Star Raiders

Last updated

Star Raiders
Star-Raiders-Box-Front.jpg
Atari 8-bit cover art
Developer(s) Atari, Inc.
Publisher(s) Atari, Inc.
Programmer(s) Doug Neubauer
Platform(s) Atari 8-bit, Atari 2600, Atari 5200, Atari ST
Release
March 1980
  • Atari 400/800
  • March 1980
  • Atari 2600
  • September 1982
  • Atari 5200
  • January 1983
Genre(s) Space combat simulator [1]
Mode(s) Single-player

Star Raiders is a space combat simulator video game created by Doug Neubauer and published in 1980 by Atari, Inc. Originally released for the Atari 400/800 computers, Star Raiders was later ported to the Atari 2600, Atari 5200, and Atari ST. The player assumes the role of a starship fighter pilot, who must protect starbases from invading forces called Zylons. Piloting and combat are shown in the 3D cockpit view, while a 2D galactic map shows the state of the Zylon invasion. Neubauer made the game during in his spare time at Atari, inspired by contemporary media such as Battlestar Galactica and Star Wars , as well as the 1971 mainframe game Star Trek .

Contents

Star Raiders became one of the most successful games on Atari's 400 and 800 computers. It influenced space combat games such as Elite (1984) and Wing Commander (1990), as well as spawning an official sequel and a 2011 remake. Star Raiders was included in a list of ten games that were submitted as a game canon to the Library of Congress in 2007.

Plot and gameplay

Gameplay footage of the Atari 5200 version of Star Raiders. This footage shows the galactic map, the hyperwarp, a battle with a Zylon ship and long-range scan.

Star Raiders is a space combat simulator set during a galactic war between the Atarian Federation and the Zylon Empire. [1] [2] The player assumes the role of the captain of the Elite Atarian Starship fleet, fighting the Zylons before they eliminate humanity. [2] To win, the player must destroy the Zylon ships before they destroy the Atarian ship and before their own ship runs out of energy. [3] [4]

Star Raiders is controlled using both a keyboard and a joystick. [3] [5] It is primarily experienced from a first-person, 3D cockpit view and larger, 2D map overviews for long-distance travel. [6] The player can control the speed of travel in space, and the angle of display (rear and front-views), and engage a mini-display called the Attack Computer Display that displays the coordinates of enemy ships and other targets. In action sequences, the player will sometimes avoid or destroy asteroids before they damage their starship, while battling enemy ships using photon torpedoes. [5] In this mode, the control panel displays the player's velocity, energy, number of kills, and remaining targets. [7] Energy is consumed by traversing space, using shields, and firing photon torpedoes; energy can be restored by matching coordinates with a friendly starbase. [8]

The player can activate a long-range scanner, which displays a top-down view of their ship and nearby targets. When the long-range scan is damaged, the player will see the objects in the area and false reflections of them. [4] The player can also view a galactic chart, indicating the player's location, enemy ships, and friendly star bases. The player engages the hyper-warp to visit new sectors. [5] [7] A subspace radio delivers messages through the galactic chart when star bases are surrounded or destroyed. [4] Six types of equipment can be damaged in action, which is tracked using the acronym PESCLR (for photon torpedoes, engines, shields, computer, long-range scan, and radio). Damaged equipment will affect gameplay, engine damage, for example, slows ship's movement. [7]

Star Raiders' skill levels are Novice, Pilot, Warrior, and Commander. [9] On high-difficulty levels, during hyperwarp moments, players must manually navigate their ship using crosshairs while warping. [10] Zylon ships will move faster and strike more deliberately, with less randomness in their attack algorithm. [11]

Development

Atari-400-Comp.jpg
Atari 400
Atari-800-Computer-FL.jpg
Atari 800
Star Raiders was developed for the Atari 400 and 800, the first Atari 8-bit computers.

Doug Neubauer worked as an electrical engineer before creating Star Raiders. [12] While working at National Semiconductor, Neubauer programmed scenes with star backgrounds. [13]

National canceled its home computer projects, leading Neubauer to move to Atari, where design manager Richard Simone hired him. [6] [12] Neubauer became a key figure in the development of the POKEY sound chip, used in the Atari 400 and 800 computers. [12] Using the sound chip he created, Neubauer tried to emulate the sound effects from Star Trek , such as explosions, engines, and photon torpedoes. [6] [14]

During a period where Atari had fewer hardware design needs, supervisor Jay Miner allowed Neubauer to work on software that eventually developed into Star Raiders. Neubauer said he "just did [Star Raiders] for fun" and that "Atari was pretty laid back...I think Star Raiders, along with other early games, helped in finding any bugs in the Atari 400/800 chips". [14] [15] Development began in early 1979; Neubauer finished the game after eight to ten months. [16] [17]

Neubauer was inspired to make the game after discovering the text-based game Star Trek (1971). He said that it "just didn't look that interesting to play", but liked the idea of the galactic chart within the game. [15] Neubauer wanted to create something that resembled 3D space combat for the system, and was inspired by science-fiction films such as 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968), THX 1138 (1971) and Star Wars (1977). He also cited the television series Battlestar Galactica (1978) as an influence, specifically for the name of the Zylon enemies. Other game visuals such as the 3D cockpit point of view and the hyper warp were influenced by Star Trek and Star Wars. [15]

Neubauer asked fellow employees if they had algorithms for 3D motion, with no success. This led him to spend weeks figuring out the equations without using sine and cosine, which he achieved using pen and paper. After figuring out an algorithm for 3D motion, Neubauer quickly developed a star field and explosions for the game. He described his code for it as "crummy 16-bit multiplier code" that slowed down the game during the explosions. Neubauer did not know how to use the graphics capabilities of the Atari 800 computer, and could only make the screen display two enemies at once. Neubauer initially designed the hyper warp system to involve calculations inspired by Isaac Asimov's The Stars, Like Dust (1951), but decided to abandon it as "a dumb idea in terms of gameplay for an action game". [18] The way enemies attacked star bases was also changed during development because Neubauer's algorithm would sometimes make them adhere to the map while approaching star bases. This led him to add random variations to their paths to stop them adhering to the map. Due to the limited memory in the ROM cartridge, Neubauer also abandoned a feature that would allow players to dock at star bases. [18]

At the end of Star Raiders, the player is ranked using humorous titles such as "Galactic Cook", "Garbage Scow Captain" and "Star Commander (Class 1)". Neubauer did not want a number-score system and instead applied a military ranking with humorous ratings to poorly performing players. [11] One week before the game was to be ported to ROM cartridges, Neubauer was adjusting the difficulty of the game to earn certain rankings. [13] He stated the game had "a lot of ugly spaghetti code" so Star Raiders could run on less-expensive Atari 400 computers and fit on an eight-kilobyte cartridge. [11]

Release

The Atari 2600 version shipped with the Video Touch Pad controller. Atari-Video-Touch-Pad-FL.jpg
The Atari 2600 version shipped with the Video Touch Pad controller.

Star Raiders was released in March 1980. [20] A port was released for the Atari 2600 in 1982, featuring an eight-button touch pad. [19] [21] [22] [23] The following year, the game was ported to Atari 5200, becoming the first game to use all 12 buttons on the console's gamepad. [22] [24] A 16-bit version of Star Raiders was released for the Atari ST computers. [10]

The Atari 2600 version of the game was re-released in various compilations, such as the Atari 80 in One for Windows in 2003 and the Atari Anthology for PlayStation 2 and Xbox in 2004. [25] The Atari 5200 version was included as part of the Atari 50: The Anniversary Celebration (2022) compilation for Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Steam, and Xbox One. [26] This port of the game included additional content such as overlays that show player status and rumble effects when entering hyperspace. [27]

Reception

By October 1982, the Atari 2600 port of Star Raiders was among the sixth-best-selling console releases and continued to be a top-ten release in November. [28] [29]

Contemporaneous

Star Raiders received positive reviews from various computer publications such as InfoWorld , Softline , and Byte . Joretta Klepfer of Compute! did not find the game intuitive, but noted that it was both exciting to play and watch, praising the 3D gameplay, use of color and sound. [30]

David C. Cole of InfoWorld said the game is "graphically rich" and noted its addictive qualities and challenge. [31] Cole noted difficulty in the game, stating in more-difficult modes if the ship is damaged it is nearly impossible to locate a base for repairs. [32] An anonymous reviewer in Softline also noted the game's replayability and challenge, while describing the game as bigger and better than its peers made for the Atari 2600. [33] The review concluded; "the game stands repeat play well and remains quite difficult". [9] Henry Allen echoed the praise in The Washington Post , saying Star Raiders is like "the best possible combination of a shooting gallery and a planetarium". [34]

Greg Williams of Byte proclaimed "no one – I repeat, no one – has created either a home-computer game or a coin-operated video game that is better than Star Raiders"." [35] The review praised the games 3D gameplay, color, sound and controls while stating "the feature that gives it life is its real-time animation". [35] [36] Williams concluded; "to all software vendors, this is the game you have to surpass to get our attention". [36] In Electronic Games , Bill Kunkel and Frank Laney found the game similar to previous Star Trek-styled games but said; "it is far superior to all past efforts in this field" and is the game that "best demonstrates the outstanding videogame and computer capabilities of 6502-based machines". [37] In the March 1983 issue of Softline, readers voted for Star Raiders as the best program for Atari computers, with 45% more ballots than the second-place contender Jawbreaker (1981). [38]

From contemporaneous reviews of the game's ports, The Video Game Update called it a "classic space game", while criticizing the Atari 2600 version's relative quality. [19] Tim Onosko of The Capital Times wrote that the Atari 2600 version was poorly made with inadequate graphics, stating Activision's similar game Starmaster was superior. [39] The Video Game Update later reviewed the Atari 5200 version of Star Raiders, finding it to be essentially the same as the original home-computer game, and calling "unquestionably one of the best space games in existence." [23] Jack Schofield of The Guardian gave a negative review to the Atari ST version, stating the improved graphics do not make Star Raiders a better game and that the original is "still a brilliant game". [40]

Retrospective

Star Raiders was included in GameSpot's series "The Great Games of All Time"; writer Jeff Gerstmann stated the game has a level of complexity that is usually only found within text adventures of the era and that it launched the space simulation genre. [41] In 1995, Flux magazine ranked the original computer version of Star Raiders 46th on its list of "Top 100 Video Games". [42]

From retrospective reviews of the game ports, Mike Bevan of Retro Gamer referred to the Atari 2600 version as a "rather weak port" with a smaller galactic chart. The game was more expensive than the average Atari 2600 game because it included a touch-screen pad controller. [10] Jeff Gerstmann of GameSpot stated the Atari 2600 version "was pretty good on its own, but one look at the Atari 400/800 version of the game was all it took to sour someone on the Atari 2600 version forever". [41] A 16-bit version of Star Raiders was released for the Atari ST computers; according to Bevan, the controls feel "floaty", low-quality graphics, and the game was slower-paced than the original. [10]

Legacy

Star Raiders prompted several clones following its release. [43] These include Phaser Patrol , Starmaster , Space Spartans , Sentinel, and Codename MAT . [10] [43] Schofield stated in 1986 Codename Mat and Sentinel were the better attempts. [40] According to Barton and Loguidice, Star Raiders established many conventions that would be part of the space simulation genre that would rise with later games such as Elite (1984), Star Control (1990), and Wing Commander (1990). [44] [45]

Barton and Loguidice described Star Raiders is one of the best-known games for Atari's 400 and 800 computers. [44] The game remained popular throughout the 1980s; in 1987, readers of The Computer Entertainer voted for Star Raiders as the 14th favorite game of all time. [46] The popularity of Star Raiders had negative side effects for the Atari home-computer line, which was intended to seriously compete with other home computers and not to be considered a game machine like the Atari 2600. [20] When asked about the popularity of the game in 1986, Neubauer said: "It's pretty amazing, the way the game caught on. I think it was the first game to combine action with a strategy screen, and, luckily, the concept worked out pretty well." [13] Neubauer also said the game "looks pretty primitive" by 1986 standards. [13]

In 2007, Henry Lowood, the curator of the History of Science and Technology Collections at Stanford University, created a project to preserve video games. Lolwood submitted a list of games to the Library of Congress through a committee that included himself, game designers Warren Spector and Steve Meretzky, Matteo Bittanti, and Joystiq journalist Christopher Grant. Star Raiders was included in their initial game canon of ten submitted video games. [47]

Follow-ups

Neubauer made no profit from the game because Atari did not grant royalties to its developers. Neubauer left the company but later did contract work for it. [44] Atari later released Star Raiders II for several home computer systems. [10] Bevan wrote in Retro Gamer fans of Star Raiders sometimes considered Neubauer's 1986 Atari 2600 game Solaris to be the "true successor" to the original game. [15] Neubauer explained that Solaris was not a sequel, and that he preferred Star Raiders for its gameplay, cockpit view, and explosion graphics. [15] In 1994, Atari promoted a game called Star Raiders 2000 for the Atari Jaguar that was later retitled Space War 2000 . The game was later cancelled. [48] [49] [50]

Years later, Incinerator Studios developed a new version of Star Raiders , which was released in 2011. [51] [52] On the game's release, it received "generally unfavorable reviews" according to Metacritic. [53] Carolyn Petit of GameSpot compared the new version of game to the original, stating the original game is complex and ambitious with a sense of humor while the new version "possesses none of the ambition or fun of its namesake". [52]

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>Asteroids</i> (video game) 1979 video game

Asteroids is a space-themed multidirectional shooter arcade video game designed by Lyle Rains and Ed Logg released in November 1979 by Atari, Inc. The player controls a single spaceship in an asteroid field which is periodically traversed by flying saucers. The object of the game is to shoot and destroy the asteroids and saucers, while not colliding with either, or being hit by the saucers' counter-fire. The game becomes harder as the number of asteroids increases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atari 5200</span> Home video game console

The Atari 5200 SuperSystem or simply Atari 5200 is a home video game console introduced in 1982 by Atari, Inc. as a higher-end complement for the popular Atari Video Computer System. The VCS was renamed to the Atari 2600 at the time of the 5200's launch. Created to compete with Mattel's Intellivision, the 5200 wound up a direct competitor of ColecoVision shortly after its release. While the Coleco system shipped with the first home version of Nintendo's Donkey Kong, the 5200 included the 1978 arcade game Super Breakout which had already appeared on the Atari 8-bit computers and Atari VCS in 1979 and 1981 respectively.

<i>Kaboom!</i> (video game) 1981 action game

Kaboom! is an action video game published in 1981 by Activision for the Atari 2600. The gameplay was based on the Atari arcade video game Avalanche (1978), with the game now involving a Mad Bomber who drops bombs instead of falling rocks. Kaboom! was programmed by Larry Kaplan with David Crane coding the graphics for the buckets and Mad Bomber. It was the last game designed by Kaplan for Activision, who left the company shortly after the release of the game. The game was later ported by Paul Wilson for the Atari 5200 system.

<i>Solaris</i> (video game) 1986 video game

Solaris is a space combat video game for the Atari 2600 published in 1986 by Atari. The game involves a player seeking out the planet Solaris via their starship. To accomplish this, the player must navigate the galactic scanner to explore quadrants of a map. Doing so allows them to explore Federation planets to refuel their ship, and engage in combat with hostile aliens known as the Zylons.

<i>Miner 2049er</i> 1982 video game

Miner 2049er is a platform game developed for Atari 8-bit computers by Bill Hogue and released by his company, Big Five Software, in 1982. The player controls Bounty Bob through multiple levels of a mine, with the goal of traversing all of the platforms while avoiding or defeating enemy mutants. At a time when "climbing games" such as Donkey Kong had four screens, Miner 2049er had ten.

<i>Defender</i> (1981 video game) 1981 video game

Defender is a horizontally scrolling shooter developed by Williams Electronics in 1980 and released as an arcade video game in 1981. The game is set on either an unnamed planet or city where the player must defeat waves of invading aliens while protecting astronauts. Development was led by Eugene Jarvis, a pinball programmer at Williams; Defender was Jarvis's first video game project and drew inspiration from Space Invaders and Asteroids. Defender was demonstrated in late 1980, before entering production in early 1981. It was distributed in Japan by Taito.

<i>Gorf</i> 1981 video game

Gorf is an arcade video game released in 1981 by Midway Manufacturing, whose name was advertised as an acronym for "Galactic Orbiting Robot Force". It is a fixed shooter with five distinct levels, the first of which is based on Space Invaders and another on Galaxian. The game makes heavy use of synthesized speech for the Gorfian robot which taunts the player, powered by the Votrax speech chip. Gorf allows the player to buy two additional lives per quarter before starting the game, for a maximum of seven lives.

<i>Warlords</i> (1980 video game) 1980 video game

Warlords is an arcade video game released by Atari, Inc. in 1980. The game resembles a combination of Breakout and Quadrapong ; up to four players play the game at the same time, and the "castles" in the four corners of the screen are brick walls that can be broken with a flaming ball.

<i>Keystone Kapers</i> 1983 video game

Keystone Kapers is a platform game developed by Garry Kitchen for the Atari 2600 and published by Activision in 1983. The game involves a Keystone Cops-theme, with the player controlling police officer Kelly, who traverses the many levels of a department store, dodging objects to catch the escaped thief Harry Hooligan.

<i>Alien</i> (1982 video game) 1982 video game

Alien is a 1982 maze video game for the Atari 2600 published by Fox Video Games. The game has the player control a human moving through the hallways of a space ship avoiding the adult alien and destroying the small alien eggs.

<i>River Raid</i> 1982 video game

River Raid is a video game developed by Carol Shaw for the Atari Video Computer System and released in 1982 by Activision. The player controls a fighter jet over the River of No Return in a raid behind enemy lines. The goal is to navigate the flight by destroying enemy tankers, helicopters, fuel depots and bridges without running out of fuel or crashing.

<i>Vanguard</i> (video game) 1981 video game

Vanguard is a scrolling shooter arcade video game developed by TOSE. It was released by SNK in Japan and Europe 1981, and licensed to Centuri for manufacture in North America in October and to Zaccaria in Italy the same year. Cinematronics converted the game to cocktail arcade cabinets in North America.

<i>Star Trek</i> (arcade game) 1983 video game

Star Trek: Strategic Operations Simulator is a space combat simulation arcade video game based on the original Star Trek television program and movie series, and released by Sega in 1983. Star Trek uses color vector graphics for both a 2D display and a 3D first-person perspective. The player controls the Starship Enterprise and must defend sectors from invading Klingon ships. The game includes synthesized speech

<i>Pac-Man</i> (Atari 2600 video game) Atari 2600 version of Pac-Man

Pac-Man is a 1982 maze video game developed and published by Atari, Inc. under official license by Namco, and an adaptation of the 1980 hit arcade game of the same name. The player controls the title character, who attempts to consume all of the wafers in a maze while avoiding four ghosts that pursue him. Eating flashing wafers at the corners of the screen causes the ghosts to temporarily turn blue and flee, allowing Pac-Man to eat them for bonus points. Once eaten, a ghost is reduced to a pair of eyes, which return to the center of the maze to be restored.

<i>Astro Chase</i> 1982 video game

Astro Chase is a multidirectional shooter written by Fernando Herrera for Atari 8-bit computers. It was published by First Star Software in 1982 as the company's first game. Parker Brothers licensed it, releasing cartridge versions for the Atari 8-bit family and Atari 5200 console in 1983 and a Commodore 64 version in 1984. Exidy licensed it for arcade use with its Max-A-Flex cabinet.

<i>Megamania</i> 1982 video game

Megamania is a fixed shooter video game developed by Steve Cartwright for the Atari 2600. It was published by Activision in 1982. A pilot of an intergalactic space cruiser has a nightmare where his ship is being attacked by food and household objects. Using the missile launcher from their space cruiser, the pilot fends of the attackers. The game was later released for the Atari 5200 and Atari 8-bit computers.

<i>Jawbreaker</i> (video game) 1981 video game

Jawbreaker is a Pac-Man clone programmed by John Harris for Atari 8-bit computers and published by On-Line Systems. Released in 1981 before an official version of Pac-Man was available, it was widely lauded by reviewers and became a major seller. The story of its creation and Harris's Atari 8-bit implementation of Frogger form a portion of Steven Levy's 1984 book, Hackers: Heroes of the Computer Revolution.

<i>RealSports Tennis</i> 1983 video game

RealSports Tennis is a sports video game developed and published by Atari, Inc. for the Atari 2600, Atari 5200, and Atari 8-bit computers in 1983. It is part of the RealSports series of games.

<i>Star Raiders</i> (2011 video game) 2011 video game

Star Raiders is a video game for the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and Microsoft Windows. Developed by Incinerator Studios, it was published in May 2011 by Atari SA. It is a re-imagining of 1979's Star Raiders which was the killer app for Atari, Inc.'s new Atari 8-bit family of home computers. The remake is an action, first-person spaceship combat game in which the player travels through a starfield in pursuit of the enemy Zylons. It adds a new storyline, customizable ships, and multiplayer gameplay with several modes.

<i>RealSports Baseball</i> 1982 baseball game for Atari 2600, 5200, and 7800

RealSports Baseball is a 1982 sports video game developed and published by Atari, Inc. originally for the Atari 2600. It was also launched on the Atari 5200 and 7800 machines. A version for the Atari 8-bit family of home computers was also in development, but it was cancelled.

References

  1. 1 2 Scoleri III.
  2. 1 2 Atari 1980, p. 2.
  3. 1 2 Atari 1980, p. 3.
  4. 1 2 3 Atari 1980, p. 6.
  5. 1 2 3 Atari 1980, p. 4.
  6. 1 2 3 Fleming 2007, p. 1.
  7. 1 2 3 Atari 1980, p. 5.
  8. Atari 1980, p. 7.
  9. 1 2 "Softline Gameline Reviews". Softline. Vol. 1, no. 3. January 1982. p. 32.
  10. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Bevan 2010, p. 66.
  11. 1 2 3 Bevan 2010, p. 67.
  12. 1 2 3 Bevan 2010, p. 64.
  13. 1 2 3 4 Pappas 1986, p. 90.
  14. 1 2 Fleming 2007b.
  15. 1 2 3 4 5 Bevan 2010, p. 65.
  16. Pappas 1986, p. 89.
  17. Tomczyk 1980, p. 75.
  18. 1 2 Bevan 2010, pp. 67–68.
  19. 1 2 3 "Critically Speaking... Atari-Compatible". The Video Game Update. Vol. 1, no. 7. October 1982.
  20. 1 2 Fulton 2008.
  21. "Availability Update". The Video Game Update . Vol. 1, no. 6. September 1982.
  22. 1 2 Weiss 2007, p. 112.
  23. 1 2 "Atari 5200-Compatible". The Video Game Update. Vol. 1, no. 10. January 1983.
  24. "The Year in Review". The Video Game Update. Vol. 2, no. 10. January 1984.
  25. Harris 2004.
  26. Machkovech 2022.
  27. Musgrave 2022.
  28. "Video Take-Out's Top 10 Sellers". The Video Game Update. Vol. 1, no. 7. October 1982.
  29. "Video Take-Out's Top 10 Sellers". The Video Game Update. Vol. 1, no. 8. November 1982.
  30. Klepfer 1980, pp. 74–75.
  31. Cole 1980, p. 13.
  32. Cole 1980, p. 27.
  33. "Softline Gameline Reviews". Softline. Vol. 1, no. 3. January 1982. p. 16.
  34. Allen 1980.
  35. 1 2 Williams 1981, p. 106.
  36. 1 2 Williams 1981, p. 108.
  37. Kunkel & Laney 1981.
  38. "The Most Popular Atari Program Ever". Softline. Vol. 2. March 1983. pp. 44–45.
  39. Onosko 1982.
  40. 1 2 Schofield 1986.
  41. 1 2 Gerstmann.
  42. Amrich et al. 1995, p. 30.
  43. 1 2 Barton & Loguidice 2009a.
  44. 1 2 3 Barton & Loguidice 2009, p. 2.
  45. "Principles of Good Game Design". Compute!. Vol. 14, no. 1. Computer Publications International Ltd. January 1992. p. 94. ISSN   0194-357X.
  46. "The Computer Entertainer Readers' Hall of Fame Awards". Computer Entertainer. April 1988. p. 3.
  47. Chaplin 2007.
  48. Tramiel, Sam. "To Our Shareholders". Atari Annual Report 1993. "We are currently developing over twenty-five software titles, such as Alien vs. Predator, Kasumi Ninja and Star Raiders 2000
  49. "New Jaguar Titles!". Toad Computers Product Catalogue. p. 5.
  50. Le Grand et al. 1998, p. 10.
  51. Thorsen 2010.
  52. 1 2 Petit 2011.
  53. "Star Raiders". Metacritic . Fandom, Inc. Archived from the original on November 7, 2023. Retrieved July 11, 2023.

Sources