Brood reduction

Last updated

Brood reduction occurs when the number of nestlings in a birds brood is reduced, usually because there is a limited amount of resources available. It can occur directly via infanticide, or indirectly via competition over resources between siblings. [1] Avian parents often produce more offspring than they can care for, resulting in the death of some of the nestlings. Brood reduction was originally described by David Lack in his brood-reduction hypothesis to explain the existence of hatching asynchrony in many bird species. [2]

Contents

Bird nest in which hatching asynchrony is occurring. Baby birds in nest02.jpg
Bird nest in which hatching asynchrony is occurring.

Hatching asynchrony occurs when the parents start incubating their eggs before all of them have been laid. [3] If resources are limited, it benefits the parents to allow brood reduction, because it reduces the amount of work they must do and increases their chances of surviving and reproducing again in future years. [3]

Brood reduction has been observed in many avian species including seabirds such as black-legged kittiwakes, [4] [5] birds of prey such as Swainson's hawk [6] and several eagle species, [7] and songbirds including black-billed magpies [8] and house wrens. [9]

Methods of brood reduction

Infanticide

Brood reduction often occurs as infanticide, the killing of nestlings by members of the same species. Infanticide can be done by siblings, which is referred to as siblicide, or by the parents, which is called filial infanticide. In virtually all species, brood reduction only occurs via siblicide, however in some species such as the white stork, filial infanticide has been observed. [10] [11] Siblicide often occurs via harassment and intimidation, preventing the smaller chicks from having enough food. [7] However, fatal aggression between siblings is also common. [1]

Golden eagle nestling. Golden eagle chick, circa 1938 (6478691399).jpg
Golden eagle nestling.

Brood reduction by means of siblicide can be facultative or obligate. Facultative brood reduction depends on the conditions of that particular year, and only occurs when there is a limit to the resources available for the nestlings. Obligate brood reduction always occurs and does not depend on food availability.

Hatching asynchrony results in a dominance hierarchy between the nestlings, which often leads to the death of the youngest sibling. [7] This can be seen in several species of birds of prey, such as eagles, and depends on the size difference between the siblings and therefore the amount of time that passes between each egg hatching. [7] In the crowned eagle, the time interval between eggs hatching is 3 days, and in this species the brood reduction observed is obligate. [7] In other eagle species, such as the greater spotted eagle and the imperial eagle, the hatching interval is only 2 days, and the type of brood reduction observed is facultative brood reduction. [7]

Brood parasitism

Brown-headed cowbird as a brood parasite. Savannah Sparrow, Passerculus sandwichensis, nestlings baby birds and eggs with much larger Brown-headed cowbird, Molothrus ater nestling AB Canada (2).jpg
Brown-headed cowbird as a brood parasite.

Brood reduction can also be done by members of a different species. This can be seen in interspecific brood parasitism. Brood parasites lay their eggs in the nest of another bird species, relying on the host parents to raise their offspring. Brood parasitism can lead to brood reduction in different ways. Some brood parasites kill the eggs of the host species so that there is no competition for their own offspring. [12] Parasitic nestlings can also cause brood reduction by out-competing the host species nestlings, or by simply killing them. [12] Two species of cowbirds, the shiny cowbird, and the screaming cowbird, frequently parasitize the nests of the brown-and-yellow marshbird, resulting in an increased amount of brood reduction in this species. [12]

Lack's hypothesis

The brood-reduction hypothesis was first proposed by David Lack in 1947 to explain the evolution of hatching asynchrony and dominance hierarchy in the broods of some bird species. [2] The hypothesis stated that hatching asynchrony exists to maximize the fitness of the nestlings in years where resources are low. [2] During these years, the asynchronous pattern allows the brood size to be reduced to an amount that can be supported by the parents, by either directly killing the weakest nestlings or by siblings out-competing them. [13] Hatching asynchrony would have no cost during years when resources are plentiful, and the whole brood would survive. [2]

In a study on brood reduction in the common kestrel, it was shown that when brood reduction occurred in asynchronous nests, the cellular immunity of the nestlings improved compared to those in synchronous nests. [14]

Criticisms of the hypothesis

Lack's assumption that there is no cost associated with hatching asynchrony during years where food is plentiful can not be proven. [2] Studies show that competition remains a factor even when there are enough resources and that the last nestling to hatch is still at a disadvantage. [2] In orders to test Lack's hypothesis, brood reduction must be adaptive, which can be determined by comparing the success of asynchronous broods and synchronous broods. [2] Birds that have naturally synchronous broods must have higher nestling mortality when there are insufficient resources. [3] It has been suggested that this can be tested using artificially synchronous broods, however, this artificial manipulation may have an effect on resource use. [2] Also, in order to test this, the brood reduction threshold must be crossed. In other words, the conditions must be poor enough for brood reduction to occur. It is also possible that brood reduction could occur even when resources are plentiful, in this case being a maladaptive trait. [3] Another criticism of the hypothesis is that there is no general threshold for brood reduction; conditions are not static and are not always the same for all individuals. [2]

An alternate hypothesis that builds off of Lack's is the Offspring Quality Assurance Hypothesis. [2] This hypothesis states that the benefit to hatching asynchrony is the hierarchy created from it. The hierarchy guarantees that at least some of the nestlings will survive, and whether or not some of the weaker nestlings die is irrelevant.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White stork</span> Species of bird

The white stork is a large bird in the stork family, Ciconiidae. Its plumage is mainly white, with black on the bird's wings. Adults have long red legs and long pointed red beaks, and measure on average 100–115 cm (39–45 in) from beak tip to end of tail, with a 155–215 cm (61–85 in) wingspan. The two subspecies, which differ slightly in size, breed in Europe, northwestern Africa, southwestern Asia and southern Africa. The white stork is a long-distance migrant, wintering in Africa from tropical Sub-Saharan Africa to as far south as South Africa, or on the Indian subcontinent. When migrating between Europe and Africa, it avoids crossing the Mediterranean Sea and detours via the Levant in the east or the Strait of Gibraltar in the west, because the air thermals on which it depends for soaring do not form over water.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Black stork</span> Large migratory bird in the family Ciconiidae

The black stork is a large bird in the stork family Ciconiidae. It was first described by Carl Linnaeus in the 10th edition of his Systema Naturae. Measuring on average 95 to 100 cm from beak tip to end of tail with a 145-to-155 cm (57-to-61 in) wingspan, the adult black stork has mainly black plumage, with white underparts, long red legs and a long pointed red beak. A widespread but uncommon species, it breeds in scattered locations across Europe, and east across the Palearctic to the Pacific Ocean. It is a long-distance migrant, with European populations wintering in tropical Sub-Saharan Africa, and Asian populations in the Indian subcontinent. When migrating between Europe and Africa, it avoids crossing broad expanses of the Mediterranean Sea and detours via the Levant in the east, the Strait of Sicily in the center, or the Strait of Gibraltar in the west. An isolated, non-migratory, population occurs in Southern Africa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tree swallow</span> Species of bird in the Americas

The tree swallow is a migratory bird of the family Hirundinidae. Found in the Americas, the tree swallow was first described in 1807 by French ornithologist Louis Vieillot as Hirundo bicolor. It has since been moved to its current genus, Tachycineta, within which its phylogenetic placement is debated. The tree swallow has glossy blue-green upperparts, with the exception of the blackish wings and tail, and white underparts. The bill is black, the eyes dark brown, and the legs and feet pale brown. The female is generally duller than the male, and the first-year female has mostly brown upperparts, with some blue feathers. Juveniles have brown upperparts, and grey-brown-washed breasts. The tree swallow breeds in the US and Canada. It winters along southern US coasts south, along the Gulf Coast, to Panama and the northwestern coast of South America, and in the West Indies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brown-headed cowbird</span> Species of bird

The brown-headed cowbird is a small, obligate brood parasitic icterid native to temperate and subtropical North America. It is a permanent resident in the southern parts of its range; northern birds migrate to the southern United States and Mexico in winter, returning to their summer habitat around March or April.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brood parasitism</span> Subclass of parasitism, phenomenon that an animal relies on other inidivids to raise its young.

Brood parasitism is a subclass of parasitism and phenomenon and behavioural pattern of certain animals, brood parasites, that rely on others to raise their young. The strategy appears among birds, insects and fish. The brood parasite manipulates a host, either of the same or of another species, to raise its young as if it were its own, usually using egg mimicry, with eggs that resemble the host's.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Blue-footed booby</span> Species of bird

The blue-footed booby is a marine bird native to subtropical and tropical regions of the eastern Pacific Ocean. It is one of six species of the genus Sula – known as boobies. It is easily recognizable by its distinctive bright blue feet, which is a sexually selected trait and a product of their diet. Males display their feet in an elaborate mating ritual by lifting them up and down while strutting before the female. The female is slightly larger than the male and can measure up to 90 cm (35 in) long with a wingspan up to 1.5 m (5 ft).

Parent–offspring conflict (POC) is an expression coined in 1974 by Robert Trivers. It is used to describe the evolutionary conflict arising from differences in optimal parental investment (PI) in an offspring from the standpoint of the parent and the offspring. PI is any investment by the parent in an individual offspring that decreases the parent's ability to invest in other offspring, while the selected offspring's chance of surviving increases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shiny cowbird</span> Species of bird

The shiny cowbird is a passerine bird in the New World family Icteridae. It breeds in most of South America except for dense forests and areas of high altitude such as mountains. Since 1900 the shiny cowbird's range has shifted northward, and it was recorded in the Caribbean islands as well as the United States, where it is found breeding in southern Florida. It is a bird associated with open habitats, including disturbed land from agriculture and deforestation.

<i>Acanthiza</i> Genus of birds

Acanthiza is a genus of passeriform birds, most endemic to Australia, but with two species restricted to New Guinea. These birds are commonly known as thornbills. They are not closely related to species in the hummingbird genera Chalcostigma and Ramphomicron, which are also called thornbills.

<i>Aechmophorus</i> Genus of birds

Aechmophorus is a genus of birds in the grebe family.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nazca booby</span> Species of bird

The Nazca booby is a large seabird of the booby family, Sulidae, native to the eastern Pacific. First described by Walter Rothschild in 1902, it was long considered a subspecies of the masked booby until recognised as distinct genetically and behaviorally in 2002. It has a typical sulid body shape, with a long pointed orange-yellow bill, long neck, aerodynamic body, long slender wings and pointed tail. The adult is bright white with black and white wings, a black tail and a dark face mask.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siblicide</span>

Siblicide is the killing of an infant individual by its close relatives. It may occur directly between siblings or be mediated by the parents, and is driven by the direct fitness benefits to the perpetrator and sometimes its parents. Siblicide has mainly, but not only, been observed in birds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maguari stork</span> Species of bird

The maguari stork is a large species of stork that inhabits seasonal wetlands over much of South America, and is very similar in appearance to the white stork; albeit slightly larger. It is the only species of its genus to occur in the New World and is one of the only three New World stork species, together with the wood stork and the jabiru.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Blue-throated bee-eater</span> Species of bird

The blue-throated bee-eater is a species of bird in the bee-eater family. They are found throughout southeast Asia in subtropical or tropical mangrove forests. Their diet consists mostly of bees, wasps, and dragonflies. Blue-throated bee-eaters are small with colorful plumage consisting of a red nape, dark green wings, light green breast, and their signature blue throat. Juvenile plumage contain dark green head and wings and light green breasts, only developing their full plumage in adulthood. They have a rich variety of songs and calls, including longcalls which allow them to communicate long distances in the forest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Screaming cowbird</span> Species of bird

The screaming cowbird is an obligate brood parasite belonging to the family Icteridae and is found in South America. It is also known commonly as the short billed cowbird.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Egg tossing (behavior)</span>

Egg tossing or egg destruction is a behavior observed in some species of birds where one individual removes an egg from the communal nest. This is related to infanticide, where parents kill their own or other's offspring. Egg tossing is observed in avian species, most commonly females, who are involved with cooperative breeding or brood parasitism. Among colonial non-co-nesting birds, egg-tossing is observed to be performed by an individual of the same species, and, in the case of brood parasites, this behavior is done by either the same or different species. The behavior of egg tossing offers its advantages and disadvantages to both the actor and recipient.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Seabird breeding behavior</span>

The term seabird is used for many families of birds in several orders that spend the majority of their lives at sea. Seabirds make up some, if not all, of the families in the following orders: Procellariiformes, Sphenisciformes, Pelecaniformes, and Charadriiformes. Many seabirds remain at sea for several consecutive years at a time, without ever seeing land. Breeding is the central purpose for seabirds to visit land. The breeding period is usually extremely protracted in many seabirds and may last over a year in some of the larger albatrosses; this is in stark contrast with passerine birds. Seabirds nest in single or mixed-species colonies of varying densities, mainly on offshore islands devoid of terrestrial predators. However, seabirds exhibit many unusual breeding behaviors during all stages of the reproductive cycle that are not extensively reported outside of the primary scientific literature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Avian clutch size</span>

Clutch size refers to the number of eggs laid in a single brood by a nesting pair of birds. The numbers laid by a particular species in a given location are usually well defined by evolutionary trade-offs with many factors involved, including resource availability and energetic constraints. Several patterns of variation have been noted and the relationship between latitude and clutch size has been a topic of interest in avian reproduction and evolution. David Lack and R.E. Moreau were among the first to investigate the effect of latitude on the number of eggs per nest. Since Lack's first paper in the mid-1940s there has been extensive research on the pattern of increasing clutch size with increasing latitude. The proximate and ultimate causes for this pattern have been a subject of intense debate involving the development of ideas on group, individual, and gene-centric views of selection.

Animals, including siblings, compete for resources such as food, territory, and potential mating partners. In animal sibling rivalry, individuals compete for parental care or limited resources, which can sometimes result in siblicide, the killing of siblings. Sibling rivalry occurs in many different forms. Siblings may compete for resources in a prenatal and/or post-birth environment. The degree of rivalry varies, ranging from a low level of violence in non-aggressive to the killing of kin in siblicide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reproduction and life cycle of the golden eagle</span>

Golden eagles usually mate for life. A breeding pair is formed in a courtship display. This courtship includes undulating displays by both in the pair, with the male bird picking up a piece of rock and dropping it only to enter into a steep dive and catch it in mid-air, repeating the maneuver 3 or more times. The female takes a clump of earth and drops and catches it in the same fashion. Small sticks may also be used in this display. Compared to the bald eagle, golden eagles do not repeat courtship displays annually and rarely engage in talon-locking downward spirals.

References

  1. 1 2 Anderson, David J. (1995). "The Role of Parents in Sibilicidal Brood Reduction of Two Booby Species". The Auk. 112 (4): 860–869. doi:10.2307/4089018. JSTOR   4089018.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Amundsen, Trond; Slagsvold, Tore (1996). "Lack's Brood Reduction Hypothesis and Avian Hatching Asynchrony: What's Next?". Oikos. 76 (3): 613–620. doi:10.2307/3546359. JSTOR   3546359.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Mock, Douglas W.; Forbes, L. Scott (1994). "Life-History Consequences of Avian Brood Reduction". The Auk. 111 (1): 115–123. doi: 10.2307/4088510 . JSTOR   4088510.
  4. Giudici, Paula I.; Quintana, Flavio; Svagelj, Walter S. (2017). "The Role of Hatching Asynchrony in a Seabird Species Exhibiting Obligate Brood Reduction". Waterbirds. 40 (3): 221–232. doi:10.1675/063.040.0304. ISSN   1524-4695.
  5. Braun, Barbara M.; Hunt, George L. (1983). "Brood Reduction in Black-Legged Kittiwakes". The Auk. 100 (2): 469–476. doi:10.1093/auk/100.2.469. JSTOR   4086541.
  6. Bechard, Marc J. (1983). "Food Supply and the Occurrence of Brood Reduction in Swainson's Hawk". The Wilson Bulletin. 95 (2): 233–242. JSTOR   4161753.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Edwards, Thomas C.; Collopy, Michael W. (1983). "Obligate and Facultative Brood Reduction in Eagles: An Examination of Factors That Influence Fratricide". The Auk. 100 (3): 630–635. doi:10.1093/auk/100.3.630. JSTOR   4086464.
  8. Reynolds, P. S. (1996). "Brood Reduction and Siblicide in Black-Billed Magpies (Pica pica)". The Auk. 113 (1): 189–199. doi:10.2307/4088945. JSTOR   4088945.
  9. Harper, R. Given; Juliano, Steven A.; Thompson, Charles F. (1992). "Hatching asynchrony in the house wren, Troglodytes aedon: a test of the brood-reduction hypothesis". Behavioral Ecology. 3 (1): 76–83. doi:10.1093/beheco/3.1.76. ISSN   1045-2249.
  10. Tortosa, Francisco S.; Redondo, Tomas (1992). "Motives for Parental Infanticide in White Storks Ciconia ciconia". Ornis Scandinavica (Scandinavian Journal of Ornithology). 23 (2): 185–189. doi:10.2307/3676447. JSTOR   3676447.
  11. Zieliński, Piotr (2002). "Brood Reduction and Parental Infanticide – are the White StorkCiconia ciconiaand the Black StorkC. nigraexceptional?". Acta Ornithologica. 37 (2): 113–119. doi: 10.3161/068.037.0207 . ISSN   0001-6454.
  12. 1 2 3 Ruiz, Natalia M. Duré; Mermoz, Myriam E.; Fernández, Gustavo J. (2008). "Effect of Cowbird Parasitism on Brood Reduction in the Brown-and-Yellow Marshbird". The Condor. 110 (3): 507–513. doi: 10.1525/cond.2008.8428 . ISSN   0010-5422.
  13. Mock, Douglas W.; Parker, Geoffrey A. (1986). "Advantages and Disadvantages of Egret and Heron Brood Reduction". Evolution. 40 (3): 459–470. doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.1986.tb00499.x. ISSN   0014-3820. PMID   28556322.
  14. Martínez-Padilla, Jesús; Viñuela, Javier (2011-06-14). "Hatching asynchrony and brood reduction influence immune response in Common Kestrel Falco tinnunculus nestlings". Ibis. 153 (3): 601–610. doi:10.1111/j.1474-919x.2011.01133.x. hdl: 10261/69368 . ISSN   0019-1019.