Exile and death of Pedro II of Brazil

Last updated
Pedro II in 1891 Pedro II of Brazil by Nadar.jpg
Pedro II in 1891

Pedro II of Brazil was the second and last emperor of Brazil. Despite his popularity among Brazilians, Pedro II was removed from his throne in 1889 after a 58-year reign. He was promptly exiled with his family. Despite his deposition, he did not make an attempt to regain power. He died in late 1891 while in Paris, France, after two years in exile.

Exile

Landing of Dom Pedro on Lisbon: The imperial boat approaching the Navy's Arsenal. La Revolution au Bresil. -- Debarquement de Dom Pedro, a Lisbonne. -- Le canot imperial abordant a l'Arsenal de la Marine.jpg
Landing of Dom Pedro on Lisbon: The imperial boat approaching the Navy's Arsenal.
The last photograph of the Brazilian imperial family, 1889 Familia Imperial por Otto Hees.jpg
The last photograph of the Brazilian imperial family, 1889

The monarchist reaction after the fall of the empire "was not small, and even less so its repression." [1] The "new regime suppressed with swift brutality and total disdain for civil liberties all attempts to launch a monarchist party or to publish monarchist newspapers." [2] Soon after several popular riots in protest against the coup occurred as well as battles between monarchist Army troops and republican militias. [3] Those were followed by a civil war in which monarchist military and politicians tried to restore the empire in the Federalist Revolution and the Second Navy Rebellion. [4] [5] The last monarchist rebellion occurred in 1904, in what was called the Vaccine Revolt. [5] [6] They went into exile in Paris, France.

Death

On 23 November 1891, Pedro II appeared at the French Academy of Sciences for the last time to participate in an election. [7] [8] The following morning, he dispassionately noted in his diary the news that the dictator Deodoro da Fonseca had resigned: "10:30. Deodoro has quit." [9] He soon afterwards took a long drive in an open carriage along the Seine, even though it was a very cold day. He felt ill after returning to the Hôtel de Bedford that evening. [7] [10] The illness progressed into pneumonia during the following days. [7] [11] There was no celebration of his birthday on 2 December, with the exception of a simple mass said while he remained in bed. At that time his daughter Isabel, his son-in-law Gaston and his grandchildren were in attendance. [11] [12] [13] However, he later received several French and Brazilian visitors who had come to offer birthday congratulations. [11]

Pedro II, dressed with the uniform of Marshal of the Army lying in state, 6 December 1891. Notice the book under his head. Atelier Nadar - Pedro II. (1825-1891), Konig von Brasilien, auf seinem Totenbett in Paris (Zeno Fotografie).jpg
Pedro II, dressed with the uniform of Marshal of the Army lying in state, 6 December 1891. Notice the book under his head.

His health suddenly worsened on the morning of 3 December. [14] Other relatives and friends went to see him once news of the seriousness of the situation began to spread. On 4 December, he received the last sacrament from Abbé Pierre-Jacques-Almeyre Le Rébours, curé of La Madeleine. [15] [16] That night Pedro II began declining, and died at 12:35 am on 5 December. [12] [13] [17] His last words were, "May God grant me these last wishes – peace and prosperity for Brazil..." [14] He was so weakened that he suffered no pain. [16] Pedro II was surrounded by his daughter Isabel, the Count of Eu, his grandchildren (Pedro, Luís, Antonio, Pedro Augusto and Augusto Leopoldo), his sisters Januária and Francisca with their husbands (respectively the Count of Aquila and the Prince of Joinville). [18]

According to the death certificate the causa mortis was acute pneumonia in the left lung. [13] [19] [20] Pedro II died without abdicating, and Isabel inherited the claim to the throne of the Brazilian Empire. [13] She solemnly kissed her father's hands, and after that, all those present, including dozens of Brazilians already there kissed her hand, recognizing her as the Empress de jure of Brazil. [17] [20] The Baron of Rio Branco, who was also present, later wrote: "The Brazilians, thirty and something, went in line and, one by one, sprinkled holy water on the corpse and kissed his hand. I did the same. They were saying farewell to the great dead." [18] Senator Gaspar da Silveira Martins arrived soon after the Emperor's death and, when he saw the body of his old friend, wept convulsively. [21]

Isabel declined an autopsy, which allowed the body to be embalmed at 9 am on 5 December. Six liters of hydrochloride of zinc and aluminum was injected into his common carotid artery. [22] A death mask was also made. [21] Pedro II was attired in the court dress uniform of a Marshal of the Army to represent his position as commander-in-chief of the Brazilian armed forces. [19] [22] On his chest were placed the Order of the Southern Cross, the Order of the Golden Fleece and the Order of the Rose. His hands held a silver crucifix sent by Pope Leo XIII. Two Brazilian flags covered his legs. [13] [22] [23] While the body was being prepared, the Count of Eu found a sealed package in the room, and next to it a message written by the Emperor himself: "It is soil from my country, I wish it to be placed in my coffin in case I die away from my fatherland." [13] [24] [25] The package, which contained soil from every Brazilian province, was duly placed inside the coffin. [24] [26] Three coffins were used: an inner coffin of lead lined with white satin which contained the body, and two outer coffins (one of varnished oak and the other of oak covered by black velvet). [26]

Funeral

Funeral of Pedro II of Brazil depicted at the cover of the Le Petit Journal (by Hans Meyer). Hans Meyer - Funerailles de l'empereur du Bresil, 1891.jpg
Funeral of Pedro II of Brazil depicted at the cover of the Le Petit Journal (by Hans Meyer).

In the hours following the death of Pedro II, thousands of people came to the Hôtel de Bedford. Among these were the President of the Council of Ministers, Charles de Freycinet, and the ministers of War and the Navy. [21] [23] In a single day, more than 2,000 telegrams were received by the hotel with messages of condolence. [19] [26] French president Sadi Carnot was traveling in the south of the country and sent the members of the Military Household to pay homage to the deceased monarch on his behalf. [27] Princess Isabel wished to hold a discrete and private burial ceremony. [28] However, she eventually accepted the French Government's request for a Head of State's funeral. To prevent political disruption, [29] the government decided that the burial would be officially accorded because the Emperor was a recipient of the Grand Cross of the Légion d'honneur, [19] [30] although with the pomp due to a monarch. [13] Requests from Brazil's republican government to deny an official funeral and any public display of the imperial flag were ignored by the French government. [29]

The coffin which contained the body of Pedro II departed the Hôtel de Bedford for La Madeleine on the evening of 8 December. [31] Eight French soldiers bore the coffin, which was covered with the imperial flag. [31] [32] A crowd of more than 5,000 people was on hand to witness the cortege. [31] The hearse was the same one used for the funerals of Cardinal Morlot, the duc de Morny and Adolphe Thiers. [19] [32]

Pedro II's coffin leaving the Church of Madeleine, 1891. Funeral Pedro II 1891.jpg
Pedro II's coffin leaving the Church of Madeleine, 1891.

On the following day, thousands of mourners attended the ceremony at La Madeleine. Aside from Pedro II's family, these included: Francis II, former king of the Two Sicilies; Isabella II, former queen of Spain; Philippe, comte de Paris; and other members of European royalty. [33] [34] Also present were General Joseph Brugère, representing President Sadi Carnot; the presidents of the Senate and the Chamber of Deputies [19] as well as their members; diplomats; and other representatives of the French government. [35] Nearly all members of the French Academy, the Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, the French Academy of Sciences, the Académie des Beaux-Arts and the Académie des Sciences Morales et Politiques were in attendance. [19] [32] Also among those present were Eça de Queiroz, [19] Alexandre Dumas, fils, Gabriel Auguste Daubrée, Jules Arsène Arnaud Claretie, Marcellin Berthelot, Jean Louis Armand de Quatrefages de Bréau, Edmond Jurien de la Gravière, Julius Oppert, Camille Doucet, and many other notable personages. [32] [33] Other governments from the Americans and Europe also sent representatives, as did distant countries such as Ottoman Turkey, China, Japan and Persia. [35] Notably absent was any delegation from Brazil. [19]

Funeral of Pedro II, Emperor of Brazil, in Paris (by Charles Morel, published at L'Univers illustre: journal hebdomadaire, Levy (Paris), no 1.917, 19/12/1891). Paris. -- Funerailles de Dom Pedro II, Empereur de Bresil. -- (Dessin d'apres nature, de M. Charles Morel.).jpg
Funeral of Pedro II, Emperor of Brazil, in Paris (by Charles Morel, published at L'Univers illustré: journal hebdomadaire, Levy (Paris), nº 1.917, 19/12/1891).

Following the services, the coffin was taken in procession to the train station, from whence it would travel to Portugal. Between 200,000 [19] and 300,000 [36] people lined the route despite incessant rain and cold temperatures. [37] Some 80,000 French military troops marched in the procession. [38] Two carriages carried almost 200 funeral wreaths which bore messages paying homage to the Emperor such as: "To Dom Pedro, Victoria R.I.", [36] "To the great Emperor for whom Caxias, Osório, Andrade Neves and many other heroes fought, Fatherland Volunteers from Rio de Janeiro", [36] [39] "A group of Brazilian students in Paris", [36] "Happy times when the thought, the word and the pen were free, when Brazil freed oppressed people…" (sent by the Baron of Ladário, Marquis of Tamandaré, Viscount of Sinimbu, Rodolfo Dantas, Joaquim Nabuco and Taunay), [36] "To the great Brazilian worthy of honors from the Fatherland and Humanity. Ubique Patria Memor." [36] (sent by the Baron of Rio Branco), [25] "From the people of Rio Grande do Sul to the liberal and patriotic king", [36] and "A Brazilian black on behalf of his race". [36] The "state funeral granted by the French republic proclaimed the former’s [Pedro II] personal virtues and popularity and, by implication, distinguished the imperial regime from other monarchies." [40]

All along the route, from France, through Spain and finally into Portugal, people paid homage to Pedro II. But still no representative appeared on behalf of Brazil's republican government. [41] The journey continued on to the Church of São Vicente de Fora near Lisbon, where the body of Pedro II was interred in the Braganza Pantheon on 12 December. His tomb rested between that of his stepmother Amélia and that of his wife Teresa Cristina. [41] [42]

Death's repercussions

The Brazilian republican government, "fearful of a backlash resulting from the death of the emperor," banned any official reaction. [43] Nevertheless, the Brazilian people were far from indifferent to Pedro II's demise, and the "repercussions in Brazil were also immense, despite the government's effort to suppress. There were demonstrations of sorrow throughout the country: shuttered business activity, flags displayed at half-staff, black armbands on clothes, death knells, religious ceremonies." [41] [44] An article written by João Mendes de Almeida on 7 December 1891 says that, "The news of the death of His Majesty Emperor Dom Pedro II has revealed the feelings of the Brazilian nation towards the Imperial dynasty. The consternation has been general." [45] Solemn "masses were held all over the country, which were followed by eulogies praising Dom Pedro II and the monarchy". [44] So, the "Republic stood by silently, given the strength and impact of reactions." [43]

Pedro II's coffin arriving in Lisbon, 1891. Funeral pedro II Lisboa 1891.jpg
Pedro II's coffin arriving in Lisbon, 1891.

Police were sent to suppress public demonstrations of sorrow, "provoking serious incidents", although "the people were in sympathy with these manifestants." [46] A popular gathering in memory of the deceased emperor occurred on 9 December and was organized by the Marquis of Tamandaré, Viscount of Ouro Preto, Viscount of Sinimbu, Baron of Ladário, Carlos de Laet, Alfredo d' Escragnolle Taunay, Rodolfo Dantas, Afonso Celso and Joaquim Nabuco. [47] Even old political adversaries of Pedro II praised him, "criticizing his policies" but pointing out "his patriotism, honesty, abnegation, spirit of justice, devotion to work, tolerance and simplicity." [48] Quintino Bocaiúva, one of the main republican leaders, spoke: "The entire world, it may be said, has paid homage which Mr. Dom Pedro de Alcântara has earned through his virtues as a great citizen." [41] Some "members of republican clubs protested against what they characterized as exaggerated sentimentalism in the tributes, seeing in these monarchist maneuvers. They were lonely voices." [41]

Foreign reaction also revealed sympathy towards the monarch. The New York Times on 5 December praised Pedro II, considering him "the most enlightened monarch of the century" and also stating that "he made Brazil as free as a monarchy could be." [49] The Herald wrote: "In another time, and in happier circumstances, he would be worshiped and honored by his subjects and would be known in history as 'Dom Pedro the Good'." [50] The Tribune affirmed that his "reign was serene, peaceable and prosperous." [50] The Times observed, in a long article, "Until November 1889, it was believed that the deceased Emperor and his wife were unanimously beloved in Brazil due to his intellectual and moral qualities and by his affectionate interest for the well-being of his subjects [...] When in Rio de Janeiro he was constantly seen in public; and two times per week he met his subjects, as well as foreign travelers, captivating all with his courtesy." [50]

The Weekly Register wrote, "He looked more like a poet or a scholar than an emperor, but had he had been given the chance to materialize his several projects, without a doubt he would have made Brazil one of the richest countries in the New World." [51] The French periodical Le Jour affirmed that "he was effectively the first sovereign that, following our disaster of 1871, dared to visit us. Our defeat did not move him away from us. France will know how to be grateful." [28] The Globe also wrote that he "was well learned, he was patriotic; he was gentle and indulgent; he had all the private virtues, as well as the public ones, and died in exile." [52]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pedro II of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil from 1831 to 1889

DomPedro II, nicknamed the Magnanimous, was the second and last monarch of the Empire of Brazil, reigning for over 58 years. He was born in Rio de Janeiro, the seventh child of Emperor Dom Pedro I of Brazil and Empress Dona Maria Leopoldina and thus a member of the Brazilian branch of the House of Braganza. His father's abrupt abdication and departure to Europe in 1831 left the five-year-old as emperor and led to a grim and lonely childhood and adolescence, obliged to spend his time studying in preparation for rule. His experiences with court intrigues and political disputes during this period greatly affected his later character; he grew into a man with a strong sense of duty and devotion toward his country and his people, yet increasingly resentful of his role as monarch.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Empire of Brazil</span> State in South America (1822–1889)

The Empire of Brazil was a 19th-century state that broadly comprised the territories which form modern Brazil and Uruguay. Its government was a representative parliamentary constitutional monarchy under the rule of Emperors Pedro I and his son Pedro II. A colony of the Kingdom of Portugal, Brazil became the seat of the Portuguese Empire in 1808, when the Portuguese Prince regent, later King Dom John VI, fled from Napoleon's invasion of Portugal and established himself and his government in the Brazilian city of Rio de Janeiro. John VI later returned to Portugal, leaving his eldest son and heir-apparent, Pedro, to rule the Kingdom of Brazil as regent. On 7 September 1822, Pedro declared the independence of Brazil and, after waging a successful war against his father's kingdom, was acclaimed on 12 October as Pedro I, the first Emperor of Brazil. The new country was huge, sparsely populated and ethnically diverse.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Isabel, Princess Imperial of Brazil</span> Princess Imperial of the Empire of Brazil

DonaIsabel, nicknamed "the Redemptress", was the Princess Imperial of the Empire of Brazil and the Empire's regent on three occasions. Born in Rio de Janeiro as the eldest daughter of Emperor Pedro II of Brazil and Empress Teresa Cristina, she was a member of the Brazilian branch of the House of Braganza. After the deaths of her two brothers in infancy, she was recognized as her father's heir presumptive. She married a French prince, Gaston, Count of Eu, in an arranged marriage and they had three sons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaston, Count of Eu</span> French prince; grandson of Louis Philippe I

Prince Gaston of Orleans, Count of Eu was a French prince and military commander who fought in the Spanish-Moroccan War and the Paraguayan War. He was the first son of Louis, Duke of Nemours and Princess Victoria of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha, and was married to Princess Isabel, daughter of Pedro II of Brazil and heiress to the Brazilian throne.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teresa Cristina of the Two Sicilies</span> Empress of Brazil from 1843 to 1889

Dona Teresa Cristina, nicknamed "the Mother of the Brazilians", was Empress of Brazil as the consort of Emperor Dom Pedro II from their marriage on 30 May 1843 until 15 November 1889, when the monarchy was abolished. Born a princess of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies in present-day southern Italy, Teresa Cristina was the daughter of King Don Francesco I (Francis I) of the Italian branch of the House of Bourbon and his wife Maria Isabel. It was long believed by historians that the Princess was raised in an ultra-conservative, intolerant atmosphere which resulted in a timid and unassertive character in public and an ability to be contented with very little materially or emotionally. Recent studies revealed a more complex character, who despite having respected the social norms of the era, was able to assert a limited independence due to her strongly opinionated personality as well as her interest in learning, sciences and culture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Princess Paula of Brazil</span>

Dona Paula was a princess of the Empire of Brazil and thus, a member of the Brazilian branch of the Portuguese House of Braganza. Her parents were Emperor Dom Pedro I, the first ruler of an independent Brazil, and Archduchess Leopoldina of Austria. Born in Rio de Janeiro, Paula was the couple's fifth child and third daughter child; she lost her mother at the age of three and her father at the age of eight, when he abdicated and left Brazil for Portugal, where he wanted to restore the throne of Paula's eldest sister, Maria da Glória, who should have become queen regnant of Portugal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">José Paranhos, Viscount of Rio Branco</span> 19th century Brazilian politician and diplomat

José Maria da Silva Paranhos, Viscount of Rio Branco, was a Brazilian politician, monarchist, diplomat, teacher and journalist. Rio Branco was born in Salvador, in what was then the Captaincy of Bahia, to a wealthy family, but most of the fortune was lost after his parents' deaths early in his childhood. In 1871, Rio Branco became the President of the Council of Ministers for the first time. He would become the Council's longest-serving president, and his cabinet the second longest, in Brazilian history. His government was marked by a time of economic prosperity and the enactment of several reforms. The most important of these initiatives was the Law of Free Birth, which granted freeborn status to children born to slave women. Rio Branco led the government that enacted this law, and its passage increased his popularity. His government was plagued by a long crisis with the Catholic Church that resulted from the expulsion of Freemasons from its lay brotherhoods. After more than four years heading the Cabinet, Rio Branco resigned in 1875. Following a long vacation in Europe, his health swiftly declined and he was diagnosed with oral cancer. Rio Branco died in 1880 and was widely mourned throughout the country. He is regarded by most historians as one of Brazil's greatest statesmen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Afonso, Prince Imperial of Brazil</span> 19th century Brazilian heir to throne

Dom Afonso was the Prince Imperial and heir apparent to the throne of the Empire of Brazil. Born in Rio de Janeiro, he was the eldest child of Emperor Dom Pedro II and Dona Teresa Cristina of the Two Sicilies, and thus a member of the Brazilian branch of the House of Braganza.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Armed Forces of the Empire of Brazil</span> Combined military forces of the erstwhile Empire of Brazil (1822–1889)

The Armed Forces of the Empire of Brazil were the overall unified military forces of the Empire of Brazil. The Brazilian military was first formed by Emperor Dom Pedro I to defend the new nation against the Portuguese in the Brazilian War of Independence. The Army and Armada were commissioned in 1822 with the objective of defeating and expelling the Portuguese troops from Brazilian soil.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Early life of Pedro II of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil

The early life of Pedro II of Brazil covers the period from his birth on 2 December 1825 until 18 July 1841, when he was crowned and consecrated. Born in Rio de Janeiro, the Brazilian Emperor Dom Pedro II was the youngest and only surviving male child of Dom Pedro I, first emperor of Brazil, and his wife Dona Leopoldina, archduchess of Austria. From birth, he was heir to his father's throne and was styled Prince Imperial. As member of the Brazilian Royalty, he held the honorific title "Dom".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Consolidation of Pedro II of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil

The consolidation of Pedro II of Brazil covers the period from his coronation on 18 July 1841 until 6 September 1853.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Legacy of Pedro II of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil

The legacy of Pedro II of Brazil became apparent soon after his death. Emperor Pedro II was the second and last monarch of the Empire of Brazil, whose long 58-year reign (1831–1889) represented a time of remarkable prosperity and progress for his country. Despite his achievements, he was deposed in a coup by disgruntled republicans, though there was no desire for a change in the form of government among the majority of the Brazilian people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Decline and fall of Pedro II of Brazil</span> 1880s events surrounding Pedro II of Brazil

The decline and fall of Pedro II of Brazil took place in the 1880s. It coincided with a period of economic and social stability and progress for the Empire of Brazil, with the nation achieving a prominent place as an emerging power in the international arena.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pedro II of Brazil in the Paraguayan War</span>

The history of Pedro II of Brazil in the Paraguayan War began after the invasion of Brazilian provinces by Paraguayan forces by the end of 1864.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Apogee of Pedro II of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil

The Apogee of Pedro II of Brazil refers to the decade from 1870 to 1881 during which Emperor Pedro II, and Brazil itself, reached the height of their prestige and activity. The nation experienced rapid development and the emperor was intimately involved in pushing for further progress on a variety of economic and cultural fronts. It was during this period that serious efforts toward the end of slavery began to be implemented.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Growth of Pedro II of Brazil</span> Emperor of Brazil

In the life of Pedro II of Brazil, growth in both his personal and public roles took place in the decade beginning in 1853. At the start of this period, he was still struggling to find his way. But by its end the Emperor was a mature and steady leader, and Brazil was united and on its way to unprecedented national prosperity and prestige.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pedro Afonso, Prince Imperial of Brazil</span> Prince Imperial of Brazil

Dom Pedro Afonso was the Prince Imperial and heir apparent to the throne of the Empire of Brazil. Born at the Palace of São Cristóvão in Rio de Janeiro, he was the second son and youngest child of Emperor Dom Pedro II and Dona Teresa Cristina of the Two Sicilies, and thus a member of the Brazilian branch of the House of Braganza. Pedro Afonso was seen as vital to the future viability of the monarchy, which had been put in jeopardy by the death of his older brother Dom Afonso almost three years earlier.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Imperial Brazilian Navy</span> Navy of the Brazilian Empire between 1822 and 1889

The Imperial Brazilian Navy was the navy created at the time of the independence of the Empire of Brazil from the United Kingdom of Portugal, Brazil and the Algarves. It existed between 1822 and 1889 during the vacancy of the constitutional monarchy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Imperial Brazilian Army</span> 1822–1889 land warfare branch of the Brazilian military

The Imperial Brazilian Army was the name given to the land force of the Empire of Brazil. The Brazilian Army was formed after the independence of the country from Portugal in 1822 and reformed in 1889, after the republican coup d'état that created the First Brazilian Republic, a dictatorship headed by the army.

References

Footnotes

  1. Salles 1996, p. 194.
  2. Barman 1999, p. 400.
  3. Mônaco Janotti 1986, p. 117.
  4. Martins 2008, p. 116.
  5. 1 2 Salles 1996, p. 195.
  6. Mônaco Janotti 1986, p. 255.
  7. 1 2 3 Carvalho 2007, p. 238.
  8. Besouchet 1993, p. 26.
  9. Besouchet 1993, p. 28.
  10. Besouchet 1993, p. 27.
  11. 1 2 3 Besouchet 1993, p. 29.
  12. 1 2 Carvalho 2007, pp. 238–9.
  13. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Schwarcz 1998, p. 489.
  14. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 30.
  15. Calmon 1975, p. 1891.
  16. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 601.
  17. 1 2 Calmon 1975, p. 1892.
  18. 1 2 Lyra 1977, Vol 3, p. 165.
  19. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Carvalho 2007, p. 239.
  20. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 602.
  21. 1 2 3 Besouchet 1993, p. 605.
  22. 1 2 3 Besouchet 1993, p. 603.
  23. 1 2 Calmon 1975, p. 1893.
  24. 1 2 Calmon 1975, p. 1897.
  25. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 604.
  26. 1 2 3 Besouchet 1993, p. 606.
  27. Besouchet 1993, p. 607.
  28. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 609.
  29. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 613.
  30. Calmon 1975, p. 1896.
  31. 1 2 3 Besouchet 1993, p. 615.
  32. 1 2 3 4 Calmon 1975, p. 1899.
  33. 1 2 Calmon 1975, p. 1898.
  34. Besouchet 1993, p. 617.
  35. 1 2 Besouchet 1993, p. 618.
  36. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Calmon 1975, p. 1900.
  37. Besouchet 1993, p. 614.
  38. Besouchet 1993, p. 620.
  39. Besouchet 1993, p. 619.
  40. Barman 1999, p. 401.
  41. 1 2 3 4 5 Carvalho 2007, p. 240.
  42. Calmon 1975, pp. 1900–2.
  43. 1 2 Schwarcz 1998, p. 493.
  44. 1 2 Mônaco Janotti 1986, p. 50.
  45. Schwarcz 1998, p. 495.
  46. Besouchet 1993, p. 610.
  47. Calmon 1975, p. 1907.
  48. Carvalho 2007, p. 241.
  49. Carvalho 2007, pp. 240–1.
  50. 1 2 3 Schwarcz 1998, p. 491.
  51. Schwarcz 1998, pp. 491–2.
  52. Schwarcz 1998, p. 492.

Bibliography

Further reading