William's Doll

Last updated
William's Doll
William's Doll (1972 book).jpg
Author Charlotte Zolotow
Illustrator William Pène du Bois
Genre Picture book
PublisherHarper & Row
Publication date
1972
Pages30 pp
ISBN 978-0-06-443067-8
OCLC 347798

William's Doll is a 1972 picture book by Charlotte Zolotow, one of the first children's texts to address nontraditional gender stereotypes. The story follows William, a young boy who wishes for a doll to care for. His father is unhappy with this, instead giving him toys that he considers to be more gender appropriate. Finally, his grandfather fulfills his request, explaining to her son that it will let him practice good parenting.

Contents

Zolotow cites personal observations about the relationship between her husband and son as inspiration for the book. [1] [2] She believes that denying young boys access to certain toys and absences of early interaction between father and child are destructive to expression and relationship formation. [3]

The book often is used in the classroom for lessons on gender roles, intolerance, or general anti-bias education. [4] [5] [6] To counterbalance inherent micro-inequalities in the classroom, William's Doll is employed as a method through which educators expose students to the concept of sex-stereotyping. [4] While exposure through children's literature has been employed by many marginalized populations, representations of males such as William with traditionally female characteristics have not been as easily welcomed. [5] [6] Many educators, for example, object to using texts representing gender-role reversal in the classroom, whereas others promote it, recognizing the critical role schools play in childhood identity and sexuality development. [7] [8]

A song based on the story was included in the 1972 best-selling Free to Be... You and Me children's album and songbook. [9] In 1981, William's Doll also became a 14-minute film starring Craig Salles. [1]

Background

Published in 1972, William's Doll extends Zolotow's legacy of recognizing and legitimatizing the emotional capacity of small children. [1] Rejecting condescension based on age, Zolotow appeals to genuineness by introducing themes such as death and anger, and in William's Doll, non-traditional gender stereotypes, to young audiences. [1]

Zolotow explained that although she is a feminist and appreciates feminist support of the book's message, her inspiration derives from personal observations about her husband's early attempts to bond with the couple's son, Stephen. [1] [2] She cites a specific experience that later became the basis of the book. [2] As a result of her husband's refusal to fulfil their son's request for a stuffed animal lion due to his association between stuffed animals and femininity, Zolotow later purchased the item for Stephen behind her husband's back. [2] Zolotow argues that denying young boys access to certain toys rejects fulfilment of genuine human instinct. [3] Observing similar interactions between fathers and sons at local parks, Zolotow found inspiration in how men of the time period missed out on some of the pleasures of being closely involved with their children's early development. [1] [3] She observed, for example, that by always exiting the room during diaper changes, her husband missed their son's first smile. [1] [3] Such absences of early interaction between father and child, Zolotow believes, result in a breach in the foundation of the relationship. [3]

Summary

William's Doll follows the story of William, a young boy who wishes for a doll to care for. His father, uncomfortable with William's request, tries giving William toys that he considers to be more gender-appropriate, such as a basketball and a train set. William still enjoys these toys, practicing his basketball skills and playing with his train set for hours. He persists with his request for a doll, enduring taunting by his brother and other boys in the neighborhood. When William's grandmother comes to visit, William shows her the toys his father bought him, but mentions his continuing desire for a doll to care for. Finally, William's grandmother fulfills William's request, upsetting William's father. William's grandmother explains to William's father that the doll will allow for William to practice good parenting and grow into a great father just like him.[ citation needed ]

Analysis

Numerous scholars analyze the use of William's Doll in the classroom. The impact of the book, a representation of non-traditional gender stereotypes in children, is significant in the classroom as a tool to address gender micro-inequalities, intolerance, and learning challenges faced by non-English speaking students. [4] [5] [6] The effects of sexism are residual, especially in the classroom, the center of childhood socialization. [4] [8] Sex stereotyping by educators is reinforced by inequity of time, encouragement, difficulty of assignments, and expectation of success offered between male and female students, labeled "hidden curriculum." [4] [8] To counterbalance inherent inequity in the classroom, William's Doll is employed as a method through which educators may expose students to the concept of sex-stereotyping. [4] Introducing relatable characters who are not stereotypically gender-conformant such as William allows for a source of new role models. [4]

This method of exposure through children's literature has been employed by many marginalized populations. Representations of males such as William who are portrayed as having traditionally female characteristics have not been as easily welcomed. [5] [6] For example, to promote women's involvement in traditionally male-dominated careers, sports, and other interests, the Women's Movement witnessed a surge of empowering female characters in children's literature. [6] A persistent lack of non-traditional male characters such as William is proposed to be a reflection of unchanging male stereotypes despite evolving popular opinion regarding gender roles. [6] Dr. Cecilia Silva, a professor at Texas Christian University, claims society is oblivious to this "boy code," only prominent when characters such as William contravene. [6] For many noncomformant males, the result of conforming with the "code" is low self-esteem and emotional growth obstacles. [5]

Implementing William's Doll in the classroom is frequently proposed as a tool to assist children in identifying sex stereotyping, so it has become the focus of many classroom studies. [4] Martha Goldstein-Schultz, a professor at the University of Connecticut, suggests family and consumer science classrooms as environments to promote discussions concerning sex stereotypes. [8] She emphasizes the critical role schools play in childhood identity and sexuality development as platforms to encourage questions and acceptance through exposure to literature such as William's Doll. [8] A study investigating student responses to a classroom read-aloud of William's Doll to a sample of young boys found that including literature with gender-uncomforant males elicits increased identification of textual interrelation. [10]

Reception and legacy

Considering the role of William's Doll in the classroom, scholars focus on teachers' reception of the book as they choose class readings. Julie Wollman-Bonilla, a graduate of Harvard University's Institute for Educational Management, identifies elementary teachers' lack of selection of nonmainstream titles such as William's Doll. [7] She argues that every children's text presents a set of morals and endorses a specific code of conduct. [7] Texts displaying white, middle-class American values are the prevailing choice among elementary school educators, neglecting books representing the perspective of marginalized populations on the basis of sex, race, or socioeconomic factors. [7]

In Wollman-Bonilla's sample of teachers' reception, she found that most educators objected to texts representing gender-role reversal. [7] In response to William's Doll, many teachers referenced their own parenting techniques as reasons to reject its use in the classroom. [7] For example, many educators' responses aligned with this male teacher's assertion about the text: "I would never let my son play with a doll!" [7] In general, male educators were more adverse to the use of William's Doll in their classrooms than female educators, although the dominant opinion across both genders was negative. [7] Wollman-Bonilla identifies that opposition to William's Doll was mostly by gender-conformant people who endorse gender roles as a natural order. [7] Books such as William's Doll suggest that sex stereotyping is an intrinsic societal issue that needs to be addressed. [7]

Adaptations

A song based on the story, with music by Mary Rodgers and lyrics by Sheldon Harnick, was included in the best-selling Free to Be... You and Me children's album and songbook in 1972, where it was sung by Alan Alda and Marlo Thomas. [9] The song was later sung by B. D. Wong at the Ms. Foundation's 15th Annual Gloria Awards ceremony in 2003, where Marlo Thomas and former Ms. Foundation president Letty Cottin Pogrebin received the Creative Philanthropy Award for the album's creation. [9]

When Free to Be... You and Me became a television special in 1974, ABC asked producer Marlo Thomas to omit William's Doll for fear it would promote homosexuality. [11] Thomas rejected the omission. [11]

William's Doll also became a 14-minute film in 1981. [1] The 1981 film starred Craig Salles as William and was shot in Graceada Park in Modesto, California. In 2010, the producers of RiffTrax, formerly Mystery Science Theater 3000, released William's Doll. [12] This was their "riff" of the aforementioned short. [12]

Related Research Articles

A gender role, or sex role, is a set of socially accepted behaviors and attitudes deemed appropriate or desirable for individuals based on their sex. Gender roles are usually centered on conceptions of masculinity and femininity, although there are exceptions and variations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Toy</span> Entertaining object primarily used by children

A toy or plaything is an object that is used primarily to provide entertainment. Simple examples include toy blocks, board games, and dolls. Toys are often designed for use by children, although many are designed specifically for adults and pets. Toys can provide utilitarian benefits, including physical exercise, cultural awareness, or academic education. Additionally, utilitarian objects, especially those which are no longer needed for their original purpose, can be used as toys. Examples include children building a fort with empty cereal boxes and tissue paper spools, or a toddler playing with a broken TV remote control. The term "toy" can also be used to refer to utilitarian objects purchased for enjoyment rather than need, or for expensive necessities for which a large fraction of the cost represents its ability to provide enjoyment to the owner, such as luxury cars, high-end motorcycles, gaming computers, and flagship smartphones.

Gender identity is the personal sense of one's own gender. Gender identity can correlate with a person's assigned sex or can differ from it. In most individuals, the various biological determinants of sex are congruent, and consistent with the individual's gender identity. Gender expression typically reflects a person's gender identity, but this is not always the case. While a person may express behaviors, attitudes, and appearances consistent with a particular gender role, such expression may not necessarily reflect their gender identity. The term gender identity was coined by psychiatry professor Robert J. Stoller in 1964 and popularized by the controversial psychologist John Money.

Gender neutrality, also known as gender-neutralism or the gender neutrality movement, is the idea that policies, language, and other social institutions should avoid distinguishing roles according to people's sex or gender. This is in order to avoid discrimination arising from the impression that there are social roles for which one gender is more suited than another. The disparity in gender equality throughout history has had a significant impact on many aspects of society, including marketing, toys, education and parenting techniques. In order to increase gender neutrality in recent years, there has been a societal emphasis on utilizing inclusive language and advocating for equality.

<i>Free to Be... You and Me</i> 1970s US childrens entertainment project

Free to Be... You and Me is a children's entertainment project, conceived, created and executive-produced by actress and author Marlo Thomas. Produced in collaboration with the Ms. Foundation for Women, it was a record album and illustrated book first released in November 1972 featuring songs and stories sung or told by celebrities of the day including Alan Alda, Rosey Grier, Cicely Tyson, Carol Channing, Michael Jackson, Roberta Flack, Shirley Jones, Jack Cassidy, and Diana Ross. An ABC television special, also created by Thomas, using poetry, songs, and sketches, followed sixteen months later in March 1974. The basic concept was to encourage post-1960s gender neutrality, saluting values such as individuality, tolerance, and comfort with one's identity. A major thematic message is that anyone—whether a boy or a girl—can achieve anything.

Charlotte Zolotow was an American writer, poet, editor, and publisher of many books for children. She wrote about 70 picture book texts.

Childhood gender nonconformity (CGN) is a phenomenon in which prepubescent children do not conform to expected gender-related sociological or psychological patterns, or identify with the opposite sex/gender. Typical behavior among those who exhibit the phenomenon includes but is not limited to a propensity to cross-dress, refusal to take part in activities conventionally thought suitable for the gender and the exclusive choice of play-mates of the opposite sex.

Earring Magic Ken, also known as "Gay Ken" and "Fey Ken", is a model of the Ken doll introduced by Mattel in 1993 as a companion to its Earring Magic Barbie figure, one of five dolls in the Earring Magic Barbie line.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sex differences in education</span> Educational discrimination on the basis of sex

Sex differences in education are a type of sex discrimination in the education system affecting both men and women during and after their educational experiences. Men are more likely to be literate on a global average, although higher literacy scores for women are prevalent in many countries. Women are more likely to achieve a tertiary education degree compared to men of the same age. Men tended to receive more education than women in the past, but the gender gap in education has reversed in recent decades in most Western countries and many non-Western countries.

The social construction of gender is a theory in the humanities and social sciences about the manifestation of cultural origins, mechanisms, and corollaries of gender perception and expression in the context of interpersonal and group social interaction. Specifically, the social construction of gender theory stipulates that gender roles are an achieved "status" in a social environment, which implicitly and explicitly categorize people and therefore motivate social behaviors.

Gender typing is the process by which a child becomes aware of their gender and thus behaves accordingly by adopting values and attributes of members of the sex that they identify as their own. This process is important for a child's social and personality development because it largely impacts the child's understanding of expected social behavior and influences social judgments.

Feminist pedagogy is a pedagogical framework grounded in feminist theory. It embraces a set of epistemological theories, teaching strategies, approaches to content, classroom practices, and teacher-student relationships. Feminist pedagogy, along with other kinds of progressive and critical pedagogy, considers knowledge to be socially constructed.

<i>My Princess Boy</i> Book about a gender non-conforming child

My Princess Boy is a 2009 children's picture book written by Cheryl Kilodavis and illustrated by Suzanne DeSimone. The story centers on a boy who likes "pretty things" and prefers to wear tiaras and "girly dresses." The story informs readers about supporting children regardless of their expression. Despite the attention he receives regarding his appearance, the Princess Boy always has the love and support of his family throughout the entire story.

Gender roles are culturally influenced stereotypes which create expectations for appropriate behavior for males and females. An understanding of these roles is evident in children as young as age four. Children between 3 and 6 months can form distinctions between male and female faces. By ten months, infants can associate certain objects with females and males, like a hammer with males or scarf with females. Gender roles are influenced by the media, family, the environment, and society. In addition to biological maturation, children develop within a set of gender-specific social and behavioral norms embedded in family structure, natural play patterns, close friendships, and the teeming social jungle of school life. The gender roles encountered in childhood play a large part in shaping an individual's self-concept and influence the way an individual forms relationships later on in life.

Feminist children's literature is the writing of children's literature through a feminist lens. Children's literature and women's literature have many similarities. Both often deal with being seen as weak and placed towards the bottom of a hierarchy. In this way feminist ideas are regularly found in the structure of children's literature. Feminist criticism of children's literature is therefore expected, since it is a type of feminist literature. Feminist children's literature has played a critical role for the feminist movement, especially in the past half century. In her book Feminism Is for Everybody: Passionate Politics, bell hooks states her belief that all types of media, including writing and children's books, need to promote feminist ideals. She argues "Children's literature is one of the most crucial sites for feminist education for critical consciousness precisely because beliefs and identities are still being formed". The cover of hooks' book, drawn by Laura DeSantis, depicts children alongside adults, showing the importance of the youth. The presence of feminism in children's literature has evolved over the years, but the overall message and goals have remained consistent.

The portrayal of parents in media sometimes depicts gender stereotypes in society, often highlighting the "traditional nuclear family" as opposed to nonconventional configurations. Social Scientists have found that home, family, and romance are three of the most important components of the way characters are presented. Moreover, these qualities are often presented in a stereotypical and traditional fashion. In the 1950s the meaning of the word parent coincided with the nuclear family structure—husband, wife, and children. Parents had a responsibility to uphold traditional gender roles in society. Gender roles in society were as follows: fathers work outside of the home and bring in the bread, while mothers tend to housework, make sure they are emotionally available, and look after the children. In today's time, the definition and responsibility of a parent has become more flexible/adjustable since the 1950s, although some parents tend to stick to their traditional gender roles. For example, two-married-parent families were the most common type of family unit a generation ago; however, in the year 2000 that particular family structure could only be found in one out of four households. Because of the shift in parenting, media outlets took it upon themselves to provide representation for certain family structures outside of the nuclear family, leaving them flexible as well. Mass media has presented a multitude of family structures and has promoted the acceptance of alternate family structures in many ways including television, newspapers, movies, commercials, books, comics, etc. Media is linked to the structure of families, given that parents and their children confide in it when questioning their own family and parenting practices. Its influence impacts parents positively and negatively, either by underrepresentation or drawing the perfect picture.

Sex differences in education in the United States refers to the specific issues, such as gender-based discrimination related to coursework and use of disciplinary action, that American students of all genders encounter. Furthermore, while sex differences in education explains the prevalence of gender-based differences in education on a global scale, the American education system includes specific forms of gender discrimination dissimilar to other countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Boys' toys and games</span> Subset of toy and games that appeal to male children

Boys' toys and games, as opposed to girls' toys and games, are a subset of toy and games that appeal to male children. Research suggests that this appeal may be driven by biological factors, peer pressure, parental choices, marketing, and tradition.

<i>X: A Fabulous Childs Story</i> Picture book first published as a short story

X: A Fabulous Child's Story, written by Lois Gould, was first published as a short story in the magazine Ms. in 1972 and republished by Daughters Publishing as a picture book in 1978 with illustrations by Jacqueline Chwast. The book tells the story of X, a child raised as part of an experiment to keep its gender unknown to everyone but its parents and the scientists conducting the experiment.

Men in early childhood education comprise a very low minority in the profession. Early childhood education is among the most female-dominated industries in terms of employment. Based on studies, estimates on the percentage of workers in the sector who are men include 1.4%, 2%, 2.4%, and 3%. Due to the low percentage of men in early childhood education, there is also little representation of queer men or men of colour overall in the field.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Charlotte Zolotow on the origins of William's Doll, charlottezolotow.com (retrieved June 1, 2007)
  2. 1 2 3 4 Johnson, Nancy J.; Giorgis, Cyndi (2006). "Talking with Charlotte Zolotow". Book Links. 15 (6). ProQuest   197210015.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Zolotow, Charlotte (1998). "Making Picture Books: The Words". The Horn Book Magazine. 74 (2): 185–189. ProQuest   199349189.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Marshall, Carol Sue; Reinhartz, Judy (21 November 2012). "Gender Issues in the Classroom". The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas. 70 (6): 333–337. doi:10.1080/00098655.1997.10543538. JSTOR   30185879. ProQuest   196868730.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Tunks, Karyn Wellhousen; McGee, Jessica (June 2006). "Embracing William, Oliver Button, and Tough Boris: Learning Acceptance from Characters in Children's Literature". Childhood Education. 82 (4): 213–218. doi:10.1080/00094056.2006.10522825. S2CID   145102079. ProQuest   210389626.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Silva, Cecilia; Kucer, Stephen B. (1997). "Expanding Curricular Conversations Through Unification, Diversity, and Access". Language Arts. 74 (1): 26–32. JSTOR   41482835. ProQuest   196878718.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Wollman-Bonilla, Julie E. (1998). "Outrageous Viewpoints: Teachers' Criteria for Rejecting Works of Children's Literature". Language Arts. 75 (4): 287–295. JSTOR   41962063. ProQuest   196857007.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Goldstein-Schultz, Martha (1 August 2016). "The Living Gender Curriculum: Helping FCS Students Analyze Gender Stereotypes". Journal of Family & Consumer Sciences. 108 (3): 56–62. doi:10.14307/JFCS108.3.56. ProQuest   1815971560.
  9. 1 2 3 "Yoko Ono Presents Award" (undated article, retrieved June 1, 2007) Archived from the original
  10. ↑ Hansen, Cory Cooper; Zambo, Debby (15 December 2009). "Boys in the Club: Exploring Positive Male Archetypes with Preschool Males". Literacy Research and Instruction. 49 (1): 40–55. doi:10.1080/19388070802613468. S2CID   144177466. ProQuest   205371709.
  11. 1 2 Ingall, Majorie (May 28, 2004). "The JCC in Manhattan". Archived from the original on 2005-11-26. Retrieved 2019-12-15.
  12. 1 2 RiffTrax.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.