CityTrees

Last updated

CityTrees, also known as Robot Trees,Robo-Trees, and Moss Walls, are large air filters installed in many European cities, as well as Hong Kong, that remove pollutants from the atmosphere.

Contents

A Braunschweig CityTree in 2022 BS CityTree 2.JPG
A Braunschweig CityTree in 2022

CityTrees are large structures covered in moss. The filters intend to curb harmful emissions from nearby traffic congestion, including fine dust particles and nitrogen oxides, of which they are claimed to take in 80%, [1] although this has been disputed by some experts. [2]

The structures have been criticised, especially in Cork, Ireland, for their perceived ineffectiveness, possible wastage of energy and water, and costs of around €400,000 per year. [3] [4] [5] Following this criticism, a Cork City Council debate on the CityTrees scheme was held on 13 November 2023. [6] Councillors decided that the data available for the CityTrees was too inconclusive, partly due to the windy conditions where they were placed, and so they will remain for another 6–12 months. [5]

History and development

A Glasgow CityTree in 2018 CityTree phytoremediation, Glasgow City Centre, Scotland. Installed by Glasgow City Council.jpg
A Glasgow CityTree in 2018

The developers of CityTrees, German company Green City Solutions, previously created the first vertical moss farm in Bestensee, Berlin. [7]

The first CityTree was constructed in Jena, Germany in late 2014. [8] CityTrees have since been installed in Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Brussels, Budapest, Cork, Glasgow, London, Oslo, Paris, and Skopje. [6] [9] [10] Outside of Europe, these structures are also present in Hong Kong. [8]

The operations director for Cork City, Council David Joyce, said that the CityTrees "are not there to replace a tree", because they perform a different function. Where a tree "takes in carbon dioxide and releases oxygen", the CityTrees "take in particulate matter — dust — from diesel engines, from burning fossil fuels, and it captures that dust and eats the dust so it takes 80% of that dust out of the air." [1] Cork City Council were planning to plant 1 million trees from 2021 to 2028, but this was postponed following a lack of funding. [11] [12]

Although it has been reported that one CityTree is equivalent to about 275 real trees, Green City Solutions' marketer Simon Dierks told Cork newsletter Tripe + Drisheen that this figure is "four or five years old", "not true", and "not a smart thing to say". Dierks restated the company's commitment to planting real trees, and cited the shadowing effects and ability to serve as a home for animals as things that real trees can do, that CityTrees cannot. [13]

A newer version of the CityTree was unveiled at the Bikini Berlin  [ DE ] shopping centre in 2020. [14] The new version had been researched from 2018 to 2020 with an €2 million grant from the EU. [15] Simon Dierks told Tripe + Drisheen Green City Solutions are working on replacing the earlier iterations of the CityTree with the more recent model. [13]

Design

The structures are under 4 meters tall, 3 meters wide, and 2.19 meters deep. CityTrees are covered in living Hypnum mosses that capture and consume pollutants around them. Each CityTree has a bench attached. [13] [16] To further capture pollutants, CityTrees use Internet of Things technology. [17]

They include a 40-inch TV screen that displays information about air quality in the area. [1] The structures are self sustaining with solar panels and rainwater collection systems that require only a few hours of maintenance every year. [1]

The slim version of the CityTree, for use in more compact environments, omits the bench and takes up only 1.5 meters of floor space. [16]

CityTree 2020

The newer model, dubbed "CityTree 2020", is made of wood and is a hexagonal shape, which Green City Solutions called a "Bauhaus-inspired design". They stated that the 2020 version also has a reduced CO2 footprint. [18] Green City Solutions claimed in February 2021 that the new CityTree can "inactivate 1/5 of coronaviruses". [19]

Reception

Ireland

When they were installed in Cork, UCC atmospheric scientist Dr. Dean Venables told the Irish Examiner that they were "a costly and ineffectual gimmick" and predicted that they would have little impact on Cork’s air quality. He stated that it would be better to regulate production of emissions, instead of attempting to curb emissions after the fact. [1]

According to the Waltham Forest Echo, after the CityTrees were installed, "local residents took to pelting the units with fast food and pinning posters to them that said the money could have been spent on providing free school meals for school children in need." [20]

Labour party politician Peter Horgan called the CityTrees "the most expensive benches ever purchased by a local authority". Horgan criticised the cost for maintenance and installation, as well as the lack of a formal vote by the Cork Council for their installation. It was his belief that the installation of public footpaths, benches, or real trees would be more beneficial. [4] Horgan has since said he desires "a full explanation of why and how they were purchased coupled with the spending expected on them, and a full vote of the council to determine whether they should continue". [2]

Professor John Sodeau, an expert in air pollution and climate change, contests the 80% pollutant capture figure. He has stated that the independent study by the Leibniz Institute for Tropospheric Research only mentioned a particle reduction of up to 30% for indoor measurements, and that no outdoor measurements are mentioned, besides that "the measurements were shown to be dependent on meteorological conditions". [2] [21]

Many Cork City councilors have said they believe it time to "pull the plug" on the project. [22]

North Macedonia

A withered Skopje CityTree in 2021 Ovenato city tree vo Skopje.jpg
A withered Skopje CityTree in 2021

The CityTrees in Skopje and Tetovo have withered after neglect by the city governments. Additionally, Tetovo CityTrees have been almost entirely destroyed. A local resident told Sloboden Pečat "Here in Tetovo, whatever is set up in the interest of the city and its citizens is destroyed." [23] [24] Sloboden Pečat was critical of the lack of fines for polluters in Tetovo, and noted that despite the CityTrees, the amount of PM10 particles was only going to increase. [24]

The Netherlands

In 2018, the city of Amsterdam started a 1 year trial for the CityTrees before deciding whether to install them permanently. At the trial's conclusion, only one-fourth of the plants survived, and experts from the Municipal Health Service and Wageningen University found that CityTrees took in less than 1% of particle matter, instead of the promised 20%. [25] [26]

The experts had also found that, as CityTrees suck in the nitrogen oxides it then emits again, pollution along the tested street had actually increased. [25]

In response to this study, Amsterdam chose not to keep the CityTrees. [25]

United Kingdom

Waltham Forest Council abandoned CityTrees installed in Leytonstone, following the death of the towers and the quiet removal of projects elsewhere, such as Westminster. [20]

Glasgow City Council abandoned an investment in CityTrees that were estimated to remove less than 0.02 percent of the city’s pollutants each year. [27]

Similar projects

Another air filter modelled after trees, the BioUrban, was constructed in Puebla, Mexico in 2019. The company that created the BioUrban plans to expand to Turkey and Colombia. [6] [28]

In Belgrade, Serbia, currently ranked 24th in the world for worst air quality, the Liquid3, also called a "liquid tree", was installed in 2019. The Liquid3 contains 600 liters of water and uses micro-algae that binds carbon dioxide. The company that installed the Liquid3 says it is "10-50 times more efficient than trees and grass at photosynthesising and creating pure oxygen." [6]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pollution</span> Introduction of contaminants that cause adverse change

Pollution is the introduction of contaminants into the natural environment that cause adverse change. Pollution can take the form of any substance or energy. Pollutants, the components of pollution, can be either foreign substances/energies or naturally occurring contaminants.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urban heat island</span> Urban area that is significantly warmer than its surrounding rural areas

Urban areas usually experience the urban heat island (UHI) effect, that is, they are significantly warmer than surrounding rural areas. The temperature difference is usually larger at night than during the day, and is most apparent when winds are weak, under block conditions, noticeably during the summer and winter. The main cause of the UHI effect is from the modification of land surfaces while waste heat generated by energy usage is a secondary contributor. A study has shown that heat islands can be affected by proximity to different types of land cover, so that proximity to barren land causes urban land to become hotter and proximity to vegetation makes it cooler. As a population center grows, it tends to expand its area and increase its average temperature. The term heat island is also used; the term can be used to refer to any area that is relatively hotter than the surrounding, but generally refers to human-disturbed areas. Urban areas occupy about 0.5% of the Earth's land surface but host more than half of the world's population.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stormwater</span> Water that originates during precipitation events and snow/ice melt

Stormwater, also written storm water, is water that originates from precipitation (storm), including heavy rain and meltwater from hail and snow. Stormwater can soak into the soil (infiltrate) and become groundwater, be stored on depressed land surface in ponds and puddles, evaporate back into the atmosphere, or contribute to surface runoff. Most runoff is conveyed directly as surface water to nearby streams, rivers or other large water bodies without treatment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Water pollution</span> Contamination of water bodies

Water pollution is the contamination of water bodies, with a negative impact on their uses. It is usually a result of human activities. Water bodies include lakes, rivers, oceans, aquifers, reservoirs and groundwater. Water pollution results when contaminants mix with these water bodies. Contaminants can come from one of four main sources. These are sewage discharges, industrial activities, agricultural activities, and urban runoff including stormwater. Water pollution may affect either surface water or groundwater. This form of pollution can lead to many problems. One is the degradation of aquatic ecosystems. Another is spreading water-borne diseases when people use polluted water for drinking or irrigation. Water pollution also reduces the ecosystem services such as drinking water provided by the water resource.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leaf blower</span> Machine used to blow leaves and debris

A leaf blower, commonly known as a blower, is a device that propels air out of a nozzle to move debris such as leaves and grass cuttings. Leaf blowers are powered by electric or gasoline motors. Gasoline models have traditionally been two-stroke engines, but four-stroke engines were recently introduced to partially address air pollution concerns. Leaf blowers are typically self-contained handheld units, or backpack mounted units with a handheld wand. The latter is more ergonomic for prolonged use. Larger units may rest on wheels and even use a motor for propulsion. These are sometimes called "walk-behind leaf blowers" because they must be pushed by hand to be operated. Some units called blower vacs, can also suck in leaves and small twigs via a vacuum, and shred them into a bag.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urban forestry</span> Land use management system in which trees or shrubs are cared or protected for well-being

Urban forestry is the care and management of single trees and tree populations in urban settings for the purpose of improving the urban environment. Urban forestry involves both planning and management, including the programming of care and maintenance operations of the urban forest. Urban forestry advocates the role of trees as a critical part of the urban infrastructure. Urban foresters plant and maintain trees, support appropriate tree and forest preservation, conduct research and promote the many benefits trees provide. Urban forestry is practiced by municipal and commercial arborists, municipal and utility foresters, environmental policymakers, city planners, consultants, educators, researchers and community activists.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Drisheen</span> Type of Irish blood sausage pudding

Drisheen is a type of blood pudding made in Ireland. It is distinguished from other forms of Irish black pudding by having a gelatinous consistency. It is made from a mixture of cow's, pig's or sheep's blood, milk, salt and fat, which is boiled and sieved and finally cooked using the main intestine of an animal as the sausage skin. The sausage may be flavoured with herbs. Historically, tansy had sometimes been used as a seasoning for drisheen. However, it has since been discovered to be toxic to humans. The recipe for drisheen varies widely from place to place and it also differs depending on the time of year. Drisheen is a cooked product but it usually requires further preparation before eating. How this is done varies widely from place to place.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Environmental issues in Afghanistan</span>

Environmental issues in Afghanistan are monitored by the National Environmental Protection Agency (NEPA). They predate the political turmoil of the past few decades. Forests have been depleted by centuries of grazing and farming, practices which have only increased with modern population growth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urban forest</span> Collection of trees within a city, town or a suburb

An urban forest is a forest, or a collection of trees, that grow within a city, town or a suburb. In a wider sense, it may include any kind of woody plant vegetation growing in and around human settlements. As opposed to a forest park, whose ecosystems are also inherited from wilderness leftovers, urban forests often lack amenities like public bathrooms, paved paths, or sometimes clear borders which are distinct features of parks. Care and management of urban forests is called urban forestry. Urban forests can be privately and publicly owned. Some municipal forests may be located outside of the town or city to which they belong.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air pollution</span> Presence of dangerous substances in the atmosphere

Air pollution is the contamination of air due to the presence of substances called pollutants in the atmosphere that are harmful to the health of humans and other living beings, or cause damage to the climate or to materials. It is also the contamination of the indoor or outdoor environment either by chemical, physical, or biological agents that alters the natural features of the atmosphere. There are many different types of air pollutants, such as gases, particulates, and biological molecules. Air pollution can cause diseases, allergies, and even death to humans; it can also cause harm to other living organisms such as animals and crops, and may damage the natural environment or built environment. Air pollution can be caused by both human activities and natural phenomena.

Environmental policy in China is set by the National People's Congress and managed by the Ministry of Environmental Protection of the People's Republic of China. Under the Ministry of Environmental Protection of the People's Republic of China, the Department of Policies, Laws, and Regulations is in charge of establishing and strengthening basic laws and policies such as environmental laws, administrative policies and economical regulations. It is also responsible for the development of national environmental protection policy and macro strategy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urban runoff</span> Surface runoff of water caused by urbanization

Urban runoff is surface runoff of rainwater, landscape irrigation, and car washing created by urbanization. Impervious surfaces are constructed during land development. During rain, storms, and other precipitation events, these surfaces, along with rooftops, carry polluted stormwater to storm drains, instead of allowing the water to percolate through soil. This causes lowering of the water table and flooding since the amount of water that remains on the surface is greater. Most municipal storm sewer systems discharge untreated stormwater to streams, rivers, and bays. This excess water can also make its way into people's properties through basement backups and seepage through building wall and floors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Water pollution in the United States</span> Overview of water pollution in the United States of America

Water pollution in the United States is a growing problem that became critical in the 19th century with the development of mechanized agriculture, mining, and industry, although laws and regulations introduced in the late 20th century have improved water quality in many water bodies. Extensive industrialization and rapid urban growth exacerbated water pollution as a lack of regulation allowed for discharges of sewage, toxic chemicals, nutrients and other pollutants into surface water.

The health of a mother directly affects the fetus during pregnancy. High levels of vehicle pollution where pregnant women reside can have adverse health effects on fetuses.

Pristina, the capital of the Republic of Kosovo, is the country's most populated city with more than 200,000 inhabitants. Its air pollution level rivals big cities like Beijing, Mumbai and New Delhi. The main sources of Pristina's air pollution include power plants emissions during energy production, household emissions as well as its traffic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smog tower</span> Urban large-scale air purifier

Smog towers or smog free towers are structures designed as large-scale air purifiers to reduce air pollution particles (smog). This approach to the problem of urban air pollution involves air filtration, and removal of suspended mechanical particulates such as soot, and requires energy or power. Another approach is to remove urban air pollution by a chimney effect in a tall stack, or updraft tower, which may be either filtered or simply released at altitude as with a solar updraft tower, and which may not require operating energy beyond what may be produced by the updraft.

Environmental issues in North Macedonia include air and water pollution, deforestation, threats to endemic species and climate change. There is substantial degree of pollution in the air, water and land of North Macedonia. According to 2019 estimates, the country is considered to have one of the highest degrees of pollution in Europe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air pollution in South Korea</span>

Air pollution in South Korea is an increasing threat to people and the environment. The air pollution comes from many sources, both domestic and international. Many forms of pollution have increased in South Korea since its rapid industrialization, especially in Seoul and other cities. According to the U.S. National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), Seoul is amongst one of the world's cities with the worst air pollution. From 2009 and 2013, the city's mean PM10 were higher than in many of the largest metropolitan cities in the world such as: Los Angeles, Tokyo, Paris, and London. This has resulted in health and environmental problems. Koreans buy masks and air purifiers to breathe cleaner air, and are working to reduce the country's emissions.

<i>Hypnum</i> Genus of mosses

Hypnum is a genus of mosses belonging to the family Hypnaceae.

Pollution in Korea has become diversified and serious due to rapid industrialization and urbanization since the 1960s. The causes of environmental pollution, both in South and North Korea, can be found in population growth, urban concentration, and industrial structure, similar to the rest of the world.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 English, Liz Dunphy and Eoin (2021-08-10). "New 'robot trees' installed on Cork City streets". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 2023-11-10.
  2. 1 2 3 "City's robot trees still rooted in controversy". Cork Independent. 2023-09-27. Retrieved 2023-11-12.
  3. "Cork's 'robot trees' labelled a waste of energy by campaigner as council analyses impact". echo live. 2023-05-03. Retrieved 2023-11-10.
  4. 1 2 Curran, Faye. "Lack of transparency around Cork City 'robot trees' is 'concerning' – Councillor". Newstalk. Retrieved 2023-11-10.
  5. 1 2 McAuley, Eimer (2023-11-13). "Cork city cllrs decide against dumping €400,000 'robo trees', amid concerns they aren't working". TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 2023-11-15.
  6. 1 2 3 4 "Debate on robot trees looks to clear the air: What are other countries doing?". echo live. 2023-11-09. Retrieved 2023-11-11.
  7. Cork, Yay (2021-08-18). "The inventors of Cork's controversial 'robot trees' want you to check out their Berlin moss farm". Yay Cork. Retrieved 2023-11-10.
  8. 1 2 "Vertical gardens that 'eat' air pollution and how Hong Kong could use them". South China Morning Post. 2016-09-07. Retrieved 2023-11-13.
  9. "This London bench absorbs as much pollution as 275 trees". Wired UK. ISSN   1357-0978 . Retrieved 2023-11-12.
  10. "CityTree - Reducing Urban Air Pollution One Bench at a Time". WorldAtlas. 2018-03-29. Retrieved 2023-11-15.
  11. English, Eoin (2022-01-19). "Cork City Council says it lacks funds for ambitious tree planting scheme". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 2023-12-27.
  12. "Tree Planting & Greening". Cork City Council. Retrieved 2023-11-13.
  13. 1 2 3 O'Donoghue, J. J.; O'Byrne, Ellie (2021-08-11). "Everything you wanted to know about Cork's new Robo-trees but were afraid to ask". Tripe + Drisheen. Retrieved 2023-11-19.
  14. "Wunderbäume für die Stadt: "City Trees" sollen Berliner Luft sauberer machen". Der Tagesspiegel Online (in German). ISSN   1865-2263 . Retrieved 2023-11-25.
  15. Dunphy, Liz (2021-08-13). "A waste of money or a key part of cleaner air? The CityTree debate". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 2024-01-03.
  16. 1 2 Giles, Chris (2017-06-08). "This 'tree' has the environmental benefits of a forest". CNN. Retrieved 2023-12-26.
  17. Gain, Vish (2021-08-13). "Cork installs robot CityTrees to tackle air pollution amid criticism". Silicon Republic. Retrieved 2024-02-01.
  18. OUTFLUENCER (2020-03-20). "WORLD PREMIERE IN BERLIN". Green City Solutions. Retrieved 2023-11-28.
  19. Dierks (2021-02-02). "CityTree can inactivate one-fifth of corona viruses". Green City Solutions. Retrieved 2023-11-28.
  20. 1 2 Forest, Waltham (2023-10-09). "Council removes dead pollution eating moss walls". Waltham Forest Echo. Retrieved 2023-12-12.
  21. English, Eoin (2023-11-08). "Cork City's €400k 'robotrees' like using 'bathroom sponges in Midleton' to combat flooding". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 2023-12-12.
  22. "Controversial 'CityTrees': Mixed views on what should be done next". echo live. 2023-11-09. Retrieved 2023-11-13.
  23. Стојковски, Алек (2019-06-26). "The City of Skopje with (carelessness) dried the donation of 25.000 euros - THE REASONABLE REASON - Free Press". Слободен печат. Retrieved 2023-11-19.
  24. 1 2 Димовски, Зоран (2022-11-16). "The "ecological tree" did not survive in the non-ecological city under "Shara", where there are no fines for polluters - Sloboden Pechat". Слободен печат. Retrieved 2023-11-19.
  25. 1 2 3 van Zoelen, Bart (2019-05-31). "Proef met CityTrees loopt uit op mislukking". Het Parool (in Dutch). Retrieved 2024-03-04.
  26. https://www.oudestadt.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/TNO%202018%20R10613%20Rapport%20Luchtkwaliteit_6%20juni_finaal_tcm318-398657.pdf
  27. McAdams, Hugh (2019-10-16). "It isn't necessarily good just because it is green". New Scientist. Retrieved 2024-05-15.
  28. "Mexico installs 'robotic trees' to tackle air pollution". France 24. 2019-08-15. Retrieved 2023-11-10.