Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris

Last updated October 29, 2024

Le Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris is an account of politics, war and everyday life in Paris covering the period between 1405 and 1449. The exact identity of its author is unknown. It has long been acknowledged as an invaluable source of information on the life and times of the city of Paris in the first half of the 15th century, a period marked by the Hundred Years' War and the English occupation of part of the kingdom of France.

The book title's reference to 'bourgeois de Paris' was first introduced by Denis Godefroy in his 1653 edition and has been retained in some subsequent editions. However, there are doubts about the accuracy of the reference to 'Bourgeois.' Many historians now believe that its author was not a bourgeois, but instead a member of the clergy.

Subject matter

Portrait of Charles VII by Jean Fouquet, Louvre Museum, Paris, c. 1445-1450 KarlVII.jpg — Portrait of Charles VII by Jean Fouquet, Louvre Museum, Paris, c. 1445–1450

The text, whose title dates from the 17th century, is a chronicle of the reigns of Charles VI and Charles VII. It is presented in the form of short sections, each relating to particular events over a period extending from 1405 to 1449.^[1]^[2] The author's account is strictly personal — he describes what he saw and heard. He had pretensions "neither to artistic merit (despite his occasional metaphors and flights into allegory) nor to historical accuracy and objectivity."^[3]

The book covers the political and religious events that animated Paris during the first half of the fifteenth century. Notably, it contains valuable information on the Armagnac–Burgundian Civil War,^[4] the siege of Meaux by Henry V of England and the economic consequences of the war against the English and the trial of Joan of Arc. Finally, it provides a wealth of information on daily life at the time, including: food and wine prices, religious processions,^[5] weather, deaths from epidemics, the level of the Seine, attacks by wolves in the city,^[6] and the suffering caused by the numerous domestic and international armed conflicts.^[2]^[7]

The text of the Journal shows clearly that, for many years, the author was a fierce partisan of the Burgundy faction in the Armagnac-Burgundian civil war, the conflict that dominated most aspects of life in Paris and in France more generally. The war pitted two branches of the French royal family against one another – the House of Orléans (Armagnac faction) and the House of Burgundy (Burgundian faction) from 1407 to 1435. This civil war is closely linked to the Hundred Years’ War because the Burgundians formed an alliance with the English. The author's pro-Burgundian views were aligned with those of Paris's commoners and with the academics at the University, who hoped that the Burgundians would be able to rein in the excesses of the French monarchy, including in fiscal and monetary matters.^[7] By 1423, however, he becomes disillusioned with the Burgundians and their English allies (noting, for example, that they caused nearly as much suffering in the countryside as the Armagnacs) and, by the end of the Journal, he accepts the legitimacy of Charles VII as the French king.^[2]

Sources

The author relied on multiple sources. First and foremost, he was an eye witness to much of it. Second, he reports on rumours and public opinion concerning these events, as well as on official news and decrees communicated in both written and oral forms.^[4]^[7]

Despite the title’s use of the word ‘Journal’ (or diary) the text is not structured as a diary in the sense of a book with daily entries, each reporting on subject matter gathered on that day. Instead, it is clear that the author reported on events using information that he could only have obtained well after the event took place (for example, he reports in May 1431 that Henry VI would be coming to Paris in December, though he could not have known this until later in the year). Thus, the text has more the character of a memoir than a diary or journal.^[2]

Versions of the text

Six manuscripts of the Journal exist and numerous editions have been published.^[7]^[8] The 6 manuscripts consist of two copies made in the fifteenth century and four that are made much later:

The oldest version, known as the Roman manuscript, is a copy dating from the end of the 15th century, which is preserved today in the collections of the Vatican. This is not a very careful copy — has no paragraphs and the binding places the year 1408 before 1405. The year 1438 is damaged and illegible.^[2]
Another fifteenth-century copy is in Oxford, but the text has entire sections cut out. It is, in fact a collection of excerpts from the Journal that have been chosen to shed a flattering light on English exploits during the war in France.^[2]
Other manuscripts exist dating from the end of the sixteenth century or the first half of the seventeenth century. They repeat the text of the Vatican copy and sometimes even provide additional details. This is particularly the case with the manuscript from Aix-en-Provence and the copy in the collection of the National Library of France in Paris, which allow the year 1438 (missing from the Vatican's copy) to be reconstituted.^[8]

None of the extant manuscripts are the original.^[2] A comparison of the copies reveals transcription errors and omissions.^[3] The various versions are complementary in the sense that, by considering them as a whole, it is possible to reconstitute the original Journal.^[7]

The first publications of the manuscript — that of Étienne Pasquier in 1596 and Denys Godefroy in 1653 — are partial, containing only excerpts. The first complete edition is that of La Barre in 1729. It occupies the first 208 pages of La Barre's collection of historical documents entitled Memoirs to serve the history of France and Burgundy.^[8] Alexandre Tuetey's 1881 edition, along with its extensive introduction,^[1] are still used today. Colette Beaune has edited a more accessible version with updated spelling, a detailed annotations and a glossary^[2] and Janet Shirley has translated the Journal into modern English.^[9]

Theories about who the author was

The author is unknown because the original manuscript was lost, as was the prologue of the text where he might have identified himself.^[2]

All historians and scholars who have analysed the text, however, agree broadly on his milieu and profile. Based on clues provided in the text of the Journal, he was almost certainly a man of the cloth. He may have held an academic position at the University of Paris and it is likely that he was a doctor of theology.^[2] Given his detailed knowledge of parishes on the right bank of the Seine, it is reasonable to conclude that he had a pastoral role in one or more of these.^[7]^[8]

Some historians have sought to pinpoint an exact identity for the author, but none have provided a universally accepted answer. Auguste Longnon proposed Jean Beaurigout, parish priest of the Saint-Nicolas-des-Champs church. This thesis was rejected by Alexandre Tuetey, in his prologue to his 1881 edition, who attributes authorship to the canon of Notre-Dame de Paris, Jean Chuffart. Born in Tournai in Picardy, Chuffart first sided with the Anglo-Bourguignons before joining the camp of Charles VII on his return to Paris.^[8] This identification was rejected in turn by Colette Beaune in her introduction to the 1990 edition, where she notes that he was too often absent from Paris to be the author (based on the article devoted to Chuffart in the fourth volume of the Chartularium universitatis parisiensis by Denifle).^[2] A review of the 1968 Clarendon Press translation^[9] of the Vatican and Aix manuscripts into English describes the translator’s explanatory section on the identity of the author as « somewhat unprofitable speculation. »^[10] At the present time, the determination of the exact identity of the author cannot, it would seem, be unequivocally determined. ^[2]

Related Research Articles

Burgundy is a historical territory and former administrative region and province of east-central France. The province was once home to the Dukes of Burgundy from the early 11th until the late 15th century. The capital, Dijon, was wealthy and powerful, being a major European centre of art and science, and of Western Monasticism. In early Modern Europe, Burgundy was a focal point of courtly culture that set the fashion for European royal houses and their court. The Duchy of Burgundy was a key in the transformation of the Middle Ages towards early modern Europe.

Anne of Burgundy, Duchess of Bedford was a daughter of John the Fearless, Duke of Burgundy (1371–1419), and his wife Margaret of Bavaria (1363–1423).

Philip III the Good ruled as Duke of Burgundy from 1419 until his death in 1467. He was a member of a cadet line of the Valois dynasty, to which all 15th-century kings of France belonged. During his reign, the Burgundian State reached the apex of its prosperity and prestige, and became a leading centre of the arts.

John I was a scion of the French royal family who ruled the Burgundian State from 1404 until his assassination in 1419. He played a key role in French national affairs during the early 15th century, particularly in his struggle to remove the mentally ill King Charles VI and during the Hundred Years' War against Kingdom of England. A rash, ruthless and unscrupulous politician, John murdered Charles's brother, the Duke of Orléans, in an attempt to gain control of the government, which led to the eruption of the Armagnac–Burgundian Civil War in France and in turn culminated in his own assassination in 1419.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Burgundian School</span> 15th century European composers

The Burgundian School was a group of composers active in the 15th century in what is now northern and eastern France, Belgium, and the Netherlands, centered on the court of the Dukes of Burgundy. The school inaugurated the music of Burgundy.

Jean de Waurin or Wavrin was a medieval French chronicler and compiler, also a soldier and politician. He belonged to a noble family of Artois, and witnessed the Battle of Agincourt from the French side, but later fought on the Anglo-Burgundian side in the later stages of the Hundred Years' War. As a historian, he put together the first chronicle intended as a complete history of England, very extensive but largely undigested and uncritical. Written in French, in its second version it extends from 688 to 1471, though the added later period covering the Wars of the Roses shows a strong bias towards Burgundy's Yorkist allies. Strictly his subject is Great Britain, but essentially only England is covered, with a good deal on French and Burgundian events as well.

Georges Chastellain, Burgundian chronicler and poet, was a native of Aalst in Flanders. Chastellain's historical works are valuable for the accurate information they contain. As a poet he was famous among his contemporaries. He was the great master of the school of grands rhétoriqueurs, whose principal characteristics were fondness for the most artificial forms and a profusion of Latinisms and graecisms.

The Burgundian party was a political allegiance against France that formed during the latter half of the Hundred Years' War. The term "Burgundians" refers to the supporters of the Duke of Burgundy, John the Fearless, that formed after the assassination of Louis I, Duke of Orléans. Their opposition to the Armagnac party, the supporters of Charles, Duke of Orléans, led to a civil war in the early 15th century, itself part of the larger Hundred Years' War.

The Grandes Chroniques de France is a vernacular royal compilation of the history of the Kingdom of France, most manuscripts of which are luxury copies that are heavily illuminated. Copies were produced between the thirteenth and fifteenth centuries, the text being extended at intervals to cover recent events. It was first compiled in the reign of Saint Louis, who wished to preserve the history of the Franks, from the coming of the Trojans to his own time, in an official chronography whose dissemination was tightly controlled. It was continued under his successors until completed in 1461. It covers the Merovingian, Carolingian, and Capetian dynasties of French kings, with illustrations depicting personages and events from virtually all their reigns.

The Lancastrian War was the third and final phase of the Hundred Years' War between England and France. It lasted from 1415, when Henry V of England invaded Normandy, to 1453, when the English were definitively defeated in Aquitaine. It followed a long period of peace from the end of the Caroline War in 1389. The phase is named after the House of Lancaster, the ruling house of the Kingdom of England, to which Henry V belonged.

Margaret of Nevers, also known as Margaret of Burgundy, was Dauphine of France and Duchess of Guyenne as the daughter-in-law of King Charles VI of France. A pawn in the dynastic struggles between her family and in-laws during the Hundred Years' War, Margaret was regarded as the future Queen of France at two separate times, as a result of her two marriages: first to the Dauphin and second to the Duke of Brittany.

Marie de Berry was suo jure Duchess of Auvergne and Countess of Montpensier in 1416–1434. She was the daughter of John, Duke of Berry, and Joanna of Armagnac. She was married three times. She acted as administrator of the Duchy of Bourbon for her third spouse John I, Duke of Bourbon, during his imprisonment in England after he was captured following the French defeat at the Battle of Agincourt in 1415, until 1434.

Jean (II) Juvénal des Ursins, the son of the royal jurist and provost of the merchants of Paris Jean Juvénal, was a French cleric and historian. He is the author of several legal treatises and clerical publications and the Histoire de Charles VI, Roy de France is attributed to him. His works serve as some of the main sources for information relating to the Armagnac-Burgundian Civil War and the final phase of the Hundred Years' War.

Tanneguy III du Châtel was a Breton knight who fought in the Armagnac–Burgundian Civil War and the Hundred Years' War. A member of the Armagnac party, he became a leading adviser of King Charles VII of France, and was one of the murderers of Duke John the Fearless of Burgundy in 1419.

The Armagnac–Burgundian Civil War was a conflict between two cadet branches of the French royal family: the House of Orléans and the House of Burgundy from 1407 to 1435. It began during a lull in the Hundred Years' War against the English and overlapped with the Western Schism of the papacy.

Thomas Scales, 7th Baron Scales was an English nobleman and one of the main English military commanders in the last phase of the Hundred Years' War. The son of Robert de Scales, 5th Baron Scales, he succeeded his brother Robert de Scales, 6th Baron Scales as baron.

John the Fearless, Duke of Burgundy, was assassinated on the bridge at Montereau on 10 September 1419 during a parley with the French Dauphin, by Tanneguy du Chastel and Jean Louvet, the Dauphin's close counsellors.

Colette Beaune is a French historian and professor emeritus at the University of Paris X - Nanterre.

The siege of Saint-Denis was the last instance of cooperation between the English and their Burgundian allies in the Hundred Years' War. Saint-Denis, the traditional burial place of the kings of France, was located in the outskirts of English-held Paris, and had been captured by the French a couple of months earlier. The enemy presence there critically endangered the English position in the capital, and, aiming to retake it urgently, the English moved onto the town in August with a handful of Burgundian auxiliaries. The siege was undertaken during the peace congress of Arras, during which no end to the fighting was seen, as both sides struggled to gain ground around and over Paris. The English were victorious at St. Denis after the French garrison surrendered due to lack of external support.

The Burgundian State is a concept coined by historians to describe the vast complex of territories that is also referred to as Valois Burgundy.

References

1 2 Tuetey, Alexandre, ed. (1881). Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris, 1405-1449 (in French). Paris: H. Champion.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Beaune, Colette, ed. (1990). Editor's introduction and annotations, Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris (in French) (Lettres gothiques ed.). Paris: Livres de poche.
1 2 Gillis, James C. (1971). "Review of A Parisian Journal 1405-1449. Journal d'un Bourgeois de Paris". The Modern Language Review. 66 (4): 893–894. doi:10.2307/3723031. ISSN 0026-7937. JSTOR 3723031.
1 2 Beaune, Colette (1993). "La rumeur dans le Journal du Bourgeois de Paris". Actes des congrès de la Société des historiens médiévistes de l'enseignement supérieur public. 24 (1): 191–203. doi:10.3406/shmes.1993.1640.
↑ Chiffoleau, Jacques (1990). "Les processions parisiennes de 1412. Analyse d'un rituel flamboyant". Revue Historique. 284 (1 (575)): 37–76. ISSN 0035-3264. JSTOR 40955201.
↑ Classen, Albrecht (2002). "Review of Catastrophes naturelles et calamités au Moyen Age (Micrologus' Library 1)". Mediaevistik. 15: 279–280. ISSN 0934-7453. JSTOR 42585910.
1 2 3 4 5 6 Monneret-Muyard, Renaud (2018–2019). Paris, une capitale dans les guerres d'après le Journal d'un bourgeois à Paris (in French). Franche-Comté: Université de Franche-Comté. pp. 10, 12, 14.
1 2 3 4 5 Tuetey, Alexandre, ed. (1881). Editor's introduction to Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris, 1405-1449 (in French). Paris: H. Champion.
1 2 Translator's introduction and annotations, Journal of Paris, 1405-1449. Translated by Shirley, Janet. Oxford: Clarendon Press. 1968. ISBN 0198214669.
↑ Ferrier, Janet M. (1969). "Review of A Parisian Journal 1405-1449. Journal d'un Bourgeois de Paris". Medium Ævum. 38 (3): 350–352. doi:10.2307/43627590. ISSN 0025-8385. JSTOR 43627590.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[:5-1] 1 2 Tuetey, Alexandre, ed. (1881). Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris, 1405-1449 (in French). Paris: H. Champion.

[:1-2] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Beaune, Colette, ed. (1990). Editor's introduction and annotations, Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris (in French) (Lettres gothiques ed.). Paris: Livres de poche.

[:4-3] 1 2 Gillis, James C. (1971). "Review of A Parisian Journal 1405-1449. Journal d'un Bourgeois de Paris". The Modern Language Review. 66 (4): 893–894. doi:10.2307/3723031. ISSN 0026-7937. JSTOR 3723031.

[:2-4] 1 2 Beaune, Colette (1993). "La rumeur dans le Journal du Bourgeois de Paris". Actes des congrès de la Société des historiens médiévistes de l'enseignement supérieur public. 24 (1): 191–203. doi:10.3406/shmes.1993.1640.

[5] Chiffoleau, Jacques (1990). "Les processions parisiennes de 1412. Analyse d'un rituel flamboyant". Revue Historique. 284 (1 (575)): 37–76. ISSN 0035-3264. JSTOR 40955201.

[6] Classen, Albrecht (2002). "Review of Catastrophes naturelles et calamités au Moyen Age (Micrologus' Library 1)". Mediaevistik. 15: 279–280. ISSN 0934-7453. JSTOR 42585910.

[:3-7] 1 2 3 4 5 6 Monneret-Muyard, Renaud (2018–2019). Paris, une capitale dans les guerres d'après le Journal d'un bourgeois à Paris (in French). Franche-Comté: Université de Franche-Comté. pp. 10, 12, 14.

[:0-8] 1 2 3 4 5 Tuetey, Alexandre, ed. (1881). Editor's introduction to Journal d'un bourgeois de Paris, 1405-1449 (in French). Paris: H. Champion.

[:6-9] 1 2 Translator's introduction and annotations, Journal of Paris, 1405-1449. Translated by Shirley, Janet. Oxford: Clarendon Press. 1968. ISBN 0198214669.

[10] Ferrier, Janet M. (1969). "Review of A Parisian Journal 1405-1449. Journal d'un Bourgeois de Paris". Medium Ævum. 38 (3): 350–352. doi:10.2307/43627590. ISSN 0025-8385. JSTOR 43627590.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]