Drug testing welfare recipients

Last updated

Some states in the United States of America have enacted or proposed legislation requiring drug testing of people applying for welfare. As of early 2017, 15 US states had passed legislation enabling drug testing of welfare applicants or recipients, primarily in relation to Temporary Assistance for Needy Families payments. [1] Drug testing of welfare recipients has been proposed but not implemented in Canada and the UK, [2] and a trial program is being considered in Australia. [3] In New Zealand, recipients of some payments may be required to take a drug test if this is a requirement of a potential employer or trainer. [2]

Contents

Arguments for

Proponents of such programs have supported them with a variety of goals in mind, including: getting help for drug users on welfare payments by referring those testing positive to treatment, avoiding "subsidizing drug habits" with public money, [4] deterring drug use, reducing state welfare spending, and protecting children. [5] [6]

Arguments against

Opponents have criticized these laws for costing more money than they save. [7] The cost per positive test varies because of differences in state programs, but a review of 14 programs in 2016 reported costs per positive test result of between $200 (Tennessee) and $7,006 (Missouri). [8] Eric Liu has criticized drug tests of welfare recipients, which are often promoted by Republican lawmakers, as hypocritical, as they promote government paternalism. [9] Some suggest drug testing welfare recipients is linked to discrimination against welfare recipients or to racism. [10] [11] Executives of the non-profit group CLASP have stated that the laws will have a chilling effect on the willingness of existing welfare recipients to admit themselves to drug treatment. [12] Additionally, public policy professor Harold Pollack wrote that "Other physical and mental health problems are far more prevalent. Yet these less-moralized concerns receive much less attention from legislators or the general public." [13] The American Civil Liberties Union has opposed welfare drug testing laws in Florida and expressed concern about the proposal gaining traction in other states. [14] Almost all scholarly articles on the subject of suspicionless drug testing of welfare recipients has concluded that this testing violates the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution [15] (for this reason many programs now involve initial screening with a psychological assessment tool, with those considered likely to have a drug problem then referred for testing [8] ). The ethical acceptability of drug testing welfare recipients has also been questioned. [5] [16]

Laws by state

Arizona

In 2009, Arizona enacted a drug-testing law for welfare applicants that have a felony drug conviction. [17]

Florida

In December 2013, federal judge Mary Stenson Scriven struck down a Florida law, passed in May 2011, that required welfare recipients to be drug tested before they could receive benefits. [18] Rick Scott, the governor of Florida, had endorsed the legislation, and said he intended to appeal Scriven's decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals. [19]

Georgia

In April 2014, Georgia governor Nathan Deal signed a bill requiring drug testing for welfare applicants "if authorities have a 'reasonable suspicion' of drug use." [20]

Michigan

In 1999 a pilot program of drug testing welfare recipients was introduced, but terminated after a legal challenge that it violated the Fourth Amendment. [1] In December 2014, Rick Snyder, the governor of Michigan, signed a bill beginning a pilot program whereby welfare recipients in three Michigan counties will be drug tested if they are suspected of having used drugs. [21]

Utah

From August 2012 to July 2013, Utah spent over $30,000 on drug testing welfare applicants. State Representative Brad Wilson claimed in September 2013 that the program had saved more than $350,000 based on a drop of 247 applicants for TANF after the drug testing was instituted. [22]

Wisconsin

Scott Walker, the former governor of Wisconsin, has previously endorsed drug testing for welfare recipients. [23]

Positive drug test result rates

In a pilot drug testing program in Florida in 1999-2000, 5.1% returned a positive urinalysis. [24] A 2015 study by ThinkProgress found that out of seven states reporting data on welfare drug testing, only one had a usage rate above 1%. [12] Analysis of data on US state programs provided by CLASP shows that of the total population screened in 9 states, 0.19% returned positive tests, or 0.57% if refused tests (where reported) are treated as positives (see data in appendix D). [8]

Related Research Articles

Medicaid United States social health care program for families and individuals with limited resources

Medicaid in the United States is a federal and state program that helps with healthcare costs for some people with limited income and resources. Medicaid also offers benefits not normally covered by Medicare, including nursing home care and personal care services. The main difference between the two programs is that Medicaid covers healthcare costs for people with low incomes while Medicare provides health coverage for the elderly. There are also dual health plans for people who have both Medicaid and Medicare. The Health Insurance Association of America describes Medicaid as "a government insurance program for persons of all ages whose income and resources are insufficient to pay for health care."

Social services Range of public services

Social services are a range of public services intended to provide support and assistance towards particular groups, which commonly include the disadvantaged. They may be provided by individuals, private and independent organisations, or administered by a government agency. Social services are connected with the concept of welfare and the welfare state, as countries with large welfare programs often provide a wide range of social services. Social services are employed to address the wide range of needs of a society. Prior to industrialisation, the provision of social services was largely confined to private organisations and charities, with the extent of its coverage also limited. Social services are now generally regarded globally as a 'necessary function' of society and a mechanism through which governments may address societal issues.

Welfare Means-oriented social benefit

Welfare, or commonly social welfare, is a type of government support intended to ensure that members of a society can meet basic human needs such as food and shelter. Social security may either be synonymous with welfare, or refer specifically to social insurance programs which provide support only to those who have previously contributed, as opposed to social assistance programs which provide support on the basis of need alone. The International Labour Organization defines social security as covering support for those in old age, support for the maintenance of children, medical treatment, parental and sick leave, unemployment and disability benefits, and support for sufferers of occupational injury.

Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program United States government food assistance program

In the United States, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), formerly known as the Food Stamp Program, is a federal program that provides food-purchasing assistance for low- and no-income people. It is a federal aid program, administered by the United States Department of Agriculture under the Food and Nutrition Service (FNS), though benefits are distributed by specific departments of U.S. states.

Aid to Families with Dependent Children Federal assistance program in the U.S. from 1935 to 1997

Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) was a federal assistance program in the United States in effect from 1935 to 1997, created by the Social Security Act (SSA) and administered by the United States Department of Health and Human Services that provided financial assistance to children whose families had low or no income.

Scott Walker (politician) 45th Governor of Wisconsin

Scott Kevin Walker is an American politician who served as the 45th Governor of Wisconsin from 2011 to 2019. He is a member of the Republican Party.

The economic policies of Bill Clinton administration, referred to by some as Clintonomics, encapsulates the economic policies of United States President Bill Clinton that were implemented during his presidency, which lasted from January 1993 to January 2001.

Temporary Assistance for Needy Families U.S. federal aid program

Temporary Assistance for Needy Families is a federal assistance program of the United States. It began on July 1, 1997, and succeeded the Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program, providing cash assistance to indigent American families through the United States Department of Health and Human Services. TANF is often simply referred to as welfare.

Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act United States welfare reform law

The Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 (PRWORA) is a United States federal law passed by the 104th United States Congress and signed into law by President Bill Clinton. The bill implemented major changes to U.S. social welfare policy, replacing the Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program with the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program.

Rick Scott American politician and businessman (born 1952)

Richard Lynn Scott is an American politician and businessman serving as the junior United States senator from Florida since 2019. A member of the Republican Party, he was the 45th governor of Florida from 2011 to 2019.

A "welfare queen" is a derogatory term used in the United States to refer to women who allegedly misuse or collect excessive welfare payments through fraud, child endangerment, or manipulation. Reporting on welfare fraud began during the early 1960s, appearing in general-interest magazines such as Readers Digest. The term originates from media reporting in 1974, and was popularized by Ronald Reagan, beginning with his 1976 presidential campaign.

Social programs in the United States Overview of social programs in the United States of America

Social programs in the United States are programs designed to ensure that the basic needs of the American population are met. Federal and state social programs include cash assistance, health insurance, food assistance, housing subsidies, energy and utilities subsidies, and education and childcare assistance. Similar benefits are sometimes provided by the private sector either through policy mandates or on a voluntary basis. Employer-sponsored health insurance is an example of this.

Mary Stenson Scriven is a United States District Judge of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida.

Cannabis in Colorado Overview of the use and culture of cannabis in Colorado, U.S.

Cannabis in Colorado has been legal for medical use since 2000 and for recreational use since late 2012. On November 7, 2000, 54% of Colorado voters approved Amendment 20, which amended the State Constitution to allow the use of marijuana in the state for approved patients with written medical consent. Under this law, patients may possess up to 2 ounces (57 g) of medical marijuana and may cultivate no more than six marijuana plants. Patients who are caught with more than this in their possession may argue "affirmative defense of medical necessity" but are not protected under state law with the rights of those who stay within the guidelines set forth by the state. The Colorado Amendment 64, which was passed by voters on November 6, 2012, led to recreational legalization in December 2012 and state-licensed retail sales in January 2014. The policy has led to cannabis tourism. There are two sets of policies in Colorado relating to cannabis use: those for medicinal cannabis and for recreational drug use along with a third set of rules governing hemp.

Welfare culture refers to the behavioral consequences of providing poverty relief to low-income individuals. Welfare is considered a type of social protection, which may come in the form of remittances, such as 'welfare checks', or subsidized services, such as free/reduced healthcare, affordable housing, and more. Pierson (2006) has acknowledged that, like poverty, welfare creates behavioral ramifications, and that studies differ regarding whether welfare empowers individuals or breeds dependence on government aid. Pierson also acknowledges that the evidence of the behavioral effects of welfare varies across countries, because different countries implement different systems of welfare.

Welfare dependency is the state in which a person or household is reliant on government welfare benefits for their income for a prolonged period of time, and without which they would not be able to meet the expenses of daily living. The United States Department of Health and Human Services defines welfare dependency as the proportion of all individuals in families which receive more than 50 percent of their total annual income from Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), food stamps, and/or Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits. Typically viewed as a social problem, it has been the subject of major welfare reform efforts since the mid-20th century, primarily focused on trying to make recipients self-sufficient through paid work. While the term "welfare dependency" can be used pejoratively, for the purposes of this article it shall be used to indicate a particular situation of persistent poverty.

The California Work Opportunities and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program is the California welfare implementation of the federal welfare-to-work Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program that provides cash aid and services to eligible needy California families.

Jesse Panuccio American lawyer

Jesse Michael Panuccio is an American attorney and government official. He served as the acting United States Associate Attorney General in 2017 and again from February 2018 to May 2019. He previously served as general counsel to Governor Rick Scott of Florida and as the executive director of the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity.

David A. Hansell is an American advocate and expert on public policy and programs that provide assistance to vulnerable populations. He started his career in public service in the late 1980s as an advocate for New York City's HIV-positive population. He then joined the City government, where he was quickly recognized for his talent for modernizing government programs, and developing innovative methods for creating economic opportunities and sustainable supports for poor and working-class families.

Preserving Welfare for Needs Not Weed Act

The Preserving Welfare for Needs Not Weed Act is a bill that would prevent the use of electronic benefit transfer cards in businesses that sell marijuana.

References

  1. 1 2 Legislatures, National Conference of State. "Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients and Public Assistance". www.ncsl.org. Retrieved 2018-11-02.
  2. 1 2 Wincup, Emma (2014). "Thoroughfares, crossroads and cul-de-sacs: drug testing of welfare recipients". The International Journal on Drug Policy. 25 (5): 1031–1037. doi:10.1016/j.drugpo.2014.02.011. ISSN   1873-4758. PMID   24709412.
  3. ↑ Arthur, Don. "Drug testing for welfare recipients". Parliament of Australia. Retrieved 2019-09-22.
  4. ↑ Grovum, Jake (6 March 2014). "Some states still pushing drug testing for welfare". USA Today. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  5. 1 2 Walker, Mary Jean; Franklin, James (2018-10-25). "An Argument Against Drug Testing Welfare Recipients". Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal. 28 (3): 309–340. doi:10.1353/ken.2018.0019. ISSN   1086-3249. PMID   30369508. S2CID   53102270.
  6. ↑ Jeffrey, Widelitz (2011). "Florida's Suspicionless Drug Testing of Welfare Applicants". Nova Law Review. 36 (1).
  7. ↑ Cunha, Darlena (15 August 2014). "Why Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Is a Waste of Taxpayer Money". Time. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  8. 1 2 3 "Drug Testing and Public Assistance". CLASP. 2016-02-04. Retrieved 2018-11-02.
  9. ↑ Liu, Eric (18 December 2014). "Wall Street CEOs should take drug test". CNN. Retrieved 2 January 2015. ...it's the height of hypocrisy for limited-government conservatives like Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, who claim they want government out of people's lives, to champion such intrusive, shaming forms of paternalism.
  10. ↑ Ledford, Chris (2016-11-10). "Symbolic Racism, Institutional Bias, and Welfare Drug Testing Legislation: Racial Biases Matter". Policy Studies Journal. 46 (3): 510–530. doi:10.1111/psj.12192. ISSN   0190-292X.
  11. ↑ Amundson, Kalynn; Zajicek, Anna M.; Kerr, Brinck (2015-07-30). "A Social Metamorphosis: Constructing Drug Addicts From the Poor". Sociological Spectrum. 35 (5): 442–464. doi:10.1080/02732173.2015.1064799. ISSN   0273-2173. S2CID   141852776.
  12. 1 2 Covert, Bryce; Israel, Josh (2015-02-26). "What 7 States Discovered After Spending More Than $1 Million Drug Testing Welfare Recipients". ThinkProgress. Retrieved 2015-11-17.
  13. ↑ Pollack, Harold (2013-06-05). "States want drug tests for welfare recipients. That's a terrible idea". Washington Post. Retrieved 2015-11-17.
  14. ↑ Ganeva, Tana (2015-10-17). "5 reasons drug testing welfare recipients is profoundly stupid". Alternet. Retrieved 2015-11-17.
  15. ↑ Wurman, Ilan (May 2013). "Drug Testing Welfare Recipients as a Constitutional Condition". Stanford Law Review. 65 (5). SSRN   2212509.
  16. ↑ Pérez-Muñoz, Cristian (2017-12-01). "What is Wrong with Testing Welfare Recipients for Drug Use?". Political Studies. 65 (4): 912–929. doi:10.1177/0032321717692166. ISSN   0032-3217. S2CID   148584720.
  17. ↑ Editorial Board (18 March 2012). "Editorial: Drug testing welfare applicants nets little". USA Today. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  18. ↑ Cohen, Andrew (6 January 2014). "Poverty in a Cup: Why a Federal Judge Rejected a Florida Drug-Test Requirement". The Atlantic. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  19. ↑ "Judge nixes Florida's welfare drug testing". Fox News. Associated Press. 31 December 2013. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  20. ↑ Beasley, David (April 29, 2014). "Georgia governor signs law to drug test some welfare recipients". Yahoo News. Retrieved April 28, 2021.
  21. ↑ Ramsey, Nick (27 December 2014). "Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder OKs drug tests for welfare recipients". MSNBC. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  22. ↑ Price, Michelle (8 September 2013). "Utah's welfare drug testing saved more than $350,000 in first year, officials say". Deseret News. Retrieved 29 December 2014.
  23. ↑ Schwarz, Hunter (11 November 2014). "Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker wants to drug test welfare recipients". Washington Post. Retrieved 28 December 2014.
  24. ↑ Crew, Robert E.; Davis, Belinda Creel (2003). "Assessing the effects of substance abuse among applicants for TANF benefits: the outcome of a demonstration project in Florida". Journal of Health & Social Policy. 17 (1): 39–53. doi:10.1300/J045v17n01_03. ISSN   0897-7186. PMID   14620735. S2CID   2860097.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.