HMS Saucy was a British tug hired in the Second World War for use as a rescue tug in the Firth of Forth. She was lost with almost all crew on 4 September 1940 after hitting a mine. Saucy was built as an Admiralty rescue (salvage) tug in the First World War.
She was built in Hessle by Livingstone & Cooper to an order from the Dept of Transport & Shipping for the Royal Navy as a member of the Frisky-class and launched in August 1918. She measured 579 gross register tons and had a displacement of 700 tons, typically for a tug, a large part of the weight was the huge engine, designed to pull larger vessels in salvage operations. [1]
In 1924 she was sold into commercial service but retained the name Saucy. In 1939 she was hired and commissioned by the Royal Navy with a crew of 31. In expectation of war, sea-mines had been laid in many strategic locations to prevent attacks by enemy vessels. The Firth of Forth was one of the many river estuaries so equipped. Mines were generally connected together with horizontal cables, with occasional anchor points to the sea-bed. However, rough seas would regularly detach a mine from its group and these then became a major hazard to shipping. Ironically therefore, minesweepers spent most of their time locating and disarming mines from their own country. Whilst many accounts (particularly contemporary) like to blame the enemy, accidents such as these (which were fairly common) were "self-inflicted wounds" when viewing on a national level. [2]
There is a natural inclination to blame this sort of accident on an "enemy mine", however this sort of sea-mine was a defensive weapon, not a weapon of attack. The main minefield protecting the Forth lay east of Inchkeith, and it would be virtually impossible for a German mine to float through this defensive line. It is therefore a certainty that the mine was a rogue British mine escaped from the main field in one of the preceding winter storms. This was a regular occurrence and was dealt with many local minesweepers such as HMT Firefly which lost 14 crew trying to defuse a British mine. [3]
Unlike the Firefly (which was actively involved in trying to defuse a mine) all the evidence is that there was no forewarning of a mine near HMS Saucy, and the ship exploded violently without warning and sank within minutes at the spot where she was steaming. Typically, due to wartime censorship, this sort of accident received no press coverage. [4]
18 of the 26 crew lost were from Brixham in Devon. [5] Only seven bodies were recovered, five being from Brixham. These seven were buried in Seafield Cemetery in north Edinburgh, a few miles south of the disaster site. [6]
The wreck lies 15m deep 2.5km off Inchkeith island at bearing of 277 degrees from the island, and was permanently marked by an orange buoy. In October 1945 the wreck was reduced by controlled explosion to reduce the hazard to shipping and the buoy was removed. By 1967 a survey revealed that the wreck was no longer perceptible, being lost in the silt. [7]
A bronze memorial plaque on the Old Fishmarket Building at Brixham Harbour, unveiled on 4 September 2004, lists the 18 Brixham men lost and then the 8 non-Brixham men. It states that seven of the Brixham men were related to each other. [8] Records show three members of the Harvey family from Brixham, dying, were related to each other. A non-Brixham father and son (the Reids) were related. Two further Brixham relations are presumed to have survived but the survivors were not named. [9]
The 19 men whose bodies went down with the ship, or were otherwise unrecovered, are listed on panel 21 of the Liverpool Naval Memorial. [10]
The Halcyon class was a class of 21 oil-fired minesweepers built for the British Royal Navy between 1933 and 1939. They were given traditional small ship names used historically by the Royal Navy and served during the Second World War.
Seafield is a coastal strip situated on the Firth of Forth between Leith and Portobello in north-east Edinburgh, Scotland. The area is mainly commercial, and has little housing.
The first USS Swan (AM-34/AVP-7) was a Lapwing-class minesweeper acquired by the United States Navy.
HMS Port Napier was a British motor ship that was designed and laid down as a civilian cargo ship but completed in 1940 as an auxiliary minelayer for the Royal Navy. An engine room fire caused an explosion that destroyed her in November 1940. Her remains in Loch Alsh in Scotland are now a recreational wreck diving site.
USS Auk (AM-38) was a Lapwing-class minesweeper acquired by the United States Navy after World War I to remove mines that had been placed during the war.
MV Atheltemplar was a motor tanker built by Lithgows, Port Glasgow. She was launched on 15 April 1930, registered in Liverpool and operated by the United Molasses Co Ltd of London. She was transferred to Athel Lines on 1 January 1940.
HMNZS Puriri (T02) was a coastal cargo ship which was requisitioned by the Royal New Zealand Navy (RNZN) and converted into a minesweeper. She was sunk by a German naval mine 25 days after she was commissioned.
HMS Jason was a Halcyon-class minesweeper. She was named after the hero in Greek mythology and was the sixteenth Royal Navy ship to carry the name Jason. She was laid down on 12 December 1936, launched on 6 October 1937, and was completed on 9 June 1938. She survived the Second World War and was sold in 1946 to become a cargo ship. She was eventually broken up in 1950. Her pennant number was originally N99, but was changed to J99 in May 1940.
HMS Iveston was a Ton-class minesweeper of the Royal Navy launched on 1 June 1954 by Philip and Son in Dartmouth. After her decommissioning in 1992, HMS Iveston became the Sea Cadet training ship T.S. Iveston. She was sold and scrapped in March 2015.
PS Duchess of Montrose was a paddle steamer launched in 1902 and operated by the Caledonian Steam Packet Company as a River Clyde excursion steamer. She saw active service during the First World War after being requisitioned by the Admiralty and converted into a minesweeper. She was lost near Dunkirk on 18 March 1917 after striking a mine.
HMT Firefly was a minesweeping trawler that saw service during the Second World War.
Brighton was a 1,384 GRT steamship which was built in 1903 for the London, Brighton and South Coast Railway and London and South Western Railway. She passed to the Southern Railway on 1 January 1923. In 1930, she was sold to W E Guinness and converted to a private yacht, Roussalka. She was wrecked at Killary Bay on 25 August 1933.In June 2024, members of the Athlone Sub Aqua Club rediscovered the remains of the wreck.It had been found in the 1970s but its position was lost. The Sub Aqua team is logging and filming the wreck for historical interest.
SS Monte Nevoso was a cargo steamship that was launched in 1920 in England, owned in Italy, and wrecked in 1932 in the North Sea off the coast of Norfolk.
SS Gallois was a French collier built in 1917 as Tynemouth and later Lord Aberconway. She was one of seven merchant vessels which became stranded and then wrecked on Haisbro Sands off the Norfolk coast on 6 August 1941 during the Second World War as part of Convoy FS 559.
HMAS Goorangai was a 223-ton auxiliary minesweeper of the Royal Australian Navy (RAN). She was built in 1919 for the Government of New South Wales, then sold in 1926 to the fishing company Cam & Sons. The trawler was requisitioned for military service following the outbreak of World War II, converted into a minesweeper, and assigned to Melbourne. She was sunk in an accidental collision with MV Duntroon in 1940, becoming the RAN's first loss of World War II, and the first RAN surface ship to be lost in wartime.
HMS Sphinx (J69) was a Halcyon-class minesweeper of the British Royal Navy, which was commissioned in 1939, just prior to World War II. During the war she served in the North Sea until bombed and wrecked on 2 February 1940.
At least seven vessels of the Royal Navy have borne the name HMS Firefly:
SS Ashkhabad was a merchant ship of the Soviet Union sunk in 1942. She had been built as a British merchant ship in 1917 in Glasgow, Scotland as War Hostage. Over the next three decades she passed through a number of owners and had several different names; Milazzo (1919–1924), Aldersgate (1924–1925), Mistley Hall (1925–1934), Kutais (1934–1935), Dneprostroi (1935–1938) and finally Ashkhabad from 1938 to 1942. Originally designed as a freighter, she was at several points converted to a tanker to carry fuel oil. At the time of her loss the four hundred foot tanker was owned by the Soviet Union's Sovtorgflot organisation. She was torpedoed on 29 April 1942, and then sunk as a hazard to navigation on 3 May 1942. The wreck is now a popular dive site.
HMS Malvernian was an Ellerman Lines cargo steamship that was built in 1937. In January 1941 she was converted into an ocean boarding vessel. That July she sank after a German air attack crippled her in the Atlantic Ocean.