1967 VFA Grand Final

1967 VFA Division 1 Grand Final
Port Melbourne Dandenong 12.12 (84) 16.13 (109)
Date	24 September 1967
Stadium	Punt Road Oval, Melbourne, Victoria
Broadcast in Australia
Network	ATV-0

The 1967 VFA Division 1 Grand Final was an Australian rules football match played between the Dandenong Redlegs and the Port Melbourne Borough. The match was held on Sunday 24 September 1967 at the Punt Road Oval in Jolimont, Melbourne, to decide the Division 1 Premiership for the 1967 Victorian Football Association season.

The match was described by historian John Devaney as "indisputably one of the most infamous matches in Australian football history". ^[1] after Port Melbourne captain-coach Brian Buckley nearly led his team off the field in protest at the performance of umpire David Jackson. Dandenong went on to win the game 16.13 (109) to 12.12 (84), securing the first Division 1 premiership in Dandenong's history.

Background

Main article: 1967 VFA season

The Dandenong Football Club had joined the VFA less than ten years earlier, and had been promoted from Division 2 to Division 1 after 1962. Port Melbourne had been in the VFA since the 1880s, and had been regular finalists since the end of World War II. Port Melbourne was the defending Division 1 premier, and had contested the previous three Grand Finals. ^[2]

Dandenong and Port Melbourne played each other twice during the 1967 home-and-away season. In Round 1, Port Melbourne defeated Dandenong by eight points, 14.14 (98) to 13.12 (90), with full-forward John Peck, on debut for Port Melbourne, scoring six goals; ^[3] in the return match, in tough, muddy conditions, Dandenong defeated Port Melbourne by four points, 8.15 (63) to 9.5 (59), with Jim Miller kicking four goals for Dandenong. ^[4]

At the end of the home and away season, Dandenong finished on top of the ladder, with Port Melbourne second. Dandenong entered the second semi-final as narrow favourites to win, ^[5] but Port Melbourne won the match by 26 points, 14.7 (91) to 9.11 (65). ^[6] Dandenong faced Sandringham in the preliminary final, winning 15.10 (100) to 11.15 (81), to progress to the Division 1 Grand Final for the first time in club history. ^[7]

In the lead-up to the Preliminary Final, Dandenong captain-coach Alan Morrow had invited Allan Jeans, then the senior coach at the VFL's St Kilda Football Club, to lead a training session, which was focussed on maximising the team's physical strength; the session was described by players as one of the toughest the team had faced during the season. Following the success of this, Jeans was invited to sit on the Dandenong bench during the Grand Final, to allow Morrow to concentrate more fully on the play. ^[8]

The field umpire for the match was David Jackson. The match was played at the Punt Road Oval, a neutral venue. ^[9] The attendance of the match is unclear, as it was reported to be 17,000 in The Age, ^[9] and 25,000 in the Sun News-Pictorial. ^[10] It was the first VFA Grand Final to be televised, as ATV-0 had secured broadcast rights for the Association at the start of that year. ^[11]

The game

First half

The beginning of the match was a tough, physical, and oftentimes violent encounter. ^[9] Dandenong had the better of play through the first quarter, assisted in large part by captain-coach and ruckman Alan Morrow, who controlled the ruck contests, and provided a valuable forward option when resting; Dandenong followers David Sheehan and Alan McDonald provided much of the midfield drive from those ruck contests, and Dandenong centre Rod Evans kept the highly regarded young Port Melbourne rover Peter Bedford quiet. ^[9] Dandenong led by ten points at quarter time, 4.5 (29) to 3.1 (19).

Off the ball, brawls regularly broke out between the two sides. On many occasions, umpires, trainers and other officials were forced to enter the arena to break up the fights. ^[9] Three players were reported in the first quarter: Dandenong's Alan Osborne was reported for kicking Bedford; Port Melbourne's Gary Ireland was reported for striking Jim McNamara; and Port Melbourne's Graeme Taggart was reported for using continuous abusive language towards umpire David Jackson. ^[9] The fighting continued into the second quarter of the match.

Walk-off

Midway through the second quarter, after a free kick was paid against a team-mate, Port Melbourne's John Peck approached and argued with Jackson. ^[12] At this stage, Port Melbourne was on the wrong end of a lopsided free kick count – by half time, Dandenong had received 26 free kicks to Port Melbourne's nine ^[13] – and Peck had been penalised more than most. ^[12] In an incident which lasted three minutes, ^[14] Peck continued to argue with Jackson, and Jackson reported Peck for using abusive language and disputing his decisions; as Jackson attempted to look at the back of Peck's guernsey to take his number, Peck repeatedly walked away to prevent Jackson from doing so. ^[9]

Port Melbourne captain-coach Brian Buckley, who was near to Jackson and Peck during this altercation, ordered his players to leave the field in protest at Jackson's performance. Half of the team had reached the boundary, ^[9] as Jackson prepared to restart play anyway, ^[14] before Port Melbourne secretary Norm Goss Sr. and treasurer John Paton ordered them to return to the field and continue playing. ^[15]

Dandenong led by nineteen points at the time of the incident, ^[16] and Port Melbourne closed the deficit to only six points at half time, Dandenong leading 8.5 (53) to 7.5 (47).

Second half

Port Melbourne played the better football in the third quarter of the match; Bedford was able to overcome Evans' defensive effort and provide a good drive out of the midfield for Port Melbourne, and backmen John Caulfield and Geoff Grover improved after leaving their men too loose in the first half. ^[9] Midway through the quarter, Port Melbourne led by seven points, a 26-point turnaround since the walk-off. ^[16] Dandenong then kicked late goals to take a four-point lead into three-quarter time, 11.9 (75) to 10.11 (71). ^[10]

Dandenong dominated the final quarter of the match, kicking five quick goals to put the game beyond Port Melbourne's reach. ^[10] Dandenong's half forward flankers, John Townsend and Brian Hill, were dominant, and Dandenong's physical strength through the game was reported to have left Port Melbourne too tired to remain competitive in the final quarter. ^[9] The final margin was 25 points, with Dandenong winning 16.13 (109) to 12.12 (84).

Overall

Both the Age reporter Michael de Kretser and the Sun News-Pictorial reporter Chris de Kretser agreed that, while the scores had been close for much of the match, Dandenong was clearly the better team overall. ^{[9] [10]} Michael de Kretser described it as "the toughest Grand Final for years". ^[9] Dandenong had an important input from its two ruckmen, Morrow and Eddie Melai, who were strong in the midfield and contributed seven goals between them while resting in the forward line. ^[10] There was no obvious choice as best player on the ground, with different sources considering Morrow ^{[9] [16]} or Hugh Mitchell ^[10] to be Dandenong's best player, and Caulfield, ^[9] Ireland ^[10] or Jim Renouf ^[16] to be best for Port Melbourne.

Aftermath

In the immediate aftermath of the match, Jackson's umpiring performance, particularly in relation to Peck, was the main point of discussion. Jackson was reported to have paid a total of fourteen free kicks against Peck in the match, ^[13] as many as thirteen of which may have come in the first half. ^[12]

John Peck

Peck was a new recruit for Port Melbourne in 1967. At age 29, he was an established star player in the more popular and higher quality Victorian Football League. He had requested a transfer from his club, Hawthorn, to Port Melbourne, believing that he would be able to prolong his career for a further four or five years in the Association. ^[17] Peck was one of the highest profile League players to switch to the Association since the 1940s, having played more than 200 games with Hawthorn, and having been the League leading goalkicker in 1963, 1964 and 1965.

Throughout the season, Peck had been consistently frustrated by the Association umpires, frequently conceding many more free kicks than he received; Goss stated that Grand Final emergency umpire Alan O'Neil was the only umpire who had "given Peck a fair go" during the season. This opinion was also held by some outside of the Port Melbourne Football Club; future Hall of Fame football writer Alf Brown of the Herald had noted this during the year, and speculated that the Association umpires may have been showing bias against Peck because he was such a well-established League player – in Brown's exact words, "we'll show this League slicker he is not going to put anything over us." ^[13]

Immediately following the Grand Final, Peck told Port Melbourne officials that he felt he had been umpired out of the game, and that he intended to retire immediately, but Goss convinced him to stay on; ^[13] he ultimately retired at the end of 1968. ^[18]

David Jackson

Jackson's umpiring performance was the subject of much discussion, both positive and negative. Those reporting on the game agreed that Jackson had made many errors in Dandenong's favour, with Chris de Kretser describing some of his decisions against Port Melbourne in the second quarter as "shocking", ^[10] and The Sporting Globe reporter Jim Blake agreeing that Jackson had made several mistakes during the game. However, Blake also praised Jackson for his courage in upholding his decisions even when the walk-off threatened to draw the game into either chaos or farce; Dandenong captain-coach Alan Morrow agreed with Blake's praise for Jackson in the difficult situation. ^[16]

Port Melbourne voiced its displeasure at Jackson's performance, and somebody at the club reportedly went as far as telling the media that "the umpiring was so poor that it upset Port's players, and put VFA football back ten years." ^[16] However, Port Melbourne did not attempt to lodge any sort of formal complaint against Jackson. ^[15]

In a separate incident early in the second quarter, and prior to the walk-off, Jackson was knocked unconscious in an accidental collision with Dandenong's Eddie Melai. The collision occurred when Melai, who was running downfield to follow the play, ran into Jackson, who had suddenly stopped and turned to follow a brawl which had just started. Smelling salts were used to wake Jackson up, and he was able to continue umpiring; it has never been suggested that his performance was impaired by after-effects from the collision. ^[14]

Fred Allen

VFA umpires adviser, Fred Allen, controversially spoke out against the Port Melbourne Football Club for the walk-off, describing the conduct as "disgraceful, undisciplined and unsporting", and stating "when a side is influenced from outside the fence to leave the ground it is beyond my comprehension." Port Melbourne lodged a formal complaint against Allen for the comment, and secretary Norm Goss made it clear that the decision to lead the walk-off was entirely that of onfield captain-coach Brian Buckley, and that it was the club's off-field personnel who in fact prevented the walk-off from being completed. ^[15] Goss also pointed out that the players believed the walk-off was justified, and were unhappy with him for averting it. ^[13]

Match day reports

The VFA commission meeting to address the four match-day reports was held on 3 October, more than a week after the match. Anticipating a hostile response from Port Melbourne in the event of findings against its players, the commission requested two policemen to attend the hearing; Goss considered this to be insulting towards his club. ^[12]

In the hearing, Peck pleaded "not guilty under severe provocation" to abusing Jackson and disputing his decisions; he had intended to plead "guilty under severe provocation" to disputing decisions, and not guilty to using abusive language, but was forced to enter a single plea for the entire charge. Jackson testified that Peck had disputed his decisions four times, used abusive language fourteen times, and impeded him from taking his number six times. Buckley, who had been in vicinity of the incident for much of its duration, and Peck both testified that no abusive language had been used, and that Peck had been seeking clarification on the decision, rather than disputing it. The commission did not believe that Jackson had lied, and suspended Peck for six matches; in handing down the penalty, the commission stated that it recognised that it was severe, but considered it to be justified. When the suspension was handed down, Port Melbourne team advocate Charles Chrimes stood up and loudly denounced the commission, accusing it of being biased against his club, and shouting "Peck has been victimised out of VFA football", before slamming his chair against the table and storming out. ^[12]

Port Melbourne's other two players facing charges were also suspended: Graeme Taggart was suspended for three matches for abusing Jackson, and Gary Ireland was suspended for two matches for striking. Dandenong's only reported player, Alan Osborne, was cleared of his kicking charge. ^[12]

Legacy

This game has become one of the most well-known events and controversies in VFA/VFL history, and in 2008, the incident was recognised as one of the 150 Greatest Moments in Australian rules football history, compiled by the Australian Football League to celebrate the 150th anniversary of the establishment of the sport. ^[19]

Many sources written decades after the match give a different interpretation of the game, and indicate that it was only after the incident between Jackson and Peck which sparked the walk-off that Peck began to concede free kicks – carrying an implication that Jackson deliberately umpired Peck out of the game as retribution. This version of events was given in a 1989 edition of the Recorder, ^[20] and on the AFL's 150 Greatest Moments website. ^[19] However, all newspaper reports from 1967 dispute this, and indicate that both Peck and Port Melbourne were already well behind on the free kick count when the walk-off occurred.

Had Port Melbourne followed through with its walk-off, it would have been the second time a VFA team had forfeited its chance to contest the premiership in protest of umpiring; in 1904, minor premiers Richmond refused to play a challenge final against North Melbourne because of the appointment of umpire Allen to the match. In this case, both the Richmond players and committee were in favour of forfeiting the game, and the major premiership was awarded to North Melbourne. ^[21]

	1967 VFA Division 1 Grand Final
24 September 2:30pm	Port Melbourne	def. by	Dandenong	Punt Road Oval (crowd: 17,000 or 25,000)
	3.1 (19) 7.5 (47) 10.11 (71) 12.12 (84)	Q1 Q2 Q3 Final	4.5 (29) 8.5 (53) 11.9 (75) 16.13 (109)	Umpires: David Jackson
Teague 4; Peck, Howell, Bedford 2; Brownhill, Ireland		Goals	Morrow 4; McDonald 3; Hill, Townsend, Miller 2; Smith, Melai, Mitchell
Gary Ireland, for striking Jim McNamara in the first quarter Graeme Taggart, for continued abusive language towards umpire David Jackson in the first quarter John Peck, for abusive language towards and disputing decisions of umpire David Jackson in the second quarter		Reports	Alan Osborne, for kicking Peter Bedford in the first quarter

Grand Final teams

Port Melbourne Football Club
Back line	George Griffiths      21 years  175.3 cm; 76.2 kg	Geoff Grover      24 years  188 cm; 85.7 kg	Barry Bonnett      23 years  188 cm; 83.5 kg
Half back line	Barry Schmidt      23 years  175.3 cm; 76.2 kg	John Caulfield      22 years  183 cm; 79.8 kg	Jim Renouf      27 years  180.3 cm; 85.7 kg
Centre Line		Peter Bedford      20 years  177.8 cm; 76.2 kg
Half forward line	Gary Brice      18 years  180.3 cm; 73 kg	Gary Ireland      24 years  188 cm; 78.9 kg	Bob Brownhill      23 years  180.3 cm; 82.6 kg
Forward line	Phil Rowlands      19 years  189.2 cm; 88.9 kg	Peter Howell      24 years  188 cm; 79.8 kg	Barry Teague       21 years  170.2 cm; 67.1 kg
Rucks	John Peck      29 years  188 cm; 89.8 kg	Brian Buckley      32 years  185.4 cm; 82.6 kg	Graeme Taggart      26 years  167.6 cm; 66.2 kg
Interchange	Malcolm Allen      20 years  181.6 cm; 76.2 kg	Gary Williams      24 years  180.3 cm; 86.2 kg
Captain-coach	Brian Buckley

Dandenong Football Club
Back line	Ken Whitehead        22 years  172.7 cm; 73 kg	Jim McNamara        21 years  188 cm; 93.51 kg	Hugh Mitchell       32 years  183 cm; 78.9 kg
Half back line	Bruce Barron        23 years  185.4 cm; 92.1 kg	Peter Stedwell       22 years  185.4 cm; 84.8.1 kg	Lindsay Staunton        27 years  177.8 cm; 77.6 kg
Centre Line		Rod Evans        21 years  177.8 cm; 76.2 kg
Half forward line	John Townsend        21 years  183 cm; 74.4 kg	Bruce Smith       22 years  188 cm; 82.6 kg	Brian Hill        26 years  175.3 cm; 65.3 kg
Forward line	David Sheehan        20 years  165 cm; 63.5 kg	Jim Miller       23 years  183.2 cm; 90.3 kg	Eddie Melai       26 years  193 cm; 92.1 kg
Rucks	Alan Morrow       30 years  183 cm; 88.9 kg	Alan Osborne       26 years  188 cm; 88.9 kg	Alan McDonald        21 years  175.3 cm; 71.7 kg
Interchange	Hubert Savory	Barry Jeffries        18 years  183 cm; 90.7 kg
Captain-coach	Alan Morrow

The field umpire was David Jackson; and the emergency umpire was Alan O'Neil.

References

1. Devaney, (2008), p.409.
2. Devaney, John. "Victorian Football Association – Premiership Placings 1931 to 1970". Fullpointsfooty. Archived from the original on 7 June 2011. Retrieved 30 September 2011.
3. de Kretser, M., "Peck’s Six Goals in Port Win", The Age, (Monday, 24 April 1967), p.24.
4. de Kretser, M., "Miller Kicks Winning Goal for Dandenong", The Age, (Monday, 3 July 1967), p.20.
5. de Kretser, M., "Dandenong Holds Control in Attack: Port's Big Task in Semi-Final", The Age, (Saturday, 9 September 1967), p.18.
6. de Kretser, M., "Dandenong Worn Down: Port's System Gets on Top", The Age, (Monday, 11 September 1967), p.20.
7. de Kretser, M., "Dandenong's Power Tells: Zebras Fade Out", The Age, (Monday, 18 September 1967), p.20.
8. de Kretser, M., "Tactical battle for VFA Flag: Changes Unlikely", The Age, (Wednesday, 20 September 1967), p.22.
9. de Kretser, Michael (25 September 1967). "Fiery grand final – Dandenong in decisive win". The Age. Melbourne, VIC. p. 28.
10. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 de Kretser, Chris (25 September 1967). "Morrow's men are premiers". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne, VIC. p. 54.
11. "VFA matches for TV". The Age. Melbourne, VIC. 4 March 1967. p. 1.
12. Carter, Ron; Hobbs, Greg (4 October 1967). "Peck Out – Six Games". The Age. Melbourne, VIC. p. 22.
13. 1 2 3 4 5 Caden, Murray (25 September 1967). "Peck wanted to retire". The Herald. Melbourne, VIC. p. 26.
14. "Umpire: How I got KO'd". The Sun News-Pictorial. 25 September 1967. p. 3.
15. de Kretser, Michael (26 September 1967). "Move for inquiry". The Age. Melbourne, VIC. p. 26.
16. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Blake, Jim (27 September 1967). "'Don't blame Jackson'". The Sporting Globe. Melbourne, VIC. p. 5.
17. Carter, Ron (25 January 1967). "Hawthorn defers Peck decision". The Age. Melbourne, VIC. p. 12.
18. Jacob, Tom (25 June 1974). "Comeback for Peck, 36". The Age. Melbourne, VIC. p. 35.
19. 1 2 "Moment #109: Borough threaten Grand Final walk-off". Australian Football 150 Years. Archived from the original on 19 July 2008. Retrieved 1 July 2012.
20. Frank Vergona (24 September 1989), "Sweet VFA – that special day", Recorder, Football Victoria: 11
21. "Football – Association final abandoned". The Argus. Melbourne, VIC. 1 October 1904. p. 16.

• Devaney, J., Full Points Footy: Encyclopedia of Australian Football Clubs Volume One, Full Points Publications, (Lincoln), 2008.