Lygdamus

Last updated

Lygdamus (probably a pseudonym) [1] was a Roman poet who wrote love poems in Classical Latin. Six of his elegies, addressed to a girl named Neaera, are preserved in the Appendix Tibulliana alongside the apocryphal works of Tibullus. In poem 5, line 6, he describes himself as young and in 5.18 gives his birth year as the year "when both consuls died by equal fate" (that is, 43 BC). [2] This line, however, is identical to one in Ovid's Tristia from AD 11, [3] and it has been much debated by scholars. One suggestion, supported by the numerous commonalities between Lygdamus and Ovid, is that "Lygdamus" is merely a pen name used by the young Ovid; [4] other scholars have suggested that Lygdamus was a separate poet from Ovid and was imitated by him; they assume that the line quoted above is an interpolation. Some more recent scholars have argued that Lygdamus lived much later than Ovid and imitated his style. [5] No other author mentions Lygdamus, making the mystery of his real identity all the more difficult. [6]

Contents

The name "Lygdamus" was a common slave-name in Rome, [7] and it has been conjectured that the author may have chosen this pen name to indicate that he is a "slave of love". [8] The name "Neaera" is common in Greek mythology and is also thought to be a pseudonym. [9]

Structure and metre

The six poems are of different lengths: 28, 30, 38, 96, 34, and 64 lines respectively. The lengths of the poems can be arranged as follows:

1 + 2 + 3 = 96 lines
4 = 96 lines
5 + 6 = 98 lines

Thus the 4th poem, as well as being the longest, is the centre of the series.

They are written in elegiac couplets, the usual metre for Latin love poetry from the time of Cornelius Gallus (d. 26 BC) onwards.

Metrically, the poems can be divided into two groups. Poems 1, 2, 3, and 6 are more dactylic: in these the proportion of dactylic feet (not counting the ending of each line, which doesn't vary) is 45%, [10] whereas in poems 4 and 5 it is only 37%. [11] [12] The reason for this is not known, unless it might be the rather sombre subject matter of these poems. [13]

Detailed metrical studies have shown that the Lygdamus poems were clearly written by a different poet than those of Tibullus. One of the more obvious differences is that in Lygdamus the caesura of the hexameter is almost always a masculine caesura in the 3rd foot, whereas in Tibullus it varies between the 3rd foot and the 4th. [14]

Neaera

Neaera is a very different kind of woman than Tibullus's Delia and Nemesis. The latter two are apparently courtesans, who keep their lovers waiting outside the door while they entertain other lovers inside. Both girls, especially Nemesis, demand expensive gifts.

Neaera is clearly not a courtesan. She comes from a cultured family (4.92) and the author knows her "very kind" mother and "most amiable" father (4.93–94). The author considers her to be his wife (2.30) and her mother to be his mother-in-law (2.14). The author prays not only to Venus but also to Juno, the goddess of marriage, to help him (3.33–34); similarly Neaera swears by both goddesses that she loves him (6.48). [15] She appears to have left him and he prays for her return (3.27). The awful news he hears in a dream from Apollo is that she is planning to marry someone else (4.58, 4.80). The opening couplet of poem 2 indicates that the two loved each other, but a third person caused them to separate. In the last poem the poet chides Neaera for her perjury (6.47–50) but declares that, though he is now over his passion for her, he wishes her well (6.29–30).

Though it is possible to take the view that the author was originally married to Neaera, other possibilities exist and have been adopted by various scholars. [16] One view is that they were merely lovers but that the author wished Neaera to eventually become his wife. Another hypothesis is that they were betrothed, but that Neaera broke off the engagement.

The poems

Poem 1

On 1st March, the festival of Matronalia , the poet asks the Muses to advise him what present he should give to Neaera. They advise him give her a book of poems, but it should be well presented in a yellow sleeve. He begs the Muses to go and give the book to his beloved Neaera, and says that he wishes to know whether in future he is to be her husband, as he once was, or merely her brother. [17]

Poem 2

The poet declares that he cannot bear living without his wife. [18] He imagines Neaera and her mother attending his funeral and pouring expensive perfume on his bones after cremation. He ends by imagining his epitaph: "Lygdamus lies here: grief and the love of Neaera, his wife, who was taken away from him, were the cause of his death."

Poem 3

Addressing Neaera, the poet asks what is the use of praying, even though he is not praying for wealth, but merely to spend his life until old age with Neaera. He prays to Juno and Venus to help him and says that if he can't have Neaera he would prefer to die. [19]

Poem 4

Lygdamus describes an awful dream he had the night before in which Apollo appeared to him and told him that Neaera prefers to be another man's girlfriend. [20] In the dream Apollo assures him that this is all part of the trials of love and she can still be won round if he entreats her. The poet tells Neaera he cannot believe she would be so heartless, especially as she was brought up in a respectable family with delightful parents.

Poem 5

The poet imagines his friends enjoying a holiday in a thermal spa in Etruria, [21] while he himself has been ill with a fever and close to death for two weeks. He begs Persephone, goddess of the dead, to spare him, since he has committed no sacrilege, crime, or blasphemy and is still young. He ends by asking his friends to remember him and to sacrifice some black sheep on his behalf to Dis, god of the Underworld. Neaera is not mentioned in this poem.

Poem 6

The poet calls on Liber (Bacchus), the god of wine, and orders his slave to pour wine and his friends to join him. [22] He declares he no longer loves Neaera, but wishes her to be happy. He warns his friends not to make his mistake of falling in love and states that though Neaera is unfaithful she is still dear to him. At the end of the poem, however, he asks the boy to pour more wine, refusing to spend any more nights sighing with anxiety.

Date and authorship

Apart from a mention of Catullus [23] (who died in the 50s BC), no historical person or event is mentioned in Lygdamus's poems, making them difficult to date except on literary grounds. Early commentators on the Lygdamus poems assumed that the author was Tibullus, the couplet mentioning the poet's birth in the year 43 BC being assumed to be an interpolation, not part of the original text. [24] J. H. Voss (1786) was the first to question the Tibullan authorship of the poems. Other scholars also noted metrical, stylistic, and linguistic differences between Lygdamus and the genuine poems of Tibullus, making it clear that Tibullus could not be the author. [25] [26] Voss, who took a poor view of the quality of the poems, suggested that they were written by a freedman born in the same year as Ovid.

Gruppe (1839), however, was the first to suggest that Lygdamus was a pseudonym for Ovid himself. This idea was taken up by Radford (1926) and others, who noted in detail the large number of words and phrases which are common to Lygdamus and Ovid but not found or rarely found in other authors. [27] [28] There are also features of style which are typical of Ovid but not of other poets; such as lines of the form "adjective, -que, noun, adjective, -que, noun", as in Castaliamque umbram Pieriosque lacus "the Castalian shade and the Pierian lakes", [29] or the placing of a monosyllable + -que (e.g. inque, isque) at the beginning of a pentameter. Another argument supporting this view is that the circumstances described in the poems seem to fit Ovid's biographical details very well, as described in his autobiographical poem Tristia 4.10 (he was born in 43 BC; the poet seems fairly wealthy; Neaera is described as his wife, whose parents he knows; Ovid states that his marriage to his second wife lasted only a short time before she married another man). The reasons for Ovid writing anonymously are plausibly explained by Radford by the fact that his father wished him to follow a career in politics and apparently repeatedly discouraged him from writing poetry. [30]

If the poems were written by Ovid, according to Radford, since they contain echoes of Horace's Odes and Ars Poetica as well as various parts of Virgil's Aeneid, it would seem that they date from 19 BC or 18 BC, when Ovid was about 24 or 25 years old. [31]

Despite the strength of these arguments, some more recent scholars have argued that Lygdamus was not Ovid, but someone who imitated him. A. G. Lee (1958) argued that in places where similar phrases occur in both Lygdamus and Ovid, in each case the phrase is more appropriate in the Ovidian context. He also noted certain items of vocabulary which are generally not found in the time of Tibullus, on the basis of which he conjectured that the date of Lygdamus may have been in the late 1st century AD. [32] Navarro Antolín (1996) and Maltby (2021) take a similar view.

A third possibility, that Lygdamus was an earlier poet who was imitated by Ovid, though held by some scholars, [33] is thought to be less probable. Peter White (2002) writes: "the coincidences between (Ovid and Lygdamus) make it much likelier that Lygdamus is either the youthful Ovid or a later writer impersonating the young Ovid." [34]

Editions

Related Research Articles

The elegiac couplet is a poetic form used by Greek lyric poets for a variety of themes usually of smaller scale than the epic. Roman poets, particularly Catullus, Propertius, Tibullus, and Ovid, adopted the same form in Latin many years later. As with the English heroic couplet, each pair of lines usually makes sense on its own, while forming part of a larger work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ovid</span> Roman poet (43 BC – AD 17/18)

Publius Ovidius Naso, known in English as Ovid, was a Roman poet who lived during the reign of Augustus. He was a younger contemporary of Virgil and Horace, with whom he is often ranked as one of the three canonical poets of Latin literature. The Imperial scholar Quintilian considered him the last of the Latin love elegists. Although Ovid enjoyed enormous popularity during his lifetime, the emperor Augustus exiled him to Tomis, the capital of the newly-organised province of Moesia, on the Black Sea, where he remained for the last nine or ten years of his life. Ovid himself attributed his banishment to a "poem and a mistake", but his reluctance to disclose specifics has resulted in much speculation among scholars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tibullus</span> Roman poet and writer of elegies (c. 55–c. 19 BC)

Albius Tibullus was a Latin poet and writer of elegies. His first and second books of poetry are extant; many other texts attributed to him are of questionable origins.

Marcus Valerius Messalla Corvinus was a Roman general, author, and patron of literature and art.

Sulpicia is believed to be the author, in the first century BCE, of six short poems written in Latin which were published as part of the corpus of Albius Tibullus's poetry. She is one of the few female poets of ancient Rome whose work survives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Propertius</span> 1st century BC Roman elegiac poet

Sextus Propertius was a Latin elegiac poet of the Augustan age. He was born around 50–45 BC in Assisium and died shortly after 15 BC.

Marcus Valerius Messalla Messallinus was a Roman senator who was elected consul for 3 BC.

<i>Tristia</i> Elegiac poetry collection by Ovid

The Tristia is a collection of letters written in elegiac couplets by the Augustan poet Ovid during his exile from Rome. Despite five books of his copious bewailing of his fate, the immediate cause of Augustus' banishment of the most acclaimed living Latin poet to Pontus in AD 8 remains a mystery. In addition to the Tristia, Ovid wrote another collection of elegiac epistles on his exile, the Epistulae ex Ponto. He spent several years in the outpost of Tomis and died without ever returning to Rome.

<i>Appendix Vergiliana</i> Collection of Poems written by Virgil.

The Appendix Vergiliana is a collection of Latin poems traditionally ascribed as being the juvenilia of Virgil.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cornelius Gallus</span> 1st century BC Roman poet, orator and politician

Gaius Cornelius Gallus was a Roman poet, orator, politician and military commander, at one time appointed by the Emperor Augustus as prefect of Egypt. Although only nine lines of his poetry are extant today, he was considered by Ovid as one of the major Latin poets of the 1st century BC.

<i>Amores</i> (Ovid) 16 BC Roman book by Ovid

Amores is Ovid's first completed book of poetry, written in elegiac couplets. It was first published in 16 BC in five books, but Ovid, by his own account, later edited it down into the three-book edition that survives today. The book follows the popular model of the erotic elegy, as made famous by figures such as Tibullus or Propertius, but is often subversive and humorous with these tropes, exaggerating common motifs and devices to the point of absurdity.

<i>Heroides</i> Epistolary poem collection by Ovid

The Heroides, or Epistulae Heroidum, is a collection of fifteen epistolary poems composed by Ovid in Latin elegiac couplets and presented as though written by a selection of aggrieved heroines of Greek and Roman mythology in address to their heroic lovers who have in some way mistreated, neglected, or abandoned them. A further set of six poems, widely known as the Double Heroides and numbered 16 to 21 in modern scholarly editions, follows these individual letters and presents three separate exchanges of paired epistles: one each from a heroic lover to his absent beloved and from the heroine in return.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aemilius Macer</span> Roman didactic poet

Aemilius Macer of Verona was a Roman didactic poet. He authored two poems, one on birds (Ornithogonia), a translation of a work by Boios, and the other on the antidotes against the poison of serpents (Theriaca), which he imitated from the Greek poet Nicander of Colophon. According to Jerome, he died in 16 BC. It is possible that he wrote also a botanical work. The extant hexameter poem known as Floridus or De viribus herbarum, traditionally ascribed to Macer, is actually a medieval production by Odo Magdunensis, a French physician.

Sabinus was a Latin poet and friend of Ovid. He is known only from two passages of Ovid's works.

<i>Double Heroides</i>

The Double Heroides are a set of six epistolary poems allegedly composed by Ovid in Latin elegiac couplets, following the fifteen poems of his Heroides, and numbered 16 to 21 in modern scholarly editions. These six poems present three separate exchanges of paired epistles: one each from a heroic lover from Greek or Roman mythology to his absent beloved, and one from the heroine in return. Ovid's authorship is uncertain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Exile of Ovid</span> Exile of Ovid from Rome to Tomis (now Romania) by emperor Augustus

Ovid, the Latin poet of the Roman Empire, was banished in 8 AD from Rome to Tomis by decree of the emperor Augustus. The reasons for his banishment are uncertain. Ovid's exile is related by the poet himself, and also in brief references to the event by Pliny the Elder and Statius. At the time, Tomis was a remote town on the edge of the civilized world; it was loosely under the authority of the Kingdom of Thrace, and was superficially Hellenized. According to Ovid, none of its citizens spoke Latin, which as an educated Roman, he found trying. Ovid wrote that the cause of his exile was carmen et error, probably the Ars Amatoria and a personal indiscretion or mistake. The council of the city of Rome revoked his exile in December 2017, some 2000 years after his banishment.

The Garland of Sulpicia, also sometimes known as the Sulpicia cycle or the Sulpicia-Cerinthus cycle, is a group of five Latin love poems written in elegiac couplets and included in volume 3 of the collected works of Tibullus. The five poems concern a love affair between a girl Sulpicia and a young man Cerinthus. They are followed in the collection by a further group of six short elegies ostensibly written by Sulpicia herself describing the same affair.

The Panegyricus Messallae, also known as the Laudes Messallae, is a 212-line Latin poem in dactylic hexameters included in the 3rd book of the Roman poet Tibullus's collected works. It is a panegyric or praise-poem apparently written to celebrate the installation to the consulship of Tibullus's patron the Roman aristocrat Marcus Valerius Messalla Corvinus in 31 BC. The poem is numbered 3.7 in the Tibullus collection. It follows the six elegiac poems of "Lygdamus" and is followed by the five elegiac poems known as the Garland of Sulpicia.

Tibullus book 1 is the first of two books of poems by the Roman poet Tibullus. It contains ten poems written in Latin elegiac couplets, and is thought to have been published about 27 or 26 BC.

Tibullus book 2 is a collection of six Latin poems written in elegiac couplets by the poet Albius Tibullus. They are thought to have been written in the years shortly before Tibullus's death in c. 19 BC.

References

  1. ↑ "Both names are almost certainly pseudonyms." Navarro Antolín (1996), p. 21.
  2. ↑ The consuls were Pansa and Hirtius who died at the Battle of Mutina in northern Italy. The phrase might also refer to 69 AD or even 83 BC: Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 4–5; 7; 17.
  3. ↑ Ovid, Tristia 4.10.6.
  4. ↑ Patricia Anne Watson, "Lygdamus", The Oxford Classical Dictionary, 4th ed. (Oxford University Press, 2012).
  5. ↑ This last group includes Lee (1958), Navarro Antolín (1996), and Maltby (2021).
  6. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), p. 6.
  7. ↑ cf. Propertius 3.6.2, 4.7.35.
  8. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), p. 21.
  9. ↑ The name "Neaera" first occurs in Homer's Odyssey 12.111, and it is also found in Virgil's Eclogue 3.1, Horace Epodes 15.11, Horace Odes 3.14.21, and Ovid's Amores 3.6.
  10. ↑ Though 45% is a high proportion, it is not as high as in Ovid's mature work, the Ars Amatoria, where it reaches 57%. See: Radford, R. S. (1920). "The Juvenile Works of Ovid and the Spondaic Period of His Metrical Art". Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association, Vol. 51 (1920), pp. 146–171; page 151.
  11. ↑ Radford, Robert S. (1920). "The Juvenile Works of Ovid and the Spondaic Period of His Metrical Art". Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association, Vol. 51, pp. 146–171; see p. 163.
  12. ↑ Cartault, A. (1911). Le distique élégiaque chez Tibulle, Sulpicia, Lygdamus. Journal des Savants, 9(2), 85–86; page 7.
  13. ↑ Radford, Robert S. (1920). "The Juvenile Works of Ovid and the Spondaic Period of His Metrical Art". Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association, Vol. 51, pp. 146–171; see p. 165.
  14. ↑ Cartault, A. (1911). Le distique élégiaque chez Tibulle, Sulpicia, Lygdamus. Journal des Savants, 9(2), 85–86; pages 312–313.
  15. ↑ Navarro Antolín, p. 22.
  16. ↑ Navarro Antolín, pp. 22–24.
  17. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 93–96.
  18. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 147–8.
  19. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 193–4.
  20. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 258–260.
  21. ↑ There were several spas. The Aquae Caeretanae in Caere, on the coast near Rome, was a popular spa in the Augustan period: Navarro Antolín (1996), p. 413.
  22. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 459–464.
  23. ↑ Lygdamus 6.41.
  24. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), pp. 4–5.
  25. ↑ Navarro Antolín (1996), p. 6.
  26. ↑ Cartault, A. (1911). Le distique élégiaque chez Tibulle, Sulpicia, Lygdamus. Journal des Savants, 9(2), 85–86; pages 312–313.
  27. ↑ Radford, R. S. (1926). "The Ovidian Authorship of the Lygdamus Elegies". In Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association (Vol. 57, pp. 149–180). (A shorter revised version is in: Radford, R. S. (1927). "The Ovidian Authorship of the Lygdamus Elegies". Classical Philology, 22(4), 356-371.)
  28. ↑ Baligan, G. & Paratore, E. (1950). "Ancora su Ligdamo". Aevum, 24 (Fasc. 3), 270–299; p. 282.
  29. ↑ Lyg. 1.16; cf. 3.16, 5.24.
  30. ↑ Tristia 4.10.21–2.
  31. ↑ Radford (1926), p. 155–6.
  32. ↑ Lee, A. G. (1958, January). "The Date of Lygdamus, and his Relationship to Ovid". In Proceedings of the Cambridge Philological Society (No. 5 (185), pp. 15–22).
  33. ↑ Somerville, T. (2020), "The Problem of Lygdamus and Ovid Reconsidered", Hermes 148(2): 173–197.
  34. ↑ Peter White in: Boyd, B. W. (Ed.). (2002). Brill's Companion to Ovid; page 7.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.