Great Moon Hoax

Last updated
A lithograph of the hoax's "ruby amphitheater", as printed in The Sun Great Moon Hoax - Day 4.jpg
A lithograph of the hoax's "ruby amphitheater", as printed in The Sun

The "Great Moon Hoax", also known as the "Great Moon Hoax of 1835" was a series of six articles published in The Sun (a New York newspaper), beginning on August 25, 1835, about the supposed discovery of life and civilization on the Moon. The discoveries were falsely attributed to Sir John Herschel and his fictitious companion Andrew Grant. [1]

Contents

The story was advertised on August 21, 1835, as an upcoming feature allegedly reprinted from The Edinburgh Courant . [2] The first in a series of six was published four days later on August 25. These articles were never retracted, however on September 16, 1835, The Sun admitted the articles were in fact fabricated. [3]

Hoax

Portrait of a man-bat ("Vespertilio-homo"), from an edition of the Moon series published in Naples 1836 the-great-moon-hoax-new-inhabitants-of-the-moon.png
Portrait of a man-bat ("Vespertilio-homo"), from an edition of the Moon series published in Naples

The headline read:

GREAT ASTRONOMICAL DISCOVERIES,
LATELY MADE
BY SIR JOHN HERSCHEL, L.L.D. F.R.S. &c.
[From Supplement to the Edinburgh Journal of Science.]

The articles described animals on the Moon, including bison, single-horned goats, mini zebras, unicorns, bipedal tail-less beavers and bat-like winged humanoids ("Vespertilio-homo") who built temples. [4] There were trees, oceans and beaches. These discoveries were supposedly made with "an immense telescope of an entirely new principle". The telescope - transported to South Africa from New England - was said to be many times larger than any other telescope in the world. The lens measured "24 feet in diameter and 7 tons in weight". [4]

"Vespertilio-homo" can be translated from Latin as man-bat, bat-man, or man-bats. [5] [6] [7]

A reprinted edition of 1836 added a second type named the Vespertiliones or the bat-men. [8] The author of the narrative was ostensibly Dr. Andrew Grant, the travelling companion and amanuensis of Sir John Herschel, but Grant was fictitious.

Eventually, the authors announced that the observations had been terminated by the destruction of the telescope, by means of the Sun causing the lens to act as a "burning glass", setting fire to the observatory. [9]

Authorship

View of the Moon Hoax The moon hoax - View of the Moon.png
View of the Moon Hoax
The Inhabitants of the Moon, 1836, Welsh edition The Inhabitants of the Moon, 1836, Welsh edition.png
The Inhabitants of the Moon, 1836, Welsh edition

The writer of the article was at first not known to the public. Initially, authorship of the article has been attributed to Richard Adams Locke (1800–1871), [10] [11] a reporter who, in August 1835, was working for The Sun. Eventually, Locke publicly admitted to being the author in 1840, in a letter to the weekly paper New World. [12] Despite Locke's claims, rumours persisted that others were involved in the articles' creation.

Two other men have been noted in connection with the hoax: Jean-Nicolas Nicollet, [10] a French astronomer travelling in America at the time (though he was in Mississippi, not New York, when the Moon-hoax issues appeared), and Lewis Gaylord Clark, editor of The Knickerbocker , a literary magazine. However, there is no good evidence to indicate that anyone but Locke was the author of the hoax.

Assuming that Richard A. Locke was the author, his intentions were probably, first, to create a sensational story which would increase sales of The Sun, and, second, to ridicule some of the more extravagant astronomical theories that had recently been published. Locke had meant for the hoax to act of a satire to show how science can be and is influenced by the thoughts of religion. [4] For instance, in 1824, Franz von Paula Gruithuisen, professor of astronomy at Munich University, had published a paper titled "Discovery of Many Distinct Traces of Lunar Inhabitants, Especially of One of Their Colossal Buildings". One theory is that this paper is responsible for inspiring the articles written by Locke. [13]

In his paper, Gruithuisen claimed to have observed various shades of color on the lunar surface, which he correlated with climate and vegetation zones. He also observed lines and geometrical shapes, which he felt indicated the existence of walls, roads, fortifications, and cities. However, a more direct object of Locke's satire was Rev. Thomas Dick, who was known as "The Christian Philosopher" after the title of his first book. [14] Dick had computed that the Solar System contained 21,891,974,404,480 (21.9 trillion) inhabitants. In fact, the Moon alone, by his count, would contain 4,200,000,000 inhabitants. [15] His writings were very popular in America; intellectual Ralph Waldo Emerson was one of his fans. [16]

Reactions

Newsboy showing a copy of the hoax Newsboy from The New York Sun hawking a copy containing The Great Moon Hoax of 1835. restored.png
Newsboy showing a copy of the hoax
Moon Hoax 1859 NY William Gowans, Richard Adams Locke Moon Hoax 1859 NY William Gowans.png
Moon Hoax 1859 NY William Gowans, Richard Adams Locke
Moonscene Moonscene2-1-.jpg
Moonscene

According to legend, The Sun's circulation increased dramatically because of the hoax and remained permanently greater than before, thereby establishing The Sun as a successful paper. It brought the journal to international fame, and the hoax resembled crime reports that allowed the readers to play detective, trying to discover the truth. [17] [18]

However, the degree to which the hoax increased the paper's circulation has certainly been exaggerated in popular accounts of the event. It was not discovered to be a hoax for several weeks after its publication and, even then, the newspaper did not issue a retraction. [19]

Herschel was initially amused by the hoax, noting that his own real observations could never be as exciting. He later became annoyed when he had to answer questions from people who believed the hoax was serious. [20]

Edgar Allan Poe claimed the story was a plagiarism of his earlier work "The Unparalleled Adventure of One Hans Pfaall," and "Hans Phaall – A Tale", published in the Southern Literary Messenger. His editor at the time was Richard Adams Locke. He later published "The Balloon-Hoax" in the same newspaper. [21] As well as "The Unparalleled Adventure of One Hans Pfaall". The story was reprinted in the New York Transcript on September 2–5, 1835, under the headline "Lunar Discoveries, Extraordinary Aerial Voyage by Baron Hans Pfaall". [22]

Poe described a voyage to the Moon in a balloon, in which Pfaall lives for five years on the Moon with lunarians and sends back a lunarian to Earth. The Poe Moon hoax was less successful because of the satiric and comical tone of the account. Locke was able to upstage Poe and to steal his thunder. In 1846, Poe would write a biographical sketch of Locke as part of his series "The Literati of New York City" which appeared in Godey's Lady's Book . [22]

Legacy

Great Moon Hoax, Edinburgh Journal of Science, by Lilith de Thierry Freres Aug25 moon hoax-1-.jpg
Great Moon Hoax, Edinburgh Journal of Science, by Lilith de Thierry Freres

The hoax is featured in Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898, winner of the Pulitzer Prize for History. [23]

The Moon Trilogy - a series of fantasy novels by the Polish author Jerzy Żuławski, published in 1903–1911. The series consists of the following novels: On the Silver Globe. Manuscript from the Moon, The Conqueror and Old Earth.

Nate DiMeo's historical podcast The Memory Palace dedicated a 2010 episode to the Great Moon Hoax entitled "The Moon in the Sun". [24]

The hoax inspired a three-part musical by composer Matt Dahan as part of his musical radio series Pulp Musicals. [25]

Richard Adams Locke and the Great Moon Hoax are fictionalized in chapter 14 of Félix J. Palma's 2012 novel The Map of the Sky.[ citation needed ]

The hoax reflected a time when readers were looking for entertainment as much as information from penny press newspapers, which would later change with the development of ethical reporting. [26]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of astronomy</span>

Astronomy is the oldest of the natural sciences, dating back to antiquity, with its origins in the religious, mythological, cosmological, calendrical, and astrological beliefs and practices of prehistory: vestiges of these are still found in astrology, a discipline long interwoven with public and governmental astronomy. It was not completely separated in Europe during the Copernican Revolution starting in 1543. In some cultures, astronomical data was used for astrological prognostication.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Balloon-Hoax</span> Edgar Allan Poe hoax

"The Balloon-Hoax" is the title used in collections and anthologies of a newspaper article by American writer Edgar Allan Poe, first published in 1844 in The Sun newspaper in New York. Originally presented as a true story, it detailed European Monck Mason's trip across the Atlantic Ocean in only three days in a gas balloon. It was later revealed as a hoax and the story was retracted two days later.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Herschel</span> German-born British astronomer and composer (1738–1822)

Frederick William Herschel was a German-British astronomer and composer. He frequently collaborated with his younger sister and fellow astronomer Caroline Herschel. Born in the Electorate of Hanover, William Herschel followed his father into the military band of Hanover, before emigrating to Great Britain in 1757 at the age of nineteen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Herschel</span> English polymath (1792–1871)

Sir John Frederick William Herschel, 1st Baronet was an English polymath active as a mathematician, astronomer, chemist, inventor, and experimental photographer who invented the blueprint and did botanical work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Couch Adams</span> British mathematician and astronomer (1819–1892)

John Couch Adams was a British mathematician and astronomer. He was born in Laneast, near Launceston, Cornwall, and died in Cambridge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caroline Herschel</span> German-British astronomer (1750–1848)

Caroline Lucretia Herschel was a German-born British astronomer, whose most significant contributions to astronomy were the discoveries of several comets, including the periodic comet 35P/Herschel–Rigollet, which bears her name. She was the younger sister of astronomer William Herschel, with whom she worked throughout her career.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Benjamin Henry Day</span> American newspaper publisher (1810–1889)

Benjamin Henry Day was an American newspaper publisher who founded the New York Sun, the first penny press newspaper in the United States, in 1833.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transient lunar phenomenon</span> Short-lived light, color, or change in appearance on the surface of the Moon

A transient lunar phenomenon (TLP) or lunar transient phenomenon (LTP) is a short-lived change in light, color or appearance on the surface of the Moon. The term was created by Patrick Moore in his co-authorship of NASA Technical Report R-277 Chronological Catalog of Reported Lunar Events, published in 1968.

The year 1835 in science and technology involved some significant events, listed below.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johann Hieronymus Schröter</span> German astronomer

Johann Hieronymus Schröter was a German astronomer.

<i>The Sun</i> (New York City) American daily newspaper (1833–1950)

The Sun was a New York newspaper published from 1833 until 1950. It was considered a serious paper, like the city's two more successful broadsheets, The New York Times and the New York Herald Tribune. The Sun was the first successful penny daily newspaper in the United States, and was for a time, the most successful newspaper in America.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Franz von Paula Gruithuisen</span> Bavarian astronomer

Franz von PaulaGruithuisen was a Bavarian physician and astronomer. He taught medical students before becoming a professor of astronomy at the University of Munich in 1826.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moon in science fiction</span>

The Moon has appeared in fiction as a setting since at least classical antiquity. Throughout most of literary history, a significant portion of works depicting lunar voyages has been satirical in nature. From the late 1800s onwards, science fiction has successively focused largely on the themes of life on the Moon, first Moon landings, and lunar colonization.

This is a timeline of astronomy. It covers ancient, medieval, Renaissance-era, and finally modern astronomy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ewen Whitaker</span> British astronomer (1922–2016)

Ewen Adair Whitaker was a British-born astronomer who specialized in lunar studies. During World War II he was engaged in quality control for the lead sheathing of hollow cables strung under the English Channel as part of the "Pipe Line Under The Ocean" Project (PLUTO) to supply gasoline to Allied military vehicles in France. After the war, he obtained a position at the Royal Greenwich Observatory working on the UV spectra of stars, but became interested in lunar studies. As a sideline, Whitaker drew and published the first accurate chart of the South Polar area of the Moon in 1954, and served as director of the Lunar Section of the British Astronomical Association.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lunar distance (navigation)</span> Angular distance between the Moon and another celestial body

In celestial navigation, lunar distance, also called a lunar, is the angular distance between the Moon and another celestial body. The lunar distances method uses this angle and a nautical almanac to calculate Greenwich time if so desired, or by extension any other time. That calculated time can be used in solving a spherical triangle. The theory was first published by Johannes Werner in 1524, before the necessary almanacs had been published. A fuller method was published in 1763 and used until about 1850 when it was superseded by the marine chronometer. A similar method uses the positions of the Galilean moons of Jupiter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Dick (scientist)</span>

Reverend Thomas Dick, was a British church minister, science teacher and writer, known for his works on astronomy and practical philosophy, combining science and Christianity, and arguing for a harmony between the two.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Unparalleled Adventure of One Hans Pfaall</span> Science fiction short story by Edgar Allan Poe

"The Unparalleled Adventure of One Hans Pfaall" (1835) is a short story by Edgar Allan Poe published in the June 1835 issue of the monthly magazine Southern Literary Messenger as "Hans Phaall -- A Tale", intended by Poe to be a hoax.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Discovery of Neptune</span> 1846 discovery of Neptune through mathematically-predicted observation

The planet Neptune was mathematically predicted before it was directly observed. With a prediction by Urbain Le Verrier, telescopic observations confirming the existence of a major planet were made on the night of September 23–24, 1846, at the Berlin Observatory, by astronomer Johann Gottfried Galle, working from Le Verrier's calculations. It was a sensational moment of 19th-century science, and dramatic confirmation of Newtonian gravitational theory. In François Arago's apt phrase, Le Verrier had discovered a planet "with the point of his pen".

<i>Masterpieces of Science Fiction</i> 1966 anthology edited by Sam Moskowitz

Masterpieces of Science Fiction is an anthology of science fiction short stories, edited by Sam Moskowitz. It was first published in hardcover by World Publishing Co. in 1966, and reprinted by Hyperion Press in 1974.

References

  1. Vida, István Kornél (2012). "The "Great Moon Hoax" of 1835". Hungarian Journal of English and American Studies. 18 (1/2): 431–441. JSTOR   43488485.
  2. Maliszewski, Paul. "Paper Moon", Wilson Quarterly. Winter 2005. p. 26.
  3. ""The Great Moon Hoax" is published in the "New York Sun" | August 25, 1835". HISTORY. Retrieved 2023-11-29.
  4. 1 2 3 Magazine, Smithsonian; Zielinski, Sarah. "The Great Moon Hoax Was Simply a Sign of Its Time". Smithsonian Magazine. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  5. Lunar Bat-men, the Planet Vulcan and Martian Canals, Smithsonian Magazine, Erik Washam, December 2010
  6. István Kornél Vida (2012). "The "Great Moon Hoax" of 1835". Hungarian Journal of English and American Studies (Hjeas). Centre for Arts, Humanities and Sciences (CAHS). 18 (1/2): 434. JSTOR   43488485.
  7. Dave Kindy (2022). "Great Moon Hoax of 1835 convinced the world of extraterrestrial life". WashingtonPost.
  8. J L Hilton (2005). "Lucian and the Great Moon Hoax of 1835". Akroterion. University of KwaZulu-Natal. 50. doi: 10.7445/50-0-78 .
  9. Gunn, James E.; Asimov, Isaac (1975). Alternate worlds: the illustrated history of science fiction. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. p. 51. ISBN   0-89104-049-8.
  10. 1 2 "They Formed A Pair". The Deseret Weekly . Salt Lake City, UT: Deseret News Publishing Company. May 13, 1893. p. 665. Retrieved June 27, 2013.
  11. Clute, John; Eggeling, John. "Locke, Richard Adams". The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction. Retrieved November 3, 2018.
  12. Goodman, Matthew (2008). The Sun and the Moon . New York: Basic Books. p.  274. ISBN   978-0-465-00257-3.
  13. Hall, Stephanie (November 15, 2023). "Belief, Legend, and the Great Moon Hoax | Folklife Today". Library of Congress Blogs. Retrieved November 15, 2023.
  14. The Christian Philosopher
  15. Dick, Thomas (1845) [First published London 1837; New York 1838]. Celestial Scenery; or, The Wonders of the Planetary System Displayed: Illustrating the Perfections of Deity and a Plurality of Worlds (PDF). Philadelphia: Edward C. Biddle. pp. 276–277. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
  16. Brashear, J. A. (1913). "A Visit to the Home of Dr. Thomas Dick". Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada. Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada, Vol. 7. 7: 23–24. Bibcode:1913JRASC...7...19B.
  17. Burrows, Edwin G. (1999) Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898, Oxford University Press, pp. 524–525
  18. Goodman, Matthew (2008). The Sun and the Moon: The Remarkable True Account of Hoaxers, Showmen, Dueling Journalists, and Lunar Man-Bats in Nineteenth-Century New York, Basic Books [ ISBN missing ]
  19. Falk, Doris V. "Thomas Low Nichols, Poe, and the 'Balloon Hoax'" collected in Poe Studies, vol. V, no. 2. December 1972. p. 48.
  20. Steven, Ruskin (2002). "A Newly-Discovered Letter of J.F.W Herschel concerning the "Great Moon Hox"". Journal for the History of Astronomy. 33 (110): 71–74. Bibcode:2002JHA....33...71R. doi:10.1177/002182860203300108. S2CID   117016279 . Retrieved 15 November 2023.
  21. "'The Great Moon Hoax' is published in the 'New York Sun'". History.com.
  22. 1 2 Hall, Stephanie (August 26, 2014). "Belief, Legend, and the Great Moon Hoax". Library of Congress Blogs. Retrieved November 20, 2023.
  23. Burrows, Edwin G. (1999) Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898, Oxford University Press, pp. 524–525
  24. DiMeo, Nate (January 13, 2010). "Episode 24: The Moon in the Sun". The Memory Palace (Podcast). WordPress. Archived from the original on March 9, 2013. Retrieved May 20, 2013.
  25. Cristi, A. A. "Pulp Musicals Sets Sights On The Moon With New Radio-Style Musical 'The Great Moon Hoax'". BroadwayWorld.com. Retrieved 2021-11-16.
  26. In Defense of Vespertilio-homo: Finding the Truth in the 1835 Moon Hoax, James Eric Black, Georgia State University.

Further reading