Comparison of pumps

Last updated

This article lists different types of pump and provides a comparison of certain key design features. Different types of pumps are suitable for different applications, for example: a pump's maximum lift height also determines the applications it can be used for. Low-lift pumps are only suitable for the pumping of surface water (e.g., irrigation, drainage of lands, ...), while high-lift pumps allow deep water pumping (e.g., potable water pumping from wells). [1]

Pump device that moves fluids (liquids or gases) by mechanical action

A pump is a device that moves fluids, or sometimes slurries, by mechanical action. Pumps can be classified into three major groups according to the method they use to move the fluid: direct lift, displacement, and gravity pumps.

Contents

Direct lift devices

Pump typeCyclic/continuous ?Maximum lift heightProduction costEfficiencyOutputSize of deviceFabrication requirementsDifficulty of productionDurabilityDifficulty of repairSuction lift ?
Continuous bucket pumpcontinuous5m-50mlow-mediummediumlow-medium??traditional??no
Counterpoise lift or Shadoof cyclic1m-4mlow-mediumlow-mediumlow-medium??traditional??no
Mohtecyclic3m-8mlow-mediumlowmedium??traditional??no
Persian wheel "Tablia"continuous3m-10mlow-mediummediummedium??traditional??no
Persian wheel "Zawaffa"continuous3m-15mmediummedium-highmedium-high??traditional??no
Pivoting gutters and "dhones"cyclic1m-1,5mlow-mediumlow-mediumlow-medium??traditional??no
Reciprocating bucket hoistcyclic100m-500mmedium-highmediummedium-high??industrial??no
Rope & bucket and windlass cyclic5m-50mvery lowvery lowvery low??basic??no
Scoops and bailerscyclic>1mvery lowvery lowlow-medium??basic??no
Scoop wheel "Sakia"continuous>2mmedium-highmedium-highmedium-high??traditional??no
Swing basketcyclic>1mvery lowvery lowlow-medium??basic??no
Waterwheels or noria continuous>5mlow-mediumlow-mediumlow-medium??traditional??no
Watering carcyclic>3mvery lowvery lowvery low??basic??no

Displacement pumps

Pump typeCyclic/continuous ?Maximum lift heightProduction costEfficiencyOutputSize of deviceFabrication requirementsDifficulty of productionDurabilityDifficulty of repairSuction lift ?
Archimedean screw continuous>2mmediummediummedium-high??industrial??no
Chain (or rope) and washer pumpcontinuous3m-20mmedium-highmedium-highmedium??traditional??no
Coil pump and spiral pump continuous>6mmediummediumlow-medium??traditional??no
Diaphragm pump cyclic5m-10mmediummedium-highmedium??industrial??yes
Flash wheel and treadmill>2mlow-mediumlow-mediummedium-high???traditional/industrial??no
Flexible vane pumpcontinuous10m-20mmedium-highmediummedium??industrial??yes
Gas or vapour displacement pumpcyclic5m-50mmediummediummedium-high??industrial??no/yes
Gear and lobe pump continuous10m-20mmediumlow-mediumvery low??industrial??yes
Open screw pumpcontinuous>6mhighmedium-highmedium-high??industrial??no
Peristaltic pump continuous>3mmediummediumvery low??industrial??yes
Petropumpcontinuous10m-100mmedium-highhighlow-medium??industrial???
Porous ropecontinuous3m-10m??low-medium??industrial??no
Progressive cavity pump (Moyno)continuous10m-100mmedium-highmedium-highmedium??industrial??no
Piston pump, bucket pumpcyclic2m-200mmedium-highhighmedium??traditional/industrial??yes
Plunger pumpcyclic100m-500mhighmedium-highlow-medium??traditional??yes
Pulser Pump cyclic1-300mlow-mediumlowlow-mediumsmall-huge?traditionalvery higheasyno
Semi-rotary pumpcyclic5m-10mlow-mediumlow-mediumlow-medium??industrial??yes
Water ladder cyclic>2mmediummediummedium??traditional??no

Velocity pumps

Pump typeCyclic/continuous ?Maximum lift heightProduction costEfficiencyOutputSize of deviceFabrication requirementsDifficulty of productionDurabilityDifficulty of repairSuction lift ?
Centrifugal (regenerative) pumpcontinuous10m-30mmedium-highmediummedium??industrial??yes
Centrifugal (turbine) pumpcontinuous3m-200mmedium-highmedium-highhigh??industrial??yes
Centrifugal (volute) pumpcontinuous3m-20mmediummedium-highhigh??industrial??yes
Flap valve pump?2m-4mvery lowlow-mediumvery low??basic/traditional??no
Inertia pump, joggle pumpcyclic2m-4mlow-mediummedium-highlow-medium??traditional, industrial??no
Jet pump (water, air or stream)continuous2m-20mmediumlow-mediumlow-medium??industrial??no
Mixed flow pumpcontinuous2m-10mmedium-highmedium-highhigh??industrial??no
Propeller (axial flow) pumpcontinuous5m-30mmedium-highmedium-highhigh??industrial??no
Rebound inertiacyclic2m-60mmediummedium-highvery low??industrial??yes
Resonating joggle pumpcyclic2m-10mmediummedium-highmedium-high??traditional??no

Buoyancy pumps

Pump typeCyclic/continuousMaximum lift heightProduction costEfficiencyOutputSize of deviceFabrication requirementsDifficulty of productionDurabilityDifficulty of repairSuction lift ?
Airlift pump Continuous

(with collector)

5m-50mmedium-highlow-mediummedium??industrial??no

Impulse Pumps

Pump typeCyclic/continuous ?Maximum lift heightProduction costEfficiencyOutputSize of deviceFabrication requirementsDifficulty of productionDurabilityDifficulty of repairSuction lift ?
Hydraulic ram cyclic10m-100mmediumlow-mediumlow?requires flowing water as power source (e.g. river)industrialhigh?no

Note: reciprocating pumps are cyclic, rotary pumps are typically continuous.

Related Research Articles

Wing Surface used for flight, for example by insects, birds, bats and airplanes

A wing is a type of fin that produces lift, while moving through air or some other fluid. As such, wings have streamlined cross-sections that are subject to aerodynamic forces and act as an airfoils. A wing's aerodynamic efficiency is expressed as its lift-to-drag ratio. The lift a wing generates at a given speed and angle of attack can be one to two orders of magnitude greater than the total drag on the wing. A high lift-to-drag ratio requires a significantly smaller thrust to propel the wings through the air at sufficient lift.

Submersible pump Pump designed to work submerged in fluid

A submersible pump is a device which has a hermetically sealed motor close-coupled to the pump body. The whole assembly is submerged in the fluid to be pumped. The main advantage of this type of pump is that it prevents pump cavitation, a problem associated with a high elevation difference between pump and the fluid surface. Submersible pumps push fluid to the surface as opposed to jet pumps having to pull fluids. Submersibles are more efficient than jet pumps.

Hydraulic fluid

A hydraulic fluid or hydraulic liquid is the medium by which power is transferred in hydraulic machinery. Common hydraulic fluids are based on mineral oil or water. Examples of equipment that might use hydraulic fluids are excavators and backhoes, hydraulic brakes, power steering systems, transmissions, garbage trucks, aircraft flight control systems, lifts, and industrial machinery.

Check valve valve that allows to flow through it in only one direction

A check valve, clack valve, non-return valve, reflux valve, retention valve or one-way valve is a valve that normally allows fluid to flow through it in only one direction.

Gas lift Raising a fluid by introducing bubbles of gas into the outlet tube

Gas lift or bubble pumps use the artificial lift technique of raising a fluid such as water or oil by introducing bubbles of compressed air, water vapor or other vaporous bubbles into the outlet tube. This has the effect of reducing the hydrostatic pressure in the outlet tube vs. the hydrostatic pressure at the inlet side of the tube.

Injector type of pump

A steam injector is typically used to deliver cold water to a boiler against its own pressure using its own live or exhaust steam, replacing any mechanical pump. This was the purpose for which it was originally invented in 1858 by Henri Giffard. Its operation was from the start intriguing since it seemed paradoxical, almost like perpetual motion, but its operation was later explained using thermodynamics. Other types of injector may use other pressurised motive fluids such as air.

Lift table lift table

A lift table is a device that employs a scissors mechanism to raise or lower goods and/or persons. Typically lift tables are used to raise large, heavy loads through relatively small distances. Common applications include pallet handling, vehicle loading and work positioning. Lift tables are a recommended way to help reduce incidents of musculoskeletal disorders by correctly re-positioning work at a suitable height for operators. Lift tables lend themselves to being easily adapted to a specific use. They can work in hostile environments, be manufactured in stainless steel and have equipment like conveyors, turn-tables, barriers and gates easily added to their deckplates.

Drafting water

The term drafting water refers to the use of suction to move a liquid such as water from a vessel or body of water below the intake of a suction pump. A rural fire department or farmer might draft water from a pond as the first step in moving the water elsewhere. A suction pump creates a partial vacuum and the atmospheric pressure on the water's surface forces the water into the pump, usually via a rigid pipe or a semi-rigid hard suction hose.

This is a glossary of firefighting equipment.

Water pumping

The pumping of water is a basic and practical technique, far more practical than scooping it up with one's hands or lifting it in a hand-held bucket. This is true whether the water is drawn from a fresh source, moved to a needed location, purified, or used for irrigation, washing, or sewage treatment, or for evacuating water from an undesirable location. Regardless of the outcome, the energy required to pump water is an extremely demanding component of water consumption. All other processes depend or benefit either from water descending from a higher elevation or some pressurized plumbing system.

Centrifugal pump

Centrifugal pumps are a sub-class of dynamic axisymmetric work-absorbing turbomachinery. Centrifugal pumps are used to transport fluids by the conversion of rotational kinetic energy to the hydrodynamic energy of the fluid flow. The rotational energy typically comes from an engine or electric motor. The fluid enters the pump impeller along or near to the rotating axis and is accelerated by the impeller, flowing radially outward into a diffuser or volute chamber (casing), from where it exits.

Tube well type of water well

A tube well is a type of water well in which a long, 100–200 millimetres (3.9–7.9 in)-wide, stainless steel tube or pipe is bored into an underground aquifer. The lower end is fitted with a strainer, and a pump lifts water for irrigation. The required depth of the well depends on the depth of the water table.

Photobioreactor

A photobioreactor is a bioreactor that utilizes a light source to cultivate phototrophic microorganisms. These organisms use photosynthesis to generate biomass from light and carbon dioxide and include plants, mosses, macroalgae, microalgae, cyanobacteria and purple bacteria. Within the artificial environment of a photobioreactor, specific conditions are carefully controlled for respective species. Thus, a photobioreactor allows much higher growth rates and purity levels than anywhere in nature or habitats similar to nature. Hypothetically, phototropic biomass could be derived from nutrient-rich wastewater and flue gas carbon dioxide in a photobioreactor.

Artificial lift refers to the use of artificial means to increase the flow of liquids, such as crude oil or water, from a production well. Generally this is achieved by the use of a mechanical device inside the well or by decreasing the weight of the hydrostatic column by injecting gas into the liquid some distance down the well. A newer method called Continuous Belt Transportation (CBT) uses an oil absorbing belt to extract from marginal and idle wells. Artificial lift is needed in wells when there is insufficient pressure in the reservoir to lift the produced fluids to the surface, but often used in naturally flowing wells to increase the flow rate above what would flow naturally. The produced fluid can be oil, water or a mix of oil and water, typically mixed with some amount of gas.

Fluidyne engine

A Fluidyne engine is an alpha or gamma type Stirling engine with one or more liquidpistons. It contains a working gas, and either two liquid pistons or one liquid piston and a displacer.

Sprayer device used to spray a liquid

A sprayer is a device used to spray a liquid, where sprayers are commonly used for projection of water, weed killers, crop performance materials, pest maintenance chemicals, as well as manufacturing and production line ingredients. In agriculture, a sprayer is a piece of equipment that is used to apply herbicides, pesticides, and fertilizers on agricultural crops. Sprayers range in size from man-portable units to trailed sprayers that are connected to a tractor, to self-propelled units similar to tractors, with boom mounts of 4-30 feet up to 60–151 feet in length depending on engineering design for tractor and land size.

River rapids ride amusement ride that simulates whitewater rafting

A river rapids ride is an amusement ride that simulates whitewater rafting.

Lift irrigation

Lift irrigation is a method of irrigation in which water is not transported by natural flow, but is lifted with pumps or surge pools etc.

A rotodynamic pump is a kinetic machine in which energy is continuously imparted to the pumped fluid by means of a rotating impeller, propeller, or rotor, in contrast to a positive displacement pump in which a fluid is moved by trapping a fixed amount of fluid and forcing the trapped volume into the pump's discharge. Examples of rotodynamic pumps include adding kinetic energy to a fluid such as by using a centrifugal pump to increase fluid velocity or pressure.

References