Giorgio Coda

Last updated
Giorgio Coda
Giorgio Coda La Stampa 5July1974 pag5.jpg
Italian psychiatrist and professor Giorgio Coda
Born(1924-01-21)21 January 1924 [1]
Turin, Italy
NationalityItalian
Other namesThe electrician (Italian: l'elettricista) [2]
Known forTortures with electroshock

Giorgio Giuseppe Antonio Maria Coda (born 21 January 1924) is an Italian psychiatrist and professor. He was vicedirector of the mental hospital of Turin (Italian : Ospedale psichiatrico di Torino, in Collegno) [3] and director of villa Azzurra (institute for children), [4] in Grugliasco (Turin) After the trial, that lasted from 1970 to 1974, he was sentenced to five years of imprisonment for patient abuse, as well as to interdiction from the medical profession for five years and payment of legal expenses. [5] [6] He has been nicknamed "The Electrician" (Italian : l'elettricista) [2] for his misuse of the electroshock therapy.

Contents

The medical treatment consisted in the application of long-lasting electric current to the genitals and to the head. The treatment did not make the patient lose consciousness and caused strong pain. According to Giorgio Coda, this treatment should have cured the patient. The treatment was called alternatively "electro-massage" (Italian : elettromassaggio) or electroshock depending on whether it was applied to the genitals or to the head. In some cases, the two terms have been used without distinction to denote the generic treatment. The treatment was practiced systematically without anesthesia and, sometimes, without cream and rubber protection device inside the mouth, blowing up the patient's teeth during the treatments. During the trial, Giorgio Coda admitted he had practiced about 5000 "electro-massages" in his career. [7]

The above treatment was also administered to alcoholics, drug addicts, homosexuals [8] and masturbators, and it generated such a strong fear of the treatment, that most patients, at least temporarily, desisted from their acts and behaviors. The trial and the sentence, collected and analyzed in Alberto Papuzzi's book Portami su quello che canta have shown the coercive and punitive purpose of "electro-massages", which in practice were tools of torture and punishment, used on children too (in villa Azzurra).

Deaths during the treatment and suicides occurring in Coda's clinics raise the suspicion that they may have been provoked, at least in part, by the fear of suffering. [9]

At the time the case was interpreted in political terms by some journalists and by the left-wing public opinion, with the bourgeois doctor abusing the weakest members of the proletariat. [10]

Biography

Most of the details about Giorgio Coda's life and academic career is given by Alberto Papuzzi's book Portami su quello che canta.

Born in Turin on 21 January 1924 in a wealthy family, Giorgio Coda is the only child of Carlo Coda, a small industrialist from Turin who "regulated the family life as if it were a factory" and Alda Vacchieri. [11] "At school, Giorgio Coda excelled in conduct. He was not brilliant, but very diligent. A few schoolmates remember him as a grind." [12]

In 1943, Giorgio Coda enrolled in the Faculty of Medicine of the University of Turin and graduated on 15 July 1948 with a thesis about criminal anthropology. On 16 April 1955, Giorgio Coda married Giovanna Roviera. After becoming head physician of the department, on 3 April 1963 he became a professor of psychiatry. [13]

Certosa reale di Collegno, where Turin mental hospital was located until the end of 1970s Certosa Collegno.JPG
Certosa reale di Collegno, where Turin mental hospital was located until the end of 1970s

The trial starts right after the Italian court specialized in minors - Tribunale per i minorenni - receives a report from children's social worker Maria Repaci. The report is about the facts of villa Azzurra. On 7 September, Giogio Coda is indicted for the crime "misuse of the correction systems" and the amnesty is granted, as provided by Italian law (DPR n. 238 del 22 maggio 1970). [14]

On 14 December 1970, an Italian judge receives another report from an Italian association - Associazione per la lotta contro le malattie mentali - which turned out to be crucial in order to start the investigation and the trial. [15] On 11 July 1974, Giorgio Coda was found guilty - "responsible for the crime only for the facts of the mental hospital in Collegno". [5] Subsequently, Giorgio Coda's defender appeals against the sentence. [16]

On 2 December 1977, at around 6:30 pm, four men, [17] all of them members of the Italian Marxist–Leninist terrorist group Prima Linea penetrated into Giorgio Coda's office and shot him in the leg. [18]

At the Court of appeal of Turin, Coda's defense cleverly exploited what the judge Rodolfo Venditti called a "torpedo", a sort of legal trick, based on the fact that Giorgio Coda, as an expert, had been an "honorary judge" (Italian : giudice onorario) of the Juvenile Court (Italian : Tribunale per i miniorenni) in Turin and therefore, since he had been a sort of "judge", he could not be tried in the same court where he had worked as a judge (as stated by Italian law). This detail was perhaps kept hidden by Coda's defense over the whole inferior court trial, and the discovery of this led to the annulment of the judgment and to the slowdown of the whole trial. Subsequently, the sentence was sent to the so-called Court of cassation (the last step of Italy's three grades of judgement), but the crimes were time-barred and Coda never served any penalty because of crime prescription. Giorgio Coda, according to newspapers, is still alive. [19] [20]

Effects

The case (as well as the book that collected and analyzed the stories, Portami su quello che canta, published in 1977) shocked the public opinion in Italy and sparked a debate. This led to a new law regulating Italian mental hospitals - the so-called Basaglia Law (in 1978, named after its promoter Franco Basaglia) - that abolished the main articles of the previous law - legge n. 36 del 14 febbraio 1904. [21] The Basaglia Law also introduced and regulated the T.S.O. (that stands for Trattamento sanitario obbligatorio - Obligatory Sanitary Treatment), [22] narrowing its scope and defining a multi-level procedure for its enforcement.

In particular, the new law required the intermediation of the mayor and the judge for the application of a T.S.O, the possibility for anyone (including the patient) to ask the T.S.O. to be revoked or modified, the possibility for anyone (including the patient) to appeal against the order validated by the judge, and the possibility for the patient to communicate with anyone during the T.S.O. [23] The patient also has the right to change mental hospital, if possible. The previous law had given too much power to the director of the mental hospital and it did not provide that the patient could communicate with anybody during the treatment.

Even though Basaglia Law did not explicitly provide that mental hospitals should be closed, it, in fact, closed most of Italy's mental hospitals, closure that was completed in 1998. Basaglia Law made Italy one of the first countries to abolish mental hospitals. [24]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paolo Conte</span> Italian music artist and lawyer (born 1937)

Paolo Conte is an Italian singer, pianist, songwriter and lawyer, known for his distinctly grainy, resonant voice. His compositions fuse Italian and Mediterranean sounds with jazz, boogie and elements of the French chanson and Latin-American rhythms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Luciana Littizzetto</span>

Luciana Littizzetto is an Italian comedy actress, shock jock and humor writer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Franco Basaglia</span> Italian psychiatrist (1924–1980)

Franco Basaglia was an Italian psychiatrist, neurologist, and professor, who proposed the dismantling of psychiatric hospitals, pioneer of the modern concept of mental health, Italian psychiatry reformer, figurehead and founder of Democratic Psychiatry, architect, and principal proponent of Law 180, which abolished mental hospitals in Italy. He is considered to be the most influential Italian psychiatrist of the 20th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Basaglia Law</span>

Basaglia Law or Law 180 is the Italian Mental Health Act of 1978 which signified a large reform of the psychiatric system in Italy, contained directives for the closing down of all psychiatric hospitals and led to their gradual replacement with a whole range of community-based services, including settings for acute in-patient care. The Basaglia Law is the basis of Italian mental health legislation. The principal proponent of Law 180 and its architect was Italian psychiatrist Franco Basaglia. Therefore, Law 180 is known as the “Basaglia Law” from the name of its promoter. The Parliament of Italy approved the Law 180 on 13 May 1978, and thereby initiated the gradual dismantling of psychiatric hospitals. Implementation of the psychiatric reform law was accomplished in 1998 which marked the very end of the state psychiatric hospital system in Italy. The Law has had worldwide impact as other counties took up widely the Italian model. It was Democratic Psychiatry which was essential in the birth of the reform law of 1978.

Democratic Psychiatry is an Italian real society, as well as a movement for liberation of the ill and weak from segregation in mental hospitals, by pushing for the Italian psychiatric reform. The movement was political in nature but not antipsychiatric in the sense in which this term is usually used in English. Democratic Psychiatry called for radical changes in the practice and theory of psychiatry and strongly attacked the way society managed mental illness. The movement was essential in the birth of the reform Basaglia Law of 1978.

Psychiatric reform in Italy is the reform of psychiatry which started in Italy after the passing of Basaglia Law in 1978 and terminated with the very end of the Italian state mental hospital system in 1998. Among European countries, Italy was the first to publicly declare its repugnance for a mental health care system which led to social exclusion and segregation. The psychiatric reform was also a consequence of a public debate sparked by Giorgio Coda's case and stories collected and analyzed in Alberto Papuzzi's book Portami su quello che canta.

Once Upon a Time the City of Fools is Italian television film of two episodes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Memorial Day of the Exiles and Foibe</span> National Day in Italy

National Memorial Day of the Exiles and Foibe is an Italian commemoration of the victims of the Foibe and the Istrian–Dalmatian exodus, which led to the emigration of hundreds of thousands of local ethnic Italians from Yugoslavia after the end of the Second World War.

<i>The Verona Trial</i> 1963 Italian film

Il processo di Verona is a 1963 Italian historical drama film directed by Carlo Lizzani. The film tells of the final phases of the Italian fascist regime, in particular the affair of the 1944 Verona trial, in which Galeazzo Ciano, Emilio De Bono, Giovanni Marinelli and other eminent Fascist officials were sentenced to death and almost immediately executed by a shooting detachment, while Tullio Cianetti was sentenced to 30 years imprisonment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Giorgio Antonucci</span> Italian physician (1933–2017)

Giorgio Antonucci was an Italian physician, known for his questioning of the bases of psychiatry.

Stamina therapy was a controversial and unproven treatment marketed in Italy by convicted quack Davide Vannoni during 2007–2014. Mainly aimed at neurodegenerative diseases, the method relied on the conversion of mesenchymal stem cells into neurons. Its details were kept secret by its promoters and Vannoni has never published any details in a scientific journal. In the absence of scientific validation, claims of its therapeutic effectiveness are unproven.

<i>Morire di classe</i>

Morire di classe. La condizione manicomiale fotografata da Carla Cerati e Gianni Berengo Gardin, first published in 1969, is a polemical work about the conditions in Italian mental hospitals of the time, edited by Franco Basaglia and Franca Ongaro Basaglia and with black and white photographs by Carla Cerati and Gianni Berengo Gardin, an introduction by the Basaglias, and various other texts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sergio Cotta</span> Italian philosopher

Sergio Cotta was an Italian philosopher, jurist and university professor. He was considered a specialist on the political thought of the Enlightenment. Cotta, along with André Masson and Robert Shackleton, was considered the most important interpreter of Montesquieu during the 20th century.

The term State-Mafia Pact describes an alleged series of negotiations between important Italian government officials and Cosa Nostra members that began after the period of the 1992 and 1993 terror attacks by the Sicilian Mafia with the aim to reach a deal to stop the attacks; according to other sources and hypotheses, it began even earlier. In summary, the supposed cornerstone of the deal was an end to "the Massacre Season" in return for a reduction in the detention measures provided for Italy's Article 41-bis prison regime. 41-bis was the law by which the Antimafia pool led by Giovanni Falcone had condemned hundreds of mafia members to the "hard prison regime". The negotiation hypothesis has been the subject of long investigations, both by the courts and in the media. In 2021, the Court of Appeal of Palermo acquitted a close associate of former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, while upholding the sentences of the mafia bosses. This ruling was confirmed by the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation in 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Claudia Letizia</span> Italian actress, dancer and singer

Claudia Letizia also known as Lady Letizia is an Italian actress, dancer, television and radio hostess and singer. She is known for having participated in the twelfth series of the reality show Grande Fratello, the Italian version of Big Brother.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mombello Psychiatric Hospital</span> Hospital in Lombardy, Italy

The Mombello Psychiatric Hospital, also known as the Giuseppe Antonini of Limbiate Psychiatric Hospital, was the largest asylum in Italy, covering 40,000 m2 (430,000 sq ft) with multiple buildings located as to form a small village. It is located in the Italian commune of Limbiate, in the administrative district of Monza and Brianza, Lombard Province. Officially inaugurated in 1878, it was the last psychiatric hospital to be closed after the approval of the Legge Basaglia in 1978.

Ville Sbertoli was a lunatic asylum in Pistoia, Italy. The original structure was built in the 17th century. In 1868, it was bought by Agostino Sbertoli, who wanted to create a health facility for wealthy families. After serving as a political prison during World War II, it was transformed into a public psychiatric hospital in 1951. The complex was later abandoned.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Exclusive economic zone of Italy</span> Economic zone exclusive to Italy

Italy has the world's 48th largest exclusive economic zone (EEZ), with an area of 541,915 km2 (209,235 sq mi). It claims an EEZ of 200 nmi from its shores, which has long coastlines with the Tyrrhenian Sea to the west, the Ionian Sea to the south and the Adriatic Sea to the east. Its EEZ is limited by maritime boundaries with neighboring countries to the north-west, east and southeast.

A five-part abrogative referendum was held in Italy on 12 June 2022. Voters were asked to decide on the repeal of five articles or decrees relating to the functions of the Italian judicial system. Each of the five questions were submitted by nine Italian regions, all governed by the centre-right coalition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Franco Rotelli</span> Italian psychiatrist (1942–2023)

Franco Rotelli was an Italian psychiatrist and essayist.

References

  1. Papuzzi (1977), pagina 6
  2. 1 2 Perissinotto
  3. "Dalla violenza dell'eletttromassaggio alla violenza dell'abbandono". Infermieristicamente - Nursind, il sindacato delle professioni infermieristiche. Retrieved 2018-03-01.
  4. Caselli
  5. 1 2 Papuzzi (1977), p. 96
  6. "Giorgio Coda: la persona, il processo e l'elettroshock". www.crescita-personale.it (in Italian). Retrieved 2018-03-01.
  7. Papuzzi (1977), p. 60
  8. Papuzzi (1977), p. 59. Giorgio Coda, during the trial, stated, "homosexuality is a disease that needs to be cured."
  9. Papuzzi (1977), p. 79
  10. Papuzzi (1977), nota introduttiva XI and p. 95
  11. Einaudi, Giulio (1977). "Alberto Papuzzi Portami su quello che canta" (PDF). collettivomakhno.noblogs.org. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2020-09-30. Retrieved 2019-09-21.
  12. Papuzzi (1977), p. 9
  13. Papuzzi (1977), pp. 9-14
  14. Papuzzi (1977), p. 36
  15. Papuzzi (1977) pp. 31-36
  16. Papuzzi (1977), p. 114
  17. Caselli, Stefano; Valentini, Davide (2014-11-05). "Il processo deve ricominciare". Anni spietati: Torino racconta violenza e terrorismo (in Italian). Gius.Laterza & Figli Spa. ISBN   9788858117828 . Retrieved 2018-02-12.
  18. "La Prima Linea - Agiscuola". agiscuola.it. Archived from the original on 2018-02-13. Retrieved 2019-09-20.
  19. "Festival dei Matti di Venezia, in un docufilm la storia e gli abusi di Giorgio Coda sui pazienti psichiatrici". Il Fatto Quotidiano (in Italian). 2019-05-25. Retrieved 2019-09-20.
  20. - Intervista al giudice Rodolfo Venditti
  21. Legge n. 36 del 14 febbraio 1904
  22. Estratto dall'articolo 2: "la proposta di trattamento sanitario obbligatorio può prevedere che le cure vengano prestate in condizioni di degenza ospedaliera solo se esistano alterazioni psichiche tali da richiedere urgenti interventi terapeutici, se gli stessi non vengano accettati dall'infermo e se non vi siano le condizioni e le circostanze che consentano di adottare tempestive ed idonee misure sanitarie extra ospedaliere".
  23. Legge Basaglia
  24. Viani, Andrea. "La Legge 180 e la chiusura degli Ospedali Psichiatrici". www.musei.re.it (in Italian). Retrieved 2019-09-20.

Bibliography

Books

Italian laws