Cleveland Apollo

Last updated
Cleveland Apollo
Apollo Sauroktonos attributed to Praxiteles (front).JPG
ArtistAttributed to Praxiteles
Year350 BCE
Location Cleveland Museum of Art

The Cleveland Apollo is a 4th-century BCE life-size bronze Ancient Greek statue, now in the Cleveland Museum of Art. It acquired it in 2004 using the Severance and Greta Millikin Purchase Fund. The Museum attributed the piece to Praxiteles (circa 400 to 330 BCE). [1] Technical features of the Cleveland Apollo are consistent with the Late Classical Period, during Praxiteles's lifetime. [1] Scientific investigation of the sculpture and the separated parts shows that they are from the same casting. [2] The age of the casting is still under review as of 2017. [2] Scholarly investigation has raised several questions about it being a Praxiteles original. [3] [4]

Contents

Description

Apollo the Python-Slayer, also known as Apollo Sauroktonos (Lizard-Slayer), is attributed by the Cleveland Museum staff to Praxiteles from about 350 BCE. [1] It is bronze with copper and a stone inlay. [1] The height is 150 cm, the width is 66.8 cm, and the depth is 50.3 cm. [1] The statue consists of its right arm above the elbow a large portion of the left arm, and the shoulder. [1] Most of the left forearm and the left hand survive along with the small reptilian creature. [1] The reptilian figure has the strange anatomy of a coiled snake with legs of differing sizes and attached asymmetrically. [1] The inconsistencies in the reptile prove it is not a natural figure, but a smaller python from the world of mythology. [1] The figure, hand, forearm and reptilian creature belong together. [1] They were cast from the same melt as confirmed by analysis of the composition of the metal, the amount of lead in the metal, and the history of corrosion. [5]

In the first century AD Pliny the Elder wrote in his Natural History (34.69–70), that the famous fourth century BCE Athenian sculptor Praxiteles created a bronze sculpture depicting Apollo in his youth ready to stab a lizard with an arrow. [1] Pliny used the epithet sauroktonos (lizard-slayer) to refer to the Praxiteles masterpiece. [1] His youthful Apollo leans toward a tree trunk where he rests his raised left hand. [6] He holds an arrow in his right hand about to stab at the lizard that runs up the tree. [6] Here a serious mythological subject is treated as a sport or pastime with a slight allusion to the religious type. [6] The Cleveland Apollo artist following the same treatment also reveled in the youthful beauty and grace of the boyish form, the curve in its position and the delicacy with which it is modeled. [6] It is likely that the figure has been exaggerated by the copyist similar to other copies of the Sauroktonos and other figures of Apollo that appear to be based on a Praxiteles original. [6] Two other copies are possibly the work of a contemporary imitator. [7] The two are under life-size figures that represent Apollo and Dionysus. [7] The head in the Apollo agrees in pose and inclination to other works. It bears witness to the influence of Polykleita in that it has close-growing parted hair hanging down over the forehead in symmetrical curls (see the figure in the Gallery). [7]

Several marble copies of the Apollo made in Rome have survived and are in indication of its popularity into the Imperial period. [1] Wealthy Romans acquired them to decorate their homes and country villas. [1] The copies show a youthful Apollo leaning on a thick, leafless tree trunk with a lizard climbing up the surface. [1] This sculptural type has been known as Apollo Sauroktonos since Roman times. [1] Even Roman coins and gems engraved with Apollo show the sculptural type. [1] Rather than a stout tree trunk, many show Apollo with a young slender tree. [1]

Controversy About Originality

Scientific Investigation

Comparatively few bronzes like Apollo exist for study. [2] The Cleveland Museum has a rare opportunity to expand the small body of knowledge regarding casting large bronzes during the classical period. [2] Visual examination is a first step in an evaluation. [2] The borescope (a long flexible tube with a camera and fiber-optic lighting) was used to inspect the inside of the head and found several modern repair materials. [2] A CT scan (computed tomography), like an x-ray, was done resulting in information to allow the bronze to be seen in slices. [2] Viewing the slices digitally allowed the for higher resolution and development of a three-dimensional digital form. [2] The figure is made of highly leaded bronze, as appropriate for a bronze casting during classical antiquity. [2] Samples of the bronze and small pieces of wood were taken to be carbon-dated to show when the sculpture was exposed to high heat. [2] As of 2017, the samples were still being studied. [2]

More recent testing and analysis of the Cleveland Apollo have resolved several questions. [5] The reassembled bronze fragments, hand, forearm, and python belong together; they were cast from the same melt as confirmed by the metal composition, corrosion history and the lead content. [5] The corrosion suggests that the figure was exposed to the atmosphere over an extended time after it was excavated. [5] This corrosion testing revealed that the base plate does not appear to be entirely original. [5] But the lead is similar suggesting that it may be part of the original and repurposed as the base plate. [5] The figure displays evidence of having been in a fire occurring after excavation. [5] Samples of the charcoal from the forearm were carbon-dated as being much older than the Roman or Greek periods. [5] It is possible that the samples were contaminated during restoration. [5]

Efforts between 2009 and 2021 to improve understanding of the Apollo have led to more questions. [5] The testing has advanced the understanding of the sculpture, but the statue will continue to provide new chances for more research. [5]

Scholarly Investigation

The Apollo (also known as Sauroktonos) is a mainstay in classical art history. [3] It has been considered a major work of Praxiteles and is known from Roman marble replicas, coins, and gems. [3] The Apollo is one work in a field where the personal styles of famous Greek sculptors are named in ancient sources but whose masterpieces rarely, if ever, survive as originals. [3] How this statue of a young man and a lizard came to achieve iconic status in art history is an interesting story and one that may deserve to be reexamined considering both the old and more recent evidence. [3]  The Roman author Pliny the Elder in the first century CE, in his Natural History (34.60-70), noted that the famous Athenian sculptor Praxiteles produced a sculpture (in the fourth century BCE) in bronze of a youthful Apollo about to use an arrow to stab a lizard. [1] Pliny used the name sauroktonos (lizard-slayer) for the Praxiteles masterpiece. [1] In 2004 the Cleveland Museum of Art obtained the only known bronze version of this sculptural type (several marble copies from Rome survive). [1] With rare exceptions, the original sculptures from Greece are works of second or inferior rank. [7]

Questions have arisen about the identification and attribution of this Roman statue type because the attribution is based only on a passage in Pliny. [3] Recently two things have caused a reevaluation of Pliny’s credit for the work to Praxiteles and the identification of the statue. [3] The first is the Cleveland Museum’s acquisition of a life-sized bronze of the Apollo Sauroktonos type. [3] The Museum claims it is a Praxiteles original. [3] The second is the first monographic exhibit dedicated to the work of Praxiteles held at the Louvre in Paris in 2007. [3] An essay in the exhibition catalog summarizes the scholarship and issues surrounding the Sauroktonos type. [3] While the Cleveland Apollo is discussed in the catalog, it was not included in the exhibition due to issues raised about its questionable provenance. [3] The author of the catalog for the Paris exhibition commented on the work saying “In spite of its abundance, the documentation does not permit us to recognize this work in detail and the context of its creation completely eludes us. The Cleveland bronze was not included in the Paris exhibit because of issues raised over its questionable provenance but it is discussed briefly in the catalog.” [3] The exclusion of the Cleveland bronze – surely not Praxiteles’s original – was due to objections of Greek authorities regarding its authenticity. [4] It is the only existing full-scale version of this type in bronze, the original medium according to Pliny. [3] Because there is no indisputably original freestanding sculpture from Praxiteles, one of the most famous classical antiquity artists, it would be unprecedented to have one that survives. [3]

Provenance

In 2004 the ApolloSauroktonos was acquired by the Cleveland Museum of Art. [1] The Apollo was thought to be the only known bronze version of the sculpture. [1] It had been recovered from an East German estate after reunification of West and East German in 1990; Germany was separated after World War II. [1] An elderly German man who was the legal heir successfully reclaimed his estate. [1] While cleaning up the estate he found the sculpture in an old debris pile. [1] Before World War II the estate belonged to his great-uncle and the heir remembered seeing it frequently when he visited as a young man. [1] Because he believed it to be an 18th- or 19th-century copy of an ancient work, he sold it rather than investing in reconstruction. [1] It was conserved later when it was identified as ancient. [1] In 2002 a representative of the Cleveland Museum of Art saw it in the Geneva gallery of Phoenix Ancient Art, and the museum purchased it in 2004. [1] The Apollo showed signs of severe damage that could have occurred during combat between the Nazis and the Russian Red Army in eastern Germany, [1] Praxiteles’s masterwork was stranded at the time between the mayhem of World War II and the lengthy Cold War. [1] The ApolloSauroktonos was rescued by the art market. [1]

Praxiteles

Praxiteles was a master sculpturer with work that won for Greek sculpture great regard with modern artists and critics. [6] In the popular estimate of his own time, he was the most famous of all Greek sculptors. [6] His work was the most highly prized of Greco-Roman work at that time due to its personal and individual charm, the sweeping facile lines of his work, and the sensuous beauty of form. [6] Among all of the gods, we should expect the art of Praxiteles to be focused on Apollo and Artemis. [6] Several statues of these deities are recorded among his works, and many of them in our museums are derived from him or from his pupils. [6] Maybe the best known of the statues of Apollo attributed to Praxiteles is of mythological interest, the Sauroctonus, or lizard-slayer. Praxiteles’s treatment of it was popular and preserved in several copies. It is probable that with the copies of similar figures of Apollo apparently copied from a Praxitelean original, the copyist exaggerated the softness of the figure almost to effeminacy. [6]

Related Research Articles

<i>Contrapposto</i> Sculptural disposition of human figure

Contrapposto is an Italian term that means "counterpoise". It is used in the visual arts to describe a human figure standing with most of its weight on one foot, so that its shoulders and arms twist off-axis from the hips and legs in the axial plane.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Praxiteles</span> 4th-century BC Athenian sculptor

Praxiteles of Athens, the son of Cephisodotus the Elder, was the most renowned of the Attica sculptors of the 4th century BC. He was the first to sculpt the nude female form in a life-size statue. While no indubitably attributable sculpture by Praxiteles is extant, numerous copies of his works have survived; several authors, including Pliny the Elder, wrote of his works; and coins engraved with silhouettes of his various famous statuary types from the period still exist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Polykleitos</span> Fifth century BCE Greek sculptor

Polykleitos was an ancient Greek sculptor, active in the 5th century BCE. Alongside the Athenian sculptors Pheidias, Myron and Praxiteles, he is considered as one of the most important sculptors of classical antiquity. The 4th century BCE catalogue attributed to Xenocrates, which was Pliny's guide in matters of art, ranked him between Pheidias and Myron. He is particularly known for his lost treatise, the Canon of Polykleitos, which set out his mathematical basis of an idealised male body shape.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lyceus</span>

The Apollo Lyceus type, also known as Lycean Apollo, originating with Praxiteles and known from many full-size statue and figurine copies as well as from 1st century BCE Athenian coinage, is a statue type of Apollo showing the god resting on a support, his right forearm touching the top of his head and his hair fixed in braids on the top of a head in a haircut typical of childhood. It is called "Lycean" not after Lycia itself, but after its identification with a lost work described, though not attributed to a sculptor, by Lucian as being on show in the Lyceum, one of the gymnasia of Athens. According to Lucian, the god leaning on a support with his bow in his left hand and his right resting on his head is shown "as if resting after long effort." Its main exemplar is the Apollino in Florence or Apollo Medici, in the Uffizi, Florence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lysippos</span> 4th-century BC Greek sculptor

Lysippos was a Greek sculptor of the 4th century BC. Together with Scopas and Praxiteles, he is considered one of the three greatest sculptors of the Classical Greek era, bringing transition into the Hellenistic period. Problems confront the study of Lysippos because of the difficulty of identifying his style among the copies which survive. Not only did he have a large workshop and many disciples in his immediate circle, but there is understood to have been a market for replicas of his work, supplied from outside his circle, both in his lifetime and later in the Hellenistic and Roman periods. The Victorious Youth or Getty bronze, which resurfaced around 1972, has been associated with him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scopas</span> 4th century BCE Greek sculptor

Scopas was an ancient Greek sculptor and architect, most famous for his statue of Meleager, the copper statue of Aphrodite, and the head of goddess Hygieia, daughter of Asclepius.

<i>Doryphoros</i> Sculpture by Polykleitos of a warrior

The Doryphoros of Polykleitos is one of the best known Greek sculptures of Classical antiquity, depicting a solidly built, muscular, standing warrior, originally bearing a spear balanced on his left shoulder. Rendered somewhat above life-size, the lost bronze original of the work would have been cast circa 440 BC, but it is today known only from later marble copies. The work nonetheless forms an important early example of both Classical Greek contrapposto and classical realism; as such, the iconic Doryphoros proved highly influential elsewhere in ancient art.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient Greek sculpture</span>

The sculpture of ancient Greece is the main surviving type of fine ancient Greek art as, with the exception of painted ancient Greek pottery, almost no ancient Greek painting survives. Modern scholarship identifies three major stages in monumental sculpture in bronze and stone: the Archaic, Classical (480–323) and Hellenistic. At all periods there were great numbers of Greek terracotta figurines and small sculptures in metal and other materials.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cephisodotus the Elder</span> 4th-century BC Greek sculptor

Cephisodotus or Kephisodotos was a Greek sculptor, perhaps the father or an uncle of Praxiteles, one of whose sculptor sons was Cephisodotus the Younger.

<i>Diadumenos</i> Sculpture by Polykleitos of a youth tying his headband

The Diadumenos ("diadem-bearer"), together with the Doryphoros, are two of the most famous figural types of the sculptor Polyclitus, forming a basic pattern of Ancient Greek sculpture that all present strictly idealized representations of young male athletes in a convincingly naturalistic manner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aphrodite of Knidos</span> Sculpture by Praxiteles of Athens from the 4th century BC

The Aphrodite of Knidos was an Ancient Greek sculpture of the goddess Aphrodite created by Praxiteles of Athens around the 4th century BC. It was one of the first life-sized representations of the nude female form in Greek history, displaying an alternative idea to male heroic nudity. Praxiteles' Aphrodite was shown nude, reaching for a bath towel while covering her pubis, which, in turn leaves her breasts exposed. Up until this point, Greek sculpture had been dominated by male nude figures. The original Greek sculpture is no longer in existence; however, many Roman copies survive of this influential work of art. Variants of the Venus Pudica are the Venus de' Medici and the Capitoline Venus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Classical sculpture</span> Sculpture from ancient Greece and Rome

Classical sculpture refers generally to sculpture from Ancient Greece and Ancient Rome, as well as the Hellenized and Romanized civilizations under their rule or influence, from about 500 BC to around 200 AD. It may also refer more precisely a period within Ancient Greek sculpture from around 500 BC to the onset of the Hellenistic style around 323 BC, in this case usually given a capital "C". The term "classical" is also widely used for a stylistic tendency in later sculpture, not restricted to works in a Neoclassical or classical style.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Apoxyomenos</span> Subject of Greek votive sculpture

Apoxyomenos is one of the conventional subjects of ancient Greek votive sculpture; it represents an athlete, caught in the familiar act of scraping sweat and dust from his body with the small curved instrument that the Greeks called a stlengis and the Romans a strigil.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antikythera Ephebe</span> Greek bronze statue

The Antikythera Ephebe, registered as: Bronze statue of a youth in the museum collections, is a bronze statue of a young man of languorous grace that was found in 1900 by sponge-divers in the area of the ancient Antikythera shipwreck off the island of Antikythera, Greece. It was the first of the series of Greek bronze sculptures that the Aegean and Mediterranean yielded up in the twentieth century which have fundamentally altered the modern view of ancient Greek sculpture. The wreck site, which is dated about 70–60 BC, also yielded the Antikythera mechanism, a characterful head of a Stoic philosopher, and a hoard of coins. The coins included a disproportionate quantity of Pergamene cistophoric tetradrachms and Ephesian coins, leading scholars to surmise that it had begun its journey on the Ionian coast, perhaps at Ephesus; none of its recovered cargo has been identified as from mainland Greece.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hermes (Museo Pio-Clementino)</span>

The Hermes of the Museo Pio-Clementino is an ancient Roman sculpture, part of the Vatican collections, Rome. It was long admired as the Belvedere Antinous, named from its prominent placement in the Cortile del Belvedere. It is now inventory number 907 in the Museo Pio-Clementino.

<i>Apollo Sauroctonos</i> 1st - 2nd century AD Roman sculptures

Apollo Sauroktonos is the title of several 1st – 2nd century AD Roman marble copies of an original by the ancient Greek sculptor Praxiteles. The statues depict a nude adolescent Apollo about to catch a lizard climbing up a tree. Copies are included in the collections of the Louvre Museum, the Vatican Museums, and the National Museums Liverpool.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Amazon statue types</span> Style of ancient Greek & Roman statues

Pliny the Elder records five bronze statues of Amazons in the Artemision of Ephesus. He explains the existence of such a quantity of sculptures on the same theme in the same place by describing a 5th-century BC competition between the artists Polyclitus, Phidias, Kresilas, "Kydon" and Phradmon; thus:

The most celebrated of these artists, though born at different epochs, have joined in a trial of skill in the Amazons which they have respectively made. When these statues were dedicated in the Temple of Diana at Ephesus, it was agreed, in order to ascertain which was the best, that it should be left to the judgment of the artists themselves who were then present: upon which, it was evident that that was the best, which all the artists agreed in considering as the next best to his own. Accordingly, the first rank was assigned to Polycletus, the second to Phidias, the third to Cresilas, the fourth to Cydon, and the fifth to Phradmon.

<i>Resting Satyr</i> Greek sculpture

The Resting Satyr or Leaning Satyr, also known as the Satyr anapauomenos is a statue type generally attributed to the ancient Greek sculptor Praxiteles. Some 115 examples of the type are known, of which the best known is in the Capitoline Museums.

<i>Lansdowne Heracles</i> Roman sculpture of Heracles

The Lansdowne Heracles is a Roman marble sculpture of about 125 CE. Today it is in the collection of the J. Paul Getty Museum's Getty Villa on the Malibu Coast, Los Angeles. The statue represents the hero Heracles as a beardless Lysippic youth grasping the skin of the Nemean lion with his club upon his shoulder. The work was discovered in 1790 in Tivoli, Italy, on the site of Hadrian's Villa, where many fine Hadrianic copies and pastiches of Greek sculptures had been discovered since the 16th century. Today, the sculpture is considered to be an example of Roman-era improvisations on the Greek sculptural style of the fourth century BCE rather than a copy of a specific Greek original.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antoine-Félix Bouré</span> Belgian sculptor

Antoine-Félix Bouré, known in his own time as Félix Bouré but sometimes found in modern scholarship as Antoine Bouré, was a Belgian sculptor, best known for his monumental lions.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 Bennett, Michael (2013). "Apollo the Python-Slayer". Cleveland Art. Retrieved October 19, 2021.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Snyder, Coleen (2014). "Apollo in the Lab". The Cleveland Museum of Art. Archived from the original on 2019-02-17. Retrieved October 25, 2021.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Neils, Jenifer (December 2017). "Praxiteles to Caravaggio: the "Apollo Sauroktones" Redefined". The Art Bulletin. 99 (4): 10–30. doi: 10.1080/00043079.2017.1327771 . JSTOR   44973215. S2CID   194838321.
  4. 1 2 Stewart, Andrew (July 2007). "Praxiteles". American Journal of Archaeology. III. No 3 (3): 565–569. doi:10.3764/aja.111.3.565. JSTOR   40027086 via JSTOR.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Snyder, Colleen (2017). "The Cleveland Apollo: Recent Research and Revelations". Getty Publications. Archived from the original on 2017-12-14. Retrieved October 25, 2021.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Gardner, E. A. (1910). Six Greek Sculptors. Sacramento State University library, Tsakopoulos Collection: Duckworth and Co, London; Charles Scribner's Sons, New York. pp. 140, 166.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Furtwangler, Adolf (1964). Masterpieces of Greek Sculpture. Sacramento State University Library: Argonaut, Publishers. pp. viii, 314.