| 1958 NCAA Men's Basketball All-Americans | |
|---|---|
Members of the 1958 consensus first team. Clockwise from top left: Baylor, Boozer, Hennon, Rodgers, Robertson. Not pictured: Chamberlain. | |
| Awarded for | 1957–58 NCAA University Division men's basketball season |
The consensus 1958 College Basketball All-American team, as determined by aggregating the results of six major All-American teams. [1] To earn "consensus" status, a player must win honors from a majority of the following teams: the Associated Press, the USBWA, The United Press International, the National Association of Basketball Coaches, the Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA), and the International News Service.
| Player | Position | Class | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elgin Baylor | F | Junior | Seattle |
| Bob Boozer | F | Junior | Kansas State |
| Wilt Chamberlain | C | Junior | Kansas |
| Don Hennon | G | Junior | Pittsburgh |
| Oscar Robertson | G | Sophomore | Cincinnati |
| Guy Rodgers | G | Senior | Temple |
| Player | Position | Class | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pete Brennan | F | Senior | North Carolina |
| Archie Dees | F/C | Senior | Indiana |
| Mike Farmer | F | Senior | San Francisco |
| Dave Gambee | F | Senior | Oregon State |
| Bailey Howell | F | Junior | Mississippi State |
| All-America Team | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First team | Second team | Third team | ||||||
| Player | School | Player | School | Player | School | |||
| Associated Press [2] | Elgin Baylor | Seattle | Bob Boozer | Kansas State | Mike Farmer | San Francisco | ||
| Wilt Chamberlain | Kansas | Pete Brennan | North Carolina | Johnny Green | Michigan State | |||
| Don Hennon | Pittsburgh | Archie Dees | Indiana | Tom Hawkins | Notre Dame | |||
| Oscar Robertson | Cincinnati | Bailey Howell | Mississippi State | Tommy Kearns | North Carolina | |||
| Guy Rodgers | Temple | Lloyd Sharrar | West Virginia | Jerry West | West Virginia | |||
| USBWA/Look Magazine [3] | Elgin Baylor | Seattle | No second or third teams (10-man first team) | |||||
| Bob Boozer | Kansas State | |||||||
| Pete Brennan | North Carolina | |||||||
| Wilt Chamberlain | Kansas | |||||||
| Archie Dees | Indiana | |||||||
| Mike Farmer | San Francisco | |||||||
| Don Hennon | Pittsburgh | |||||||
| Bailey Howell | Mississippi State | |||||||
| Oscar Robertson | Cincinnati | |||||||
| Guy Rodgers | Temple | |||||||
| NABC [4] | Elgin Baylor | Seattle | Archie Dees | Indiana | Pete Brennan | North Carolina | ||
| Bob Boozer | Kansas State | Mike Farmer | San Francisco | Gene Brown | San Francisco | |||
| Wilt Chamberlain | Kansas | Johnny Green | Michigan State | Bailey Howell | Mississippi State | |||
| Oscar Robertson | Cincinnati | Tom Hawkins | Notre Dame | Jack Parr | Kansas State | |||
| Guy Rodgers | Temple | Don Hennon | Pittsburgh | Lloyd Sharrar | West Virginia | |||
| UPI [5] | Elgin Baylor | Seattle | Bob Boozer | Kansas State | Pete Brennan | North Carolina | ||
| Wilt Chamberlain | Kansas | Archie Dees | Indiana | Johnny Green | Michigan State | |||
| Don Hennon | Pittsburgh | Mike Farmer | San Francisco | Bailey Howell | Mississippi State | |||
| Oscar Robertson | Cincinnati | Dave Gambee | Oregon State | Lloyd Sharrar | West Virginia | |||
| Guy Rodgers | Temple | Tom Hawkins | Notre Dame | Jerry West | West Virginia | |||
| NEA | Elgin Baylor | Seattle | Connie Dierking | Cincinnati | No third team | |||
| Wilt Chamberlain | Kansas | Mike Farmer | San Francisco | |||||
| Archie Dees | Indiana | Dave Gambee | Oregon State | |||||
| Oscar Robertson | Cincinnati | Frank Howard | Ohio State | |||||
| Guy Rodgers | Temple | Jimmy Smith | Steubenville | |||||
| International News Service | Elgin Baylor | Seattle | Bob Boozer | Kansas State | No third team | |||
| Wilt Chamberlain | Kansas | Pete Brennan | North Carolina | |||||
| Tom Hawkins | Notre Dame | Mike Farmer | San Francisco | |||||
| Oscar Robertson | Cincinnati | Johnny Green | Michigan State | |||||
| Guy Rodgers | Temple | Don Hennon | Pittsburgh | |||||
AP Honorable Mention: [6]