Angoon bombardment

Last updated

Angoon Bombardment
Part of Department of Alaska
USRC Thomas Corwin (1876) engraving 1887.jpg
USRC Thomas Corwin
Date26 October 1882
Location 57°29′49″N134°34′25″W / 57.49694°N 134.57361°W / 57.49694; -134.57361
Result Destruction of Angoon
Belligerents
Commanders and leaders
Edgar C. Merriman
Michael A. Healy
Units involved
USRC Thomas Corwin, detachment from USS Adams, marines. Tlingit villagers
Strength
1 cutter, 1 tug, 1 howitzer, 1 Gatling gun, company of marines one village
Casualties and losses
none Six children killed in bombardment
An undetermined number of starvation deaths due to loss of winter supplies
USA Alaska location map.svg
Red pog.svg
Angoon, Alaska
Location within Alaska

The Angoon Bombardment was the destruction of the Tlingit village of Angoon, Alaska, by US Naval forces under Commander Edgar C. Merriman and Michael A. Healy in October 1882.

Contents

A Tlingit shaman was accidentally killed while working on a whaling ship. Tlingit villagers demanded two hundred blankets in compensation from the North West Trading Company. The Tlingit allegedly took two hostages to secure the compensation, and the US Navy went to Angoon to rescue them. The hostages were released upon the arrival of the naval expedition. Commander Merriman demanded four hundred blankets from the Tlingit in tribute. When the Tlingit delivered just eighty-one blankets, Merriman's forces destroyed the village.

Public reaction to the bombardment was instrumental to the passage of the First Organic Act of 1884 which transferred Alaska from military to civilian control.

Background

Following the Alaska Purchase, the United States Army came to Alaska to serve as the civil administering entity of the Department of Alaska. Administration of the department was transferred to the United States Navy in 1879. The U.S. authorities used common law, while the Tlingit people used indigenous law. Americans generally characterized the Tlingit legal framework as based on "revenge"; in actuality it was more complex and involved "peace ceremonies" which included compensation in either goods or human lives. [1]

In 1869, two major conflicts took place between the army and Tlingit groups following retribution killings by the Tlingit against whites:

  1. In the February 1869 Kake War, three deserted villages and two forts were destroyed near present-day Kake, Alaska by the sloop-of-war USS Saginaw. Prior to the conflict, two white trappers were killed by the Kake in retribution for the death of two Kake departing Sitka village in a canoe. Sitka was the site of a standoff between the Army and Tlingit due to the army demanding the surrender of chief Colchika who was involved in an altercation in Fort Sitka. [2]
  2. In the December 1869 Wrangell Bombardment the Stikine village of Old Wrangell was bombarded by the United States Army. The army issued an ultimatum to the villagers, demanding they deliver a Stikine named Scutd-doo to justice following the retribution murder of Leon Smith by Scutd-doo. Scutd-doo's son, Lowan, had earlier been killed by soldiers following an altercation in which he bit off the finger of the wife of the quartermaster of Fort Wrangell. Following a two-day bombardment of the village and return musket fire by Stikine skirmishers, Scutd-doo was handed over to the army, court-martialed, and in the first application of the death penalty in Alaska under US rule, was hanged before the garrison and Stikine villagers. [3]

In 1878, the North West Trading Company established a trading post and fish processing plan at Killisnoo, Alaska, near Angoon, Alaska. [4]

Events leading to the bombardment

On 22 October 1882, a harpoon gun exploded on the deck of a whaling ship operated by the Northwest Trading Company. Several crew members were injured, and a Tlingit shaman by the name of Til'tlein [lower-alpha 1] was killed. The day after his death J.M. Vanderbilt, superintendent of the company station at Killisnoo, reported to the navy station in Sitka. He stated Angoon natives had taken the Killisnoo facilities, including holding two white employees, and demanded a payment of 200 blankets in compensation for the death of Til'tlein. [5] [6] [7]

Disputed claims

In 1949 and 1950, anthropologist Frederica de Laguna collected the story of Billy Jones, an Angoon resident who was 13 at the time of the attack. According to his account, villagers did not have warning of the coming of the American Ship, and every structure was destroyed. Angoon elders have stated that Jones's account should be the basis of the Angoon story. [6] Tlingit oral tradition disputes that there were white hostages involved. [8] In the '70s, the Tlingit and Haida Central Council hired anthropologist Philip Drucker to research the case. Drucker noted that in the official documents, despite the captive white men being the primary mission that brought the ships to Angoon, neither Merriman or Morris "even mentions what should have been the climax of the expedition's achievements, the rescue of the white captives, if there actually was such a rescue." [6]

As the USS Adams was thought to be too large to navigate in the shallow waters of the bay, [7] Merriman tendered the company tug Favorite and the USRC Thomas Corwin under the command of Michael A. Healy, upon which he placed a company of marines, a Gatling gun, and a howitzer. [9] [5]

Merriman's force arrived at Angoon on 25 October, and the Tlingit released the white hostages and captured property. [7] Merriman, demanded four hundred blankets from the Tlingit as a "punishment and guarantee of future good behavior" [7] to be delivered by noon the next day. [5] The villagers were only able to collect 81 blankets for the tribute payment. Jones's account and official documents agree that Merriman brought his ship to anchor outside the lagoon, and proceeded to shell the town. Under the cover of the bombardment, marines landed and proceeded to destroy the houses of the village, forty canoes, and food stores. Naval records state a few houses survived, [7] Tlingit oral tradition holds that none did. [8] While most of the inhabitants survived after fleeing the village, six children died of smoke inhalation. [10] [11] [5] [12]

Aftermath

An unknown number of Tlingit died during the winter due to the loss of winter supplies and shelter. [10]

In 1884, the First Organic Act placed Alaska under civilian control. [6] In the debate leading up to the act, Representative James Budd of California referenced Commander Merriman's role, stating "The Indians did not comply with this pre-emptory order of this royal dictator. I understand that they did not have the blankets. The commander of this United States vessel was a law unto himself, and in the morning he, a United States officer, judge, jury and sheriff, fulfilled his threat and shelled the Indian village." [8]

In 1973, the Indian Claims Commission awarded the Angoon clans $90,000 in compensation for clan property destroyed in 1882 value. Federal law limited the value of the compensation to the value of the physical damage done to the village without regard for inflation or interest. [6] $90,000 in 1882 is equivalent to $444,667in 1973 when the award was paid out. The village of Angoon accepted the settlement from the government as a tacit acknowledgment that the Navy was wrong to shell Angoon. [6] Governor of Alaska Jay Hammond declared the 100th anniversary as "Tlingit Remembrance Day". [12]

Apology

In 2024, the US Navy announced that there would be two apologies for wrongful military action, in Kake and in Angoon. Navy Environmental Public Affairs Specialist Julianne Leinenveber stated, “The pain and suffering inflicted upon the Tlingit people warrants this long overdue apology,” and “The Navy will be issuing this apology because it is the right thing to do, regardless of how much time has passed since these tragic events transpired.” [13]

Beaver Canoe

The only canoe known to have survived the bombardment was away from the village at the time. The canoe was used extensively that winter for hunting, fishing, and gathering supplies. The canoe holds special importance, as many of the people who survived the ordeal would not have survived without it. When the canoe was no longer seaworthy, the vessel was ceremonially cremated, but the beaver carving from the prow was kept as a reminder. [14] Sometime around 1911, the beaver carving was lost. In 2011, a Tlingit delegation visiting the American Museum of Natural History discovered the carving in the museum's collection, with very little documentation as to how it got there. After the beaver's rediscovery, it was repatriated to Angoon. [15]

Notes

  1. Stikine names vary widely between sources, when named this name is given as Til'tlein, Teel' Tlein, or Tith Klane

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Southeast Alaska</span> Region of Alaska

Southeast Alaska, often abbreviated to southeast or southeastern, and sometimes called the Alaska(n) panhandle, is the southeastern portion of the U.S. state of Alaska, bordered to the east and north by the northern half of the Canadian province of British Columbia. The majority of southeast Alaska is situated in Tlingit Aaní, much of which is part of the Tongass National Forest, the United States' largest national forest. In many places, the international border runs along the crest of the Boundary Ranges of the Coast Mountains. The region is noted for its scenery and mild, rainy climate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tlingit</span> Indigenous people of the Pacific Northwest Coast of North America

The Tlingit or Lingít are Indigenous peoples of the Pacific Northwest Coast of North America and constitute two of the 231 federally recognized Tribes of Alaska. Most Tlingit are Alaska Natives; however, some are First Nations in Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angoon, Alaska</span> City in Alaska, United States

Angoon is a city on Admiralty Island, Alaska, United States. At the 2000 census the population was 572; by the 2010 census the population had declined to 459. For statistical purposes, it is in the Hoonah-Angoon Census Area. The name in Tlingit, Aangóon, means roughly "isthmus town."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kake, Alaska</span> City in Alaska, United States

Kake is a first-class city in Prince of Wales-Hyder Census Area, Alaska, United States. The population was 557 at the 2010 census. The name comes from the Tlingit word Ḵéix̱ʼ or Ḵéex̱ʼ, which is derived from ḵée 'dawn, daylight' and x̱ʼé 'mouth', i.e. 'mouth of dawn' or 'opening of daylight'.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wrangell, Alaska</span> Consolidated city-borough in Alaska, United States

Wrangell is a borough in Alaska, United States. As of the 2020 census the population was 2,127, down from 2,369 in 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stikine River</span> River in British Columbia and Alaska

The Stikine River is a major river in northern British Columbia (BC), Canada and southeastern Alaska in the United States. It drains a large, remote upland area known as the Stikine Country east of the Coast Mountains. Flowing west and south for 610 kilometres (379 mi), it empties into various straits of the Inside Passage near Wrangell, Alaska. About 90 percent of the river's length and 95 percent of its drainage basin are in Canada. Considered one of the last truly wild large rivers in BC, the Stikine flows through a variety of landscapes including boreal forest, steep canyons and wide glacial valleys.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kake War</span>

The Kake War was the destruction in February, 1869, of three semi-permanent winter villages and two forts near present-day Kake, Alaska, by the USS Saginaw. Prior to the conflict, two white trappers were killed by the Kake in retribution for the death of two Kake departing Sitka village by canoe. Sitka was the site of a standoff between the Army and Tlingit due to the army demanding the surrender of chief Colchika who was involved in an altercation in Fort Sitka.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Admiralty Island</span> Island in southeast Alaska, US

Admiralty Island is an island in the Alexander Archipelago in Southeast Alaska. It is 145 km (90 mi) long and 56 km (35 mi) wide with an area of 4,264.1 km2 (1,646.4 sq mi), making it the seventh-largest island in the United States and the 132nd largest island in the world. It is one of the ABC islands in Alaska. The island is nearly cut in two by the Seymour Canal; to its east is the long, narrow Glass Peninsula. Most of Admiralty Island—955,747 acres (3,868 km2)—is protected as the Admiralty Island National Monument administered by the Tongass National Forest. The Kootznoowoo Wilderness encompasses vast stands of old-growth temperate rainforest. These forests provide some of the best habitat available to species such as brown bears, bald eagles, and Sitka black-tailed deer.

Killisnoo Island is a small island in the Alexander Archipelago in southeastern Alaska, at 57°28′11″N134°35′26″W. It is located just off the central west coast of Admiralty Island, south of the city of Angoon. Killisnoo Island, an unincorporated area, is a settlement on the island.

USS <i>Saginaw</i> (1859) American sidewheel sloop-of-war

The first USS Saginaw was a sidewheel sloop-of-war in the United States Navy during the American Civil War. The ship was in operation throughout the 1860s, but in 1870 wrecked on what is now known as Kure Atoll, a Pacific island. The event produced several books and one of the surviving boats from the ship is in a museum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the Tlingit</span>

The history of the Tlingit includes pre- and post-contact events and stories. Tradition-based history involved creation stories, the Raven Cycle and other tangentially-related events during the mythic age when spirits transformed back and forth from animal to human and back, the migration story of arrival at Tlingit lands, and individual clan histories. More recent tales describe events near the time of the first contact with Europeans. European and American historical records come into play at that point; although modern Tlingit have access to those historical records, however, they maintain their own record of ancestors and events important to them against the background of a changing world.

Chief Shakes is a distinguished Tlingit leadership title passed down through generations among groups of native people from Northwestern North America.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edgar C. Merriman</span> U.S. Navy officer

Edgar C. Merriman was an officer in the United States Navy who served as the naval commander of the Department of Alaska from October 4, 1882 to September 13, 1883, while commanding USS Adams.

Fort Stikine was a fur trade post and fortification in what is now the Alaska Panhandle, at the site of the present-day of Wrangell, Alaska. Originally built as the Redoubt San Dionisio or Redoubt Saint Dionysius in 1834, the site was transferred to the British-owned Hudson's Bay Company as part of a lease signed in the region in 1838, and renamed Fort Stikine when turned into a Hudson's Bay Company post in 1839. The post was closed and decommissioned by 1843 but the name remained for the large village of the Stikine people which had grown around it, becoming known as Shakesville in reference to its ruling Chief Shakes by the 1860s. With the Alaska Purchase of 1867, the fortification became occupied by the US Army and was renamed Fort Wrangel, a reference to Baron von Wrangel, who had been Governor of Russian America when the fort was founded. The site today is now part of the city of Wrangell.

Southeast Alaska Regional Health Consortium (SEARHC) is a non-profit medical, dental, vision and mental health organization serving the health interests of the residents of Southeast Alaska.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tillie Paul</span>

Matilda Kinnon "Tillie"' Paul Tamaree was a Tlingit translator, civil rights advocate, educator, and Presbyterian church elder.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leon Smith (naval commander)</span> American Civil War captain in Texas

Leonidas R. Smith was an American steamboat captain and soldier. In the American Civil War he served the Confederate States of America as a volunteer; he was named Commander of the Texas Marine Department under General John B. Magruder. Smith was involved in most major conflicts along the Texas coast during the war, and was described by war-time governor of Texas Francis Lubbock as "undoubtedly the ablest Confederate naval commander in the Gulf waters".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wrangell Bombardment</span> US Army attack in Alaska

The Wrangell Bombardment was the bombardment of the Stikine village of Old Wrangell by the United States Army in 1869. The army issued an ultimatum to the villagers, demanding they deliver a Stikine named Scutd-doo to justice following the retribution murder of Leon Smith by Scutd-doo. Scutd-doo's son, Lowan, had earlier been killed by soldiers following an altercation in which he bit off a finger of the wife of the quartermaster of Fort Wrangell.

Capital punishment has never been practiced Alaska throughout its history as a state, as it was abolished in 1957. Between December 28, 1869, and April 14, 1950, between the Department, District, and Territory of Alaska, twelve felons, all male, were executed by hanging for murder, robbery, and other crimes. Some were European, some were Native American, and two were African. The territorial legislature abolished capital punishment in 1957 during preparations for statehood, making Alaska the first in the West Coast of the United States to outlaw executions, along with Hawaii, which did the same.

The Yakutat Tlingit Tribe is a federally recognized Tlingit Alaska Native tribal entity. Other federally recognized tribes with members of Tlingit heritage include the Central Council of the Tlingit & Haida Indian Tribes, the Douglas Indian Association, Skagway Village, the Organized Village of Kake, the Sitka Tribe of Alaska, and the Wrangell Cooperative Association.

References

  1. Harring, Sidney L. "The Incorporation of Alaskan Natives Under American Law: United States and Tlingit Sovereignty, 1867-1900." Ariz. L. Rev. 31 (1989): 279.
  2. ""Search for and destroy: US Army Relations with Alaska's Tlingit Indians and the Kake War of 1869,"". Archived from the original on 8 July 2018. Retrieved 28 December 2017.
  3. The 1869 Bombardment of Ḵaachx̱an.áakʼw from Fort Wrangell: U.S. Army Response to Tlingit Law, Wrangell, Alaska (Washington DC: American Battlefield Preservation Program; Juneau, AK: Sealaska Heritage Institute, 2015). Part 1 Archived 19 October 2017 at the Wayback Machine , National Park Service, American Battlefield Protection Program, Zachary Jones
  4. Herring Synthesis: Documenting and Modeling Herring Spawning Areas within Socio-Ecological Systems Over Time in the Southeastern Gulf of Alaska 2015-01-11.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Crow Dog's Case: American Indian Sovereignty, Tribal Law, and United States Law in the Nineteenth Century, Sidney L. Harring, pages 228-230
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 US Navy Bombed Angoon 125 Years Ago, Dave Kiffer, SitNews, 29 October 2007
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 Alleged Shelling of Alaska Villages: Letter of the Secretary of the Treasury, 6 December 1882
  8. 1 2 3 Worl, Rosita (November 2012). Tlingit Law, American Justice and the Destruction of Tlingit Villages (PDF) (Speech). Native American Heritage Month. Sealaska Heritage Institute. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  9. 1882 letter sheds light on Angoon tragedy Archived 24 March 2012 at the Wayback Machine , 12 August 1999, GENEVIEVE GAGNE-HAWES
  10. 1 2 The Tlingit Indians want a warship named the U.S.S Angoon, UPI, Elmer W. Lammi, 19 June 1982
  11. Hoxie, Frederick E. (2016). The Oxford Handbook of American Indian History. Oxford University Press. pp. 307–8. ISBN   9780199858897 . Retrieved 23 September 2021.
  12. 1 2 The Alaska Native Reader: History, Culture, Politics, Maria Sháa Tláa Williams, pages 144-150
  13. Stremople, Clare (16 September 2024). "U.S. Navy plans apologies to Southeast Alaska villages for century-old attacks". Alaska Beacon. Retrieved 16 September 2024.
  14. Zeldovich, Lina (28 September 2017). "The American Museum of the Alive and Well". Hakai Magazine. Retrieved 30 October 2021.
  15. "The Beaver Returns". American Museum of Natural History. American Museum of Natural History. Retrieved 30 October 2021.