Darkness Visible: A Study of Vergil's Aeneid

Last updated
Darkness Visible: A Study of Vergil's Aeneid
Darkness Visible.jpg
Cover of the first edition
Author W. R. Johnson
LanguageEnglish
Subject Vergil's Aeneid
Published1976
Publisher University of California Press
Pages179
ISBN 978-0-520-03848-6

Darkness Visible: A Study of Vergil's Aeneid is an academic monograph by the American Latinist W. R. Johnson. Published in 1976 by University of California Press, the book presents an interpretation of the Aeneid , an epic by the Roman poet Vergil. Claiming to abandon previously dominant historical-political reading, Johnson argues that the poem is at its heart concerned with the darkness of the human condition.

Contents

Darkness Visible was met with mixed reviews with commentators praising its central claims but criticising its argumentation, style, and bibliographic documentation. The book is also credited with coining the term 'Harvard school' to describe a brand of pessimistic Vergil scholarship produced in the English-speaking world. Even though the designation established itself in academic discourse, it was rejected in 1995 by one of the school's proponents, Wendell Clausen.

Publication

Darkness Visible: A Study of Vergil's Aeneid was written by the American classicist W. R. Johnson and published by University of California Press in 1976. The original edition had 179 pages. [1] In 2015, University of Chicago Press published a second edition of the work. [2]

Summary

In a first expository chapter ('Eliot's Myth and Vergil's Fictions'), Johnson reviews critical opinions about Vergil's Aeneid in the 20th century. He describes that the poem has been understood as a coherent historical and political allegory. Within this allegorical interpretation, he identifies two opposing viewpoints. The first of these views the Aeneid as a wholehearted endorsement of the political order established by Augustus, the first Roman emperor. Johnson labels this school of thought 'optimistic' or 'European' and lists as its proponents among others the British poet T. S. Eliot, the German philologists Viktor Pöschl  [ de ] and Karl Büchner  [ de ], and the American classicist Brooks Otis. The other fraction of critics, described as the 'pessimistic' or 'Harvard' school, interprets the poem as a nihilistic critique of the Augustan regime; its main proponents, according to Johnson, are the American classicists Michael C. J. Putnam, Robert Angus Brooks, Wendell Clausen, and Adam Parry. He rejects both of these approaches and proposes to interpret the Aeneid as a polysemantic work of literature, following a method devised by the French bible scholar Nicholas of Lyra which divides allegories into different levels of meaning.

The book's second chapter ('Lessing, Auerbach, Gombrich: The Norm of Reality and the Spectrum of Decorum') analyses Vergil's style by juxtaposing his symbolic imagery with the realism of the Homeric epics, a method originally devised by the German critic Erich Auerbach. In several case studies taken from the poem, Johnson argues that Vergil tends to create vague, impressionistic images that lack the clarity of the Homeric poets but illustrate the complexity of the human condition. Chapter Three ('Varia Confusus Imagine Rerum') focuses on a sequence of passages (notably the deaths of Dido and Turnus), in which the goddess Juno, the poem's antagonist, plays an important role. Johnson agrees that Juno represents the powers of irrationality and darkness looming over the poem's characters. The ending of the poem, where Aeneas gives in to his merciless fury and kills Turnus, is thus interpreted as a victory for the goddess, even though she had sought to protect Turnus.

The final chapter ('The Worlds Vergil Lived In') uses the observations of the preceding two chapters to arrive at an overall interpretation of the poem. Johnson here employs the multiple levels of meaning proposed by Nicolaus of Lyra. He argues that Aeneid depicts on the first, allegorical level the insecurities of Roman society during the tumultuous transition from the Roman Republic to the Roman Empire, which happened during Vergil's lifetime. He identifies as the poem's metaphysical concern a struggle between the rationalism of Classical Greek philosophy and what Johnson describes as 'mystery religions' such as Neopythagoreanism, whose growing influence he sees in the poem's powerful personifications of evil in characters such as Juno and Alecto. His third interpretation of the poem is ethical: through the sufferings of the Aeneas who tries to resist the surrounding darkness, Vergil holds up the rational principles of Epicureanism which, according to Johnson, formed an important part of his intellectual background.

Reception

The book received mixed reviews upon publication. The British Latinist Nicholas Horsfall considered it "difficult, wayward, and provocative" while conceding that it was "deeply stimulating, often entertaining, and strikingly independent in outlook". He accepted Johnson's claim that the world of the Aeneid is chaotic and dark, but criticised the book for a number of inaccuracies including interpretation, bibliographic documentation, and awareness of contemporary scholarship. [3] In a review for Arion , the classicist William Porter praised the book for rejecting the predominant social-political interpretation of the poem. [4] Sharing Horsfall's assessment, he endorsed the book's analysis of Vergil's negative imagery [5] but wrote that Johnson failed to see the wider implications of his observations and pursued his main line of argumentation "to the exclusion of all others". [6]

Several reviewers commented on Johnson's writing style. For the Vergil scholar Harry Rutledge, the book's style exhibited "the remarkable qualities of the oracular, the arcane, the arrestingly simple", although it suffered from the "aphoristic brevity" of its arguments. [7] The poet and classicist K. W. Gransden, on the other hand, thought that Johnson had a tendency to unnecessary obscurity and mystification. [8] He also objected to the use of untranslated quotation of ancient Greek and the lack of bibliographic documentation. [9]

Harvard school

In the first chapter, Johnson divides previous scholarship of the Aeneid into a 'European' and a 'Harvard' school. The latter term in particular became a standard descriptor for the pessimistic scholarship of the poem, produced in the English-speaking world. [10] In 1995, Clausen, whom Johnson had identified as a proponent of the Harvard School, published a short article about the term. Crediting Johnson with inventing it, he argues that the designation is a misnomer since most of the ideas central to his school of thought originated at places other than Harvard University. Instead, Clausen suggests that he and Parry formed some of their thoughts about the poem while working at Amherst College. [11]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeneas</span> Trojan hero in Greco-Roman mythology

In Greco-Roman mythology, Aeneas was a Trojan hero, the son of the Trojan prince Anchises and the Greek goddess Aphrodite. His father was a first cousin of King Priam of Troy, making Aeneas a second cousin to Priam's children. He is a minor character in Greek mythology and is mentioned in Homer's Iliad. Aeneas receives full treatment in Roman mythology, most extensively in Virgil's Aeneid, where he is cast as an ancestor of Romulus and Remus. He became the first true hero of Rome. Snorri Sturluson identifies him with the Norse god Víðarr of the Æsir.

In Greek mythology, Aeolus or Aiolos is a name shared by three mythical characters. These three personages are often difficult to tell apart, and even the ancient mythographers appear to have been perplexed about which Aeolus was which. Diodorus Siculus made an attempt to define each of these three, and his opinion is followed here.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Virgil</span> 1st-century-BC Roman poet

Publius Vergilius Maro, usually called Virgil or Vergil in English, was an ancient Roman poet of the Augustan period. He composed three of the most famous poems in Latin literature: the Eclogues, the Georgics, and the epic Aeneid. A number of minor poems, collected in the Appendix Vergiliana, were attributed to him in ancient times, but modern scholars consider his authorship of these poems to be dubious.

<i>Aeneid</i> Latin epic poem by Virgil

The Aeneid is a Latin epic poem that tells the legendary story of Aeneas, a Trojan who fled the fall of Troy and travelled to Italy, where he became the ancestor of the Romans. Written by the Roman poet Virgil between 29 and 19 BC, the Aeneid comprises 9,896 lines in dactylic hexameter. The first six of the poem's twelve books tell the story of Aeneas' wanderings from Troy to Italy, and the poem's second half tells of the Trojans' ultimately victorious war upon the Latins, under whose name Aeneas and his Trojan followers are destined to be subsumed.

In Greek mythology, Idmon may refer to the following individuals:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Turnus</span> Mythical character King of the Rutuli

Turnus was the legendary King of the Rutuli in Roman history, and the chief antagonist of the hero Aeneas in Virgil's Aeneid.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lavinia</span> Wife of Aeneas in Roman mythology

In Roman mythology, Lavinia is the daughter of Latinus and Amata, and the last wife of Aeneas.

<i>Eclogues</i> Poem collection by Virgil

The Eclogues, also called the Bucolics, is the first of the three major works of the Latin poet Virgil.

<i>Appendix Vergiliana</i> Collection of Poems written by Virgil.

The Appendix Vergiliana is a collection of Latin poems traditionally ascribed as being the juvenilia of Virgil.

Gyas, a character in Virgil's Aeneid, features most extensively as one of the captains in the boat race in Book 5. He also appears (briefly) in Books 1 and 12. He was claimed as the eponymous ancestor of the Gegania gens, a patrician family of the Roman Republic.

Darkness Visible is a phrase from Milton's poem Paradise Lost. It may refer to:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eduard Fraenkel</span> German classical scholar (1888–1970)

Eduard David Mortier FraenkelFBA was a German classical scholar who served as the Corpus Christi Professor of Latin at the University of Oxford from 1935 until 1953. Born to a family of assimilated Jews in the German Empire, he studied Classics at the universities of Berlin and Göttingen. In 1934, antisemitic legislation introduced by the Nazi Party forced him to seek refuge in the United Kingdom where he eventually settled at Corpus Christi College.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alecto</span> Fury (Erinys) in Greek mythology

Alecto is one of the Erinyes (Furies) in Greek mythology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">R. A. B. Mynors</span> British classical scholar (1903–1989)

Sir Roger Aubrey Baskerville Mynors was an English classicist and medievalist who held the senior chairs of Latin at the universities of Oxford and Cambridge. A textual critic, he was an expert in the study of manuscripts and their role in the reconstruction of classical texts.

<i>Eclogue</i> 4 Poem by Virgil

Eclogue4, also known as the FourthEclogue, is a Latin poem by the Roman poet Virgil. The poem is dated to 40 BC by its mention of the consulship of Virgil's patron Gaius Asinius Pollio.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">K. W. Gransden</span> English author and educator (1925 – 1998)

Karl Watts Gransden was a British poet and an editor, translator, scholar, and teacher of Latin and English literature. He spent his career at the British Museum and the University of Warwick.

Nicholas Mark Horsfall was a British scholar of Latin literature. Educated at Peterhouse, Cambridge, and Corpus Christi College, Oxford, he worked as a lecturer at University College London, but retired in 1987. He was a specialist on the works of the Roman poet Vergil and published five commentaries (2000–2013) on individual books of his Aeneid. This series of commentaries was described by the Latinist James O'Hara as "one of the most remarkably productive and rich periods of publication of any modern classicist".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Corynaeus</span> Name of one or more characters in Virgils Aeneid

Corynaeus is the name of one or more characters in Virgil's Aeneid (29–19 BCE). The first mention of Corynaeus in the poem is as a Trojan follower of Aeneas, who performs funerary rites for Misenus. Characters of the same name are then specified both as being killed by an archer, and later fighting in the final battle. This apparent contradiction is often explained by defining them as two separate characters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adam Parry</span> American classicist (1928–1971

Adam Milman Parry was an American classical scholar. He worked on Greek and Latin history literature, particularly the works of Thucydides, Homer and Virgil, and was a founding figure of the scholarly movement that became known as the Harvard School of criticism into Virgil's Aeneid.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">W. R. Johnson</span> American classical scholar (1933–2024)

Walter Ralph Johnson, commonly known as W. Ralph Johnson and published as W. R. Johnson, was an American classicist. He was the John Matthews Manly Distinguished Service Professor in the Department of Classics at the University of Chicago from 1989 to 1998.

References

  1. ↑ Horsfall 1979, p. 231.
  2. ↑ Darkness visible: a study of Vergil's Aeneid. OCLC   889996885 . Retrieved 2022-05-10– via WorldCat.
  3. ↑ Horsfall 1979, p. 233.
  4. ↑ Porter 1976, p. 493.
  5. ↑ Porter 1976, p. 496.
  6. ↑ Porter 1976, p. 497.
  7. ↑ Rutledge 1977, p. 73.
  8. ↑ Gransden 1978, p. 248.
  9. ↑ Gransden 1978, pp. 248–249.
  10. ↑ Tarrant 2012, pp. 16–17, n. 66.
  11. ↑ Clausen 1995, p. 313.

Bibliography

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.