Barrier analysis

Last updated

Barrier Analysis is a rapid assessment tool used in behavior change projects. The purpose of Barrier Analysis is to identify behavioral determinants of a particular behaviour so that more effective social and behavioral change messages, strategies, and supporting activities can be developed. Barrier Analysis is a relatively easy to use approach that can be conducted in a short period of time, allowing implementers to quickly make decisions based on the findings. This method has been used in 39 organizations and agencies (including UNICEF and many INGOs) in 59 countries. The training manual is available in English, Spanish, French, and Arabic.

Contents

History

Barrier Analysis (BA) was developed in 1990 by Tom Davis, MPH, winner of the 2012 APHA Gordon-Wyon Award for Community-Oriented Public Health, Epidemiology, and Practice. BA was popularized by both Bonnie Kittle MPH and Davis, both of whom were awarded the Dory Storm Child Survival Recognition Award in part due to their work on this tool. BA is based on the health belief model and the theory of reasoned action. [1] Since then, it has been adopted by at least 39 organizations working in 59 countries around the world (57 of which are LMICs) to study determinants of behaviors related to health, nutrition, WASH, agriculture/food security, education, child protection, sexual and reproductive health, injury prevention (e.g. explosive ordnance risk education), city planning, and other thematic areas. The methodology has continued to evolve as it has been tested in different settings. It has primarily been used for international development, although it has also been used and taught in the developed world as well (e.g., by the Baltimore City Government for analysis of trash can use, [2] Feed the Children [3] and Hunger Free NYC [4] to look at participation in the USDA summer meals program, and the Honey Bee Health Coalition [5] ). In 2020 and 2021, multiple organizations used Barrier Analysis to study barriers and enablers to COVID-19 vaccine acceptance. Results summaries for these Barrier Analysis studies on COVID-19 vaccine acceptance in Bangladesh, DRC, India, Myanmar, Kenya, and Tanzania are publicly available.

Usage

Barrier analysis can be used at the start of a behavior change program to determine key messages and activities for intervention. It can also be used in an ongoing program, focusing on behaviors that have not changed in order to understand what is stopping it from happening.

Methodology

The purpose of barrier analysis is to identify determinants of behavior change among a specific target audience. The four most commonly found determinants are Perceived Self-efficacy, Perceived Social Norms, Perceived Positive Consequences, and Perceived Negative Consequences. Additional determinants that are studied include Perceived Severity, Perceived Susceptibility/Risk, Perceived Action Efficacy, Perceived Divine Will, Cues for Action/Reminders, Access, Policy & Culture. Typically researchers interview 45 "Doers" (people who already practice the behavior) and 45 "Non-doers" (people who do not practice the behavior) and compare the responses. When this 45/45 samples is used, a difference of 15 percentage points or greater between the two interviewee categories is usually statistically significant, but a special BA Tabulation Table is used to test for statistical significance.

The main steps in a Barrier Analysis study are: 1. A behavior is chosen for study. This is usually a behaviour that is expected to lead to significant positive impact or outcomes if adopted and one where high adoption levels have been elusive in a particular population despite past promotion of the behavior. 2. A standard BA questionnaire including both open-ended and closed-ended questions is used to create a BA questionnaire to study the particular behavior using this guidance. The first few questions are used to identify "Doers" and "Non-doers" of the behaviour being studied, and the remaining questions are based on twelve different behavioural determinants. Sometimes questions that correspond to additional determinants are added based on a literature review (e.g. adding questions on perceived trust and safety for a BA on COVID-19 vaccines). 3. Interviews are conducted with 45 or more Doers and 45 or more Non-doers of the behavior. Interviews can be conducted over the phone, in person, or using an online survey. 4. Results are tabulated, usually by enumerators or program staff. 5. Results are then entered into an easy-to-use MS Excel Barrier Analysis Tabulation Table. This spreadsheet generates Odds Ratios, Estimated Relative Risks, and p-values so that users can see which differences between Doers and Non-doers are statistically-significant and the degree of association between particular responses and the behavior. Results statements are automatically generated in the spreadsheet (e.g. "Doers are 4.2 times more likely to give this response than Non-doers"). 6. Staff/stakeholders use the findings on significant differences between Doers and Non-doers to create useful messages and activities that leverage enablers and reduce barriers to adoption of the behaviour being studied. (Instructions for this step are included in Lesson #13 of the Practical Guide to Conducting a Barrier Analysis.) Monitoring indicators can be developed to track changes in the key determinants.

Related Research Articles

Behavior or behaviour is the range of actions and mannerisms made by individuals, organisms, systems or artificial entities in some environment. These systems can include other systems or organisms as well as the inanimate physical environment. It is the computed response of the system or organism to various stimuli or inputs, whether internal or external, conscious or subconscious, overt or covert, and voluntary or involuntary.

Malnutrition Medical condition that results from eating too little, too few, or the wrong nutrients

Malnutrition occurs when an organism gets too few or too many nutrients, resulting in health problems. Specifically, it is "a deficiency, excess, or imbalance of energy, protein and other nutrients" which adversely affects the body's tissues and form.

The technology acceptance model (TAM) is an information systems theory that models how users come to accept and use a technology.

Dialectical behavior therapy Psychotherapy for emotional dysregulation

Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) is an evidence-based psychotherapy that began with efforts to treat personality disorders and interpersonal conflicts. There is evidence that DBT can be useful in treating mood disorders, suicidal ideation, and for change in behavioral patterns such as self-harm and substance use. DBT evolved into a process in which the therapist and client work with acceptance and change-oriented strategies, and ultimately balance and synthesize them, in a manner comparable to the philosophical dialectical process of thesis and antithesis, followed by synthesis.

Consumer behaviour Study of individuals, groups, or organizations and all the activities associated with consuming

Consumer behavior is the study of individuals, groups, or organizations and all the activities associated with the purchase, use and disposal of goods and services. Consumer behaviour consists of how the consumer's emotions, attitudes, and preferences affect buying behaviour. Consumer behaviour emerged in the 1940–1950s as a distinct sub-discipline of marketing, but has become an interdisciplinary social science that blends elements from psychology, sociology, social anthropology, anthropology, ethnography, marketing, and economics.

Adolescent cliques are cliques that develop amongst adolescents. In the social sciences, the word "clique" is used to describe a group of 2 to 12 "who interact with each other more regularly and intensely than others in the same setting". Cliques are distinguished from "crowds" in that their members socially interact with one another more than the typical crowd. Crowds, on the other hand, are defined by reputation. Although the word 'clique' or 'cliquey' is often used in day-to-day conversation to describe relational aggression or snarky, gossipy behaviors of groups of socially dominant teenage girls, that is not always accurate. Interacting with cliques is part of normative social development regardless of gender, ethnicity, or popularity. Although cliques are most commonly studied during adolescence, they exist in all age groups.

Behavior change, in context of public health, refers to efforts put in place to change people's personal habits and attitudes, to prevent disease. Behavior change in public health can take place at several levels and is known as social and behavior change (SBC). More and more, efforts focus on prevention of disease to save healthcare care costs. This is particularly important in low and middle income countries, where supply side health interventions have come under increased scrutiny because of the cost.

Theory of planned behavior Theory that links behavior

The theory of planned behavior (TPB) is a psychological theory that links beliefs to behavior. The theory maintains that three core components, namely, attitude, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control, together shape an individual's behavioral intentions. In turn, a tenet of TPB is that behavioral intention is the most proximal determinant of human social behavior.

Behaviour therapy or behavioural psychotherapy is a broad term referring to clinical psychotherapy that uses techniques derived from behaviourism and/or cognitive psychology. It looks at specific, learned behaviours and how the environment, or other people's mental states, influences those behaviours, and consists of techniques based on behaviorism’s theory of learning: respondent or operant conditioning. Behaviourists who practice these techniques are either behaviour analysts or cognitive-behavioural therapists. They tend to look for treatment outcomes that are objectively measurable. Behaviour therapy does not involve one specific method, but it has a wide range of techniques that can be used to treat a person's psychological problems.

Transtheoretical model Integrative theory of therapy

The transtheoretical model of behavior change is an integrative theory of therapy that assesses an individual's readiness to act on a new healthier behavior, and provides strategies, or processes of change to guide the individual. The model is composed of constructs such as: stages of change, processes of change, levels of change, self-efficacy, and decisional balance.

Theory of reasoned action Psychological theory

The theory of reasoned action aims to explain the relationship between attitudes and behaviors within human action. It is mainly used to predict how individuals will behave based on their pre-existing attitudes and behavioral intentions. An individual's decision to engage in a particular behavior is based on the outcomes the individual expects will come as a result of performing the behavior. Developed by Martin Fishbein and Icek Ajzen in 1967, the theory derived from previous research in social psychology, persuasion models, and attitude theories. Fishbein's theories suggested a relationship between attitude and behaviors. However, critics estimated that attitude theories were not proving to be good indicators of human behavior. The TRA was later revised and expanded by the two theorists in the following decades to overcome any discrepancies in the A-B relationship with the theory of planned behavior (TPB) and reasoned action approach (RAA). The theory is also used in communication discourse as a theory of understanding.

College health Health of individuals enrolled in college

College health is a desired outcome created by a constellation of services, programs and policies directed at advancing the health and wellbeing of individuals enrolled in an institution of higher education, while also addressing and improving both population health and community health. Many colleges and universities worldwide apply both health promotion and health care as processes to achieve key performance indicators in college health. The variety of healthcare services provided by any one institution range from first aid stations employing a single nurse to large, accredited, multi-specialty ambulatory healthcare clinics with hundreds of employees. These services, programs and policies require a multidisciplinary team, the healthcare services alone include physicians, physician assistants, administrators, nurses, nurse practitioners, mental health professionals, health educators, athletic trainers, dietitians and nutritionists, and pharmacists. Some of the healthcare services extend to include massage therapists and other holistic health care professionals. While currently changing, the vast majority of college health services are set up as cost centers or service units rather than as parts of academic departments or health care delivery enterprises.

Behavioural change theories are attempts to explain why human behaviours change. These theories cite environmental, personal, and behavioural characteristics as the major factors in behavioural determination. In recent years, there has been increased interest in the application of these theories in the areas of health, education, criminology, energy and international development with the hope that understanding behavioural change will improve the services offered in these areas. Some scholars have recently introduced a distinction between models of behavior and theories of change. Whereas models of behavior are more diagnostic and geared towards understanding the psychological factors that explain or predict a specific behavior, theories of change are more process-oriented and generally aimed at changing a given behavior. Thus, from this perspective, understanding and changing behavior are two separate but complementary lines of scientific investigation.

Health belief model

The health belief model (HBM) is a social psychological health behavior change model developed to explain and predict health-related behaviors, particularly in regard to the uptake of health services. The HBM was developed in the 1950s by social psychologists at the U.S. Public Health Service and remains one of the best known and most widely used theories in health behavior research. The HBM suggests that people's beliefs about health problems, perceived benefits of action and barriers to action, and self-efficacy explain engagement in health-promoting behavior. A stimulus, or cue to action, must also be present in order to trigger the health-promoting behavior.

The unified theory of acceptance and use of technology (UTAUT) is a technology acceptance model formulated by Venkatesh and others in "User acceptance of information technology: Toward a unified view". The UTAUT aims to explain user intentions to use an information system and subsequent usage behavior. The theory holds that there are four key constructs: 1) performance expectancy, 2) effort expectancy, 3) social influence, and 4) enabling conditions.

Breastfeeding promotion Activities and policies to promote health through breastfeeding

Breastfeeding promotion refers to coordinated activities and policies to promote health among women, newborns and infants through breastfeeding.

A behavior change method, or behavior change technique, is a theory-based method for changing one or several determinants of behavior such as a person's attitude or self-efficacy. Such behavior change methods are used in behavior change interventions. Although of course attempts to influence people's attitude and other psychological determinants were much older, especially the definition developed in the late nineties yielded useful insights, in particular four important benefits:

  1. It developed a generic, abstract vocabulary that facilitated discussion of the active ingredients of an intervention
  2. It emphasized the distinction between behavior change methods and practical applications of these methods
  3. It included the concept of 'parameters for effectiveness', important conditions for effectiveness often neglected
  4. It drew attention to the fact that behavior change methods influence specific determinants.

Adolescent sexuality in Canada is not as well documented as adolescent sexuality in the United States; despite the proximity of the two nations, Canada has its own unique culture and generalizations about Canadian adolescent sexuality based on American research can be misleading. Because of this, several surveys and studies have been conducted which acquired information on Canadian adolescent sexuality. Surveys which provide this information include the Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS), the National Population Health Survey (NPHS) and the National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth (NLSCY). According to information drawn from the Canadian Community Health Survey and the National Population Health Survey, in 2005 43% of teens aged 15 to 19 reported that they had had sexual intercourse at least once.

Sander van der Linden Social psychologist

Sander L. van der Linden is a social psychologist and professor of social psychology in society in the department of psychology at the University of Cambridge, England where he has directed the Cambridge Social Decision-Making Laboratory since 2016. He is also a fellow and director of studies in psychological and behavioural sciences at Churchill College, Cambridge, a research affiliate of the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication at Yale University and the Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication at the University of Cambridge.

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on children Overview of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on children

A systematic review notes that children with COVID-19 have milder effects and better prognoses than adults. However, children are susceptible to "multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children" (MIS-C), a rare but life-threatening systemic illness involving persistent fever and extreme inflammation following exposure to the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

References

  1. Davis, Tom. "FH Tools for PM2A Projects: Barrier Analysis" . Retrieved 15 December 2012.
  2. Rockoff, Jonathan D. (12 July 2005). "City launches initiative to boost trash-can use". Baltimore Sun. Retrieved 15 December 2012.
  3. "Home". feedthechildren.org.
  4. "Hunger Free America" (PDF).
  5. "Home". honeybeehealthcoalition.org.