening's entertainment consisted of speeches, songs, declamations, and witty banter. It was at an 1899 meeting of the Five O'Clock Club that the state of Missouri came to be known as the "Show-Me-State." Rep. Willard Duncan Vandiver (D., Mo.) commented, "I come from a State that raises corn and cotton and cockleburs and Democrats, and frothy eloquence neither convinces nor satisfies me. I am from Missouri. You have got to show me." [8]

Ending

Fifty-four years after its founding, the 10 remaining members of the Five O'Clock Club decided to disband the organization. The final dinner meeting of the organization happened on Thursday, October 14, 1937, at the Art Alliance, in Philadelphia. [9] One week later, the club held their final meeting, a luncheon meeting, the first in its history, with 36 guests, at the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel's Clover Room on Thursday, October 21, 1937. [10] The final menu was oysters, green turtle soup, roast turkey and Nesselrode pudding and the final toast was "Old days, old times, old friends." Present at the final meeting were Col. Louis J. Kolb, president; J. Hampton Moore, secretary-treasurer; Joseph R. Grundy, Francis Shunk Brown, John Kent Kane, Edward T. Stotesbury, J. S. W. Holton, Judge William I. Schaffer, Henry W. Moore, and Joseph Wayne, Jr. [11]

Members

Bibliography

While the members of The Five O'Clock Club have many publications to their credit, the Club itself is responsible for a few books.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Andrew Lang</span> Scottish author and critic (1844–1912)

Andrew Lang was a Scottish poet, novelist, literary critic, and contributor to the field of anthropology. He is best known as a collector of folk and fairy tales. The Andrew Lang lectures at the University of St Andrews are named after him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fergus Hume</span> English novelist

Ferguson Wright Hume, known as Fergus Hume, was a prolific English novelist, known for his detective fiction, thrillers and mysteries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ferdinand Brunetière</span> French writer and critic (1849–1906)

Ferdinand Vincent-de-Paul Marie Brunetière was a French writer and critic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Ball (golfer)</span> English amateur golfer (1861–1940)

John Ball Jr. was an English amateur golfer of the late 19th and early 20th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Russell Young</span> American journalist and 7th Librarian of Congress

John Russell Young was an American journalist, author, diplomat, and the seventh Librarian of the United States Congress from 1897 to 1899. He was invited by Ulysses S. Grant to accompany him on a world tour for purposes of recording the two-year journey, which he published in a two-volume work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Laura E. Richards</span> American writer and poet (1850–1943)

Laura Elizabeth Howe Richards was an American writer. She wrote more than 90 books including biographies, poetry, and several for children. One well-known children's poem is her literary nonsense verse Eletelephony.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edwin J. Houston</span> American electrical engineer and author (1847–1914)

Edwin James Houston was an American author, electrical engineer, academic, businessman, and inventor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">L. T. Meade</span> Irish writer, editor

Elizabeth Thomasina Meade Smith (1844–1914), writing under the pseudonym L. T. Meade, was a prolific writer of girls' stories. She was born in Bandon, County Cork, Ireland, daughter of Rev. R. T. Meade, of Nohoval, County Cork. She later moved to London, where she married Alfred Toulmin Smith in September 1879.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nathan Haskell Dole</span> American poet

Nathan Haskell Dole was an American editor, translator, and author. A writer and journalist in Philadelphia, New York, and Boston, he translated many of the works of Leo Tolstoy and books of other Russians; novels of the Spaniard Armando Palacio Valdés (1886–90); a variety of works from the French and Italian.

The chancellor was a semi-formally designated office position for a number of high-level officials at one time during the Tang dynasty of China. This list also includes chancellors of the short-lived Wu Zhou dynasty, which is typically treated as an interregnum of the Tang dynasty by historians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Manville Fenn</span> English writer and educationalist (1831–1909)

George Manville Fenn was a prolific English novelist, journalist, editor and educationalist. Many of his novels were written with young adults in mind. His final book was his biography of a fellow writer for juveniles, George Alfred Henty.

<i>Munseys Magazine</i> American magazine (1889–1929)

Munsey's Magazine was an American magazine founded by Frank Munsey in 1889 as Munsey's Weekly, a humor magazine edited by John Kendrick Bangs. It was unsuccessful, and by late 1891 had lost $100,000. Munsey converted it into an illustrated general monthly in October of that year, retitled Munsey's Magazine and priced at twenty-five cents. Richard Titherington became the editor, and remained in that role throughout the magazine's existence. In 1893 Munsey cut the price to ten cents. This brought him into conflict with the American News Company, which had a near-monopoly on magazine distribution, as they were unwilling to handle the magazine at the price Munsey proposed. Munsey started his own distribution company and was quickly successful: the first ten cent issue began with a print run of 20,000 copies but eventually sold 60,000, and within a year circulation had risen to over a quarter of a million copies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Church of St. Luke and The Epiphany (Philadelphia)</span> Church in Pennsylvania, United States

The Church of Saint Luke and The Epiphany is an Episcopal congregation located at 330 South 13th Street between Spruce and Pine Streets in the Center City neighborhood of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. It is part of the Diocese of Pennsylvania. The church was formed in 1898 as a result of the merger of St. Luke's Church (1839) and The Church of The Epiphany (1834), which consolidated at St. Luke's location.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Conner</span> American politician and Union Army officer (1837–1918)

Henry Conner was an American hotelier, restaurateur, and politician. He was a member of the Wisconsin State Senate, representing Vernon and La Crosse counties during the 1891 and 1893 sessions. Earlier, he served as a Union Army officer during the American Civil War, and lost his right leg due to wounds. His last name was sometimes spelled Connor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tillie May Forney</span> American journalist

Matilda May Forney was a writer and journalist.

Rev. John E. Price was an elder and minister of the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church. He was a minister for around 50 years. He was the founder and president of the Garnet Equal Rights League at Harrisburg. He wrote hymns and was an editor for the Zion Church Advocate and, with William H. Day, the Zion Church Herald and Outlook, the first paper of the AME Zion Church. Day was a minister, abolitionist, and educator.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elizabeth Phipps Train</span> American novelist

Elizabeth Phipps Train was an American novelist and translator.

References

  1. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1889], p. 67.
  2. "Noted Men for Sproul Fest: Many Active in National Affairs to be Five O'Clock Club Guests," Evening Public Ledger, 7 Dec 1918, p. 2.
  3. "Five O'Clock Club Meeting," Philadelphia Times 15 Dec 1889, p. 4.
  4. "Five O'Clock Club Dinner," Philadelphia Times 10 March 1889, p. 2.
  5. "Five O'Clock Club", The Philadelphia Inquirer, 12 Feb 1883, p. 3.
  6. History of the Five O'Clock Club, J. Hampton Moore. (Philadelphia: n.p., 1891), pp. 5–6.
  7. "The Five O'Clock Club Organized." Philadelphia Times, 12 Feb 1883.
  8. "I'm From Missouri" Philadelphia Inquirer, 17 August 1967, p. 9.
  9. "Events of the Day," Philadelphia Inquirer, 14 Oct 1937, p. 12.
  10. "Five O'Clock Club Smashes Tradition," Philadelphia Inquirer, 20 Oct 1937, p. 4.
  11. The details regarding the final meeting are taken from "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  12. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  13. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  14. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  15. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  16. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  17. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  18. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  19. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  20. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  21. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  22. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  23. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  24. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  25. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  26. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  27. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  28. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  29. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  30. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  31. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  32. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  33. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  34. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  35. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  36. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  37. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  38. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer, 30 March 1930, p. 4
  39. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  40. "M. G. Brumbaugh Dies of Heart Attack," Mount Union Times 21 March 1930, p. 1.
  41. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer 30 March 1930, p. 4.
  42. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  43. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  44. "Philadelphia Jurist Dead," The Gazette Times (Pittsburgh), 5 April 1919, p. 15.
  45. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  46. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  47. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  48. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  49. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  50. "Five O'Clock Club Meeting," Philadelphia Press 15 Dec 1889, p. 4.
  51. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  52. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  53. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  54. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  55. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  56. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  57. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  58. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer 30 March 1930, p. 4.
  59. "Five O'Clock Officers Renamed," Philadelphia Inquirer 5 May 1931, p. 17.
  60. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  61. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  62. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  63. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  64. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  65. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  66. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  67. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  68. "Well Known Theatrical Manager Dead," Lancaster Intelligencer, 12 Dec 1883.
  69. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  70. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  71. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  72. "Death of James M. Ferguson," Philadelphia Times, 6 Nov 1885, p. 2.
  73. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  74. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  75. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  76. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  77. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  78. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  79. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  80. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  81. "Five O'Clock Officers Renamed," Philadelphia Inquirer, 5 May 1931, p. 17.
  82. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  83. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  84. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  85. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  86. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer, 30 March 1930, p. 4
  87. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  88. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  89. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  90. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  91. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  92. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  93. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  94. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  95. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  96. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  97. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  98. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  99. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  100. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  101. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  102. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  103. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  104. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  105. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer, 30 March 1930, p. 4
  106. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  107. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  108. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  109. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  110. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  111. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  112. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  113. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  114. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  115. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer 30 March 1930, p. 4.
  116. "Five O'Clock Officers Renamed," Philadelphia Inquirer 5 May 1931, p. 17.
  117. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  118. Lebrenz's election is reported in "Five O'Clock Club: Resumption of the Dinners Which Were So Thoroughly Appreciated Last Year," Philadelphia Inquirer, 12 Oct 1890, p. 5.
  119. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  120. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  121. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  122. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  123. "Five O'Clock Club Meeting," Philadelphia Press 15 Dec 1889, p. 4.
  124. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  125. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  126. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  127. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  128. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  129. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  130. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  131. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  132. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  133. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  134. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  135. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  136. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  137. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  138. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  139. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  140. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  141. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  142. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  143. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  144. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  145. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  146. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  147. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  148. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  149. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  150. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  151. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  152. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  153. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  154. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  155. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  156. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  157. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  158. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  159. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  160. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  161. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  162. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  163. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  164. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  165. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  166. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  167. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  168. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  169. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  170. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  171. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  172. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  173. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  174. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  175. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  176. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  177. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  178. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  179. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  180. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  181. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  182. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  183. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  184. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  185. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  186. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  187. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  188. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  189. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  190. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer 30 March 1930, p. 4.
  191. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  192. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  193. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  194. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  195. Fiveoclockiana & other poems; being a collection of original verses & songs prompted by current events, for the menus, souvenirs & dinners of the Five o'clock club of Philadelphia. [Philadelphia, Dreka, 1898].
  196. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  197. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  198. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  199. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  200. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  201. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  202. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  203. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  204. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  205. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  206. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  207. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  208. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  209. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  210. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  211. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  212. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  213. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  214. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  215. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  216. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  217. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  218. "Ex-Judge W. H. Staake," Delaware County Times, 31 July 1924, p. 10.
  219. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  220. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  221. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  222. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  223. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  224. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer 30 March 1930, p. 4.
  225. "Five O'Clock Officers Renamed," Philadelphia Inquirer 5 May 1931, p. 17.
  226. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  227. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  228. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  229. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  230. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  231. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  232. "Grundy, Brown Elected to Five O'Clock Posts," Philadelphia Inquirer 30 March 1930, p. 4.
  233. "Five O'Clock Officers Renamed," Philadelphia Inquirer 5 May 1931, p. 17.
  234. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  235. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  236. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  237. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1893], p. 578.
  238. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  239. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  240. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  241. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  242. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1896], pp. 617-618.
  243. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1898], p. 651.
  244. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1905], pp. 684-685.
  245. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1906], p. 689.
  246. "What Do You Want to Know?" Philadelphia Inquirer 26 Oct 1959, p. 20.
  247. Boyd's Philadelphia Blue Book [Philadelphia: C. E. Howe, 1890], p. 551.
  248. List of founding members taken from "The Five O'Clock Club. The First Dinner Inaugurates the Association Under Bright Auspices." Philadelphia Inquirer, 19 February 1883.
  249. "Fiveoclockiana and other poems : Being a collection of original verses and songs prompted by current events, for the menus, souvenirs, and dinners of the".
  250. "In memoriam, Henry F. McCarthy, Robert H. Foerderer".