2008 Bhutanese National Assembly election

2008 Bhutanese National Assembly election

24 March 2008 2013  →
All 47 seats in the National Assembly 24 seats needed for a majority
First party Second party   Leader Jigme Thinley Sangay Ngedup Party DPT PDP Seats won 45 2 Popular vote 169,490 83,322 Percentage 67.04% 32.96%
Results by constituency
Prime Minister before election Kinzang Dorji Independent Prime Minister-designate Jigme Thinley DPT

National Assembly elections were held in Bhutan for the first time on 24 March 2008. ^[1] Two parties were registered by the Election Commission of Bhutan to contest the elections; Druk Phuensum Tshogpa, led by Jigme Y. Thinley, which was formed by the merger of the Bhutan People's United Party and All People's Party, ^[2] and the People's Democratic Party (PDP). A third political party, the Bhutan National Party (BNP), ^[3] had its application for the registration refused.

Electoral system

The elections for the 47 seats of the National Assembly were planned to be held in two rounds: In the first round, voters would have voted for a party. The two parties with the largest share of the national vote would then have been able to field candidates in the 47 constituencies. ^[4] However, as only two parties had successfully registered for the election, the election was held in one round. ^[1]

Background

Paro College mock election

The Electoral Commission first experimented with elections with a mock election at the Paro College of Education. This involved the college's faculty and students as candidates and voters. The first round was conducted on 8 September 2006, and the second round was conducted on 9 September. 620 voters in 2 polling stations voted for one of six 'dummy' political parties using Electronic Voting Machines. ^[5]

In the first round, turnout was 96%, and it was 87% in the second round. The two parties which proceeded to the second round were the Bhutan Forward Party, and the Druk Unity Party.

Party		Primary round		General round
		Votes	%	Votes	%
	Bhutan Forward	245	41.39	295	54.43
	Druk Unity	93	15.71	247	45.57
	National Freedom	76	12.84
	Druk Socialist Party	75	12.67
	Bhutan Democratic Party	62	10.47
	Druk Yarphel Party	41	6.93
Total		592	100.00	542	100.00
Registered voters/turnout		620	–	620	–
Source: ECB

National mock election

On 21 April 2007 a mock election was held to prepare the population of Bhutan for the imminent change to democracy. These elections were held in all 47 National Assembly constituencies and at 869 polling stations with around 1,000 voters at each one of them. ^[6] The parties "contesting" the election were the Druk Blue Party, the Druk Green Party, the Druk Red Party and the Druk Yellow Party (with Druk being Dzongkha for "thunder dragon"). Each "party" represented certain values as their "party manifesto": yellow for traditional values, red for industrial development, blue for fairness and accountability, and green for the environment. The two parties winning the most votes were to proceed to a run-off election scheduled for 28 May. ^[7]

Election observers were present from the United Nations and from India. ^[8]

The results of the first round saw the Druk Yellow Party receive a plurality of the vote. ^{[9] [10] [5]} The Druk Yellow and Druk Red parties proceeded to the second, or general, round. These two parties put up randomly chosen high school students as candidates in the 47 constituencies in the second round on 28 May 2007. The Druk Yellow Party swept the vote and won 46 of the 47 constituencies, with the Druk Red Party winning the Bartsham-Shongphu constituency. ^[11] Turnout in the second round was 66%. ^[12]

246,146 people had registered to vote, though it is considered likely that a total of 400,000 would have been eligible to register as voters. ^{[13] [5]}

Party		Primary round		General round		Seats
		Votes	%	Votes	%
	Druk Yellow Party	56,531	44.75	161,986	74.96	46
	Druk Red Party	25,542	20.22	54,117	25.04	1
	Druk Blue Party	25,508	20.19			0
	Druk Green Party	18,757	14.85			0
Total		126,338	100.00	216,103	100.00	47
Registered voters/turnout		246,146	–	246,146	–
Source: ECB

Schedule

The election procedure began with the submission of the letters of intent, lists of candidates, copies of election manifestos and audited financial statements by the two political parties contesting the elections to the election commission followed by the release of the party manifestos by them on 22 January 2008. ^[14]

From 31 January to 7 February 2008 both political parties submitted the nomination papers for their candidates for the 47 constituencies. The candidates, whose nominations were accepted, started campaigning in their constituencies from 7 February. The election campaign ended at 9:00 on 22 March. The last date for receiving the postal ballots was 18 February. The elections were held on 24 March from 09:00 to 17:00 followed by the counting of ballots on the same day. The results were declared on 25 March. ^[14]

All eligible voters were allowed to register with the election commission until 20 February 2008 for the inclusion of their names in the voters list which was updated to include those eligible voters who were eighteen years old on or before 1 January 2008. The final electoral roll was published on 5 March 2008. ^[14]

Campaign

There were few differences between the platforms of the two parties and both pledged to follow the king's guidelines of "pursuing Gross National Happiness". Both party leaders had also previously served in governments. ^[15]

Results

Voter turnout reached nearly 80% by the time the polls closed, and the Bhutan Peace and Prosperity Party reportedly won 44 seats, with the People's Democratic Party winning only three seats (Phuentsholing in Chhukha, Goenkhatoe-Laya in Gasa and Sombeykha in Haa). The PDP's leader, Sangay Ngedup, who was also the ruling king's uncle, lost his own constituency by 380 votes. However, due to a mistake in tallying the votes in Phuntsholing, ^[16] the DPT had actually won 45 seats and the PDP only 2. ^[17]

The DPT's large-scale victory may have been due to it being perceived as the more royalist of the two parties. ^[18]

Party		Votes	%	Seats
	Druk Phuensum Tshogpa	169,490	67.04	45
	People's Democratic Party	83,322	32.96	2
Total		252,812	100.00	47
Registered voters/turnout		318,465	–
Source: EU Observation Mission

Aftermath

The two PDP members who were elected refused to take up their seats and resigned their mandates, claiming that the civil servants informally campaigned for the DPT and influenced the result. ^{[19] [20]}

The DPT officially approved its leader as candidate for Prime Minister on 5 April 2008. ^[21] He took office on 9 April. ^[22]

Although analysts were worried that the small representation of the opposition might obstruct the functioning of the newly founded democratic system, the next elections in 2013 were won by the PDP.

References

1. Bhaumik, Subir (17 January 2008). "Main Bhutan election date is set". BBC News. Archived from the original on 27 December 2008. Retrieved 20 November 2008.
2. "Druk Phuensum Tshogpa, the new party in town". Bhutan Portal. 25 July 2007. Archived from the original on 21 May 2008. Retrieved 20 November 2008.
3. "Bhutan gets third political party". The Hindu. 6 May 2007. Archived from the original on 11 January 2008. Retrieved 20 November 2008.
4. "Caretaker prime minister appointed in Bhutan". Hindustan Times. Indo-Asian News Service. 3 August 2007. Archived from the original on 30 September 2007. Retrieved 20 November 2008.
5. Electoral Commission of Bhutan (2015). "Statistical Information on Elections in Bhutan 2006-2015" (PDF).
6. Bhutan set for mock elections on April 21 Archived 30 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine Hindustan Times, 20 April 2007
7. Bhutan holds fake national poll BBC News, 21 April 2007
8. Bhutan's election dummy run The Australian, 21 April 2007
9. Bhutan votes for tradition and monarchy in mock poll The Star, 22 April 2007, archived from the Original.
10. Ahme, Abu Nasar Saied (2018). "Bhutan's experiments with Democracy" (PDF). KKHSOU.
11. "RAOnline Bhutan: Politics - Elections 2008 - Mock general election in May 2007". www.raonline.ch. Retrieved 21 November 2023.
12. Bhutan mock poll votes for tradition The Star, 30 May 2007
13. Encouraging turnout in Bhutan's historic mock polls India eNews, 28 May 2007
14. "March is on to Assembly Elections". Kuensel Newspaper. 19 January 2008. Archived from the original on 10 June 2011. Retrieved 11 December 2008.
15. Sengupta, Somni (5 March 2008). "Heavy Turnout in First Bhutan Election". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 1 March 2013. Retrieved 20 November 2008.
16. "Results of the Phuentsholing Constituency of National Assembly Election 2008 under Chukha Dzongkhag" (PDF). PDF. 27 March 2008. Archived from the original (PDF) on 28 October 2008. Retrieved 21 November 2008.
17. Majumdar, Bappa (27 March 2008). "CORRECTED: Bhutan corrects poll results, opposition shrinks". Reuters. Retrieved 21 November 2008.
18. Erdrutschsieg der Royalisten in Bhutan (International, NZZ Online) (German)
19. Denyer, Simon (28 March 2008). "Bhutan loses opposition as MPs cry foul over poll". Reuters India. Retrieved 11 December 2008.
20. "PDP asks ECB to investigate "very strange developments" before elections". Kuensel Newspaper. 29 March 2008. Archived from the original on 10 June 2011. Retrieved 11 December 2008.
21. "DPT endorses Jigmi Y Thinley as Prime Minister". Kuensel Newspaper. 5 April 2008. Archived from the original on 10 June 2011. Retrieved 11 December 2008.
22. "Thinley takes over as Premier", The Hindu, 11 April 2008.