Plot
Continuing from the events of "King's Tide" in the Boiling Isles, after successfully forcing Luz and her friends into the Human Realm, King Clawthorne tries to explain to the Collector the rules of "Owl House". Lilith Clawthorne and Hooty try to save King, but are turned into puppets for the Collector to play with in the Archive House, his newly built house. Eda Clawthorne then transforms into her harpy form to confront the Collector.
More than couple of months later, continuing from the events of "Thanks to Them", Luz Noceda wakes up in-between realms, where she notices a winged figure waving at her from above just before she is pulled by her girlfriend, Amity Blight, into the Demon Realm. Both accompanied by their friends Willow, Gus, and Hunter, along with Luz's mother, Camila, discover that the Boiling Isles have changed in major ways since they last left, having become cartoonishly cute, filled with vivid colors and cute objects. Luz and the group decide to head to the Owl House to regroup. Meanwhile, Emperor Belos struggles to keep his shape as he tries to find some way to regain power, all the while suffering anxiety attacks and visions of his brother, Caleb.
Luz's group discover the Owl House to now be completely abandoned and desecrated. Camila talks to Gus and Willow about Luz's worries of wanting to make amends to her mother, with Luz wanting to stay in the Human Realm permanently to do so, and talks with Willow about her bottling up her emotions, which Willow denies. Meanwhile, Hunter suffers PTSD-like symptoms from his palisman, Flapjack, dying, while Camila gives a speech to Willow and Gus. In Eda's room, Luz worries about her palisman not hatching, but Amity comforts her and tells her to be patient.
Hunter notices a shooting star carrying the Collector and King, so the group flies to the now abandoned Bonesborough, where the Collector has turned it into a playground to play with his puppets. After a round of playing, the Collector and King fly off to get Eda, the only citizen the Collector keeps that has not turned into a puppet. Afterwards, Luz's group spot a group of students from Hexside Academy, and decide to head there. They learn that after the Collector turned the teachers into puppets, the remaining students decided to create a makeshift community to survive. However, they also learn that Boscha has taken the role of their president, to most of the community's dismay due to her reputation as a spoiled, rich socialite with a disdain for considering any of the student's ideas to help.
At the same time, Belos heads to his old hideout spot, suffering further hallucinations of old memories and Grimwalkers he created, and eventually finds and absorbs an unfinished Grimwalker to heal. At the Archive House, King and the Collector pass by Odalia Blight, Amity's mother, who has now become a servant for the Collector to avoid becoming a puppet. King reads the Collector a bedtime story about the Collector's race, who would collect and preserve life from other dimensions while wiping out any that tried to resist, with the Collector rebelling due to finding them boring. While the Collector sleeps, King collects the Hooty puppet and reunites with Eda, who is hanging with the Raine Whispers puppet; she is still active due to the Collector believing her to still be stuck in her Owl Beast form. The two leave and meet with Lilith, who was also able to escape into hiding thanks to King, who then gives her the Hooty puppet, who still possesses some consciousness.
At Hexside, Mattholomule, sneaks Luz's group into the magic photo classroom, where they hope to extract memories from Luz, specifically the one when she was with Phillip in the past where he used a teleportation spell into the skull of the Titan, hoping to reach the Archive House. Willow gives Hunter a picture of him and Flapjack together and tells him everyone doesn't care that he is a Grimwalker, and that he is one of them now, but Hunter is shown to be sad over the fact, leading Willow to leave the room distraught. Gus reveals he knew Hunter's identity ever since the Day of Unity and questions if his and Hunter's decision of waiting was the right call as he goes to find Willow, with Hunter realizing that his fear and not trusting them became a mistake and quickly follows. Boscha taunts Willow like so many prior times, causing her to stand up for herself and briefly admit her stress. The taunt is revealed to be a trap, and Willow and the rest of the group are ambushed and captured by Boscha and Kikimora, who, with her Abomatron, had been posing as refugees and became Boscha's advisor.
Belos heads to the Archive House and possesses the puppet of Raine Whispers. He attempts to attack the Collector, but when he gets caught, Belos convinces him that he was magically brought back to life due to him possessing and draining flesh from wild animals he did in the human realm and that King is currently plotting to imprison him again. The Collector eavesdrops on King, Eda, and Lilith, the latter having discovered that Titan magic can cancel out the Collector's magic, and believes the idea to be true, not hearing King's true intentions to talk with him peacefully.
Luz, Amity, Camila, and Mattholomule end up in a deep pit. Kikimora, wanting to seek revenge against Luz, attacks the group with her Abomatron, sending the four fleeing in different directions. Amity and Mattholomule end up running into Boscha, who pleads with Amity to join the leadership council. Amity is disgusted by the offer and refuses to take it, and tries to convince Boscha to help them so they can rescue her friends. Meanwhile, Luz and Camila retreat into the local woods, where Luz is frustrated about messing up again, and admits she does not want to leave the Demon Realm. Camila reminds her that messing up is a part of life, relating all her mistakes, and apologizing for her greatest one: trying to change Luz into someone she wasn't. Luz realizes that all she wanted was to be understood, causing her palisman egg to finally hatch.
In another pit made of vines, Willow, Gus, and Hunter end up wandering around. Willow suffers an extreme nervous breakdown, losing control of her magic. Hunter and Gus manage to calm her down, with the former unlocking the magic of Flapjack's spirit inside of him, allowing him to perform magic without a staff. They let Willow vent about her frustrations, and Hunter admits to her how important the group is to him. As the pit caves in, the three escape and regroup with Luz and Camila, who are being attacked by Kikimora. Amity, now joined by Boscha and the rest of the students at Hexside, join in the fight and overrun Kikimora. Luz's group then succeeds in creating the teleportation spell and arrive at the Titan's skull. There, Luz's palisman is discovered to be a shape-shifting serpent, or "snakeshifter", whom she names Stringbean. As the Collector looks on, Belos' words convince him that Luz has come to assist King in defeating him. He frowns and declares that he wants to play a "new game", and snaps his fingers. [3]
