Compensating differential

Last updated

Wage differential is a term used in labour economics to analyze the relation between the wage rate and the unpleasantness, risk, or other undesirable attributes of a particular job. A compensating differential, which is also called a compensating wage differential or an equalizing difference, is defined as the additional amount of income that a given worker must be offered in order to motivate them to accept a given undesirable job, relative to other jobs that worker could perform. [1] [2] One can also speak of the compensating differential for an especially desirable job, or one that provides special benefits, but in this case the differential would be negative: that is, a given worker would be willing to accept a lower wage for an especially desirable job, relative to other jobs. [3]

Contents

The idea of compensating differentials has been used to analyze issues such as the risk of future unemployment, [4] the risk of injury, [5] the risk of unsafe intercourse, [6] the monetary value workers place on their own lives, [7] and in explaining geographical wage differentials. [8] [9] [10] [11]

Geographical Wage Differentials

There is a wide literature dealing with geographical wage differentials. Following the neoclassical assumption of clearing labour markets, where there is a more attractive area to live in and if labour mobility is perfect, then more and more workers will move to this area which in turn will increase the supply of labour in this area and in turn depress wages. If the attractiveness of that area compared to other areas do not change, the wage rate will be set at such a rate that workers would be indifferent between living in areas that are more attractive but with a lower wage and living in areas which are less attractive and with a higher wage. Henceforth, a sustained equilibrium with different wage rates across different areas can happen. [2] [12]

The theory

The theory of compensating wage differentials, by Adam Smith, provides a theoretical framework of the ideology behind pay differences. The theory explains that jobs with undesirable characteristics will compensate with higher wages compared to the popular, more desirable jobs, who provide lower wages to its workers. [13] Competition in labour markets ensures that the net advantages of different jobs will tend to equality. Thus, higher pay in some areas of the country is expected where the cost-of-living is higher while higher pay is also necessary to compensate for a less pleasant working environment. The rate of pay in the private sector represents (according to the hypothesis) the exact rate necessary to attract and retain staff. Thus all else equal a higher rate of pay in one area means that this area is less attractive (either has low amenity levels or higher cost-of-living). The pay offered in this area is set to counter the relative unattractiveness of the region. Some empirical studies have tried to test this assumption. Most of this research is interested in inter geographical wage disparities. The research ask the question: how can geographical wage differentials be explained?

Employment Benefits

Employees who receive employment benefits, like health insurance, are trading in higher wages for better benefits because the benefits are valuable to the employee and offered at a lower rate through their employer, compared to outside vendors. On the contrary, if an employer offers a health insurance plan with low coverage that is not attractive to employees, the wages at the firm will likely not be reduced due to the low participation in the health insurance plan. In this scenario, employees would prefer to receive higher wages and lower quality benefits. Transitioning the firm's expenses from wages to health insurance coverage allows the employees to receive quality health insurance by forgoing the option to get paid higher wages. Similar to the ideology of compensating wage differential where employees receive higher wages at undesirable/risky jobs and lower wages at safe/desirable jobs, receiving several employee benefits results in lower monetary compensation. [14]

Hedonic Wage Function

The hedonic wage function represents the assumption that employees maximize their utility in job selection to a budget constraint outlined by the labor market. The hedonic wage function graphically displays the compensating wage differential between a firm and its employees. The function's slope represents the best fit line going through the indifference curves, representing wages and the probability of injury while at work. [15] The function is upward sloping due to the parallel relationship between wages and the undesirable qualities of a job; the more undesirable the job is, the higher the wages employees are compensated for working at the company. The mean and variance of the function vary based on the data, whether the data is firm-level or employee-level data. The equilibrium of the hedonic wage function between employee wages and non-wage-related attributes for a particular job argues there is a minimal correlation to workers' preferences. [16]

Empirical results

Most of the empirical results from the literature attempt to decompose the geographical wage differentials according to human capital characteristics. Areas with more skilled workers will tend to have higher mean wages. Though, average wages may differ among different areas because they offer different levels of amenities. It is usually believed in economics that wages in areas where the level of amenity is high comparatively to other areas will be lower. Empirical research has attempted to measure area characteristics in order to measure this effect on average wages. Though, some characteristics may be attractive for some workers but because workers may have different utilities, other workers may not be attracted by these characteristics. The following assumption is usually made: workers among a similar occupation will share similar utility function, then it is possible to measure the characteristics of areas on the mean wage of a particular occupation. [ citation needed ]

Human capital

Some articles have brought evidence that wages differ across areas in different countries using a decomposition analysis of the mean wage. [17] In 1992, Reilly [18] used this decomposition technique [17] to decompose wage differentials between 6 local labour markets in the UK. The decomposition allows to decompose mean wage differences into two parts, one which is the consequence of individual characteristics in those 6 labour markets [note 1] and the other one which is due to unexplained differences. The author finds that the differences in wages between labour markets is at around 20%, and that between Aberdeen and Rochdale, 50% of this difference is explained by workers' characteristics, the other part is not explained. The unexplained differences can be thought of being consequences of differences in local areas attractiveness. Though this author does not give any evidence that this is the case. Similar results are obtained by García and Molina [10] for Spain [note 2] with data from 1994 [note 3] Pereira and Galego [19] analysed wage differentials in Portugal using dynamics. They also found similar results to García and Molina [10] and to Reilly. [18] [note 4]

Area characteristics

Part of the attractiveness of areas is the cost-of-living. An area with a lower cost-of-living should be more attractive than areas with an expensive cost-of-living. Unfortunately, it is difficult to measure within countries cost-of-living. In an article published in 1983, Shah and Walker [11] estimated a wage equation for male white workers in the UK using the general household survey of 1973 [note 5] The cost-of-living proxy is taken from Reward Regional Surveys Ltd [20] which publish reports on cost-of-living and regional comparisons from 1974 up to at least 1996 [21] The description of the construction of those cost-of-living is not clear. [21] [note 6] Wage differentials change and sometimes are reversed when they introduce the cost-of-living, Scotland and the South East of England are worse off when introducing cost-of-living compared to the Midlands regions. This result can be though of some evidence of the fact that differences in monetary reward are not the same as the differences in real-term awards. This suggests that the differences in wages between regions compensate at least partly for differences in cost-of-living. In 1991, Blackaby and Murphy [9] estimated standardised geographical wage differentials [note 7] and then explained these geographical wage differentials with a set of weather, [note 8] environmental [note 9] and prices indexes. [note 10] The authors include other variables based on two other theories: efficiency wage and search theory. The results provide some evidence that workers are not suffering from money illusion as areas with prices higher by 10% than another area also have wages 10% higher. In consequence, wage do compensate for local differences in prices. In England, wages are usually thought of being better in the South than in the North of the country. Though Blackaby and Murphy [8] show that wages when controlled for individual characteristics, occupations characteristics, cost-of-living and industry mix are better in the North than in the South [note 11] for manual workers. Thus they conclude that it makes sense for unemployed in the North to wait and look for a job in the North as that is where they will get relatively better pay. This give some extra evidence that wage differentials compensate, at least partly, for geographical differences in cost-of-living.

Discussion

Possible confusion with other concepts

The terms compensation differential, pay differential, and wage differential (see wage dispersion or economic inequality) are also used in economics, but normally have a different meaning. They simply refer to differences in total pay (or the wage rate) in any context. [22] So a 'compensation differential' can be explained by many factors, such as differences in the skills of the workers in those jobs, the country or geographical area in which those jobs are performed, or the characteristics of the jobs themselves. A 'compensating differential', in contrast, refers exclusively to differences in pay due to differences in the jobs themselves, for a given worker (or for two identical workers).

In the theory of price indices, economists also use the term compensating variation , which is yet another unrelated concept. A 'compensating variation' is the change in wealth required to leave a consumer's well-being unchanged when prices change.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Labour economics</span> Study of the markets for wage labour

Labour economics, or labor economics, seeks to understand the functioning and dynamics of the markets for wage labour. Labour is a commodity that is supplied by labourers, usually in exchange for a wage paid by demanding firms. Because these labourers exist as parts of a social, institutional, or political system, labour economics must also account for social, cultural and political variables.

A minimum wage is the lowest remuneration that employers can legally pay their employees—the price floor below which employees may not sell their labor. Most countries had introduced minimum wage legislation by the end of the 20th century. Because minimum wages increase the cost of labor, companies often try to avoid minimum wage laws by using gig workers, by moving labor to locations with lower or nonexistent minimum wages, or by automating job functions. Minimum wage policies can vary significantly between countries or even within a country, with different regions, sectors, or age groups having their own minimum wage rates. These variations are often influenced by factors such as the cost of living, regional economic conditions, and industry-specific factors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wage</span> Distribution of a security paid by an employer to an employee

A wage is payment made by an employer to an employee for work done in a specific period of time. Some examples of wage payments include compensatory payments such as minimum wage, prevailing wage, and yearly bonuses, and remunerative payments such as prizes and tip payouts. Wages are part of the expenses that are involved in running a business. It is an obligation to the employee regardless of the profitability of the company.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Living wage</span> Minimum income to meet a workers basic needs

A living wage is defined as the minimum income necessary for a worker to meet their basic needs. This is not the same as a subsistence wage, which refers to a biological minimum, or a solidarity wage, which refers to a minimum wage tracking labor productivity. Needs are defined to include food, housing, and other essential needs such as clothing. The goal of a living wage is to allow a worker to afford a basic but decent standard of living through employment without government subsidies. Due to the flexible nature of the term "needs", there is not one universally accepted measure of what a living wage is and as such it varies by location and household type. A related concept is that of a family wage – one sufficient to not only support oneself, but also to raise a family.


The term efficiency wages was introduced by Alfred Marshall to denote the wage per efficiency unit of labor. Marshallian efficiency wages are those calculated with efficiency or ability exerted being the unit of measure rather than time. That is, the more efficient worker will be paid more than a less efficient worker for the same amount of hours worked.

Labour power is the capacity to do work, a key concept used by Karl Marx in his critique of capitalist political economy. Marx distinguished between the capacity to do work, i.e. labour power, and the physical act of working, i.e. labour. Labour power exists in any kind of society, but on what terms it is traded or combined with means of production to produce goods and services has historically varied greatly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reservation wage</span> Lowest wage rate at which a worker would be willing to accept a particular type of job

In labor economics, the reservation wage is the lowest wage rate at which a worker would be willing to accept a particular type of job. This wage is a theoretical representation of the hourly rate at which an individual values their own leisure time. A job offer involving the same type of work and the same working conditions, but at a lower wage rate, would be rejected by the worker. In this case, based on the reservation wage theory, the individual would be better off not working as they value their leisure at a higher rate than the wage they would receive for working.

Personnel economics has been defined as "the application of economic and mathematical approaches and econometric and statistical methods to traditional questions in human resources management". It is an area of applied micro labor economics, but there are a few key distinctions. One distinction, not always clearcut, is that studies in personnel economics deal with the personnel management within firms, and thus internal labor markets, while those in labor economics deal with labor markets as such, whether external or internal. In addition, personnel economics deals with issues related to both managerial-supervisory and non-supervisory workers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Backward bending supply curve of labour</span>

In economics, a backward-bending supply curve of labour, or backward-bending labour supply curve, is a graphical device showing a situation in which as real (inflation-corrected) wages increase beyond a certain level, people will substitute time previously devoted for paid work for leisure and so higher wages lead to a decrease in the labour supply and so less labour-time being offered for sale.

Employment discrimination is a form of illegal discrimination in the workplace based on legally protected characteristics. In the U.S., federal anti-discrimination law prohibits discrimination by employers against employees based on age, race, gender, sex, religion, national origin, and physical or mental disability. State and local laws often protect additional characteristics such as marital status, veteran status and caregiver/familial status. Earnings differentials or occupational differentiation—where differences in pay come from differences in qualifications or responsibilities—should not be confused with employment discrimination. Discrimination can be intended and involve disparate treatment of a group or be unintended, yet create disparate impact for a group.

A two-tier system is a type of payroll system in which one group of workers receives lower wages and/or employee benefits than another.

The degree of labour market flexibility is the speed with which labour markets adapt to fluctuations and changes in society, the economy or production. This entails enabling labour markets to reach a continuous equilibrium determined by the intersection of the demand and supply curves.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Labor relations</span> Study of work and workers

Labor relations or labor studies is a field of study that can have different meanings depending on the context in which it is used. In an international context, it is a subfield of labor history that studies the human relations with regard to work in its broadest sense and how this connects to questions of social inequality. It explicitly encompasses unregulated, historical, and non-Western forms of labor. Here, labor relations define "for or with whom one works and under what rules. These rules determine the type of work, type and amount of remuneration, working hours, degrees of physical and psychological strain, as well as the degree of freedom and autonomy associated with the work." More specifically in a North American and strictly modern context, labor relations is the study and practice of managing unionized employment situations. In academia, labor relations is frequently a sub-area within industrial relations, though scholars from many disciplines including economics, sociology, history, law, and political science also study labor unions and labor movements. In practice, labor relations is frequently a subarea within human resource management. Courses in labor relations typically cover labor history, labor law, union organizing, bargaining, contract administration, and important contemporary topics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Minimum wage in the United States</span>

In the United States, the minimum wage is set by U.S. labor law and a range of state and local laws. The first federal minimum wage was instituted in the National Industrial Recovery Act of 1933, signed into law by President Franklin D. Roosevelt, but later found to be unconstitutional. In 1938, the Fair Labor Standards Act established it at $0.25 an hour. Its purchasing power peaked in 1968, at $1.60 In 2009, it was increased to $7.25 per hour, and has not been increased since.

In microeconomics, search theory studies buyers or sellers who cannot instantly find a trading partner, and must therefore search for a partner prior to transacting. It involves determining the best approach to use when looking for a specific item or person in a sizable, uncharted environment. The goal of the theory is to determine the best search strategy, one that maximises the chance of finding the target while minimising search-related expenses.

Labor market segmentation is the division of the labor market according to a principle such as occupation, geography and industry.

The union wage premium refers to the degree to which wages for union members exceed those for otherwise similar non-unionized workers. Union wage premiums are one of the most researched and analyzed issues in labor economics. The modern scholarly consensus is that unions tend to be associated with higher wages, greater levels of benefits like health care and paid time off, and improved workplace protections.

In economics, a monopsony is a market structure in which a single buyer substantially controls the market as the major purchaser of goods and services offered by many would-be sellers. The microeconomic theory of monopsony assumes a single entity to have market power over all sellers as the only purchaser of a good or service. This is a similar power to that of a monopolist, which can influence the price for its buyers in a monopoly, where multiple buyers have only one seller of a good or service available to purchase from.

Wage compression refers to the empirical regularity that wages for low-skilled workers and wages for high-skilled workers tend toward one another. As a result, the prevailing wage for a low-skilled worker exceeds the market-clearing wage, resulting in unemployment for low-skilled workers. Meanwhile, the prevailing wage for high-skilled workers is below the market-clearing wage, creating a short supply of high-skilled workers.

Francis Kramarz is a French economist who works as Professor at the École Nationale de la Statistique et de l'Administration Économique (ENSAE), where he has been directing the Center for Research in Economics and Statistics (CREST). He is one of the leading labour economists in France.

References

  1. ↑ Kaufman, Bruce E.; Hotchkiss, Julie L. (2005). "Education, Training, and Earnings Differentials: The Theory of Human Capital". The economics of labor markets (5th ed.). Harcourt College Publishers. ISBN   978-0-324-28879-7.
  2. 1 2 Rosen, Sherwin (1986). "The theory of equalizing differences". In Ashenfelter, Orley; Layard, Richard (eds.). The Handbook of Labor Economics. Vol. 1. New York: Elsevier. pp. 641–692. ISBN   978-0-444-87856-4.
  3. ↑ Miller, Richard D. Jr. (2004). "Estimating the compensating differential for employer-provided health insurance". International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics. 4 (1): 27–41. doi:10.1023/B:IHFE.0000019259.74756.65. PMID   15170963. S2CID   19313510.
  4. ↑ Averett, Susan; Bodenhorn, Howard; Staisiunas, Justas (2003). "Unemployment risk and compensating differential in late-nineteenth century New Jersey manufacturing". National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 9977. Cambridge, Massachusetts.
  5. ↑ Biddle, Jeff E.; Zarkin, Gary A. (1988). "Worker preference and market compensation for job risk". Review of Economics and Statistics. 70 (4): 660–667. doi:10.2307/1935830. JSTOR   1935830.
  6. ↑ Rao, Vijayendra; Gupta, Indrani; Lokshin, Michael; Jana, Smarajit (2003). "Sex workers and the cost of safe sex: the compensating differential for condom use among Calcutta prostitutes". Journal of Development Economics. 71 (2): 585–603. CiteSeerX   10.1.1.197.8491 . doi:10.1016/S0304-3878(03)00025-7. S2CID   153608532.
  7. ↑ Thaler, Richard; Rosen, Sherwin (1975). "The value of saving a life: evidence from the labor market" . In Terleckyj, Nestor E. (ed.). Household production and consumption . New York: National Bureau of Economic Research. ISBN   978-0-87014-515-5.
  8. 1 2 Blackaby, D. H.; P. D. Murphy (1995). "Earnings, Unemployment and Britain's North-South Divide: Real or Imaginary?". Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics. 57 (4): 487–512. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0084.1995.tb00036.x.
  9. 1 2 Blackaby, D. H.; P. D. Murphy (1991). "Industry Characteristics and Inter-Regional Wage Differences". Scottish Journal of Political Economy. 38 (2): 142–161. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9485.1991.tb00307.x.
  10. 1 2 3 García, Inmaculada; José Alberto Molina (March 2002). "Inter-regional wage differentials in Spain". Applied Economics Letters. 9 (4): 209–215. doi:10.1080/13504850110065849. ISSN   1350-4851. S2CID   154990389.
  11. 1 2 Shah, Anup; Walker, Martin (August 1983). "The distribution of regional earnings in the UK". Applied Economics. 15 (4): 507–520. doi:10.1080/00036848300000020. ISSN   0003-6846.
  12. ↑ Smith, Adam (1776). An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of the Nations. London: W. Strahan and T. Cadell.
  13. ↑ Smith, Robert (April 1979). "Compensating Wage Differentials and Public Policy: A Review". Industrial and Labor Review. 32 (3): 339–352. doi:10.1177/001979397903200304. S2CID   153347601 – via JSTOR.
  14. ↑ Morrisey, Michael (September–December 2001). "Why Do Employers Do What They Do? Compensating Differentials". International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics. 1. No 3/4 (3–4): 195–201. doi:10.1023/A:1013776317034. PMID   14625925. S2CID   27712813 – via JSTOR.
  15. ↑ Borjas, George (2016). Labor Economics. McGraw Hill Education. pp. 196–228. ISBN   978-0-07-802188-6.
  16. ↑ Hwang, Mortensen, and Reed (October 1998). "Hedonic Wages and Labor Market Search". Journal of Labor Economics. 16 (4): 815–847. doi:10.1086/209907. S2CID   153533456 – via JSTOR.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  17. 1 2 Oaxaca, Ronald (October 1973). "Male-Female Wage Differentials in Urban Labor Markets". International Economic Review. 14 (3): 693–709. doi:10.2307/2525981. JSTOR   2525981.
  18. 1 2 Reilly, Barry (1992). "An Analysis of Local Labour Market Wage Differentials". Regional Studies. 26 (3): 257–264. doi:10.1080/00343409212331346951. ISSN   0034-3404.
  19. ↑ Pereira, João; Aurora Galego (2011). "Regional wage differentials in Portugal: Static and dynamic approaches". Papers in Regional Science. 90 (3): 529–548. doi:10.1111/j.1435-5957.2010.00328.x. hdl: 10174/2738 . ISSN   1435-5957.
  20. ↑ Reward Regional Surveys Ltd (1981). Regional Surveys, Cost of Living Report, Regional Comparisons.
  21. 1 2 Johnston, Richard; Martin McKinney; Tom Stark (1996). "Regional Price Level Variations and Real Household Incomes in the United Kingdom, 1979/80–1993". Regional Studies. 30 (6): 567–578. doi:10.1080/00343409612331349868. ISSN   0034-3404.
  22. ↑ Bender, Keith A. (1998). "The central government-private sector wage differential". Journal of Economic Surveys. 12 (2): 177–220. doi:10.1111/1467-6419.00052.

Notes

  1. ↑ Aberdeen, Coventry, Kircaldy, Northampton, Rochdale and Swindon are the six local labour markets used.
  2. ↑ They divided Spain into 5 main regions (North, South, East, Centre and Madrid) and used the Oaxaca technique
  3. ↑ They use a cross sectional data for 1994 (European Community Household panel) combined with regional price and population data from the National Statistics Institute (INE). They have 4450 individual observations that were divided into 5 main regions (North, South, East, Centre and Madrid). They introduce controls into their wage equations for occupation, education, industry, gender, age, tenure and whether they have a second language.
  4. ↑ They use data from the Quadros de Pessoal for 1995 and 2002. This data is compulsory for all employers with at least one employee. It is completed and sent to the ministry of employment of Portugal. It does not concern employees of public administration, the armed forces and self employed professionals. They considered only workers between 16 and 65 and excluded fisheries, agriculture and unpaid family workers and apprentices. They also excluded workers in Madeira and the Açores.
  5. ↑ . They adjust their regressions on individual characteristics, industry mix and cost-of-living. They introduced regional dummies for 15 regions:Greater London, South East, West Midlands, North West, Scotland (West Coast, East Coast, North and South), Wales (South East and not South East), South West, East Midlands, East Anglia, York/Humberside, North East.
  6. ↑ The descriptions in Shad and Walker (1983) and in Johnston et al. (1996) are not very clear. Though that is how it can be summarised: the Reward Group assumes that households with two adults and two children of age 10 and 13 are representatives of the "communities". From those households they gather 200 retail prices in 100 locations to which are added 18 regional prices for fuel and car insurances and 31 national prices covering newspapers, stamps, licences etc. The prices are weighted according to eight patterns of expenditure of the households.
  7. ↑ The authors estimated a wage equation with a complete set of industry, regional dummies and interactions between the two using the General Household Survey of 1982. They restricted their sample to individuals who had worked more than 27 hours and had reported weekly earnings which resulted in a sample of 6999 individuals. They also controlled for individual characteristics (age, age square, gender, experience and education).
  8. ↑ They used year averages of rainfall, sunshine, gale days … Taken from the monthly weather report of the meteorological offices.
  9. ↑ They used atmospheric pollution, road congestion and the overall provision of recreational facilities.
  10. ↑ They matched their data with the New Earnings Survey data of the same year (1982). They introduced additional control for size of the plant and effort based on workers paid by results. They also included data on union wages. In the UK in 1982, wages, if set by collective bargaining, have national collective bargain as well as local ones. Thus they used proportions of people covered by either national bargaining, national and local ones for each regions of their analysis.
  11. ↑ The South is defined as South-East, South-West, East Anglia, East Midlands.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.