John Tamihere

New Zealand Parliament

The Honourable John Tamihere
Tamihere in 2023
6th President of the Māori Party
Incumbent
Assumed office 8 June 2022
Years	Term	Electorate	List	Party
1999 –2002	46th	Hauraki	none		Labour
2002 –2005	47th	Tāmaki Makaurau	none		Labour

Election and roles

In the 1999 election, Tamihere stood as the Labour Party's candidate for the Māori electorate of Hauraki. He won the seat with 60 percent of the vote; his nearest rival gained only 15 percent. ^[9] He became chairman of the Māori Affairs Select Committee ^[10] and also served on the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee. ^[11]

In the 2002 election, Tamihere contested the newly formed Tamaki Makaurau electorate, which he won with 73 percent of the vote. He gained the second-highest majority in a Māori electorate, exceeded only by that of Parekura Horomia, the Minister of Māori Affairs. Tamihere was appointed to Cabinet in 2002. ^[12] He served as Minister of Small Business, Minister of Youth Affairs, Minister of Statistics, and Minister for Land Information, as well as functioning as Horomia's deputy as Associate Minister of Māori Affairs until 2004. ^[13]

Journalist Vernon Small said that "in the mid-2000s Tamihere was seen as a rising star, and even a potential prime minister". ^[14]

Foreshore and seabed controversy

The foreshore and seabed controversy of 2004–2005 put considerable strain on the Labour Party's Māori MPs, with many showing dissatisfaction with the party's policy. Two Labour MPs, Tariana Turia and Nanaia Mahuta, chose to vote against Labour's legislation, and Turia elected to leave the party. Tamihere, however, eventually voted in favour of the legislation, and defended it from its critics. Tamihere also criticised the new Māori Party established by Turia and her supporters, saying that it would ultimately fail. According to Tamihere, the party's leaders belonged "to a relatively wealthy, educated elite", and did not represent ordinary Maori.

Resignation from Ministerial roles

In October 2004, Tamihere was accused^{[ by whom? ]} of dishonest financial dealings, including accepting a "golden handshake" from the Waipareira Trust after stating that he would not take one, and failing to pay tax on this payment. On 15 October 2004, Tamihere requested leave from his Ministerial portfolios; he said that he had "done nothing to bring shame", but portrayed standing down from his Ministerial roles during the investigation as the "honourable" course. On 22 October, the Waipareira Trust accepted that it, not Tamihere, had the responsibility for tax on any payment, but other allegations relating to the financial management of the Trust persisted. On 3 November Tamihere resigned from his Ministerial portfolios, citing as untenable the retention of his responsibilities during on-going investigations. On 21 December, an official investigation cleared Tamihere of the tax charges, and on 14 March 2005, the Serious Fraud Office cleared him of the charges relating to his stewardship of the Waipareira Trust.^{[ citation needed ]}

Other political controversies while in office

On 4 April 2005, the magazine Investigate published an interview in which Tamihere insulted the Prime Minister and Cabinet ministers. About Prime Minister Helen Clark he said, "But she's no good with emotions. She goes to pieces. She'll fold on the emotional side and walk away or not turn up. She knows it's going to get emotional and it upsets her. We've never had a great relationship". Tamihere also made comments regarded as derogatory about other members of the Labour Party: Steve Maharey was called "smarmy" and lacking in substance, and Michael Cullen was depicted as cunning and manipulative. Women were referred to as "front-bums" and the party's homosexual MPs were also criticised. ^[15]

Tamihere denies that the interview he gave was on the record, a claim disputed by the journalist in question. Helen Clark speculated on Tamihere's having had a "liquid lunch", ^[16] and indicated that a return to cabinet for Tamihere was no longer certain. Tamihere was advised to take leave to consider his position, and began attempting to mend relations with his colleagues.

A week later, however, more comments emerged from the interview. Tamihere was reported as being highly critical of women leaders, saying that they achieved their position through preferential treatment. He also stated that he was "sick and tired of hearing how many Jews got gassed" in the Holocaust, saying that while he found the Holocaust revolting, he believed that repeated mention of it was simply used to make people "feel guilty". He also alleged that Clayton Cosgrove, previously believed to be one of Tamihere's closest allies in the party, had conducted a "nasty" campaign of telephone harassment against Clark and her husband when Clark deposed Mike Moore as party leader in 1993. These latest revelations were regarded by many as the end of Tamihere's career within the Labour Party, and Clark indicated that she saw no chance of Tamihere being elected to Cabinet again. The revelation of these comments also ended talk of a potential move to another party, the National Party being frequently mentioned, and also ended attempts by opposition parties in New Zealand to portray Tamihere as a victim of the Labour Party and to use the comments to point out the flaws within the Labour Party. At the Labour Party caucus meeting on 12 April, Tamihere attended despite being placed on stress leave by Clark. He apologised for his comments and was censured by the meeting, but was not asked to resign from the party.

Loss of seat

In the 2005 election, Tamihere lost his electorate seat to Pita Sharples of the Māori Party and left Parliament. ^[17] He had previously decided not to seek a list placement, stating that this decision was due to his desire to determine whether he had the "people's mandate."^{[ citation needed ]}

Career after Parliament

Return to Waipareira Trust

After his election loss, Tamihere sought re-election to the Waipareira Trust. He was voted back onto the board by members of the trust, but the board itself tried to remove him by changing the governance rules. This resulted in a legal case which Tamihere and the four other newly elected board members won. ^[18] As of 2020 Tamihere is still chief executive of the trust. ^[19]

Radio career and the "Roast Busters" controversy

Tamihere previously co-hosted a talkback show, Willie & JT, ^[20] on Radio Live with Willie Jackson. He is well known for his trenchant political commentaries on television, radio and through other media. ^[21] Tamihere and Jackson also have a New Zealand current affairs debate-based TV show, "The world according to Willie and JT". In 2007, Tamihere and Jackson ran for the mayoralties in Waitakere City and Manukau City respectively. ^[22] Both were unsuccessful, Tamihere finishing second behind the incumbent, Bob Harvey. ^[23] From 2011 to 2012, he hosted the TV3 show Think Tank that dealt with issues affecting New Zealanders and particularly those of importance to Maori. ^[24]

In November 2013, on RadioLive, Willie Jackson and John Tamihere interviewed a 'friend' of an alleged rape victim, "Amy". Amy discussed information she knew about an incident by a group called the "Roast Busters" that was under investigation in New Zealand. Jackson and Tamihere asked her why and how much the girls had been drinking, and why they were out late at night. "The other side comes to it, were they willing drinkers?" They also questioned why the girls, some as young as 13, had not made formal complaints to the police, asked "how free and easy are you kids these days?", and asked Amy what age she had lost her virginity. They also described the Roast Busters' actions as "mischief". Jackson and Tamihere also implied that some young girls who had consensual sex with the young men may now "line up and say they were raped as well". Amy said she believed those involved were rapists, which was met with a small laugh by the hosts, who then said: "Well if some of the girls have consented that doesn't make them rapists, right?" Many on social media were angry with the pair, calling for them to be fired or to step down from their positions. ^[25] Vodafone, Telecom, Countdown and Briscoes suspended all RadioLive advertising due to the interview. Four other advertisers pulled their campaigns from the station earlier. ^[26]

On 11 November, the pair stood down from their show for the rest of the year. ^[27] Jackson returned in early 2014 with new co-host Alison Mau, replacing Tamihere, who did not return. This resulted in Tamihere launching legal action against Mediaworks alleging breach of his contract. Mediaworks eventually settled and apologised.

Return to politics

2014 general election

In October 2012, Tamihere made moves to resume his parliamentary career by indicating that he would like to stand again for the Labour Party in the 2014 election, ^[28] but his name was not on Labour's list. ^[29] On 17 November 2012, Tamihere was barred from the Labour Party Annual Conference after criticising the party for being "too focused on issues like gay marriage". ^[30]

Local government

In the 2013 New Zealand local elections, Tamihere stood successfully for a seat on the board of the Waitakere Licensing Trust, which owns and operates a chain of wholesale liquor outlets and bars in West Auckland. He also stood, but narrowly missed out, for a seat on the Waitemata District Health Board, which also covers the North Shore and Rodney areas. Tamihere said that he did "very well in West Auckland but just could not carry the North Shore votes." He said that he did no campaigning for either post, such as attending public meetings, putting up placards or handing out pamphlets, preferring to "just put my name on the ballot to see what happens". ^[31] Tamihere did not seek election to any local government positions in 2016. ^[32]

Tamihere ran unsuccessfully for Auckland mayor in the 2019 election. ^[1] Tamihere came second, with 22% of the vote. He used the term "Sieg Heil" during a debate. After Goff stated "We won't put up with the sort of nonsense that we get from racists coming into this country to tell us that multiculturalism doesn't work," Tamihere responded, "I say sieg heil to that." After the debate, Tamihere initially denied using the term, then stated his comments were a criticism of Goff's decision to bar Canadian visitors Stefan Molyneux and Lauren Southern from using an Auckland Council venue for an event in 2018, calling Goff "a dictator". ^[33] Also during the campaign, Tamihere made a complaint over three social media posts posted by Phil Goff, but the complaints were rejected by the Advertising Standards Authority. ^{[34] [35]}

2020 general election

In 2020, Tamihere joined the Māori Party, and in April 2020 he was announced as the party's co-leader along with Debbie Ngarewa-Packer. ^[2] Tamihere was the Māori Party's candidate for the electorate of Tāmaki Makaurau ^[36] and was seventh on the party list. ^[37]

Tamihere said he would vote yes in the 2020 New Zealand cannabis referendum that was held alongside the 2020 general election, but would rather cannabis was only decriminalised rather than legalised. ^[38] He narrowly failed to unseat incumbent Labour MP for Tamaki Makaurau Peeni Henare and did not enter Parliament. ^[39] His son-in-law Rawiri Waititi won Waiariki and, as the only Maori Party MP who successfully contested an electorate in 2020, automatically replaced him as male co-leader of the party. ^[40]

President of the Māori Party

On 8 June 2022, Tamihere succeeded Che Wilson as president of the Māori Party. ^[41]

In late September 2022, Charities Services general manager Natasha Weight confirmed that the agency was investigating two charities headed by Tamihere, the Te Whānau Waipareira Trust and the National Urban Māori Authority, for financing his 2019 Auckland mayoral and 2020 general election campaigns. Under existing legislation, charities are banned from donating or endorsing political parties or candidates and allowing them to use their resources. According to the Charities Register, Te Whānau o Waipareira Trust Group had provided NZ$385,307 in interest free loans to support Tamihere's 2020 election campaign while the National Urban Māori Authority had paid NZ$70,833 to support his 2019 Auckland mayoral campaign and NZ$82,695 payment to support his 2020 election campaign and Māori Party aspirations. In response, Tamihere accused the Charities Services of discriminating against Māori causes and the Māori Party. Tamihere and the Māori Party also confirmed that they would litigate against the Charities Service if the agency ruled against them. ^{[42] [43]}

In addition, Tamihere criticised The New Zealand Herald journalist Matt Nippert's coverage of the two charities' donations to his election campaigns, which he described as racist. He announced that the Māori Party would be boycotting The Herald. ^{[44] [45]}

2023 general election

During the 2023 New Zealand general election, Tamihere contested the Te Atatū electorate for the Māori Party. He came fifth place, with Labour's Phil Twyford winning the electorate. ^[46] Though Tamihere was not elected into Parliament, the Māori Party won six of the seven Māori electorates. ^[47]

Views and opinions

Tamihere has a high public profile, much of it derived from his beliefs on a number of issues. He has made a significant impact in Māori politics by campaigning on behalf of "Urban Māori", who often have no remaining links to their iwi or hapū (tribe or sub-tribal grouping). According to Tamihere, traditional structures such as iwi do not reflect the reality of modern Māori life, and have proven inadequate for solving today's problems. Tamihere has condemned modern iwi organisations as "new feudal tribal constructs", dominated by an elite group far removed from the majority of Maori.^{[ citation needed ]} These comments have angered many prominent Māori leaders, but won him considerable popularity with ordinary Māori voters, as well as with a large measure of non-Māori supporters.^{[ citation needed ]}

Tamihere has also attracted both criticism and praise for his views on Māori self-sufficiency. According to Tamihere, too many Māori "blam[e] others for our failure", and Māori need to "take responsibility for our own actions". This has placed him at odds with Māori politicians such as Willie Jackson, who accuse Tamihere of "victim-blaming".^{[ citation needed ]} Tamihere, however, claims that the "victim mentality" holds Māori back, and that Māori need to abandon it if they wish to improve their living standards.^{[ citation needed ]}

Other controversies

Tamihere was convicted for three drink driving and other driving offences between 1978 and 1995, according to the National Business Review . ^[48]

In May 2005, Tamihere was cautioned by the New Zealand SPCA after he left two cats when he moved house. Neighbours said the cats had been left without food or water for eleven days and the New Zealand Herald reported that the two cats were discovered with feline immunodeficiency virus. ^[49]

In April 2013, Tamihere made headlines when he removed a wheel clamp himself. ^[50]

In April 2020, two doctors walked off the job at a COVID-19 testing clinic in West Auckland, after claims Tamihere told his staff to lie in order to meet the criteria to get tested for COVID-19. The clinic is operated by the Waipareira Trust, for which Tamihere is the chief executive. Tamihere refused an interview request and said it was an employment matter. ^[19]

See also

• List of alumni of St Peter's College, Auckland

References

1. "Phil Goff wins a second term as Auckland Mayor". The New Zealand Herald . 12 October 2019. Retrieved 12 October 2019.
2. "John Tamihere and Debbie Ngarewa-Packer selected as new Māori Party co-leaders". Stuff. 14 April 2020. Retrieved 15 April 2020.
3. Taylor, Alister, ed. (2001). "New Zealand Who's Who Aotearoa 2001". New Zealand Who's Who, Aotearoa. Auckland: Alister Taylor Publishers: 852. ISSN   1172-9813.
4. "Designing the 21st Century" (PDF). Local Government New Zealand. 25 July 2004. p. 8. Archived from the original (PDF) on 18 October 2008. Retrieved 7 November 2007.
5. Stokes, Jon (12 March 2007). "Brother believes convicted killer will be out by 2009". The New Zealand Herald . Retrieved 11 November 2009.
6. Tamihere, John; Bain, Helen (2004). John Tamihere: Black and White. Auckland: Reed Publishing (NZ). pp. 33–44. ISBN   0-7900-0964-1.
7. Coffey, John; Wood, Bernie (2008). 100 years: Māori rugby league, 1908-2008. Huia Publishers. p. 316. ISBN   978-1-86969-331-2.
8. Dye, Stuart (10 April 2005). "Both fame and infamy litter Tamihere's political history". New Zealand Herald . ISSN   1170-0777 . Retrieved 15 April 2020.
9. "HAURAKI 62 Candidate Vote Details". electionresults.govt.nz. Retrieved 16 April 2020.
10. Young, Audrey (7 May 2002). "Tighter line urged on Maori TV board conflicts". New Zealand Herald . ISSN   1170-0777 . Retrieved 15 April 2020.
11. Young, Audrey (10 May 2002). "Hide refuses to be embarrassed". New Zealand Herald . ISSN   1170-0777 . Retrieved 15 April 2020.
12. "Members of Executive Council Appointed". The New Zealand Gazette: 2948. 20 August 2002. Retrieved 22 July 2012.
13. "Resignation of Executive Councillor". The New Zealand Gazette (145): 3671. 11 November 2004. 2004-vr7398. Retrieved 22 July 2012.^{[ dead link ]}
14. Small, Vernon (3 December 2012). "Tamihere back in Labour but path unknown". Stuff. Retrieved 15 April 2020.
15. "The Full Monty - John Tamihere Interview". Investigate. April 2005. Retrieved 20 December 2007.
16. "PM Seething Over Tamihere". Newstalk ZB. 4 April 2005. Archived from the original on 18 November 2005. Retrieved 20 December 2007.
17. "Official Count Results -- Tamaki Makaurau". electionresults.govt.nz. Archived from the original on 17 January 2020. Retrieved 15 April 2020.
18. Stokes, Jon (22 December 2005). "Court backs Tamihere's election to trust board". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 21 December 2007.
19. "Māori doctor accuses John Tamihere of telling staff to lie for Covid-19 test". Radio New Zealand . 8 April 2020.
20. "Willie & JT on RadioLIVE". MediaWorks. 7 June 2011. Retrieved 7 June 2011.
21. for example, Kate Chapman, "Tamihere:Cunliffe's deputy pick 'smarmy'", The Dominion Post, 2 December 2011 (retrieved 2 December 2011)
22. Thompson, Wayne (23 August 2007). "Jackson and Tamihere running for mayor". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 21 December 2007.
23. "Your Vote 07 – The results". The New Zealand Herald. 14 October 2007. Retrieved 26 December 2008.
24. "Home".
25. "Roast Busters: Radio show hosts 'victim blaming' - National - NZ Herald News". The New Zealand Herald . 5 November 2013.
26. "Roast Busters: More advertising pulled from RadioLive - National - NZ Herald News". The New Zealand Herald . 8 November 2013.
27. "Expert appointed to head Roast Busters probe". Stuff. 11 November 2013. Retrieved 26 March 2021.
28. Trevett, Claire (2 October 2012). "Tamihere eyes Labour comeback". The New Zealand Herald . Retrieved 6 October 2012.
29. "Labour List for the 2014 Election Announced" (Press release). New Zealand Labour Party. Scoop. 23 June 2014. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
30. "Angry Tamihere kept out of Labour's conference". Gay NZ. 17 November 2012. Archived from the original on 13 September 2014. Retrieved 16 April 2020.
31. Wayne Thompson, "Local elections 2013: Tamihere aims to alter trust thinking" NZ Herald, 14 October 2013 (Retrieved 21 october 2013)
32. Council, Auckland. "Election results tables 2016". Auckland Council. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
33. Truebridge, Nick (18 September 2019). "Auckland mayoral candidate John Tamihere's Nazi slogan 'utterly unacceptable'". Stuff. Retrieved 1 October 2019.
34. Niall, Todd (28 September 2019). "Auckland Council Election: Voting trend remains at an all-time low". Stuff. Retrieved 1 October 2019.
35. "Complaint number 19/356" (PDF). ASA Complaints Board.
36. Forbes, Stephen (8 March 2020). "John Tamihere says Labour 'inaction' is why he's standing for Māori Party at election". Stuff. Retrieved 15 April 2020.
37. Walls, Jason (27 August 2020). "Tāmaki Makaurau now a must-win for Māori Party's John Tamihere if it wants to be in Parliament". New Zealand Herald . ISSN   1170-0777.
38. Satherley, Dan (16 September 2020). "Cannabis referendum: Māori candidates make case for legalisation". Newshub. Retrieved 6 October 2020.
39. "Tāmaki Makaurau - Official Result". Electoral Commission . Retrieved 13 November 2020.
40. @KiwiPoll (17 October 2020). "John Tamihere confirms that Rawiri Waititi will take over the co-leadership. #MaoriPol #nzpol #Decision20 #YourVote2020" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 19 October 2020. Retrieved 19 October 2020– via Twitter.
41. McConnell, Glenn (9 June 2022). "John Tamihere replaces Che Wilson as Māori Party president". Stuff . Retrieved 10 June 2022.
42. McConnell, Glenn; Piper, Denise (28 September 2022). "John Tamihere defends his charities' payments and loans to his political campaigns". Stuff . Archived from the original on 28 September 2022. Retrieved 29 September 2022.
43. Dine, Jonty (28 September 2022). "Te Pāti Māori president claims party 'demonised' by political donations investigation". Radio New Zealand . Archived from the original on 28 September 2022. Retrieved 29 September 2022.
44. Tamihere, John (28 September 2022). "Tamihere responds to NZ Herald allegations". Waatea News . Archived from the original on 28 September 2022. Retrieved 29 September 2022.
45. Edwards, Bryce (30 September 2022). "Political Roundup: Te Pāti Māori and vested interests". Democracy Project. Victoria University of Wellington. Archived from the original on 30 September 2022. Retrieved 5 October 2022.
46. "Te Atatū - Official result". Electoral Commission. 3 November 2023. Retrieved 17 November 2023.
47. "2023 General Election - Official Result". Electoral Commission. 3 November 2023. Archived from the original on 8 November 2023. Retrieved 17 November 2023.
48. "John Tamihere Under Fire Again". TVNZ. 13 December 2000. Retrieved 21 December 2007.
49. Dye, STUART DYE, Stuart (5 May 2005). "Tamihere's abandoned cats put down due to feline HIV". The New Zealand Herald. ISSN   1170-0777 . Retrieved 21 August 2019.
50. "Can you unclamp your own car?". 3 News NZ. 12 April 2013. Archived from the original on 3 July 2013.

External links

• Ministerial profile at the Wayback Machine (archived 30 October 2004)
• Parliamentary profile at the Wayback Machine (archived 11 February 2005)

New Zealand Parliament
New constituency	Member of Parliament for Hauraki 1999–2002	Constituency abolished
	Member of Parliament for Tāmaki Makaurau 2002–2005	Succeeded by Pita Sharples
Political offices
Preceded by Matt Robson	Minister for Land Information 2002–2004	Succeeded by Paul Swain
Party political offices
Vacant Title last held by Te Ururoa Flavell	Co-leader of the Māori Party 2020 Served alongside: Debbie Ngarewa-Packer	Succeeded by Rawiri Waititi