Monsky's theorem

Last updated

In geometry, Monsky's theorem states that it is not possible to dissect a square into an odd number of triangles of equal area. [1] In other words, a square does not have an odd equidissection.

Contents

The problem was posed by Fred Richman in the American Mathematical Monthly in 1965 and was proved by Paul Monsky in 1970. [2] [3] [4]

Proof

A square can be divided into an even number of triangles of equal area (left), but into an odd number of only approximately equal area triangles (right). Square triangulation.svg
A square can be divided into an even number of triangles of equal area (left), but into an odd number of only approximately equal area triangles (right).

Monsky's proof combines combinatorial and algebraic techniques and in outline is as follows:

  1. Take the square to be the unit square with vertices at (0, 0), (0, 1), (1, 0) and (1, 1). If there is a dissection into n triangles of equal area, then the area of each triangle is 1/n.
  2. Colour each point in the square with one of three colours, depending on the 2-adic valuation of its coordinates.
  3. Show that a straight line can contain points of only two colours.
  4. Use Sperner's lemma to show that every triangulation of the square into triangles meeting edge-to-edge must contain at least one triangle whose vertices have three different colours.
  5. Conclude from the straight-line property that a tricolored triangle must also exist in every dissection of the square into triangles, not necessarily meeting edge-to-edge.
  6. Use Cartesian geometry to show that the 2-adic valuation of the area of a triangle whose vertices have three different colours is greater than 1. So every dissection of the square into triangles must contain at least one triangle whose area has a 2-adic valuation greater than 1.
  7. If n is odd, then the 2-adic valuation of 1/n is 1, so it is impossible to dissect the square into triangles all of which have area 1/n. [5]

Optimal dissections

By Monsky's theorem, it is necessary to have triangles with different areas to dissect a square into an odd number of triangles. Lower bounds for the area differences that must occur to dissect a square into an odd numbers of triangles and the optimal dissections have been studied. [6] [7] [8]

Generalizations

The theorem can be generalized to higher dimensions: an n-dimensional hypercube can only be divided into simplices of equal volume if the number of simplices is a multiple of n!. [2]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Simplicial complex</span> Mathematical set composed of points, line segments, triangles, and their n-dimensional counterparts

In mathematics, a simplicial complex is a set composed of points, line segments, triangles, and their n-dimensional counterparts. Simplicial complexes should not be confused with the more abstract notion of a simplicial set appearing in modern simplicial homotopy theory. The purely combinatorial counterpart to a simplicial complex is an abstract simplicial complex. To distinguish a simplicial complex from an abstract simplicial complex, the former is often called a geometric simplicial complex.

In combinatorics, double counting, also called counting in two ways, is a combinatorial proof technique for showing that two expressions are equal by demonstrating that they are two ways of counting the size of one set. In this technique, which van Lint & Wilson (2001) call "one of the most important tools in combinatorics", one describes a finite set from two perspectives leading to two distinct expressions for the size of the set. Since both expressions equal the size of the same set, they equal each other.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sperner's lemma</span> Theorem on triangulation graph colorings

In mathematics, Sperner's lemma is a combinatorial result on colorings of triangulations, analogous to the Brouwer fixed point theorem, which is equivalent to it. It states that every Sperner coloring of a triangulation of an -dimensional simplex contains a cell whose vertices all have different colors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Triaugmented triangular prism</span> Convex polyhedron with 14 triangle faces

The triaugmented triangular prism, in geometry, is a convex polyhedron with 14 equilateral triangles as its faces. It can be constructed from a triangular prism by attaching equilateral square pyramids to each of its three square faces. The same shape is also called the tetrakis triangular prism, tricapped trigonal prism, tetracaidecadeltahedron, or tetrakaidecadeltahedron; these last names mean a polyhedron with 14 triangular faces. It is an example of a deltahedron and of a Johnson solid.

In geometry, a dissection problem is the problem of partitioning a geometric figure into smaller pieces that may be rearranged into a new figure of equal content. In this context, the partitioning is called simply a dissection. It is usually required that the dissection use only a finite number of pieces. Additionally, to avoid set-theoretic issues related to the Banach–Tarski paradox and Tarski's circle-squaring problem, the pieces are typically required to be well-behaved. For instance, they may be restricted to being the closures of disjoint open sets.

The Knaster–Kuratowski–Mazurkiewicz lemma is a basic result in mathematical fixed-point theory published in 1929 by Knaster, Kuratowski and Mazurkiewicz.

<i>Proofs from THE BOOK</i> 1998 mathematics book by Aigner and Ziegler

Proofs from THE BOOK is a book of mathematical proofs by Martin Aigner and Günter M. Ziegler. The book is dedicated to the mathematician Paul Erdős, who often referred to "The Book" in which God keeps the most elegant proof of each mathematical theorem. During a lecture in 1985, Erdős said, "You don't have to believe in God, but you should believe in The Book."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Handshaking lemma</span> Every graph has evenly many odd vertices

In graph theory, a branch of mathematics, the handshaking lemma is the statement that, in every finite undirected graph, the number of vertices that touch an odd number of edges is even. For example, if there is a party of people who shake hands, the number of people who shake an odd number of other people's hands is even. The handshaking lemma is a consequence of the degree sum formula, also sometimes called the handshaking lemma, according to which the sum of the degrees equals twice the number of edges in the graph. Both results were proven by Leonhard Euler (1736) in his famous paper on the Seven Bridges of Königsberg that began the study of graph theory.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pseudotriangle</span>

In Euclidean plane geometry, a pseudotriangle (pseudo-triangle) is the simply connected subset of the plane that lies between any three mutually tangent convex sets. A pseudotriangulation (pseudo-triangulations) is a partition of a region of the plane into pseudotriangles, and a pointed pseudotriangulation is a pseudotriangulation in which at each vertex the incident edges span an angle of less than π.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Monsky</span> American mathematician

Paul Monsky is an American mathematician and professor at Brandeis University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tucker's lemma</span>

In mathematics, Tucker's lemma is a combinatorial analog of the Borsuk–Ulam theorem, named after Albert W. Tucker.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Associahedron</span> Convex polytope of parenthesizations

In mathematics, an associahedronKn is an (n – 2)-dimensional convex polytope in which each vertex corresponds to a way of correctly inserting opening and closing parentheses in a string of n letters, and the edges correspond to single application of the associativity rule. Equivalently, the vertices of an associahedron correspond to the triangulations of a regular polygon with n + 1 sides and the edges correspond to edge flips in which a single diagonal is removed from a triangulation and replaced by a different diagonal. Associahedra are also called Stasheff polytopes after the work of Jim Stasheff, who rediscovered them in the early 1960s after earlier work on them by Dov Tamari.

In geometry and polyhedral combinatorics, a k-neighborly polytope is a convex polytope in which every set of k or fewer vertices forms a face. For instance, a 2-neighborly polytope is a polytope in which every pair of vertices is connected by an edge, forming a complete graph. 2-neighborly polytopes with more than four vertices may exist only in spaces of four or more dimensions, and in general a k-neighborly polytope requires a dimension of 2k or more. A d-simplex is d-neighborly. A polytope is said to be neighborly, without specifying k, if it is k-neighborly for k = ⌊d2. If we exclude simplices, this is the maximum possible k: in fact, every polytope that is k-neighborly for some k ≥ 1 + ⌊d2 is a simplex.

In geometry, the moment curve is an algebraic curve in d-dimensional Euclidean space given by the set of points with Cartesian coordinates of the form

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Equidissection</span> Partition of a polygon into triangles of equal area

In geometry, an equidissection is a partition of a polygon into triangles of equal area. The study of equidissections began in the late 1960s with Monsky's theorem, which states that a square cannot be equidissected into an odd number of triangles. In fact, most polygons cannot be equidissected at all.

The Simmons–Su protocols are several protocols for envy-free division. They are based on Sperner's lemma. The merits of these protocols is that they put few restrictions on the preferences of the partners, and ask the partners only simple queries such as "which piece do you prefer?".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ky Fan lemma</span> Combinatorial lemma

In mathematics, Ky Fan's lemma (KFL) is a combinatorial lemma about labellings of triangulations. It is a generalization of Tucker's lemma. It was proved by Ky Fan in 1952.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zonogon</span> Convex polygon with pairs of equal, parallel sides

In geometry, a zonogon is a centrally-symmetric, convex polygon. Equivalently, it is a convex polygon whose sides can be grouped into parallel pairs with equal lengths and opposite orientations.

In geometry, it is an unsolved conjecture of Hugo Hadwiger that every simplex can be dissected into orthoschemes, using a number of orthoschemes bounded by a function of the dimension of the simplex. If true, then more generally every convex polytope could be dissected into orthoschemes.

In graph theory, a rainbow-independent set (ISR) is an independent set in a graph, in which each vertex has a different color.

References

  1. Aigner, Martin; Ziegler, Günter M. (2010). "One square and an odd number of triangles". Proofs from The Book (4th ed.). Berlin: Springer-Verlag. pp.  131–138. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-00856-6_20. ISBN   978-3-642-00855-9.
  2. 1 2 Xu, Moor (April 4, 2012). Sperner's Lemma (PDF) (Technical report). University of California, Berkeley.
  3. Monsky, P. (1970). "On Dividing a Square into Triangles". The American Mathematical Monthly. 77 (2): 161–164. doi:10.2307/2317329. JSTOR   2317329. MR   0252233.
  4. Stein, S. (2004). Kleber, M.; Vakil, R. (eds.). "Cutting a Polygon into Triangles of Equal Areas". The Mathematical Intelligencer. 26: 17–21. doi:10.1007/BF02985395. S2CID   117930135.
  5. Verrill, H. A. (September 8, 2004). "Dissecting a square into triangles" (PDF). Louisiana State University. Archived from the original (PDF) on August 18, 2010. Retrieved 2010-08-18.
  6. Mansow, K. (2003), Ungerade Triangulierungen eines Quadrats von kleiner Diskrepanz (en. Odd triangulations of a square of small discrepancy) (Diplomarbeit), Germany: TU Berlin.
  7. Schulze, Bernd (1 July 2011). "On the area discrepancy of triangulations of squares and trapezoids". Electronic Journal of Combinatorics . 18 (1): #P137. doi: 10.37236/624 . Zbl   1222.52017.
  8. Labbé, Jean-Philippe; Rote, Günter; Ziegler, Günter M. (2018). "Area Difference Bounds for Dissections of a Square into an Odd Number of Triangles". Experimental Mathematics. 29 (3): 1–23. arXiv: 1708.02891 . doi:10.1080/10586458.2018.1459961. S2CID   3995120.