Klemperer rosette

Last updated
A simple hexagonal rosette with two kinds of body, which Klemperer notes is the nearest to being stable. Klemperer rosette.svg
A simple hexagonal rosette with two kinds of body, which Klemperer notes is the nearest to being stable.
The simplest system is three bodies in each other's Lagrangian points each with the same elliptical orbit; it is the only configuration known to occur naturally. Klemperer called this a "rhombus" instead of a "rosette". Elliptical orbit with objects at l4 and l5.gif
The simplest system is three bodies in each other's Lagrangian points each with the same elliptical orbit; it is the only configuration known to occur naturally. Klemperer called this a "rhombus" instead of a "rosette".

A Klemperer rosette is a gravitational system of (optionally) alternating heavier and lighter bodies orbiting in a symmetrical pattern around a common barycenter. It was first described by W.B. Klemperer in 1962, [1] and is a special case of a central configuration.

Contents

Klemperer described rosette systems as follows:

Such symmetry is also possessed by a peculiar family of geometrical configurations which may be described as "rosettes". In these an even number of "planets" of two (or more) kinds, one (or some) heavier than the other, but all of each set of equal mass, are placed at the corners of two (or more) interdigitated regular polygons so that the lighter and heavier ones alternate (or follow each other in a cyclic manner). [1] (p 163)

The simplest rosette would be a series of four alternating heavier and lighter bodies, 90 degrees from one another, in a rhombic configuration [Heavy, Light, Heavy, Light], where the two larger bodies have the same mass, and likewise the two smaller bodies have the same mass, all orbiting their (empty) geometric center. The more general trojan system has unequal masses for the two heavier bodies, which Klemperer also calls a "rhombic" system, and which is the only version that is not symmetric around the gravitational center.

The number of "mass types" can be increased, so long as the arrangement is symmetrical and cyclic pattern: e.g. [ 1,2,3 ... 1,2,3 ], [ 1,2,3,4,5 ... 1,2,3,4,5 ], [ 1,2,3,3,2,1 ... 1,2,3,3,2,1 ], etc.

Klemperer's article specifically analyzes regular polygons with 2–9 corners – dumbbell-shaped through nonagon – and non-centrally symmetric "rhombic rosettes" with three orbiting bodies, the outer two stationed at the middle orbiting body's triangular points (L4 and L5), which had already been described and studied by Lagrange in 1772. [2] Systems with an even number of 4 or more corners can have alternating heavy and light masses at the corners, although the possible range of mass ratios is constrained by para-stability requirements; systems with odd numbers of corners must have equal masses at every corner. While Klemperer notes that all the rosettes and the rhombus are vulnerable to destabilization, the hexagonal rosette is the most nearly stable because the "planets" sit in each other's semi-stable triangular Lagrangian points, L4 and L5. [1] (p 165)

The regular polygonal configurations ("rosettes") do not require a central mass (a "sun" at the center is optional, and if present it may bobble above and below the orbital plane), although a Lagrange-type rhombus does. If a central body is present, its mass constrains the ranges for the mass-ratio between the orbiting bodies. [1]

Misuse and misspelling

A pentagonal rosette as described in Larry Niven's novel Ringworld. Niven Rosette.svg
A pentagonal rosette as described in Larry Niven's novel Ringworld .

The term "Klemperer rosette" (often misspelled "Kemplerer rosette") is often used to mean a configuration of three or more equal masses, set at the points of an equilateral polygon and given an equal angular velocity about their center of mass. Klemperer does indeed mention this configuration at the start of his article, but only as an already known set of equilibrium systems before introducing the actual rosettes.

In Larry Niven's novel Fleet of Worlds in the Ringworld series, the Puppeteers' eponymous "Fleet of Worlds" is arranged in such a configuration [lower-alpha 1] which Niven calls a "Kemplerer rosette"; this (possibly intentional) misspelling is one possible source of the wider confusion. It is notable that these fictional planets were maintained in position by large engines, in addition to gravitational force.

Instability

Both simple linear perturbation analysis and simulations of rosettes [4] demonstrate that such systems are unstable: Klemperer explains in his original article, any displacement away from the perfectly symmetrical geometry causes a growing oscillation, eventually leading to the disruption of the system. [1] (pp 165–166) The system is unstable regardless of whether the center of the rosette is in free space, or is in orbit around a central star.

The short-form reason for the instability is that any perturbation corrupts the geometric symmetry, which increases the perturbation, which further undermines the geometry, and so on. The longer explanation is that any tangential perturbation brings a body closer to one neighbor and further from another; the gravitational imbalance becomes greater towards the closer neighbor and less for the farther neighbor, pulling the perturbed object further towards its closer neighbor, amplifying the perturbation rather than damping it. An inward radial perturbation causes the perturbed body to get closer to all other objects, increasing the force on the object and increasing its orbital velocity – which leads indirectly to a tangential perturbation and the argument above. [lower-alpha 2]

Notes

  1. The Klemperer rosette Niven & Lerner describe in Fleet of Worlds is a system of 5 planets spaced at the points of a pentagon. [3] Jenkins criticizes the engineering choice of 5 planets instead of the more nearly stable 6 planet hexagon as out-of-character for the safety-obsessed Pierson's Puppeteers. [4]
  2. Because of the gravitational instability, the Puppeteers' rosette of farming worlds described by Niven would require some form of artificial stabilization, which Niven & Lerner do specify in Fleet of Worlds . [3]

Related Research Articles

Known Space is the fictional setting of about a dozen science fiction novels and several collections of short stories by American writer Larry Niven. It has also become a shared universe in the spin-off Man-Kzin Wars anthologies. The Internet Speculative Fiction Database (ISFDB) catalogs all works set in the fictional universe that includes Known Space under the series name Tales of Known Space, which was the title of a 1975 collection of Niven's short stories. The first-published work in the series, which was Niven's first published piece, was "The Coldest Place", in the December 1964 issue of If magazine, edited by Frederik Pohl. This was the first-published work in the 1975 collection.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lagrange point</span> Equilibrium points near two orbiting bodies

In celestial mechanics, the Lagrange points are points of equilibrium for small-mass objects under the gravitational influence of two massive orbiting bodies. Mathematically, this involves the solution of the restricted three-body problem.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Orbit</span> Curved path of an object around a point

In celestial mechanics, an orbit is the curved trajectory of an object such as the trajectory of a planet around a star, or of a natural satellite around a planet, or of an artificial satellite around an object or position in space such as a planet, moon, asteroid, or Lagrange point. Normally, orbit refers to a regularly repeating trajectory, although it may also refer to a non-repeating trajectory. To a close approximation, planets and satellites follow elliptic orbits, with the center of mass being orbited at a focal point of the ellipse, as described by Kepler's laws of planetary motion.

<i>Ringworld</i> 1970 science fiction novel by Larry Niven

Ringworld is a 1970 science fiction novel by Larry Niven, set in his Known Space universe and considered a classic of science fiction literature. Ringworld tells the story of Louis Wu and his companions on a mission to the Ringworld, a rotating wheel artificial world, an alien construct in space 186 million miles in diameter. Niven later added three sequel novels and then cowrote, with Edward M. Lerner, four prequels and a final sequel; the five latter novels constitute the Fleet of Worlds series. All the novels in the Ringworld series tie into numerous other books set in Known Space. Ringworld won the Nebula Award in 1970, as well as both the Hugo Award and Locus Award in 1971.

<i>Ringworld</i> (role-playing game) Science fiction tabletop role-playing game

The Ringworld science fiction role-playing game was published by Chaosium in 1984, using the Basic Role-Playing system for its rules and Larry Niven's Ringworld novels as a setting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Celestial mechanics</span> Branch of astronomy

Celestial mechanics is the branch of astronomy that deals with the motions of objects in outer space. Historically, celestial mechanics applies principles of physics to astronomical objects, such as stars and planets, to produce ephemeris data.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Orbital mechanics</span> Field of classical mechanics concerned with the motion of spacecraft

Orbital mechanics or astrodynamics is the application of ballistics and celestial mechanics to the practical problems concerning the motion of rockets and other spacecraft. The motion of these objects is usually calculated from Newton's laws of motion and the law of universal gravitation. Orbital mechanics is a core discipline within space-mission design and control.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barycenter</span> Center of mass of multiple bodies orbiting each other

In astronomy, the barycenter is the center of mass of two or more bodies that orbit one another and is the point about which the bodies orbit. A barycenter is a dynamical point, not a physical object. It is an important concept in fields such as astronomy and astrophysics. The distance from a body's center of mass to the barycenter can be calculated as a two-body problem.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kzin</span> Fictional alien ethnic group

The Kzinti are a fictional, warlike, and bloodthirsty race of cat-like aliens in Larry Niven's Known Space series.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierson's Puppeteers</span>

Pierson's Puppeteers, often known just as Puppeteers, are a fictional alien race from American author Larry Niven's Known Space books. The race first appeared in Niven’s novella Neutron Star.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hill sphere</span> Region in which an astronomical body dominates the attraction of satellites

The Hill sphere of an astronomical body is the region in which it dominates the attraction of satellites. It is sometimes termed the Roche sphere. It was defined by the American astronomer George William Hill, based on the work of the French astronomer Édouard Roche.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alderson disk</span> Hypothetical artificial astronomical megastructure

An Alderson disk is a hypothetical artificial astronomical megastructure, like Larry Niven's Ringworld and the Dyson sphere. The disk is a giant platter with a thickness of several thousand miles. The Sun rests in the hole at the center of the disk. The outer perimeter of an Alderson disk would be roughly equivalent to the orbit of Mars or Jupiter. According to the proposal, a sufficiently large disk would have a larger mass than its Sun.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Megastructure</span> Very large artificial object

A megastructure is a very large artificial object, although the limits of precisely how large vary considerably. Some apply the term to any especially large or tall building. Some sources define a megastructure as an enormous self-supporting artificial construct. The products of megascale engineering or astroengineering are megastructures. The lower bound of megastructural engineering might be considered any structure that has any single dimension 1 megameter (1000 km) in length.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sphere of influence (astrodynamics)</span> Region of space gravitationally dominated by a given body

A sphere of influence (SOI) in astrodynamics and astronomy is the oblate-spheroid-shaped region around a celestial body where the primary gravitational influence on an orbiting object is that body. This is usually used to describe the areas in the Solar System where planets dominate the orbits of surrounding objects such as moons, despite the presence of the much more massive but distant Sun. In the patched conic approximation, used in estimating the trajectories of bodies moving between the neighbourhoods of different masses using a two body approximation, ellipses and hyperbolae, the SOI is taken as the boundary where the trajectory switches which mass field it is influenced by.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Polydeuces (moon)</span> Trojan moon of Saturn

Polydeuces, also designated Saturn XXXIV, is a small trojan moon of Saturn occupying the trailing L5 Lagrange point of Dione. It was discovered by the Cassini Imaging Science Team in images taken by the Cassini space probe on 21 October 2004. With a mean diameter of about 3 km (1.9 mi), Polydeuces is thought to have a smooth surface coated with fine, icy particles accumulated from the cryovolcanic plumes of Enceladus. In its orbit around Saturn, Polydeuces periodically drifts away from Dione's Lagrange point due to gravitational perturbations by other nearby moons of Saturn. Of the four known trojan moons of Saturn, Polydeuces exhibits the largest displacement from its Lagrange point.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Perturbation (astronomy)</span> Classical approach to the many-body problem of astronomy

In astronomy, perturbation is the complex motion of a massive body subjected to forces other than the gravitational attraction of a single other massive body. The other forces can include a third body, resistance, as from an atmosphere, and the off-center attraction of an oblate or otherwise misshapen body.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Osculating orbit</span> Orbital perturbations

In astronomy, and in particular in astrodynamics, the osculating orbit of an object in space at a given moment in time is the gravitational Kepler orbit that it would have around its central body if perturbations were absent. That is, it is the orbit that coincides with the current orbital state vectors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trojan (celestial body)</span> Objects sharing the orbit of a larger one

In astronomy, a trojan is a small celestial body (mostly asteroids) that shares the orbit of a larger body, remaining in a stable orbit approximately 60° ahead of or behind the main body near one of its Lagrangian points L4 and L5. Trojans can share the orbits of planets or of large moons.

<span class="texhtml mvar" style="font-style:italic;">n</span>-body problem Problem in physics and celestial mechanics

In physics, the n-body problem is the problem of predicting the individual motions of a group of celestial objects interacting with each other gravitationally. Solving this problem has been motivated by the desire to understand the motions of the Sun, Moon, planets, and visible stars. In the 20th century, understanding the dynamics of globular cluster star systems became an important n-body problem. The n-body problem in general relativity is considerably more difficult to solve due to additional factors like time and space distortions.

In celestial mechanics and the mathematics of the n-body problem, a central configuration is a system of point masses with the property that each mass is pulled by the combined gravitational force of the system directly towards the center of mass, with acceleration proportional to its distance from the center. Central configurations may be studied in Euclidean spaces of any dimension, although only dimensions one, two, and three are directly relevant for celestial mechanics.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Klemperer, W.B. (April 1962). "Some properties of rosette configurations of gravitating bodies in homographic equilibrium". Astronomical Journal . 67 (3): 162–167. Bibcode:1962AJ.....67..162K. doi: 10.1086/108686 .
  2. Lagrange, Joseph-Louis (1772). "Essai sur le Problème des Trois Corps" [Essay on the Three-Body Problem](PDF). Prix de l'Adadémie Royale des Sciences de Paris (in French). Paris, FR: Adadémie Royale des Sciences. IX. Archived from the original (PDF) on 22 December 2017.
  3. 1 2 Niven, Larry; Lerner, Edward (2007). Fleet of Worlds. New York: Tor Books. ISBN   978-0-7653-1825-1.
  4. 1 2 Jenkins, Bob. "Klemperer rosettes". burtleburtle.net. Physics. Retrieved 2007-01-12.