Crater illusion

Last updated

In astronomical imaging and Earth imaging, the crater illusion, also known as the dome illusion or crater/dome illusion, is an optical illusion which causes impact craters and other depressions to appear raised as domes or mountains. [1] It is believed to be caused by our being accustomed to seeing light from overhead. [2] When some images are taken from orbit, the light from the sun is nearly horizontal. This is the only time shadows are seen. Our brains are tricked into thinking that the interior of the crater is above the surrounding terrain instead of below it. [3]

Contents

Examples

In September 2015, NASA released an image from the space probe Dawn of the crater Occator on dwarf planet Ceres. Because of the position of the Sun at the time the image was taken, the walls of the crater may appear to be convex instead of concave. On the right is the same image rotated 180 degrees to change the position of the shadows and eliminate the illusion.

Crater Occator on the dwarf planet Ceres Occator Crater Illusion.jpg
Crater Occator on the dwarf planet Ceres
The same image of Occator rotated 180-degrees Crater Occator without Crater Illusion.jpg
The same image of Occator rotated 180-degrees

In December 1968, the Apollo 8 mission took the photograph on the right of the Moon's crater Goclenius. On the left is the same image rotated in an attempt to create the illusion.

Photograph of Goclenius rotated in an attempt to create the crater illusion Apollo 8 Photograph of Goclenius Rotated to Create Illusion.jpg
Photograph of Goclenius rotated in an attempt to create the crater illusion
The original Apollo 8 Photograph of the Moon's Goclenius Crater 1968 Apollo 8 Photo of Goclenius not showing illusion.jpg
The original Apollo 8 Photograph of the Moon's Goclenius Crater

In March 2011, NASA released an image of Mercury's Spitteler and Holberg craters taken by the MESSENGER spacecraft. [4] The image on the left is the original image and the image on the right is the same image rotated in an attempt to remove the illusion.

Original image of Spitteler and Holberg craters showing illusion. Spitteler and Holberg Craters from MESSENGER Space Probe.jpg
Original image of Spitteler and Holberg craters showing illusion.
The same image rotated in an attempt to eliminate the illusion March 2011 Image of Spitteler and Holberg Craters Rotated.jpg
The same image rotated in an attempt to eliminate the illusion

In the image on the left of the Tin Bider crater produced by NASA Earth Observatory's EO-1-based Advanced Land Imager produces a reverse illusion. The crater rises above the surrounding terrain, however the position of the sun makes it appear to be below it. [5]

Original NASA Earth Observatory image of Tin Bider Crater NASA Earth Observatory ALI 2011 image of Tin Bider Crater.jpg
Original NASA Earth Observatory image of Tin Bider Crater
The same image rotated 2011 NASA Earth Observatory image of Tin Bider Crater rotated.jpg
The same image rotated

Related Research Articles

Parallax Difference in the apparent position of an object viewed along two different lines of sight

Parallax is a displacement or difference in the apparent position of an object viewed along two different lines of sight, and is measured by the angle or semi-angle of inclination between those two lines. Due to foreshortening, nearby objects show a larger parallax than farther objects when observed from different positions, so parallax can be used to determine distances.

A terminator or twilight zone is a moving line that divides the daylit side and the dark night side of a planetary body. The terminator is defined as the locus of points on a planet or moon where the line through the center of its parent star is tangent. An observer on the terminator of such an orbiting body with an atmosphere would experience twilight due to light scattering by particles in the gaseous layer.

Surveyor 1 Lunar lander spacecraft

Surveyor 1 was the first lunar soft-lander in the uncrewed Surveyor program of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. This lunar soft-lander gathered data about the lunar surface that would be needed for the crewed Apollo Moon landings that began in 1969. The successful soft landing of Surveyor 1 on the Ocean of Storms was the first by an American space probe on any extraterrestrial body, occurring on the first attempt and just four months after the first Moon landing by the Soviet Union's Luna 9 probe.

Sunrise Time of day when the sun appears above the earth

Sunrise is the moment when the upper rim of the Sun appears on the horizon in the morning. The term can also refer to the entire process of the solar disk crossing the horizon and its accompanying atmospheric effects.

Dione (moon) Moon of Saturn

Dione is a moon of Saturn. It was discovered by Italian astronomer Giovanni Domenico Cassini in 1684. It is named after the Titaness Dione of Greek mythology. It is also designated Saturn IV.

<i>Mars Global Surveyor</i> NASA Mars orbiter launched in 1996

Mars Global Surveyor (MGS) is an American robotic space probe developed by NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory and launched November 1996. MGS was a global mapping mission that examined the entire planet, from the ionosphere down through the atmosphere to the surface. As part of the larger Mars Exploration Program, Mars Global Surveyor performed atmospheric monitoring for sister orbiters during aerobraking, and helped Mars rovers and lander missions by identifying potential landing sites and relaying surface telemetry.

Tin Bider crater

Tin Bider is an impact crater that sits in dry, rugged terrain in Algeria. The crater was formed in the last 70 million years, perhaps in the late Cretaceous or early Tertiary Period. Spanning 6 kilometres, the crater sits at the southern end of a range of hills. The elevated position and concentric rings of Tin Bider suggest that its structure is complex.

Coronagraph Telescopic attachment designed to block out the direct light from a star

A coronagraph is a telescopic attachment designed to block out the direct light from a star so that nearby objects – which otherwise would be hidden in the star's bright glare – can be resolved. Most coronagraphs are intended to view the corona of the Sun, but a new class of conceptually similar instruments are being used to find extrasolar planets and circumstellar disks around nearby stars as well as host galaxies in quasars and other similar objects with active galactic nuclei (AGN).

Plato (crater)

Plato is a lava-filled lunar impact crater on the Moon. Its diameter is 101 km. It was named after ancient Greek philosopher Plato. It is located on the northeastern shore of the Mare Imbrium, at the western extremity of the Montes Alpes mountain range. In the mare to the south are several rises collectively named the Montes Teneriffe. To the north lies the wide stretch of the Mare Frigoris. East of the crater, among the Montes Alpes, are several rilles collectively named the Rimae Plato.

Shackleton (crater) Lunar impact crater

Shackleton is an impact crater that lies at the lunar south pole. The peaks along the crater's rim are exposed to almost continual sunlight, while the interior is perpetually in shadow. The low-temperature interior of this crater functions as a cold trap that may capture and freeze volatiles shed during comet impacts on the Moon. Measurements by the Lunar Prospector spacecraft showed higher than normal amounts of hydrogen within the crater, which may indicate the presence of water ice. The crater is named after Antarctic explorer Ernest Shackleton.

Malapert (crater) Lunar surface depression caused by impact

Malapert is a lunar impact crater that lies near the southern limb of the Moon. From the Earth this formation is viewed from the side, limiting the amount of detail that can be seen. The crater is also illuminated at very low angles, so that parts of the interior remain in almost constant darkness. The nearest craters of note are Cabeus to the west, and Shoemaker to the south-southeast and nearer to the south pole of the Moon.

Geology of Mercury Geologic structure and composition of planet Mercury

The geology of Mercury is the scientific study of the surface, crust, and interior of the planet Mercury. It emphasizes the composition, structure, history, and physical processes that shape the planet. It is analogous to the field of terrestrial geology. In planetary science, the term geology is used in its broadest sense to mean the study of the solid parts of planets and moons. The term incorporates aspects of geophysics, geochemistry, mineralogy, geodesy, and cartography.

Geology of Venus Geological structure and composition of the second planet from the Sun

Venus is a planet with striking geology. Of all the other planets in the Solar System, it is the one nearest to Earth and most like it in terms of mass, but has no magnetic field or recognizable plate tectonic system. Much of the ground surface is exposed volcanic bedrock, some with thin and patchy layers of soil covering, in marked contrast with Earth, the Moon, and Mars. Some impact craters are present, but Venus is similar to Earth in that there are fewer craters than on the other rocky planets that are largely covered by them. This is due in part to the thickness of the Venusian atmosphere disrupting small impactors before they strike the ground, but the paucity of large craters may be due to volcanic re-surfacing, possibly of a catastrophic nature. Volcanism appears to be the dominant agent of geological change on Venus. Some of the volcanic landforms appear to be unique to the planet. There are shield and composite volcanoes similar to those found on Earth. Given that Venus has approximately the same size, density, and composition as Earth, it is plausible that volcanism may be continuing on the planet today, as demonstrated by recent studies.

STEREO Solar observation mission

STEREO is a solar observation mission. Two nearly identical spacecraft were launched in 2006 into orbits around the Sun that cause them to respectively pull farther ahead of and fall gradually behind the Earth. This enabled stereoscopic imaging of the Sun and solar phenomena, such as coronal mass ejections.

Third-party evidence for Apollo Moon landings Independent confirmations of Apollo Moon landings

Third-party evidence for Apollo Moon landings is evidence, or analysis of evidence, about Moon landings that does not come from either NASA or the U.S. government, or the Apollo Moon landing hoax theorists. This evidence serves as independent confirmation of NASA's account of the Moon landings.

Geology of solar terrestrial planets Geology of Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars and Ceres

The geology of solar terrestrial planets mainly deals with the geological aspects of the four terrestrial planets of the Solar System – Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars – and one terrestrial dwarf planet: Ceres. Earth is the only terrestrial planet known to have an active hydrosphere.

Lowell (Martian crater) Crater on Mars

The Lowell crater is a large impact crater on Aonia Terra in the Thaumasia quadrangle of Mars. The crater is about 203 kilometers in diameter. Lowell is an example of a well-preserved peak ring crater on Mars.

Solar eclipses on the Moon Lunar phenomenon wherein the Sun is obscured by Earth

Solar eclipses on the Moon are caused when the planet Earth passes in front of the Sun and blocks its light. Viewers on Earth experience a lunar eclipse during a solar eclipse on the Moon.

Ahuna Mons

Ahuna Mons is the largest mountain on the dwarf planet and asteroid Ceres. It protrudes above the cratered terrain, is not an impact feature, and is the only mountain of its kind on Ceres. Bright streaks run top to bottom on its slopes; these streaks are thought to be salt, similar to the better known Cererian bright spots, and likely resulted from cryovolcanic activity from Ceres's interior. It is named after the traditional post-harvest festival Ahuna of the Sumi Naga people of India. In July 2018, NASA released a comparison of physical features, including Ahuna Mons, found on Ceres with similar ones present on Earth.

Mapping of Venus Process and results of human description of the geological features of the planet Venus

The mapping of Venus refers to the process and results of human description of the geological features of the planet Venus. It involves surface radar images of Venus, construction of geological maps, and the identification of stratigraphic units, volumes of rock with a similar age.

References

  1. "An Impact Melt Crater You'll Flip For". Slate.com Bad Astronomy. 28 July 2013.
  2. Crater Illusion by Paul Doherty, retrieved September 12, 2015
  3. "Do You See a Mountain or a Crater in this Picture?". Universe Today. 29 January 2015.
  4. "A Trip Around our Solar System". The Atlantic In Focus. 27 May 2001.
  5. Tin Bider Crater, Algeria from the NASA Earth Observatory, retrieved September 12, 2015