Church property disputes in the United States

Last updated

Church property disputes in the United States arise when a disagreement amongst a church congregation or between a congregation and its national denomination results in a legal dispute over the control of the congregation's property. [1] Litigation over the property requires conformance with the First Amendment of the United States Constitution which protects the autonomy of churches. Therefore, church property is treated differently than any other type of property by courts of law. [2]

Contents

The First Amendment requires courts adjudicating church property disputes to do so without interpreting any religious doctrine. [3] As a result, courts in the United States have developed two separate legal approaches to handle such disputes. [1]

St. Michael's Episcopal Church was one of 29 Episcopal parishes involved in church property disputes after the parishes broke away in the late 2000s to form the Anglican Diocese of South Carolina. St. Michael's Episcopal Church - Charleston, SC.jpg
St. Michael's Episcopal Church was one of 29 Episcopal parishes involved in church property disputes after the parishes broke away in the late 2000s to form the Anglican Diocese of South Carolina.

The current legal framework that the majority of courts use is called the Neutral Principles approach. [5] The Neutral Principles approach allows courts to adjudicate church property by deferring to unambiguous legal documents such as deeds, church constitutions, charters, and trusts or by looking entirely to the structure of church governance. [1] [5] However, because courts cannot interpret religious doctrine, the once common "English rule," that the congregation or denomination who most aligns with the denomination's traditional doctrine be given the property, is unconstitutional. [1] [3]

Some state courts use the deference to hierarchy approach, meaning the state courts defer to the highest hierarchical body within the church's decision on the matter. [1] [5]

Legal scholars have criticized the efficacy of both approaches. [5] [6] In 2021, petitions for certiorari asking the U.S. Supreme Court to address the split in approaches were denied. [7] [8] [9]

History

Church property disputes in the United States have arisen in many contexts but often arise due to social conflict. [1] For instance, the first seminal Supreme Court case on the issue, Watson v. Jones (1872) involved a Presbyterian congregation that split into two groups over some members support of slavery. [1] [10] Watson v. Jones was the first U.S. Supreme Court case handling a church property dispute. [2]

The next seminal Supreme Court case, Presbyterian Church in the United States v. Mary Elizabeth Blue Hull Memorial Presbyterian Church (1969) involved a split from the Presbyterian Church in the United States by two Georgian congregations over the main denomination's support for the ordination of women as ministers and its support for the Civil rights movement. [1]

Finally, in the late 2000s, property disputes arose when congregations split from the Episcopal Church (United States) after the national denomination approved the election of a gay bishop in New Hampshire. [1] [6] Courts using the neutral principles approach have grappled with the legal significance of the Dennis Canon, a rule adopted by the national church in 1979 stating that the property of each local congregation was held in trust for the national church. [1]

Related Research Articles

The United Free Church of Scotland is a Scottish Presbyterian denomination formed in 1900 by the union of the United Presbyterian Church of Scotland and the majority of the 19th-century Free Church of Scotland. The majority of the United Free Church of Scotland united with the Church of Scotland in 1929.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Truro Anglican Church (Fairfax, Virginia)</span> Church in Virginia USA, United States

Truro Anglican Church is an Anglican church in Fairfax, Virginia, USA.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Church of South India</span> United Protestant church in South India

The Church of South India (CSI) is a united Protestant Church in India. It is the result of union of a number of Protestant denominations in South India that occurred after the independence of India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Episcopal Church in North Texas</span> Diocese of the Episcopal Church in the United States

The Episcopal Church in North Texas was a diocese of the Episcopal Church from 1982 to its merger with the Diocese of Texas in 2022. The diocese included a geographic area of 24 counties in the north central part of Texas. As of 2021, it includes 13 churches, including a number of other congregations in the process of reorganization. The jurisdiction was the site of a major schism in 2008. This schism was the result of the diocese's bishop, Jack Iker, leading the majority of clergy and parishes to join the Anglican Church of North America as the Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth. The Episcopal Church diocese is headquartered in Fort Worth, Texas. It announced on April 22, 2022, that it would seek reunion with the Episcopal Diocese of Texas. The merger was finalized by the 80th General Convention of the Episcopal Church in the United States of America on July 11, 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anglican Diocese of South Carolina</span> Anglican diocese in the United States

The Anglican Diocese of South Carolina (ADOSC) is a diocese of the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA). The diocese covers an area of 24 counties in the eastern part of the state of South Carolina. In 2019, it had 18,195 baptized members and 47 parishes. The see city is Charleston, home to the Cathedral of St. Luke and St. Paul.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ecclesiastical polity</span> Government of Christian churches

Ecclesiastical polity is the government of a church. There are local (congregational) forms of organization as well as denominational. A church's polity may describe its ministerial offices or an authority structure between churches. Polity relates closely to ecclesiology, the theological study of the church.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh</span> Diocese of the Episcopal Church in the United States

The Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh is a diocese in the Episcopal Church in the United States of America. Geographically, it encompasses 11 counties in Western Pennsylvania. It was formed in 1865 by dividing the Episcopal Diocese of Pennsylvania. The diocesan cathedral is Trinity Cathedral in downtown Pittsburgh. The Rt. Rev. Ketlen A. Solak was consecrated and seated as its current bishop in autumn 2021.

A middle judicatory is an administrative structure or organization found in religious denominations between the local congregation and the widest or highest national or international level. The term is meant to be neutral with regard to polity, though it derives from Presbyterianism where the local, regional and national bodies are themselves respectively higher courts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Falls Church</span> Historic church in Virginia, United States

The Falls Church is an historic Episcopal church, from which the city of Falls Church, Virginia, near Washington, D.C., takes its name. Established in 1732, the parish in 1769 built a brick church building that remains in use today.

The Dennis Canon is a common name used for Title I.7.4 of the Canons of the Episcopal Church in the United States of America.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth</span> Anglican diocese in the United States

The Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth is a diocese of the Anglican Church in North America. The diocese comprises 56 congregations and its headquarters are in Fort Worth, Texas.

The ordination of lesbian, gay, bisexual and/or transgender (LGBT) clergy who are open about their sexuality or gender identity; are sexually active if lesbian, gay, or bisexual; or are in committed same-sex relationships is a debated practice within some contemporary Christian denominations.

Presbyterian Church v. Hull Church, 393 U.S. 440 (1969), was a United States Supreme Court case involving the secession of two local churches, including Hull Memorial Presbyterian Church, from the parent body Presbyterian Church in the United States because, they claimed, the Church had departed from its original doctrinal tenets. The Court ruled that the state could not pass judgment concerning religious doctrine or church law.

Watson v. Jones, 80 U.S. 679 (1871), is a seminal United States Supreme Court case regarding the role of secular courts adjudicating ecclesiastical disputes. In Watson v. Jones, the Court held that in adjudications of church property disputes: (1) courts cannot rule on the truth or falsity of a religious teaching, (2) where a previous authority structure existed before the dispute, courts should defer to the decision of that structure, and (3) in the absence of such an internal authority structure, courts should defer to the wishes of a majority of the congregation.

The ministerial exception, sometimes known as the ecclesiastical exception, is a legal doctrine in the United States barring the application of anti-discrimination laws to religious institutions' employment of ministers or as to jobs with ministerial roles. As explained by the Supreme Court in the landmark 2012 case Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. E.E.O.C., the exception is drawn from the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and serves two purposes: to safeguard the freedom of religious groups "to select their own ministers" and to prevent "government involvement in [...] ecclesiastical decisions". The first purpose is rooted in the Free Exercise Clause; the second, in the Establishment Clause. When the ministerial exception applies, it gives religious institutions an affirmative defense against lawsuits for discrimination. For example, a woman seeking to become a Catholic priest cannot sue the Catholic Church for sex discrimination over its position that women cannot be ordained as priests. The Supreme Court later elaborated on when employees qualify as ministerial – and thus how broadly the exception applies – in Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey-Berru (2020).

Serbian Orthodox Diocese v. Milivojevich, 426 U.S. 696 (1976), is a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that the judicial determination of the Illinois Supreme Court violated the First Amendment and Fourteenth Amendments. In matters of dispute within hierarchal religious organizations, the Establishment Clause precludes intervention by civil courts regarding internal disputes of church governance. Per the Establishment Clause, decisions imposed by hierarchal religious organizations are binding in civil courts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina</span> Diocese of the Episcopal Church in the United States

The Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina (EDOSC), known as The Episcopal Church in South Carolina from January 2013 until September 2019, is a diocese of the Episcopal Church. The diocese covers an area of 24 counties in the eastern part of the U.S. state of South Carolina. The see city is Charleston, home to Grace Church Cathedral and the diocesan headquarters. The western portion of the state forms the Episcopal Diocese of Upper South Carolina. As a diocese of the Episcopal Church, the Diocese of South Carolina is part of the worldwide Anglican Communion and traces its heritage to the beginnings of Christianity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Highland Park Presbyterian Church (University Park, Texas)</span> Church in Texas , USA

Highland Park Presbyterian Church is a Presbyterian church in University Park, Texas, with a Dallas post office address. In 2013, HP Pres voted to change its affiliation from Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) to ECO: A Covenant Order of Evangelical Presbyterians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christ Church Anglican (Savannah, Georgia)</span> Historic Anglican church in Savannah, Georgia, United States

Christ Church Anglican (CCA) is an Anglican parish in the Thomas Square neighborhood of Savannah, Georgia. It traces its history to 1733, when Christ Church was founded as the oldest Anglican presence in Georgia. In 2006, the majority of the clergy and parishioners of Christ Church departed from the Episcopal Diocese of Georgia; in 2012, after a loss in a court case, the congregation leaving the Episcopal Church relocated and renamed itself Christ Church Anglican. It is today part of the Gulf Atlantic Diocese in the Anglican Church in North America; its building is a contributing property to the Thomas Square Streetcar Historic District.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Terrell Glenn (bishop)</span> American Anglican bishop (born 1958)

Terrell Lyles Glenn Jr. is an American bishop of the Anglican Church in North America. He is a former Episcopal priest who played an active role in the Anglican realignment in the United States. Consecrated in 2008 to serve as a bishop in the Anglican Mission in the Americas, Glenn is now an assisting bishop overseeing North Carolina congregations in the Diocese of the Carolinas.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 "Internal Property Disputes". Pew Research Center's Religion & Public Life Project. 2011-03-31. Retrieved 2022-06-18.
  2. 1 2 Eric G. Osborne & Michael D. Bush, Rethinking Deference: How the History of Church Property Disputes Calls into Question Long-Standing First Amendment Doctrine, 69 SMU L. Rev. 811 (2016)
  3. 1 2 Louis J. Sirico, Jr., Church Property Disputes: Churches as Secular and Alien Institutions, 55 Fordham L. Rev. 335 (1986). Available at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/flr/vol55/iss3/2
  4. ↑ Ciapha, Rickey (April 20, 2022). "SC Supreme Court rules some breakaway churches must return properties to Episcopal Diocese" . Post & Courier. Retrieved June 21, 2022.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Cameron W. Ellis, Church Factionalism and Judicial Resolution: A Reconsideration of the Neutral-Principles Approach, 60 Ala. L. Rev. 1001, 1003 (2009)
  6. 1 2 Bernie D. Jones, Litigating the Schism and Reforming the Canons: Orthodoxy, Property & the Modern Social Gospel of the Episcopal Church, 42 Golden Gate U.L. Rev. 151 (2012)
  7. ↑ "Disputes over church property and ACCA ambiguity". SCOTUSblog. 2021-02-18. Retrieved 2022-06-18.
  8. ↑ "All Saints' Episcopal Church (Fort Worth) v. Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved 2022-06-18.
  9. ↑ "Episcopal Church v. Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved 2022-06-18.
  10. ↑ Weeks, Louis; Hickey, James C. (1976). ""Implied Trust" for Connectional Churches: Watson v. Jones Revisited". Journal of Presbyterian History (1962-1985). 54 (4): 459–470. ISSN   0022-3883.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.