Kevin Sweeney case

Last updated

Kevin Sweeney is a British businessman convicted in 2001 in the Netherlands for the murder of his wife, Suzanne Davies, by arson on 17 July 1995. The prosecution offered no motive for the alleged crime and Suzanne's life insurance policies were in trust for the children.

Contents

Sweeney was acquitted after a 1996 trial, but the prosecution appealed the verdict (the Dutch legal system permits appeal of acquittals). In May 2008 Sweeney made an application to the Dutch Supreme Court for a re-trial. [1] On 22 August 2008 he was released from jail after serving 7 and a half years of the original sentence of 13 and a half. [2] In the Netherlands, such early release is normal for prisoners who have shown good behaviour and are not considered to be a danger to society.

Case

Kevin Sweeney and Suzanne Davies lived with their three children and had recently bought a new house at Steensel, near Eindhoven in the Netherlands. [3] On Monday, 17 July 1995, Sweeney had left Steensel at around 2 a.m. because one of his daughters, in the care of a nurse at the Sweeney's other home, was seriously ill. At about a quarter to three, the housekeeper and a policeman walked around the house in response to a report of an electrical failure by the recently installed burglar alarm. They noticed nothing, no one answered the door, and they were unable to enter the house since the doors were bolted from the inside. At 3:30 a.m., smoke and later fire was noticed coming from an upstairs bedroom window by neighbours and passers by. At 4:00 a.m., Sweeney arrived at his other home about 180 km from Steensel. At the same time, the fire brigade, police and ambulance arrived in Steensel. Davies was found in the dressing room next to her bedroom. The bedroom was full of smoke and a small fire was burning at the foot of the bed. She showed signs of life, but resuscitation attempts failed. Half an hour later she was pronounced dead. The cause of death was carbon monoxide poisoning.[ citation needed ]

Prosecution

Kevin Sweeney was charged with murdering Suzanne Davies by setting fire to her bedroom in Steensel. He was cleared by the court in Den Bosch of these charges on 24 October 1996. [3] The Public Prosecutor appealed on 6 November 1996, but stated during proceedings on 3 November 1997 that there remained much still to be investigated. The case was adjourned. Fire investigator Peter Reijman made seven attempts at reconstructions of the fire, costing 6 million Dutch guilders. On 6 February 2001, three years and three months later, the appeal continued. The court in Den Bosch found Sweeney guilty and sentenced him to 13 years in prison on 20 February 2001. Appeals to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands, and then to the European Court of Human Rights [4] both failed.

Defence argument

The defence argued that the fire evidence was consistent with a mattress fire, caused by smoking in bed. The reconstruction attempts, in which the fire was started using six litres of petrol and a naked flame, yielded quite different fire damage. Witnesses reported that Davies was a smoker. There were cigarette butts in the bathroom, a pack of cigarettes and a lighter on the floor. However the prosecution argued that she did not smoke because no ash tray was found in her bedroom. Moreover, a police fire investigator stated that the idea that smoking in bed caused fire was a myth. The judge did not allow the defence to present data from the Dutch Central Bureau of Statistics which show that this is one of the most common causes of house fires. [2] [ better source needed ]

The "smoking problem" relates to fires started by smouldering combustion. Fire statistics draw attention to the magnitude of the smouldering as the leading cause of fire deaths in residential areas. More than 25% of the fire deaths in the United States are attributed to smoulder-initiated fires, [5] with similar figures in other developed countries (i.e. New Zealand [6] ).

Media coverage

A 1997 episode of The Cook Report , Lady Killer? was devoted to the case. Here, Cook and her parents also raised suspicions about the death of Sweeney's previous wife, Beverly Flint. [7]

Dutch crime reporter Peter R. de Vries was reportedly surprised that Sweeney was convicted in view of the flimsiness of the evidence. [8] [ better source needed ] The Dutch philosopher of science Ton Derksen has studied this case together with four other controversial recent Dutch cases, and argues that the Public Prosecution service is committing the same major errors in all of them. [9]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smoke</span> Mass of airborne particulates and gases

Smoke is a suspension of airborne particulates and gases emitted when a material undergoes combustion or pyrolysis, together with the quantity of air that is entrained or otherwise mixed into the mass. It is commonly an unwanted by-product of fires, but may also be used for pest control (fumigation), communication, defensive and offensive capabilities in the military, cooking, or smoking. It is used in rituals where incense, sage, or resin is burned to produce a smell for spiritual or magical purposes. It can also be a flavoring agent and preservative.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smoking (cooking)</span> Exposing food to smoke to flavor or preserve it

Smoking is the process of flavoring, browning, cooking, or preserving food by exposing it to smoke from burning or smoldering material, most often wood. Meat, fish, and lapsang souchong tea are often smoked.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Enschede fireworks disaster</span> 2000 explosion in the eastern Netherlands

The Enschede fireworks disaster was a catastrophic fireworks explosion on 13 May 2000 in Enschede, Netherlands. The explosion killed 23 people including four firefighters and injured 950 others. A total of 400 homes were destroyed and 1,500 buildings were subsequently damaged.

Guus Kouwenhoven, often misspelled as Gus Kouwenhoven or Guus van Kouwenhoven is a Dutch arms dealer convicted for arms trafficking in Liberia during the presidency of Charles Taylor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Burning Mountain</span> Common name for Mount Wingen, a hill near Wingen, New South Wales, Australia

Burning Mountain, the common name for Mount Wingen, is a hill near Wingen, New South Wales, Australia, approximately 224 km (139 mi) north of Sydney just off the New England Highway. It takes its name from a smouldering coal seam running underground through the sandstone. Burning Mountain is contained within the Burning Mountain Nature Reserve, which is administered by the NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peter R. de Vries</span> Dutch investigative journalist and reporter (1956–2021)

Peter Rudolf de Vries was a Dutch investigative journalist and crime reporter. His television program Peter R. de Vries, misdaadverslaggever covered high-profile cases and set a Dutch television viewing record. For decades he was famous in the Netherlands for his works in unsolved crimes. He also became internationally renowned for his programme covering the disappearance of Natalee Holloway. In 2005, he founded his own political party which was disbanded soon after.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smoked fish</span> Fish that has been cured by smoking

Smoked fish is fish that has been cured by smoking. Foods have been smoked by humans throughout history. Originally this was done as a preservative. In more recent times fish is readily preserved by refrigeration and freezing and the smoking of fish is generally done for the unique taste and flavour imparted by the smoking process.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Willem Holleeder</span> Dutch criminal (born 1958)

Willem Frederik Holleeder is a Dutch criminal. He is nicknamed De Neus because of the size of his nose.

Hartman v. Moore, 547 U.S. 250 (2006), is a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States involving the pleading standard for retaliatory prosecution claims against government officials. After a successful lobbying attempt by the CEO of a manufacturing company against competing devices that the US Postal Service supported, the CEO found himself the target of an investigation by US postal inspectors and a criminal prosecution that was dismissed for lack of evidence. The CEO then filed suit against the inspectors and other government officials for seeking to prosecute him in retaliation for exercising his First Amendment rights to criticize postal policy. The Court ruled 5-2 that to prove that the prosecution was caused by a retaliatory motive, the plaintiff bringing such a claim must allege and prove that the criminal charges were brought without probable cause.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lucia de Berk case</span> Dutch miscarriage of justice case

The Lucia de Berk case was a miscarriage of justice in the Netherlands concerning the wrongful conviction for murder of a Dutch licensed paediatric nurse. In 2003, Lucia de Berk was sentenced to life imprisonment, for which no parole is possible under Dutch law, for four murders and three attempted murders of patients under her care. In 2004, after an appeal, she was convicted of seven murders and three attempted murders.

Wesam al-Delaema, also known as Wesam Khalaf Chayed Delaeme,, is an Iraqi-born Dutch citizen accused by the United States Department of Justice of conspiring to kill American soldiers in Iraq.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cured fish</span> Fish subjected to fermentation, pickling or smoking

Cured fish is fish which has been cured by subjecting it to fermentation, pickling, smoking, or some combination of these before it is eaten. These food preservation processes can include adding salt, nitrates, nitrite or sugar, can involve smoking and flavoring the fish, and may include cooking it. The earliest form of curing fish was dehydration. Other methods, such as smoking fish or salt-curing also go back for thousands of years. The term "cure" is derived from the Latin curare, meaning to take care of. It was first recorded in reference to fish in 1743.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tobacco politics</span> Politics surrounding the use and distribution of tobacco

Tobacco politics refers to the politics surrounding the use and distribution of tobacco.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brennender Berg</span> Mountain

The Brennender Berg is a natural monument located in a deep and narrow gorge between Dudweiler and Sulzbach in Saarland, Germany. It is a smouldering coal-seam fire that ignited in 1668 and continues to burn today.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deventer murder case</span>

The Deventer murder case is a murder case which took place in the Dutch city of Deventer in 1999. It has become a cause célèbre because the murder has officially been solved, but not everybody agrees with the final judgment of the court. The case has been re-opened twice. The first time this was done because the evidence previously used for the conviction had proven to be incorrect, while the second time there were strong clues that another suspect's testimony about his whereabouts during the time of the murder did not match real facts. Nevertheless, the same suspect—former tax advisor Ernest Louwes—has been convicted twice. His second conviction took place on the basis of different evidence from that used during the first trial. However, some people such as the opinion pollster Maurice de Hond are still convinced of Louwes' innocence.

The trial of Geert Wilders, a member of the House of Representatives of the Netherlands, took place in the Netherlands in 2010 and 2011. Wilders was accused of criminally insulting religious and ethnic groups and inciting hatred and discrimination. He was found not guilty in June 2011.

The Amsterdam sex crimes case is a court case involving Robert Mikelson's abuse of babies in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. The defendant was Roberts Mikelson, dubbed "the Monster of Riga" by the Dutch press, who had worked at several daycare centres in Amsterdam and was accused of abusing 87 children as well as possession, production and distribution of child pornography. Mikelson was found guilty and sentenced to 18 years and 11 months in prison, followed by involuntary commitment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Killing of Nicole van den Hurk</span> 1995 murder case in North Brabant, Netherlands

15-year-old Nicole van den Hurk disappeared on her way to work on 6 October 1995, in Eindhoven,. Her body was later found in the woods between the towns of Mierlo and Lierop on November 22, 1995.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Death of Nicky Verstappen</span> Child sexual abuse and homicide case in the Netherlands

On the morning of 10 August 1998, 11-year-old Nicky Verstappen disappeared from a summer camp he was attending in Brunssum, Limburg. His body was found on the evening of 11 August, 1.2 kilometres (0.75 mi) away in Landgraaf, and a murder investigation was subsequently launched. Despite extensive investigation, the case remained unsolved for over twenty years.

<i>State of the Netherlands v. Urgenda Foundation</i> Dutch court case about carbon dioxide emissions

State of the Netherlands v. Urgenda Foundation was a court case heard by the Supreme Court of the Netherlands in 2019 related to government efforts to curtail carbon dioxide emissions. The case was brought against the Dutch government in 2013, arguing the government, by not meeting a minimum carbon dioxide emission-reduction goal established by scientists to avert harmful climate change, was endangering the human rights of Dutch citizens as set by national and European Union laws.

References

  1. "English translation of petition to "Hoge Raad"" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 8 January 2010. Retrieved 1 February 2009.
  2. 1 2 Website Justice for Kevin Sweeney Archived 2008-05-12 at the Wayback Machine
  3. 1 2 Silverman, Jon (6 January 2004). "Guilty second time around". The Guardian. Retrieved 7 October 2023.
  4. Dossier on the case at Fair Trials International Archived 2009-01-06 at the Wayback Machine the organisation which supported Sweeney's appeal to the European Court of Human Rights[ dead link ]
  5. Hall, J.R. (2010). The smoking-material fire problem. Quincy, MA: National Fire Protection Association. pp. 50–57.
  6. Rein, Guillermo (January 2009). "Smouldering Combustion Phenomena in Science and Technology". International Review of Chemical Engineering. 1: 3–18.
  7. "The Cook Report - Lady Killer/Kevin Sweeney S16E01 (1997)". YouTube .
  8. (in Dutch) Crime reporter Peter R. de Vries' dossier on the Sweeney case Archived 2008-04-09 at the Wayback Machine
  9. Derksen, Ton (15 August 2015). Het OM in de fout: 94 structurele missers (in Dutch) (Heruitgave ed.). ISVW Uitgevers. ISBN   978-94-91693-69-4.