Ethel Lawrence

Last updated May 01, 2024

Ethel Robinson Lawrence (March 16, 1926 - July 19, 1994) was a civil rights activist who was known as the "Rosa Parks of affordable housing".^[1] Lawrence was the lead plaintiff in the Mount Laurel, New Jersey litigation for affordable housing, which led to the New Jersey Fair Housing Act, the New Jersey Council on Affordable Housing (COAH) and the Mount Laurel doctrine.^[2] In her final years, Lawrence worked closely with attorney Peter O'Connor to start the non-profit organization Fair Share Housing Development Inc., which built over 200 units for moderate- to low-income tenants in Mount Laurel.^[1]

Early life

Lawrence was the second of eight children born to Mary and Leslie Robinson.^[3] Lawrence's ancestors had resided in Mount Laurel since the nineteenth-century when her slave ancestors had used the Underground Railroad stations organized by the Quakers who had made the Mount Laurel area a sanctuary to runaways during the Civil War.^[1] Growing up, Lawrence attended the segregated school on Moorestown-Mount Laurel Road. Lawrence's mother, Mary, was a religious and civic-minded woman who instilled similar values in all her children. At her mother's urging, sixteen-year-old Lawrence, with other African American youth, demanded to be seated in the "whites only" section of a local movie theater.^[2]

Adult life

Lawrence met and married Thomas Lawrence (who died in 1979), and together they reared nine children: four boys and five girls. In 1955, Ethel and Thomas purchased their own home in Mount Laurel. Struggling to maintain their home and support their children, Lawrence decided to enroll in college at the Bank Street College of Education in New York and received a degree in early childhood education. She went on to be employed as a pre-school teacher for Daycare 100.^[2]

Lawrence's civil rights work placed a significant and often dangerous burden on her family, specifically her children. One of her daughters, Ethel Lawrence-Halley, remembers: "At first, some of the kids we used to play with told us they wouldn't play with us anymore. My sister and I had dogs set on us while we were walking. Then came the words and the threats. I'd never been called the N-word in my life until then. People called my mother a troublemaking bitch. We had to change our phone number so many times I lost count. The worst it got was when somebody shot out my mother's bedroom window."^[1]^[4] However, Lawrence persisted in her civic work because she believed that her family, and her neighbors' families, had the same rights to affordable housing as the new wealthy, suburban residents.

Mount Laurel I

Lawrence was an officer, pianist, and director of the Young People's Dept. (YPD) of Jacob's Chapel, A.M.E. (African Methodist Episcopal) Church in Mount Laurel. Around 1960, Mount Laurel officials were condemning and tearing down the substandard homes of many "lower income" people; however, no efforts were made to assist them in relocating elsewhere in Mount Laurel. As a result, Lawrence, along with Reverend Stuart Wood and other church members, formed a non-profit corporation, called The Springville Community Action Committee, to develop low- and moderate-income housing. In 1969, the Township zoning board denied the 36-unit housing project proposed by the Action Committee, with Bill Haines, the Mayor at the time, saying, "If you people can't afford to live in our town, then you'll just have to leave."^[5]

Outraged, the Committee sued. At Camden Regional Legal Services, three young lawyers—Peter O'Connor, Carl Bisgaier, and Ken Meiser—took on their case, with Lawrence agreeing to be the lead plaintiff. The lawsuit accused the township of using its zoning laws to discriminate against poor residents. In 1975, the Supreme Court of New Jersey ruled in favor of Lawrence, in a ruling called Mount Laurel I.^[6] Mount Laurel I holds that all New Jersey municipalities have an obligation under the New Jersey Constitution to provide their fair share of the region's need for low-income and moderate-income housing.^[7]

However, in 1976, in response to the ruling, Mount Laurel Township changed its zoning law, allowing the low-income housing project to be built, but on unstable, swampy land.^[6] As a result, Lawrence and her neighbors returned to court.^[6]

Mount Laurel II

In 1983, the Supreme Court of New Jersey again ruled in favor of Lawrence and the other plaintiffs, in a ruling known as Mount Laurel II. In the second ruling, the courts specified how many units of affordable housing should be built in the township, and instructed lower court judges to set similar goals for other towns.^[6] This decision only increased controversy among suburban communities, with many fair share numbers doubling the housing stock and increasing worry among wealthy residents who feared that their communities would be invaded by hordes of "poor people" bringing crime, higher taxes, and lower property values ^[5]

Fair Housing Act & the Council on Affordable Housing

As a result of many disputes, and under pressure from municipalities that objected to the Mount Laurel rulings, the New Jersey Legislature passed the Fair Housing Act of 1985.^[6] The Act created a Council on Affordable Housing and an administrative process for setting local housing goals.^[6]

This compromise piece of legislation was met with annoyance by both sides.^[6] From the beginning, the Council recalled the state's affordable housing need, reducing it from the 277,808 reached by the court to 145,707. The Council also allowed municipalities to reduce their quotas even further by crediting them for subsidized apartments built since 1980 and for environmentally sensitive land considered unbuildable. They also could count renovated houses and accessory apartments tucked in basements and garages towards their totals.^[7] The most controversial act set by the Council allowed municipalities to reduce their housing obligations by up to one-half by making a one-time payment to another municipality (usually poor and urban) that agreed to accept their housing obligation.

Mount Laurel III

Despite Mount Laurel I, II, the Fair Housing Act, and the Council on Affordable Housing, the law and its provisions continued to be challenged in court, with talk in the legislature of denying Chief Justice Wilentz's (the Judge responsible for the ruling of Mount Laurel II) permanent nomination to the Supreme Court of the United States.^[7] In February 1986, the State Supreme Court issued another decision, now referred to as Mount Laurel III, which unanimously upheld the law as constitutional and consistent with Mount Laurel I and II.^[6]

Fair Share Housing Development, Inc.

In 1986 attorney Peter O'Connor founded a non-profit organization called Fair Share Housing Development Inc.^[8] Lawrence was named the charter president of the board of trustees of the company. According to their website: "The mission of Fair Share Housing Development (FSHD) is to promote economically and racially diverse communities throughout the tri-county region surrounding the City of Camden, New Jersey through the development of affordable housing with supportive services in an effort to improve the lives of moderate-income, low-income and very low-income families, the elderly and disabled and to reverse decades of decline and segregation in the City of Camden by providing Camden City residents with the choice to reside in affordable housing in high-opportunity communities with access to decent jobs, good schools, and a safe environment." In May 1994, Lawrence's daughter Ethel Lawrence-Halley was named administrator of the Mount Laurel project.^[1]

However, Lawrence would not live to see the township grant final approval for the construction of 100 subsidized townhouses to Fair Share Housing, the first phase of Ethel R. Lawrence Homes (ERLH). It wasn't until 1997 that the Mount Laurel Planning Board finally approved the nonprofit's request to build.^[6] Following the first phase, two other phases were built in 2003 (ERLH II - 40 units) and 2018 (ERLH III - 36 units). A nearby development in Mount Laurel called Robinson Estates (named after Ethel’s mother Mary) features 24 single-family homes, a rarity in affordable housing, and was also built in 2018, as part of the redevelopment project that led to the construction of ERLH III.

Lawrence died from cancer on July 19, 1994, at the age of 68.

Related Research Articles

Burlington County is a county in the South Jersey region of the U.S. state of New Jersey. The county is the largest by land area in New Jersey and ranks second behind neighboring Ocean County in total area. Its county seat is Mount Holly. As of the 2020 census, the county was the state's 11th-most-populous county, with a population of 461,860, its highest decennial count ever and an increase of 13,126 (+2.9%) from the 448,734 recorded at the 2010 census, which in turn had reflected an increase of 25,340 (6.0%) from the 423,394 enumerated at the 2000 census. The most populous place in the county was Evesham Township with 46,826 residents as of the 2020 census. Washington Township covered 102.71 square miles (266.0 km²), the largest area of any municipality in the county. The county is part of the South Jersey region of the state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mount Laurel, New Jersey</span> Township in Burlington County, New Jersey, US

Mount Laurel is a township in Burlington County in the U.S. state of New Jersey. The township, and all of Burlington County, is a part of the Philadelphia-Reading-Camden combined statistical area and the Delaware Valley. As of the 2020 United States census, the township's population was 44,633, its highest decennial count ever and an increase of 2,769 (+6.6%) from the 2010 census count of 41,864, which in turn reflected an increase of 1,643 (+4.1%) from the 40,221 counted in the 2000 census. It is the home of NFL Films.

Bellmawr is a borough in Camden County, in the U.S. state of New Jersey. As of the 2020 United States census, the borough's population was 11,707, an increase of 124 (+1.1%) from the 2010 census count of 11,583, which in turn reflected an increase of 321 (+2.9%) from the 11,262 counted in the 2000 census.

Laurel Springs is a borough in Camden County, in the U.S. state of New Jersey. As of the 2020 United States census, the borough's population was 1,978, an increase of 70 (+3.7%) from the 2010 census count of 1,908, which in turn reflected a decline of 62 (−3.1%) from the 1,970 counted in the 2000 census.

Mount Ephraim is a borough in Camden County, in the U.S. state of New Jersey. As of the 2020 United States census, the borough's population was 4,651, a decrease of 25 (−0.5%) from the 2010 census count of 4,676, which in turn reflected an increase of 181 (+4.0%) from the 4,495 counted in the 2000 census.

Somerdale is a borough in Camden County, in the U.S. state of New Jersey. As of the 2020 United States census, the borough's population was 5,566, an increase of 415 (+8.1%) from the 2010 census count of 5,151, which in turn reflected a decline of 41 (−0.8%) from the 5,192 counted in the 2000 census.

Stratford is a borough in Camden County, in the U.S. state of New Jersey. As of the 2020 United States census, the borough's population was 6,981, a decrease of 59 (−0.8%) from the 2010 census count of 7,040, which in turn reflected a decline of 231 (−3.2%) from the 7,271 counted in the 2000 census. Rowan-Virtua School of Osteopathic Medicine is located in Stratford.

Inclusionary zoning (IZ) is municipal and county planning ordinances that require or provide incentives when a given percentage of units in a new housing development be affordable by people with low to moderate incomes. Such housing is known as inclusionary housing. The term inclusionary zoning indicates that these ordinances seek to counter exclusionary zoning practices, which exclude low-cost housing from a municipality through the zoning code. Non-profit affordable housing developers build 100% of their units as affordable, but need significant taxpayer subsidies for this model to work. Inclusionary zoning allows municipalities to have new affordable housing constructed without taxpayer subsidies. In order to encourage for-profit developers to build projects that include affordable units, cities often allow developers to build more total units than their zoning laws currently allow so that there will be enough profit generating market-rate units to offset the losses from the below market-rate units and still allow the project to be financially feasible. Inclusionary zoning can be mandatory or voluntary, though the great majority of units have been built as a result of mandatory programmes. There are variations among the set-aside requirements, affordability levels, and length of time the unit is deed-restricted as affordable housing.

The Comprehensive Permit Act is a Massachusetts law which allows developers of affordable housing to override certain aspects of municipal zoning bylaws and other requirements. It consists of Massachusetts General Laws (M.G.L.) Chapter 40B, Sections 20 through 23, along with associated regulations issued and administered by the Massachusetts Department of Housing and Community Development. Chapter 40B was enacted in 1969 to address the shortage of affordable housing statewide by reducing barriers created by local municipal building permit approval processes, local zoning, and other restrictions. Its goal is to encourage the production of affordable housing in all communities throughout the Commonwealth.

Abbott districts are school districts in New Jersey that are provided remedies to ensure that their students receive public education in accordance with the state constitution. They were created in 1985 as a result of the first ruling of Abbott v. Burke, a case filed by the Education Law Center. The ruling asserted that public primary and secondary education in poor communities throughout the state was unconstitutionally substandard. The Abbott II ruling in 1990 had the most far-reaching effects, ordering the state to fund the (then) 28 Abbott districts at the average level of the state's wealthiest districts. The Abbott District system was replaced in 2007 by the New Jersey Schools Development Authority.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Davidoff</span>

Paul Davidoff was an American planner, planning educator, and planning theoretician who conceptualized "advocacy planning" with his wife, Linda Stone Davidoff. In legal scholarship, he is known as the primary litigant in the Mount Laurel decision, which established a state-constitutional basis for inclusionary zoning in New Jersey, a doctrine which has been accepted in other United States jurisdictions. Davidoff founded the Suburban Action Institute and the urban planning department at Hunter College, and also taught at the University of Pennsylvania and Princeton University during his career.

Warth v. Seldin, 422 U.S. 490 (1975), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court reviewed the concept of judicial standing and affirmed that if the plaintiffs lacked standing, they could not maintain a case against the defendants.

The Mount Laurel doctrine is a significant judicial doctrine of the New Jersey State Constitution. The doctrine requires that municipalities use their zoning powers in an affirmative manner to provide a realistic opportunity for the production of housing affordable to low- and moderate-income households.

Robert Nathan Wilentz was Chief Justice of the New Jersey Supreme Court from 1979 to 1996, making him the longest-serving Chief Justice since the Supreme Court became New Jersey's highest court in 1948.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Washington Oak</span>

The Washington Oak is a protected ancient white oak tree in Princeton, New Jersey, USA that overlooks the Princeton Battlefield State Park. The International Society of Arboriculture and the Tree Care Industry Association jointly recognize the Washington Oak as having lived at the time of the signing of the United States Constitution in 1787.

The Council on Affordable Housing (COAH) is a defunct agency of the Government of New Jersey within the New Jersey Department of Community Affairs that was responsible for ensuring that all 566 New Jersey municipalities provided their fair share of low and moderate income housing.

Cherry Hill is a township within Camden County, in the U.S. state of New Jersey. As a suburb of Philadelphia the township is part of South Jersey and the Delaware Valley region. Cherry Hill Township grew during the mid-20th century suburbanization, becoming one of the Delaware Valley's main commercial centers, including the Cherry Hill Mall. As of the 2020 United States census, the township's population was 74,553.

Howard County Housing is the umbrella organization for the Howard County Department of Housing and Community Development and the Howard County Housing Commission. The Department is Howard County Government’s housing agency, and the Commission is a public housing authority and non-profit. Both have boards that meet monthly.

A "poor door" is a separate entrance to a multi-unit housing development for those living in less expensive apartments.

The builder's remedy is a legal mechanism in the United States that can be used in certain states to expedite the construction of low or middle income housing when a municipality fails to comply with laws related to housing development. Typically, where a municipality fails to comply with state laws regarding the development of new housing, the builder's remedy either allows a developer to bypass or ignore nearly all of the municipality's zoning laws and begin construction on a development in an expedited manner or provides the developer with a legal remedy that can be enforced in court or through an administrative process. Builder's remedy projects are increasingly common in California, where new state laws have been passed to force local municipalities to approve additional housing to address the ongoing California housing shortage. Massachusetts and New Jersey also employ a form of the builder's remedy as well.

References

1 2 3 4 5 Kent, Bill. “Coming Home.” New Jersey Monthly, Feb. 2000, pp. 23–27.
1 2 3 Lawrence-Halley, Ethel A. “Biography: Ethel Robinson Lawrence.” Online, Mount Laurel, NJ.
↑ Courtney, Marian. "For Chief Plaintiff, A 15-Year Battle.", The New York Times , August 4, 1985. Accessed August 17, 2021
↑ Liebling, Charles. “Race and Affordable Housing: The Saga of Mount Laurel Reads like a Civil Rights Docudrama.” Sunday Press, March 10, 1998.
1 2 Kirp, David L. "Here Comes the Neighborhood.", The New York Times , October 13, 2013. Accessed August 17, 2021.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Smothers, Ronald. "Ending Battle, Suburb Allows Homes for Poor", The New York Times , April 12, 1997. Accessed August 17, 2021.
1 2 3 DePalma, Anthony. "Mount Laurel: Slow, Painful Progress", The New York Times , 1 May 1988.
↑ Smothers, Ronald. "Decades Later, Town Considers Housing Plan For the Poor.", The New York Times , March 3, 1997. Accessed August 17, 2021.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[Coming_Home-1] 1 2 3 4 5 Kent, Bill. “Coming Home.” New Jersey Monthly, Feb. 2000, pp. 23–27.

[Biography-2] 1 2 3 Lawrence-Halley, Ethel A. “Biography: Ethel Robinson Lawrence.” Online, Mount Laurel, NJ.

[Plaintiff-3] Courtney, Marian. "For Chief Plaintiff, A 15-Year Battle.", The New York Times , August 4, 1985. Accessed August 17, 2021

[Saga-4] Liebling, Charles. “Race and Affordable Housing: The Saga of Mount Laurel Reads like a Civil Rights Docudrama.” Sunday Press, March 10, 1998.

[Neighborhood-5] 1 2 Kirp, David L. "Here Comes the Neighborhood.", The New York Times , October 13, 2013. Accessed August 17, 2021.

[Votes_to_Build-6] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Smothers, Ronald. "Ending Battle, Suburb Allows Homes for Poor", The New York Times , April 12, 1997. Accessed August 17, 2021.

[Slow_Painful_Progress-7] 1 2 3 DePalma, Anthony. "Mount Laurel: Slow, Painful Progress", The New York Times , 1 May 1988.

[Decades_Later-8] Smothers, Ronald. "Decades Later, Town Considers Housing Plan For the Poor.", The New York Times , March 3, 1997. Accessed August 17, 2021.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]