1st Michigan Legislature

1st Michigan Legislature
← 6th Michigan Territorial Council 2nd Michigan Legislature →
The State Capitol in Detroit, which later housed a school
Overview
Legislative body	Michigan Legislature
Jurisdiction	Michigan, United States
Meeting place	Michigan State Capitol, Detroit
Term	November 2, 1835 (1835-11-02) – January 2, 1837 (1837-01-02)
Website	www.legislature.mi.gov
Michigan Senate
Members	16 Senators
President	Edward Mundy
President pro tempore	John S. Barry
Michigan House of Representatives
Members	50 Representatives
Speaker	Ezra Convis
Sessions
1st November 2, 1835 – November 14, 1835 2nd February 1, 1836 – March 28, 1836 3rd July 11, 1836 – July 26, 1836

The 1st Michigan Legislature, consisting of the Michigan Senate and the Michigan House of Representatives, met in Detroit in three sessions between November 2, 1835, and July 26, 1836, during the first year of Stevens T. Mason's governorship of the (prospective) state.

The legislature met with the expectation that Michigan would be granted statehood during this time, but this was delayed until January 1837. During the first part of the 1st Legislature's term, there were two parallel governments in the portion of Michigan Territory that was covered by the newly drafted state constitution.

Background

The people of the Territory of Michigan voted on October 1, 1832, to seek admission to the United States. ^[1] A census in 1834 verified that the territory had 87,273 white inhabitants, ^[2] well above the requirement for statehood of 60,000 defined by the Northwest Ordinance. In previous such instances, the U.S. Congress normally passed an enabling act calling on the residents of a prospective state to draft a constitution. But Michigan was embroiled in a territorial dispute with Ohio that Congress had not been able to resolve, and no such act was passed, so Michigan moved forward without one. ^[3]

Another election was held on April 4, 1835, to elect delegates to a convention to draft a constitution. The convention began meeting in Detroit that May, and voters approved the new constitution in a statewide election held on October 5, 1835. ^[1]

Opposition to statehood in Congress

In Congress, opposition to Michigan's application for statehood centered around several objections, two of which Congress resolved for itself. One was that Congress had never passed an enabling act for Michigan as it had with previous states; this objection was overcome on the basis that the U.S. Constitution did not require such an act, which had simply been the conventional approach for Congress to use. Another was that the new state constitution allowed aliens to vote, which led to concerns that this was tantamount to conferring U.S. citizenship; this objection was also overcome, since states were allowed to set their own qualifications for voting, even for federal elections, and this was separate from the notion of citizenship. ^[4]

The Toledo War, the dispute over a ten-mile-wide strip of land along the Michigan–Ohio border, continued to occupy both Congress and the Legislature throughout the term of the 1st Legislature. ^[1] Some southern senators also employed delaying tactics in order to ensure that Arkansas's application for statehood would be ready in time for it to be admitted simultaneously with Michigan, preserving the tradition of admitting free states and slave states in pairs in order to maintain the balance of the U.S. Senate. ^[5] A bill formally offering Michigan and Arkansas admission to the union was not passed and signed into law until late in the legislature's term, on June 15, 1836. ^[2]

Election and parallel governments

Voters elected a governor, a lieutenant governor, a U.S. congressman, and members of the state legislature in the same October 5, 1835, election which asked them to approve the new constitution; all of these elections were contingent on the constitution itself being approved, which it was. ^[1] Most of the elected officials were Democrats, as the Whigs generally either didn't want to pursue statehood or thought the constitution itself was a sham since Congress had not passed an enabling act; the Whigs did not nominate a candidate for governor. ^[6]

The newly elected government was not officially recognized by the federal government, which still maintained a separate territorial government. President Andrew Jackson had installed John S. Horner as acting governor on September 15, 1835, after removing Mason from the position. The existence of the two parallel governments, one under Horner and one under Mason, continued for several months, until the federal government gave up since the people of Michigan clearly thought of the new government under Mason as their legitimate representatives. ^[7] Having been mostly ignored in Michigan, Horner left to become secretary of the Wisconsin Territory when Congress organized a territorial government there on April 20, 1836, and no replacement was appointed. ^[8]

Sessions

The constitution made Detroit the state capital until 1847, when the legislature was due to choose a new location; ^[9] at that time they moved the capital to Lansing. ^[1] The 1st Legislature met in Detroit ^[10] in three sessions. Much of the business before the legislature in these sessions involved Michigan's pending application for statehood.

The first session ran from November 2, 1835, to November 14, 1835. ^[11] Along with certifying the election of Governor Mason and Lieutenant Governor Mundy and performing other organizational tasks, the legislature elected Michigan's first two U.S. senators. Each chamber nominated two people; Lucius Lyon was nominated by both chambers for one position, while John Norvell was nominated by the House and John Biddle by the Senate for the other. Norvell won a joint vote, 35 to 28, and so was elected alongside Lyon. ^[12] The legislature adjourned with the expectation that statehood would be quickly forthcoming. ^[1] Since Michigan was not yet a state, the U.S. Senate admitted Lyon and Norvell to its chamber as "spectators" at the urging of Thomas Hart Benton and over the opposition of Henry Clay. ^[3]

The second session, held despite the continued delay in statehood, ran from February 1, 1836, to March 28, 1836. ^[13] The legislature elected Henry Howard as the state's first treasurer, in place of Levi Cook, who had declined the position. ^[14]

Extra session and the Conventions of Assent

The June 15, 1836, bill passed by Congress made Michigan's admittance conditional upon a popular convention approving the exchange of the disputed Ohio territory for the western three-quarters of the Upper Peninsula. ^[15] Governor Stevens T. Mason called an extra session of the legislature, which ran from July 11, 1836, to July 26, 1836, ^[16] in order to make provisions for the election of delegates to such a convention. ^[2] Democrats generally supported the compromise, seeing no value in antagonizing Congress and continuing to delay statehood and the financial benefits it would bring, while the Whigs felt Congress had no right to assist in the perceived theft of land from Michigan and wanted to press the case in the Supreme Court. ^[17]

The Convention of Assent met in Ann Arbor on September 26 and, after deliberating for four days, rejected the compromise proposed by Congress. Supporters of the compromise called upon Mason to organize a second convention, which he refused to do, but he did declare that the people could do so themselves. The Democrats of Washtenaw County and Wayne County called for another convention, and this "Frostbitten Convention" was held beginning December 14 in Ann Arbor. The Whigs and several counties boycotted, and the compromise was overwhelmingly approved. ^[18] Scholars have held that the second convention lacked any legal basis and that Mason overstepped his authority by suggesting the people hold a convention without any legislative or congressional consent, but it provided sufficient basis for Congress to finally grant Michigan's statehood on January 26, 1837. ^[19]

Leadership and organization

Lieutenant Governor Edward Mundy was ex officio President of the Senate, as prescribed by the state constitution. ^[20] The senate appointed John S. Barry President of the Senate pro tempore ; ^[21] John J. Adam was chosen as the secretary, Silas D. McKeen as the enrolling and engrossing clerk, Edward A. King as the recording clerk, George W. Dexter as the sergeant-at-arms, and Diodate Hubbard as the doorkeeper. ^[22]

The House elected Ezra Convis as Speaker, George R. Griswold as the clerk, Egbert Van Buren as the enrolling clerk, Lewis Bond as the sergeant-at-arms, William Terry and Thomas Lappin as the messenger and assistant messenger, and James Houston as the doorkeeper. ^[23]

Members

The apportionment of senators and representatives in the new state legislature was defined by the recently adopted constitution, which also directed that a new census be taken in 1837 and used as the basis for future apportionments. ^[24] Only white inhabitants were considered in the apportioning of seats. ^[25] The constitution mandated that the number of representatives be between 48 and 100, inclusive, and the number of senators be one-third that number, or as close as possible. ^[26]

Seats in both houses were apportioned by county, with the provision that: ^[24]

Any country attached to any county for judicial purposes, if not otherwise represented, shall be considered as forming part of such county, so far as regards elections for the purpose of representation in the legislature.

Senate

The constitution created districts made up of one or more counties each, and apportioned senators as follows: ^[24]

... for the election of senators, the state shall be divided into five districts, and the apportionment shall be as follows: The county of Wayne shall compose the first district, and elect three senators; the counties of Monroe and Lenawee shall compose the second district and elect three senators; The Counties of Hillsdale, Branch, St. Joseph, Cass, Berrien, Kalamazoo and Calhoun shall compose the third district, and elect three senators; The counties of Washtenaw and Jackson shall compose the fourth district and elect three senators; And the counties of Oakland, Lapeer, Saganaw, Macomb, St. Clair, Michilimackinac and Chippewa shall compose the fifth district, and elect four senators.

Senators

District [27]	Name [10]	City [10]	County [27]	Party [28]
1	Davis, Jonathan D.	Plymouth	Wayne	Democratic
	McDonell, John	Detroit	Wayne	Democratic
	Ten Eyck, Conrad	Dearbonville	Wayne	Democratic
2	Durocher, Laurent	Monroe	Monroe	Democratic
	Ellis, Edward D.	Monroe	Monroe	Democratic
	Hough, Olmsted	Tecumseh	Lenawee	Democratic
3	Barry, John S.	Constantine	St. Joseph	Democratic
	Britain, Calvin	St. Joseph	Berrien	Democratic
	Comstock, Horace H.	Comstock	Kalamazoo	Democratic
4	Finch, Silas	Saline	Washtenaw	Democratic
	Moody, William J.	Jackson	Jackson	Democratic
	Rumsey, Henry	Ann Arbor	Washtenaw	Democratic
5	Clarke, John	China	St. Clair	Democratic
	Hascall, Charles C.	Flint	Genesee [29]	Democratic
	Raynale, Ebenezer	Franklin	Oakland	Democratic
	Stockton, John	Mount Clemens	Macomb	Democratic

House of Representatives

The constitution assigned representatives to each county, or district made up of multiple counties, apportioned as follows: ^[24]

... the County of Wayne shall be entitled to eight representatives; the county of Monroe to four representatives; the county of Washtenaw to seven representatives; the county of St. Clair to one representative; the County of St. Joseph to two representatives; the county of Berrien to one representative; the county of Calhoun to one representative; the county of Jackson to one representative; the county of Cass to two representatives; the county of Oakland to six representatives; the county of Macomb to three representatives; the county of Lenawee to four representatives; the county of Kalamazoo, and the unorganized counties of Allegan and Barry, to two representatives; the county of Branch to one representative; the county of Hillsdale to one representative; the county of Lapeer to one representative; the county of Saganaw and the unorganized counties of Genesee and Shiawasse to one representative; the county of Michilimakinac to one representative; the county of Chippewa to one representative; and the unorganized counties of Ottawa, Kent, Ionia and Clinton to one representative.

The constitution as written provided for 49 representatives. Allegan County was organized on August 25, 1835—after the constitution was drafted by the convention, but before it was approved by the voters. According to other language in the constitution, Allegan was thus eligible to elect its own representative rather than be included as part of "the county of Kalamazoo, and the unorganized counties of Allegan and Barry". ^[30] The House seated the additional representative, Elisha Ely, bringing the total for this legislature to 50. ^[31]

Representatives

District [32]	Name [33]	City [33]	Party	Notes
Allegan County	Ely, Elisha	Allegan
Berrien County	Green, Cogswell K.	Niles	Democratic [34]
Branch County	Alden, Hiram	Coldwater	Democratic [35]
Calhoun County	Convis, Ezra	Battle Creek	Democratic [36]
Cass County	O'Dell, James [37]	Cassopolis
	Smith, Joseph	Edwardsburgh	Democratic [38]
Chippewa County	Levake, Henry A.	Sault Ste. Marie
Hillsdale County	Miller, Lewis T.	Moscow	Democratic [39]
Jackson County	Gidley, Townsend E.	Barry	Whig [40]
Kalamazoo County	Burdick, Cyren	Bronson
	Lothrop, Edwin H.	Schoolcraft	Democratic [41]
Kent, Ottawa, Ionia and Clinton counties	Britton, Roswell	Grandville	Democratic [42]
Lapeer County	Hart, Alvin N.	Whitesville	Democratic [43]
Lenawee County	Dodge, Hiram	Clinton
	Howe, George	Clinton
	Hutchins, Allen	Adrian	Democratic [44] |
	Mead, Darius	Blissfield	Democratic [45]
	Wheeler, James	Tecumseh	Democratic [46]
Macomb County	Monfore, Isaac	Ray	Democratic [47]
	Summers, Jacob	Utica	Democratic [48]
	Tackels, Alexander	Romeo	Democratic [49]
Mackinac County	King, Jonathan P.	Mackinac County	Democratic [50]
Monroe County	Charter, Francis	La Salle
	Felch, Alpheus	Monroe	Democratic [51]
	Godfroy, James J.	Monroe	Democratic [52]
	Jackson, Joseph	Perry's Grove
Oakland County	Brownell, George	East Farmington	Democratic [53]
	Ellenwood, John	Pine Lake	Democratic [54]
	Higley, Hiram	Rochester	Democratic [55]
	Niles, Johnson	Troy	Democratic [56]
	Richardson, Origen D.	Pontiac	Democratic [57]
	Voorheis, Isaac I.	Lake Elizabeth	Democratic [58]
Saginaw County	Williams, Gardner D.	Saginaw
St. Clair County	Heath, John S.	Black River [59]
St. Joseph County	Sherman, Benjamin	Centreville	Democratic [60]
	Ullman, Isaac J.	Constantine	Democratic [61]
Washtenaw County	Brewer, John	Ypsilanti
	Crossman, Alanson	Dexter	Democratic [62]
	Hill, James W.	Columbia Lake	Democratic [63]
	Howe, Orrin	Lodi	Democratic [64]
	Mathews, Rufus [65]	Dixborough	Democratic [66]
	Morse, Richard E.	Ypsilanti	Democratic [67]
Wayne County	Bradshaw, Elias	Van Buren	Democratic [68]
	Brown, Ammon	Nankin	Democratic [69]
	Fay, Jonathan P.	Detroit	Democratic [70]	Died in office March 12, 1836; succeeded by Charles Moran [71]
	Ferrington, George W.	Redford	Democratic [72]
	Moran, Charles	Detroit	Democratic [73]	Succeeded Jonathan P. Fay (deceased) for extra session [71]
	Noyes, Horace A.	Plymouth	Democratic [74]
	Strong, John	Detroit	Democratic [75]
	Van Every, Peter	Hamtramck	Democratic [76]
	Whipple, Charles W.	Detroit	Democratic [77]

Notes

1. Cyclopedia of Michigan 1900, p. 27.
2. Bingham 1888, p. 20.
3. Currie 2007, p. 32.
4. Currie 2007, pp. 33–35.
5. Dunbar & May 1995, pp. 216–217.
6. Faber 2012, p. 63.
7. Dunbar & May 1995, pp. 188, 219.
8. Dunbar & May 1995, p. 211.
9. Constitution of Michigan 1835, Article XII, section 9.
10. Michigan Manual 1877, p. 548.
11. Journal of the Senate 1836, p. 3.
12. Journal of the Senate 1836, p. 37-38.
13. Journal of the Senate 1836, p. 61.
14. Journal of the Senate 1836, p. 156, 169.
15. Dunbar & May 1995, pp. 217–218.
16. Journal of the Senate 1836, p. 305.
17. Faber 2012, p. 69.
18. Dunbar & May 1995, pp. 218–219.
19. Faber 2012, pp. 71–73.
20. Constitution of Michigan 1835, Article V, section 15.
21. Journal of the Senate 1836, pp. 12.
22. Journal of the Senate 1836, pp. 14–15.
23. Journal of the House of Representatives 1836, pp. 11–12.
24. Constitution of Michigan 1835, Schedule, section 12.
25. Constitution of Michigan 1835, Article IV, section 3.
26. Constitution of Michigan 1835, Article IV, section 2.
27. Michigan Manual 1907, pp. 135–148.
28. Streeter 1918, p. 171: "The Senate was composed entirely of Democrats."
29. Genesee County was attached to Oakland County for judicial purposes at its formation on March 28, 1835, ( MPHS 1907 , p. 368), and was thus in the fifth district.
30. Documents 1839, pp. 180–182.
31. Journal of the House of Representatives 1836, p. 11.
32. Michigan Manual 1907, pp. 151–217.
33. Michigan Manual 1877, pp. 549–550.
34. Ellis 1911, p. 123.
35. Chapman Brothers 1888, p. 596.
36. Bingham 1888, p. 191.
37. Sources differ as to whether spelling is Odell ( Michigan Manual 1877 , p. 550) or O'Dell ( Michigan Manual 1907 , p. 195).
38. Bingham 1888, p. 596.
39. Bingham 1888, p. 462.
40. Bingham 1888, p. 289.
41. Bingham 1888, p. 421.
42. Bingham 1888, p. 123.
43. Bingham 1888, p. 327.
44. Bingham 1888, p. 371.
45. Bingham 1888, p. 456.
46. Bingham 1888, p. 684.
47. Bingham 1888, p. 467.
48. Bingham 1888, p. 623.
49. Bingham 1888, p. 627.
50. Library of Michigan n.d.
51. Bingham 1888, p. 262.
52. Bingham 1888, p. 293.
53. Bingham 1888, p. 133.
54. Bingham 1888, p. 251.
55. Bingham 1888, p. 342.
56. Bingham 1888, p. 491.
57. Bingham 1888, p. 553.
58. Bingham 1888, p. 660.
59. Later listed as Desmond ( Michigan Manual 1907 , p. 178); Heath lived in Port Huron, and Port Huron was a later name for Desmond ( Jenks 1912 , pp. 338, 422).
60. Bingham 1888, p. 585.
61. L. H. Everts 1877, p. 74.
62. Bingham 1888, p. 208.
63. Bingham 1888, p. 343.
64. Bingham 1888, p. 360.
65. Sources differ as to whether spelling is Mathews ( Michigan Manual 1907 , p. 188) or Matthews ( Bingham 1888 , p. 438).
66. Bingham 1888, p. 438.
67. Bingham 1888, p. 478; Republican after 1861.
68. Bingham 1888, p. 117; "presumed" to be a Democrat.
69. Bingham 1888, p. 127.
70. Bingham 1888, p. 261; "supposed" to be a Democrat.
71. Michigan Manual 1907, pp. 192–193.
72. Bingham 1888, p. 265.
73. Bingham 1888, p. 473.
74. Bingham 1888, p. 497.
75. Moore 1915, p. 742.
76. Bingham 1888, p. 654; Whig and Republican after 1837.
77. Bingham 1888, p. 685.

References

• Bingham, Stephen D. (1888), Early History of Michigan: With Biographies of State Officers, Members of Congress, Judges and Legislators, Thorp & Godfrey, retrieved 2018-11-08
• Constitution of Michigan, State of Michigan, 1835, archived from the original on 2018-09-03, retrieved 2018-11-05
• Currie, David P. (2007), The Constitution in Congress: Descent into the Maelstrom, 1829-1861, University of Chicago Press, ISBN   978-0-226-13116-0 , retrieved 2018-11-08
• Cyclopedia of Michigan: Historical and Biographical Synopsis of General History of the State, New York & Detroit: Western Publishing and Engraving, 1900, retrieved 2018-11-05
• Documents Accompanying the Journal of the House of Representatives (1839 ed.), Detroit: J. S. & S. A. Bagg, 1839, retrieved 2018-11-05
• Dunbar, Willis F.; May, George S. (1995-09-05), Michigan: A History of the Wolverine State, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, ISBN   978-0-8028-7055-1 , retrieved 2018-11-08
• Ellis, William A. (1911), Norwich University, 1819-1911: Her History, Her Graduates, Her Roll of Honor, vol. 2, Montpelier, Vermont: Capitol City Press, retrieved 2018-11-11
• Faber, Don (2012-09-14), The Boy Governor: Stevens T. Mason and the Birth of Michigan Politics, University of Michigan Press, ISBN   978-0-472-05158-8 , retrieved 2018-11-08
• History of St. Joseph County, Michigan, Philadelphia: L. H. Everts, 1877, retrieved 2018-12-18
• Jenks, William L. (1912), St. Clair County, Michigan, Its History and Its People, vol. 1, Chicago and New York: Lewis, retrieved 2018-11-06
• Journal of the House of Representatives of the State of Michigan (1835–1836 ed.), Detroit: Morse & Bagg, 1836, retrieved 2018-11-05– via HathiTrust
• Journal of the Senate of the State of Michigan (1835–1836 ed.), Detroit: John S. Bagg, 1836, retrieved 2018-11-05– via HathiTrust
• "Legislator Details: Jonathan P. King", Michigan Legislative Biography, Library of Michigan, retrieved 2018-12-14
• Michigan Manual (1877–78 ed.), Lansing: W. S. George & Co., 1877, retrieved 2018-11-04
• Michigan Manual (1907–1908 ed.), Lansing: Wynkoop Hallenbeck Crawford, 1907, retrieved 2018-11-05
• Michigan Pioneer and Historical Society (1907), Historical Collections, vol. 35, Lansing: Wynkoop Hallenbeck Crawford, retrieved 2018-11-08
• Moore, Charles (1915), History of Michigan, vol. 2, Chicago: Lewis, retrieved 2018-12-31
• Portrait And Biographical Album of Branch County, Michigan, Chicago: Chapman Brothers, 1888, retrieved 2018-11-17
• Streeter, Floyd B. (January 1918), "The Factional Character of Early Michigan Politics", Michigan History, Lansing: Michigan Historical Commission, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 165–191, retrieved 2018-11-08