Book Review Digest

Last updated

Title page of the digest's first volume, 1905 The Cumulative Book Review Digest, Volume 1, 1905.djvu
Title page of the digest's first volume, 1905

Book Review Digest is a reference work by H. W. Wilson Company that compiles recent book reviews. Printed monthly with annual compendia, it digests American and English periodicals from 1905 to the present day. Before the Internet, Book Review Digest was a significant reference tool and bibliographic aid used by the American public and librarians alike to find current literature. An online edition of the collection is offered in two subscription products: Book Review Digest Retrospective (1905–1982) and Book Review Digest Plus (1983 through present day).

Contents

Description and usage

During the 20th century, Book Review Digest was a common American library bibliographic aid for the public to find current literature. [1] The reference work compiles book reviews from major periodicals of the period beneath each book's bibliographic entry. [2] Beginning in 1905, the H. W. Wilson Company issued Book Review Digest monthly, with cumulative compilations. [1] By the 1950s, Book Review Digest covered 4,000 books annually. [2]

Each book's bibliographic entry is introduced with a noncritical description, [2] annotating discrete features with no assessment of quality. [3] Beneath each is a digest of reviewer commentary in brief excerpt. Plus and minus symbols indicate the review's favorability, if apparent, letting readers quickly summarize critical consensus towards the book. [2] (Generally, listed reviews tend towards praise. [4] ) Each volume additionally lists the review source publications, which are both American and English. For a sense of expansion over time, the 1905 volume had 386 pages while the 1948 volume had 1,067. [5]

While also used to aid libraries in their acquisition selection, as a compilation of book reviews often published and compiled after the book's release, Book Review Digest was not as useful to acquisition librarians as the American Library Association's Booklist new book guide, which is based on short descriptions rather than compiled, printed reviews. [1] Book Review Digest nevertheless was a mainstay for new book selection. [6] Some libraries clip and paste each book's digested review summary within the reviewed book itself or in the library's card catalog. [2]

Like other Wilson bibliographies, Book Review Digest was printed as a cumulative catalog. Issued as a monthly, Book Review Digest collected book reviews for each catalog entry, printing each month's new reviews alongside the reviews compiled in prior issues. When the issue became too expensive to print, twice a year, Wilson issued a cumulative list: a six-month cumulation in August, and a bounded, full-year annual in February. Wilson released a cumulative index, compiled continuously, every five years. [7]

The cumulative format is based on the technical linotype print production technique. Each catalog entry is typeset as a linotype slug, i.e., a small metal bar, and can be kept in alphabetical order, simply adding reviews beneath each slug between monthly issues. This let the monthly issue remain current and uniform while building towards the annual cumulative volume. [7]

Its subject–title index additionally classifies books by type or special interest. Fiction, for example, is divided into "Cheerful Stories", "Ghost Stories", "Historical Novels", "Mystery Novels", and "Novels of Locality" (with subdivisions), as well as groupings by theme, such as school or sex. [8]

The 1905–1974 author/title index, published in 1976 across four volumes, alphabetically compiled bibliographic references for Book Review Digest's roughly 300,000 reviewed books in its first 75 years. It contains cross references for variant forms of each title and author. [9]

Digital

Wilson publishes its digest online as two products: Book Review Digest Retrospective and Book Review Digest Plus, respectively covering 1905–1982 and 1983 through the present day. At the time of their launch in the mid-2000s, [10] [11] Retrospective compiled 1.5 million reviews from over 500 English-language publications on 300,000 books published between 1905 and 1982. The equivalent of Book Review Digest's first 78 annual cumulative volumes, Retrospective replaced 14 linear feet of reference material. [10] At its launch, Plus compiled over a million reviews from thousands of periodicals on 700,000 books published from 1983 through the present day. Updated daily, it also pulled reviews from other Wilson periodical databases, including Readers' Guide Full Text. [11] Retrospective does not contain full text reviews, only excerpts up to 500 words. [12] Plus extended coverage beyond general fiction and nonfiction reviews to include full-text reviews of reference works, children's books, and textbooks. [13] [14]

Wilson first released Plus online in 2003, [11] followed by Retrospective two years later. [12] Both were initially offered through Wilson's redesigned WilsonWeb online interface. [11] Users had three modes of search: Basic, Advanced, and Browse. While Basic search let users use natural language and Boolean operators in a simple search box to search the database, the default mode was Advanced search, which let users select search fields by parameters like book title, book author, publication year, publisher, subject, [12] and ISBN. Users could also filter by date and by type of text result (excerpt, full text, peer reviewed, or PDF), when available. [10] The Browse mode let users navigate the database like an index. For retrieval, users could save, print, or email individual entries, which also saved in a search history. [12] WilsonWeb features also included connection to the individual library's online public access catalogs, [11] OpenURL interlibrary loan, multi-window pane navigation, citation formatting and citation manager export. [12] While Book Review Digest had been available in some form on EBSCOhost, OCLC, and SilverPlatter platforms as early as July 2003, Plus was exclusive to WilsonWeb. [15] EBSCO Publishing deprecated WilsonWeb upon acquiring the H. W. Wilson Company in 2011, with all Wilson databases being converted to the EBSCOhost platform. [16]

Among initial reviews of Retrospective and Plus in WilsonWeb, Harvard College Library's Head of Instructional Services described the online catalog as "an essential acquisition for every public, academic, and research library" in 2006. [10] Other called the catalogs powerful [12] and exciting. [17] Lack of a Retrospective search field for review source was an absence palpable among reviewers, [17] [10] who struggled to separate reviews by Choice , Booklist , and History from other uses of those keywords in a general search. The workaround of using ISSN search to identify the review source was not obvious. [17] A 2003 Online magazine comparison between Plus and Amazon.com found that the latter was mostly sufficient for bestsellers, between Amazon's use of published reviews as well as their own. Amazon's customer reviewers were only worthwhile in the case of some specialized and technical books. Book Review Digest, on the other hand, only sourced professional opinions. While Amazon was quicker to post new excerpts and reviews since the late 1990s, Plus had 20 years of history. Plus also had a more robust search function and integration with library catalogs, but was only accessible through subscribing libraries whereas Amazon was accessible everywhere. While Plus was more complete, Amazon's accessibility and quickness provided for general audience needs. [15]

Related Research Articles

MEDLINE is a bibliographic database of life sciences and biomedical information. It includes bibliographic information for articles from academic journals covering medicine, nursing, pharmacy, dentistry, veterinary medicine, and health care. MEDLINE also covers much of the literature in biology and biochemistry, as well as fields such as molecular evolution.

William Thomas Lowndes, English bibliographer, was born about 1798, the son of a London bookseller.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">EBSCO Information Services</span> Distributor of eBooks and other digital media

EBSCO Information Services, headquartered in Ipswich, Massachusetts, is a division of EBSCO Industries Inc., a private company headquartered in Birmingham, Alabama. EBSCO provides products and services to libraries of very many types around the world. Its products include EBSCONET, a complete e-resource management system, and EBSCOhost, which supplies a fee-based online research service with 375 full-text databases, a collection of 600,000-plus ebooks, subject indexes, point-of-care medical references, and an array of historical digital archives. In 2010, EBSCO introduced its EBSCO Discovery Service (EDS) to institutions, which allows searches of a portfolio of journals and magazines.

Current Biography is an American monthly magazine published by the H. W. Wilson Company of New York City, a publisher of reference books, that appears every month except December. Current Biography contains profiles of people in the news and includes politicians, athletes, businessmen, and entertainers. Published since 1940, the articles are annually collected into bound volumes called Current Biography Yearbook. A December issue of the magazine is not published because the staff works on the final cumulative volume for the year. Articles in the bound volumes correct any mistakes that may have appeared in the magazine and may include additional relevant information about the subject that became available since publication of the original article. The work is a standard reference source in American libraries and the publisher keeps in print the older volumes. Wilson also issues cumulative indexes to the set, and an online version is available as a subscription database.

Wild Flowers Worth Knowing is a book published in 1917 as a result of an adaptation by Asa Don Dickinson of Neltje Blanchan's earlier work Nature's Garden (1900).

ABC-Clio, LLC is an American publishing company for academic reference works and periodicals primarily on topics such as history and social sciences for educational and public library settings. ABC-Clio provides service to fifteen different online databases which contain over one million online textbooks. The company consults academic leaders in the fields they cover in order to provide authority for their reference titles. The headquarters are located in Santa Barbara, California.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Halsey William Wilson</span>

Halsey William Wilson was the creator of the Readers' Guide, the Cumulative Book Index, and the Book Review Digest and founder of the H. W. Wilson Company, a publisher. In 1999, American Libraries named him one of the "100 Most Important Leaders We Had in the 20th Century".

Book Review Index is an index of book reviews and literary criticism, found in leading academic, popular, and professional periodicals. It has been published since 1965. For most of its history it has been owned by Gale and is based in Detroit.

American Literature is a literary journal published by Duke University Press. It is sponsored by the American Literature Section of the Modern Language Association. The current editors are Priscilla Wald and Matthew A. Taylor. The first volume of this journal was published in March 1929.

The Encyclopedia of Recorded Sound is a reference work that, among other things, describes the history of sound recordings, from November 1877 when Edison developed the first model of a cylinder phonograph, and earlier, in 1857, when Léon Scott de Martinville invented the phonautograph. The first edition – Guy Anthony Marco, Phd (editor), and Frank Andrews (1920–2015) – was published in 1993. The second 2-volume edition, published in 2005, spans one hundred forty-seven years of recorded sound. Frank W. Hoffman, PhD, of Sam Houston State University is Editor and Howard William Ferstler of Florida State University is Technical Editor.

A Legal Bibliography of the British Commonwealth of Nations, formerly Sweet & Maxwell's Legal Bibliography, is a bibliography of law published in London by Sweet & Maxwell.

<i>Tomorrowland</i> (book) 2015 book by Steven Kotler

Tomorrowland: Our Journey from Science Fiction to Science Fact is a 2015 nonfiction book by science journalist Steven Kotler and published by Amazon Publishing.

<i>Kronstadt, 1921</i>

Kronstadt, 1921, is a history book by Paul Avrich about the 1921 Kronstadt rebellion against the Bolsheviks.

<i>The Haymarket Tragedy</i>

The Haymarket Tragedy is a 1984 history book by Paul Avrich about the Haymarket affair and the resulting trial.

Our Children Are Dying is a book-length extended portrait of Elliott Shapiro, the experimental principal of P.S. 119 in Harlem, New York, written by Nat Hentoff and published by Viking Press in 1966.

<i>Footsteps</i> (autobiography)

Footsteps: Adventures of a Romantic Biographer is an autobiographical book by the biographer Richard Holmes, published in 1985. Harper Perennial first published reprints of Footsteps in 2005.

<i>Literary Research Guide</i> Reference work

Literary Research Guide is a reference work that annotates and evaluates important research materials related to English literature and English literary studies. The first edition appeared in 1989 and the fifth edition was published in 2008. These editions were printed books and the work was digitalized into an electronic version c. 2008.

Punished by Rewards: The Trouble with Gold Stars, Incentive Plans, A's, Praise, and Other Bribes is a 1993 book by Alfie Kohn that argues against the use of rewards to incentivize behavior.

Born to Buy: The Commercialized Child and the New Consumer Culture is a 2004 book by Juliet Schor on consumerist targeting of children.

Trashing the Planet: How Science Can Help Us Deal With Acid Rain, Depletion of the Ozone, and Nuclear Waste is a 1990 book by zoologist and Governor of Washington Dixy Lee Ray. The book talks about the seriousness about acid rain, the problems with the ozone layer and other environmental issues. Ray co-wrote the book with journalist Lou Guzzo.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Haines 1957, p. 70.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Haines 1957, p. 71.
  3. ↑ Haines 1957, p. 73.
  4. ↑ Haines 1957, p. 101.
  5. ↑ Haines 1957, p. 72.
  6. ↑ Haines 1957, p. 382.
  7. 1 2 Haines 1957, pp. 70–71.
  8. ↑ Haines 1957, pp. 71–72.
  9. ↑ Olevnik, Peter P. (September 1, 1976). "Rev. of Book Review Digest: author/title index, 1905–1974, 4 vols". Library Journal . 101 (15): 1758–1759. ISSN   0363-0277. EBSCOhost   5939337.
  10. 1 2 3 4 5 LaGuardia, Cheryl (January 2006). "A Bibliophile's Heaven: Book Review Digest Retrospective: 1905-1982". Library Journal . 131 (1): 36. ISSN   0363-0277. EBSCOhost   19426602. ProQuest   196831122.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 "H.W. Wilson Introduces Book Review Digest Plus". Information Today . 20 (1): 3. January 2003. ISSN   8755-6286. EBSCOhost   8877540.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Quinn, Mary Ellen (November 1, 2005). "Book Review Digest Retrospective: 1905–1982". Booklist . 102 (5): 69. ISSN   0006-7385. EBSCOhost   18857430.
  13. ↑ Shigo, Kimberly (February 2003). "H.W. Wilson Expands Book Review Digest". Computers in Libraries. 23 (2): 47. ISSN   1041-7915. EBSCOhost   8986969.
  14. ↑ Rogers, Michael (2003). "WilsonWeb Adds Expanded BRD". Library Journal . 128 (1): 29. ISSN   0363-0277. EBSCOhost   8936380.
  15. 1 2 O'Leary, Mick (July 2003). "Book Review Digest Plus Battles Amazon for Title". Online . 27 (4): 49–51. ISSN   0146-5422. EBSCOhost   10099212.
  16. ↑ Kelley, Michael (June 15, 2011). "In Major Deal, EBSCO Acquires H.W. Wilson". Library Journal . 136 (11): 15. ISSN   0363-0277. EBSCOhost   61428285.
  17. 1 2 3 Jacso, Peter (February 2006). "AnaVist, Book Review Digest Retrospective, and Past Pans". Online. 30 (1): 58–60. ISSN   0146-5422. EBSCOhost   19292440.

Works cited

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.