Proximity of blood

Last updated May 26, 2024

Proximity of blood, or proximity by degree of kinship, is one of the ways to determine hereditary succession based on genealogy. In effect, the application of this rule is a refusal to recognize the right of representation, a component of primogeniture.^[1]

In some feudal entities, proximity of blood was a generally accepted principle. For example, according to the "ancient custom" (French : ancienne coutume) in the Duchy of Burgundy, a grandson could not take precedence over a son or daughter, and it was not even clear whether the ruler's grandson could claim precedence over the ruler's brother.^[2]

Examples

Proximity of blood and primogeniture were at loggerheads in numerous medieval succession disputes.

Successful applications

When Richard the Lionheart died in 1199, the succession to the English throne, as well as to Normandy and Anjou, was disputed between his fourth but sole surviving brother, John, and his nephew Arthur (the son of his second brother, Geoffrey). The Angevin law favored primogeniture and thus Arthur, while the Norman law recognized the proximity of blood and gave precedence to John. Arthur's claim had been recognized by Richard in 1191, but just before his death Richard expressed support for John, who in the end prevailed.^[3]

Alfonso X of Castile wished to enforce primogeniture by the Siete Partidas in the late 1270s and bequeath his crown to Alfonso, the son of his deceased eldest son, Ferdinand. His second but eldest surviving son, Sancho, rebelled with the support of the nobility and successfully claimed the crown by degree of kinship.^[4]

In 1307, a dispute erupted over the County of Artois between Mahaut, who had succeeded her father, Robert II, in 1302, and Mahaut's nephew, Robert. Robert II had outlived his son, Philip, and Mahaut put herself forward as "the closest relative to our said father at the time of his death, the reason of propinquity or proximity being notorious in custom". Her nephew, Philip's son, insisted on "representation of our aforesaid father who was the first born of our same grandfather". His appeal was rejected in 1309 on the basis that the established custom of Artois favored Mahaut, but he never relinquished his claim.^[5]

Odo IV, Duke of Burgundy, having outlived his son Philip, decreed in his will in 1348 that he should be succeeded by his grandson, also named Philip, unless Odo fathered another son. Odo's grandson, however, should have precedence over any daughters Odo might have and over Odo's sisters. In case of Philip's death without issue, the duchy was to pass to Odo's youngest but sole surviving sister, Joan, rather than to the descendants of his deceased older sisters.^[2] Odo IV had no further sons and was succeeded by his grandson, Philip I. Philip died childless in 1361, having outlived his grandfather's last sibling, Joan. The duchy would have gone to Charles II of Navarre, grandson of Odo's older sister Margaret, according to primogeniture, but was successfully claimed by John II of France, son of the younger sister Joan, according to proximity of blood. Since Charles was the grandson of a sister of Odo and John was the son of another, the latter was one degree closer to the dukes of Burgundy than Charles.^[2]

During the reign of Charles XII of Sweden, it was never resolved whether his heir should be his younger sister, Ulrika Eleonora, or his nephew, Charles Frederick (the son of his deceased elder sister, Hedwig Sophia).^[6] The sister was more closely related to the reigning king, but the nephew had precedence according to primogeniture.^[7] Upon Charles XII's death in 1718 it was Ulrika Eleonora who successfully claimed the crown.^[8]

Unsuccessful applications

In 1269, upon the death of Conrad III of Jerusalem, Maria of Antioch and Hugh III of Cyprus both claimed the crown. She was the daughter of Melisende, fifth daughter of Isabella I of Jerusalem, while he was the grandson of Alice, second daughter of Isabella I. Maria was the only living grandchild of Isabella I and closer in kinship to Conrad III (first cousin twice removed) and the other kings of Jerusalem, while Hugh had precedence by primogeniture but was more distantly related to Conrad III (second cousin) and Isabella I (great-grandchild). The High Court decided in favour of Hugh but Maria did not relinquish her claim.^[9]

Alexander III of Scotland drafted a treaty in 1281 in which he set out the rules of succession among his descendants. The provisions appeared to favor primogeniture for male heirs but proximity of blood for female heirs; the son of a deceased older son would take precedence over a surviving younger son but a younger daughter over a deceased older daughter's children.^[10] Upon the death of his granddaughter and successor, Margaret, in 1290, the succession was unclear. Robert de Brus claimed the crown by proximity in degree of kinship to the kings of Scotland,^[11] while John Balliol made a claim based on primogeniture.^[1] Robert and John were both descended from David of Huntingdon (grandson of David I of Scotland); Robert was a grandson (son of Isobel, second daughter of David of Huntingdon) while John was a great-grandson (grandson of Margaret, first daughter of David of Huntingdon).^[1] Arbitration by Edward I of England awarded the throne to John, but Robert's grandson later successfully claimed the crown as Robert I of Scotland.^[11]

Related Research Articles

The Capetian house of Valois was a cadet branch of the Capetian dynasty. They succeeded the House of Capet to the French throne, and were the royal house of France from 1328 to 1589. Junior members of the family founded cadet branches in Orléans, Anjou, Burgundy, and Alençon.

The Salic law, also called the Salian law, was the ancient Frankish civil law code compiled around AD 500 by the first Frankish King, Clovis. The written text is in Latin and contains some of the earliest known instances of Old Dutch. It remained the basis of Frankish law throughout the early Medieval period, and influenced future European legal systems. The best-known tenet of the old law is the principle of exclusion of women from inheritance of thrones, fiefs, and other property. The Salic laws were arbitrated by a committee appointed and empowered by the King of the Franks. Dozens of manuscripts dating from the sixth to eighth centuries and three emendations as late as the ninth century have survived.

Philip V, known as the Tall, was King of France and Navarre from 1316 to 1322. Philip engaged in a series of domestic reforms intended to improve the management of the kingdom. These reforms included the creation of an independent Court of Finances, the standardization of weights and measures, and the establishment of a single currency.

Primogeniture is the right, by law or custom, of the firstborn legitimate child to inherit the parent's entire or main estate in preference to shared inheritance among all or some children, any illegitimate child or any collateral relative. In most contexts, it means the inheritance of the firstborn son ; it can also mean by the firstborn daughter, or firstborn child.

An heir apparent or simply heir is a person who is first in an order of succession and cannot be displaced from inheriting by the birth of another person. A person who is first in the current order of succession but could be displaced by the birth of a more eligible heir is known as heir presumptive.

Duke of Burgundy was a title used by the rulers of the Duchy of Burgundy, from its establishment in 843 to its annexation by the French crown in 1477, and later by members of the House of Habsburg, including Holy Roman Emperors and kings of Spain, who claimed Burgundy proper and ruled the Burgundian Netherlands.

The Free County of Burgundy was a medieval feudal state ruled by a count from 982 to 1678. It was also known as Franche-Comté, from French: franc comte meaning 'free count', and was located in the modern region of Franche-Comté. It bordered the Duchy of Burgundy to the west, which was part of France from 843.

The Duchy of Burgundy emerged in the 9th century as one of the successors of the ancient Kingdom of the Burgundians, which after its conquest in 532 had formed a constituent part of the Frankish Empire. Upon the 9th-century partitions, the French remnants of the Burgundian kingdom were reduced to a ducal rank by King Robert II of France in 1004. Robert II's son and heir, King Henry I of France, inherited the duchy but ceded it to his younger brother Robert in 1032.

Margaret of Burgundy was Queen of France and Navarre as the first wife of King Louis X; however, she was locked in prison during her whole French queenship.

The County of Auxerre was a county in current central France, with its capital in Auxerre. It was commonly associated with the Duchy of Burgundy.

When the crown of Scotland became vacant in September 1290 on the death of the seven-year-old Queen Margaret, 13 claimants to the throne came forward. Those with the most credible claims were John Balliol; Robert de Brus, 5th Lord of Annandale; John Hastings and Floris V, Count of Holland.

<i>The Accursed Kings</i> Series of historical novels by French author Maurice Druon

The Accursed Kings is a series of historical novels by French author Maurice Druon about the French monarchy in the 14th century. Published between 1955 and 1977, the series has been adapted as a miniseries twice for television in France.

The County of Artois was a historic province of the Kingdom of France, held by the Dukes of Burgundy from 1384 until 1477/82, and a state of the Holy Roman Empire from 1493 until 1659.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mahaut, Countess of Artois</span> Countess of Artois

Mahaut of Artois also known as Mathilda, ruled as Countess of Artois from 1302 to 1329. She was furthermore regent of the County of Burgundy from 1303 to 1315 during the minority and the absence of her daughter, Joan II, Countess of Burgundy.

An order, line or right of succession is the line of individuals necessitated to hold a high office when it becomes vacated, such as head of state or an honour such as a title of nobility. This sequence may be regulated through descent or by statute.

Joan of Burgundy, also known as Joan the Lame, was Queen of France as the first wife of King Philip VI. Joan ruled as regent while her husband fought on military campaigns during the Hundred Years' War during the years 1340, 1345–1346 and 1347. Her son John succeeded as king in 1350. She is the matriarch of the House of Valois, which ruled France from the beginning of her husband's reign in 1328 until 1589.

Yolande II or Yolande of Nevers, was ruling Countess of Nevers between 1262 and 1280.

Louis XIV (1638–1715), the Bourbon monarch of the Kingdom of France, was the son of King Louis XIII of France and Queen Anne.

Succession to the French throne covers the mechanism by which the French crown passed from the establishment of the Frankish Kingdom in 486 to the fall of the Second French Empire in 1870.

References

1 2 3 Kidd 2014, p. 88.
1 2 3 Chattaway 2006, p. 92.
↑ Barlow 1999, p. 305.
↑ Previté-Orton 1975, p. 831.
↑ Wood 1966, p. 60.
↑ Hatton 1968, p. 132, 393.
↑ Hatton 1968, p. 371.
↑ Hatton 1968.
↑ Runciman 1987, p. 328-329.
↑ Duncan 2002, p. 166-169.
1 2 Stevenson 2014.

Sources

Barlow, Frank (1999). The Feudal Kingdom of England, 1042–1216. Pearson Education. ISBN 0-582-38117-7.
Chattaway, Carol Mary (2006). The Order of the Golden Tree: the gift-giving objectives of Duke Philip the Bold of Burgundy. Brepols. ISBN 2503522971.
Duncan, Archibald Alexander McBeth (2002). The Kingship of the Scots 842–1292: Succession and Independence. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 0-7486-1626-8.
Hatton, Ragnhild Marie (1968). Charles XII of Sweden. Weybright and Talley.
Kidd, Colin (2003). Subverting Scotland's Past: Scottish Whig Historians and the Creation of an Anglo-British Identity 1689-1830. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0521520193.
Previté-Orton, C. W. (1975). Cambridge Medieval History, Shorter . Vol. 2. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0521099773.
Runciman, Steven (1987). A History of the Crusades. Vol. 3. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0521347726.
Stevenson, Katie (2014). Power and Propaganda: Scotland 1306-1488. Edinburg University Press. ISBN 978-0748694204.
Wood, Charles T. (1966). The French apanages and the Capetian monarchy, 1224-1328 . Harvard University Press.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[FOOTNOTEKidd201488-1] 1 2 3 Kidd 2014, p. 88.

[FOOTNOTEChattaway200692-2] 1 2 3 Chattaway 2006, p. 92.

[FOOTNOTEBarlow1999305-3] Barlow 1999, p. 305.

[FOOTNOTEPrevité-Orton1975831-4] Previté-Orton 1975, p. 831.

[FOOTNOTEWood196660-5] Wood 1966, p. 60.

[FOOTNOTEHatton1968132,_393-6] Hatton 1968, p. 132, 393.

[FOOTNOTEHatton1968371-7] Hatton 1968, p. 371.

[FOOTNOTEHatton1968-8] Hatton 1968.

[FOOTNOTERunciman1987328-329-9] Runciman 1987, p. 328-329.

[FOOTNOTEDuncan2002166-169-10] Duncan 2002, p. 166-169.

[FOOTNOTEStevenson2014-11] 1 2 Stevenson 2014.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]