Hadiza Bawa-Garba case

Last updated

Balmoral building, Leicester Children's Hospital, LRI. Childrens floor 3 Balmoral building 17.jpg
Balmoral building, Leicester Children's Hospital, LRI.

Jack Adcock, a 6-year-old child, was admitted to Leicester Royal Infirmary (LRI) on 18 February 2011. He died later that day, in part because of failings in his treatment. Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba, the junior doctor who treated him (under the supervision of duty consultant Dr Stephen O'Riordan) and a nurse, Isabel Amaro, were subsequently found guilty of manslaughter on the grounds of gross negligence. Both were subsequently struck off their respective professional registers, although Bawa-Garba had that decision overturned at appeal. There is an ongoing debate about the judgements against Bawa-Garba, [1] partly around Bawa-Garba's personal culpability versus a context of systemic failures, and partly around the possible use of her reflective notes about her own practice as evidence. [2]

Contents

Background

In 2010, the Medical Programme Board demonstrated almost a quarter of junior doctors dropped out of their NHS training in England after two years, and according to Unions, this was due to high workload. Denied by the department of Health, the BMA highlighted issues around the 'European Working Time Directive', shift patterns and understaffing. [3] [4] [5]

In 2016, a report issued by the Royal College of Physicians stressed "gaps in rotas, poor access to basic facilities and an ever-growing workload" for doctors in training. Despite feeling valued by their patients, 80% of these doctors reported excessive stress, either ‘sometimes’ or ‘often’. The report presented "a bleak picture of the conditions junior doctors currently face and the impact this is having on the patients they care for every day" and this was at "a harmful and unsustainable level". [6] [7] The problem of rota gaps and high levels of stress and its resulting effect on staff morale was also later emphasised at the 2017 BMA annual representative meeting. [8]

Timeline

Jack Adcock's death

On 18 February 2011, Jack Adcock, a 6-year-old boy, was referred to Leicester Royal Infirmary by his GP and admitted to a Children's Assessment Unit (CAU) at 10.20am. He had Down's syndrome and had an atrioventricular septal defect repaired at 4.5 months of age. He was on an angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor, enalapril. He presented with diarrhoea, vomiting and difficulty breathing. [1]

He was treated by Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba, a specialist registrar (SpR) in year six of her postgraduate training (ST6) who had recently returned from maternity leave, who was responsible for Jack's care. There was no senior consultant available, leaving her with sole responsibility for the whole CAU. Rota gaps had meant that Bawa-Garba had to cover the work of two other doctors [9] and the on-call consultant (Dr Stephen O'Riordan) was off-site in Warwick until 4.30pm that day, as he had not realised he was on-call. The morning hand-over between the incoming and outgoing teams was not completed due to a cardiac arrest call.

Soon after admission, Bawa-Garba was alerted to Jack's condition by the nursing staff in CAU. After clinical examination, she found him to be dehydrated. A point-of-care venous blood gas test revealed profound Metabolic acidosis with a lactate of 11.4 mmol/L and serum pH of 7.084. She diagnosed hypovolaemia from gastroenteritis, and administered intravenous fluid replacement. Blood tests were sent off for laboratory analysis and a chest x-ray was requested.

Bawa-Garba made a number of mistakes. She did not ask the on-call consultant to review Jack during an afternoon handover meeting at 4.30pm but did share abnormal laboratory results with him which he duly wrote down in his notebook. He wrote down that the child's pH was 7.08 and lactate of 11. However, the consultant did not review the patient as he said later that he expected Bawa-Garba to "stress" these results to him. It was the first occasion they were working on the same shift. Although she correctly omitted the patient's medicine enalapril on the drug chart, she did not make it clear to the child's mother not to give it. Jack's mother subsequently asked a nurse, who told her incorrectly that she could give it. Jack's mother gave it to the child that day at 7pm which led to the child's circulatory shock and death. [10] This was the custom and practice in the hospital – to permit parents to administer medicines in the hospital before being prescribed.

Separately, a hospital-wide IT failure delayed test results being available until 4.30pm, despite the blood samples being sent at 11am. After phoning the laboratory, the team received the blood results showing CRP 97, Urea 17.1, Creatinine 252. The chest radiograph was undertaken an hour later at 12 noon, but was not reported by a radiologist. Bawa-Garba reviewed the radiograph at 3pm, identified left upper lobe pneumonia, and prescribed intravenous cefuroxime. A repeat venous gas showed an improvement in the pH to 7.24. She reviewed Jack again in CAU, and saw that he had improved, and was sitting up and having a drink. The antibiotics were administered by the nursing staff at 4pm. The hospital Trust has acknowledged systemic failures contributed to events. [11]

Earlier that day, Bawa-Garba had admitted a terminally-ill child with a Do not resuscitate (DNAR) order to the side-room on the ward. This child was seen by another consultant during the day and discharged home in the afternoon. At 7pm, unbeknownst to Bawa-Garba, Jack was transferred from CAU to the same side-room on the ward. At around 8pm Jack began to deteriorate further, whereupon the on-call anaesthetic and paediatric registrars were fast-bleeped. Despite urgent treatment, he suffered cardiac arrest, CPR was commenced, and endotracheal intubation was carried out. Bawa-Garba attended the cardiac arrest call to the side-room believing it to be the terminally-ill child she admitted earlier with a DNAR order. She requested the team to stop resuscitation, but realised it to be the wrong patient within 2 minutes, and therefore recommenced CPR.

Jack Adcock died of a cardiac arrest as a result of sepsis [12] at 9.20pm. [1]

Isabel Amaro cases

On 2 November 2015, Amaro was sentenced to a 2-year suspended jail sentence, having been found guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence. Her monitoring of Jack Adcock's condition and record-keeping were criticized. She was subsequently struck off the nursing register. [13]

Hadiza Bawa-Garba cases

On 4 November 2015, Bawa-Garba was found guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence in Nottingham Crown Court before a jury directed by Mr Justice Andrew Nicol after a 4-week trial. [14] She was found guilty by a majority verdict 10-2 after 25 hours of deliberation. She was represented by Zoe Johnson QC, with prosecution led by Andrew Johnson QC. The following month, she was given a 2-year suspended jail sentence. She appealed against the sentence, but the appeal was denied in December 2016. [1]

The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service suspended Bawa-Garba for 12 months on 13 June 2017. [15] The General Medical Council successfully appealed and Bawa-Garba was struck off on 25 January 2018. [1] [16]

On 13 August 2018, Bawa-Garba won an appeal against being struck off, restoring the one-year suspension. [17] [18]

Many healthcare professionals have raised concerns that Bawa-Garba was being unduly punished for failings in the system, notably the understaffing on the day. [1] [19] The consultant on-call, Dr Stephen O'Riordan, who was ultimately responsible for the care of all children on the day - as the consultant in charge - received no formal consequences. He moved to Ireland following the event.

She completed her specialist training and gained consultant status in April 2022. [20]

E-portfolio

A series of high-profile medical scandals including the Bristol heart scandal and The Shipman Inquiry has influenced the proposals of revalidation, that is, the relicensing of doctors. The process was put on hold in 2005, when Dame Janet Smith criticised the plans as inadequate for identifying dangerous doctors. Revalidation was eventually implemented in late 2012. All doctors in the UK who wished to retain their licences to practise were informed that they were legally required to be revalidated every five years, based on a combination of demonstrating up-to-date knowledge by fulfilling CPD (continuous professional development) requirements of the Colleges and providing multisource feedback from patients and colleagues. This was designed to demonstrate they were up to date and fit to practise. Revalidation, according to BMA council GMC working party chair Brian Keighley 2012, was intended "to encourage quality in healthcare for patients through self-assessment, appraisal, continuing medical education and reflective practice." He also stated that, "Over the past 10 years there has been confusion and tension between those who believe it is a screening tool for the incompetent, rather than a formative, educational process for the individual." [21]

Since 2012, several concerns have been highlighted including in 2016, that for junior doctors "A large number of doctors are required to 'reflect' on Serious Unresolved Incidents (SUIs) and Significant Event (SE) information as part of their specialty training. This could therefore create a significant administrative burden and result in cases of double jeopardy." [22]

As is common for clinicians, Bawa-Garba kept reflective learning material in an e-portfolio as part of her training, including relating to the treatment of Jack Adcock. This material was used against her, although to what degree has been disputed. [23] [24] Her defence team have stated that her e-portfolio was not used in the 2018 case. [25] The e-portfolio was not used explicitly in the 2015 case, but had been seen by expert witnesses. [2] [26]

This has raised concerns that clinicians would be concerned to be honest in their own reflective learning. [27] [28] [29]

Reaction

There is broad agreement that serious errors were made in Adcock's treatment. However, there has been a public debate about the background, context and pressures in which doctors work, and what happens when mistakes are made. The discussion centred on the issues of what systems and processes are in place that make mistakes less likely, and improve the chances of detecting them when they do occur. In the case of Dr Bawa-Garba, the NHS Trust in question recognised there were systemic failures and pressures which contributed to the death of a patient. Dr Bawa-Garba had an excellent record until then. [12] Dr Jeeves Wijesuriya, the then junior doctors' committee chair for the British Medical Association (BMA), argued that these systemic shortcomings were not adequately considered in the initial trial. [30]

At the end of January 2018, BMA council chair, Chaand Nagpaul, expressed concerns over doctors' fears and challenges in working under pressure in the NHS. He explained that without clarity from the General Medical Council (GMC) and others, issues surrounding recording reflective learning would result in defensive practice and failure to learn from experience. The BMA, in response, would, therefore, take actions to liaise with the GMC regarding the culture of fear, blame and system failings. Guidance to doctors on appraisal and recording reflection have also been included, as well as the launch of an online reporting system. [11] Jeremy Hunt warned of the "unintended consequences" of the ruling, saying that "For patients to be safe, we need doctors to be able to reflect completely openly and freely about what they have done, to learn from mistakes, to spread best practice around the system, to talk openly with their colleagues." [31]

The Doctors’ Association UK, a campaign and lobbying group for Doctors and the NHS campaigned to raise awareness of system failures in the case. [32]

During the period that the MPTS and GMC suspended and then erased Dr Bawa-Garba, confidence among doctors in England that the GMC is regulating doctors well and that its procedures are fair fell. [33] The GMC released a FAQ about the case, covering issues such as what doctors should do if concerned about staffing levels and reflective practice. [34]

The UK government introduced a series of reforms in response to the case, with a report released in June 2018. [35]

Related Research Articles

Sir Samuel Roy Meadow is a British retired paediatrician infamous for facilitating several wrongful convictions of mothers for murdering their babies. He was awarded the Donald Paterson prize of the British Paediatric Association in 1968 for a study of the effects on parents of having a child in hospital. In 1977, he published an academic paper describing a phenomenon dubbed Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy (MSbP). In 1980 he was awarded a professorial chair in paediatrics at St James's University Hospital, Leeds, and in 1998, he was knighted for services to child health.

David Southall is a retired British paediatrician who specialised in international maternal and child hospital healthcare and in child protection. He worked in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1993-1995, for which he received an OBE in 1999. In 1995 he set up the charity Maternal and Childhealth Advocacy International (MCAI), of which he remains a trustee as of 2023. His child protection work and research into Munchausen syndrome by proxy attracted controversy and led to conflict with the General Medical Council.

The British Medical Association (BMA) is a registered trade union for doctors in the United Kingdom. It does not regulate or certify doctors, a responsibility which lies with the General Medical Council. The BMA has a range of representative and scientific committees and is recognised by National Health Service (NHS) employers alongside the Hospital Consultants and Specialists Association as one of two national contract negotiators for doctors.

In the United Kingdom, junior doctors are qualified medical practitioners working whilst engaged in postgraduate training. The period of being a junior doctor starts when they qualify as a medical practitioner following graduation with a Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery degree and start the UK Foundation Programme. It culminates in a post as a consultant, a general practitioner (GP), or becoming a SAS Doctor, such as a specialty doctor or Specialist post.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leicester Royal Infirmary</span> Hospital in England

The Leicester Royal Infirmary (LRI) is a National Health Service hospital in Leicester, England. It is located to the south-west of the city centre. It has an accident and emergency department and is managed by of the University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">General Medical Council</span> Healthcare regulator for medical profession in the UK

The General Medical Council (GMC) is a public body that maintains the official register of medical practitioners within the United Kingdom. Its chief responsibility is to "protect, promote and maintain the health and safety of the public" by controlling entry to the register, and suspending or removing members when necessary. It also sets the standards for medical schools in the UK. Membership of the register confers substantial privileges under Part VI of the Medical Act 1983. It is a criminal offence to make a false claim of membership. The GMC is supported by fees paid by its members, and it became a registered charity in 2001.

In the United Kingdom, Ireland, and parts of the Commonwealth, consultant is the title of a senior hospital-based physician or surgeon who has completed all of their specialist training and been placed on the specialist register in their chosen speciality. Their role is entirely distinct from that of a general practitioner.

In the United Kingdom and Australia, revalidation refers to a mechanism used to "affirm or establish the continuing competence" of health practitioners, whilst strengthening and facilitating ethical and professional "commitment to reducing errors, adhering to best practice and improving quality of care". Medical practitioners, nurses and midwives practicing in the UK are subject to revalidation to prove their skills are up-to-date and they remain fit to practise medicine. It is intended to reassure patients, employers and other professionals, and to contribute to improving patient care and safety. The Medical Board of Australia is currently engaged in a review and trial of revalidation of medical registration in Australia.

Sir Duncan Brian Walter Ouseley, styled The Hon. Mr Justice Ouseley, is a retired High Court judge in England and Wales, Queen's Bench Division. He is notable for involvement in many legal cases reported in the British press.

Alexander Wiseman MacAra, also known as Sandy MacAra, was a Scottish professor of epidemiology at Bristol University and chairman of British Medical Association (BMA) from 1993 to 1998.

Michael Alexander Leary Pringle CBE is a British physician and academic. He is the emeritus professor of general practice (GP) at the University of Nottingham, a past president of the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP), best known for his primary care research on clinical audit, significant event audit, revalidation, quality improvement programmes and his contributions to health informatics services and health politics. He is a writer of medicine and fiction, with a number of publications including articles, books, chapters, forewords and guidelines.

The British Association of Physicians of Indian Origin (BAPIO) is a voluntary organisation for doctors of Indian sub-continental origin, established in 1996 and based in the United Kingdom. Its president is Ramesh Mehta of Bedford Hospital NHS Trust.

Peter Wilmshurst is a British medical doctor and successful whistleblower who has been the subject of multiple cases of harassment through vexatious libel actions brought by companies whose products he criticised as ineffective. He has also reported at least twenty doctors to the General Medical Council in the course of two decades of investigating research misconduct.

The Lancet MMR autism fraud centered on the publication in February 1998 of a fraudulent research paper titled "Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children" in The Lancet. The paper, authored by now discredited and deregistered Andrew Wakefield, and twelve coauthors, falsely claimed causative links between the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine and colitis and between colitis and autism. The fraud involved data selection, data manipulation, and two not-disclosed conflicts of interest. It was exposed in a lengthy Sunday Times investigation by reporter Brian Deer, resulting in the paper's retraction in February 2010 and Wakefield being struck off the UK medical register three months later. Wakefield reportedly stood to earn up to US$43 million per year selling diagnostic kits for a non-existent syndrome he claimed to have discovered. He also held a patent to a rival vaccine at the time, and he had been employed by a lawyer representing parents in lawsuits against vaccine producers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Donald Irvine (physician)</span> British general practitioner

Sir Donald Hamilton Irvine was a British general practitioner (GP) who was president of the General Medical Council (GMC) between 1995 and 2002, during a time when there were a number of high-profile medical failure cases in the UK, including the Alder Hey organs scandal, the Bristol heart scandal and The Shipman Inquiry. He transformed the culture of the GMC by setting out what patients could expect of doctors and is credited with leading significant changes in the regulation of professional medicine and introducing the policy of professional revalidation in the UK.

The Doctors’ Association UK (DAUK) is a professional association for doctors in the United Kingdom. The association was formed by junior doctors led by Samantha Batt-Rawden in January 2018 in response to the Bawa-Garba case.

Dr Samantha Batt-Rawden is a British intensive care and pre-hospital doctor.

Sarah Catherine Clarke FRCP FESC FACC is a British consultant cardiologist and was the president of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) of London between September 2022 and June 2024.

Jennifer Rosemary Vaughan was a British neurologist and co-lead of The Doctors' Association UK. She specialised in movement disorders, with a focus on Parkinson's disease. Alongside her research, Vaughan campaigned to improve justice within healthcare. She was made an Officer of the Order of the British Empire in the 2023 New Year Honours.

Martha's Rule is a patient safety initiative being implemented in English NHS hospitals from April 2024. It gives patients, families, carers and staff in hospitals who have concerns about a patient's deteriorating condition access to a rapid review from a critical care outreach team. Similar measures have been instituted in Australia, Denmark and the United States, and a programme called "Call 4 Concern" was previously trialled in the United Kingdom. Martha's Rule is also a 'cultural intervention', which will help to flatten hierarchies within medicine, improve listening and openness on the part of clinicians and give patients and their families greater agency.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "What really happened in the case that every doctor in Britain is talking about". Independent.co.uk . 30 January 2018.
  2. 1 2 "Revealed: how reflections were used in the Bawa-Garba case". Archived from the original on 5 February 2018. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
  3. ↑ "Junior medics 'leaving training'". BBC News. 6 September 2010. Retrieved 6 February 2018.
  4. ↑ "BBC News – Irregular shifts for junior doctors 'cause fatigue'". 25 May 2010. Retrieved 6 February 2018.
  5. ↑ Datta, Shreelata; Chatterjee, J.; Roland, D.; Fitzgerald, J. E. F.; Sowden, D. (6 September 2011). "The European Working Time Directive: time to change?". Careers. BMJ. 343: d5532. doi:10.1136/bmj.d5532. S2CID   79931158.
  6. ↑ "Junior doctors say patient safety is suffering as a result of poor staff morale and excessive stress". RCP London. 1 December 2016. Retrieved 6 February 2018.
  7. ↑ "Overworked and underpaid: Diary of a Junior Doctor 2017". www.newstatesman.com. 6 April 2016. Retrieved 6 February 2018.
  8. ↑ "BMA – Incidences of rota gaps surge". www.bma.org.uk. Retrieved 6 February 2018.
  9. ↑ "Rachel Clarke: The Hadiza Bawa-Garba case is a watershed for patient safety – The BMJ". blogs.bmj.com. 29 January 2018.
  10. ↑ Jha, Saurabh (6 February 2018). "To Err Is Homicide in Britain: The Case of Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba". Medscape .
  11. 1 2 "The Bawa-Garba ruling: our response". 17 May 2024.
  12. 1 2 Cohen, Deborah (2017). "Back to blame: The Bawa-Garba case and the patient safety agenda". BMJ. 359: j5534. doi: 10.1136/bmj.j5534 . PMID   29187347.
  13. ↑ "Jack Adcock death: Nurse Isabel Amaro struck off register". BBC News . 4 August 2016.
  14. ↑ "Doctor guilty of boy's manslaughter". BBC News. 4 November 2015.
  15. ↑ "Doctor suspended over boy's death". BBC News. 13 June 2017.
  16. ↑ "The Bawa Garba Case". www.theukcatpeople.co.uk. 24 February 2024. Retrieved 24 February 2024.
  17. ↑ Iacobucci, Gareth (2018). "Bawa-Garba to appeal High Court ruling and may challenge manslaughter conviction". BMJ. 360: k655. doi:10.1136/bmj.k655. PMID   29438984. S2CID   3663398.
  18. ↑ Gayle, Damien; Boseley, Sarah (13 August 2018). "Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba wins appeal against being struck off". The Guardian.
  19. ↑ "Medics rally behind struck off doctor". BBC News. 5 February 2018.
  20. ↑ "Paediatrician Who Won Victory Over GMC Gains Consultant Status". Medscape. 2 April 2022. Retrieved 4 April 2022.
  21. ↑ "BMA – A background on revalidation". www.bma.org.uk. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
  22. ↑ "BMA – Revalidation". www.bma.org.uk. Retrieved 5 February 2018.
  23. ↑ "E-portfolio was not used against Dr Bawa-Garba in court, claims defence body". 31 January 2018.
  24. ↑ "Revealed: how reflections were used in the Bawa-Garba case". 31 January 2018.
  25. ↑ MPS. "E-portfolios and the Dr Bawa-Garba case – Dr Pallavi Bradshaw clarifies". www.medicalprotection.org.
  26. ↑ Dyer, Clare; Cohen, Deborah (2018). "How should doctors use e-portfolios in the wake of the Bawa-Garba case?". BMJ. 360: k572. doi:10.1136/bmj.k572. PMID   29437673. S2CID   3291809.
  27. ↑ "The Bawa-Garba ruling: our response". BMA – Connecting doctors. Retrieved 7 February 2018.
  28. ↑ "GPs boycott reflective entries for appraisal after Bawa-Garba case – GPonline". www.gponline.com.
  29. ↑ Ward, Victoria (5 February 2018). "More than 7,500 doctors warn they will be too scared to admit mistakes after pediatrician is struck off". The Telegraph– via www.telegraph.co.uk.
  30. ↑ "Why the case of Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba makes doctors so nervous". www.newstatesman.com. 2 February 2018. Retrieved 7 February 2018.
  31. ↑ "Jeremy Hunt says doctors must be allowed to discuss mistakes". BBC. 26 January 2018. Retrieved 18 June 2022.
  32. ↑ Cunningham, Cicely (14 August 2018). "The court of appeal was right to reinstate Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba | Cicely Cunningham". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 3 March 2020.
  33. ↑ Medisauskaite, Asta; Potts, Henry; Gishen, Faye; Alexander, Kirsty; Sarker, Shah-Jalal; Griffin, Ann (2021). "Cross-sectional exploration of the impact of the Dr Bawa-Garba case on doctors' professional behaviours and attitudes towards the regulator". BMJ Open. 11 (8): e045395. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2020-045395. PMC   8375764 . PMID   34408029.
  34. ↑ "FAQs: outcome of High Court appeal – Dr Bawa-Garba case". 2 February 2018.
  35. ↑ "Doctors to be protected over medical errors". BBC News. 11 June 2018.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.