Moderating power (Empire of Brazil)

Last updated
Illustration showing emperor Pedro II holding the balance between the Liberal and Conservative parties while pointing to the Fortress of Humaita; Henrique Fleiuss, 1865 Emperor pedro II the moderating power.jpg
Illustration showing emperor Pedro II holding the balance between the Liberal and Conservative parties while pointing to the Fortress of Humaitá; Henrique Fleiuss, 1865

The Moderating power (Portuguese : Poder moderador) in the Empire of Brazil was the fourth state branch instituted by the 1824 Brazilian Constitution alongside the Executive, Legislative and Judiciary. It was the most innovative and original item conceived by the 1824 Constitution.

Contents

This fourth branch, exclusively exercised by the emperor, served as a "mechanism for absorbing the attrition between the legislative and executive branches" [1] and in its role as "keeper of the balance", it granted emperor Pedro II throughout his reign "that situation of primacy which he exercised with so much pleasure and peace". [2]

When analyzing the Moderating Power and the parliamentary government, Tobias Barreto explained the reason for the adoption of both by arguing that: [3]

"[The] institutions that are not a product of customs, but rather a product of reason, do not withstand the test of experience for a long time and soon break up against the facts".

Galvão Sousa argued that, thanks to the Moderating Power, Brazil was able to "open a valve through which it could escape parliamentary anarchy". [4] According to historian João Camilo Torres, the reason for the existence of the Moderating Power was due to the fact that "the monarch, due to dynastic continuity, not being part of groups, classes, nor having regional connections, owing his power to parties or economic groups, having electoral promises to keep, not needing to 'think ahead' – as the future of his family will be guaranteed if peace and national grandeur are preserved – since he is not subject to the temptation to avail himself of a quick passage through his government to take personal benefits and advantages at the expense of the nation, leaving the burden to his successors", as his "successor is his own son, and History often charges grandchildren with crimes committed by their grandparents". [5]

Prerogatives

Article 99 of the 1824 Brazilian Constitution declared that "the person of the Emperor is inviolable and sacred; he is not subject to any responsibility". [6] Such declaration was not a unique feature of the Brazilian constitutional regime in the 19th century and still exists in several parliamentary monarchies. [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]

The powers reserved for the Moderating Power should be exercised only after the Council of State had been consulted. Such prerogatives, which were listed in Article 101, were identical, for the most part, to the attributions reserved for current monarchs, such as:

  1. Convene the General Assembly (Parliament) extraordinarily between sessions; [12]
  2. Enact the decrees and resolutions of the General Assembly, so that they have the force of law; [13]
  3. Prolong or postpone the General Assembly and dissolve the Chamber of Deputies, calling another immediately to replace the previous one; [14]
  4. Freely appoint and dismiss Ministers of State; [15]
  5. Pardon and moderate sentences imposed on defendants and grant amnesty. [16]

The other prerogatives were: to suspend magistrates for complaints against their persons, but only after holding a hearing with them, collecting all pertinent information and listening to the Council of State; approving or suspending the resolutions of Provincial Councils (as the State Chambers of Deputies were called) and nominating senators through a list of the three candidates with the most popular votes. [6]

According to Paulo Bonavides, the Moderating Power "can only be estimated in the incomparable consequences it had for the consolidation of national unity and for the stability of the Empire's political system", [17] in a "continent politically plagued by civil hatred and pulverized into weak and rival republics". [18] For Galvão Sousa, the Moderating Power under Pedro II, "gave rise to the famous 'dictatorship of honesty'. It soon became the personal power of the monarch, always exercised with a high public spirit". [19]

Related Research Articles

A head of state is the public persona of a sovereign state. The specific naming of the head of state depends on the country's form of government and separation of powers; the head of state may be a ceremonial figurehead or concurrently the head of government and more.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Politics of Portugal</span> Political system of Portugal

Politics in Portugal operates as a unitary multi-party semi-presidential representative democratic republic, whereby the Prime Minister of Portugal is the head of government, and the President of Portugal is the non-executive head of state with several significant political powers they exercise often. Executive power is exercised by the Government, whose leader is the prime minister. Legislative power is primarily vested in the Assembly of the Republic, although the government is also able to legislate on certain matters. The Judiciary of Portugal is independent of the executive and the legislature. The President exerts a sort of "moderating power", not easily classified into any of the traditional three branches of government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pedro I of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil (1822–31) and King of Portugal (1826)

DomPedro I was the founder and first ruler of the Empire of Brazil, where he was known as "the Liberator". As King Dom Pedro IV, he reigned briefly over Portugal, where he also became known as "the Liberator" as well as "the Soldier King". Born in Lisbon, Pedro I was the fourth child of King Dom John VI of Portugal and Queen Carlota Joaquina, and thus a member of the House of Braganza. When the country was invaded by French troops in 1807, he and his family fled to Portugal's largest and wealthiest colony, Brazil.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Liberal Wars</span> Civil war in the Kingdom of Portugal (1828–1834)

The Liberal Wars, also known as the War of the Two Brothers, was a war between liberal constitutionalists and conservative traditionalists in Portugal over royal succession that lasted from 1832 to 1834. Embroiled parties included the Kingdom of Portugal, Portuguese rebels, the United Kingdom, France, the Catholic Church, and Spain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Commander-in-chief</span> Supreme commanding authority of a military

A commander-in-chief or supreme commander is the person who exercises supreme command and control over an armed force or a military branch. As a technical term, it refers to military competencies that reside in a country's executive leadership, a head of state, head of government, or other designated government official.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">President of Malta</span> Head of State of Malta

The president of Malta is the constitutional head of state of Malta. The president is indirectly elected by the House of Representatives of Malta, which appoints the president for a five-year term and requires them to swear an oath to "preserve, protect and defend" the Constitution. The president of Malta also resides directly or indirectly in all three branches of the state. They are part of Parliament and responsible for the appointment of the judiciary. Executive authority is nominally vested in the president, but is in practice exercised by the prime minister.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">President of Portugal</span> Head of state of the Portuguese Republic

The president of Portugal, officially the president of the Portuguese Republic, is the head of state and highest office of Portugal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Assembly of Pakistan</span> Lower house of the Parliament of Pakistan

The National Assembly of Pakistan is the lower house of the bicameral Parliament of Pakistan, with the upper house being the Senate. As of 2023, the National Assembly has a maximum membership of 336, of which 266 are directly elected by an adult universal suffrage and a first-past-the-post system to represent their respective constituencies, while 70 are elected on reserved seats for women and religious minorities from all over the country. Members hold their seats for five years or until the house is dissolved by the President on the advice of the Prime Minister. The house convenes at the Parliament House, Red Zone, Islamabad.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Politics of the Empire of Brazil</span>

Politics of the Empire of Brazil took place in a framework of a quasi-federal parliamentary representative democratic monarchy, whereby the Emperor of Brazil was the head of state and nominally head of government although the Prime Minister, called President of the Council of Ministers, was effectively the de facto head of government, and of a multi-party system. Executive power was exercised by the government. Legislative power was vested in both the government and the two chambers of the General Assembly. The Judiciary was independent of the Executive and the Legislative. There was also a fourth power, the Moderating power, exercised by the emperor. The Empire of Brazil was divided into 20 provinces and the Neutral Municipality, capital of the country.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marcos Pontes</span> Brazilian astronaut and senator (born 1963)

Marcos Cesar Pontes is a Brazilian Air Force pilot, engineer, AEB astronaut, politician and author. He became the first South American and the first Lusophone to go into space when he docked onto the International Space Station aboard Soyuz TMA-8 on March 30, 2006. He is the only Brazilian to have completed the NASA astronaut training program, although he switched to training in Russia after NASA's Space Shuttle program encountered problems. After Jair Bolsonaro's election as President of Brazil in 2018, Pontes was officially nominated to be Minister of Science, Technology and Innovation, a post which he accepted days later and assumed when Bolsonaro's government began. He left the post on 31 March 2022 and in the same year was elected federal senator for his state, São Paulo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constitution of Belgium</span> Fundamental law of Belgium, most recently revised in 1993

The Constitution of Belgium dates back to 1831. Since then Belgium has been a parliamentary monarchy that applies the principles of ministerial responsibility for the government policy and the Trias Politica.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constitution of Uzbekistan</span>

The Constitution of Uzbekistan was adopted on 8 December 1992 on the 11th session of the Supreme Council of Uzbekistan. It replaced the Constitution of the Republic of Uzbekistan of 1978. It is the supreme law of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The Constitution of Uzbekistan contains six parts and it is further divided into 26 chapters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brazilian Constitution of 1824</span> Brazils first constitution

The Political Constitution of the Empire of Brazil commonly referred to as the Constitution of 1824, was Brazil's first constitution, issued on 25 March 1824 and revoked on 24 February 1891. In force during the period of the Empire of Brazil, it was issued at the emperor's request, that is, unilaterally imposed by the will of emperor Pedro I, who had ordered it from the Council of State. Pedro had dissolved the Constituent Assembly in 1823 and, through the Constitution of 1824, imposed his own political project on the country. The same Pedro later issued, in Portugal, the Constitutional Charter of 29 April 1826, inspired by the Brazilian model.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brazilian Constitution of 1937</span> Brazilian statute between 1937-1946

The Brazilian Constitution of 1937, promulgated by President Getúlio Vargas on November 10, 1937, was Brazil's fourth constitution and the third of the republican period. It was instituted on the same day as the installation of the Estado Novo, Vargas' dictatorial regime, and aimed to legitimize his powers. The text was inspired by the sanationist structure of the April Constitution of Poland, which was extremely centralizing and granted unlimited powers to the President. It was drafted by the jurist Francisco Campos, Minister of Justice, and obtained the prior approval of Vargas and General Eurico Gaspar Dutra, Minister of War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bernardo Pereira de Vasconcelos</span>

Bernardo Pereira de Vasconcelos was a Brazilian politician, journalist, judge and law expert of the Imperial era.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diretório Monárquico do Brasil</span> Monarchical institution

Diretório Monárquico do Brasil was a monarchical institution established in Rio de Janeiro in 1890, one year after the proclamation of the republic, by Afonso Celso de Assis Figueirado, The Viscount of Ouro Preto, the last Prime Minister of the Empire of Brazil, entrusted by the former Princess Regent Isabel, to whom they considered Empress of Brazil after the death of her father Pedro II, in 1891, to organize the actions of Brazilian monarchists. The organization was constituted as an unofficial representation of the deposed heiress to the throne of Brazil and also functioned as a council.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Portuguese Constitution of 1822</span>

The Portuguese Constitution of 1822 approved on 23 September 1822 was the first Portuguese constitution, marking an attempt to end absolutism and introduce a constitutional monarchy. Although it was actually in force only for two brief periods, 1822–23 and 1836–38, it was fundamental to the history of democracy in Portugal. It was replaced by the Constitutional Charter of 1826.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Regency period (Empire of Brazil)</span> Period in Brazilian history

The regency period is how the decade from 1831 to 1840 became known in the history of the Empire of Brazil, between the abdication of Emperor Pedro I, on 7 April 1831, and the declaration of age of Pedro II, who was legally declared of age by the Senate at the age of 14 on 23 July 1840.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First reign (Empire of Brazil)</span> Historical period of Brazil (1822–1831)

The First Reign was the period of Brazilian history in which Pedro I ruled Brazil as Emperor. It began on September 7, 1822, when Brazil's independence was proclaimed, and ended on April 7, 1831, when Pedro I abdicated the Brazilian throne.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reverse parliamentarism</span> Brazilian Empire political system, 1840–1889

Reverse parliamentarism was the political system in force in the Brazilian Empire during the Second Reign. This system consisted of the Conservative and Liberal parties alternating at the head of the executive branch, based on the choice of the Moderator.

References

Citations

  1. Faoro 2001, pp. 343–344.
  2. Sodré 2004, p. 91.
  3. Sousa 1962, p. 126.
  4. Sousa 1962, p. 125.
  5. Torres 2017, pp. 105–106.
  6. 1 2 "Constituição Politica do Imperio do Brazil" . Retrieved 18 April 2022.
  7. "The Constitution of the Kingdom of Norway" . Retrieved 18 April 2022. The King's person cannot be censured or accused. The responsibility rests with his Council.
  8. "Luxembourg 1868 (rev. 2009)". Constitute. Retrieved 18 April 2022. The person of the grand Duke is inviolable.
  9. "Netherlands 1814 (rev. 2008)". Constitute. Retrieved 18 April 2022. The Ministers, and not the King, shall be responsible for acts of government.
  10. "Denmark's Constitution of 1953" (PDF). Constitute. Retrieved 18 April 2022. The King shall not be answerable for his actions; his person shall be sacrosanct. The Ministers shall be responsible for the conduct of the government; their responsibility shall be determined by Statute.
  11. "The Spanish Constitution" (PDF). Agencia Estatal Boletín Oficial del Estado. Retrieved 18 April 2022. The person of the King is inviolable and shall not be held accountable. His acts shall always be countersigned in the manner established in Article 64. Without such countersignature they shall not be valid, except as provided under Article 65,2.
  12. "The Spanish Constitution" (PDF). Agencia Estatal Boletín Oficial del Estado. Retrieved 18 April 2022. It is incumbent upon the King: to summon and dissolve the Cortes Generales and to call elections under the terms provided in the Constitution
  13. "The Constitution of the Kingdom of Norway" . Retrieved 18 April 2022. If the King assents to the Bill, he appends his signature, whereby it becomes law.
  14. "Netherlands 1814 (rev. 2008)". Constitute. Retrieved 18 April 2022. 1. Each of the Houses may be dissolved by Royal Decree. 2. A decree for dissolution shall also require new elections to be held for the House which has been dissolved and the newly elected House to meet within three months.
  15. "Denmark's Constitution of 1953" (PDF). Constitute. Retrieved 18 April 2022. The King shall appoint and dismiss the Prime Minister and the other Ministers. He shall decide upon the number of Ministers and upon the distribution of the duties of government among them. The signature of the King to resolutions relating to legislation and government shall make such resolutions valid, provided that the signature of the King is accompanied by the signature or signatures of one or more Ministers. A Minister who has signed a resolution shall be responsible for the resolution.
  16. "Luxembourg 1868 (rev. 2009)". Constitute. Retrieved 18 April 2022. The Grand Duke has the right to remit or reduce the penalties pronounced by the judges, save that which is established concerning the members of the Government.
  17. Bonavides 1978, p. 233.
  18. Bonavides 2002, p. 145.
  19. Sousa 1962, p. 127.

Bibliography