Courthouse facility dog

Last updated
A courthouse facility dog (2014) AstroCourthouseFacilityDog.jpg
A courthouse facility dog (2014)

In the United States, a courthouse facility dog is a professionally trained facility dog that has graduated from an accredited assistance dog organization that is a member of Assistance Dogs International. Such dogs assist crime victims, witnesses and others during the investigation and prosecution of crimes, as well as during other legal proceedings. Courthouse facility dogs also provide assistance to Drug Court and Mental Health Court participants during their recovery from drugs, alcohol, mental illness and posttraumatic stress disorder.

Contents

In addition to the courthouse, these dogs work in child advocacy centers, district attorney offices, and law enforcement settings. The handlers of these dogs are professionals working in the legal system such as district attorneys, law enforcement officers, forensic interviewers, psychologists, social workers and victim advocates. Nonprofessional handlers are not utilized with courthouse facility dogs due to the confidential nature of some proceedings, and because the presence of lay people during the investigation of a crime and in the courtroom may create legal issues.

Typical work

Training

Courthouse facility dogs are usually bred, raised and trained by service dog organizations that are members of Assistance Dogs International, [3] such as Canine Companions for Independence, Assistance Dogs of the West, [4] and Support Dogs, Inc.

Facility dogs are not service dogs because they do not assist a person with a disability. Assistance Dogs International defines a facility dog and describes their training standards that must be maintained by their handlers who work as professionals in a specific setting. [5]

Most of these dogs are either golden or Labrador retrievers or a combination of the two breeds. These dogs have typically spent eighteen months being raised by a volunteer puppy raiser with weekly obedience classes and had six months or more of work with a professional dog trainer. During this time the organization’s trainers carefully assess which facility assistance dogs have the best temperament to work in a courthouse environment. [6] A successful courthouse dog will have a quiet, calm demeanor and be self-confident. The dog will also need to be adaptable, highly social and work independently with many individuals throughout a typical day and have multiple handlers. In addition to the dog’s basic training, that should involve passing a public access test, the dog should be able to tolerate people wearing a variety of clothing from all walks of life, angry people, drug abusers, children who invade boundaries, erratic behavior, and emotionally charged situations. Most importantly, the dog should know when to engage with people in public and when to become almost invisible for extended periods of time during child forensic interviews and courtroom proceedings. [7] The courthouse dog’s handler receives intensive training before graduating from the service dog organization with their dog. In order to protect the jurisdiction and handler of the dog should a lawsuit be filed, these dogs often carry a minimum of one million dollars in liability insurance. Many qualified dogs carry such policies as a part of the certification process, such as the courthouse facility dogs provided by Canine Companions for Independence. [8]

When courthouse facility dogs are off duty, they are pets that live with their primary handlers.

Although prosecuting attorneys, law enforcement officers, and victim advocates support the use of courthouse facility dogs in assisting crime victims and witnesses while they testify in court, some defense attorneys object to their use out of concern that it is prejudicial to their clients. [9] The objection is usually based on the argument that the presence of the dog may make the prosecution witness more appealing to the jury. However, courthouse facility dogs are for everyone. If this type of dog is available and the witnesses can demonstrate to the judge that the presence of a courthouse dog would facilitate their ability to testify in court, then the dog should be made available to everyone including defendants. [10]

The National Crime Victim Law Institute suggests that this jury instruction regarding the presence of the dog in the courtroom be provided to the jurors before deliberations to overcome unfair prejudice to either the defense or prosecution.

"Testifying in court is an unfamiliar and stressful event for most people; these dogs are used in a courthouse setting to help reduce witness anxiety and are available to any witness who requests one." [11]

In the 2013 Washington state Supreme Court case State v Dye, the court found that it was not unduly prejudicial for facility dog Ellie who was trained by, and lives with, the prosecutor at Dye's trial. [12] Addressing the possibility of biasing the jury with the use of the courthouse facility dog, the court found the following: [13]

Furthermore, whatever subconscious bias may have befallen the jury was cured by the trial court's limiting instruction, which cautioned the jury not to "make any assumptions or draw any conclusions based on the presence of this service. Juries are presumed to follow instructions absent evidence to the contrary. State v. Kirkman, 159 Wn.2d 918, 928, 155 P.3d 125 (2007). No such evidence appears on the record here. The constitutional role of the jury prevents us from presuming-on the force of a bare allegation-that the jury "[made] a decision based on the dog's reaction and demeanor, not the witness's .... " Br. of Amicus Curiae Wash. Defender Ass'n & The Defender Ass'n at 14. And our own precedent compels us to respect the trial court's decision: whether or not we might have conducted the trial differently, we cannot say the trial court acted in a manifestly unreasonable manner.

History

Firsts in using trained dogs to assist victims and witnesses in the criminal-justice system:

Notable events in the establishment of organizations and legislature centered around the use of courthouse facility dogs:

Since 2003, the use of courthouse facility dogs has spread throughout the United States and internationally. [26]

See also

Related Research Articles

In law, a witness is someone who, either voluntarily or under compulsion, provides testimonial evidence, either oral or written, of what they know or claim to know.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Guide dog</span> Assistance dog trained to lead blind or visually impaired people around obstacles

Guide dogs are assistance dogs trained to lead blind or visually impaired people around obstacles. Although dogs can be trained to navigate various obstacles, they are red–green colour blind and incapable of interpreting street signs. The human does the directing, based on skills acquired through previous mobility training. The handler might be likened to an aircraft's navigator, who must know how to get from one place to another, and the dog is the pilot, who gets them there safely. In several countries guide dogs, along with most other service and hearing dogs, are exempt from regulations against the presence of animals in places such as restaurants and public transportation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Labrador Retriever</span> British breed of retriever gun dog

The Labrador Retriever, or simply Labrador, is a British breed of retriever gun dog. It was developed in the United Kingdom from St. John's water dogs imported from the colony of Newfoundland, and was named after the Labrador region of that colony. It is among the most commonly kept dogs in several countries, particularly in the European world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Assistance dog</span> Working dog trained to aid or assist an individual with a disability

An assistance dog, known as a service dog in the United States, is a dog trained to aid or assist an individual with a disability. Many are trained by an assistance dog organization, or by their handler, often with the help of a professional trainer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scottsboro Boys</span> Racism based miscarriage of justice

The Scottsboro Boys were nine African American male teenagers accused in Alabama of raping two white women in 1931. The landmark set of legal cases from this incident dealt with racism and the right to a fair trial. The cases included a lynch mob before the suspects had been indicted, all-white juries, rushed trials, and disruptive mobs. It is commonly cited as an example of a legal injustice in the United States legal system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Retriever</span> Dog type

A retriever is a type of gun dog that retrieves game for a hunter. Generally gun dogs are divided into three major classifications: retrievers, flushing spaniels, and pointing breeds. Retrievers were bred primarily to retrieve birds or other prey and return them to the hunter without damage; retrievers are distinguished in that nonslip retrieval is their primary function. As a result, retriever breeds are bred for soft mouths and a great willingness to please, learn, and obey. A soft mouth refers to the willingness of the dog to carry game in its mouth without biting into it. "Hard mouth" is a serious fault in a hunting dog and is very difficult to correct. A hard-mouthed dog renders game unpresentable or at worst inedible.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Police dog</span> Dog trained and used for law enforcement

A police dog, also known as a K-9, is a dog that is trained to assist police and other law enforcement officers, search and rescue, or the military. Their duties may include searching for drugs and explosives, locating missing people, finding crime scene evidence, protecting officers and other people, and attacking suspects who flee from officers. The breeds most commonly used by law enforcement are the German Shepherd, Belgian Malinois, Bloodhound, Dutch Shepherd, and Labrador Retriever. In recent years, the Belgian Malinois has become the leading choice for police and military work due to their intense drive, focus, agility, and smaller size, though German Shepherds remain the breed most associated with law enforcement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Therapy dog</span> Dog that is trained to provide affection, comfort and support to people

A therapy dog is a dog that is trained to provide affection, comfort and support to people, often in settings such as hospitals, retirement homes, nursing homes, schools, libraries, hospices, or disaster areas. In contrast to assistance dogs, which are trained to assist specific patients with their day-to-day physical needs, therapy dogs are trained to interact with all kinds of people, not just their handlers.

Maryland v. Craig, 497 U.S. 836 (1990), was a U.S. Supreme Court case involving the Sixth Amendment. The Court ruled that the Sixth Amendment's Confrontation Clause, which provides criminal defendants with the right to confront witnesses against them, did not bar the use of one-way closed-circuit television to present testimony by an alleged child sex abuse victim.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brian Nichols</span> American mass murderer and rapist

Brian Gene Nichols is an accused rapist and convicted murderer known for his escape and killing spree in the Fulton County Courthouse in Atlanta, Georgia, on March 11, 2005. Nichols was on trial for rape when he escaped custody and murdered the judge presiding over his trial, a court reporter, a Fulton County Sheriff's deputy, and later an ICE special agent. Twenty-six hours after a large-scale manhunt was launched in the metropolitan Atlanta area, Nichols was taken into custody. The prosecution charged him with committing 54 crimes during the escape; he was found guilty on all counts on November 7, 2008 and was subsequently sentenced to life in prison.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jesse James Hollywood</span> American criminal

Jesse James Hollywood is an American former drug dealer who kidnapped and ordered the murder of Nicholas Markowitz in 2000. He was arrested in 2005 and is serving life without parole at Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego, California.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Courtroom</span> Enclosed space in which a judge regularly holds court

A courtroom is the enclosed space in which courts of law are held in front of a judge. A number of courtrooms, which may also be known as "courts", may be housed in a courthouse. In recent years, courtrooms have been equipped with audiovisual technology to permit everyone present to clearly hear testimony and see exhibits.

Canine Companions for Independence is a US-based 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that trains and provides assistance dogs. As of 2018, it has placed over 6,000 assistance dogs with recipients at no charge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Court of assizes (Belgium)</span> Criminal court in Belgium

The court of assizes is the trial court which tries the most serious crimes in the judicial system of Belgium. It is the highest Belgian court with criminal jurisdiction; as such, it is the only Belgian court that can sentence someone to life imprisonment. The courts of assizes are not permanent courts; a new court of assizes is assembled for each new trial. There is a court of assizes in each of the ten provinces of Belgium, as well as one in the arrondissement of Brussels-Capital which is not part of any province. Further below, an overview is provided of the eleven courts of assizes and their seats. They are the only courts in Belgium for which the provinces are used as territorial subdivisions. They are also the only courts in Belgium that hold jury trials. The jury acts as sole trier of fact, but decides on the penalty together with the judges. The trial by jury of certain crimes is laid down in article 150 of the Belgian Constitution. The Belgian courts of assizes have the same origin as their French namesakes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Service animal</span> Animal to assist people with disabilities

Service animals are working animals that have been trained to perform tasks that assist disabled people. Service animals may also be referred to as assistance animals or helper animals depending on the country and the animal's function. Dogs are the most common service animals, having assisted people since at least 1927.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baltimore City Sheriff's Office (Maryland)</span>

The Baltimore City Sheriff's Office is the law enforcement arm of the Circuit Court of Maryland, serving Baltimore, Maryland. The office is headquartered in Courthouse West of the Baltimore City Circuit Courthouses, which also serves as the sites for Baltimore City branch of the Circuit Court of Maryland.

Victims' rights are legal rights afforded to victims of crime. These may include the right to restitution, the right to a victims' advocate, the right not to be excluded from criminal justice proceedings, and the right to speak at criminal justice proceedings.

Susan Lucille Wright is an American convicted murderer from Houston, Texas, who made headlines in 2003 for stabbing her husband, Jeff Wright, 193 times in an act of mariticide and then burying his body in their backyard. She was convicted of murder in 2004, and was given a 20-year sentence at the Crain Unit in Gatesville, Texas. She was denied parole on June 12, 2014, and July 24, 2017. She was granted parole in July 2020 and released from prison on December 30, 2020.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Travis Alexander</span> 2008 murder in Mesa, Arizona

Travis Victor Alexander was an American salesman who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend, Jodi Ann Arias, in his house in Mesa, Arizona. Arias was convicted of first-degree murder on May 8, 2013, and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole on April 13, 2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Courthouse Dogs Foundation</span> American non-profit organization

The Courthouse Dogs Foundation is a non-profit organization that trains professionals involved in the legal system about how courthouse facility dogs that are graduates from assistance dog organizations that are members of Assistance Dogs International (ADI) can assist them in the investigation and prosecution of crimes and other legal proceedings. Based on a practice that developed in Seattle, Washington, in 2003, the foundation was founded in 2012 by former prosecuting attorney Ellen O'Neill-Stephens and veterinarian Celeste Walsen. The Courthouse Dogs Foundation is based in Bellevue, Washington.

References

  1. "Stilson Comforts at Sentencing". Thebark.com. Retrieved 2012-04-21.
  2. Grey, Jamie. "Courthouse dog helps child victims". KTVB. kvtb.com. Archived from the original on 30 March 2012. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
  3. "assistancedogsinternational.org". assistancedogsinternational.org. Retrieved 2012-04-21.
  4. "assistancedogsofthewest.org". assistancedogsofthewest.org. 2011-05-19. Retrieved 2012-04-21.
  5. "Assistance Dogs International Standards for dog training". assistancedogsinternational.org. Archived from the original on 2015-07-24. Retrieved 2015-07-23.
  6. Ban, Charlie. "Dog Puts Victims at Ease in the Courtroom in Maricopa County". NACO County News. National Association of Counties Newsletter. Archived from the original on 7 July 2011. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
  7. Gray, Kathleen (2010-02-23). "Dogs help provide cupport in courtrooms". USA Today. USA Today. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
  8. Henry, Chris. "Newest Hand in Kitsap Prosecutor's Office Gives a Yip About Crime Victims". Kitsap Sun. Scripps Interactive Newspapers Group. Archived from the original on 2 August 2011. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
  9. Wiessner, Dan (2011-09-12). "U.S. courtroom dogs spark legal debate". Reuters. Reuters. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
  10. Glaberson, William (2011-08-08). "By Helping a Girl Testify at a Rape Trial, a Dog Ignites a Legal Debate". New York Times. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
  11. "Terry Campos, J.D. Practical Tips and Legal Strategies for Protecting Child-Victims While Testifying (NCVLI News 10th Edition), 2008 p. 12-15" . Retrieved 2012-04-21.
  12. State v. Dye, 1 (Wash.2013-09-13).
  13. "Washington Supreme Court case State v Dye" (PDF). 2015-09-26. Retrieved 2015-07-23.
  14. Clarridge, Christine (2005-05-14). "Bark Magazine - Dogs lend comfort to kids in court". Community.seattletimes.nwsource.com. Retrieved 2012-04-21.
  15. Wallick, Rebecca. "Dogs in the Courtroom". Thebark.com. Retrieved 2012-04-21.
  16. "Facility Service Dog Program". Children's Home of Poughkeepsie. 10 August 2015. Retrieved 2016-08-19.
  17. Glaberson, William (8 August 2011). "Dog Helps Rape Victim, 15, Testify". New York Times. Retrieved 2016-08-19.
  18. 1 2 Spruin, Elizabeth. "Justice Support Dogs International". Canterbury.ac.uk. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  19. Hauser, Jessica (2015-04-03). "Arkansas adopts 'courthouse dogs' for child witnesses". thecabin.net. Archived from the original on 2015-07-22. Retrieved 2015-07-21.
  20. Lundy, Steve (2015-07-21). "Courtroom dogs now the law in Illinois" . Retrieved 2015-07-24.
  21. "House Bill 2375". Article 7, Act No. 2375 of May 2016 (PDF). p. 2. Retrieved 2013-06-27.
  22. "House Bill 1668". Act No. 1668 of June 2016 (PDF). Retrieved 2016-08-16.
  23. Spruin, E; Mozova, K (September 2017). "Using specially trained dogs in the Criminal Justice System". Forensic Update (125): 39–42.
  24. Spruin, E; Mozova, K (2018). "Specially trained dogs in the UK Criminal Justice System". Seen and Heard (28): 63–67.
  25. Spruin, E; Mozova, K (2018). "Dogs in the criminal justice system: consideration of facility and therapy dogs". Pet Behaviour Science (5): 1–12. doi: 10.21071/pbs.v0i5.10084 . hdl: 10396/17854 .
  26. O'Neill-Stephens, Ellen (2010-07-01). "Courthouse Dogs Go South" (PDF). The Bark. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-07-22. Retrieved 2015-07-21.