INA-MOL dispute

Last updated October 23, 2022

The INA-MOL dispute was a dispute between the government of Croatia and MOL Plc., as to the management rights of INA d.d. MOL held the controlling interest in the company, while Croatian representatives maintained this controlling share was obtained illegally, through the bribery of the former Croatian prime minister Ivo Sanader.^[1] The dispute was brought before the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, with the UNCITRAL ruling in favor of MOL.

Background

Following the declaration of independence of Croatia, the country began a number of privatization initiatives, intending to shift from socialist economics to economic liberalism.^[3] The sale of INA d.d. shares to MOL Plc. and other buyers was part of this privatization process.

The first public sale of INA d.d. shares happened in July 2003, when MOL Plc. acquired 25% of all shares for a price of €505 million. The first shareholders' agreement was signed at the time, establishing an oversight board with seven members: five to be named by the Croatian government, and two by MOL Plc. In November 2006, 44 000 Croatian citizens bought stocks as well, for a price of 2.8 billion kuna. INA d.d. stocks were included in the Zagreb Stock Exchange and London Stock Exchange for the first time. In October 2008 MOL Plc. bought another 22.15% of stocks, raising their total share to 47.15%. This made them the majority stakeholder, as the Croatian government was left with 44.83% of the shares.^[4]

In January 2009, the number of members in oversight board was raised from seven to nine, with MOL appointing five members, the Croatian government three members, and the remaining shareholders one member. MOL further gained the privilege of appointing three of six board members in INA d.d. as well. MOL Plc. had effectively gained ownership at that point. By mid-2011, the first allegations of bribery had surfaced, and USKOK had begun their investigation into Ivo Sanader and Zsolt Hernádi.^[5]

The Hernádi - Sanader legal process

The legal proceedings against Ivo Sanader began in the County Court of Zagreb on 28 August 2011, with Sanader claiming innocence and pleading not guilty. The prosecutors claimed Sanader had accepted a €10 million bribe for changing the shareholder's agreement, which enabled MOL Plc. to gain ownership of INA d.d.^[6] After a three year proceeding, Sanader was found guilty of a number of criminal wrongdoings, and sentenced to a nine year prison term. This sentence was later overturned by the Supreme Court of Croatia, and Sanader was released on a 12.4 million kuna bail.^[7] This would prove to be crucial in the arbitration process.

The legal proceedings resumed, and Sanader was once again found guilty of accepting a bribe on 31 December 2019. He was sentenced, in a non-final judgment, to a six year prison term.^[8]

Hernádi was investigated by both Hungarian and Croatian authorities, for the alleged bribery. In early 2012, Hungarian legal authorities found Hernádi to be not guilty of all charges brought against him. Meanwhile, he was tried in absentia in Croatia. He was sentenced to a two-and a half year prison term, although Hungary refused to extradite him.^[9]

The arbitration process

In 2014, the Croatian government began an arbitration process with MOL Plc. before the UNCITRAL. Croatian representatives wanted the 2009 changes to the shareholders' agreement, which enabled MOL Plc. to take over the controlling stake in INA d.d., to be made null and void. They based this claim on an alleged €10 million bribe made by the president of MOL Plc. Zsolt Hernádi to the, then current prime minister, Ivo Sanader.^[10] Hungary launched their own investigation into the matter, and dismissed all allegations of criminal activity in early 2012.^[11]

UNCITRAL made their ruling on 23 December 2016, ruling in favor of MOL Plc., and based their ruling on five points:^[12]

There was inconsistency in the Croatian version of events as to the Hernádi questioning. USKOK claimed Hungary obstructed their investigation, after they had asked the Hungarian prosecutors to question Hernádi as to the alleged bribery. However, while USKOK claimed the questioning never took place, documents from Hungarian prosecutors, as well as documents from the County Court of Zagreb, show Zsolt Hernadi was questioned in 2010, although it was connected primarily to a separate case, the Podravka affair.
It couldn't be proven that Ivo Sanader played an important role in the negotiations with MOL Plc., as to the changes in the shareholders' agreement. In fact, the evidence brought forward didn't show Sanader played a part in any detailed negotiations with the Hungarian company.
Robert Ježić, an influential Croatian businessman during the 2000s,^[13] testified that the MOL Plc. representatives had through him paid a €5 million bribe to Sanader, in return for selling a controlling share in INA d.d. UNCITRAL found the witness unreliable, claiming Ježić "had a strong motive to shift blame onto Sanader". They furthermore brought forward various differences between a number of his statements, made throughout the legal proceedings against Sanader. There was also no evidence anyone beside Ježić was aware that this alleged €5 million bribe took place.
The Croatian representatives failed to prove good relations between Ježić and Sanader, which would have been the basis for bribery to take place.
Sanader had been found guilty of criminal wrongdoing by the first instance court, but the Supreme Court of Croatia later overturned this first instance verdict against Sanader, although this ruling was heavily criticized by Croatian legal experts.^[14] This contributed to the idea that no bribe actually took place.

Related Research Articles

Parliamentary elections to elect all 151 members of the Croatian Parliament were held on 23 November 2003. They were the fifth parliamentary elections to take place since the first multi-party elections in 1990. Voter turnout was 61.7%. The result was a victory for the opposition Croatian Democratic Union (HDZ) which won a plurality of 66 seats, but fell short of the 76 needed to form a government. HDZ chairman Ivo Sanader was named the eighth Prime Minister of Croatia on 23 December 2003, after parliament passed a confidence motion in his government cabinet, with 88 MPs voting in favor, 29 against and 14 abstaining. The ruling coalition going into the elections, consisting of the Social Democratic Party (SDP), Croatian People's Party (HNS), Croatian Peasant Party (HSS), Party of Liberal Democrats (Libra) and the Liberal Party (LS), did not contest the elections as a single bloc; the SDP ran with the Istrian Democratic Assembly (IDS), the Party of Liberal Democrats (Libra) and the Liberal Party, HNS ran with the Alliance of Primorje-Gorski Kotar (PGS) and the Slavonia-Baranja Croatian Party (SBHS), while HSS ran on its own.

Ivo Sanader is a former Croatian politician who served as Prime Minister of Croatia from 2003 to 2009.

The Croatian Democratic Union is the major conservative, centre-right political party in Croatia. It is one of the two major contemporary political parties in Croatia, along with the centre-left Social Democratic Party (SDP). It is currently the largest party in the Sabor with 61 seats. The HDZ governed Croatia from 1990 before the country gained independence from Yugoslavia until 2000 and, in coalition with junior partners, from 2003 to 2011, and since 2016. The party is a member of the European People's Party (EPP). The HDZ's leader, Andrej Plenković, is the current Prime Minister of Croatia, having taken office following the 2016 parliamentary election.

This is the history of Croatia since the end of the Croatian War of Independence.

Jadranka Kosor is a Croatian politician and former journalist who served as Prime Minister of Croatia from 2009 to 2011, having taken office following the sudden resignation of her predecessor Ivo Sanader. Kosor was the first and so far only woman to become Prime Minister of Croatia since independence.

Matija Babić is a Croatian journalist and entrepreneur best known for being the former editor-in-chief of the Croatian news website Index.hr.

MOL Plc., also commonly known as MOL Group, is a Hungarian multinational oil and gas company headquartered in Budapest, Hungary. Members of MOL Group include among others the Croatian and Slovak formerly state-owned oil and gas companies, INA and Slovnaft. MOL is Hungary's most profitable enterprise, with net profits of $770 million in 2019. The company is also the third most valuable company in Central and Eastern Europe and placed 402 on the Fortune Global 500 list of the world's largest companies in 2013 with a revenue equal to one fifth of Hungary's GDP at the time.

Božidar Kalmeta is a Croatian politician and member of the Croatian Democratic Union (HDZ) party. From 2003 to 2011 he served in the Croatian Government as Croatia's Minister of the Sea, Transport and Infrastructure under HDZ prime ministers Ivo Sanader and Jadranka Kosor.

INA-Industrija nafte, d.d. is a Croatian multinational oil company. INA Group has leading role in Croatia's oil business, a strong regional position in the oil and gas exploration and production, oil processing, and oil product distribution activities. INA, d.d. is a stock company with the Hungarian MOL Group and the Croatian Government as its biggest shareholders, while a minority of shares is owned by private and institutional investors. INA shares have been listed at the London and Zagreb stock exchanges since December 1, 2006. INA Group is composed of several affiliated companies wholly or partially owned by INA, d.d.. The Group has its headquarters in Zagreb.

The D12 is a partially built state road in central Croatia that is intended to connect the Vrbovec 2 interchange with Bjelovar, Virovitica and end at the border crossing Terezino Polje. Its planned length is 86.5 kilometres (53.7 mi).

Damir Polančec is a Croatian politician who served as Minister of Economy, Labour and Entrepreneurship from 2008 to 2009, and as Deputy Prime Minister of Croatia from 2005 to 2009, in the cabinets of two prime ministers, Ivo Sanader and Jadranka Kosor.

Parliamentary elections were held in Croatia on Sunday, 4 December 2011 to elect 151 members to the Croatian Parliament. They were the sixth parliamentary election in Croatia since independence.

Remetinec prison is a closed-type prison located in the Remetinec neighborhood of Zagreb, Croatia.

The Eleventh Government of the Republic of Croatia was the Croatian Government cabinet led by Prime Minister Jadranka Kosor. It was announced on 6 July 2009 and its term ended on 23 December 2011. The cabinet came into existence after Prime Minister Ivo Sanader abruptly resigned on 1 July 2009, designating Kosor as his successor and making her the first woman to serve as Prime Minister since Croatia gained independence in 1991. It was succeeded by the Cabinet of Zoran Milanović following the centre-left Kukuriku coalition's success in the 2011 parliamentary elections.

The murder of the Zec family occurred in Zagreb, Croatia on 7 December 1991, during the Croatian War of Independence, when a squad of five Croatian militiamen shot dead three members of a Serb family: Mihajlo Zec, his wife Marija, and their 12-year-old daughter, Aleksandra. Two other Zec children escaped. The murderers were apprehended, but released after a controversial court decision in 1992.

Events in the year 2012 in Croatia.

The D10 expressway is a partially built expressway in the central Croatia northeast from Zagreb extending towards the city of Križevci. It is currently executed as a 35 km (14 mi) long expressway that spans from the A4 motorway Sveta Helena interchange via Vrbovec, to the city of Križevci. The D10 expressway represents the western arm of the so-called Podravina Y, as the eastern arm is planned to be the D12 expressway.

Croatia has severe problems with corruption, and among European Union member states, it is one of the top 3 most corrupt countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cabinet of Tihomir Orešković</span>

The Thirteenth Government of the Republic of Croatia was the Croatian Government cabinet led by Prime Minister Tihomir Orešković. It was the government cabinet of Croatia between 22 January until 19 October 2016. It was formed following the 2015 election. The negotiation process leading to its formation was the longest in Croatian history, totaling at a record 76 days. On 16 June 2016, Orešković's government lost a motion of no confidence in the Parliament with 125 MPs voting for, 15 against and 2 abstaining. As a result, the Orešković cabinet served in an acting capacity until a new government took office after the 2016 election.

The native form of this personal name is Hernádi Zsolt. This article uses Western name order when mentioning individuals.

References

↑ Dešković, Marin. "PRESUDA ZA VELIKU AFERU INA-MOL Sanader i Hernadi proglašeni krivima! Bivši premijer osuđen na šest godina zatvora, a čelnik MOL-a na dvije". jutarnji.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ Jelinić, Berislav. "VLADA UBRZAVA: Četiri strane tvrtke žele otkupiti dionice Ine od MOL-a". nacional.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ Juraić, Željka. "Proces privatizacije u Republici Hrvatskoj". repozitorij.vuka.hr. Veleučilište u Karlovcu. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Kronologija Ina-MOL: 15 godina pregovora, problema, političkih sukoba..." tportal.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Kronologija afere INA-MOL: 13 godina pregovora i sukoba". hr.n1info.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Uoči presude: kronologija prvog suđenja Sanaderu". iusinfo.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Pala cijela presuda za slučaj Fimi-media, Sanader može na slobodu čim uplati jamčevinu od 12,4 milijuna kuna". telegram.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Krivi su! Ivi Sanaderu šest godina, Hernadiju dvije godine za aferu Ina-MOL". dnevnik.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Croatia Sentences ex-PM, Hungary Energy Firm Boss for Graft". voanews.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ Radosavljević, Zoran. "Croatia says MOL CEO is suspect in bribe case". reuters.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "Hungary prosecutors say MOL had no role in INA bribe". reuters.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ "MOL Hungarian Oil and Gas Company Plc v. Republic of Croatia, ICSID Case No. ARB/13/32". italaw.com. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
↑ Filipović, Luka. "Tko je Robert Ježić, bivši skiper, biznismen i medijski mogul koji nikako da vrati pet milijuna eura spremljenih za Sanadera?". tportal.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
↑ Raić Knežević, Ana. "Cijenjena profesorica pronašla je uznemirujuće propuste u odluci Ustavnog suda o Sanaderovom slučaju". telegram.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[1] Dešković, Marin. "PRESUDA ZA VELIKU AFERU INA-MOL Sanader i Hernadi proglašeni krivima! Bivši premijer osuđen na šest godina zatvora, a čelnik MOL-a na dvije". jutarnji.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[2] Jelinić, Berislav. "VLADA UBRZAVA: Četiri strane tvrtke žele otkupiti dionice Ine od MOL-a". nacional.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[3] Juraić, Željka. "Proces privatizacije u Republici Hrvatskoj". repozitorij.vuka.hr. Veleučilište u Karlovcu. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[4] "Kronologija Ina-MOL: 15 godina pregovora, problema, političkih sukoba..." tportal.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[5] "Kronologija afere INA-MOL: 13 godina pregovora i sukoba". hr.n1info.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[6] "Uoči presude: kronologija prvog suđenja Sanaderu". iusinfo.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[7] "Pala cijela presuda za slučaj Fimi-media, Sanader može na slobodu čim uplati jamčevinu od 12,4 milijuna kuna". telegram.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[8] "Krivi su! Ivi Sanaderu šest godina, Hernadiju dvije godine za aferu Ina-MOL". dnevnik.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[9] "Croatia Sentences ex-PM, Hungary Energy Firm Boss for Graft". voanews.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[10] Radosavljević, Zoran. "Croatia says MOL CEO is suspect in bribe case". reuters.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[11] "Hungary prosecutors say MOL had no role in INA bribe". reuters.com. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[12] "MOL Hungarian Oil and Gas Company Plc v. Republic of Croatia, ICSID Case No. ARB/13/32". italaw.com. Retrieved 23 January 2021.

[13] Filipović, Luka. "Tko je Robert Ježić, bivši skiper, biznismen i medijski mogul koji nikako da vrati pet milijuna eura spremljenih za Sanadera?". tportal.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[14] Raić Knežević, Ana. "Cijenjena profesorica pronašla je uznemirujuće propuste u odluci Ustavnog suda o Sanaderovom slučaju". telegram.hr. Retrieved 7 January 2021.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]